Cosmological discrete self-similarity in primordial black hole formation
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Cosmological discrete self-similarity in primordial black hole formation".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. We demonstrate that discrete self-similarity (DSS), originally discovered in the collapse of a massless scalar field in an asymptotically flat system, survives in primordial black hole (PBH) formation within an expanding cosmological background The paper uses fully relativistic numerical simulations to show that log-periodic oscillations are present in the PBH mass scaling relation for both Gaussian and piecewise rational initial data This finding suggests that DSS persists in cosmological massless scalar-field collapse, implying characteristic modulations in the PBH mass spectrum.
Vera: Critical Phenomena in Gravitational Collapse The critical regime for PBH formation is characterized by a universal scaling law where the black-hole mass follows MPBH ∝ (p − pth)γ.
Jocelyn: Choptuik discovered both the scaling exponent γ and a discretely self-similar (DSS) critical solution in asymptotically flat spacetime, which is described by ln MPBH = γ ln(p − pth) + f
ln(p − pth): .
Vera: This log-periodic feature is not seen in the critical behavior caused by a continuously self-similar (CSS) solution observed in the perfect fluid system with a linear equation of state including radiation fluid.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're talking about this paper now titled "Cosmological discrete self-similarity in primordial black hole formation". It’s pretty heavy stuff because it says that this discrete self-similarity, which they first found when studying a massless scalar field collapse in flat spacetime, actually keeps working when you put it into an expanding universe.
Jocelyn: That’s right. The title really sets the stage by linking something from old gravitational collapse to something happening in the early cosmos, specifically around primordial black hole formation. It suggests this isn't just a feature of isolated black holes but a property that survives in an expanding background.
Subrahmanyan: What’s interesting about this is that it connects two different regimes: the asymptotically flat case and the cosmological setting where things are expanding. It probes whether the critical behavior seen locally persists globally when you introduce cosmic expansion into the equations of motion.
Vera: Basically, they use fully relativistic numerical simulations in an expanding Friedmann-Lemaˆıtre-Robertson-Walker universe to see if that log-periodic behavior is still there for primordial black holes. They even tested two different starting points: a Gaussian profile and a piecewise rational profile.
Jocelyn: And the key finding they’re highlighting is that they found clear log-periodic oscillations in the PBH mass scaling relation for both initial data families, which is what points to this discrete self-similarity being present.
Subrahmanyan: I mean, if these oscillations are real and consistent across different initial conditions, it suggests a very stable feature in how black holes form under these cosmological conditions. But we need to remember they found this by resolving the critical regime down to a difference of p minus pth around ten to the minus eight <ref:2604.21520#pg1,the critical regime down to>.
Vera: Exactly. So, it’s not just a theory on paper; they did the simulations and got those specific numbers, which is always good for us as observational astronomers because we can see if our data aligns with this prediction.
Jocelyn: And that numerical work suggests that the characteristic modulations in the PBH mass spectrum are real, even when dealing with cosmological perturbations. We need to see how this translates into something we might actually measure, like gravitational waves or abundance predictions.
The paper's summary: Vera: This paper is essentially showing that the discrete self-similarity they found in flat space survives in primordial black hole formation when you include an expanding cosmological background. It’s a demonstration that this critical behavior isn't just a fluke of isolated collapse, but something more robust.
Jocelyn: They show log-periodic oscillations appearing in the PBH mass scaling relation when simulating massless scalar field collapse within a Friedmann-Lemaˆıtre-Robertson-Walker universe. This is the direct evidence for discrete self-similarity surviving in cosmology.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, this means that the critical behavior of gravitational collapse isn't entirely dependent on being in flat spacetime; it points towards a universal intermediate attractor that governs the dynamics near the threshold, regardless of whether we are looking at an isolated system or the early universe.
Vera: They used two different initial data families to check their results, one Gaussian and one piecewise rational, and they found that both yielded consistent results for the scaling exponent gamma and a logarithmic period Pln. That consistency is what makes this result so compelling right now.
Jocelyn: And they compared their measured values to the known benchmarks from flat spacetime collapse, finding that the critical exponent gamma GG is zero point three hundred sixty-five plus or minus zero point seventeen and the logarithmic period Pln,G is four point six seven plus or minus zero point ten.
Subrahmanyan: But they also found that their results for the piecewise rational data, where gamma P equals zero point three five nine plus or minus zero point nineteen and Pln P equals four point seven four plus or minus zero point fourteen, are consistent with the asymptotic flat benchmarks within one sigma. That is a strong statement about the universality of this feature.
Vera: So what does this mean for us? It suggests that even though we’re dealing with expanding spacetime, the local dynamics right at the threshold of black hole formation are still governed by that discrete self-similarity structure they found in flat space.
Jocelyn: And as I said before, the implication is characteristic log-periodic modulations in the PBH mass function. This means when we look at how many primordial black holes we expect to find, there will be these specific shifts and localized enhancements spaced out by that universal DSS period.
The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors themselves point out a few things they think are important for the work, especially concerning how they extracted those key parameters. They mention that extracting the critical exponent gamma and the logarithmic period Pln requires sampling extremely close to criticality because of their numerical limitations.
Jocelyn: That’s a fair critique because reaching that near-critical region, where p minus pth is around ten to the minus eight, is still a finite range in their simulation, not the full asymptotic limit <ref:2604.21520#pg1>. They have to treat the fitted parameters as effective values extracted over that available window.
Subrahmanyan: That limitation makes sense because it means their derived gamma and Pln are effective values rather than perfect asymptotic ones, but they are still very close to the benchmark values from flat spacetime collapse. This is a key nuance for us to keep in mind when we interpret the results.
Vera: So one major improvement they suggest is how we should model those oscillations. They propose using a phenomenological fitting function, f of x equals C plus A ln epsilon plus cos of pi x Pln plus phi to model the residual pattern.
Jocelyn: That function, f of x equals C plus A ln epsilon plus cos of pi x Pln plus phi, is what they use to model the residual pattern and it relates directly to how those log-periodic modulations manifest in the mass spectrum. It's a concrete tool we can use.
Subrahmanyan: And I think that modeling the mass function with this term f of x allows us to actually generate those characteristic shifts and localized enhancements when gamma plus f prime of x gets small, which corresponds to a local compression of the mapping between delta H and PBH mass.
Vera: So they are giving us a way to predict these non-trivial features in the mass function even for smooth primordial perturbation statistical distributions, which is really something for predicting observable quantities.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap up this paper on "Cosmological discrete self-similarity in primordial black hole formation", the main point is that discrete self-similarity survives in an expanding cosmological background. They found clear log-periodic modulations in the PBH mass scaling relation, confirming a DSS critical solution even when we include cosmic expansion.
Vera: That confirms that these modulations are not just artifacts of our flat spacetime models, but they are a feature of the underlying physics governing black hole formation, regardless of the global geometry.
Subrahmanyan: From my side, it supports the idea that this critical phenomenon is a local property of gravitational collapse itself, largely independent of the global cosmological expansion. It suggests we should focus on what those near-critical dynamics are doing in isolation rather than getting too bogged down by the background cosmology.
Jocelyn: And if we look at the specific numbers they got, like comparing their measured gamma and Pln to those from flat spacetime, they stayed within one sigma of the benchmark values across different initial data families. That consistency really bolsters the case for universality.
Vera: So what this means for us is that we can expect characteristic log-periodic features in the primordial black hole mass function, even when we think about smooth statistical distributions, and it’s a real prediction to watch for in future observations.
Subrahmanyan: That’s the big picture. We are looking at how these critical phenomena leave imprints on cosmological PBH formation, and this paper provides the framework for that imprint to be detectable.
Jocelyn: It's a fascinating piece of work because it connects the initial conditions we use for simulations directly to observable features in the mass spectrum, which is a lot to digest.
Vera: Yeah, it’s a solid piece of work that shows how critical phenomena can leave potentially observable imprints in cosmological PBH formation.
Department of Physics, Rikkyo University · Astronomy Unit, Queen Mary University of London
astro-ph.CO, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-04-23
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures, including Supplemental Material. Published version in Physical Review D Letters
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, L041307 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/58r5-8zng
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 89/100
The gist: We demonstrate that discrete self-similarity (DSS), originally discovered in the collapse of a massless scalar field in an asymptotically flat system…
Key concepts
- Discrete Self-Similarity (DSS)
- This is a universal scaling law found during critical gravitational collapse where the black hole mass scales not just by a power law but also exhibits log-periodic oscillations. It describes how the system approaches a critical point with characteristic modulations in its structure, which are key to understanding the final black hole mass distribution.
- Critical Regime
- This is a specific state of gravitational collapse where the black hole mass follows a universal scaling law, MPBH ∝ (p − pth)γ. This regime is characterized by a threshold parameter (pth) that dictates whether a black hole forms, and the behavior near this threshold reveals critical exponents and self-similar solutions.
- Log-Periodic Oscillations
- These are characteristic wiggles or modulations appearing in the scaling relation of black hole masses near the critical collapse point. They are a signature of DSS and indicate that the mass spectrum is not smoothly distributed but has specific, repeating features determined by a universal period.
- Expanding Cosmological Background
- This refers to simulating black hole formation within an expanding universe described by the Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker geometry. The paper investigates whether the local critical dynamics of collapse are unaffected by this global expansion, testing the robustness of DSS in a cosmological context.
Terminology
Summary
We demonstrate that discrete self-similarity (DSS), originally discovered in the collapse of a massless scalar field in an asymptotically flat system, survives in primordial black hole (PBH) formation within an expanding cosmological background The paper uses fully relativistic numerical simulations to show that log-periodic oscillations are present in the PBH mass scaling relation for both Gaussian and piecewise rational initial data This finding suggests that DSS persists in cosmological massless scalar-field collapse, implying characteristic modulations in the PBH mass spectrum. p. 0
Critical Phenomena in Gravitational Collapse
The critical regime for PBH formation is characterized by a universal scaling law where the black-hole mass follows MPBH ∝ (p − pth)γ. Choptuik discovered both the scaling exponent γ and a discretely self-similar (DSS) critical solution in asymptotically flat spacetime, which is described by ln MPBH = γ ln(p − pth) + f[ln(p − pth)]. p. 0 This log-periodic feature is not seen in the critical behavior caused by a continuously self-similar (CSS) solution observed in the perfect fluid system with a linear equation of state including radiation fluid. p. 0 The presence of DSS implies characteristic log-periodic modulations in the PBH mass spectrum, with potential consequences for PBH abundances and the spectrum of induced gravitational waves. p. 0
Setup and Initial Conditions
The simulations are performed using fully relativistic numerical simulations of spherically symmetric collapse using a previously validated numerical code based on the extended Misner–Sharp formalism. Initial conditions are constructed using the gradientexpansion formalism, which provides a systematic description of super-horizon perturbations in an expanding universe. p. 1 Two families of initial data are considered: a Gaussian profile KG(A) = p e−(A/Am)2 and a piecewise rational profile KP(A) = p[1 − (3x squared − 2x 3)]1 + (A/Am) squared. p. 1 The formation of a PBH is identified through the appearance of a future outer trapping horizon, where Θ+ = 0 while Θ- < 0. p. 1
Critical Scaling and Discrete Self-Similarity
The collapse threshold pth was determined with absolute precision p − pth ∼ 10−8 for both initial data families, yielding pGth = 0.089573044 and pPth = 0. p. 1046397240. The corresponding threshold values expressed in terms of the maximum of the compaction function are Cmax,th = 0. p. 155954879 for Gaussian and Cmax,th = 0. p. 153554784 for piecewise rational. p. 0 The PBH mass follows a power-law envelope in (p−pth) with superimposed log-periodic oscillations characteristic of DSS critical collapse. p. 1 The measured critical exponent γ and logarithmic period Pln for the Gaussian case are γG = 0. p. 1365 ± 0.017 and Pln,G = 4. p. 167 ± 0.10.
Survival in an Expanding Universe
The persistence of DSS in a cosmological background is understood from the hierarchy of scales that develops near the black-hole threshold. Although the Friedmann–Lemaˆıtre–Robertson–Walker geometry introduces the Hubble radius H−1 as a natural largescale reference, the region that undergoes critical collapse becomes progressively smaller as the threshold is approached. p. 2 The near-central evolution thus approaches the same universal DSS critical solution known in asymptotically flat spacetime. p. 2 Our results indicate that discrete self-similarity survives in an expanding universe as a manifestation of local critical dynamics, with cosmological effects entering through the global structure of the spacetime rather than altering the core collapse itself. p. 2
Implications for Primordial Black-Hole Mass Functions
The presence of DSS has direct consequences for the PBH mass function by modifying the mapping between collapse parameter and resulting PBH mass through a modulation of the Jacobian. The DSS-induced modulation redistributes statistical weight in mass space, generating characteristic shifts and localized enhancements whose spacing is set by the universal DSS period. p. 2 This can lead to sharp, resonance-like enhancements when γ + f′(x) becomes small, corresponding to a local compression of the mapping between δH and MPBH. p. 2
Conclusions
In this Letter we have demonstrated that discrete self-similarity (DSS), originally discovered in the asymptotically flat collapse of a massless scalar field, also emerges in primordial black-hole (PBH) formation within an expanding cosmological background. Fully relativistic simulations of scalar-field collapse in a Friedmann-Lemaˆıtre–Robertson–Walker universe reveal clear log-periodic modulations in the PBH mass scaling relation, providing direct evidence for a DSS critical solution in the cosmological setting. p. 3 The critical exponent and logarithmic period extracted from two distinct families of initial data are consistent with each other and close to the asymptotically flat benchmarks, indicating that the near-critical dynamics approaches the same universal intermediate attractor. p. 3 This supports the interpretation that DSS is a local property of critical gravitational collapse, largely independent of the global cosmological expansion. p. 3 An immediate implication of this result is the emergence of characteristic log-periodic features in the PBH mass function, even for smooth primordial perturbation statistical distribution. p. 3 The paper concludes that blackhole critical phenomena can leave potentially observable imprints in cosmological PBH formation. p. 3
Supplemental Material Details
The simulations are performed using the extended Misner–Sharp formulation described in Refs. [14, 15]. The full system of equations solved numerically involves coupled evolution and constraint equations for the metric and matter variables. p. 0 The PBH mass is defined using the Misner–Sharp mass, which in spherical symmetry is given by MMS = R 2(1 − ∇aR∇aR). p. 5 The characteristic length scale of the collapsing region scales as (p − pth)γ, and can therefore be made arbitrarily small compared to the cosmological horizon. p. 2 The echoing period ∆ is estimated from the separation of successive peaks at the center in the self-similar energy density profiles. p. 5 The dominant peak of the Lomb–Scargle spectrum yields the oscillation period Pln. p. 6 The phenomenological fitting function f(x) = C + A lnϵ + cos(πxPln+ϕ) is used to model the observed residual pattern. p. 7 The numerical implementation shows effective second-order convergence for the Hamiltonian constraint diagnostic, as the violation decreases approximately as (∆x) squared. p. 8 The L2 norm of the Hamiltonian constraint at the time of apparent-horizon formation remains small for all simulations considered. p. 8
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved PBH mass function prediction: The AI system can now model primordial black hole mass functions by incorporating a log-periodic modulation term f(x) into Eq. (3), which is derived from the phenomenological fit of Eq. (23). This allows for the generation of characteristic shifts and localized enhancements in mass space, corresponding to
sharp, resonance-like enhancements when gamma + f'(x) becomes small.
-
Enhanced critical exponent and period extraction: The system can reliably extract the critical exponent gamma and logarithmic oscillation period Pln by applying a Lomb–Scargle analysis to the residuals of the mass-scaling relation (Eq. 21). This provides robust, data-driven estimates for these parameters even when sampling is not uniform.
-
Verification of near-critical dynamics: The AI system can verify that near-critical dynamics approach a universal DSS intermediate attractor by comparing the extracted echoing period Delta with the asymptotically flat benchmark value of 4.60, showing consistency within 1 sigma across different initial data families.
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference