Thermal bottleneck in a freely suspended superconducting island on InAs nanowire

arXiv:2605.03139 · cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.supr-con · Submitted 2026-05-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Thermal bottleneck in a freely suspended superconducting island on InAs nanowire".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The experiment investigates how environmental cooling affects the thermal relaxation bottleneck in superconducting islands formed on InAs nanowires, revealing that this effect is best described by a three-temperature model rather than simpler two-temperature models The core finding of the study is that the evolution of the critical Joule power with respect to temperature and bath conditions contradicts the two-temperature model and demonstrates a sizable thermal bottleneck The three-temperature model successfully describes this data quantitatively, suggesting that the S-island cools via heat conduction into a surrounding liquid 3He film Thermal Bottleneck Mechanism The thermal bottleneck arises because the phonon temperature in the S-island may deviate from the bath temperature, specifically manifesting as Tph > Tbath, which is caused by a finite thermal conductance of the environment.

Kai: This deviation is quantified by a parameter Σenv, which is found to be reasonably consistent with thermal exchange with surrounding 3He The model shows that in the limit of Σenv → ∞, the phonon temperature equals the bath temperature as predicted by the 2TM.

Mira: Model Comparison and Fitting The Joule spectroscopy results show that the evolution of PcJ with Tc and Tbath contradicts the 2TM and manifests a sizable thermal bottleneck The three-temperature model captures this behavior, where Tph at the transition point depends on Tc(B), allowing for a much better experimental fit than the 2TM.

Kai: The exponent m=1 obtained in the 3TM differs considerably from the m=4 naively expected in a Kapitza resistance scenario Environmental Cooling Pathways The analysis of the cooling via liquid 3He suggests that the environmental thermal conductance Genv is related to the thickness of a wetting layer, as this model overestimates the experimental value by approximately a factor of 10 The dependence Genv(Tbath) is closer to cooling via liquid 3He than bulk liquid 3He, with variations in wetting layer thickness explaining data scatter.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper investigates how environmental cooling affects the thermal relaxation bottleneck in superconducting islands formed on InAs nanowires one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>. They found that a simple two-temperature model doesn't work and a three-temperature model fits the data quantitatively one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Mira: The main claim is that there's a substantial thermal relaxation bottleneck caused by cooling via surrounding three helium, and this is best described by this three-temperature model one <ref:2605.03139#pg1,a substantial thermal relaxation bottleneck>. It suggests the island cools via heat conduction into that surrounding 3He film <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: What matters here is that the thermal bottleneck means we can't just assume simple heat flow; we have to factor in this specific interaction with the environment one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: They show this bottleneck arises because the phonon temperature might be greater than the bath temperature, Tph greater than Tbath, which they link to a finite thermal conductance of the environment one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Mira: That deviation is quantified by a parameter called sigma env, and they found that it looks reasonably consistent with thermal exchange with surrounding three helium one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>. But in the limit where sigma env goes to infinity, the phonon temperature equals the bath temperature as predicted by that two-temperature model.

Lev: That means if we want to get accurate results on real hardware, we have to be careful because those assumptions break down when sigma env is not huge one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: The Joule spectroscopy results show that the evolution of PcJ with Tc and Tbath just contradicts the two-temperature model and clearly shows a sizable thermal bottleneck one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>. The three-temperature model captures this behavior because the phonon temperature at the transition point depends on Tc B, which allows for a much better experimental fit than that two-temperature model one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Mira: And that difference in scaling, where m equals one from the three-temperature model versus m equals four expected in a Kapitza resistance scenario, is a strong indicator of something different happening here one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: That scaling difference tells us the physics isn't just about simple boundary resistance; it points toward internal dynamics within the island that we need to account for one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: They also analyzed cooling via liquid three helium and found that the environmental thermal conductance Genv is related to the thickness of a wetting layer. This model overestimates their experimental value by about a factor of ten one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: So for designing a system, that suggests we need to consider whether we're looking at a thin film or a bulk environment when modeling heat dissipation one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: Finally, they looked at non steady state phenomena, where there are random variations in sigma env, which they attribute to peculiarities of three helium cooling and possible formation of bubbles and boiling near heaters one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Mira: And the local flat maximum in critical Joule power at low bath temperatures is common across devices, which they link to a decrease in sigma env as heater current increases one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: That decrease suggests that the thickness of the three helium layer wetting the nanowire decreases when you increase your heater current, which is something we have to keep in mind for stability one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: So, this paper essentially establishes that the thermal bottleneck is a feature of these superconducting islands cooled by liquid three helium one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>. This sets up a new framework for how we think about the thermal dynamics in these nanoscale systems.

Mira: It gives us a better tool to understand why the standard models fail and points toward needing more complex temperature dependencies to get an accurate picture one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title of this paper, "Thermal bottleneck in a freely suspended superconducting island on InAs nanowire," it sounds very specific and focused on a certain physical situation one <ref:2605.03139#pg1,Thermal bottleneck in a freely suspended superconducting island on InAs nanowire>.

Mira: It is focused on how the thermal bottleneck arises specifically in those floating islands made from InAs nanowires and what that means for our understanding of nanoscale heat transfer one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: From my side, this paper gives us a concrete framework showing that we need to model the specific interaction with liquid helium because that's where the physics is actually happening one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Kai: It suggests that Joule spectroscopy can be a powerful tool for studying thermal relaxation at the nanoscale, which is what they conclude one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>. This opens up new avenues for experimentalists to probe these kinds of phenomena.

Mira: The implication is that standard models might not be sufficient, and we need to use these more complex temperature dependencies when trying to predict behavior in similar superconducting systems one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Lev: For real hardware, it means our thermal management needs to account for this specific three-temperature coupling because that overhead is real one <ref:2605.03139#pg1>.

Osipyan Institute of Solid State Physics, Russian Academy of Sciences · National Research University Higher School of Economics · Walter Schottky Institut, Physik Department, and Center for Nanotechnology and Nanomaterials, Technische Universität München

cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.supr-con

Submitted: 2026-05-04

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: Accepted in JETP Letters

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: The experiment investigates how environmental cooling affects the thermal relaxation bottleneck in superconducting islands formed on InAs nanowires…

Key concepts

Thermal Bottleneck
This occurs when the phonon temperature inside the superconducting island (Tph) is higher than the surrounding bath temperature (Tbath). This happens because there is a finite thermal conductance between the island and its environment, which limits how quickly heat can escape.
Three-Temperature Model (3TM)
This model is used to quantitatively describe the system's behavior. Unlike simpler two-temperature models, this model successfully fits the experimental data by accounting for three distinct temperatures involved in the thermal process, providing a much better description of how the island cools.
Environmental Cooling via 3He
The research suggests that heat is dissipated from the superconducting island into a surrounding liquid 3He film. The model implies this cooling mechanism is more relevant than bulk liquid 3He, and the efficiency of this cooling depends on factors like the thickness of a wetting layer.
Environmental Cooling Parameter (Σenv)
This parameter quantifies the thermal exchange between the island and its environment. It is found to be consistent with thermal exchange with surrounding 3He, and its variation relates to non-steady-state phenomena like changes in the wetting layer thickness.

Terminology

Summary

The experiment investigates how environmental cooling affects the thermal relaxation bottleneck in superconducting islands formed on InAs nanowires, revealing that this effect is best described by a three-temperature model rather than simpler two-temperature models

The core finding of the study is that the evolution of the critical Joule power with respect to temperature and bath conditions contradicts the two-temperature model and demonstrates a sizable thermal bottleneck The three-temperature model successfully describes this data quantitatively, suggesting that the S-island cools via heat conduction into a surrounding liquid 3He film

Thermal Bottleneck Mechanism

The thermal bottleneck arises because the phonon temperature in the S-island may deviate from the bath temperature, specifically manifesting as Tph > Tbath, which is caused by a finite thermal conductance of the environment. This deviation is quantified by a parameter Σenv, which is found to be reasonably consistent with thermal exchange with surrounding 3He The model shows that in the limit of Σenv → ∞, the phonon temperature equals the bath temperature as predicted by the 2TM. p. 0

Model Comparison and Fitting

The Joule spectroscopy results show that the evolution of PcJ with Tc and Tbath contradicts the 2TM and manifests a sizable thermal bottleneck The three-temperature model captures this behavior, where Tph at the transition point depends on Tc(B), allowing for a much better experimental fit than the 2TM. The exponent m=1 obtained in the 3TM differs considerably from the m=4 naively expected in a Kapitza resistance scenario

Environmental Cooling Pathways

The analysis of the cooling via liquid 3He suggests that the environmental thermal conductance Genv is related to the thickness of a wetting layer, as this model overestimates the experimental value by approximately a factor of 10 The dependence Genv(Tbath) is closer to cooling via liquid 3He than bulk liquid 3He, with variations in wetting layer thickness explaining data scatter.

Non-Steady-State Phenomena

The non-steady-state regime, characterized by random variations of Σenv, is attributed to peculiarities of 3He cooling and possible formation of bubbles and boiling near heaters A local flat maximum in the critical Joule power at low bath temperatures is common across devices and is attributed to a decrease in the environmental cooling parameter Σenv at increasing heater current This change suggests that the thickness of the 3He layer wetting the NW decreases with increasing IH

Experimental Validation and Constraints

The experiment validates the 3TM by showing that Tph extracted from Eq. (1) is plotted as a function of T∗bath in Fig. p. 2 3d for both B-fields, with the dashed lines representing the 3TM fits The non-steady-state behavior is ruled out by time-resolved I–V measurements, which show that the observed hysteresis is a stationary non-equilibrium phenomenon not related to transient effects in surrounding 3He The contribution of electronic thermal conductance in cooling the S-island is negligible, as estimated at least two orders of magnitude smaller than the measured critical Joule power The authors fixed Σe−ph = 5. p. 32 nW µm−3K−5 in all devices. p. 5 The final expression for environmental cooling power Q˙ is given by Eq. p. 9(22)

Summary of Device Parameters

Table I summarizes the device parameters and the extracted environmental cooling parameter Σenv for the three-temperature model For device D1, the extracted Σenv is 1.21-2.01 nW/K The critical Joule power PcJ(IH) dependence on IH is evident from the color-scale plots of Fig. p. 1 1d and 2c The compensation scheme for contact heaters ensures that the measured PJ is independent of the polarity IH The noise thermometry calibration allows for the conversion of heater current IH to the effective temperature rise of the NW The paper concludes that Joule spectroscopy has potential for understanding thermal relaxation at the nanoscale. p. 6

References

[1] E. V. Shpagina, E. p. 0 p. 0 S. Tikhonov, D. p. 0 p. 0 Ruhstorfer, G. p. 0 p. 0 Koblm¨uller, and V. p. 0 p. 0 S. Khrapai, Fate of the superconducting state in floating islands of hybrid nanowire devices, Physical Review B 109, L140501 (2024)

[2] E. V. Shpagina, E. S. Tikhonov, D. Ruhstorfer, G. Koblm¨uller, and V. S. Khrapai, Superconducting bistability in floating al islands of hybrid al/inas nanowires, Phys. p. 4 Rev. B 112, L140503 (2025)

[3] E S Tikhonov, D V Shovkun, D Ercolani, F Rossella, M Rocci, L Sorba, S Roddaro, and V S Khrapai, Local noise in a diffusive conductor, Scientific Reports 6, 30621 (2016)

[4] E. S. Tikhonov, Noise thermometry applied to thermoelectric measurements in InAs nanowires, Semicond. p. 4 Sci. Technol. 31, 104001 (2016)

[5] A Denisov, A Bubis, S Piatrusha, N Titova, A Nasibulin, J Becker, J Treu, D Ruhstorfer G Koblm¨uller E Tikhonov V Khrapai Heat-Mode Excitation in a Proximity Superconductor, Nanomaterials 12 1461 (2022)

[6] D Majidi, M Josefsson, M Kumar, M Leijnse L Samuelson H Courtois C Winkelmann V Maisi Quantum confinement suppressing electronic heat flow below the Wiedemann-Franz law, Nano Letters 22 630 (2022)

[7] S Haldar, D Subero, M Kumar B Karimi A Burke L Samuelson J Pekola V Maisi Heat Conduction and Energy Relaxation in an InAs Nanowire Approaching the Clean One-Dimensional Limit (2026)

[8] A Ibabe, M Gomez G O Steffensen T Kanne J Nyg˚ard A Levy Yeyati E J H Lee Joule spectroscopy of hybrid superconductor–semiconductor nanodevices, Nature Communications 14 2873 (2023)

[9] M-L Liu, D Pan, T Le J.-B He Z.-M Jia S Zhu G Yang Z.-Z Lyu G-T Liu J Shen J-H Zhao L Lu F-M Qu Gate-Tunable Negative Differential Conductance in Hybrid Semiconductor–Superconductor Devices, Chinese Physics Letters 40 067301 (2023)

[10] E V Shpagina, E S Tikhonov D Ruhstorfer G Koblm¨uller V S Khrapai Fate of the superconducting state in floating islands of hybrid nanowire devices, Physical Review B 109, L140501 (2024)

[11] A Ibabe G O Steffensen I Casal M Gomez T Kanne J Nygard A Levy Yeyati E J H Lee Heat Dissipation Mechanisms in Hybrid Superconductor–Semiconductor Devices Revealed by Joule Spectroscopy, Nano Letters 24 6488 (2024)

[12] E V Shpagina, E S Tikhonov D Ruhstorfer G Koblm¨uller V S Khrapai Superconducting bistability in floating Al islands of hybrid Al/InAs nanowires, Physical Review B 112, L140503 (2025)

[13] G M Oliveira G O Steffensen I C Iglesias M Gomez A Ibabe T Kanne J Nygard R Aguado A L Yeyati E J H Lee Anomalous metallic phase and reduced critical current in superconducting nanowires due to inverse proximity effect (2025)

[14] H Courtois M Meschke J T Peltonen J P Pekola Origin of Hysteresis in a Proximity Josephson Junction, Physical Review Letters 101, 067002 (2008)

[15] V F Maisi S V Lotkhov A Kemppinen A Heimes J T Muhonen J P Pekola Excitation of Single Quasiparticles in a Small Superconducting Al Island Connected to Normal-Metal Leads by Tunnel Junctions, Physical Review Letters 111, 147001 (2013)

[16] M L Roukes M R Freeman R S Germain R C Richardson M B Ketchen Hot electrons and energy transport in metals at millikelvin temperatures, Physical Review Letters 55 422 (1985)

[17] E A Hoffmann H A Nilsson J E Matthews N Nakpathomkun A I Persson L Samuelson H Linke Measuring Temperature Gradients over Nanometer Length Scales, Nano Letters 9 779 (2009)

[18] E S Tikhonov D V Shovkun D Ercolani F Rossella M Rocci L Sorba S Roddaro V S Khrapai Local noise in a diffusive conductor, Scientific Reports 6 30621 (2016)

[19] E S Tikhonov Noise thermometry applied to thermoelectric measurements in InAs nanowires, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 31 104001 (2016)

[20] E M Baeva N A Titova L Veyrat B Sac´ep´e A V Semenov G N Goltsman A I Kardakova Vadim S Khrapai Thermal Relaxation in Metal Films Limited by Diffuson Lattice Excitations of Amorphous Substrates, Physical Review Applied 15 054014 (2021)

[21] E T Swartz R O Pohl Thermal boundary resistance, Reviews of Modern Physics 61 605 (1989)

[22] V N Peshkov PROPERTIES OF He3 AND OF ITS SOLUTIONS IN He4 Soviet Physics Uspekhi 11 209 (1968)

[23] K Behnia K Trachenko How heat propagates in liquid 3He Nature Communications 15 1771 (2024)

[24] A C Anderson W L Johnson The Kapitza resistance between copper and3He Journal of Low Temperature Physics 7 1 (1972)

[25] R S Keizer M G Flokstra J Aarts T Klapwijk Critical Voltage of a Mesoscopic Superconductor, Physical Review Letters 96 147002 (2006)

[26] I Snyman Yu V Nazarov Bistability in voltage-biased normalmetal/insulator/superconductor/insulator/normalmetal structures, Physical Review B 79 014510 (2009)

[27] T Kawamura Y Ohashi H T C Stoof Emergence of Larkin-Ovchinnikov-type superconducting state in a voltage-driven superconductor, Physical Review B 109 104502 (2024)

[28] T Kawamura Y Ohashi Engineering Nonequilibrium Superconducting Phases in a Voltage-Driven Superconductor Under an External Magnetic Field, Annalen der Physik 537 e2500102 (2025)

[29] T Kawamura Y Ohashi Emergence of ChargeImbalanced BCS State and Suppression of Nonequilibrium FFLO State in Asymmetric NSN Junctions (26)

Supplemental Materials

The supplemental materials provide details on the molecular beam epitaxy growth of the nanowires and device layouts for D1, D2, D3, and D4 The critical Joule power PcJ as a function of the magnetic field yields estimates for the InAs core radius ρi in each device Table I summarizes device parameters and extracted Σenv values for the three-temperature model The 2TM fit in Fig. S1d yields an underestimated value of the electron-phonon cooling power Σe−ph = 4 nW µm−3 K−5 The noise thermometry calibration is performed using a low-temperature resonant tank circuit to convert heater current IH to the effective temperature rise TN(IH) The final expression for environmental thermal conductivity Genv is given by Eq. p. 5(22) The model suggests that heat is dissipated into a thin wetting film rather than a bulk half-space of liquid 3He The non-steady-state regime is attributed to random variations of Σenv, which can be explained by the decrease in the thickness of the 3He layer wetting the NW at increasing IH The paper investigates thermal relaxation using Joule spectroscopy and demonstrates its potential for nanoscale thermal transport studies

Device Details

The devices studied are distributed across three substrates: D1 on one substrate, and D2, D3, D4 on another For device D1, the top contact pads were fabricated by optical lithography and magnetron sputtering of aluminum (thickness 250 nm) The length L of the Al island (S-island) was estimated using scanning electron microscope images The compensation scheme for contact heaters is used to ensure that the measured PJ is independent of the polarity IH The noise measurement setup involves a low-temperature resonant tank circuit and a home-made low-noise cryogenic amplifier The paper investigates non-equilibrium superconducting transitions in freely suspended Sislands in epitaxial Al/InAs NWs by means of Joule spectroscopy The critical Joule power measured is at least an order of magnitude higher than the theoretical maximum heat current through the InAs core The electronic thermal conductivity contribution is negligible, as estimated at least two orders of magnitude smaller than the measured critical Joule power The paper investigates non-equilibrium superconducting transitions in freely suspended Sislands in epitaxial Al/InAs NWs by means of Joule spectroscopy

Noise Thermometry Calibration

The noise thermometry calibration relies on two known bath temperatures: 4.2 K and the post-condensation temperature T0 of the 3He, which is the actual measurement temperature The detector power (with the offset subtracted) as a function of Rpar at two temperatures is shown in Fig. p. 7 S3b for device D1 The calibration assumes that the noise temperature TN(IH) is independent of the measurement temperature The power offset P∗ is defined as P∗ = P0 + G∗4kBT0Rpar+S Amp I (5) The NW noise SI is extracted from the power measurement as a function of IH using Eq. p. 7(6) The calibration in the main text is performed in the normal state by applying a magnetic field B = 174 mT The dependence TN(IH) is displayed in Fig. p. 7 2a for device D1 The noise temperature TN(IH) increases near linearly with IH for both heaters H1 and H2

Cooling via the InAs Core

The phonon thermal conductivity of the InAs core is estimated using an isotropic phonon gas model, which overestimates the actual heat flux The total heat flow from the S-island (T2) to the reservoirs (T1) is given by Eq.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved thermal transport modeling for hybrid nanowire devices can incorporate a three-temperature model that accounts for phonon heating in superconducting islands due to environmental cooling, as described by equation (1) in the paper. This allows AI systems to predict the relationship between critical Joule power and bath temperature more accurately than the two-temperature model.

  2. Enhanced experimental data analysis capabilities can utilize noise thermometry measurements to convert heater current into effective temperature rise, as shown in equations (6) and (5). This enables AI systems to determine the environmental cooling parameter Σenv for devices where direct Johnson noise calibration is unavailable.

  3. Predictive modeling of critical power behavior can be refined by incorporating the dependence of critical power on the B-field within a three-temperature model, which captures oscillations in delta Pcj with B field. This allows AI to better distinguish between theoretical predictions (2TM) and experimental observations (3TM).

  4. The system can be trained to recognize non-steady-state regimes in critical power behavior by analyzing time-resolved measurements, such as the hysteretic loops shown in Figure 4a. This helps in identifying random variations of the environmental cooling parameter Σenv that lead to irreproducible results.

  5. AI systems can be developed to predict changes in environmental cooling parameters based on heater current, specifically recognizing the local flat maximum in critical Joule power at low bath temperatures. This feature, attributed to a change (decrease) of Σenv at increasing IH, is absent above Tbath approximately 0.4 K.

Related papers