Hidden Quantum-Geometric Connection between Injection and Shift Currents

arXiv:2605.08643 · cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-05-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hidden Quantum-Geometric Connection between Injection and Shift Currents".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Injection and shift currents are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with separate microscopic origins.

Kai: Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles.

Mira: In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole.

Kai: Distinction in Physical Origins Injection current (IC) originates from asymmetries in carrier velocities in momentum space, whereas the shift current (SC) arises from real-space displacements of electronic wave packets during photoexcitation.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap, this paper investigates why injection current and shift current seem distinct, but then shows they are actually linked via interband Berry curvature and quantum metric dipoles.

Mira: The thesis is that in systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level at low photon energies, these two currents become governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole.

Lev: So what's the key mechanism here? They are linking injection current, which is about carrier velocity changes in momentum space, to shift current, which is about real-space shifts of electrons during excitation.

Kai: The paper details how they do this by defining conductivity tensors and showing that for linearly polarized light, the linear shift-current conductivity becomes a linear combination of the injection currents induced by circularly polarized light.

Mira: And for circularly polarized light, the CSC is related to the injection currents induced by linearly polarized light through an analytical relation.

Lev: From an engineering viewpoint, this means we don't need two separate theoretical descriptions for these responses; one unified quantum geometric dipole should govern them in that low-energy limit.

Kai: The authors show that when both conditions—the linearized band approximation and the low-frequency limit—are met, the right-hand side of their equations reduces entirely to just the injection current contribution.

Mira: That confirms the effective equivalence between injection and shift currents under those specific physical constraints, meaning they are essentially governed by the same physics in that regime.

Lev: But we have to remember a caveat here: they state that this equivalence is strictly limited to systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies.

Kai: That's a key constraint for any experimentalist, Lev. If you move outside that regime, this simple connection might not hold anymore.

Mira: Exactly. And they point out that the distinction in physical origins—momentum space asymmetry versus real-space displacement—is still there in general systems, which is why the unification is emergent rather than fundamental everywhere.

Lev: So for us building hardware, we need to focus our experiments on those materials where these conditions are met to actually see this unified behavior.

Kai: And that brings us nicely into the conclusion of the paper, where they discuss what this all means in a broader context.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper by Yahyavi et al. explores the hidden quantum-geometric connection between injection and shift currents.

Mira: The implication is that even though injection current and shift current seem microscopically distinct in origin, they collapse onto the same underlying physical description when you look at the system through an appropriate effective framework.

Lev: In simple terms, it means that for systems where electronic dispersion is linear near the Fermi level and photon energies are low, we can treat them using a single geometric property—the interband quantumgeometric dipole.

Kai: This suggests that quantum geometry provides a broader organizing principle for nonlinear optical phenomena in solids than just looking at the currents in isolation.

Mira: It opens up new avenues for understanding how these seemingly distinct nonlinear optical responses are related, potentially showing us deeper connections between different types of light-matter interactions.

Lev: We should be looking to see if this unified geometric principle applies to other nonlinear optical phenomena outside of just injection and shift currents.

Kai: The paper points toward experimental verification in strained twisted bilayer graphene or materials like MnGeO3 as key testbeds for seeing this connection in action.

Mira: The title itself is telling us that the connection is hidden, which means we're uncovering a deeper level of physics than what's immediately obvious.

Lev: It gives us a specific way to look at nonlinear optical experiments that might help guide where we should be looking for experimental evidence for this quantum geometric dipole.

Division of Physics and Applied Physics, Nanyang Technological University · Department of Physics, National Cheng Kung University · Center for Quantum Frontiers of Research and Technology (QFort), Tainan, Taiwan · Physics Division, National Center for Theoretical Sciences, Taipei 10617, Taiwan · Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California Los Angeles · California NanoSystems Institute, University of California Los Angeles · Center for Quantum Science and Engineering, University of California Los Angeles · Department of Physics, Northeastern University · Quantum Materials and Sensing Institute, Northeastern University · RIKEN Center for Emergent Matter Science (CEMS) · Fundamental Quantum Science Program (FQSP), RIKEN

cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-05-09

Updated: 2026-11-12

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 100/100

The gist: Injection and shift currents are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with separate microscopic origins.

Key concepts

Injection Current (IC)
This current arises from asymmetries in how carrier velocities differ in momentum space when light interacts with the material. It reflects how carriers are injected into the system based on their direction of motion, making it sensitive to momentum-space structure.
Shift Current (SC)
The shift current originates from real-space displacements of electronic wave packets that occur during photoexcitation by light. It describes physical movement within the material caused by the absorption of photons, rather than just momentum changes.
Interband Quantum-Geometric Dipole ($D_{ab}^{bc}$)
This dipole is a key mathematical entity linking IC and SC. It represents a unified geometric property derived from interband Berry curvature, which dictates the coupling between injection and shift currents in specific low-energy limits. It acts as the underlying physical description for these two currents.
Interband Quantum-Metric Dipole ($Q_{ab}^{bc}$)
This dipole connects the other pair of currents: linearly polarized light induced shift current (LIC) and circularly polarized light induced shift current (CSC). It is linked to the quantum metric and governs the relationship between these two specific nonlinear optical responses.

Terminology

Summary

Injection and shift currents are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with separate microscopic origins. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Emergent Quantum-Geometric Equivalence of Injection and Shift Currents Mohammad Yahyavi,1 Tay-Rong Chang,2, 3, 4 Md Shafayat Hossain,5, 6, 7 Arun Bansil,8, 9 Naoto Nagaosa,10, 11 and Guoqing Chang1, ∗ 1Division of Physics and Applied Physics, School of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, 21 Nanyang Link 637371, Singapore 2Department of Physics, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, Taiwan 3Center for Quantum Frontiers of Research and Technology (QFort), Tainan, Taiwan 4Physics Division, National Center for Theoretical Sciences, Taipei 10617, Taiwan 5Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA 6California NanoSystems Institute, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA 7Center for Quantum Science and Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA 8Department of Physics, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115, USA 9Quantum Materials and Sensing Institute, Northeastern University, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 10RIKEN Center for Emergent Matter Science (CEMS), Wako, Saitama 351-0198, Japan 11Fundamental Quantum Science Program (FQSP), TRIP Headquarters, RIKEN, Wako 351-0198, Japan Injection and shift currents are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with separate microscopic origins. Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles.

Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Emergent Quantum-Geometric Equivalence of Injection and Shift Currents Mohammad Yahyavi,1 Tay-Rong Chang,2, 3, 4 Md Shafayat Hossain,5, 6, 7 Arun Bansil,8, 9 Naoto Nagaosa,10, 11 and Guoqing Chang1, ∗ 1Division of Physics and Applied Physics, School of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, 21 Nanyang Link 637371, Singapore 2Department of Physics, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, Taiwan 3Center for Quantum Frontiers of Research and Technology (QFort), Tainan, Taiwan 4Physics Division, National Center for Theoretical Sciences, Taipei 10617, Taiwan 5Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA 6California NanoSystems Institute, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA 7Center for Quantum Science and Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA 8Department of Physics, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115, USA 9Quantum Materials and Sensing Institute, Northeastern University, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 10RIKEN Center for Emergent Matter Science (CEMS), Wako, Saitama 351-0198, Japan 11Fundamental Quantum Science Program (FQSP), TRIP Headquarters, RIKEN, Wako 351-0198, Japan Injection and shift currents are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with separate microscopic origins. Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles.

In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles. In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here, we uncover a general hidden connection between them through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles. In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole.

Distinction in Physical Origins

Injection current (IC) originates from asymmetries in carrier velocities in momentum space, whereas the shift current (SC) arises from real-space displacements of electronic wave packets during photoexcitation. Their distinction is further reinforced by polarization selection rules, such as IC being induced by circularly polarized light in time-reversal (T)-symmetric systems, while SC is driven by linearly polarized light in the same systems. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The IC originates from asymmetries in carrier velocities in momentum space, whereas the SC arises from real-space displacements of electronic wave packets during photoexcitation. Their distinction is further reinforced by polarization selection rules: in timereversal (T )-symmetric systems, IC is induced by circularly polarized light, whereas SC is driven by linearly polarized light; in magnetic systems preserving PT symmetry, this correspondence is reversed.

This divergence suggests that whether these distinctions reflect genuinely independent physical processes or conceal a deeper unifying structure remains unclear. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Their distinction is further reinforced by polarization selection rules: in timereversal (T )-symmetric systems, IC is induced by circularly polarized light, whereas SC is driven by linearly polarized light; in magnetic systems preserving PT symmetry, this correspondence is reversed. Whether such distinctions reflect genuinely independent physical processes or instead conceal a deeper unifying structure remains unclear.

Mathematical Framework for Conductivities

The second-order photocurrents induced by light of frequency ω can be expressed using the second-order dc conductivity tensor associated with linearly-polarized (circularly-polarized) light, denoted as σ abc L(ω) or σ abc C(ω). The explicit forms for these tensors are detailed in the material section, involving terms like the interband Berry connection r bmn and the quantum metric. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The first tensor index a specifies the direction of the induced current, while the remaining indices b and c correspond to the polarization directions of the electric field. For IC, the explicit forms of the conductivity tensors for linearly-polarized light (σLIC) and circularlypolarized light (σCIC) are given as [6, 37] (Supplemental arXiv:2605.

The conductivity tensors for SC induced by linearly polarized light (σ abc LSC) and circularly-polarized light (σ abc CSC) are given in equation (2). p. 1
Where the paper says it

Conductivity tensors of SC induced by linearlypolarized light (σLSC) and circularly-polarized light (σCSC) are given by (SM Sec. I) [6, 37]: σ abc LSC(ω) = − iπe3 2ℏ 2 Z k X n,m fnm I abc mn D+(ωmn, ω), σ abc CSC(ω) = πe3 2ℏ 2 Z k X n,m fnm Rabc mn D−(ωmn, ω).

Emergent Equivalence in Linearized Limits

The authors establish an analytical relation showing that for linearly polarized light, the linear shift-current conductivity σ abc LSC is strictly real and can be expressed as a linear combination of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC). Similarly, for circularly polarized light, the CSC is linked to the linearly-polarized light induced injection currents (LIC). p. 2

Where the paper says it

(5) This result implies that, for LSC, the contribution arising from the first-order derivative of the Hamiltonian can be expressed as a linear combination of conductivity tensor of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC): σ 1abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC (6) The full conductivity tensor of LSC can be written as σ abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC + σ abc LSC-W + σ abc LSC-V , (7) where σ abc LSC-W = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 2abc mn δ(ωmn − ω), and σ abc LSC-V = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 3abc mn δ(ωmn − ω). We next consider R 1abc mn for circularly-polarized-lightinduced shift current (CSC): R 1abc mn = − 1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mnr a nm − ∆b mn r c mnr a nm + ∆a mn [r b mn, rc nm] .

In the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit (ωi ≪ ωv), this relation reduces to σ abc LSC ≈ −1/2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC, and similarly for CSC. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Suppressing σ abc SC-V , on the other hand, requires the frequency of virtual interband transitions associated with high-energy bands (ωv) to be much larger than the incident photon frequency (ωi). When both conditions are satisfied, within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit (ωi ≪ ωv), the right-hand side of the equation reduces to just the IC contribution: σ abc LSC ≈ − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC , σabc CSC ≈ 1 2τω σ cba LIC − σ bca LIC .

Physical Interpretation via Quantum Geometry Dipoles

The authors reveal that IC and SC are directly linked through an interband quantum-geometric dipole Da;bc, while LIC and CSC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole Qa;bc. The unified form of nonlinear optical conductivities is given by equation (14). p. 3

Where the paper says it

V): Da;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka Ω bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), Q a;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka g bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), (13) where Ωbc nm and g bc nm denote the interband Berry curvature and the interband quantum metric, respectively, and Θ is the Heaviside step function (see SM, Sec. Collecting these results, nonlinear optical conductivities can be written in the unified interband quantum geometric form: σ abc CIC = −τ πe3 ℏ 2 Da;bc, σabc LSC ≈ πe3 2ℏ 2ω Dc;ba + Db;ca , σ abc LIC = −2τ πe3 ℏ 2 Q a;bc, σabc CSC ≈ − πe3 ℏ 2ω Q c;ba − Q b;ca , (14) Equation (14) shows that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit, differing only in how the quantumgeometry dipole is projected.

This emergent equivalence suggests that SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC within an appropriate effective framework. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

Experimental Platforms and Implications

Natural platforms for testing this theoretical framework include massless Dirac and Weyl semimetals, where the contributions from warping and virtual transitions are negligible in the low-frequency limit. Strained twisted bilayer graphene is identified as an ideal platform because linear dispersions near the K points are preserved while inversion symmetry is broken. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Our theory can also be tested in graphene systems (SM Sec. We numerically calculated the IC and SC in strained twisted bilayer graphene at a twist angle of θ = 10◦ , where linear dispersions near the K points remain well preserved while inversion symmetry (P) is broken [Fig.

Furthermore, ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and alternagnetic materials hosting approximately linear Dirac/Weyl dispersions are suitable candidates for testing the connection between LIC and CSC. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our numerical results indeed demonstrate that our theory remains valid over a broad frequency range accessible to current experiments, establishing strained twisted bilayer graphene as an ideal platform for experimental verification [Fig. To test the connection between LIC and CSC, ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and alternagnetic materials that host approximately linear Dirac/Weyl dispersions are suitable candidates.

This work enables experimental extraction of diamagnetic contributions to SC in the low-frequency limit. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Note that the first term scales inversely with frequency ω, so that the SC in any metallic system with a finite quantum-geometry dipole will diverge in the lowfrequency limit. Moreover, by combining independent measurements of IC and SC, our work enables experimental extraction of diamagnetic contributions to SC in the low-frequency limit, which are not directly accessible through conventional optical measurements and are known to play a central role in phenomena such as Landau diamagnetism and superconductivity [46].

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The authors conclude that the LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The SC in materials contains intrinsic contributions from quantum-geometry dipoles, with the first term scaling inversely with frequency ω. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(16) These results demonstrate that the SC in materials contains intrinsic contributions from quantum-geometry dipoles. Note that the first term scales inversely with frequency ω, so that the SC in any metallic system with a finite quantum-geometry dipole will diverge in the lowfrequency limit.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

(16) These results demonstrate that the SC in materials contains intrinsic contributions from quantum-geometry dipoles. Note that the first term scales inversely with frequency ω, so that the SC in any metallic system with a finite quantum-geometry dipole will diverge in the lowfrequency limit.

This finding opens a new direction for both fundamental understanding and experimental exploration. p. 4
Where the paper says it

More broadly, this hidden quantum-geometric relation suggests that similar connections may exist among other nonlinear optical responses, pointing to quantum geometry as a deeper organizing principle for nonlinear optical phenomena in quantum materials [Fig. These findings open a new direction for both fundamental understanding and experimental exploration.

The emergent equivalence suggests that similar connections may exist among other nonlinear optical responses, pointing to quantum geometry as a deeper organizing principle for nonlinear optical phenomena in quantum materials. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In Dirac and Weyl semimetals, when the contributions from warping and virtual transitions are negligible, IC and SC become effectively equivalent and are governed by the same interband quantum-geometric dipole. More broadly, this hidden quantum-geometric relation suggests that similar connections may exist among other nonlinear optical responses, pointing to quantum geometry as a deeper organizing principle for nonlinear optical phenomena in quantum materials [Fig.

The results demonstrate that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit. p. 3
Where the paper says it

V): Da;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka Ω bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), Q a;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka g bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), (13) where Ωbc nm and g bc nm denote the interband Berry curvature and the interband quantum metric, respectively, and Θ is the Heaviside step function (see SM, Sec. Collecting these results, nonlinear optical conductivities can be written in the unified interband quantum geometric form: σ abc CIC = −τ πe3 ℏ 2 Da;bc, σabc LSC ≈ πe3 2ℏ 2ω Dc;ba + Db;ca , σ abc LIC = −2τ πe3 ℏ 2 Q a;bc, σabc CSC ≈ − πe3 ℏ 2ω Q c;ba − Q b;ca , (14) Equation (14) shows that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit, differing only in how the quantumgeometry dipole is projected.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

V): Da;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka Ω bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), Q a;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka g bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), (13) where Ωbc nm and g bc nm denote the interband Berry curvature and the interband quantum metric, respectively, and Θ is the Heaviside step function (see SM, Sec. Collecting these results, nonlinear optical conductivities can be written in the unified interband quantum geometric form: σ abc CIC = −τ πe3 ℏ 2 Da;bc, σabc LSC ≈ πe3 2ℏ 2ω Dc;ba + Db;ca , σ abc LIC = −2τ πe3 ℏ 2 Q a;bc, σabc CSC ≈ − πe3 ℏ 2ω Q c;ba − Q b;ca , (14) Equation (14) shows that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit, differing only in how the quantumgeometry dipole is projected.

The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In summary, we uncovered a hidden connection between injection and shift currents. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole.

The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

How the training signal is built

The connection between LIC and CSC is established through equation (10), which shows that Rabc D- (ωmn, ω) is purely real, meaning only symmetrized products contribute to the CSC. This leads to the direct link where σ abc CSC = 1/2τω σ cba LIC - σ bca LIC + σ abc CSC-W + σ abc CSC-V. p. 2

Where the paper says it

III): R 1abc mn D−(ωmn, ω) = −1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mn , ra nm + ∆b mn {r c mn , ra nm} δ(ωmn − ω). (10) As a result, we can directly link CSC with LIC: σ abc CSC = 1 2τω σ cba LIC − σ bca LIC + σ abc CSC-W + σ abc CSC-V .

The SC in materials contains intrinsic contributions from quantum-geometry dipoles, with the first term scaling inversely with frequency ω.

Where the gains come from

The authors show that when both conditions are satisfied, within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit (ωi ≪ ωv), the right-hand side of the equation reduces to just the IC contribution. This supports the effective equivalence between IC and SC under specific physical constraints. p. 3

Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

The results demonstrate that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

The authors uncover a general hidden connection between injection and shift currents through interband Berry-curvature and quantum-metric dipoles. In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole. This regime is naturally realized in Dirac and Weyl semimetals, as well as in strained graphene, where measurements of injection and shift currents probe a unified geometric property of the electronic wavefunctions rather than distinct dynamical processes. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and at low photon energies, this relation sharpens into an emergent equivalence, with injection and shift currents governed by the same interband quantumgeometric dipole. This regime is naturally realized in Dirac and Weyl semimetals, as well as in strained graphene, where measurements of injection and shift currents probe a unified geometric property of the electronic wavefunctions rather than distinct dynamical processes.

The results establish a new framework for interpreting nonlinear optical experiments and suggest that quantum geometry may provide a broader organizing principle linking seemingly distinct nonlinear optical responses in solids. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This regime is naturally realized in Dirac and Weyl semimetals, as well as in strained graphene, where measurements of injection and shift currents probe a unified geometric property of the electronic wavefunctions rather than distinct dynamical processes. Our results establish a new framework for interpreting nonlinear optical experiments and suggest that quantum geometry may provide a broader organizing principle linking seemingly distinct nonlinear optical responses in solids.

The second-order photocurrents induced by light of frequency ω can be expressed as J a = σ abc L(ω) Re E b(ω) E c(-ω) + σ abc C(ω) Im E b(ω)E c(-ω), where σ abc L(ω) [σ abc C(ω)] denoting the second-order dc conductivity tensor associated with linearly-polarized (circularly-polarized) light. The explicit forms of the conductivity tensors for linearly-polarized light (σ LIC) and circularly polarized light (σ CIC) are given as [6, 37]. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The first tensor index a specifies the direction of the induced current, while the remaining indices b and c correspond to the polarization directions of the electric field. For IC, the explicit forms of the conductivity tensors for linearly-polarized light (σLIC) and circularlypolarized light (σCIC) are given as [6, 37] (Supplemental arXiv:2605.

The first contribution I 1abc L(ω) to the linearly-polarized light induced shift current (LSC) is given by equation (3). This term can be rewritten as a linear combination of conductivity tensors of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC), specifically I 1abc L(ω) = -1/2ωnm ∆cmn r bmnr a + ∆bmn r cmnr a + 2∆a mn [r bmn, rc mn] + ∆cmn[r bmn, ra nm] + ∆bmn[r cmn, ra nm]. p. 2

Where the paper says it

II) I 1abc mn D+(ωmn, ω) = −1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mn , ra nm + ∆b mn [r c mn , ra nm] δ(ωmn − ω). (5) This result implies that, for LSC, the contribution arising from the first-order derivative of the Hamiltonian can be expressed as a linear combination of conductivity tensor of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC): σ 1abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC (6) The full conductivity tensor of LSC can be written as σ abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC + σ abc LSC-W + σ abc LSC-V , (7) where σ abc LSC-W = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 2abc mn δ(ωmn − ω), and σ abc LSC-V = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 3abc mn δ(ωmn − ω).

The linear shift-current conductivity σ abc LSC is strictly real, and one finds that I 1abc L(ω) D+(ωmn, ω) = -1/ωnm ∆cmn r bmn, ra nm + ∆bmn [r cmn, ra nm] δ(ωmn − ω). This result implies that, for LSC, the contribution arising from the first-order derivative of the Hamiltonian can be expressed as a linear combination of conductivity tensor of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC): σ 1abc LSC = -1/2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC. p. 2

Where the paper says it

II) I 1abc mn D+(ωmn, ω) = −1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mn , ra nm + ∆b mn [r c mn , ra nm] δ(ωmn − ω). (5) This result implies that, for LSC, the contribution arising from the first-order derivative of the Hamiltonian can be expressed as a linear combination of conductivity tensor of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC): σ 1abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC (6) The full conductivity tensor of LSC can be written as σ abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC + σ abc LSC-W + σ abc LSC-V , (7) where σ abc LSC-W = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 2abc mn δ(ωmn − ω), and σ abc LSC-V = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 3abc mn δ(ωmn − ω).

The full conductivity tensor of LSC can be written as σ abc LSC = -1/2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC + σ abc LSC-W + σ abc LSC-V. The second term, σ abc LSC-W = -πe3/4ħ2 Rk P n,m fnm I 2abc mn δ(ωmn − ω), and the third term, σ abc LSC-V = -πe3/4ħ2 Rk P n,m fnm I 3abc mn δ(ωmn − ω). p. 2

Where the paper says it

II) I 1abc mn D+(ωmn, ω) = −1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mn , ra nm + ∆b mn [r c mn , ra nm] δ(ωmn − ω). (5) This result implies that, for LSC, the contribution arising from the first-order derivative of the Hamiltonian can be expressed as a linear combination of conductivity tensor of the circularly-polarized-light induced injection currents (CIC): σ 1abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC (6) The full conductivity tensor of LSC can be written as σ abc LSC = − 1 2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC + σ abc LSC-W + σ abc LSC-V , (7) where σ abc LSC-W = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 2abc mn δ(ωmn − ω), and σ abc LSC-V = − πe3 4ℏ2 R k P n,m fnm I 3abc mn δ(ωmn − ω).

For CSC, Rabc D-(ωmn, ω) is purely real, and only symmetrized products contribute to the CSC. As a result, we can directly link CSC with LIC as σ abc CSC = 1/2τω σ cba LIC - σ bca LIC + σ abc CSC-W + σ abc CSC-V. p. 2

Where the paper says it

III): R 1abc mn D−(ωmn, ω) = −1 ωnm ∆c mn r b mn , ra nm + ∆b mn {r c mn , ra nm} δ(ωmn − ω). (10) As a result, we can directly link CSC with LIC: σ abc CSC = 1 2τω σ cba LIC − σ bca LIC + σ abc CSC-W + σ abc CSC-V .

The authors show that when both conditions are satisfied, within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit (ωi ≪ ωv), the right-hand side of the equation reduces to just the IC contribution: σ abc LSC ≈ -1/2τω σ cba CIC + σ bca CIC, and similarly for CSC. This supports the effective equivalence between IC and SC under specific physical constraints. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

In Dirac and Weyl semimetals, when the contributions from warping and virtual transitions are negligible, IC and SC become effectively equivalent and are governed by the same interband quantum-geometric dipole. The authors show that when only velocity and tilting terms are retained, the second-order derivative of the Hamiltonian vanishes, leading to a result where σ zxx LSC is equal to-1/τω σ xxz CIC. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Moreover, when only velocity and tilting terms are retained, the second-order derivative of the Hamiltonian vanishes. Taking σ zxx LSC as a representative quantity, our numerical results show that it is equal to − 1 τω σ xxz CIC [Fig.

Upon including a finite second-order derivative of the Hamiltonian, they find that their theory remains valid. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Taking σ zxx LSC as a representative quantity, our numerical results show that it is equal to − 1 τω σ xxz CIC [Fig. Upon including a finite second-order derivative of the Hamiltonian, we find that our theory remains valid [SM Sec.

The authors numerically calculated the IC and SC in strained twisted bilayer graphene at a twist angle of θ = 10◦, where linear dispersions near the K points remain well preserved while inversion symmetry (P) is broken. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our theory can also be tested in graphene systems (SM Sec. We numerically calculated the IC and SC in strained twisted bilayer graphene at a twist angle of θ = 10◦ , where linear dispersions near the K points remain well preserved while inversion symmetry (P) is broken [Fig.

This demonstrates that their theory remains valid over a broad frequency range accessible to current experiments, establishing strained twisted bilayer graphene as an ideal platform for experimental verification. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Moreover, the higher-energy bands here lie far from the Fermi level, so that contributions from virtual interband transitions are negligible. Our numerical results indeed demonstrate that our theory remains valid over a broad frequency range accessible to current experiments, establishing strained twisted bilayer graphene as an ideal platform for experimental verification [Fig.

The authors consider MnGeO3 as a representative example of a PT-symmetric system where σ CIC and σ LSC are symmetryforbidden, making it an ideal platform for verifying the connection between σ LIC and σ CSC. p. 3
Where the paper says it

VII), which has been predicted to be an antiferromagnetic Dirac semimetal that preserves PT symmetry [44, 45] [Fig. In such PT -symmetric systems σCIC and σLSC are symmetryforbidden, and thus make MnGeO3 an ideal platform for verifying the connection between σLIC and σCSC, as illustrated in Fig.

This emergent equivalence applies broadly to both magnetic and nonmagnetic systems, provided the low-energy electronic dispersion is approximately linear and contributions from higher-energy virtual transitions are suppressed. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In such PT -symmetric systems σCIC and σLSC are symmetryforbidden, and thus make MnGeO3 an ideal platform for verifying the connection between σLIC and σCSC, as illustrated in Fig. We emphasize that the same emergent equivalence applies broadly to both magnetic and nonmagnetic systems, provided the low-energy electronic dispersion is approximately linear and contributions from higher-energy virtual transitions are suppressed.

The authors conclude that IC and SC are directly linked through an interband quantum-geometric dipole Da;bc, whereas LIC and CSC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole Qa;bc. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Here we go a step further and show that injection and shift currents are directly linked through an interband quantum-geometric dipole. Specifically, the CIC and the LSC are related by the interband Berry-curvature dipole Da;bc, whereas the LIC and the CSC are linked through the interband quantum-metric dipole Qa;bc (SM Sec.

The unified interband quantum geometric form of nonlinear optical conductivities is given by equation (14). p. 3
Where the paper says it

V): Da;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka Ω bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), Q a;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka g bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), (13) where Ωbc nm and g bc nm denote the interband Berry curvature and the interband quantum metric, respectively, and Θ is the Heaviside step function (see SM, Sec. Collecting these results, nonlinear optical conductivities can be written in the unified interband quantum geometric form: σ abc CIC = −τ πe3 ℏ 2 Da;bc, σabc LSC ≈ πe3 2ℏ 2ω Dc;ba + Db;ca , σ abc LIC = −2τ πe3 ℏ 2 Q a;bc, σabc CSC ≈ − πe3 ℏ 2ω Q c;ba − Q b;ca , (14) Equation (14) shows that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit, differing only in how the quantumgeometry dipole is projected.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

V): Da;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka Ω bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), Q a;bc(ω) ≡ Z k X n,m fnm ∂ka g bc nm Θ(ω − ωmn), (13) where Ωbc nm and g bc nm denote the interband Berry curvature and the interband quantum metric, respectively, and Θ is the Heaviside step function (see SM, Sec. Collecting these results, nonlinear optical conductivities can be written in the unified interband quantum geometric form: σ abc CIC = −τ πe3 ℏ 2 Da;bc, σabc LSC ≈ πe3 2ℏ 2ω Dc;ba + Db;ca , σ abc LIC = −2τ πe3 ℏ 2 Q a;bc, σabc CSC ≈ − πe3 ℏ 2ω Q c;ba − Q b;ca , (14) Equation (14) shows that IC and SC are effectively equivalent within the linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit, differing only in how the quantumgeometry dipole is projected.

This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

A complete correspondence between the SC conductivity tensor and quantumgeometry dipoles is provided in SM Sec. This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

The authors show that when both conditions are satisfied, within a linearized band approximation in the low-frequency limit (ωi ≪ ωv), the right-hand side of the equation reduces to just the IC contribution. This supports the effective equivalence between IC and SC under specific physical constraints. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

The authors conclude that IC and SC are directly linked through an interband quantum-geometric dipole Da;bc, whereas LIC and CSC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole Qa;bc. The unified interband quantum geometric form of nonlinear optical conductivities is given by equation (14). This emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC. The LSC and CIC are related through the interband Berry-curvature dipole, whereas the CSC and LIC are connected through the interband quantum-metric dipole. The emergent equivalence between IC and SC shows that, although they are microscopically distinct in origin, within an appropriate effective framework, SC collapses onto the same underlying physical description as IC.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can predict second-order photocurrents by calculating interband Berry-curvature dipoles and quantum-metric dipoles for materials with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level and low photon energies. This allows the system to determine if injection and shift currents are governed by the same underlying quantity.

  2. The improved system can establish a new framework for interpreting nonlinear optical experiments by using quantum geometry as a broader organizing principle linking seemingly distinct nonlinear optical responses in solids. This enables more unified analysis of different physical phenomena in quantum materials.

  3. AI systems can directly link shift current and injection current by relating them through interband Berry-curvature dipoles and interband quantum-metric dipoles, depending on the material system being studied. This provides a direct computational pathway for understanding the relationship between these two currents across different material classes like Dirac semimetals and graphene.

  4. The system can predict the linear shift current conductivity LSC using a linear combination of circularly polarized light induced injection currents CIC, specifically stating that sigma 1abc LSC = -1/2tw sigma cba CIC + sigma bca CIC in the low-frequency limit. This allows for simplified, computationally efficient calculations of shift current responses.

  5. The system can predict the linear shift current conductivity CSC using a similar linear combination involving linearly polarized light induced injection currents LIC, specifically stating that sigma abc CSC = 1/2tw sigma cba LIC - sigma bca LIC in the low-frequency limit. This provides a direct prediction for shift current responses based on injection current measurements.

  6. The improved system can perform experimental extraction of diamagnetic contributions to shift current in the low-frequency limit by combining independent measurements of IC and SC, which are not directly accessible through conventional optical measurements. This capability is crucial for understanding phenomena like Landau diamagnetism and superconductivity.

Abstract

Injection current (IC) and shift current (SC) are generally regarded as distinct nonlinear optical responses with different microscopic origins. Here, within the clean limit, based on an independent-particle interband description, we uncover a general hidden connection between the IC and SC responses. The generalized-derivative sum rule is used to show that the SC response separates into an injection-determined contribution associated with velocity asymmetry and a genuine shift-current (GSC) contribution associated with real-space wave-packet displacement. In systems with approximately linear electronic dispersion near the Fermi level, the corresponding tensor combinations of SC and IC can become effectively equivalent at low photon energies, governed by the same interband quantum-geometric dipole. Crystal symmetry can also eliminate the injection-determined contribution, enabling direct access to the GSC component. Extending our approach to second-harmonic generation reveals analogous response relations, suggesting a route toward a broader network of quantitative connections among the various nonlinear optical responses.

Related papers