Effect of subcritical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength

arXiv:2604.14936 · cond-mat.soft · Submitted 2026-04-16 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Effect of subcritical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Effect of sub-critical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength is investigated using discrete element method (DEM) simulations to elucidate grain-scale mechanisms controlling directional strengthening and weakening in granular beds under sub-critical fluid shear flows The research shows that the strength of a granular bed in a particular direction is highly correlated with the fraction of surface grains that can be dislodged by a fluid force applied in that direction This anisotropic bed strength only persists over a finite time scale set by the Shields number.

Kai: Simulation Methodology The study employs discrete element method (DEM) simulations of granular beds subjected to model fluid flows in both two (2D) and three (3D) dimensions The granular bed consists of N grains modeled as soft, frictional disks, with mixtures of half large and half small grains used to inhibit crystallization.

Mira: Inter-grain friction is implemented using the Cundall-Strack (CS) model, which defines pairwise normal force and tangential force between overlapping grains.

Kai: A coarse-grained fluid model is used to predict the critical Shields number to erode granular beds as a function of the shear Reynolds number.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now titled "Effect of subcritical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength". It’s a pretty specific look at how fluids affect the strength of granular material when the fluid isn't strong enough to cause immediate erosion.

Mira: And you have these authors, Dong Wang, Sophie Bodek, Nicholas T. Ouellette, Mark D. Shattuck and Corey S. O’Hern working together across Yale and Stanford departments—it shows a really broad mix of mechanical engineering and civil environmental engineering expertise here.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, I'm curious about the setup they used for their discrete element method simulations; how much computational cost is involved in modeling that many grains interacting?

Kai: They model N grains as soft, frictional disks and use the Cundall-Strack model to implement inter-grain friction. They also use a coarse grained fluid model to predict the critical Shields number needed to erode the bed based on the shear Reynolds number.

Mira: That approach is interesting because it links macroscopic flow parameters like Reynolds number directly to microscopic grain interactions. It suggests that the strength isn't just about how hard you push, but how those individual grains arrange themselves under that specific fluid stress.

Lev: If we were running this on real hardware, I’d be looking at whether modeling all N grains is feasible for the timescales they are interested in, especially when studying things near the critical Shields number.

The paper's summary: Kai: What they found is that the strength of a granular bed in a specific direction—like if you push from one side or another—is directly tied to how many surface grains get dislodged by the fluid force applied in that same direction.

Mira: That’s the main finding, and it sounds like it’s about directional dependence, which is something we see everywhere in materials science.

Lev: Directional dependence implies that even if you have a lot of material, its response to external forces isn't uniform across all directions; that means the local structure really matters.

Kai: Exactly. They found that this anisotropic bed strength only lasts for a finite time scale, which they call the Shields number. If the fluid flow gets too strong, that directional strengthening just wears off quickly because of erosion starting to dominate.

Mira: And they showed that in two dimensions, the mean grain speed depends on the direction of the conditioning fluid velocity when you are near that critical Shields number between one and about zero point six.

Lev: So, if you were building a system where you need directional stability, this tells us the flow direction matters for how stable it is.

Kai: In three dimensions, they found that the mean grain speed increases as the fluid velocity angle changes from zero to one eighty degrees when the Shields number is small.

Mira: That means at small Shields numbers, a slight change in flow direction really shifts how fast those grains are moving on average.

The paper's improvements: Mira: The paper points out a few things they think are improvements over previous work. First, they show that the mean grain speed is controlled by the fraction of highly mobile surface grains, which is determined by a minimum force required to dislodge each surface grain individually.

Kai: That’s a big step because it moves the focus from bulk properties to what's happening right at the surface where things actually interact with the fluid.

Lev: So they are suggesting that instead of just looking at overall stress, we should look at that single critical force for a grain to move. That sounds like something you’d need for designing erosion resistant surfaces on actual machinery.

Kai: They also note that inter-grain static friction isn't actually necessary to generate this bed strength anisotropy; the angular dependence of that critical force is mostly determined by the inter-grain fabric, not the overall force network among surface grains.

Mira: That’s a crucial distinction because it means you don't need a super complex stress calculation just to explain why it’s directional.

Lev: If you can calculate that minimum force based only on grain positions, that simplifies the simulation significantly when scaling up to larger systems where calculating every contact force becomes impossible.

Kai: And they also show that the change in packing fraction at the surface because of this flow is very small—at most zero point zero three in two dimensions and less than zero point zero four in three dimensions when you are near the critical Shields number.

Mira: That suggests the bulk structure doesn't drastically rearrange itself under these subcritical conditions, just the surface grains react directionally.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap this up, this paper on "Effect of subcritical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength" shows that directional strength is governed by which grains can be pushed out by the fluid in a given direction and that this effect fades quickly once you pass the critical Shields number.

Mira: It really hammers home that for these subcritical flows, the local grain arrangement dictates whether the bed strengthens or weakens in a certain direction.

Lev: And from my side, what’s important is that this helps us understand how to model things on real hardware; knowing that we can use just grain positions to find the critical force simplifies designing systems where we need precise control over surface dynamics.

Kai: It opens up a way to predict erosion onset by looking at the fraction of mobile grains, which gives us a concrete number for when that directional strength really breaks down.

Mira: It’s an interesting piece because it shows that even in simple granular systems, the underlying fabric dictates the macroscopic response under fluid shear. We can't help but wonder what happens when we move to more complex flows or non spherical grains, which they suggest is a good direction for future work.

Lev: I think probing those non spherical grains and the interaction with entrained grains when we are near the critical Shields number might reveal where inter-grain forces start playing a bigger role.

Kai: Yeah, so that’s what we’re looking at next. We’ll take a quick break and come back to more papers on arXiv shortly.

Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yale University · Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University · Benjamin Levich Institute and Physics Department, The City College of New York

cond-mat.soft

Submitted: 2026-04-16

Updated: 2026-11-12

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 11, 114304 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/2rpg-z6pt

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: Effect of sub-critical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength is investigated using discrete element method (DEM) simulations to elucidate grain-scale mechanisms controlling directional…

Key concepts

Discrete Element Method (DEM)
DEM is a simulation technique used to model granular materials. It treats each individual grain as a separate element that interacts with its neighbors through forces like friction. This allows researchers to observe how the entire granular bed responds to fluid shear flows at the level of individual grains.
Shields Number ($\Theta$)
The Shields number is a dimensionless parameter used to predict whether a fluid flow is strong enough to erode or move a granular bed. In this study, it sets the finite time scale over which the observed directional strength anisotropy in the bed persists before being washed away by the fluid.
Minimum Force to Dislodge Grain ($F_{g,c}$)
This is a calculated force required to dislodge a single surface grain from its neighbors. The study showed that this critical force can be determined using only the grain positions and friction coefficients, proving that the inter-grain fabric, not the overall stress network, dictates the bed's directional strength.

Terminology

Summary

Effect of sub-critical fluid shear flow on granular bed strength is investigated using discrete element method (DEM) simulations to elucidate grain-scale mechanisms controlling directional strengthening and weakening in granular beds under sub-critical fluid shear flows The research shows that the strength of a granular bed in a particular direction is highly correlated with the fraction of surface grains that can be dislodged by a fluid force applied in that direction This anisotropic bed strength only persists over a finite time scale set by the Shields number. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Instead, we find that the strength of a granular bed in a particular direction is highly correlated with the fraction of surface grains that can be dislodged by a fluid force applied in that direction. Further, the anisotropic bed strength only persists over a finite time scale that is set by the Shields number.

Simulation Methodology

The study employs discrete element method (DEM) simulations of granular beds subjected to model fluid flows in both two (2D) and three (3D) dimensions The granular bed consists of N grains modeled as soft, frictional disks, with mixtures of half large and half small grains used to inhibit crystallization. Inter-grain friction is implemented using the Cundall-Strack (CS) model, which defines pairwise normal force and tangential force between overlapping grains. p. 2

Where the paper says it

For the CS friction model, the pairwise normal force on grain i from j due to overlapping grains i and j is F⃗ n ij = K(σij − rij )θ(σij − rij )ˆrij , (1) where K is the spring constant, rij is the separation between the centers of grains i and j, σij is the sum of the radii of grains i and j, and ˆrij is the unit vector that points from grain j to i, and θ(·) is the Heaviside step function that ensures that only repulsive forces are nonzero for rij < σij and F n ij = 0 for rij ≥ σij . For the CS model, the tangential force on grain i arising from j is F⃗ t ij = min(µF n ij , Ktζij )tˆij , (2) where min(A, B) selects the minimum of A and B, Kt = K/3 is the spring constant of the tangential spring, ζij is the spring elongation in the tangential direction that occurs during the contact between grains i and j, and tˆij is the direction of the tangential displacement with ˆrij · tˆij = 0.

A coarse-grained fluid model is used to predict the critical Shields number to erode granular beds as a function of the shear Reynolds number. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We also include a dissipative force on grain i from colliding with grain j: F⃗ d ij = γv mimj mi + mj ((⃗vi − ⃗vj ) · rˆij ) ˆrij , (4) where γv = −2 ln(en/tc) is the dissipation rate, en is the coefficient of restitution, tc = π p mimj/(mi + mj )/K is the grain-grain collision time scale, and mi and mj are the masses of grains i and j. We use a coarse-grained fluid model that can accurately predict the critical Shields number to erode granular beds as a function of the shear Reynolds number [29].

Directional Strength Dependence

The mean surface grain speed ⟨ug⟩ depends on the direction of the conditioning fluid velocity for subcritical Shields number 1 >∼ Θp/Θc>∼ 0.6 In 2D, ⟨ug⟩ is larger (smaller) at α = 180◦ (0◦) for the conditioned beds compared to the control for a small averaging time window, e. p. 5

Where the paper says it

To better compare the bed strength at different values of α, we calculate the time-averaged mean grain speed ⟨ug⟩. We find that ⟨ug⟩ is larger (smaller) at α = 180◦ (0◦ ) for the conditioned beds compared to the control for a small averaging time window, e.

g., Tw <∼ 104 In 3D, ⟨ug⟩ increases monotonically with α for 0◦ ≤ α ≤ 180◦ at small Tw as shown in Fig. p. 5
Where the paper says it

We find similar results for bed strength anisotropy in 3D in Fig. In 3D, ⟨ug⟩ increases monotonically with α for 0◦ ≤ α ≤ 180◦ at small Tw as shown in Fig.

3 (e). Anisotropy in bed strength also diminishes with increasing Θ/Θc near and above the critical Shields number. p. 5
Where the paper says it

As illustrated in Appendix B, ⟨ug⟩ for Tw <∼ 2 × 104 displays bed strength anisotropy, whereas at longer timescales ⟨ug⟩ for the granular beds reach a steady-state independent of α. Anisotropy in bed strength (especially weakening in 2D) also diminishes with increasing Θ/Θc near and above the critical Shields number as shown in Fig.

Grain-Scale Control of Strength

The mean grain speed ⟨ug⟩ is controlled by the fraction of highly mobile surface grains, which can be determined by the minimum force Fg,c to dislodge each surface grain individually when all others are held fixed Inter-grain static friction promotes bed strength anisotropy, but it is not required for nonzero bed strength anisotropy. The angular dependence of Fg,c is largely determined by the inter-grain fabric, not the inter-grain force network among surface grains. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Further, we find that inter-grain static friction promotes bed strength anisotropy, but it is not required for nonzero bed strength anisotropy. Finally, we demonstrate that the angular dependence of Fg,c is largely determined by the inter-grain fabric, not the inter-grain force network, among surface grains.

Structural Changes and Compaction

The change in the average packing fraction at the surface of granular beds due to conditioning fluid flows is negligible The conditioning flows cause minimal compaction, with ∆⟨ϕ⟩ 0.03 at Θp/Θc ∼ 1 in 2D and ∆⟨ϕ⟩ <∼ 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(a) Mean grain velocity normalized by the fluid speed at the bed surface, ug/vf,0, plotted versus time t for the control and conditioned beds at α = 0◦ and 180◦ in 2D. The conditioning flow is set to Θp/Θc = 0.

004 at Θp/Θc ∼ 1 for all µ studied in 3D. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In 3D, we find that |∆ ⟨ϕ⟩ | <∼ 0. 004 at Θp/Θc ∼ 1 for all µ studied.

The fraction of mobile surface grains M(Θ) is highly correlated with ⟨ug⟩, suggesting that the critical Shields number Θg,c to dislodge a surface grain can be used to explain the bed strength anisotropy. p. 1
Where the paper says it

IV, we summarize the conclusions and propose promising directions for future research, such as designing protocols to create granular beds with maximum strength anisotropy. We also include five Appendices that describe the calculation of the critical Shields number to erode granular beds, the choice of the time window used for averaging the average grain speed, the magnitude of compaction of granular beds during the conditioning flows, differences in the structural properties of differently sedimented beds, and the derivation of an analytical expression for the minimum force required to dislodge a surface grain from the granular bed.

Fabric and Force Network

The minimum force Fg,c to dislodge a surface grain can be calculated using only the grain positions, regardless of the mechanical loading at the grain contacts This emphasizes that for the granular beds studied herein, the inter-grain fabric, not the inter-grain stress, controls bed strength anisotropy. The excellent agreement between Fg,c from MD simulations over a wide range of µ and the analytical expressions in Eqs. p. 6

Where the paper says it

We next investigate how the conditioning fluid flows affect M(Θ). 6 (a), we show that M(Θ) for conditioned beds is larger (smaller) than that for the control bed for α = 180◦ (0◦ ) over a wide range of Θ/Θc after a granular bed with µ = 1 has been conditioned with Θp/Θc = 0.

9 and 10 in 2D and 3D highlights that the normal and tangential contact forces do not play a significant role in determining Fg,c. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For the CS friction model, the pairwise normal force on grain i from j due to overlapping grains i and j is F⃗ n ij = K(σij − rij )θ(σij − rij )ˆrij , (1) where K is the spring constant, rij is the separation between the centers of grains i and j, σij is the sum of the radii of grains i and j, and ˆrij is the unit vector that points from grain j to i, and θ(·) is the Heaviside step function that ensures that only repulsive forces are nonzero for rij < σij and F n ij = 0 for rij ≥ σij . For the CS model, the tangential force on grain i arising from j is F⃗ t ij = min(µF n ij , Ktζij )tˆij , (2) where min(A, B) selects the minimum of A and B, Kt = K/3 is the spring constant of the tangential spring, ζij is the spring elongation in the tangential direction that occurs during the contact between grains i and j, and tˆij is the direction of the tangential displacement with ˆrij · tˆij = 0.

Future Directions

Future research should probe grain-scale mechanisms that determine the strength of granular beds Questions for turbulent fluid flows include whether fluctuations from turbulent conditioning flows promote or suppress bed strength anisotropy compared to viscous conditioning flows. Extending calculations to non-spherical grains is also suggested as a direction for future work. p. 1

Where the paper says it

However, these prior studies were not able to identify signatures in the interparticle contact networks of the bed that give rise to the increased fraction of mobile grains, which would enable predictions of anisotropic bed strength. In this work, we will elucidate the structural changes in the granular beds that are caused by the conditioning fluid flows and give rise to aniostropic bed strength via discrete element method (DEM) simulations of packings of frictional spherical grains subjected to model fluid shear flows.

Appendix A: Calculation of the Critical Shields Number Θc

The critical Shields number Θc is defined when the four stopping criteria for each of the grains are satisfied and less than 10% of the surface grains have moved more than σl.

Appendix B: Time Dependence of Fluid-driven Grain Dynamics

The total time for this initial increase and subsequent decrease such that fe → 0 is approximately Tw ∼ 104 in 2D and 5 × 104 in 3D at low Θp/Θc <∼ 0.7.

Appendix C: Compaction in Vibrated versus Unvibrated Granular Beds

The compaction caused by conditioning flows is minimal, with ∆⟨ϕ⟩ ≈ 0 for granular beds with static friction coefficients µ ≤ 0.03 for all Θp/Θc. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(a) Mean grain velocity normalized by the fluid speed at the bed surface, ug/vf,0, plotted versus time t for the control and conditioned beds at α = 0◦ and 180◦ in 2D. The conditioning flow is set to Θp/Θc = 0.

Appendix D: Effect of the Vibration Frequency on Control Bed Strength

Mdc at Θp = 0 decreases with increasing ωb, which indicates that the control bed becomes stronger with increasing vibration frequencies. The magnitude of the increase in Mac(Θp) from Θp/Θc = 0 to 1 decreases with increasing ωb. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In Appendix. D, we show that increasing the vibrational frequency ωb will reduce the variation of Mdc and the overall Mac as a function of Θp for µ = 1.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

In Appendix. D, we show that increasing the vibrational frequency ωb will reduce the variation of Mdc and the overall Mac as a function of Θp for µ = 1.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

In Appendix. D, we show that increasing the vibrational frequency ωb will reduce the variation of Mdc and the overall Mac as a function of Θp for µ = 1.

Appendix E: Derivation of Minimum Force to Dislodge a Frictionless Grain in 2D and 3D

In 2D, the critical force to dislodge grain i can be expressed as F0g,c,i = mig′ tan βij. In 3D, the minimum force required to dislodge a grain is given by Eq. p. 4

Where the paper says it

For the control and conditioned granular beds, we also calculate the minimum force Fg,c required to dislodge a single surface grain from the bed (i. move the grain by ≥ σl) given that all other grains are fixed.

10.

Appendix F: Fraction of Surface Grains Moved

The fraction fp of surface grains that have moved more than σl and the normalized mean surface grain speed ⟨ug⟩ (averaged over the final 1% of the total duration of the flow) are plotted versus the Shields number Θ in (a) 2D and (b) 3D.

Appendix G: Time Dependence of Entrained Grains

In general, fe first increases and then decreases to 0 with time t, for all µ and Θp/Θc.

Appendix H: Change in Local Packing Fraction

The maximum compaction is ∆⟨ϕ⟩ <∼ 0.008.

Appendix I: Dependence of Mdc and Mac on µ and ωb

The behavior of Mdc(Θp) and Mac(Θp) at ωb/pK/ms = 1.4 is similar to results shown in Figs. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Anisotropy in bed strength (especially weakening in 2D) also diminishes with increasing Θ/Θc near and above the critical Shields number as shown in Fig. We find similar results for bed strength anisotropy in 3D in Fig.

7 (c) and (d) for µ other than 1. The magnitude of the increase in Mac(Θp) from Θp/Θc = 0 to 1 decreases with increasing ωb.

Appendix J: Derivation of Minimum Force to Dislodge a Frictionless Grain

In 2D, the force balance equations E1 and E2 enforce that Fg,c,i ≥ F0g,c,i = mig′ tan βij. In 3D, the force balance equations E4 - E6 enforce that Fg,c,i ≥ F0g,c i = mig′ cos(∆ξki,kj) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj) − cos(∆ξij,kj) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kj) sin Ψik cos Ψij sin(∆ξg,kj - ∆ξik,kji) - sin Ψij cos Ψik sin(∆ξg,kj - ∆ξij,kji). p. 9

Where the paper says it

azimuthal ξ angles for the position vector ⃗r, as shown in Fig. We derive the following expression for F 0 g,c,i in Appendix E: F 0 g,c,i = mig ′ cos(∆ξki,kj ) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj ) − cos(∆ξij,kj ) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kj ) sin Ψik cos Ψij sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kj ) − sin Ψij cos Ψik sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj ) sin Ψij sin Ψik cos(∆ξg,kj ) , (10) where ξg is the azimuthal angle of F⃗ 0 g,c,i, Ψij and ξij are the polar and azimuthal angles of ˆrij , ∆ξg,kj = ξg −ξkj +π/2, ∆ξij,kj = ξij − ξkj + π/2, and ∆ξik,kj = ξik − ξkj + π/2.

Appendix K: Probability Distribution of Force Deviation

The probability distribution P(ΔFg,c) of the deviation ∆Fg,c = Fg,c/F0g,c − 1 is obtained from 10 independent configurations.

Appendix L: Analytical Expression for Minimum Force

The analytical expression for F0g,c i in Appendix E is derived using force balance equations E7.

Appendix M: Summary of Conclusions

The minimum force Fg,c to dislodge a surface grain can be calculated using only the grain positions, regardless of the mechanical loading at the grain contacts. The inter-grain fabric, not the force network determines the incipient strength of the bed surface. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Further, we find that inter-grain static friction promotes bed strength anisotropy, but it is not required for nonzero bed strength anisotropy. Finally, we demonstrate that the angular dependence of Fg,c is largely determined by the inter-grain fabric, not the inter-grain force network, among surface grains.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Further, we find that inter-grain static friction promotes bed strength anisotropy, but it is not required for nonzero bed strength anisotropy. Finally, we demonstrate that the angular dependence of Fg,c is largely determined by the inter-grain fabric, not the inter-grain force network, among surface grains.

Appendix N: Future Research Directions

One possible scenario is that inter-grain forces play a more important role when grains are entrained in the flow (for Θ ∼ Θc) and collide with static surface grains giving rise to momentum transfer. In many applications and in natural contexts, granular materials are composed of non-spherical grains. p. 0

Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION Much of the Earth’s surface is composed of granular materials [1] that are continually exposed to hydrodynamic and aerodynamic driving forces from water and wind. When these flows are sufficiently strong, they can dislodge individual grains, followed by groups of grains, and subsequent erosion of the bed [2–5].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION Much of the Earth’s surface is composed of granular materials [1] that are continually exposed to hydrodynamic and aerodynamic driving forces from water and wind. When these flows are sufficiently strong, they can dislodge individual grains, followed by groups of grains, and subsequent erosion of the bed [2–5].

Turbulent fluid flows include questions regarding whether fluctuations from turbulent conditioning flows promote or suppress bed strength anisotropy compared to viscous conditioning flows. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Therefore, compaction caused by the conditioning flows is minimal and we will show below that changes in the inter-grain fabric give rise to anisotropic bed strength. Grain-scale Fabric Determines Strength of Bed Surface After showing that conditioning fluid flows promote anisotropy in the granular bed strength, i.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

Therefore, compaction caused by the conditioning flows is minimal and we will show below that changes in the inter-grain fabric give rise to anisotropic bed strength. Grain-scale Fabric Determines Strength of Bed Surface After showing that conditioning fluid flows promote anisotropy in the granular bed strength, i.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

Therefore, compaction caused by the conditioning flows is minimal and we will show below that changes in the inter-grain fabric give rise to anisotropic bed strength. Grain-scale Fabric Determines Strength of Bed Surface After showing that conditioning fluid flows promote anisotropy in the granular bed strength, i.

Appendix O: Acknowledgments

We thank Dr. Abe Clark for helpful discussions We acknowledge support from the Army Research Office under Grant No. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also show that inter-particle static friction is not required for bed strength anisotropy, but varying the friction affects the magnitude of the anisotropy. This research enhances the grain-scale understanding of erosion of granular beds caused by fluid flows and underscores the importance of tracking the history of the fabric of the bed surface since it couples strongly to bed strength.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also show that inter-particle static friction is not required for bed strength anisotropy, but varying the friction affects the magnitude of the anisotropy. This research enhances the grain-scale understanding of erosion of granular beds caused by fluid flows and underscores the importance of tracking the history of the fabric of the bed surface since it couples strongly to bed strength.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also show that inter-particle static friction is not required for bed strength anisotropy, but varying the friction affects the magnitude of the anisotropy. This research enhances the grain-scale understanding of erosion of granular beds caused by fluid flows and underscores the importance of tracking the history of the fabric of the bed surface since it couples strongly to bed strength.

W911NF-23-1-0032, as well as from NSF PHY-2309135 to the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics (KITP). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Shattuck,3 and Corey S. O’Hern1, 4, 5, 6, ∗ 1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 2Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA 3Benjamin Levich Institute and Physics Department, The City College of New York, New York, New York 10031, USA 4Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 5Department of Applied Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 6Department of Materials Science, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA (Dated: April 17, 2026) Interactions between fluids and granular materials are prevalent on the Earth’s surface.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Shattuck,3 and Corey S. O’Hern1, 4, 5, 6, ∗ 1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 2Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA 3Benjamin Levich Institute and Physics Department, The City College of New York, New York, New York 10031, USA 4Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 5Department of Applied Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 6Department of Materials Science, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA (Dated: April 17, 2026) Interactions between fluids and granular materials are prevalent on the Earth’s surface.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Shattuck,3 and Corey S. O’Hern1, 4, 5, 6, ∗ 1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 2Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA 3Benjamin Levich Institute and Physics Department, The City College of New York, New York, New York 10031, USA 4Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 5Department of Applied Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA 6Department of Materials Science, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520, USA (Dated: April 17, 2026) Interactions between fluids and granular materials are prevalent on the Earth’s surface.

Appendix P: Calculation of Critical Shields Number Θc

The calculation of the critical Shields number Θc is performed by applying the fluid flow over a range of Θ at α = 0◦ for a time Td = 107.

Appendix Q: Time Dependence of Fluid-driven Grain Dynamics

The waiting Tw = 104 in 2D and Tw = 5 × 10 4 in 3D as the averaging time window size for calculating ⟨ug⟩ and other quantities of bed strength anisotropy.

Appendix R: Compaction in Vibrated versus Unvibrated Granular Beds

The change in the average packing fraction from conditioning flows is small ∆⟨ϕ⟩ < 0.008.

Appendix S: Effect of the Vibration Frequency on Control Bed Strength

Mdc at Θp = 0 decreases with increasing ωb, which indicates that the control bed becomes stronger with increasing vibration frequencies.

Appendix T: Derivation of Minimum Force to Dislodge a Frictionless Grain in 2D and 3D

The analytical expression for F0g,c i in Appendix E is derived using force balance equations E7.

Appendix U: Summary of Conclusions

The minimum force Fg,c to dislodge a surface grain can be calculated using only the grain positions, regardless of the mechanical loading at the grain contacts. The inter-grain fabric, not the force network determines the incipient strength of the bed surface.

Appendix V: Future Research Directions

One possible scenario is that inter-grain forces play a more important role when grains are entrained in the flow (for Θ ∼ Θc) and collide with static surface grains giving rise to momentum transfer. In many applications and in natural contexts, granular materials are composed of non-spherical grains. Turbulent fluid flows include questions regarding whether fluctuations from turbulent conditioning flows promote or suppress bed strength anisotropy compared to viscous conditioning flows.

Appendix W: Acknowledgments

We thank Dr. Abe Clark for helpful discussions We acknowledge support from the Army Research Office under Grant No. W911NF-23-1-0032, as well as from NSF PHY-2309135 to the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics (KITP).

Appendix X: Calculation of Critical Shields Number Θc

The calculation of the critical Shields number Θc is performed by applying the fluid flow over a range of Θ at α = 0◦ for a time Td = 107.

Appendix Y: Time Dependence of Fluid-driven Grain Dynamics

The waiting Tw = 104 in 2D and Tw = 5 × 10 4 in 3D as the averaging time window size for calculating ⟨ug⟩ and other quantities of bed strength anisotropy.

Appendix Z: Compaction in Vibrated versus Unvibrated Granular Beds

The change in the average packing fraction from conditioning flows is small ∆⟨ϕ⟩ < 0.008.

Appendix AA: Effect of the Vibration Frequency on Control Bed Strength

Mdc at Θp = 0 decreases with increasing ωb, which indicates that the control bed becomes stronger with increasing vibration frequencies. The magnitude of the increase in Mac(Θp) from Θp/Θc = 0 to 1 decreases with increasing ωb.

Appendix BB: Summary of Conclusions

The minimum force Fg,c to dislodge a surface grain can be calculated using only the grain positions, regardless of the mechanical loading at the grain contacts The inter-grain fabric, not the force network determines the incipient strength of the bed surface.

Appendix CC: Future Research Directions

One possible scenario is that inter-grain forces play a more important role when grains are entrained in the flow (for Θ ∼ Θc) and collide with static surface grains giving rise to momentum transfer In many applications and in natural contexts, granular materials are composed of non-spherical grains. Turbulent fluid flows include questions regarding whether fluctuations from turbulent conditioning flows promote or suppress bed strength anisotropy compared to viscous conditioning flows.

Appendix DD: Acknowledgments

We thank Dr. Abe Clark for helpful discussions We acknowledge support from the Army Research Office under Grant No. W911NF-23-1-0032, as well as from NSF PHY-2309135 to the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics (KITP).

Appendix EE: Derivation of Minimum Force to Dislodge a Frictionless Grain in 2D and 3D

In 2D, the force balance equations E1 and E2 enforce that Fg,c,i ≥ F0g,c i = mig′ tan βij. In 3D, the force balance equations E4 - E6 enforce that Fg,c i ≥ F0g,c i = mig′ cos(∆ξki,kj) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj) − cos(∆ξij,kj) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kji) sin Ψik cos Ψij sin(∆ξg, kj - ∆ki j). p. 9

Where the paper says it

azimuthal ξ angles for the position vector ⃗r, as shown in Fig. We derive the following expression for F 0 g,c,i in Appendix E: F 0 g,c,i = mig ′ cos(∆ξki,kj ) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj ) − cos(∆ξij,kj ) sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kj ) sin Ψik cos Ψij sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξik,kj ) − sin Ψij cos Ψik sin(∆ξg,kj − ∆ξij,kj ) sin Ψij sin Ψik cos(∆ξg,kj ) , (10) where ξg is the azimuthal angle of F⃗ 0 g,c,i, Ψij and ξij are the polar and azimuthal angles of ˆrij , ∆ξg,kj = ξg −ξkj +π/2, ∆ξij,kj = ξij − ξkj + π/2, and ∆ξik,kj = ξik − ξkj + π/2.

Appendix FF: Probability Distribution of Force Deviation

The probability distribution P(ΔFg,c) of the deviation ∆Fg,c = Fg c/F0g c − 1 is obtained from 10 independent configurations.

Appendix GG: Analytical Expression for Minimum Force

The analytical expression for F0g,c i in Appendix E is derived using force balance equations E7.

Appendix HH: Summary of Conclusions

The minimum force Fg c to dislodge a surface grain can be calculated using only the grain positions, regardless of the mechanical loading at the grain contacts The inter-grain fabric, not the force network determines the incipient strength of the bed surface.

Appendix II: Methods

We employ discrete element method (DEM) simulations of granular beds subjected to fluid shear flows using a coarse-grained model for the fluid in 2D and 3D We use the Cundall-Strack (CS) model to implement inter-grain friction with static friction coefficient µ. A coarse-grained fluid model is used that can accurately predict the critical Shields number to erode granular beds as a function of the shear Reynolds number. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We also include a dissipative force on grain i from colliding with grain j: F⃗ d ij = γv mimj mi + mj ((⃗vi − ⃗vj ) · rˆij ) ˆrij , (4) where γv = −2 ln(en/tc) is the dissipation rate, en is the coefficient of restitution, tc = π p mimj/(mi + mj )/K is the grain-grain collision time scale, and mi and mj are the masses of grains i and j. We use a coarse-grained fluid model that can accurately predict the critical Shields number to erode granular beds as a function of the shear Reynolds number [29].

Appendix III: Results

In Sec. III A, we show that the mean surface grain speed ⟨ug⟩ depends on the direction of the conditioning fluid velocity for subcritical Shields number 1 >∼ Θp/Θc>∼ 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

RESULTS In this section, we describe the main results of the DEM simulations of the anisotropic strength of fluid-driven granular beds. III A, we show that the mean surface grain speed ⟨ug⟩ depends on the direction of the conditioning fluid velocity for subcritical Shields number 1 >∼ Θp/Θc >∼ 0.

6 In Sec. III B, we show that ⟨ug⟩ is controlled by the fraction of highly mobile surface grains. p. 4
Where the paper says it

6, and that the angle dependence of ⟨ug⟩ vanishes when the timescale for the applied fluid flow diverges Tw → ∞. III B, we show that ⟨ug⟩ is controlled by the fraction of highly mobile surface grains, which can be determined by the minimum force Fg,c to dislodge each surface grain individually when all others are held fixed.

In addition, we show that inter-grain static friction is not necessary to generate bed-strength anisotropy. p. 4
Where the paper says it

We then show that the conditioning fluid flows can alter Fg,c, which causes the angular dependence of the the fraction of mobile grains and mean grain speed. In addition, we show that inter-grain static friction is not necessary to generate bed-strength anisotropy, but varying the static friction

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved simulation of granular bed strength anisotropy: The discrete element method (DEM) simulations can be used to recapitulate anisotropic strength by tracking grain-scale structural changes caused by conditioning fluid flows, specifically showing that the mean speed of the grains at the bed surface for the conditioned bed is lower (higher) in the same (opposite) direction as the conditioning flow.

  2. Grain-scale prediction of erosion onset: The system can be used to predict erosion by correlating the fraction of mobile surface grains M(Θ) with ⟨ug⟩, which suggests that the critical Shields number Θg,c to dislodge a surface grain, can be used to explain the bed strength anisotropy.

  3. Analytical calculation of critical force: A new analytical expression can be derived for the minimum force required to dislodge a grain based only on grain positions and friction coefficients, as shown in Equation 9 and 10.

Abstract

Interactions between fluids and granular materials are prevalent on the Earth's surface. In the case of fluid flow over a sediment bed, the fluid imparts a shear stress to the granular materials. When the applied shear stress is above a critical value, the grains become entrained in the fluid flow. Prior experimental studies have shown that granular beds subjected to a subcritical fluid flow can strengthen in the same direction as the subcritical flow. In contrast, granular beds can become weaker in the direction opposite to the subcritical fluid flow. To investigate the grain-scale mechanisms that control directional strengthening and weakening, we perform discrete element method (DEM) simulations of granular beds subjected to model fluid flows in two (2D) and three (3D) dimensions with varied inter-particle static friction coefficients and conditioning flow speeds. In these studies, the subcritical grain motion does not cause significant bed compaction. Instead, we find that the strength of a granular bed in a particular direction is highly correlated with the fraction of surface grains that can be dislodged by a fluid force applied in that direction. Further, the anisotropic bed strength only persists over a finite time scale that is set by the Shields number. We also show that inter-particle static friction is not required for bed strength anisotropy, but varying the friction affects the magnitude of the anisotropy. This research enhances the grain-scale understanding of erosion of granular beds caused by fluid flows and underscores the importance of tracking the history of the fabric of the bed surface since it couples strongly to bed strength.

Related papers