MINDS: Intertwined evolution of dust and gas in large planet-forming disks. A diversity driven by halted pebble drift?
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "MINDS: Intertwined evolution of dust and gas in large planet-forming disks. A diversity driven by halted pebble drift?".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates the diversity of inner disks around Sun-like stars using JWST mid-IR spectroscopy to determine if this diversity is driven by halted pebble drift.
Vera: Our goal is to investigate the diversity of inner disks with a specific focus on large and massive disks around Sun-like stars These are thought to be the progenitors of planetary systems with wide-orbit planets and potential instances of disks with quenched pebble drift The JWST spectra reveal a striking diversity, in line with previous observations Diversity in Molecular Emission The mid-IR spectra reveal a striking diversity, in line with previous observations V1094 Sco and DL Tau exhibit the highest C2H2/H2O flux ratio of the MINDS sample of full T Tauri disks (M∗ > 0.4M⊙) In contrast, the IM Lup spectrum is dominated by O-bearing species No one-to-one correspondence is found between the gas in the outer disk, as traced by the C2H (3-2)/C 18O (2-1) flux ratio, and that of the inner disk as traced by the C2H2/H2O flux ratios To account for these observational results, we propose a scenario based on a toy model of halted pebble drift relevant to the pebble-rich disks Modeling and Constraints The analysis uses a single-zone LTE slab model to analyze the molecular features The three free parameters of a single-slab model are the excitation temperature T, the column density of the species N, and the effective emitting radius R which sets the emitting area A with the convention A = πR squared We propose a new approach where slab models of gas are treated as any observed JWST spectrum by subtracting the continuum as in Temmink et al.
Jocelyn: (2024b) The fits of the JWST spectra are performed using an MCMC approach with the emcee package We find that the C/O ratio in DL Tau and V1094 Sco is likely elevated but below 1 Radial Transport Scenario The first scenario discussed is the inward radial transport of material from the cold outer disk to the warm inner disk The toy model predicts that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 This scenario suggests that DL Tau and V1094 Sco would be the best instances of this category of disk Dust Stoichiometry as a Diagnostic The silicate emission feature also encodes information about the grain composition We propose that silica grains could be related to the reformation of silicate in elevated C/O gas thereby providing a new diagnostic of C/O Prominent silica features are observed in some debris disks and are interpreted as the recondensation of vaporized bodies following giant impacts We unveil a mismatch between the outer carbon-rich and inner oxygen-rich regions in a sample of eight T Tauri disks that host substantial amounts of pebbles We propose that the retention of oxygen-rich icy grains in the outer disk and the advection of gas with high C/O drives an increase in C/O and a decrease in the (C+O)/H ratio in the inner disk, resulting in prominent C2H2 emission We show that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 Therefore, inner disks are unlikely to reach C/O above unity, even when the majority of the solids is blocked in the outer disk The discovery of a correlation between gas and dust emission in T Tauri disks open new avenues to build a consistent picture of disk evolution coupling dust and gas composition Key Findings Summary DL Tau and V1094 Sco show the highest C2H2/H2O flux ratios among the MINDS sample of full T Tauri disks The high C2H2/H2O flux ratios in DL Tau and V1094 Sco are also associated with a flat dust SED with the signature of silica grains (SiO2) We propose that silica is formed at the sublimation front of the silicates in a gas with super-solar but below unity C/O ratio The toy model demonstrates that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 Therefore, inner disks are unlikely to reach C/O above unity, even when the majority of the solids is blocked in the outer disk Future Directions Studies gathering large samples and forward modelling are required to confirm this proposal and obtain a global picture of disk evolution Comprehensive studies combining multiple JWST programs and focusing on representative samples of disks with similar stellar properties are needed to determine whether prominent C2H2 emission is more prevalent in pebble-rich disks and, more broadly, to fully test pebble drift models The developments of forward models should also be a priority to go beyond slab models retrieval and robustly convert the observed molecular emission to elemental abundances Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for valuable and detailed comments on the manuscript This work is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA/CSA James Webb Space Telescope The data were obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper now titled "MINDS: Intertwined evolution of dust and gas in large planet-forming disks. A diversity driven by halted pebble drift?" and the authors are Tabone, Temmink, Waters, van Dishoeck, Sellek, Estève, Kurtovic, Kamp, Henning, Gasman, Grant and Varga. They’re trying to figure out why inner disks around Sun-like stars look so different when we look at them with JWST mid-IR spectroscopy.
Jocelyn: It sounds like they are focusing on the diversity of those inner disks—the ones smaller than ten astronomical units—and they want to see if this difference comes down to a specific physical process, which is halted pebble drift.
Subrahmanyan: That's interesting because the elemental composition of these disks changes depending on where and when planets form, and this paper is trying to link the gas diversity we see now with that history.
Vera: Right. The paper’s main point is that they observe a striking diversity in molecular emission, especially in large and massive disks around Sun-like stars, and they find that the C2H2/H2O flux ratio isn't matching up with the outer disk gas ratios.
Jocelyn: They found that for instance, V1094 Sco and DL Tau show the highest C2H2/H2O flux ratios in this sample of full T Tauri disks, which is a key observation they are using to frame their discussion.
Subrahmanyan: And it’s important because they note there isn't a one-to-one correspondence between the gas traced by the C2H (three-two)/C 18O (two-one) flux ratio in the outer disk and the gas traced by the C2H2/H2O ratios in the inner disk.
Vera: So, they’re proposing a scenario based on a toy model of halted pebble drift, specifically relevant for those pebble-rich disks where this mismatch is happening.
Jocelyn: That model helps explain the observation by suggesting how material moves or gets trapped within these disks to create the observed chemical differences between the inner and outer regions.
Subrahmanyan: The modeling part seems to use a single-zone LTE slab model, which means they are treating the gas as if it were a simple layer with constant properties—temperature, column density, and an effective emitting radius.
Vera: They’re using a new approach where they treat these slab models as the actual JWST spectrum by subtracting the continuum, which is different from how some other papers have done it.
Jocelyn: And in their fits using that method with an emcee package, they found that the C/O ratio in DL Tau and V1094 Sco is likely elevated, but still below one.
Title and authors: Subrahmanyan: That’s a specific constraint on the chemistry, suggesting we might be dealing with some carbon enrichment in those particular systems.
Vera: Then they move into a radial transport scenario where material moves inward from the cold outer disk to the warm inner disk, and this toy model predicts that to get a match between the gas composition of the inner disk and an outer C-rich disk, you need efficient blocking of icy grains by about ninety five percent to get a C/O ratio around one.
Jocelyn: So they are suggesting that those disks would be the best examples for this scenario, which points toward DL Tau and V1094 Sco being the prime candidates here.
Subrahmanyan: That’s a big deal because it sets up a physical condition—that efficient grain blocking—to explain how we get C/O around one in that inner disk environment, even if most of the solids are blocked out there in the outer disk.
Vera: They also look at dust stoichiometry, specifically the silicate emission feature, and they propose that silica grains could be linked to the reformation of silicates in gas with an elevated C/O ratio, offering a new diagnostic for that ratio.
Jocelyn: They are suggesting that prominent silica features seen in some debris disks might actually be the recondensation of vaporized bodies after giant impacts, which ties dust composition back into the disk's evolution.
Subrahmanyan: That connects the gas and dust components directly, which is what they’re aiming for when they study how dust and gas evolve together.
Vera: In their conclusion for this paper, they unveil a mismatch between the outer carbon-rich and inner oxygen-rich regions in eight T Tauri disks with lots of pebbles. They propose that retaining oxygen-rich icy grains in the outer disk, combined with advection of gas with high C/O, drives an increase in C/O and a decrease in the (C plus O) over H ratio in the inner disk, which results in prominent C2H2 emission.
Jocelyn: And they reinforce that to get a match between the inner gas and an outer C-rich disk composition, you need that efficient blocking of icy grains by about ninety five percent to hit a C/O around one.
Subrahmanyan: So the main implication is that inner disks are unlikely to reach a carbon-to-oxygen ratio above unity, even if most of the solids are blocked in the outer disk. That’s a strong constraint on what we expect from planetary formation scenarios.
Title and authors: Vera: And they wrap things up by saying this correlation between gas and dust emission in T Tauri disks opens new ways to build a consistent picture of how disks evolve by coupling dust and gas composition together, which is pretty significant for understanding planet formation pathways.
Jocelyn: For the next step, they suggest that studies gathering larger samples and doing forward modeling are needed to confirm this proposal and get a global view of disk evolution.
Subrahmanyan: I agree, we need those large samples and forward modeling to move beyond these single-zone slab models and robustly convert the observed molecular emission into elemental abundances so we can really test these pebble drift theories.
Vera: Exactly, the paper flags that a priority should be developing forward models to go beyond slab models retrieval and make sure we are actually converting the observed molecular emission into elemental abundances correctly.
Jocelyn: So for future work, they’re calling for comprehensive studies combining multiple JWST programs and focusing on disks with similar stellar properties to see if this prominent C2H2 emission is more common in pebble-rich disks.
Subrahmanyan: And those forward models should also be a priority so we can test these pebble drift models robustly, which means we need to figure out how the gas and dust are truly coupled during the disk lifetime.
Vera: So, looking at this paper on "MINDS: Intertwined evolution of dust and gas in large planet-forming disks. A diversity driven by halted pebble drift?", it’s clear they found specific chemical signatures that point toward a mechanism—halted pebble drift—that explains the diversity they see in inner disks around Sun-like stars.
Jocelyn: They used JWST mid-IR spectroscopy to show how gas and dust composition are intertwined in these disks, and the key finding is that an efficient grain blocking process seems necessary to get a carbon-to-oxygen ratio of one between the inner and outer regions.
Subrahmanyan: For the bigger picture, this suggests that we need to incorporate pebble drift effects into our models of disk evolution if we want to accurately predict what kinds of planets will end up in those systems.
Vera: That’s right, it gives us a new way to interpret the observed compositions of exoplanets by understanding where and when those elements are mixed within the disk structure.
Jocelyn: It opens up a new avenue for connecting observations across different wavelengths, linking molecular lines with dust features to build that consistent picture of disk evolution.
Subrahmanyan: We need to keep looking at these large samples, because confirming this relationship between gas and dust emission is crucial for understanding the entire process of giant planet formation.
The paper's summary: Jocelyn: So, we just looked at how different these inner disks are around Sun-like stars and this paper, it really tries to explain that diversity by looking at how pebbles get stuck in those disks for a while.
Vera: Right. The main idea is that the gas and dust aren't behaving the same way in the inner parts of these disks, and they think this difference comes down to some kind of halted pebble drift, which means the pebbles just stop moving inward after they get there.
Subrahmanyan: It suggests a physical mechanism where gas gets enriched in carbon over time because certain icy grains are being blocked or retained out there in the outer disk.
Jocelyn: They show that when you look at the molecular signatures, like C2H2 and H2O, they don't match up between the inner and outer disk regions unless you introduce this idea of grain blocking.
Vera: They found that for DL Tau and V1094 Sco, these specific disks show the highest carbon dioxide to water flux ratios compared to other full T Tauri disks in their sample.
Subrahmanyan: And they propose that those high ratios aren't just random; they’re tied to a specific dust signature, which is silica grains, which they link back to gas with a slightly elevated but still below one carbon-to-oxygen ratio.
Jocelyn: It’s an interesting connection because it links the chemistry we see in the gas right there to what’s happening in the solid dust component.
Vera: They built a toy model, which is basically like a simplified simulation, and they found that to get the inner disk gas composition to match an outer carbon-rich disk, you need about ninety five percent of those icy grains to be blocked.
Subrahmanyan: That's a pretty specific number. It suggests that even if most of the solids are trapped far out in the outer disk, they still need to block most of their icy material to get that carbon enrichment inside.
Jocelyn: So, it changes how we think about planet formation models because it’s not just about where you form a planet, but how the pebbles move and get stuck during the whole process.
Vera: It also suggests that inner disks are unlikely to reach a carbon-to-oxygen ratio above one, even if they have all those solids blocked out in the outer region.
Subrahmanyan: That's a strong constraint for structure formation theory. If you want to build a planet around that star, the chemical environment of the gas you're interacting with is more constrained than we thought.
Jocelyn: And they’re calling for bigger samples and better forward modeling to really test this hypothesis and see if this pebble drift idea holds up across more systems.
Vera: Exactly. We need those larger studies to confirm if this correlation between gas and dust emission is a general feature of disk evolution or just an isolated thing happening in a few cases like DL Tau.
The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: So we just talked about how different these inner disks are around Sun-like stars and how this paper tries to explain that diversity by looking at how pebbles get stuck in those disks for a while.
Vera: Yeah, it’s all about the idea that the gas and dust aren't behaving the same way in those inner regions, and they think halted pebble drift is driving that difference.
Subrahmanyan: They show that this process leads to carbon enrichment because certain icy grains get blocked or retained out there in the outer disk.
Jocelyn: And they found a direct link between what we see in the molecular gas emissions, like C2H2 and H2O, and what’s happening with the dust composition, specifically silica grains.
Vera: They propose that those silica grains are actually related to how silicates reform in gas that has a carbon-to-oxygen ratio that's a bit higher than one.
Subrahmanyan: That connects the gas chemistry to the solid dust component directly, which is crucial for understanding how these materials evolve together.
Jocelyn: They also developed some ways to make this research better by suggesting improvements, like using forward modeling instead of just simple slab models.
Vera: Right, they’re saying that we need to move beyond those simple slab models and use more complex methods to actually convert the molecular emission into elemental abundances correctly.
Subrahmanyan: They want a system that can test radial transport scenarios by including chemical timescales and pebble trap leakiness parameters in their toy models.
Jocelyn: And they also suggest creating a diagnostic tool that links dust stoichiometry to gas composition by calculating the maximum amount of carbon species consistent with observed molecular features.
Vera: That’s smart, because it gives us a way to set an upper limit on the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in those water reservoirs based on what we actually observe.
Subrahmanyan: They also want a model that can distinguish between how elemental abundances and dust opacity affect the molecular emission by comparing line-to-continuum ratios with slab model results.
Jocelyn: And they’re calling for a comprehensive approach, combining multiple JWST programs and focusing on representative disks to confirm this idea globally.
Vera: So, they are looking for more data to see if this prominent C2H2 emission is really common in pebble-rich disks and whether pebble drift models are the right way to understand disk evolution.
Conclusion: Tom: So we’ve covered how different the inner disks are around Sun-like stars and how this paper tries to explain that diversity by looking at halted pebble drift.
Jocelyn: Basically, they found that gas and dust aren't behaving the same way in those inner regions because of how pebbles get stuck.
Vera: It really boils down to an efficient grain blocking process being necessary to match the chemical signatures between the inner and outer disk parts.
Subrahmanyan: This suggests that even if most of the solids are trapped far out in the outer disk, they still need to block most of their icy material to get that carbon enrichment inside.
Jocelyn: That’s a pretty specific number they used, about ninety five percent blocking to get a carbon-to-oxygen ratio around one between the inner and outer regions.
Vera: And it changes how we think about planet formation because it’s not just about where you form a planet, but how the pebbles move and get stuck during the whole process.
Subrahmanyan: It also suggests that inner disks are unlikely to reach a carbon-to-oxygen ratio above one, even if they have all those solids blocked out in the outer region.
Jocelyn: They’re calling for bigger samples and better forward modeling to really test this hypothesis and see if this pebble drift idea holds up across more systems.
Vera: Exactly. We need those larger studies to confirm if this correlation between gas and dust emission is a general feature of disk evolution or just an isolated thing happening in a few cases like DL Tau.
Subrahmanyan: It’s important for structure formation theory because it gives us a new constraint on the chemical environment that dictates how planets can evolve.
Jocelyn: And they're really opening up new avenues for linking molecular lines with dust features to build that consistent picture of disk evolution across different wavelengths.
Vera: I think the real value here is seeing how this coupling between gas and dust composition helps us build a more complete picture of planet formation pathways.
Subrahmanyan: So, to wrap up, this paper on "MINDS: Intertwined evolution of dust and gas in large planet-forming disks. A diversity driven by halted pebble drift?" gives us a specific physical condition—that efficient grain blocking—to explain the chemical differences we see in inner disks.
Jocelyn: And it sets the stage for what’s next, which is really pushing those forward models to test this mechanism robustly across many systems.
ESO · Leiden Observatory Leiden University · Department of Astrophysics/IMAPP Radboud University · Max-Planck-Institut für Extraterrestrische Physik Giessenbachstrasse · Kapteyn Astronomical Institute Rijksuniversiteit Groningen · Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie Königstuhl Heidelberg · Institute of Astronomy KU Leuven Celestijnenlaan 200D Leuven Belgium · Earth and Planets Laboratory Carnegie Institution for Science Washington DC
astro-ph.EP, astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.SR
Submitted: 2026-04-23
Updated: 2026-04-23
Comments: Accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics
Journal ref: A&A, 715, A24 (2026)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202556952
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: The paper investigates the diversity of inner disks around Sun-like stars using JWST mid-IR spectroscopy to determine if this diversity is driven by halted pebble drift.
Key concepts
- Halted Pebble Drift
- This scenario suggests that pebbles (small solid particles) stop drifting inward in the disk. This halting allows gas and solids to coexist in a way that influences chemical compositions, potentially leading to the observed diversity in inner disk chemistry.
- C2H2/H2O Flux Ratio
- This ratio is a key tracer used from JWST spectra to distinguish between different chemical environments in disks. High ratios are found in some disks, while others show dominance by oxygen-bearing species, indicating varying levels of carbon enrichment.
- Dust Stoichiometry as a Diagnostic
- The paper proposes that the presence of specific silicate features in dust emission relates to the gas composition. This suggests that silica grains might form when gas has a C/O ratio between super-solar and unity, offering a way to link dust properties to the surrounding gas chemistry.
Terminology
Summary
The paper investigates the diversity of inner disks around Sun-like stars using JWST mid-IR spectroscopy to determine if this diversity is driven by halted pebble drift. p. 0 Our goal is to investigate the diversity of inner disks with a specific focus on large and massive disks around Sun-like stars. These are thought to be the progenitors of planetary systems with wide-orbit planets and potential instances of disks with quenched
pebble drift.Where the paper says it
Our goal is to investigate the diversity of inner disks with a specific focus on large and massive disks around Sun-like stars These are thought to be the progenitors of planetary systems with wide-orbit planets and potential instances of disks with quenched pebble drift The JWST spectra reveal a striking diversity, in line with previous observations
Diversity in Molecular Emission
The mid-IR spectra reveal a striking diversity, in line with previous observations V1094 Sco and DL Tau exhibit the highest C2H2/H2O flux ratio of the MINDS sample of full T Tauri disks (M∗ > 0.4M⊙) In contrast, the IM Lup spectrum is dominated by O-bearing species No one-to-one correspondence is found between the gas in the outer disk, as traced by the C2H (3-2)/C 18O (2-1) flux ratio, and that of the inner disk as traced by the C2H2/H2O flux ratios To account for these observational results, we propose a scenario based on a toy model of halted pebble drift relevant to the pebble-rich disks
Modeling and Constraints
The analysis uses a single-zone LTE slab model to analyze the molecular features The three free parameters of a single-slab model are the excitation temperature T, the column density of the species N, and the effective emitting radius R which sets the emitting area A with the convention A = πR squared We propose a new approach where slab models of gas are treated as any observed JWST spectrum by subtracting the continuum as in Temmink et al. (2024b) The fits of the JWST spectra are performed using an MCMC approach with the emcee package We find that the C/O ratio in DL Tau and V1094 Sco is likely elevated but below 1
Radial Transport Scenario
The first scenario discussed is the inward radial transport of material from the cold outer disk to the warm inner disk The toy model predicts that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 This scenario suggests that DL Tau and V1094 Sco would be the best instances of this category of disk
Dust Stoichiometry as a Diagnostic
The silicate emission feature also encodes information about the grain composition We propose that silica grains could be related to the reformation of silicate in elevated C/O gas thereby providing a new diagnostic of C/O Prominent silica features are observed in some debris disks and are interpreted as the recondensation of vaporized bodies following giant impacts
Conclusions on Disk Evolution
We unveil a mismatch between the outer carbon-rich and inner oxygen-rich regions in a sample of eight T Tauri disks that host substantial amounts of pebbles We propose that the retention of oxygen-rich icy grains in the outer disk and the advection of gas with high C/O drives an increase in C/O and a decrease in the (C+O)/H ratio in the inner disk, resulting in prominent C2H2 emission We show that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 Therefore, inner disks are unlikely to reach C/O above unity, even when the majority of the solids is blocked in the outer disk The discovery of a correlation between gas and dust emission in T Tauri disks open new avenues to build a consistent picture of disk evolution coupling dust and gas composition
Key Findings Summary
** DL Tau and V1094 Sco show the highest C2H2/H2O flux ratios among the MINDS sample of full T Tauri disks **
** The high C2H2/H2O flux ratios in DL Tau and V1094 Sco are also associated with a flat dust SED with the signature of silica grains (SiO2) **
** We propose that silica is formed at the sublimation front of the silicates in a gas with super-solar but below unity C/O ratio **
** The toy model demonstrates that a match between a Crich gas composition of the inner versus a C-rich outer disk requires efficient blocking of icy grains of about ≃ 95% to obtain C/O ≃ 1 **
** Therefore, inner disks are unlikely to reach C/O above unity, even when the majority of the solids is blocked in the outer disk **
Future Directions
Studies gathering large samples and forward modelling are required to confirm this proposal and obtain a global picture of disk evolution Comprehensive studies combining multiple JWST programs and focusing on representative samples of disks with similar stellar properties are needed to determine whether prominent C2H2 emission is more prevalent in pebble-rich disks and, more broadly, to fully test pebble drift models The developments of forward models should also be a priority to go beyond slab models retrieval and robustly convert the observed molecular emission to elemental abundances
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for valuable and detailed comments on the manuscript This work is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA/CSA James Webb Space Telescope The data were obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop a forward modeling capability that robustly converts observed molecular emission to elemental abundances using multiple slab models, as suggested by
A robust analysis of JWST spectra is often hampered by a pseudo-continuum due to highly optically thick gas; this cannot be unambiguously separated from the dust continuum
andwe propose a new approach. The slab models of the gas are treated as any observed JWST spectrum by subtracting the continuum as in Temmink et al. (2024b).
-
Implement a system capable of testing radial transport scenarios using toy models that incorporate chemical timescales, advection timescales, and pebble trap leakiness parameters to predict the evolution of C/O ratios between outer and inner disks.
-
Create a diagnostic tool that links dust stoichiometry to gas composition by calculating the maximum column density of carbon species consistent with observed molecular features assuming the same emitting area and temperature as water reservoirs, as described in
To obtain an upper limit of C2H2/H2O abundance ratio in each of the water reservoirs.
-
Design a model that distinguishes between elemental abundance effects and dust opacity effects on molecular emission by comparing line-to-continuum ratios with slab model results to infer the location of the emitting gas relative to the dust photosphere.
Abstract
(Abridged) We aim to investigate the inner regions of large and massive disks orbiting T Tauri stars, thought to be progenitors of systems with wide-orbit planets and possible cases of halted pebble drift. We analyze the MIRI spectra of three disks from the MINDS program: V1094 Sco, DL Tau, and IM Lup. The spectra reveal a striking diversity. V1094 Sco and DL Tau exhibit the highest C 2 H 2 /H 2 O flux ratio in the MINDS sample of T Tauri disks. In V1094 Sco, even cold C 4 H 2 is seen. In contrast, the IM Lup spectrum is dominated by O-bearing species. No one-to-one correspondence is found between the gas in the outer disk, as traced by the C 2 H/C 18 O flux ratio, and that of the inner disk as traced by the C 2 H 2 /H 2 O flux ratio. To explain these results, we propose a scenario based on a toy model of halted pebble drift. We show that a volatile C/O ratio close to unity and low C and O abundances in inner disks arise only if: (1) 95 % of the icy grains are blocked in the outer disk, (2) the outer disk is chemically evolved, and (3) the gas in the outer disk has had time to reach the inner disk. DL Tau and perhaps V1094 Sco would be the rare examples for which all these conditions are met. Therefore, a high C 2 H 2 /H 2 O flux ratio in pebble-rich disks would have a different origin than proposed for very-low mass stars, for which fast drift of O-rich pebbles would eventually leave a C-rich inner disk. We also show for the first time that the disks with high C 2 H 2 /H 2 O flux ratio exhibit a prominent silica dust component, a result found in four disks published so far (V1094 Sco, DL Tau, CY Tau, DoAr 33). We propose that the reformation of dust at the sublimation front of silicates in a gas with super-solar (but below unity) C/O ratio leads to a silica stoichiometry (SiO 2). In turn, silica is a promising diagnostic of the C/O ratio in the inner disks.
Sources
- MINDS: The very low-mass star and brown dwarf sample. Detections and trends in the inner disk gas
- The JDISC Survey: Linking the Physics and Chemistry of Inner and Outer Protoplanetary Disk Zones
- JWST Edge-on Disk Ice (JEDIce): Program overview and ice survey results
- SpectRes: A Fast Spectral Resampling Tool in Python
- The ALMA Survey of Gas Evolution of PROtoplanetary Disks (AGE-PRO): III. Dust and Gas Disk Properties in the Lupus Star-forming Region
- XUE 10. The CO2-rich terrestrial planet-forming region of an externally irradiated Herbig disk
- A transition from H$_2$O to C$_2$H$_2$ dominated spectra with decreasing stellar luminosity
- MINDS. Young binary systems with JWST/MIRI: Variable water-rich primaries and extended emission
- Chemical transformation of CO in evolving protoplanetary discs across stellar masses: a route to C-rich inner regions
- Exoplanet atmospheres at high spectral resolution
- MINDS. Water reservoirs of compact planet-forming dust disk: A diversity of H$_2$O distributions
- The ALMA Survey of Gas Evolution of PROtoplanetary Disks (AGE-PRO): X. Dust Substructures, Disk Geometries, and Dust-disk Radii
- A Precise Metallicity and Carbon-to-Oxygen Ratio for a Warm Giant Exoplanet from its Panchromatic JWST Emission Spectrum
Related papers
- A Bright L4 Neptune Trojan Found by Stacking Archival ZTF Images
- PDS 70 c and SR 12 c: Observational Constraints on Giant-Planet and Satellite Formation
- JWST Rocky Worlds DDT Observations of LTT 1445 A b and c in Secondary Eclipse Using MIRI/F1500W
- A Joint Study of Epoch Astrometry and Radial Velocities of Gaia-4b
- Using Structure Functions to Characterize Protoplanetary Disk Velocity Residuals
- An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque