Stationary solutions in the small- c expansion of GR
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Stationary solutions in the small- c expansion of GR".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Stationary solutions in the small-c expansion of GR study how general relativity in its small-c expansion yields a richer stationary vacuum sector than magnetic Carroll truncation by capturing both strong-gravity and weak-field branches up to next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) <ref:2604.23677#pg2>.
Kai: The small-c expansion of general relativity leads to Carrollian gravity organized order by order in the parameter c <ref:2604.23677#pg2>.
Mira: The full NLO/NNLO theories, which contain a richer structure than the magnetic truncation, may admit nontrivial rotating solutions <ref:2604.23677#pg2>.
Kai: This suggests that the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects <ref:2604.23677#pg2>.
Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper on "Stationary solutions in the small c expansion of GR", what's the final word on what this research actually achieved? It seems to be about proving that the small c expansion isn't just a way to simplify things, but a way to organize them systematically > <ref:2604.23677#pg20>.
Mira: Right. The authors show that the stationary sector naturally breaks down into these strong-gravity and weak-field branches, and that at NNLO they get significantly more structure than just what the magnetic Carroll truncation offers > <ref:2604.23677#pg20>.
Lev: And it provides a concrete way to build solutions, showing exact vacuum geometries like the Lense–Thirring and rotating C-metric backgrounds at NLO and then extending that to NNLO > <ref:2604.23677#pg19>. That's a tangible result for checking our error correction models on real hardware > <ref:2604.23677#pg19>.
Kai: So, the implication is that we can use this framework to explore more complex rotating and multipolar solutions in Carroll gravity, which helps us understand these compact object geometries better > <ref:2604.23677#pg20>.
Mira: And it confirms that these Carrollian backgrounds are not just abstract mathematical constructs; they can actually be found by expanding the corresponding relativistic metrics with the appropriate scaling of parameters like mass and gravity constant > <ref:2604.23677#pg20>.
Lev: Ultimately, it's a useful framework for exploring rotating and multipolar solutions in Carroll gravity, which is a solid tool for anyone trying to model these things > <ref:2604.23677#pg19>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this deep dive on "Stationary solutions in the small c expansion of GR". Basically, these authors are showing how you can systematically organize general relativity using this small c expansion method to find stationary solutions.
Mira: Right. They build a framework that splits everything into strong gravity and weak field branches, which is much more structured than just looking at the magnetic truncation alone. It's about capturing both the heavy gravity stuff and the weaker field effects up to next-to-next-to-leading order.
Lev: For us building hardware, what this means is they're showing you exactly how these complex geometries can be generated, which is a big step for checking our error correction models against actual physics. It moves it from just theory to something with a concrete structure we can test against.
Kai: I think the main point is that these solutions aren't just artifacts of the expansion; they match up perfectly with what you get when you expand the standard relativistic metrics using specific scaling factors for things like mass or the gravity constant. It’s a consistency check that’s hard to get elsewhere.
Mira: Exactly. They show that this organized framework naturally handles both rotating and multipolar structures, which is what we need to understand compact objects better in both extreme and less extreme environments. The paper lays out how these specific parameters map onto the known solutions like the Lense–Thirring metric.
Lev: It’s useful because they fix those parameters by matching them directly to the seed relativistic metrics, so you don't have to guess what the scaling should be for mass or angular momentum. That makes it a practical tool for finding these specific backgrounds.
Kai: So, the implication is that this method provides a reliable way to explore more complex rotating and multipolar solutions in Carroll gravity. And we still need to look at what happens when you push those multipole moments higher, past four.
Enes Bal, Ertu˘grul Ekiz, Emre Onur Kahya, Utku Zorbab
Department of Physics, Istanbul Technical University · Department of Engineering Sciences, Istanbul University-Cerrahpaşsa
gr-qc, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-04-26
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 38 pages; v2: 39 Pages, references and additional explanations added; v3: 40 pages, published version, one sentence added to the abstract, stationary ADM reduction and boundary conditions clarified, two references added
Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 1283 (2026)
DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-026-16509-y
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Stationary solutions in the small-c expansion of GR study how general relativity in its small-c expansion yields a richer stationary vacuum sector than magnetic Carroll truncation by capturing both…
Key concepts
- Small-c Expansion
- This method organizes general relativity by expanding it in terms of a small parameter 'c'. This expansion allows researchers to systematically study gravity across different regimes, separating strong-gravity effects from weak-field effects. It provides an organizational framework analogous to how large-'c' expansions are used in other gravitational theories.
- Strong Gravity Branch
- This branch focuses on spacetimes where the gravitational potential remains significant at the leading order. In this regime, solutions like the Lense–Thirring geometry appear as exact vacuum solutions of NLO Carroll gravity, and they are obtained by dressing static backgrounds with a rotational shift vector.
- Weak Field Branch
- This branch starts from flat or mass-independent backgrounds, where complex structure emerges only through subleading fields in the small-c expansion. At NNLO, this branch includes richer structures like scalar fields and spatial deformations, leading to exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions with higher multipole moments.
- Magnetic Carroll Truncation
- This is a simpler approximation of NLO Carroll gravity based on satisfying only the leading-order field equations. The study shows that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a significantly richer stationary vacuum sector than this truncation, which often misses important rotational and multipolar structures.
Terminology
Summary
Stationary solutions in the small-c expansion of GR study how general relativity in its small-c expansion yields a richer stationary vacuum sector than magnetic Carroll truncation by capturing both strong-gravity and weak-field branches up to next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) <ref:2604. p. 0 More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. tr
Abstract: We study the small-c expansion of general relativity in ADM variables up to
next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). We show that, in the stationary sector, this formulation renders the field equations more tractable for explicit solution building.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Introduction and Motivation
The small-c expansion of general relativity leads to Carrollian gravity organized order by order in the parameter c <ref:2604.23677#pg2>. The full NLO/NNLO theories, which contain a richer structure than the magnetic truncation, may admit nontrivial rotating solutions <ref:2604. p. 3 However, the corresponding solution spaces of Carroll gravity remain
poorly understood, especially beyond the magnetic truncation. This suggests that the full
NLO/NNLO theories, which contain a richer structure than the magnetic truncation, may
admit nontrivial rotating solutions. This suggests that the full
NLO/NNLO theories, which contain a richer structure than the magnetic truncation, may
admit nontrivial rotating solutions. In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Moreover, it admits
an extension to higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4. Accordingly, the full NLO and NNLO Carroll
theories provide a finite-order framework for organizing exterior rotational and multipolar
deformations motivated by compact-object geometries in the strong-gravity and weak-field
regimes.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Strong Gravity Stationary Branch
The strong-gravity branch analysis focuses on spacetimes where the gravitational potential remains significant at the leading order <ref:2604.23677#pg2>. The NLO solutions admit rotational data encoded in the subleading shift vector Ai, which reproduces the Lense–Thirring geometry as an exact vacuum solution of NLO Carroll gravity <ref:2604. p. 9 NLO solutions
At the NLO level, the stationary reduced equations (C. 3) admit solutions in which the rotational data are encoded in the subleading shift vector Ai
. These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up
to O(J
3
) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. Strong-gravity stationary branch
In this section, we analyze the stationary solutions where the gravitational potential remains
significant at the leading order. By setting the leading-order shift vector to zero (Ni = 0),
we focus on spacetimes that reduce to static Carrollian backgrounds in the c → 0 limit.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Weak Field Stationary Branch
The weak-field regime starts from the flat solution or mass-independent leading C-metric background, where nontrivial structure appears only through subleading fields in the small-c expansion <ref:2604.23677#pg2>. At NNLO, this branch acquires a richer structure, including the scalar field M, spatial deformation βij, and vector field Zphi <ref:2604. p. 0 The stationary
sector exhibits both strong-gravity and weak-field branches, whose structure becomes richer
at NNLO. In the strong-gravity branch, we first obtain exact vacuum solutions of NLO Carroll gravity, including the Lense–Thirring and rotating C-metric backgrounds. We show that the small-c expansion of general relativity, which gives rise to LO, NLO, and
NNLO Carroll gravity, captures the strong-gravity regime together with rotational corrections
up to order J
3
. In the weak-field regime, it also captures an independently parametrized
quadrupolar deformation Q and rotational corrections up to order J
2
. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. We further extend the ℓ = 0, 2 sector by including
higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4, where ℓ denotes the multipole index.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Solution Types and Consistency Checks
The paper constructs several exact vacuum solutions across the two branches:
-
Strong NLO solutions include the Lense–Thirring solution (3. p. 4
1) and a rotating C-metric solution (3. p. 0Where the paper says it
Since the Hartle–Thorne and Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after expansion. More generally, the solutions obtained in this work fall into two distinct regimes, namely the strong-gravity and weak-field branches, at both NLO and NNLO.
2) <ref:2604. p. 0Where the paper says it
These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up to O(J 3 ) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution.
23677#pg10>.Where the paper says it
More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.
-
Weak NNLO solutions include Hartle–Thorne-type, Kerr-type, and mixed-type solutions <ref:2604. p. 0
23677#pg16>.Where the paper says it
These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up to O(J 3 ) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution.
-
The results show that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a richer stationary vacuum sector than the magnetic Carroll truncation <ref:2604. p. 0
23677#pg20>. The same Carrollian geometries can be recovered by directly expanding corresponding relativistic metrics with appropriate parameter scalings <ref:2604. p. 4Where the paper says it
We further extend the ℓ = 0, 2 sector by including higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4, where ℓ denotes the multipole index. These results show that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a richer stationary vacuum sector than the magnetic Carroll truncation.
23677#pg20>.Where the paper says it
In particular, the weak-field NNLO sector includes an exact Hartle–Thorne-type branch together with its extension to higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4. An important point is that the same Carrollian geometries can also be recovered by directly expanding the corresponding relativistic metrics with appropriate parameter scalings, and the two approaches agree.
Conclusion and Outlook
The ADM formulation provides a practical framework for constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The results show that the stationary sector naturally organizes into strong-gravity and weak-field branches <ref:2604. p. 9 Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. In this stationary sector, as we will see, the
solutions of the NLO and NNLO field equations naturally organize into two distinct small-c
regimes, which we refer to as the strong-gravity and weak-field branches. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. Likewise, there may exist exact solutions of Carrollian
gravity even when the corresponding relativistic metric is not an exact solution of GR. We
expect that the ADM form of Carroll gravity and its extensions will be useful for exploring
further non-Lorentzian geometries in both the strong-gravity and weak-field regimes.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Review of Carroll Expansion
The small-c expansion proceeds by introducing the pre-ultra-local (PUL) form of the metric and inverse metric <ref:2604.23677#pg22>. The leading-order Lagrangian is given by L Carr = e Kmu nu Kmu nu - K2 <ref:2604. p. 9 Before constructing these stationary metrics, we simplify the field equations by imposing
the stationary ansatz: we demand that the fields be time-independent (∂t = 0) and set the
leading-order shift vector to zero (Ni = 0) in the NLO and NNLO field equations. Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. The leading-order
action is called electric Carrollian gravity, whereas a consistent truncation of the NLO action
defines magnetic Carroll gravity. Although manifest covariance is lost in this description,
the resulting formalism is well suited for constructing solutions order by order in the small-c
expansion.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Field Equations and Truncations
The field equations expand as E0 → (0) E 0 + c2 (2) E 0 + c4 (4) E 0, and similarly for Ei and Eij <ref:2604.23677#pg12>. The magnetic truncation of NLO Carroll gravity is based on the condition that the leading-order field equations are satisfied, reducing the NLO Lagrangian to the spatial-curvature term alone <ref:2604. p. 3 The resulting theories are referred to as the electric/LO (leading
order), NLO (next-to-leading order), and NNLO (next-to-next-to-leading order) sectors of
Carroll gravity. Accordingly, a consistent truncation of the NLO theory gives rise to magnetic Carroll gravity. Therefore, the relativistic Lagrangian can be expanded in the following form:
L → c
2 LLO + c
4 LNLO + c
6 LNNLO . The explicit forms of the Lagrangians are4
:
LLO =
N
√γ
2 κ
KijKij − K2
, (2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
ADMs Decomposition and Maps
The ADM decomposition is useful because it isolates the constrained structure of the theory and provides a practical framework for solving the field equations <ref:2604.23677#pg11>. The ADM actions presented here are equivalent to the covariant ones up to boundary terms <ref:2604. p. 8 17)
where β = γ
ijβij , and we define
θ
ij =
L
ij − γ
ijL − β
jk Ki
k + β
ij K
. 18)
The relation to the covariant Carroll formulation is summarized in Appendix A, where we
show that the ADM actions presented here are equivalent to the covariant ones up to boundary
terms. 17)
where β = γ
ijβij , and we define
θ
ij =
L
ij − γ
ijL − β
jk Ki
k + β
ij K
. 18)
The relation to the covariant Carroll formulation is summarized in Appendix A, where we
show that the ADM actions presented here are equivalent to the covariant ones up to boundary
terms. 17)
where β = γ
ijβij , and we define
θ
ij =
L
ij − γ
ijL − β
jk Ki
k + β
ij K
. 18)
The relation to the covariant Carroll formulation is summarized in Appendix A, where we
show that the ADM actions presented here are equivalent to the covariant ones up to boundary
terms. tr
Abstract: We study the small-c expansion of general relativity in ADM variables up to
next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). We show that, in the stationary sector, this formulation renders the field equations more tractable for explicit solution building.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Field Equation Reductions
The stationary reduction of the field equations is obtained by imposing time independence of all fields and setting the leading-order shift vector to zero, Ni = 0 <ref:2604. p. 9 Instead, the NLO and NNLO theories admit distinct
stationary sectors whose relation to relativistic rotating metrics is captured order by order. Before constructing these stationary metrics, we simplify the field equations by imposing
the stationary ansatz: we demand that the fields be time-independent (∂t = 0) and set the
leading-order shift vector to zero (Ni = 0) in the NLO and NNLO field equations. 19)
in the NLO full field equations (see (C. 1)), which yields:
R = 0 ,
NGij − ∇i ∇jN + γij ∇2 N = 0 . LO, NLO and NNLO field equations 24
C. Stationary reduction and reduced field equations 27
C. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Relativistic Metrics and Scaling
The Lense–Thirring metric is an exact vacuum solution of NLO Carroll gravity, arising from the small-c expansion of the Hartle–Thorne, Kerr, and Lense–Thirring geometries by suitable scalings <ref:2604.23677#pg12>. The strong-gravity branch solutions are obtained by scaling J → c cubed J, m → c m, G → c G <ref:2604. p. 4 In particular, there may exist genuinely
non-Lorentzian background solutions that cannot be obtained from the scaling or expansion
of any relativistic spacetime metric. Likewise, there may exist exact solutions of Carrollian
gravity even when the corresponding relativistic metric is not an exact solution of GR. These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up
to O(J
3
) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. More generally, the solutions obtained in this work fall into two distinct regimes,
namely the strong-gravity and weak-field branches, at both NLO and NNLO. Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. In this stationary sector, as we will see, the
solutions of the NLO and NNLO field equations naturally organize into two distinct small-c
regimes, which we refer to as the strong-gravity and weak-field branches. Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. In this stationary sector, as we will see, the
solutions of the NLO and NNLO field equations naturally organize into two distinct small-c
regimes, which we refer to as the strong-gravity and weak-field branches. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
C-Metric Backgrounds
The C-metric, together with its rotating generalization, provides an exact solution of the vacuum Einstein equations <ref:2604.23677#pg19>. The non-rotating C-metric background is given by ds2 = 1/omega squared - Q c squared dt + dr squared Q + r squared P dθ squared + P r squared sin squared θ dϕ squared. p. 0 These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up
to O(J
3
) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution.Where the paper says it
Conclusion Summary
The paper demonstrates that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a richer stationary vacuum sector than the magnetic Carroll truncation, including nontrivial rotational and multipolar structure <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The leading-order theory corresponds to electric Carroll gravity, while a consistent truncation of the NLO theory gives magnetic Carroll gravity <ref:2604. p. 3 The resulting theories are referred to as the electric/LO (leading
order), NLO (next-to-leading order), and NNLO (next-to-next-to-leading order) sectors of
Carroll gravity. Accordingly, a consistent truncation of the NLO theory gives rise to magnetic Carroll gravity. In particular, the weak-field NNLO sector includes an exact Hartle–Thorne-type branch together
with its extension to higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4. An important point is that the same Carrollian geometries can also be recovered by directly expanding the corresponding relativistic
metrics with appropriate parameter scalings, and the two approaches agree. In particular, the weak-field NNLO sector includes an exact Hartle–Thorne-type branch together
with its extension to higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4. An important point is that the same Carrollian geometries can also be recovered by directly expanding the corresponding relativistic
metrics with appropriate parameter scalings, and the two approaches agree. Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. In this stationary sector, as we will see, the
solutions of the NLO and NNLO field equations naturally organize into two distinct small-c
regimes, which we refer to as the strong-gravity and weak-field branches. Henceforth,
we use the field equations given in Appendix C. In this stationary sector, as we will see, the
solutions of the NLO and NNLO field equations naturally organize into two distinct small-c
regimes, which we refer to as the strong-gravity and weak-field branches. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. More generally, the solutions obtained in this work fall into two distinct regimes,
namely the strong-gravity and weak-field branches, at both NLO and NNLO. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. More generally, the solutions obtained in this work fall into two distinct regimes,
namely the strong-gravity and weak-field branches, at both NLO and NNLO. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Mehmet Ozkan, O˘guzhan Ka¸sık¸cı, and Niels A. Obers for their useful ¨ comments and feedback <ref:2604. p. 0 More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. Stationary solutions in the small-c expansion of GR
Enes Bal,a Ertu˘grul Ekiz,a Emre Onur Kahya,a and Utku Zorbab
aDepartment of Physics, Istanbul Technical University
Maslak 34469 Istanbul, T¨urkiye
bDepartment of Engineering Sciences, Istanbul University-Cerrahpa¸sa
Avcilar 34320 Istanbul, T¨urkiye
E-mail: bale19@itu. tr, ekize15@itu. Stationary solutions in the small-c expansion of GR
Enes Bal,a Ertu˘grul Ekiz,a Emre Onur Kahya,a and Utku Zorbab
aDepartment of Physics, Istanbul Technical University
Maslak 34469 Istanbul, T¨urkiye
bDepartment of Engineering Sciences, Istanbul University-Cerrahpa¸sa
Avcilar 34320 Istanbul, T¨urkiye
E-mail: bale19@itu. tr, ekize15@itu. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix A Review
The small-c expansion proceeds by introducing the pre-ultra-local (PUL) form of the metric and inverse metric <ref:2604.23677#pg19>. The LO and NLO Lagrangians are obtained in the following forms, respectively, L Carr = e Kmu nu Kmu nu - K2 <ref:2604. p. 8 Therefore, the relativistic Lagrangian can be expanded in the following form:
L → c
2 LLO + c
4 LNLO + c
6 LNNLO . The explicit forms of the Lagrangians are4
:
LLO =
N
√γ
2 κ
KijKij − K2
, (2. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. In the next subsection,
we formulate the small-c expansion in ADM variables order by order. The leading-order
action is called electric Carrollian gravity, whereas a consistent truncation of the NLO action
defines magnetic Carroll gravity.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
NNLO Action
The compact form of the NLO action can be written as LNLO = sqrt(gammaN/2 κ N R + M(0) E 0 + A i(0) E i - βij 2(0) E ij!) <ref:2604.23677#pg19>. The NNLO action is given by LNNLO = sqrt(gammaN (∇j∇i − γij ∇2 − Gij βij + M N hR + 2 Kijθij + 1/2 (KijKij − K2) βi + P N (KijKij − K2) + 2 F ijKij − 2 F K - 4 Ki kKjϵjk + 2 K K ijϵjk + 1/8 (KijKij − K2)ϵ + (LijL ij − L 2) + 2 KijL βij + KijLij β - K L β - 4 KijLi kβjk + 2 Ki jβiji) <ref:2604. p. 8 Therefore, the relativistic Lagrangian can be expanded in the following form:
L → c
2 LLO + c
4 LNLO + c
6 LNNLO . The explicit forms of the Lagrangians are4
:
LLO =
N
√γ
2 κ
KijKij − K2
, (2.Where the paper says it
Field Equations Expansion
The field equations expand as E0 → (0) E 0 + c2 (2) E 0 + c4 (4) E 0, and similarly for Ei and Eij <ref:2604.23677#pg19>. The stationary reduction of the field equations is obtained by imposing time independence of all fields and setting the leading-order shift vector to zero, Ni = 0 <ref:2604.23677#pg29>. The reduced NNLO field equations are simplified in the stationary limit as follows: δN:L squared − LijL ij − Rijβij + ∇j∇iβij − ∇2β = 0 <ref:2604. p. 1 LO, NLO and NNLO field equations 24
C. Stationary reduction and reduced field equations 27
C. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. We further extend the ℓ = 0, 2 sector by including
higher multipoles up to ℓ = 4, where ℓ denotes the multipole index. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Lense–Thirring and Hartle–Thorne Metrics
The Lense–Thirring metric is an exact vacuum solution of NLO Carroll gravity, arising from the small-c expansion of the Hartle–Thorne, Kerr, and Lense–Thirring geometries by suitable scalings <ref:2604.23677#pg12>. The Hartle–Thorne metric admits two distinct scaling regimes in the present context <ref:2604. p. 4 Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. More generally, the solutions obtained in this work fall into two distinct regimes,
namely the strong-gravity and weak-field branches, at both NLO and NNLO. These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up
to O(J
3
) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. In particular, there may exist genuinely
non-Lorentzian background solutions that cannot be obtained from the scaling or expansion
of any relativistic spacetime metric. Likewise, there may exist exact solutions of Carrollian
gravity even when the corresponding relativistic metric is not an exact solution of GR.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Kerr Metric Expansion
The Kerr metric expansion in the strong-gravity branch gives precisely the vacuum NNLO Carroll solution shown in (3.5) <ref:2604.23677#pg36>. The weak-field expansion corresponds to the solution given in (4.13) <ref:2604.23677#pg36>. The Kerr metric expansion recovers both the Lense–Thirring solution and the J squared contributions appearing in NNLO Carroll gravity <ref:2604. p. 4 This geometry can also be obtained from the small-c expansion of the Hartle–
Thorne, Kerr, and Lense–Thirring geometries by suitable scalings of parameters such as the
mass m, gravitational constant G, and rotation parameter J. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion.Where the paper says it
The paper demonstrates that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a richer stationary vacuum sector than the magnetic Carroll truncation by capturing both strong-gravity and weak-field branches up to NNLO <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The results show that these Carrollian backgrounds can also be recovered from the small-c expansion of the corresponding relativistic metrics, provided one chooses the appropriate scalings of the parameters m, G, J, and Q <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The stationary sector naturally organizes into strong-gravity and weak-field branches <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The labels m, J, Q, and α used in this work are fixed by matching to the corresponding relativistic seed metrics <ref:2604.23677#pg20>. The analysis provides a useful framework for exploring further rotating and multipolar solutions in Carroll gravity <ref:2604.23677#pg20>.
Review of References
The references include works on Carroll expansion of general relativity <ref:2604.23677#pg19>, rotating Carroll black holes <ref:2604. p. 3 Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). Recent work has also applied Carrollian methods
to string dynamics near BTZ black holes [14]. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. Recent work has also applied Carrollian methods
to string dynamics near BTZ black holes [14]. Early studies of Carrollian-like structures
originated from the electric limit of GR, first introduced in [15, 16], in the context of strong
gravity, where the gravitational theory exhibits ultralocal behavior. In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604. In particular, there may exist genuinely
non-Lorentzian background solutions that cannot be obtained from the scaling or expansion
of any relativistic spacetime metric. Likewise, there may exist exact solutions of Carrollian
gravity even when the corresponding relativistic metric is not an exact solution of GR. In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). This geometry can also be obtained from the small-c expansion of the Hartle–
Thorne, Kerr, and Lense–Thirring geometries by suitable scalings of parameters such as the
mass m, gravitational constant G, and rotation parameter J. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. In this sense, the small-c expansion may provide an organizational framework analogous to the role played by the large-c expansion in post-Newtonian
and multipolar descriptions of slowly rotating and weakly deformed compact objects. Carrollian geometries have been studied in various areas of theoretical physics, ranging from
physics on null hypersurfaces and black-hole-horizon dynamics to string theory and holography (see [3–13] and references therein). These solutions also arise from the small-c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up
to O(J
3
) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle–Thorne-type solutions
with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and
a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. This geometry can also be obtained from the small-c expansion of the Hartle–
Thorne, Kerr, and Lense–Thirring geometries by suitable scalings of parameters such as the
mass m, gravitational constant G, and rotation parameter J. Since the Hartle–Thorne and
Lense–Thirring geometries are approximate slow-rotation exterior metrics rather than exact
vacuum solution families of GR such as Kerr, this also shows that approximate relativistic
backgrounds can still give rise to exact vacuum solutions of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity after
expansion. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for
constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small-c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole
deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries. arXiv:2604.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can perform explicit construction of exact vacuum solutions for NLO Carroll gravity, including Lense-Thirring and rotating C-metric backgrounds up to NNLO order J cubed in the strong-gravity branch. This allows the system to systematically generate higher-order stationary geometries directly from field equations.
-
Improved AI system can distinguish between the magnetic Carroll truncation and the full NLO/NNLO theory by identifying nontrivial rotational solutions, which is crucial for exploring solution spaces beyond known magnetic truncations. This capability enables the system to search for genuinely non-Lorentzian backgrounds not derivable from relativistic metric expansions.
-
Improved AI system can utilize a consistent small-c expansion framework to organize exterior rotational and higher-multipole deformations up to multipole index l equals four in the weak-field regime. This allows for the systematic construction of Hartle–Thorne-type solutions with independent quadrupole moments and higher multipoles, matching both the Kerr and C-metric expansions.
-
Improved AI system can perform a consistent mapping between ADM form of NLO/NNLO Carroll gravity and covariant Carroll expansion, enabling it to solve field equations more systematically by leveraging known results from the covariant formulation up to NLO. This facilitates a recursive approach where solutions at each order provide data for the next.
-
Improved AI system can apply specific parameter scalings (m -> c m, G -> c G, J -> c 3 J) to relativistic metrics like Kerr and Hartle-Thorne to directly recover the corresponding finite-order NNLO Carrollian solutions in both strong-gravity and weak-field branches. This provides a robust cross-validation method between the two theoretical approaches.
Abstract
We study the small- c expansion of general relativity in ADM variables up to next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). We show that, in the stationary sector, this formulation renders the field equations more tractable for explicit solution building. The stationary equations acquire a structure, in which the leading lapse and spatial metric are determined by a closed subsystem, the NLO rotational field satisfies a linear equation on that background, and the NNLO fields satisfy a linear system sourced by the NLO data. The stationary sector exhibits both strong-gravity and weak-field branches, whose structure becomes richer at NNLO. In the strong-gravity branch, we first obtain exact vacuum solutions of NLO Carroll gravity, including the Lense--Thirring and rotating C-metric backgrounds. At NNLO, we then construct the corresponding Lense--Thirring-type and C-metric-type exact vacuum geometries. These solutions also arise from the small- c expansion of the Kerr and rotating C-metric geometries around the strong-gravity background, up to O(J) at NLO and up to O(J 3) at NNLO. In the weak-field branch, we find exact Hartle--Thorne-type solutions with an independent quadrupole moment, together with exact spin-squared corrections and a mixed quadrupolar-rotating solution. We further extend the =0,2 sector by including higher multipoles up to =4, where denotes the multipole index. These results show that the full NLO/NNLO theory admits a richer stationary vacuum sector than the magnetic Carroll truncation. More broadly, the ADM formulation provides a practical framework for constructing and analyzing stationary backgrounds in the small- c expansion of general relativity, and may also offer a useful framework for organizing rotational and higher-multipole deformations motivated by relativistic compact-object geometries.
Sources
- Carroll Expansion of General Relativity
- Rotating Carroll Black Holes: A No Go Theorem
- The Carrollian Kaleidoscope
- A non-lorentzian primer
- Matrix Theory Reloaded: A BPS Road to Holography
- Carroll symmetry, dark energy and inflation
- Carroll stories
- Foundations of Carrollian Geometry
- Carrollian Physics and Holography
- The Tensionless Lives of Null Strings
- Lectures on Carrollian Holography
- Carroll Geometry Meets De Sitter Space via Holography
- Strings near BTZ black holes: A Carrollian Chronicle
- Mixmasters in Wonderland: Chaotic dynamics from Carroll limits of gravity
- Geodesics in Carrollian Reissner-Nordstr\"om black holes
- Carroll black holes in (A)dS and their higher-derivative modifications
- Asymptotic symmetries in Carrollian theories of gravity
- Asymptotic symmetries in Carrollian theories of gravity with a negative cosmological constant
- A 3+1 formulation of the 1/c expansion of General Relativity
- Non-Relativistic Gravitation: From Newton to Einstein and Back
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals