Calculating extremely high energy bremsstrahlung in matter

arXiv:2605.03002 · hep-ph, nucl-th · Submitted 2026-05-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Calculating extremely high energy bremsstrahlung in matter".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ultra-relativistic electrons initiate electromagnetic showers in ordinary matter that evolve through bremsstrahlung and pair production.

Kai: The paper extends an analysis of the Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) effect to lower energies by accounting for electron mass and medium-induced photon mass, leading to a rich map of behavior in different regions of (kγ, E).

Mira: Very high energy electrons or positrons passing through ordinary matter lose energy predominantly through showering via repeated bremsstrahlung (e → eγ) and pair production (γ → ee¯) mediated by the electric fields inside atoms.

Kai: At sufficiently high energy, the quantum duration of bremsstrahlung becomes longer than the mean free time between elastic scatterings from the medium, leading to a drastic suppression known as the Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) effect.

Paper summary: Kai: So to get into this paper "Calculating extremely high energy bremsstrahlung in matter," Peter Arnold and Joshua Bautista are looking at how ultra-relativistic electrons start electromagnetic showers in ordinary matter.

Mira: The central thesis is that as the electron energy gets very high, the quantum mechanical duration of bremsstrahlung starts becoming longer than the mean free time for elastic scattering off particles inside that medium.

Kai: This leads to a significant suppression known as the Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal effect in ordinary matter.

Mira: But they found a way to extend this analysis by accounting for the electron mass and also including the photon mass induced by the medium.

Lev: So what does that extension actually claim? It claims that for certain combinations of initial electron energy and photon energy, this overlapping pair production disrupts the standard LPM suppression.

Kai: And when that overlap happens, it means the bremsstrahlung rates are much larger than what you would get from just applying the original LPM rate formula.

Mira: This is important because it shows a correction term is necessary to describe the energy loss in these specific conditions, which leads to a richer map of behavior across different energy regions.

Lev: It suggests that simply ignoring that overlapping pair production effect would lead you to severely underestimate the true bremsstrahlung rates in those regimes.

Kai: This whole paper sets up a framework where they look at how the physics changes when you move from the simple massless case, where m equals zero, to a full treatment including both electron mass and medium-induced photon mass m gamma.

Mira: They use that scale E hat LPM, which is defined as m to the power of four over q hat.

Lev: That scale E hat LPM relates back to the conventional ELPM by a factor of two or one depending on whether you have negligible or extreme suppression.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at "Calculating extremely high energy bremsstrahlung in matter," Peter Arnold and Joshua Bautista are essentially showing how the physics gets more complex when you look at very high energies for electron showers.

Mira: It’s about moving beyond the basic Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal effect to include things like electron mass and that medium-induced photon mass, which opens up new ways to calculate energy loss rates.

Lev: The implication for a real system is that if you are simulating these high energy losses, ignoring the overlapping pair production correction could lead you to get the wrong picture of how fast particles are actually losing energy.

Kai: The authors show that this correction term can be important enough to make the bremsstrahlung rates significantly larger than predicted by older, simpler LPM calculations in specific conditions.

Mira: It’s about understanding that for a complete picture at these high energies, you need to consider how the dielectric properties of the medium affect both bremsstrahlung and pair production simultaneously.

University of Virginia · State Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology, Institute of Quantum Matter, South China Normal University, Guangdong Basic Research Center of Excellence for Structure and Fundamental Interactions of Matter, Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Nuclear Science, Guangzhou 510006, China · National Centre for Physics · Theoretical Physics Department at CERN

hep-ph, nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-05-04

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 60 pages, 12 figures. Major change from v1: new sections VIII (finite-width media) and IX (radiation vs. ionization energy loss) added

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Ultra-relativistic electrons initiate electromagnetic showers in ordinary matter that evolve through bremsstrahlung and pair production.

Key concepts

Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) effect
This is a phenomenon where ultra-high energy particles lose energy slowly when passing through matter. Normally, the quantum duration of bremsstrahlung is longer than scattering times, causing suppression. The paper studies how this suppression changes when subsequent pair production overlaps with the bremsstrahlung process.
Medium-induced photon mass (mγ)
This concept accounts for how the surrounding medium affects photons generated during bremsstrahlung. When considering lower energies, the photon gains a mass due to interactions with the medium, which is crucial for accurately describing its propagation and subsequent pair production.
Overlapping pair production correction ($\delta d\Gamma/dx\gamma$)
This term represents the extra rate of energy loss caused by bremsstrahlung photons immediately undergoing pair production. The paper shows that this overlap disrupts the standard LPM suppression, leading to a higher total bremsstrahlung rate than predicted by the original LPM model alone.

Terminology

Summary

Ultra-relativistic electrons initiate electromagnetic showers in ordinary matter that evolve through bremsstrahlung and pair production. p. 0 The paper extends an analysis of the Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) effect to lower energies by accounting for electron mass and medium-induced photon mass, leading to a rich map of behavior in different regions of (kγ, E). p. 0

Introduction and Problem Statement

Very high energy electrons or positrons passing through ordinary matter lose energy predominantly through showering via repeated bremsstrahlung (e → eγ) and pair production (γ → ee¯) mediated by the electric fields inside atoms. At sufficiently high energy, the quantum duration of bremsstrahlung becomes longer than the mean free time between elastic scatterings from the medium, leading to a drastic suppression known as the Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal (LPM) effect. p. 3 For some ranges of bremsstrahlung photon and initial electron energies (kγ, E), this duration can overlap with subsequent pair production by the bremsstrahlung photon, disrupting LPM suppression and drastically changing LPM predictions. p. 0 The paper revisits this issue, concluding that overlapping pair production disrupts LPM suppression, leading to bremsstrahlung rates much larger than the original LPM rate. p. 3

Review of Formalism and Approximations

The analysis relies on a leading-log approximation assuming the medium is large compared to the bremsstrahlung formation length. The scale EˆLPM is defined as EˆLPM ≡ m4/qˆ, which agrees with the conventional ELPM to within a factor of 2. p. 4 The description of bremsstrahlung and pair production in terms of EˆLPM is based on the diffusion constant ˆq for the transverse momentum of high-energy electrons. p. 4 The relation between EˆLPM and ELPM varies between roughly EˆLPM ≃ ELPM × (2, for negligible or mild LPM suppression; 1, for extreme LPM suppression). p. 4

Calculation of LPM Effects

The calculation involves examining the ordinary LPM effect separately for bremsstrahlung and pair production before considering their overlap. The rate formula in the deep-LPM regime is given by dΓ/dxγ ≈ α 2π Pe→γ(xγ) s/xγ qˆ (1−xγ)E (deep LPM). p. 8 The analysis proceeds by incorporating the electron mass m and the medium-induced photon mass mγ into these calculations, moving from the massless case to a full treatment where 0 < mγ ≪ m. p. 3 The final result is presented as dΓ/dxγ LPM = dΓ/dxγ LPM + δdΓ/dxγ, where δdΓ/dxγ represents the correction due to overlapping pair production. p. 4

Physical Origin of Logarithms and Limits

The logarithms in the deep-LPM+ regimes arise from contributions involving bremsstrahlung overlapping either real or virtual subsequent pair production. The limiting formulas for different regions (1, 2, 3, 4a, 4b, and 5) are summarized in Table I and II. p. 0 For the deep dielectric region (region 5), the rate is given by dΓ/dxγ LPM ≈ α 2π Pe→γ(xγ) Γpair Re h ln m2/m2γ + 41 21 i. p. 5

Influence of Photo-Nuclear Cross-Section

The paper warns about the applicability of results at extreme energies kγ≳ 10 20 eV, where photo-nuclear processes like γA → hadrons could disrupt LPM bremsstrahlung. The photo-nuclear rate becomes important when k ≥ kc with kc = 9α 2 qˆ 64(nσγA)2 ≈ 9α 2m4 e 64(nσγA)2 ELPM. p. 4 This suggests that for ice, the photo-nuclear effect will be important at roughly the photon energies shown in Table III. p. 1

Final Result and Conclusion

The final result for dΓ/dxγ is summarized as dΓ/dxγ LPM = dΓ/dxγ LPM + δdΓ/dxγ, where the full result is given by (5.12). The deep dielectric region limit of this final result is dΓ/dxγ LPM ≈ α 2π Pe→γ(xγ) Γpair h ln m2/m2γ + 20 21 i. p. 4 This shows the modification to the ordinary LPM bremsstrahlung rate due to the dielectric effect. p. 5 The distinction between regions is determined by whether [dΓ/dxγ]LPM or δ[dΓ/dxγ] term dominates the total rate. p. 9 The deep dielectric region corresponds to a limit where hγ ≫ Gpair and hγ ≫ omega0. p. 9 The final result for the deep dielectric region is dΓ/dxγ LPM ≈ α 2π Pe→γ(xγ) Γpair Re h ln m2/m2γ + 20 21 i. p. 4

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced handling of complex integrals through asymptotic expansion integration in Appendix D allows for numerical control over large cancellations when integrating over eta in equations like (4.18) and (4.34). This specifically addresses the machine precision round-off errors that cause adaptive integrators to focus effort on the eta equals zero region.

  2. Improved ability to transition between different physical regimes by providing explicit parametric conditions for when specific limiting formulas apply, such as when t form is large compared to 1 over Gamma pair or hγ. This facilitates a more accurate identification of the boundary lines in Fig 9b between regions like 4a and 5.

  3. Integration of helicity-flip amplitudes into the calculation of LPM corrections for both bremsstrahlung and pair production using equations (B3) and (B7). This allows the system to account for terms proportional to m squared, which are otherwise ignored in the massless limit, leading to a more general description of energy loss rates.

  4. Automated derivation of large q expansions for the generalized Stieltjes constant gamma 1(q) using equation (E1), allowing for better parameterization of logarithmic enhancements in deep-LPM regimes (e.g., equations D3 and D4).

  5. Integration of the full result including the dielectric effect by computing the difference delta mγ dGamma/dxγ⊥ using equation (5.2a) and subsequent algebraic manipulation to arrive at equation (5.10), providing a unified formula for both m=0 and m not equal to 0 cases.

Sources

Related papers