Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups

arXiv:2606.02719 · astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA · Submitted 2026-06-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups Context.

Vera: Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model’s baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems I show that the observed departures from self-similar predictions can be efficiently described by two physical quantities modeled with power laws These phenomenological parameters are the gas mass fraction (fg ∼ T f1E fz z) and the temperature variation (fT ∼ T t1E tz z), which are also discussed in the context of the generalized form of the X-ray scaling laws Modeling these departures with these parameters drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3σ (> 5σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent Calibration of Phenomenological Parameters The study employs an MCMC-based meta-analysis to constrain the temperature- and redshift-dependence of the meta-parameters fg and fT This analysis uses a large variety of published X-ray scaling relations to calibrate the model The calibration indicates that while the gas mass fraction (fg) does not show significant evolution with cosmic time (fz = −0.11 ± 0.03), it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass (f1 = 0.50 ± 0.01) On the other hand, the temperature variation (fT) shows a mild positive increase with both mass and redshift (t1 = 0.16 ± 0.01; tz = 0.12 ± 0.07) Impact on Scaling Relations Modeling the departures from the self-similar model with these parameters drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3σ (> 5σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent By imposing a minimal relative statistical error of 3 (5) percent on the published relations, I reduce the number of relations in tension at > 3σ to two (none) The modelization through the generalized form allows me to present an extended discussion of the expected slopes and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws Physical Interpretation of Temperature Variation The meaning of fT is more subtle, as it is justified by evidence that the gas temperature varies radially and differs from any global value representative of a typical halo mass If the temperature used in the scaling laws is the spectroscopic measurement Tsp, then fT = T(R500)/Tsp, where T(R500) is the 3D gas temperature at R500 or, for an isothermal gas, T500 This parameter allows the model to address biases introduced by different definitions of the "global" temperature This work presents an extension and an update of the analysis discussed in E23, by investigating how departures from the self-similar scenario can be interpreted using fg and fT The calibration yields stronger T-dependence in fg that translates into a mass-dependence well consistent with some recent studies Furthermore, the construction of a new quantity YLGT0 = L −1M2 gT 1/2 is predicted to relate directly to the mass without any redshift evolution The best-fit results are quite consistent with those discussed in E23, with an increase of 10–25% on the slopes and slightly more evident negative evolution in fg and less clear positive evolution in fT Appendix A: Relations Investigated The analysis involves constructing the expected slope B and the redshift evolution C for each scaling law by adding contributions from the four parameters Table A.1 quotes the expected values of the slope B and redshift evolution C for the most relevant relations For example, for the M − T relation, B = 3/2 + 3/2 · t1 and C = 3/2 · tz − 1 in a pure self-similar scenario Rescaling of Thermodynamic Profiles Table A.3 quotes the exponent for the dependence in temperature (and mass) and relative redshift evolution for common thermodynamic quantities For instance, the conversion to Q∆ ∼ MaM E aMz z is obtained via the relation T∆ = fT T ∼ T 1+t1E tz z = (EzM) 2/3 Published Results and Tension Reduction Among 39 relations considered in this meta-analysis, nineteen (14) exhibit tensions > 3σ (> 5σ) when self-similarity is assumed These numbers decrease to 4 (1) when fg − fT are left free to vary By imposing a relative statistical error not lower than 3 (5) percent on the constraints extracted from the literature, the number of values in tension at > 5σ drops to zero, and those still at > 3σ are reduced to two (none) Future Directions The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al.

Jocelyn: 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

Vera: 2024), will permit detailed studies of both the relations among integrated quantities and the universal behavior of spatially-resolved gas thermodynamic properties Complementary analyses linking slopes and evolutions of the reconstructed X-ray scaling laws in numerical simulations to the metaparameters will permit us to assess and constrain the level of feedback acting on the baryon energy and distribution as a function of halo mass and cosmic time Acknowledgements I thank Y.

Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper today, "Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups." It's about how the usual simple models for galaxy clusters and groups aren't quite matching what we actually observe.

Jocelyn: Exactly. The authors are using some new tools to figure out why those standard scaling relations, which describe things like gas mass or temperature, don't fit perfectly when you look at real data across different masses and redshifts.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like they're trying to fix the baseline model so it doesn't have these systematic departures that we see in the observed data. How do you think they approach modeling those deviations?

Vera: Well, they introduce two specific physical quantities to model these departures with power laws. They call them the gas mass fraction, f g, and the temperature variation, f T.

Jocelyn: That sounds like a way to add some flexibility to the standard equations. It’s essentially saying the scaling isn't just one simple relationship anymore; it has these extra dependencies on mass and time.

Subrahmanyan: So, what are the results of this modeling? Does it actually help bring those forty-nine percent in tension down to something more manageable?

Vera: It does significantly. By modeling these departures with f g and f T, they drastically improve how well the model predicts the data. They reduce the number of scaling relations showing tension, from forty-nine percent under the self-similar scenario down to just eleven percent.

Jocelyn: That's a big win for predictive accuracy. But how do we know these new parameters, f g and f T, are actually real physics?

Subrahmanyan: That’s where the meta-analysis comes in. The paper uses MCMC, which means Markov Chain Monte Carlo, to check these parameters against a huge variety of published X-ray scaling relations from different sources.

Vera: They use that large set of published relations as a calibration tool to constrain the temperature and redshift dependence of f g and f T. The analysis shows some specific constraints on how these things change with mass and time.

Jocelyn: I see they found that the gas mass fraction, f g, doesn't really evolve much with cosmic time, meaning its evolution parameter, f z, is around negative zero point one one. But it does decrease quite a bit when the halo mass gets smaller.

Title and authors: Subrahmanyan: And what about the temperature variation, f T ? What are its constraints? Is it evolving predictably with redshift?

Vera: The results show that the temperature variation, f T, actually shows a mild positive evolution with both halo mass and redshift. Their calibration yielded a value for t one around zero point one six, and t z around zero point one two <ref:2606.02719#pg1>.

Jocelyn: So they found that the gas mass fraction is relatively stable over time but sensitive to the cluster size, while the temperature variation does evolve somewhat with both mass and redshift. That gives us a clearer picture of what's driving those deviations.

Subrahmanyan: It’s interesting how these parameters are connected to the generalized form of X-ray scaling laws, which is like a more complex equation that includes these factors we just talked about. This whole framework lets them explore the expected slopes and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws in a much richer way.

Vera: And they even predict something new called Y LGT0, which is defined as the gas mass times the square root of temperature variation, scaled by one over two. They say this quantity is predicted to relate directly to the mass without any redshift evolution.

Jocelyn: That sounds like a really clean prediction for a relationship between mass and some other observable, independent of how far back in time we look at it. What does that imply for structure formation studies?

Subrahmanyan: It suggests a more direct link between the underlying mass distribution and the thermodynamic state of the gas, which is something we need to see confirmed by future observations or simulations. This paper also mentions that their best-fit results are quite consistent with some earlier work they discussed in a prior paper.

Vera: Before we wrap up this discussion on "Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups," let's just quickly summarize what this work does for us. It takes the observed discrepancies between simple models and reality and describes them using two physical parameters, f g and f T, which are constrained by a large meta-analysis of existing data.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: And the main implication is that this modeling drastically cleans up those tensions in X-ray scaling relations, reducing the number of conflicting relations from forty-nine percent down to just eleven percent under the self-similar assumption.

Subrahmanyan: For cosmology, this work suggests that we can move beyond assuming perfect self-similarity and incorporate these mass and redshift dependencies into our models of structure formation, which should lead to more accurate predictions for cluster properties.

Vera: So, looking ahead, the team points toward new datasets coming online. They mention X-ray data from CHEXMATE and X-GAP as being important for future work. These new datasets will allow them to study both integrated quantities and spatially resolved gas properties in much more detail than before.

Jocelyn: That makes sense. If we have better, cleaner data on the sky, we can test these models even more rigorously to see if f g and f T are still the right way to describe the physics. What's next for them?

Subrahmanyan: The paper suggests complementary analyses linking the slopes and evolutions of these reconstructed X-ray scaling laws in numerical simulations with these metaparameters. That should allow us to constrain how feedback affects the baryon energy and distribution as a function of halo mass and cosmic time.

Vera: It's about connecting what we see on the sky with what simulations predict, using these phenomenological parameters as a bridge between the two. That’s where we need that kind of work to really get a handle on galaxy clusters.

Jocelyn: Well, that’s the picture for this paper. We've looked at how f g and f T can help us reconcile those scaling relations and what the new constraints tell us about mass evolution in these systems.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a solid step in refining our understanding of how baryonic physics influences the large-scale structure of the universe, moving away from purely self-similar assumptions.

Vera: We’ll keep an eye on those new X-ray datasets to see if they confirm these findings or push us into new territory.

Jocelyn: Definitely. And we'll be watching how this paper shapes the next set of scaling relations we test against real observations.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, this paper is essentially taking the standard, simple picture of how galaxy clusters and groups behave—the self-similar model—and showing where that picture breaks down when we look at real X-ray data.

Jocelyn: Right. They’re not just saying the old models are wrong; they’re proposing two specific ways to fix them: these parameters, the gas mass fraction, f g, and the temperature variation, f T.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical side, this is interesting because it stops us from just throwing out the whole self-similar idea and starts building a more flexible framework based on mass and time.

Vera: Exactly. The big win here is that by adding these two power laws, they can fit way more of the observed scaling relations than before. They take those forty-nine relations that were in tension under the simple model, down to just eleven percent tension under this new model.

Jocelyn: That means their predictions are much more accurate when you try to compare them to what we actually measure across different redshifts and masses. It’s about making the data match the theory better.

Subrahmanyan: The calibration of these parameters using a meta-analysis across a huge set of published data is how they make this work. They aren't just guessing; they are constraining f g and f T based on what other researchers have already found, which is a smart way to test the physics.

Vera: The constraints they found are pretty specific, you know? For instance, the gas mass fraction doesn't really change much over cosmic time, but it definitely drops when the halo mass gets smaller.

Jocelyn: And f T, that temperature variation factor? It shows a mild increase with both mass and redshift. So it’s not static; it’s evolving in a predictable way within this framework.

Subrahmanyan: The authors also predict something called Y LGT0, which they suggest relates directly to the halo mass without any dependence on redshift. That suggests a very clean relationship between the mass and the gas thermodynamics that might be independent of cosmic time.

Vera: It’s a powerful prediction because if that holds up, it means we have a more direct way to link the gravitational structure of these clusters to how hot and dense their gas is.

Jocelyn: And they are looking ahead, which is good. They point out that new datasets coming online, like CHEXMATE and X-GAP, will be crucial for testing these findings further.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly. Those new X-ray observations will let them move from just integrating quantities to studying the actual spatial structure of the gas in these systems, which is a big step toward understanding feedback mechanisms.

Vera: So, while this paper doesn't solve all our problems, it gives us a much sharper tool— f g and f T —to model those messy departures we see in the data.

Jocelyn: It’s a solid extension of the work they did before. It takes the tension and gives it a concrete mathematical handle to work with.

Subrahmanyan: This approach, using these phenomenological parameters to bridge the gap between self-similarity and reality, is exactly what we need to move toward more robust cosmological models for structure formation.

Vera: So, this paper shows us how fine-tuning these two quantities can significantly clean up those scaling relations we rely on every day.

Jocelyn: And now that they have this new framework, the next step is to see if those theoretical predictions about Y LGT0 actually show up in the future observations.

The paper's improvements: Vera: So, to recap, this paper is about using two new physical parameters, gas mass fraction f g and temperature variation f T, to describe how real galaxy cluster data deviates from the simple self-similar model.

Jocelyn: Right. They use these to improve the accuracy of their scaling relations and reduce the amount of tension they see in the literature by modeling those deviations explicitly.

Subrahmanyan: It’s about taking a set of observed relations that don't fit perfectly and giving them a more flexible mathematical structure, which is essential for connecting them back to our cosmological models.

Vera: The improvements they suggest are pretty significant because they move us past just saying the self-similar model fails; they give us a way to quantify exactly *how* it fails based on mass and time.

Jocelyn: It changes how we look at the data by adding these parameters, f g and f T, into our analysis pipeline. It’s about making sure our predictions match the observed scatter better.

Subrahmanyan: The implication for cosmology is that if these constraints on f g and f T hold up across a wide range of systems, it gives us a much stronger handle on how baryonic physics like feedback affects structure formation at different scales.

Vera: They also point out that by using these new parameters, they can predict things like the quantity Y LGT0 without any redshift dependence. That’s a neat prediction because it links mass and temperature in a way that seems fundamental to the underlying process.

Jocelyn: It suggests there might be an intrinsic link between the gas thermodynamics and the dark matter halo structure that is independent of cosmic time evolution in some sense.

Subrahmanyan: And this is where we need those new datasets you mentioned earlier, like CHEXMATE, to truly test if these relationships hold up when we move to higher resolution or different epochs.

Vera: Exactly. The limitations they state are that this is a phenomenological model; it’s based on fitting the data, not necessarily deriving the physics from first principles of gravity alone.

Jocelyn: So, the paper provides a powerful observational tool for understanding cluster evolution while being clear about what kind of physical assumptions they are making to keep their model consistent.

Subrahmanyan: And that consistency is what matters for pushing cosmology forward; we need these parameters constrained by real observations to see if they tell us anything new about how energy is partitioned in those massive systems.

Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap things up, this paper shows that modeling the departures from self-similarity using f g and f T significantly improves our ability to predict what we see in X-ray scaling relations across different cluster masses and redshifts.

Jocelyn: It’s about moving away from a single simple model toward one that accounts for these mass and time dependencies, which is crucial for interpreting the data we collect.

Subrahmanyan: This work gives us a more rigorous way to test how feedback processes shape the thermodynamic state of the gas in galaxy clusters over cosmic history.

Vera: The main implication is that by constraining f g and f T through this meta-analysis, we can reduce the number of scaling relations that are currently in tension, making our literature much more reliable.

Jocelyn: It means future researchers have a better baseline to compare their own results against when they look at integrated quantities or spatially resolved gas properties.

Subrahmanyan: We need to see if these parameters truly capture the physics of baryonic energy distribution in these halos, and that’s what we'll be looking for in future high-resolution simulations.

Vera: And they do flag a limitation: this is a phenomenological fit based on existing data, so we have to be careful about extrapolating these parameters to completely new physical regimes.

Jocelyn: Exactly. It’s a strong tool for understanding the current landscape, but it opens the door for more fundamental tests when those new X-ray datasets arrive, like CHEXMATE and X-GAP.

Subrahmanyan: I'm hoping those upcoming observations will confirm these scaling laws or reveal new physics that forces us to refine what f g and f T actually represent.

INAF · INFN

astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA

Submitted: 2026-06-01

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 8 pages (plus 2 pages of Appendix). A&A in press. This revised version includes a new subsection (Sect. 2.1) on the mass proxy Y_{LGT0}}, which has been corrected, and an extended analysis of the systematic uncertainties associated with the estimation of the meta-parameters

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups Context.

Key concepts

Self-Similar Model
This is a baseline theoretical model suggesting that the thermodynamic properties of gas in galaxy clusters and groups should follow simple scaling laws based only on gravity and cosmology. The paper shows that real observational data systematically deviates from this simple baseline, especially in smaller systems.
$f_g$ (Gas Mass Fraction)
This parameter models how the fraction of gas mass within a halo changes with its mass and cosmic time. Calibration shows it decreases significantly as halo mass decreases, indicating a dependence on the system's size.
$f_T$ (Temperature Variation)
This parameter quantifies how the gas temperature varies relative to a global average temperature. It is physically motivated by radial temperature variations and helps correct biases introduced by different definitions of 'global' temperatures used in scaling relations.

Terminology

Summary

Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups Context. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ettori1, 2,⋆ 1 INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129 Bologna, Italy 2 INFN, Sezione di Bologna, viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127 Bologna, Italy ABSTRACT Context. Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups.

Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model’s baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems I show that the observed departures from self-similar predictions can be efficiently described by two physical quantities modeled with power laws These phenomenological parameters are the gas mass fraction (fg ∼ T f1E fz z) and the temperature variation (fT ∼ T t1E tz z), which are also discussed in the context of the generalized form of the X-ray scaling laws Modeling these departures with these parameters drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3σ (> 5σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent

Calibration of Phenomenological Parameters

The study employs an MCMC-based meta-analysis to constrain the temperature- and redshift-dependence of the meta-parameters fg and fT This analysis uses a large variety of published X-ray scaling relations to calibrate the model The calibration indicates that while the gas mass fraction (fg) does not show significant evolution with cosmic time (fz = −0.11 ± 0.03), it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass (f1 = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These calibrations indicate that, while the gas mass fraction (fg) does not show significant evolution with cosmic time (fz = −0. 03), it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass (f1 = 0.

50 ± 0.01) On the other hand, the temperature variation (fT) shows a mild positive increase with both mass and redshift (t1 = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

03), it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass (f1 = 0. On the other hand, the temperature variation (fT ) shows a mild positive increase with both mass and redshift (t1 = 0.

16 ± 0.01; tz = 0.12 ± 0.07)

Impact on Scaling Relations

Modeling the departures from the self-similar model with these parameters drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3σ (> 5σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent By imposing a minimal relative statistical error of 3 (5) percent on the published relations, I reduce the number of relations in tension at > 3σ to two (none) The modelization through the generalized form allows me to present an extended discussion of the expected slopes and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws

Physical Interpretation of Temperature Variation

The meaning of fT is more subtle, as it is justified by evidence that the gas temperature varies radially and differs from any global value representative of a typical halo mass If the temperature used in the scaling laws is the spectroscopic measurement Tsp, then fT = T(R500)/Tsp, where T(R500) is the 3D gas temperature at R500 or, for an isothermal gas, T500 This parameter allows the model to address biases introduced by different definitions of the global temperature

Summary and Conclusions

This work presents an extension and an update of the analysis discussed in E23, by investigating how departures from the self-similar scenario can be interpreted using fg and fT The calibration yields stronger T-dependence in fg that translates into a mass-dependence well consistent with some recent studies Furthermore, the construction of a new quantity YLGT0 = L −1M2 gT 1/2 is predicted to relate directly to the mass without any redshift evolution The best-fit results are quite consistent with those discussed in E23, with an increase of 10–25% on the slopes and slightly more evident negative evolution in fg and less clear positive evolution in fT

Appendix A: Relations Investigated

The analysis involves constructing the expected slope B and the redshift evolution C for each scaling law by adding contributions from the four parameters Table A.1 quotes the expected values of the slope B and redshift evolution C for the most relevant relations For example, for the M − T relation, B = 3/2 + 3/2 · t1 and C = 3/2 · tz − 1 in a pure self-similar scenario

Rescaling of Thermodynamic Profiles

Table A.3 quotes the exponent for the dependence in temperature (and mass) and relative redshift evolution for common thermodynamic quantities For instance, the conversion to Q∆ ∼ MaM E aMz z is obtained via the relation T∆ = fT T ∼ T 1+t1E tz z = (EzM) 2/3

Published Results and Tension Reduction

Among 39 relations considered in this meta-analysis, nineteen (14) exhibit tensions > 3σ (> 5σ) when self-similarity is assumed These numbers decrease to 4 (1) when fg − fT are left free to vary By imposing a relative statistical error not lower than 3 (5) percent on the constraints extracted from the literature, the number of values in tension at > 5σ drops to zero, and those still at > 3σ are reduced to two (none)

Future Directions

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021)1 and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021)1 and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021)1 and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021)1 and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021)1 and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

2024), will permit detailed studies of both the relations among integrated quantities and the universal behavior of spatially-resolved gas thermodynamic properties Complementary analyses linking slopes and evolutions of the reconstructed X-ray scaling laws in numerical simulations to the metaparameters will permit us to assess and constrain the level of feedback acting on the baryon energy and distribution as a function of halo mass and cosmic time

Acknowledgements

I thank Y. Emre Bahar, Vittorio Ghirardini, Mauro Sereno for comments on the manuscript I acknowledge the financial contribution from Theory Grant / Bando INAF per la Ricerca Fondamentale 2024 on “Constraining the non-thermal pressure in galaxy clusters with high-resolution X-ray spectroscopy” (1. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Emre Bahar, Vittorio Ghirardini, Mauro Sereno for comments on the manuscript. I acknowledge the financial contribution from Theory Grant / Bando INAF per la Ricerca Fondamentale 2024 on “Constraining the non-thermal pressure in galaxy clusters with high-resolution X-ray spectroscopy” (1.

05.24.05.10)

References

Akino, D., Eckert, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

2023, the latter one hereafter referred to as E23). While the self-similar model provides a baseline, observed data show systematic departures, particularly in lower-mass systems (∼ 1013 − 1014M⊙; see recent reviews in Eckert et al.

, Okabe, N. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Eckert, D. , Okabe, N.

, et al. 2022, PASJ, 74, 175 Arnaud, M. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Okabe, N. 2022, PASJ, 74, 175 Arnaud, M.

, Pratt, G. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(2025) (+9. 5σ); Lb − M relation in Pratt et al.

W., Piffaretti, R. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Pratt, G. , Piffaretti, R.

, et al. 2010, A&A, 517, A92 Bahar, Y. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Piffaretti, R. 2010, A&A, 517, A92 Bahar, Y.

E., Bulbul, E. p. 4
Where the paper says it

5 in different redshift bins and up to z ∼ 1. 1 as measured in 10,440 objects selected in the eROSITA eRASS-1 survey (Bulbul et al.

, Clerc, N. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Bulbul, E. , Clerc, N.

, et al. 2022, A&A, 661, A7 Böhringer, H. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Clerc, N. 2022, A&A, 661, A7 Böhringer, H.

, Dolag, K. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2022, A&A, 661, A7 Böhringer, H. , Dolag, K.

, & Chon, G. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Dolag, K. , & Chon, G.

2012, A&A, 539, A120 Bulbul, E. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, & Chon, G. 2012, A&A, 539, A120 Bulbul, E.

, Liu, A., Kluge, M. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2012, A&A, 539, A120 Bulbul, E. , Kluge, M.

, et al. 2024, A&A, 685, A106 CHEX-MATE Collaboration, Arnaud, M. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Kluge, M. 2024, A&A, 685, A106 CHEX-MATE Collaboration, Arnaud, M.

, Ettori, S. p. 0
Where the paper says it

the review in Voit 2005, Böhringer et al. 2012, Ettori et al.

, et al. 2021, A&A, 650, A104 Eckert, D. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Ettori, S. 2021, A&A, 650, A104 Eckert, D.

, Gaspari, M. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2021, A&A, 650, A104 Eckert, D. , Gaspari, M.

, Gastaldello, F. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Gaspari, M. , Gastaldello, F.

, Le Brun, A. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Gastaldello, F. , Le Brun, A.

M. C., & O’Sullivan, E. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Le Brun, A. , & O’Sullivan, E.

2021, Universe, 7, 142 Eckert, D. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, & O’Sullivan, E. 2021, Universe, 7, 142 Eckert, D.

, Seppi, R. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2024, Galaxies, 12, 24 Eckert, D. , Seppi, R.

, Braspenning, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Seppi, R. , Braspenning, J.

, et al. 2026, A&A, 709, L4 Ettori, S. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Braspenning, J. 2026, A&A, 709, L4 Ettori, S.

2013, MNRAS, 435, 1265 Ettori, S. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2026, A&A, 709, L4 Ettori, S. 2013, MNRAS, 435, 1265 Ettori, S.

2015, MNRAS, 446, 2629 Ettori, S. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2013, MNRAS, 435, 1265 Ettori, S. 2015, MNRAS, 446, 2629 Ettori, S.

, Lovisari, L. p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the self-similar model provides a baseline, observed data show systematic departures, particularly in lower-mass systems (∼ 1013 − 1014M⊙; see recent reviews in Eckert et al. 2021; Lovisari et al.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

While the self-similar model provides a baseline, observed data show systematic departures, particularly in lower-mass systems (∼ 1013 − 1014M⊙; see recent reviews in Eckert et al. 2021; Lovisari et al.

, & Eckert, D. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2023, the latter one hereafter referred to as E23). While the self-similar model provides a baseline, observed data show systematic departures, particularly in lower-mass systems (∼ 1013 − 1014M⊙; see recent reviews in Eckert et al.

2023, A&A, 669, A133 Ettori, S. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, & Eckert, D. 2023, A&A, 669, A133 Ettori, S.

, Lovisari, L., & Sereno, M. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Acknowledgements. Emre Bahar, Vittorio Ghirardini, Mauro Sereno for comments on the manuscript.

2020, A&A, 644, A111 Toptun, V. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, & Sereno, M. 2020, A&A, 644, A111 Ettori, S.

, Popesso, P. p. 4
Where the paper says it

2024), and with the value of 0. 02 obtained for optically (GAMA) selected local objects followed-up with eROSITA signal in Popesso et al.

, Marini, I. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Biviano, A. , Marini, I.

, et al. 2025, A&A, 700, A167 Vikhlinin, A. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Marini, I. 2025, A&A, 700, A167 Vikhlinin, A.

2006, ApJ, 640, 710 Vikhlinin, A. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2025, A&A, 700, A167 Vikhlinin, A. 2006, ApJ, 640, 710 Vikhlinin, A.

, Kravtsov, A. p. 2
Where the paper says it

thus, α = 3/4, θ = 3/8, ϕ = 3/2) and then by eliminating the mass-dependence in the M − T and M − L relations. Other relations can be obtained by combining different observables (such as YX = Mgas × T -see Kravtsov et al.

, Forman, W. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Kravtsov, A. , Forman, W.

, et al. 2006, ApJ, 640, 691 Voit, G. p. 5
Where the paper says it

, Forman, W. 2006, ApJ, 640, 691 Voit, G.

M. 2005, Reviews of Modern Physics, 77, 207

--- Page 1 ---

Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. beyondSS ©ESO 2026 June 3, 2026 Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups S. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. beyondSS ©ESO 2026 June 3, 2026 Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups S.

Ettori1, 2,⋆ INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129 Bologna, Italy INFN, Sezione di Bologna, viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127 Bologna, Italy ABSTRACT Context. p. 0
Where the paper says it

beyondSS ©ESO 2026 June 3, 2026 Beyond Self-Similarity: Reconciling X-Ray Scaling Relations in Galaxy Clusters and Groups S. Ettori1, 2,⋆ 1 INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129 Bologna, Italy 2 INFN, Sezione di Bologna, viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127 Bologna, Italy ABSTRACT Context.

Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model’s baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems Aims. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups. However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model’s baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems.

I show that the observed departures from self-similar predictions can be efficiently described by two physical quantities modeled with power laws

--- Page 2 ---

Ettori (Sect 3) introduced temperature-dependent and redshift-evolving parameters (namely fg and fT) to modify the ideal self-similar relations These parameters fg and fT are introduced as phenomenological, but physically motivated, factors that accommodate observed departures in galaxy cluster scaling relations

--- Page 3 ---

It is worth noting that the temperature T in both equations refers to a “measured” quantity, such as the spectroscopic estimate Tsp, and is here adopted as the reference quantity due to its intensive nature, which does not depend on any cosmological parameter

--- Page 4 ---

Assuming that published scaling relations reflect the intrinsic properties of the underlying galaxy group and cluster population, we can use their best-fit values to calibrate our model and its parameters for departures from self-similarity The meta-analysis constrains the four (meta-)parameters (and their correlations; see the corner plot in Fig. 4) by reproducing the best-fit values reported in the recent literature and spanning a wide range in mass and redshift

--- Page 5 ---

Overall, modeling the departures from self-similarity with these parameters drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in > 3σ (> 5σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent

--- Page 6 ---

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al. 2024), will permit detailed studies of both the relations among integrated quantities and the universal behavior of spatially-resolved gas thermodynamic properties

--- Page 7 ---

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al. 2024), will permit detailed studies of both the relations among integrated quantities and the universal behavior of spatially-resolved gas thermodynamic properties

--- Page 8 ---

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al. 2024), will permit detailed studies of both the relations among integrated quantities and the universal behavior of spatially-resolved gas thermodynamic properties

--- Page 9 ---

The new datasets that are becoming available, accurately selected and homogeneously exposed to X-rays, such as CHEXMATE (CHEX-MATE Collaboration et al. 2021) and X-GAP (Eckert et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved predictive accuracy for X-ray scaling relations by incorporating two physical quantities, gas mass fraction (fg) and temperature variation (fT). The model reduces tension in 19 out of 39 published relations from greater than 3 sigma to just two, by modeling departures from self-similarity with these parameters.

  2. Enhanced ability to predict the slopes and redshift evolution of various X-ray scaling laws using the generalized form. This framework allows for the study of the expected slope and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws, including the new quantity YLGT0, which is predicted to relate directly to mass without any redshift evolution.

  3. Robust calibration of meta-parameters using MCMC analysis across a large set of published data. The analysis yields constraints like f1 = 0.502 (±0.007) and t1 = 0.156 (±0.009), providing quantitative measures of how gas mass fraction and temperature variation depend on halo mass and redshift, as shown in Fig 5.

  4. Identification of the most deviant scaling relations through a meta-analysis framework. The study can recognize anomalies in published best-fit parameters by quantifying tension, finding that "the most deviant relation, the slope of L05 - Mg in Ramos-Ceja et al. (2025), is also the one with the smallest relative statistical error (0.5% at 1 sigma level of confidence) among all the relations considered in this study."

Abstract

Scaling relations hold among observed quantities that describe the thermodynamic properties of the gas in galaxy clusters and groups. However, observed data show systematic departures from the self-similar model's baseline predictions, particularly in lower-mass systems. I show that the observed departures from self-similar predictions can be efficiently described by two physical quantities modeled with power laws: the gas mass fraction f g and the temperature variation f T. Using a wide range of published X-ray scaling relations, this study conducts an MCMC-based meta-analysis to constrain the temperature- and redshift-dependence of the meta-parameters f g and f T and calibrate the model. These calibrations indicate that, while the gas mass fraction does not show significant evolution with cosmic time, it decreases significantly with decreasing halo mass. On the other hand, the temperature variation shows a mild positive increase with both mass and redshift. Overall, modeling the departures from the self-similar model with f g, f T drastically improves predictive accuracy, reducing the number of scaling relations in >3σ (>5 σ) tension from 49 (36) percent under the self-similar scenario to just 11 (3) percent (four and one out of 39, respectively) that might be identified for their peculiarity. Moreover, modeling through this generalized framework allows for an extended discussion of the expected slopes and redshift evolution for several X-ray scaling laws, including the new quantity Y LGT0 = L-1 M g squared T a L, a proxy for the cluster's volume that is independent of f g and f T by construction, and is predicted to scale directly with mass with a well-defined redshift evolution (M about Y LGT0 f g 0 f T 0 E z squared), as validated against hydrodynamical simulations and observational constraints.

Sources

Related papers