Proton and neutron elastic scattering at low energies on He targets from ab initio optical potentials

arXiv:2606.07465 · nucl-th · Submitted 2026-06-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Proton and neutron elastic scattering at low energies on He targets from ab initio optical potentials".

Title and authors: Kai: So, to recap, the paper is about constructing these ab initio optical potentials for proton and neutron scattering on helium targets using the SA-NCSM Green’s function method. It’s a big effort because it tries to build this from the ground up.

Mira: And what I want to emphasize is that they are using this framework to construct potentials that are nonlocal, energy dependent, and dispersive, which should give them a lot of flexibility compared to older methods.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, building these potentials involves solving the Schrödinger equation in coordinate space using Eq. seven after you've calculated the many-body wavefunctions in the SA-NCSM framework <ref:2606.07465#pg3,in the SA-NCSM framework>. It’s computationally intensive because of that many-body calculation part first.

Kai: That’s right. And they show that these potentials actually reproduce experimental differential cross sections and phase shifts for proton and neutron elastic scattering remarkably well, especially for three helium targets, like 3He and 4He, at laboratory kinetic energies from two to sixteen point four mega electron volts <ref:2606.07465#pg1,reproduce experimental differential cross sections and phase shifts for proton and neutron>.

Mira: So the numbers look good there—close agreement with what we measure experimentally across that energy range. But they also tackle the challenging n plus six helium target system.

Lev: That’s where I have to pause and think about how this scales on real hardware; handling those higher spin systems or more complex partitions in the many-body calculations can introduce significant overhead compared to simpler models.

Kai: They also noted that for the proton plus four helium system, these ab initio potentials are highly nonlocal, meaning they depend on where you are in space, but interestingly, for energy less than twelve mega electron volts, they show almost no dependence on scattering energy for most partial waves except when the energy is right near a pole of the Green’s function.

The paper's summary: Mira: Okay, so summarizing what they did: this study uses the SA-NCSM/GF approach, which combines the symmetry-adapted no-core shell model with the Green’s function technique to build optical potentials. They extend this to proton scattering and targets with nonzero spin.

Kai: And they use Eq. seven that coordinate space Schrödinger equation, to calculate differential cross sections by solving it using these potentials <ref:2606.07465#pg3>. The radial wavefunction is denoted as u J pi c r, and they solve it in a way similar to the R-matrix approach forty-six <ref:2606.07465#pg3,the R-matrix approach 46>.

Lev: The complexity lies in how they calculate those many-body wavefunctions and one body overlaps within the SA-NCSM framework, which is where you get most of your computational time spent before you even get to the scattering dynamics.

Mira: And what’s really interesting from their summary is that they show that for three helium and four helium targets, the calculated differential cross sections are in close agreement with experiment when the laboratory kinetic energies are from two to sixteen point four mega electron volts.

Kai: They also mention how these potentials can be used to model reactions involving d and alpha partitioning, which means they contain information about all near reaction channels. That’s useful because it lets us look at breakup channels.

Lev: The paper stresses that this method provides effective nucleonnucleus potentials applicable from stable to unstable nuclei, which is important for modeling decay processes.

Mira: So the main point of the summary is that they have a complete framework—from input interactions to final scattering observables—that works well for these light targets and shows promise for broader applications in nuclear physics.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Moving on to the improvements section, what they highlight is that their SA-NCSM/GF approach accommodates everything from single particle features up to collective and clustering correlations in nuclei by combining the Green’s function technique with the SA-NCSM.

Mira: That means it moves beyond just a simple mean-field description; it can capture those complex correlations that are crucial for understanding how these light nuclei behave when they interact.

Lev: From an error correction perspective, incorporating these many-body correlations into the potential calculation adds layers of complexity to the error analysis needed to run this on real hardware.

Kai: They also point out that the efficient expression for the differential cross section in Eq. A3 can be used to calculate it for any two body reaction with arbitrary projectile and target spins, which gives a speedup compared to Eq. fifteen.

Mira: That algorithmic speedup is significant because when you deal with complex spin configurations, you want that kind of efficiency in your calculation pipeline.

Lev: So, if we were to run this on a real system for something like excited target states or odd-A nuclei, that way the speedup would translate directly into less required computational time for the scattering part itself.

Kai: And they also provide a compact expression for the total scattering amplitude in matrix form using Eq. B3, which helps you separate and analyze contributions from things like central potential versus spin orbit interaction.

Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up the conclusions, the core idea is that they’ve constructed these ab initio optical potentials using chiral potentials within the SA-NCSM/GF framework. They specifically provided the first translationally invariant optical potentials for proton plus four helium targets for partial waves less than or equal to four at low energies.

Kai: And they found these potentials exceptionally reproduce experimental phase shifts and differential cross sections for four helium projectile scattering while also being reasonably independent of the parameter h bar omega, providing a reliable parameter free optical potential.

Lev: From an error correction view, the fact that they find this approach is reasonably independent of h bar omega helps because you don't have to spend time tuning that specific parameter across different model spaces to get stable results.

Mira: They also note that the Green’s function technique uses many-body Hamiltonians with a realistic inter nucleon interaction, ensuring exact translational invariance, which is critical for light targets like helium.

Kai: This approach provides effective nucleonnucleus potentials applicable from stable to unstable nuclei and contains information about all near reaction channels, including d and alpha partitioning. They also illustrate the method’s applicability to open-shell and halo targets.

Lev: To add one final engineering note, the paper mentions that convergence with respect to n max and h bar omega is needed for ab initio descriptions in no core shell model calculations, but their infinite space extrapolations for all three h bar omega values agree within one mega electron volt and provide reliable predictions of resonant phase shifts and differential cross sections.

Mira: So, the final picture from "Proton and neutron elastic scattering at low energies on He targets from ab initio optical potentials" is that they’ve given us a way to build these potentials that are robust enough for astrophysics, because they work well across different targets and energy ranges.

Kai: It's a solid foundation for calculating reaction observables in few body methods using these constructed optical potentials. We'll keep an eye on how this method translates into other complex scattering problems.

Department of Physics and Astronomy, Louisiana State University · Department of Computer Systems, Faculty of Information Technology, Czech Technical University in Prague · Nuclear Physics Institute

nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-06-05

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Proton and neutron elastic scattering at low energies on He targets from ab initio optical potentials constructs and discusses ab initio nucleon-nucleus optical potentials at low energies for 3,4,6He…

Key concepts

Ab Initio Optical Potentials
These are theoretical potentials derived from first principles (ab initio) using realistic nucleon-nucleon interactions. They describe how protons and neutrons interact when scattering off a nucleus, providing a detailed, microscopic view of the nuclear force that goes beyond simple phenomenological models.
SA-NCSM/GF Approach
This is the specific theoretical method used to build the potentials. It combines many-body approaches (SA-NCSM) with Green's function calculations (GF). This allows the model to account for complex nuclear structure effects and information about all possible reaction channels simultaneously.
Nonlocal and Energy Dependent Potentials
The resulting potentials are not simple, fixed functions; they depend on both the scattering energy and the spatial distribution of nucleons. Nonlocality means the interaction depends on where the particles are located relative to each other, which is crucial for accurately describing low-energy nuclear reactions.
Near Reaction Channels
The optical potentials constructed contain information about various processes that happen near a collision, such as deuteron (d) or alpha ($\alpha$) partitioning. This means the potential captures how the nucleus might break apart or interact with other particles during the scattering event.

Terminology

Summary

Proton and neutron elastic scattering at low energies on He targets from ab initio optical potentials constructs and discusses ab initio nucleon-nucleus optical potentials at low energies for 3,4,6He targets. p. 0 The ab initio SA-NCSM/GF approach provides nonlocal, energy dependent and dispersive optical potentials, suitable for the astrophysically relevant regime of low energies and for exotic nuclei. p. 0

Theoretical Framework

The theoretical framework involves constructing inter-cluster effective interactions by utilizing many-body approaches with realistic inter-nucleon interactions, typically derived in the chiral effective-field theory. The Green’s function technique is employed to construct the optical potentials, which includes information about all near reaction channels through the GF calculations in the composite (A ± a) systems. p. 0 The potential is constructed using Eq. p. 1 (6), which involves terms like Trel(r) and VCoul(r). p. 1

Scattering Dynamics

The differential cross sections are calculated by solving the coordinate-space Schrödinger equation using Eq. (7). The asymptotic expression for the scattering wavefunction is given in terms of incoming and outgoing spherical Hankel functions H±l(ην, kνr). p. 2 The unpolarized differential cross section is obtained by averaging over the (incoming) Mb labels. p. 3

Target Specific Results

The calculations provide ab initio proton scattering differential cross sections, as well as cross sections for neutron scattering for several He targets, including the challenging n+6He system. The SA-NCSM/GF approach reproduces the experimental differential cross sections and phase shifts for proton and neutron elastic scattering remarkably well. p. 0 For 3He and 4He targets, the calculated differential cross sections are in close agreement with experiment for projectile laboratory kinetic energies Elab from 2 to 16. p. 44 MeV.

Potential Characteristics

The ab initio SA-NCSM/GF optical potentials for p +4He are highly nonlocal. These potentials depend on the scattering energy E, however, for this system, they find almost no dependence for ECM < 12 MeV for all S1/2, P1/2, P3/2, and D3/2 partial waves except when E is very close to a pole of the Green’s function for ϵ = 0. p. 5 The p +4He optical potentials, which exclude the Coulomb interaction, are nearly identical to the n +4He optical potentials provided in Ref. p. 5 [25].

Convergence and Applicability

The convergence of results with respect to Nmax and ħomega is needed for ab initio descriptions in no-core shell-model calculations. The infinite-space extrapolations for all three ħomega-values agree to within 1 MeV and provide reliable predictions of the resonant phase shifts and differential cross sections. p. 7 The approach provides effective nucleonnucleus potentials that are applicable from stable to unstable nuclei, and contain the information about all near reaction channels, including d and α partitioning. p. 7 The work also illustrates the approach’s applicability to open-shell and halo targets. p. 5 p. 5

Conclusion

In this work, we have constructed ab initio optical potentials, key ingredients for calculating reaction observables in few-body methods. The optical potentials are obtained in the SA-NCSM/GF framework with chiral potentials, and are illustrated here for several He nuclei. p. 7 Specifically, we provided the first ab initio translationally invariant optical potentials for p +4He l ≤ 4 partial waves at low energies. p. 7 They exceptionally reproduce the experimental phase shifts and differential cross section for 4He(p, p)4He elastic scattering while also being reasonably independent of ħomega, thereby providing a reliable parameter-free optical potential. p. 7 The Green’s function technique uses manybody Hamiltonians with a realistic inter-nucleon interaction, and ensures exact translational invariance, which is critical for light targets. p. 7 This provides effective nucleonnucleus potentials that are applicable from stable to unstable nuclei, and contain the information about all near reaction channels, including d and α partitioning. p. 7 The work also illustrates the approach’s applicability to open-shell and halo targets.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (DE-SC0023532), and in part by the National Nuclear Security Administration through the Center for Excellence in Nuclear Training and University Based Research (CENTAUR) under grant number DE-NA-0004150, and the Czech Science Foundation (No. p. 7 22-14497S). p. 7 This work benefited from high performance computational resources provided by LSU (www. p. 7hpc.lsu.edu), the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), a U. p. 7S. Department of Energy Office of Science User Facility at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory operated under Contract No. p. 7 DE-AC02-05CH11231, as well as the Frontera computing project at the Texas Advanced Computing Center, made possible by National Science Foundation award OAC-1818253. p. 7 We would also like to thank Grigor H. p. 7 Sargsyan and Alexis Mercenne for useful discussions. p. 7

Appendix A

Eq. (15) is suitable to calculate the differential cross section for any two-body nuclear reaction with arbitrary projectile-target spins. p. 8 The advantage of Eq. p. 0 (A3) over Eq. (15) is two-fold, first the elimination of sums over spin components yields remarkable algorithmic speedup, especially when higher spins are involved such as in excited target states or odd-A nuclei. p. 8 Second the complete set of symmetries and selection rules are more apparent. p. 8

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Ab initio SA-NCSM/GF optical potentials can be used to construct nonlocal, energy dependent and dispersive optical potentials suitable for low energies and exotic nuclei, where experimental data is difficult or unavailable. This allows AI systems to model reactions in regimes where traditional parameterized Woods-Saxon potentials fail due to a lack of constraints from elastic scattering data.

  2. The system can accurately reproduce experimental differential cross sections and phase shifts for proton and neutron elastic scattering remarkably well using the constructed optical potentials. This capability enables AI systems to perform reliable predictions for low energy nuclear reactions, such as those relevant to astrophysical processes or rare isotope beams.

  3. The SA-NCSM/GF framework accommodates from single-particle features to collective and clustering correlations in nuclei by combining the Green’s function technique with the SA-NCSM. This allows AI systems to incorporate complex nuclear structure effects into reaction models, moving beyond simple mean-field descriptions.

  4. The approach provides effective nucleonnucleus potentials that are applicable from stable to unstable nuclei and contain information about all near reaction channels, including d and alpha partitioning. This feature allows AI systems to model the influence of different decay or breakup channels during nuclear reactions.

  5. The efficient expression for the differential cross section in Eq (A3) can be used to calculate the nuclear differential cross section for any two-body reaction with arbitrary projectile-target spins, yielding a remarkable algorithmic speedup compared to Eq (15). This means AI systems can process scattering data much faster when dealing with complex spin configurations.

  6. The method provides a compact expression for the total scattering amplitude in matrix form (Eq B3), which readily yields a convenient expression for the differential cross section by relating it to central and spin orbit components. This allows AI systems to easily separate and analyze the contributions of different interaction mechanisms, such as central potential versus spin-orbit interaction.

  7. The calculation of convergence with respect to partial waves shows that for He targets, only the first few partial waves affect scattering observables, suggesting a manageable basis size is sufficient for accurate predictions. This helps AI systems select optimal computational resources by focusing on the most influential degrees of freedom in the reaction calculation.

  8. The use of extrapolated energies derived from SA-NCSM energies across different model spaces provides reliable predictions of resonant phase shifts and differential cross sections, even when using low model space calculations for convergence. This capability allows AI systems to make robust predictions about resonance locations without requiring extensive experimental data for every energy point.

Sources

Related papers