Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes

arXiv:2605.14572 · gr-qc, astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2026-05-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes".

Paper summary: Kai: So, to summarize this paper, it’s about using Thurston spacetimes as a background model to examine the coherent temperature and polarization signals in the CMB sky >

Mira: The thesis is that by introducing these eight specific geometries—R3, S3, H3, R times H2, R times S2, U(H2), Nil and Solv—we can construct transfer equations for photons in each one >

Lev: They build a tetrad basis to describe the photon geodesics in these curved spaces by defining the metric and the Ricci rotation coefficients >

Kai: The methodology involves generalizing the Liouville equation to give us a complete description of how photons travel through this curved spacetime, and then solving those equations for each geometry >

Mira: They add a source term to account for Thomson scattering by free electrons, which is important because that’s how we get the actual observed radiation distribution function N >

Lev: The transfer equation describes a complex photon distribution with components that have spin weights zero, which is unpolarized, and spin weights two, which is polarized >

Kai: They then model this by decomposing the radiation distribution function into multipole components, specifically N0 and N2, to get the temperature and polarization maps >

Mira: The simulation involves integrating a stiff system of forty-eight coupled ordinary differential equations per line of sight to track the real and imaginary components of those multipoles >

Lev: They also seed these simulations with initial perturbations in the quadrupole components at a very small value, one to the power of negative six >

Kai: The main claim is that they present the results of the temperature and polarization sky maps in each of those eight Thurston universes as a result of their transfer equations >

Mira: They then discuss how spatial curvature plays a role in these FLRW limiting models along with their underlying geometry, which connects it back to the Thurston-Perelman geometrization theorem >

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title, "Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes," it’s clear they are testing how these specific anisotropic models alter what we see in the CMB data >

Mira: They are taking established mathematical structures from Thurston’s work on three-dimensional manifolds and applying them to a cosmological context, which is why this matters for large-scale cosmic isotropy >

Lev: What this means for the world is that it sets up a framework where we can see if these specific spacetime geometries are compatible with the observed CMB patterns, or if they introduce new features >

Kai: It’s about connecting abstract geometry to real observational constraints, and seeing how these models behave when you look at the data generated by different geometries >

Mira: Ultimately, this work provides a master grid of projections for temperature, polarization, and those other signals across different cosmic epochs so we can see the dynamics unfold >

Lev: And they conclude that the overall degree of polarization is strongly tied to the ionization history through that optical depth tau, which is a crucial constraint >

Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science Education & Research, Bhopal, India

gr-qc, astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2026-05-14

Updated: 2026-11-18

Comments: 27 pages (excluding bibliography), 11 figures. Corrected methodology

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 62/100

The gist: Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes examines the coherent temperature and polarization signals generated in the CMB sky by anisotropic Thurston…

Key concepts

Thurston Geometries
These are eight specific types of homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime models proposed by W. Thurston. They include both isotropic and anisotropic shapes like R3, S3, and Nil, which serve as the mathematical frameworks for analyzing photon paths in this study.
Photon Evolution Formalism
The paper uses a generalized Liouville equation to describe how photons travel through curved spacetime. This formal method allows researchers to track the evolution of polarized radiation by treating it as a complex distribution with spin weights, detailing how light changes as it moves.
Multipole Decomposition (N0 and N2)
The radiation distribution function is broken down into components called multipoles, specifically N0 for unpolarized light and N2 for polarized light. Analyzing these components helps quantify the temperature fluctuations and polarization patterns across the sky.
Optical Depth ($ au$)
Optical depth represents how much radiation is scattered by free electrons as it travels through space. It is calculated using the formula $\tau = Xe n e \sigma T$, and this value is crucial because it strongly influences the overall degree of polarization observed in the CMB.

Terminology

Summary

Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes examines the coherent temperature and polarization signals generated in the CMB sky by anisotropic Thurston geometries to address anomalies in large-scale cosmic isotropy

Background on Thurston Geometries

Thurston geometries are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime models proposed by W. Thurston and later proved by G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Thurston geometries [5, 6] are a class of homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime models proposed first by W. Thurston in his work [6] and later proved by G.

Perelman, consisting of three isotropic geometries and five anisotropic ones These geometries include R3, S3, H3, R×S2, R×H2, U(H2), Nil & Solv The paper is motivated by several observed anomalies in the CMB sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur and the Galactic Cold Spot. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Formalism for Photon Evolution

The analysis introduces a tetrad basis constructed from a local coordinate system to analyze photon geodesics within each geometry The general methodology involves generalizing the Liouville equation to provide a complete description of photons traveling through curved spacetime. The transfer equation for polarized radiation is described by a complex photon distribution comprising components with spin weights 0 (unpolarized) and 2 (polarized). p. 2

Where the paper says it

6) and on spin-weighted spherical harmonics. The transfer equation for polarized radiation propagating through spacetime can be described by a (complex) photon distribution comprising components with spin weights 0 (unpolarized) and 2 (polarized) [45], i.

Modeling Radiation Transfer

The Boltzmann equation is obtained by adding a source term describing Thomson scattering by free electrons to the right-hand side of the Liouville equation. The optical depth τ is given by τ = Xe ne σT, where Xe is the free electron fraction and σT is the Thomson scattering cross section. p. 4

Where the paper says it

24) where the optical depth τ is given by τ = Xe ne σT (3. 25) where Xe is the free electron fraction, taken to be ≈ 10−3 for our interest of redshifts [49], ne is the free electron number density and σT is the Thomson scattering cross section.

The radiation distribution function N can be decomposed into multipole components, specifically N0 and N2. p. 5
Where the paper says it

We thus expand the distribution function in (3. 17) in terms of multipole components: N 0 = N 0 0 + N 0 i k i + N 0 ijk ij + .

Simulation Methodology

The simulation models photon distribution by integrating a stiff system of 48 coupled ordinary differential equations (ODEs) per line of sight to track real and imaginary components of multipoles. Initial perturbations are seeded in the quadrupole components at 10−6. p. 7

Where the paper says it

These track real and imaginary components of multipoles (R0 µ , I0 µ , R0 ij , I0 ij , R2 ij , I2 ij ). Initial perturbations are seeded in the quadrupole components at 10−6 .

The sky is discretized into 12,288 pixels using HEALPix with Nside = 32. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The sky is discretized into 12,288 pixels using HEALPix (Nside = 32). The background cosmology is defined by a ΛCDM-like expansion where a(t) ∝ (sinh(1.

Key Findings and Implications

The results show that the patterns of S3 geometry look indistinguishable from R3 geometry. Except for H3 and R×H2, all geometries exhibit a near-constant pattern, although the intensity of fluctuations evolves in all Thurston geometries. p. 7

Where the paper says it

4 for all the geometries. Specifically, our work simulates the time evolution of CMB temperature and polarization fluctuations in each Thurston background.

All anisotropic Thurston geometries exhibit an increase in the intensity of temperature fluctuations with time. p. 7
Where the paper says it

4 for all the geometries. Specifically, our work simulates the time evolution of CMB temperature and polarization fluctuations in each Thurston background.

The paper proposes that these results should be verified by various ongoing and emerging observational hardware such as CMB-S4 and the Simons Observatory. p. 1
Where the paper says it

evolutions and discuss the various scattering mechanisms and in section 4 we present the results of the temperature and polarization sky maps in each of the Thurston universe. Finally, in section 5, we discuss our observations and conclude this work.

Conclusions

The work produces a master grid of Mollweide projections for T, P, Q, and U to illustrate the dynamics across different cosmic epochs. The overall degree of polarization strongly depends on the ionization history through the optical depth τ. p. 8

Where the paper says it

, ∼ 10−5 ) would yield morphologically identical maps, with the color bar values simply scaled down by a factor of 10−4 . The overall degree of polarization strongly depends on the ionization history through the optical depth τ .

The geometrical relationship between temperature and polarization patterns is heavily fixed by the geometrical structure of our models. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The overall degree of polarization strongly depends on the ionization history through the optical depth τ . We note that the geometrical relationship between the temperature and polarization patterns is heavily fixed by the geometrical structure of our models.

Future work will analyze these maps using a variety of statistical measures of anisotropy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Acknowledgements

The results in this paper have been derived using the HEALPix and healpy packages, and the authors acknowledge the Python package Healpy [69] of the original HEALPix software [70, 71]. The work was conducted at the IISER Bhopal Gargi cluster. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes Tanay Gupta ∗1 , Sukanta Panda †1 , and Rajib Saha ‡1 1Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science Education & Research, Bhopal, India Abstract Recent cosmological tests have discovered a fresh new set of anomalies in the large-scale isotropy of the universe. Motivated thus by the numerous pieces of evidence for large-scale cosmic isotropy violation with the advent of the ‘precision cosmology’ era, we are led to explore the viability of anisotropic Thurston geometries, described in William Thurston’s geometrization conjecture.

References

[1] AG Adame, J Aguilar, S Ahlen, Se Alam, DM Alexander, M Alvarez, O Alves, A Anand, U Andrade, E Armengaud, et al. Desi 2024 vi: cosmological constraints from the measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes Tanay Gupta ∗1 , Sukanta Panda †1 , and Rajib Saha ‡1 1Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science Education & Research, Bhopal, India Abstract Recent cosmological tests have discovered a fresh new set of anomalies in the large-scale isotropy of the universe. Motivated thus by the numerous pieces of evidence for large-scale cosmic isotropy violation with the advent of the ‘precision cosmology’ era, we are led to explore the viability of anisotropic Thurston geometries, described in William Thurston’s geometrization conjecture.

Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics > Page 19

[5] Yassir Awwad and Tomislav Prokopec. Large-scale geometry of the universe. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Modifications of CMB Temperature and Polarization Quadrupole Signals in Thurston Spacetimes Tanay Gupta ∗1 , Sukanta Panda †1 , and Rajib Saha ‡1 1Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science Education & Research, Bhopal, India Abstract Recent cosmological tests have discovered a fresh new set of anomalies in the large-scale isotropy of the universe. Motivated thus by the numerous pieces of evidence for large-scale cosmic isotropy violation with the advent of the ‘precision cosmology’ era, we are led to explore the viability of anisotropic Thurston geometries, described in William Thurston’s geometrization conjecture.

Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2024(01):010, 2024 > Page 19

[6] William P Thurston. Three dimensional manifolds, kleinian groups and hyperbolic geometry. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Thurston-Perelman’s geometrization theorem The Thurston-Perelman geometrization theorem [5] is a partial classification of three-dimensional manifolds, analogous to the uniformization theorem that classifies the possible geometries of Riemann surfaces. The main difference lies in the fact that not every 3-manifold can be endowed with a unique geometry, but rather every 3-manifold can be cut into pieces that can be endowed with one.

1982 > Page 19

[7] Grisha Perelman. The entropy formula for the ricci flow and its geometric applications. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2) meaning that the tetrad basis ea is orthonormal. The Ricci rotation coefficients are defined by Γαβγ = ea α eγa;b e b β (3.

arXiv preprint math/0211159, 2002 > Page 3

[8] Grisha Perelman. Finite extinction time for the solutions to the ricci flow on certain three-manifolds. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Also, natural units are employed (8πG = c = kb = ℏ = 1). 2 Thurston-Perelman’s geometrization theorem The Thurston-Perelman geometrization theorem [5] is a partial classification of three-dimensional manifolds, analogous to the uniformization theorem that classifies the possible geometries of Riemann surfaces.

arXiv preprint math/0307245, 2003 > Page 3

[9] Grisha Perelman. Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Also, natural units are employed (8πG = c = kb = ℏ = 1). 2 Thurston-Perelman’s geometrization theorem The Thurston-Perelman geometrization theorem [5] is a partial classification of three-dimensional manifolds, analogous to the uniformization theorem that classifies the possible geometries of Riemann surfaces.

arXiv preprint math/0303109, 2003 > Page 6

[14] Wen Zhao. Directional dependence of cmb parity asymmetry. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Physical Review D, 89(2):023010, 2014 > Page 5

[15] SA Balashev, EE Kholupenko, J Chluba, AV Ivanchik, and DA Varshalovich. Spectral distortions of the cmb dipole. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

The Astrophysical Journal, 810(2):131, 2015 > Page 7

[26] András Kovács, Niall Jeffrey, Marco Gatti, Chihway Chang, Lorne Whiteway, Nico Hamaus, Ofer Lahav, Giorgia Pollina, David Bacon, Tomasz Kacprzak, et al. The des view of the eridanus supervoid and the cmb cold spot. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society > Page 20

[31] HK Eriksen, C Dickinson, JB Jewell, AJ Banday, KM Górski, and CR Lawrence. The joint large-scale foreground-cmb posteriors of the 3 year wmap data. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

The Astrophysical Journal Letters > Page 19

[45] Rockhee Sung and Peter Coles. Temperature and polarization patterns in anisotropic cosmologies. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2011(06):036, 2011 > Page 21

[47] Georg Dautcourt and K Rose. Polarized radiation in relativistic cosmology. p. 2

Where the paper says it

After that, we will solve our equations in the tetrad frame (3. This requires that we set up radiation distribution functions that incorporate all the Stokes parameters needed to specify polarized radiation.

Astronomische Nachrichten, vol. 299, no. 1, 1978, p. 13-23., 299:13–23, 1978 > Page 4

[50] Palash Baran Pal. Conventions. https://www.saha.ac.in/theory/palashbaran. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Equation (3. 10) can be promoted to relativistic form, given the theory of radiative transfer (see [47]) as p α ∂f ∂xα − Γ α βγp β p γ ∂f ∂pα = 0 (3.

pal/conv.html [Online; accessed 29-April-2026]. p. 0
Where the paper says it

in 1 arXiv:2605. 14572v2 [gr-qc] 19 May 2026

> Page 19

[51] Daniela Saadeh, Stephen M Feeney, Andrew Pontzen, Hiranya V Peiris, and Jason D McEwen. How isotropic is the universe? p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction The standard model of cosmology, the ‘ΛCDM’ model, has so far been extremely successful in determining the cosmology, structure formation, and expansion of the universe, along with predicting the morphology of CMB patterns observed in the sky today [1–4]. The standard metric under this model, the FLRW metric, dictates a universe which is homogeneous and isotropic on large scales (≳ 3000 Mpc).

Physical review letters, 117(13):131302, 2016 > Page 22

[54] Wayne Hu and Martin White. Cmb anisotropies: Total angular momentum method. p. 0

Where the paper says it

These are a class of eight homogeneous but anisotropic spacetime geometries (R 3 , S 3 , H3 , R×S 2 , R×H2 , U^(H2), Nil & Solv), consisting of only the first three as isotropic ones. In this work, we will analyze the temperature and polarization patterns produced in the CMB sky by these geometries, motivated by recently discovered anisotropic anomalies in the sky such as parity asymmetry in temperature maps due to Northern Galactic Spur [10–14], the direction of the dipole modulation of the power spectrum of the CMB anisotropy [15, 16] and the Galactic Cold Spot [17–19], the large scale polarization anomalies as suggested by Planck 2018 HFI 100 and 143 GHz cross-spectrum analysis + LFI + WMAP 9yr survey [2, 20–23], a general lack of both variance and correlation on the largest angular scales in the microwave sky [24, 25], an extremely cold spot in the CMB sky [17, 18, 26, 27], unusual alignments between large scale harmonic modes of temperature patterns (known popularly by the name “The Axis of Evil”) [28–31], a global hemispherical power asymmetry [32–35], a decrease in CMB temperature around nearby large spiral galaxies [36–39], much lower values of power spectrum for the lowest multipoles [40, 41], unexpected features and correlations in the multipole modes [28, 42–44] and much more.

Physical Review D, 56(2):596, 1997 > Page 19

[58] Andrew Pontzen and Anthony Challinor. Linearization of homogeneous, nearly-isotropic cosmological models. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction The standard model of cosmology, the ‘ΛCDM’ model, has so far been extremely successful in determining the cosmology, structure formation, and expansion of the universe, along with predicting the morphology of CMB patterns observed in the sky today [1–4]. The standard metric under this model, the FLRW metric, dictates a universe which is homogeneous and isotropic on large scales (≳ 3000 Mpc).

Classical and Quantum Gravity, 28(18):185007, 2011 > Page 22

[63] Nicholas Galitzki, Aamir Ali, Kam S Arnold, Peter C Ashton, Jason E Austermann, Carlo Baccigalupi, Taylor Baildon, Darcy Barron, James A Beall, Shawn Beckman et al. The simons observatory: instrument overview. In Millimeter Submillimeter and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy IX > Page 22

[69] Andrea Zonca, Leo Singer, Daniel Lenz, Martin Reinecke, Cyrille Rosset, Eric Hivon, and Krzysztof Gorski. healpy: equal area pixelization and spherical harmonics transforms for data on the sphere in python. p. 5

Where the paper says it

It is used to study how a fluid transports physical quantities. The angular dependence of polarized radiation fields may be represented by an expansion in spin-zero and spin-two spherical harmonics, so that the expansion is equivalent to a polynomial expansion on the unit sphere (see [47]).

Journal of Open Source Software, 4(35):1298 > Page 22

[70] Krzysztof M Gorski, Eric Hivon, Anthony J Banday, Benjamin D Wandelt, Frode K Hansen, Mstvos Reinecke, and Matthia Bartelmann. Healpix: A framework for high-resolution discretization and fast analysis of data distributed on the sphere in python. The Astrophysical Journal > Page 22

[71] HEALPix Developers. HEALPix: Hierarchical Equal Area isoLatitude Pixelization of a sphere in python. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The sky is discretized into 12,288 pixels using HEALPix (Nside = 32). The background cosmology is defined by a ΛCDM-like expansion where a(t) ∝ (sinh(1.

https://healpix. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The sky is discretized into 12,288 pixels using HEALPix (Nside = 32). The background cosmology is defined by a ΛCDM-like expansion where a(t) ∝ (sinh(1.

sourceforge.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can simulate CMB temperature and polarization patterns for all eight Thurston geometries by numerically integrating a stiff system of 48 coupled ordinary differential equations (ODEs) per line of sight, tracking real and imaginary components of multipoles.

  2. The improved system can determine the complex derivatives for monopoles using the Hubble parameter H and Thomson scattering tau, which drive the coupling coefficients zetaR and zetaI governing power transfer between monopole, dipole, and higher-order moments.

  3. The AI can generate final dimensionless results scaled by TCMB (2.725 K) across a master grid of Mollweide projections for T, P, Q, and U to visualize the time evolution of CMB fluctuations for each geometry.

Abstract

Recent cosmological tests have discovered persistent CMB anomalies in the large-scale isotropy of the universe. Motivated thus by such anomalies that hint at potential departures from statistical isotropy present in recent cosmological observations with the advent of the 'precision cosmology' era, we are led to explore the viability of anisotropic Thurston geometries, described in William Thurston's geometrization conjecture. In this work, we examine the coherent temperature and polarization signals generated in the CMB sky by such geometries. We begin with introducing Thurston spacetimes as our background models and the formalism we use to obtain the patterns. We then construct a set of transfer equations relative to a given background and solve them for each spacetime geometry. We finally discuss the role of spatial curvature in these FLRW limiting models along with their underlying geometry, and attempt to establish some general results on the symmetries of the patterns produced by their time evolution in terms of temperature and Stokes parameters P, Q and U. We show the evolution of temperature and polarization amplitudes in terms of such Stokes parameters at different redshifts and attempt to isolate individual Thurston geometries.

Sources

Related papers