Breaking-induced energy dissipation of surface gravity waves at varying scales and co-flowing wind stresses

arXiv:2606.01705 · physics.flu-dyn, physics.ao-ph · Submitted 2026-06-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Breaking-induced energy dissipation of surface gravity waves at varying scales and co-flowing wind stresses".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of underlying wave scales and wind stresses This refined framework accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes The study shows that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics by modifying the breaking onset threshold The presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both fractional energy dissipation and the dissipation rate compared to unforced conditions An appropriate scaling for the dissipation rate is formulated based on the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb) The scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation Refined Framework for Energy Loss Quantification The authors propose a refined framework to quantify the energy loss due to breaking, denoted as ∆Ebr, in laboratory conditions.

Kai: This framework is based on revisiting and assessing methods like D08, T10, and C23.

Mira: The refined approach decomposes the total energy loss into upstream background dissipation ∆Efr,u and downstream background dissipation ∆Efr,d.

Kai: The resulting formula for breaking-induced energy dissipation is given by equation (17c).

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper investigates how breaking-induced energy loss is affected by wave scale variations and the presence of co-flowing wind stresses in lab experiments. The authors propose a refined framework to estimate the breaking-induced energy dissipation that handles background dissipation from non-breaking processes better.

Mira: They show that changing the wave scale mainly impacts this energetics through how it sets when a wave actually breaks, and they quantify how co-flowing wind systematically lowers both the fractional energy dissipation and the rate of energy loss.

Lev: It’s interesting because in our field, we’re often fighting with background noise or non-breaking effects, so having a framework that separates that background from the breaking itself is valuable for building better error correction schemes.

Kai: Specifically, they use surface elevation measurements at two fixed locations xI and xO to define a control volume, along with breaking locations xb1 and xb2 determined from side-view imagery to estimate delta Ebr.

Mira: They also focus on deriving a scaling for the energy dissipation rate epsilon sub b equals delta Ebr over tau sub b, which they found is constrained by the crest-front steepness Sfront of tb.

Lev: That Sfront of tb connection is key; it links the measured dissipation rate directly to that specific local wave steepness across all their tested scales.

Kai: And they show how this leads to a scaling for fractional energy dissipation proportional to beta star times S front of tb times tau sub b over Tb, which shows the role of both asymmetry and duration.

Mira: It's clear they are trying to move away from just looking at local non-linearity and incorporating other factors into that picture.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you can nail that scaling based on Sfront of tb, it means the measurement becomes much more predictable regardless of the specific wave scale you’re observing.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title, "Breaking-induced energy dissipation of surface gravity waves at varying scales and co-flowing wind stresses," it really captures the complexity they are tackling in this study.

Mira: It sounds like they are showing how different physical conditions—scale, wind stress—don't just add up linearly but interact to change the breaking process itself.

Lev: What this means for us is that when we think about modeling wave evolution, we can't just treat these things as independent variables; they have a joint effect on the breaking event.

Kai: The authors are giving us a clearer way to quantify how much energy is lost when waves break, which is important because it moves us beyond just measuring the individual events in the open ocean.

Mira: It suggests that for future work we need to look at where this scaling holds up when we move from controlled flumes to real ocean conditions where more physical processes are happening.

Lev: That's right, because in reality, those extra factors can complicate things significantly, and understanding the constraints of this scaling is how you figure out where the assumptions break down.

Rui Cao, Enrique M. Padilla, Xu Chen, Adrian H. Callaghan

State Key Laboratory of Physical Oceanography, Ocean University of China · College of Oceanic and Atmospheric Sciences, Ocean University of China · Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Imperial College London · Barcelona School of Industrial Engineering, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya

physics.flu-dyn, physics.ao-ph

Submitted: 2026-06-01

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 36 pages, 14 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of underlying wave…

Key concepts

Breaking-induced energy dissipation (\u0394Ebr)
This measures the specific amount of energy lost when a wave breaks. The authors created a refined method to calculate this loss by separating it into upstream and downstream background dissipation, making the measurement more accurate than previous methods.
Crest-front steepness (Sfront(tb))
This is a measure of how steep the front of the breaking wave is. The study shows that this steepness effectively constrains and scales both fractional energy dissipation and the energy dissipation rate, regardless of the underlying wave scale.
Fractional Energy Dissipation Scaling
The paper derives a scaling relationship for how much energy is lost relative to the initial energy ($ΔEbr/E0). This scaling depends on crest asymmetry and breaking duration, showing that these factors are crucial in determining the final energy loss amount.
Co-flowing Wind Effects
When wind flows with the wave, it systematically lowers both fractional energy dissipation and the overall dissipation rate. This reduction is attributed to wind modifying wave dispersion and altering high-frequency spectral energy content.

Terminology

Summary

Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of underlying wave scales and wind stresses This refined framework accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes The study shows that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics by modifying the breaking onset threshold The presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both fractional energy dissipation and the dissipation rate compared to unforced conditions An appropriate scaling for the dissipation rate is formulated based on the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb) The scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation

Refined Framework for Energy Loss Quantification

The authors propose a refined framework to quantify the energy loss due to breaking, denoted as ∆Ebr, in laboratory conditions. This framework is based on revisiting and assessing methods like D08, T10, and C23. p. 7

Where the paper says it

2 Existing methods used to quantify breaking wave energy dissipation in laboratory 3. 1 Revisiting the T10 framework The method proposed by Tian et al.

The refined approach decomposes the total energy loss into upstream background dissipation ∆Efr,u and downstream background dissipation ∆Efr,d. p. 9
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, C23 also noted that their formulation may slightly overestimate ∆Efr, and thus underestimate ∆Ebr, because ∆Efr is related only to the upstream wave group energy E(xI ). In practice, following breaking, a ’new’ and less energetic wave group is formed downstream, which is expected to experience weaker background dissipation.

The resulting formula for breaking-induced energy dissipation is given by equation (17c). p. 2
Where the paper says it

2 Problem formulation and objectives Although breaking-induced energy loss and dissipation rates are commonly nondimensionalised, and scaled using wave steepness owing to its close link with wave non-linearity and breaker intensity, available evidence indicates that an intrinsic scale dependence remains. For example, for a given value of Sn, breaking waves of different scales have been observed to exhibit systematically different levels of fractional energy dissipation, ∆Ebr/E0, as evident in figure 3(a) of Perlin et al.

This allows ∆Ebr to be estimated using surface elevation measurements at the two fixed locations xI and xO defining the control volume, alongside the breaking locations xb1 and xb2 determined from side-view imagery.

Role of Wave Scale and Wind Forcing

The primary influence of wave scale on both fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and dissipation rate ϵb is through its role in setting the breaking onset Both ∆Ebr/E(xI) and ϵb are found to decrease systematically in the presence of co-flowing wind. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold. We also show that the presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ∆Ebr/E0 and ϵb compared to unforced conditions without wind, as wind-forced waves break earlier and have a reduced degree of crest forward-leaning.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold. We also show that the presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ∆Ebr/E0 and ϵb compared to unforced conditions without wind, as wind-forced waves break earlier and have a reduced degree of crest forward-leaning.

This reduction is likely due to a combination of wind-related effects such as modifications to wave dispersion and changes in high-frequency spectral energy content The crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) provides the most effective description of breaking-induced fractional energy dissipation across different wave scales. p. 3
Where the paper says it

, 2022), the manner in which direct wind stress modifies the wave shape at incipient breaking has been clarified. Here, we aim to systematically examine how direct wind stress influences breaking-induced energy dissipation, the associated dissipation rate and b, and to interpret these effects in the context of wind-induced modifications to the local crest geometry.

Energy Dissipation Rate Scaling

The authors derive a scaling for the energy dissipation rate of the form ϵb = ∆Ebr/τb. This scaling is found to be effectively constrained by the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) across all breaking conditions studied. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also show that the presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ∆Ebr/E0 and ϵb compared to unforced conditions without wind, as wind-forced waves break earlier and have a reduced degree of crest forward-leaning. Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure.

The resulting scaling for fractional energy dissipation is given by ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

This scaling identifies the non-dimensional breaking duration τb/Tb as an additional controlling variable for fractional energy dissipation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

Breaking Strength Parameter Constraints

The authors revisit the breaking strength parameter b and find that a natural next step involves relating bb to locally measured Sfront(tb) after accounting for the breaking onset threshold. They find an approximately linear relationship between bb and Sfront(tb). p. 9

Where the paper says it

In the next section, we describe how this effect is accounted for and introduce the refined framework adopted in the present study. 3 A refined framework based on C23 Notwithstanding the approximately linear relationship between the background dissipation ∆Efr and the initial wave group energy reported in Cao et al.

This scaling highlights that ∆Ebr/E(xI) depends not only on local non-linearity but also on crest asymmetry and the breaking duration relative to the wave period. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

Method Comparison and Robustness

The comparison of methods indicates that the D08 method tends to systematically overestimate ∆Ebr relative to the present refined framework. The magnitude of this overestimation generally increases with increasing E(xI). p. 1

Where the paper says it

While wave steepness has been defined in different ways across studies, it is generally constructed from a combination of some characteristic wave amplitude, a, and some characteristic wavenumber, k, such that S ∼ ak. Notwithstanding differences in the precise definition of wave steepness, there is broad agreement that, for individual breaking events, ∆Ebr/E0 increases monotonically with S at low steepness and may approach an upper bound as breaking becomes sufficiently energetic or involves multiple breaking processes.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

While wave steepness has been defined in different ways across studies, it is generally constructed from a combination of some characteristic wave amplitude, a, and some characteristic wavenumber, k, such that S ∼ ak. Notwithstanding differences in the precise definition of wave steepness, there is broad agreement that, for individual breaking events, ∆Ebr/E0 increases monotonically with S at low steepness and may approach an upper bound as breaking becomes sufficiently energetic or involves multiple breaking processes.

The refined framework retains a high degree of robustness, with moderate subjectivity in the selection of xb1 and xb2 exerting only a limited influence on the estimated breaking-induced energy dissipation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold. We also show that the presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ∆Ebr/E0 and ϵb compared to unforced conditions without wind, as wind-forced waves break earlier and have a reduced degree of crest forward-leaning.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold. We also show that the presence of co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ∆Ebr/E0 and ϵb compared to unforced conditions without wind, as wind-forced waves break earlier and have a reduced degree of crest forward-leaning.

Conclusion on Scaling

The study concludes that once appropriately scaled, the energy dissipation rate can be effectively constrained by Sfront(tb) across all breaking conditions studied here. This leads to a scaling for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb). p. 0

Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

The study reinforces that the non-dimensional breaking duration τb/Tb plays an active role in controlling dissipation in individual breaking waves. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation.

The authors suggest examining how these relationships extend to oceanic breaking waves where additional physical processes can come to play a part

The energy dissipation rate is quantified by ϵb = ∆Ebr/τb. The authors find that once appropriately scaled the energy dissipation rate can be constrained effectively by the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) over the range of breaking conditions studied here. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

This leads to a scaling for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb). The proportional relationship in (23) is verified in figure 11 using all the breaking waves from the SIREN, BUBER, and EURUS experiments. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The experimental results and their interpretation are presented in §4, followed by a summary of the key findings and implications of the present work in §5. 2 Descriptions of the datasets: SIREN, BUBER and EURUS The laboratory measurements of surface breaking waves analysed in the present study were obtained from three experimental campaigns, formally referred to as SIREN, BUBER, and EURUS.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

The experimental results and their interpretation are presented in §4, followed by a summary of the key findings and implications of the present work in §5. 2 Descriptions of the datasets: SIREN, BUBER and EURUS The laboratory measurements of surface breaking waves analysed in the present study were obtained from three experimental campaigns, formally referred to as SIREN, BUBER, and EURUS.

This scaling highlights that ∆Ebr/E(xI) depends not only on local non-linearity but also on crest asymmetry and the breaking duration relative to the wave period. The authors reinforce that it plays an active role in controlling dissipation in individual breaking waves. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In a broader context, wave breaking plays a direct role in air–sea exchange processes and provides a key physical constraint for spectral wave modelling (Deike, 2022; Callaghan et al. Accurately characterising both the severity and the rate of energy dissipation associated with individual breaking events therefore remains an active area of research.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In a broader context, wave breaking plays a direct role in air–sea exchange processes and provides a key physical constraint for spectral wave modelling (Deike, 2022; Callaghan et al. Accurately characterising both the severity and the rate of energy dissipation associated with individual breaking events therefore remains an active area of research.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In a broader context, wave breaking plays a direct role in air–sea exchange processes and provides a key physical constraint for spectral wave modelling (Deike, 2022; Callaghan et al. Accurately characterising both the severity and the rate of energy dissipation associated with individual breaking events therefore remains an active area of research.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In a broader context, wave breaking plays a direct role in air–sea exchange processes and provides a key physical constraint for spectral wave modelling (Deike, 2022; Callaghan et al. Accurately characterising both the severity and the rate of energy dissipation associated with individual breaking events therefore remains an active area of research.

Breaking Strength Parameter Scaling

The authors find that the scaling laws proposed previously, including bb ∝ S5/2n (Drazen et al., 2008) and bb ∝ Ss (Tian et al. p. 1

Where the paper says it

, 1998; Drazen et al. , 2008; Tian et al.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

, 1998; Drazen et al. , 2008; Tian et al.

, 2010), capture the overall trends across much of the dataset. Motivated by practical limitations associated with applying such measures to individual breaking events in the field, they relate bb to locally measured Sfront(tb) and find an approximately linear relationship between bb and Sfront(tb) after accounting for the breaking onset threshold. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation. Finally, we consider the implications for the breaking strength parameter b by first assessing existing steepness-based scaling laws, and subsequently relating b to Sfront(tb) which yields an approximately linear dependence once the breaking-onset threshold is considered.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This scaling explicitly highlights that crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role in setting the breaking wave energy dissipation. Finally, we consider the implications for the breaking strength parameter b by first assessing existing steepness-based scaling laws, and subsequently relating b to Sfront(tb) which yields an approximately linear dependence once the breaking-onset threshold is considered.

This suggests that once appropriately scaled the energy dissipation rate can be constrained effectively by the crest-front steepness. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

The resulting scaling is given by ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ 2β∗ π Sb (τb/Tb), where β∗ is a crest-leaning parameter. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

This scaling highlights that ∆Ebr/E(xI) depends not only on local non-linearity but also on crest asymmetry and the breaking duration relative to the wave period. The authors reinforce that it plays an active role in controlling dissipation in individual breaking waves.

Method Comparisons

In this appendix we compare estimates of breaking-induced energy dissipation, ∆Ebr, obtained using the methods of D08, T10, and C23 with those produced by the refined framework they propose in §3.3. We see that across all breaking conditions examined, the D08 method tends to systematically overestimate ∆Ebr relative to the present refined framework. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In §3, we introduce a refined framework for quantifying the energy loss due to breaking, ∆Ebr, in laboratory conditions, alongside a brief reassessment of methods employed in previous studies. The experimental results and their interpretation are presented in §4, followed by a summary of the key findings and implications of the present work in §5.

The magnitude of this overestimation generally increases with increasing E(xI). Estimates obtained using the T10 method and the refined framework are in close agreement with those obtained using D8 and C23. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Because ∆Ebr is obtained from the difference between two fitted curves at xb, estimates for weakly dissipative breaking events may be sensitive to fitting uncertainty and the choice of xb. 2 Comparison of the methods used in D08 and C23 Both D08 and C23 estimate breaking-induced energy dissipation ∆Ebr using a control-volumebased energy balance.

We also see a reduced difference in ∆Ebr among the different methods at larger Tp. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Because ∆Ebr is obtained from the difference between two fitted curves at xb, estimates for weakly dissipative breaking events may be sensitive to fitting uncertainty and the choice of xb. 2 Comparison of the methods used in D08 and C23 Both D08 and C23 estimate breaking-induced energy dissipation ∆Ebr using a control-volumebased energy balance.

Sensitivity Test on the Refined Framework

The selection of the two horizontal locations xb1 and xb2 inevitably involves a degree of subjectivity. The results indicate that reasonable variations in the selection of xb1 and xb2 do not critically affect the resulting estimates of ∆Ebr. The refined framework retains a high degree of robustness, with moderate subjectivity in the selection of xb1 and xb2 exerting only a limited influence on the estimated breaking-induced energy dissipation.

Summary of Contributions

The first contribution is the development of a refined framework for quantifying the breaking-induced energy loss ∆Ebr in physical wave flumes. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In the following, we comment on these existing approaches and their underlying assumptions, before introducing a refined framework based on C23 that is adopted in the present study. 1 General framework for wave energetics and breaking-induced energy dissipation In quantifying the amount of energy dissipated by wave breaking in unidirectional wave groups, one first considers the local mechanical energy flux, F(x, z, t) (units: J m−2 s −1 ), through vertical sections at different streamwise locations along the wave flume.

This framework more reliably accounts for background dissipation arising from wave group propagation without introducing substantial additional measurement complexity. p. 0
Where the paper says it

cn 1 June 2026 Abstract Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of underlying wave scales and wind stresses. A refined framework to estimate the breakinginduced energy dissipation ∆Ebr is first proposed which accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

cn 1 June 2026 Abstract Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of underlying wave scales and wind stresses. A refined framework to estimate the breakinginduced energy dissipation ∆Ebr is first proposed which accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes.

The study finds that the primary influence of wave scale on both fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and dissipation rate ϵb is through its role in setting the breaking onset. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A refined framework to estimate the breakinginduced energy dissipation ∆Ebr is first proposed which accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes. Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

A refined framework to estimate the breakinginduced energy dissipation ∆Ebr is first proposed which accounts for background dissipation arising from non-breaking processes. Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as the fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and the associated dissipation rate ϵb, by modifying the breaking onset threshold.

Both ∆Ebr/E(xI) and ϵb are found to decrease systematically in the presence of co-flowing wind. The authors suggest examining how these relationships extend to oceanic breaking waves where additional physical processes can come to play a part.

The energy dissipation rate is quantified by ϵb = ∆Ebr/τb. The authors find that once appropriately scaled the energy dissipation rate can be effectively constrained by the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) across all breaking conditions studied here. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

This leads to a scaling for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ β∗ Sb (τb/Tb). The proportional relationship in (23) is verified in figure 11 using all the breaking waves from the SIREN, BUBER, and EURUS experiments. This scaling highlights that ∆Ebr/E(xI) depends not only on local non-linearity but also on crest asymmetry and the breaking duration relative to the wave period. The authors reinforce that it plays an active role in controlling dissipation in individual breaking waves.

The authors find that the scaling laws proposed previously, including bb ∝ S5/2n (Drazen et al., 2008) and bb ∝ Ss (Tian et al., 2010), capture the overall trends across much of the dataset. Motivated by practical limitations associated with applying such measures to individual breaking events in the field, they relate bb to locally measured Sfront(tb) and find an approximately linear relationship between bb and Sfront(tb) after accounting for the breaking onset threshold. This suggests that once appropriately scaled the energy dissipation rate can be constrained effectively by the crest-front steepness. The resulting scaling is given by ∆Ebr/E(xI) ∝ 2β∗ π Sb (τb/Tb). p. 0

Where the paper says it

Exploiting the ability of the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking Sfront(tb) to characterise both the breaking onset threshold and the local crest geometry, an appropriate scaling for ϵb is subsequently formulated based on this local measure. This leads to a relation for fractional energy dissipation of the form ∆Ebr/E0 ∝ β ∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where β ∗ , Sb and τb/Tb represent the degree of crest forward leaning, the local steepness, and the non-dimensional breaking duration.

This scaling highlights that ∆Ebr/E(xI) depends not only on local non-linearity but also on crest asymmetry and the breaking duration relative to the wave period. The authors reinforce that it plays an active role in controlling dissipation in individual breaking waves.

In this study, we have used laboratory measurements of unsteady, unidirectional surface wave groups to investigate breaking-induced energy dissipation and dissipation rates in individual breaking events across a range of underlying wave scales and under both wind-unforced and co-flowing wind conditions. The first contribution is the development of a refined framework for quantifying the breaking-induced energy loss ∆Ebr in physical wave flumes. This framework more reliably accounts for background dissipation arising from wave group propagation without introducing substantial additional measurement complexity. The study finds that the primary influence of wave scale on both fractional energy dissipation ∆Ebr/E0 and dissipation rate ϵb is through its role in setting the breaking onset. Both ∆Ebr/E(xI) and ϵb are found to decrease systematically in the presence of co-flowing wind. The authors suggest examining how these relationships extend to oceanic breaking waves where additional physical processes can come to play a part.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Refined framework for quantifying breaking-induced energy loss: The improved system can calculate breaking-induced energy dissipation using equation 17c, which explicitly decomposes total energy loss into upstream background dissipation and downstream background dissipation based on a power-law relationship derived from non-breaking cases (equation 12).

  2. Wave scale influence modeling: The AI system can determine the primary influence of wave scale on both fractional energy dissipation and dissipation rate by using the crest-front steepness Sfront(tb) rather than just wave group steepness, as this measure is shown to provide a most effective description of breaking-induced fractional energy dissipation.

  3. Co-flowing wind effect prediction: The system can predict the systematic reduction in fractional energy dissipation and dissipation rate under co-flowing wind conditions by leveraging the scaling relation ∆Ebr/E0 proportional to β∗ Sb (τb/Tb), where Sfront(tb) accounts for crest asymmetry and breaking duration play an important role.

  4. Breaking strength parameter estimation: The improved system can estimate the breaking strength parameter b by relating it to local steepness measures, finding an approximately linear relationship between bb and Sfront(tb), after explicitly accounting for the breaking onset threshold.

Abstract

Breaking-induced energy dissipation is studied for individual unsteady breaking waves using laboratory measurements of unidirectional surface gravity wave groups across a range of wave scales and wind stresses. A refined framework to estimate breaking-induced dissipation ΔE br is proposed that accounts for background dissipation from non-breaking processes. Using this framework, we show that variations in wave scale primarily influence breaking energetics, such as fractional dissipation ΔE br/E 0 and dissipation rate ε b, by modifying the breaking onset threshold. Also, co-flowing wind systematically reduces both ΔE br/E 0 and ε b relative to unforced conditions, as wind-forced waves break earlier with reduced crest forward-leaning. Exploiting the crest-front steepness at incipient breaking S front(t b) to characterise breaking onset and local crest geometry, we formulate a scaling for ε b based on this local measure. This then yields ΔE br/E 0 proportional to β*, S b,(τ b/T b), where β* is crest forward leaning, S b local steepness, and τ b/T b non-dimensional breaking duration. This scaling highlights the important roles of crest asymmetry and breaking duration in setting the breaking energy dissipation. Finally, we consider the breaking strength parameter b by assessing existing steepness-based scaling laws, and relate b to S front(t b), yielding an approximately linear dependence once the breaking-onset threshold is considered.

Sources

Related papers