Energies and lifetimes of the 9p and 10p excited states in atomic francium

arXiv:2604.12467 · physics.atom-ph · Submitted 2026-04-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Energies and lifetimes of the 9p and 10p excited states in atomic francium".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium This work provides the first experimental data on the absolute wavenumbers, fine-structure splittings, and radiative lifetimes for the 9p and 10p excited states in francium The results offer a precision experimental test of relativistic coupled-cluster theory for the heaviest alkali, showing good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies despite a residual global offset in absolute energies Experimental Methodology The experimental procedure was benchmarked against previous measurements of the 8p 2P3/2 state The experimental data were obtained at the Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy (CRIS) experiment using a beam of 221Fr+ produced at the ISOLDE radioactive ion-beam facility at CERN After irradiation, 221Fr+ continued to be formed in the target as part of the decay chain of the long-lived 225Ac and 229Th Francium atoms were released by heating the target and diffused into a hot-cavity surface ionization ion source where they were ionized with near unity efficiency The ions were accelerated to 30 keV, separated by their mass-to-charge ratio in the high-resolution separator magnets HRS

20: , cooled and bunched in a gas-filled radio-frequency quadrupole linear Paul trap (ISCOOL)

21: and delivered to the experimental setup Neutralized francium atoms entered the interaction region where they were resonantly ionised via a two-step pulsed laser scheme The laser pulses for the 365–368-nm excitation needed for 7s 2S1/2 → 9p 2P1/2,3/2 were produced by a second Ti:Sa laser by internal cavity SHG The frequency of the OPO laser was determined via an internal reference calibrated on known atomic lines in francium and rubidium Theoretical Framework and Comparison The search for physics beyond the standard model is pursued at a wide range of energy scales, from the highest experimentally obtainable to ultra-high precision experiments using molecular and atomic systems Accurate knowledge of the E1 matrix elements is crucial for estimating atomic parity-violating amplitudes Previous theoretical studies of francium have shown that excitation energies and transition properties are strongly affected by relativistic and electron-correlation effects, with significant method-dependent corrections, particularly for highly excited states The RCCSDT method provides a consistent treatment of electron correlations The good agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions Results and Analysis The centroid of the 7s 2S1/2 → 8p 2P3/2 transition for 212Fr and isotope shift between 212Fr and 25657.5355(11) cm−1 is in agreement with this literature value within uncertainties The main contribution to the total uncertainty for wavenumber measurements is statistical, followed by the OPO wavenumber calibration for the 10p levels For lifetime measurements, the dominant contribution to the systematic uncertainty arises from the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy Uncertainty Assessment The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of the lifetimes of lower-lying cascade levels, which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution Fluctuations in the laser-induced ion rate also contribute to the total uncertainty The accurate reproduction of relative level spacings demonstrates that the RCCSDT method captures the essential state-dependent correlation physics in francium The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states confirms that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements Future work will include results from ongoing measurements of the higher members of the P series as well as the 6d and higher angular momentum states while a more precise determination of isotope shifts remains an important goal The agreement between experimental and theoretical lifetimes shows good agreement within uncertainties for all states, with relative deviations of 4% or less Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper presents the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium The results provide a precision experimental test of relativistic coupled-cluster theory for the heaviest alkali, showing good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies despite a residual global offset in absolute energies How the training signal is built The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq.

Kai: (10) The lifetime (in s) of the state Ψi⟩, then, is determined by τi = 1/P f Ai→f The branching ratios (BR) for each state are listed in Table III Where the gains come from The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions This agreement indicates that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements These results confirm that relativistic coupledcluster theory at the RCCSDT level provides a reliable and internally-consistent description of both the atomic energy structure and transition properties of francium The good agreement indicates that the RCCSDT method yields accurate E1 matrix elements, which can be very useful for atomic parity-violating studies using francium atoms Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The experimental procedure was benchmarked against previous measurements of the 8p 2P3/2 state The experimental data were obtained at the Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy (CRIS) experiment using a beam of 221Fr+ produced at the ISOLDE radioactive ion-beam facility at CERN The laser pulses for the 365–368-nm excitation needed for 7s 2S1/2 → 9p 2P1/2,3/2 were produced by a second Ti:Sa laser by internal cavity SHG The frequency of the OPO laser was determined via an internal reference calibrated on known atomic lines in francium and rubidium Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The centroid of the 7s 2S1/2 → 8p 2P3/2 transition for 212Fr and isotope shift between 212Fr and isotope shift between 8p and isotope shift between isotope shift are in agreement with this literature value within uncertainties The main contribution to the total uncertainty for wavenumber measurements is statistical, followed by the OPO wavenumber calibration for the 10p levels For lifetime measurements, the dominant contribution to the systematic uncertainty arises from the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions This agreement indicates that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements These results confirm that relativistic coupledcluster theory at the RCCSDT level provides a reliable and internally-consistent description of both the atomic energy structure and transition properties of francium The good agreement indicates that the RCCSDT method yields accurate E1 matrix elements, which can be very useful for atomic parity-violating studies using francium atoms Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq.

Mira: (10) The lifetime (in s) of the state Ψi⟩, then, is determined by τi = 1/P f Ai→f The branching ratios (BR) for each state are listed in Table III Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states shows good agreement within uncertainties for all states, with relative deviations of 4% or less The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq.

Paper summary: Kai: The paper starts by setting up a direct comparison to previous measurements of the eight-parallel '8p' state <ref:2604.12467#pg1>.

Mira: They describe how they got their data using a specific experimental setup called Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy, which involves firing a beam of two hundred twenty-one francium plus ions at CERN <ref:2604.12467#pg2>.

Kai: The core idea is that this combined experimental and theoretical work enables them to verify the accuracy of calculations for E one matrix elements, which are essential for atomic parity violating amplitude measurements.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if you were trying to run this on real hardware, the uncertainty in the lower lying cascade levels ends up being a systematic contribution because you have to propagate that uncertainty through the whole model.

Mira: The authors note that their RCCSDT calculations reproduce all the measured lifetimes with high accuracy, which serves as an independent validation of those theoretical wavefunctions.

Kai: They also found that the relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy despite some systematic offset in absolute binding energies from their theory.

Lev: So, it means the relativistic coupled cluster method at this level gives a reliable description of both the energy structure and how these transitions happen, even if the absolute energy scale is slightly off for now.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at this paper, "Energies and lifetimes of the 9p and 10p excited states in atomic francium," it’s really about getting concrete experimental numbers for these higher energy levels <ref:2604.12467#pg1,Energies and lifetimes of the 9p and 10p excited states in atomic>.

Mira: The implication is that by nailing these measurements—the absolute wavenumbers, the splittings, and especially those radiative lifetimes—we get a much better handle on how relativistic effects play out in heavy atoms.

Kai: It confirms that the relativistic coupled cluster theory we use is doing a good job capturing the essential state-dependent correlation physics in francium.

Lev: For someone building real hardware, this means we have a strong benchmark for what our error correction schemes need to handle when dealing with these kinds of complex atomic interactions.

Mira: The agreement between the calculated and measured lifetimes being within about four percent is quite good, especially for the states they measured.

Kai: That closeness suggests that the RCCSDT approach provides a consistent description of both the atomic energy structure and transition properties, which is very useful for things like atomic parity violating studies.

KU Leuven · Systems Department, CERN · JILA and University of Colorado · Department of Chemistry, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz · Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Manchester · Physical Research Laboratory Ahmedabad · Experimental Physics Department, CERN · Department of Physics Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge · Laboratory for Nuclear Science Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge · Institut de Physique de Nice Université Cote d’ Azur CNRS/IN2P3 IJCLab Orsay · Belgian Nuclear Research Centre SCK CEN Belgian Nuclear Research Centre

physics.atom-ph

Submitted: 2026-04-14

Updated: 2026-11-05

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 90/100

The gist: We present the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium This work provides the first experimental data on the…

Key concepts

Absolute Wavenumbers
These are the precise energy levels of an atom expressed in wavenumbers. They represent the exact energy spacing between different electronic states. Measuring these accurately helps determine the fundamental structure of francium atoms.
Radiative Lifetime
This is the average time an excited atomic state exists before it decays by emitting a photon (E1 transition). Determining lifetimes allows scientists to test theoretical models of how electrons interact and transition between energy levels.
Relativistic Coupled-Cluster Theory (RCCSDT)
This is a highly accurate quantum mechanical method used to calculate the properties of atoms, especially heavy ones like francium. It accounts for complex electron correlations and relativistic effects that are crucial for describing these atoms' behavior.

Terminology

Summary

We present the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium This work provides the first experimental data on the absolute wavenumbers, fine-structure splittings, and radiative lifetimes for the 9p and 10p excited states in francium The results offer a precision experimental test of relativistic coupled-cluster theory for the heaviest alkali, showing good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies despite a residual global offset in absolute energies

Experimental Methodology

The experimental procedure was benchmarked against previous measurements of the 8p 2P3/2 state The experimental data were obtained at the Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy (CRIS) experiment using a beam of 221Fr+ produced at the ISOLDE radioactive ion-beam facility at CERN After irradiation, 221Fr+ continued to be formed in the target as part of the decay chain of the long-lived 225Ac and 229Th Francium atoms were released by heating the target and diffused into a hot-cavity surface ionization ion source where they were ionized with near unity efficiency The ions were accelerated to 30 keV, separated by their mass-to-charge ratio in the high-resolution separator magnets HRS [20], cooled and bunched in a gas-filled radio-frequency quadrupole linear Paul trap (ISCOOL) [21] and delivered to the experimental setup Neutralized francium atoms entered the interaction region where they were resonantly ionised via a two-step pulsed laser scheme The laser pulses for the 365–368-nm excitation needed for 7s 2S1/2 → 9p 2P1/2,3/2 were produced by a second Ti:Sa laser by internal cavity SHG The frequency of the OPO laser was determined via an internal reference calibrated on known atomic lines in francium and rubidium

Theoretical Framework and Comparison

The search for physics beyond the standard model is pursued at a wide range of energy scales, from the highest experimentally obtainable to ultra-high precision experiments using molecular and atomic systems Accurate knowledge of the E1 matrix elements is crucial for estimating atomic parity-violating amplitudes Previous theoretical studies of francium have shown that excitation energies and transition properties are strongly affected by relativistic and electron-correlation effects, with significant method-dependent corrections, particularly for highly excited states The RCCSDT method provides a consistent treatment of electron correlations The good agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions

Results and Analysis

The centroid of the 7s 2S1/2 → 8p 2P3/2 transition for 212Fr and isotope shift between 212Fr and 25657.5355(11) cm−1 is in agreement with this literature value within uncertainties The main contribution to the total uncertainty for wavenumber measurements is statistical, followed by the OPO wavenumber calibration for the 10p levels For lifetime measurements, the dominant contribution to the systematic uncertainty arises from the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy

Uncertainty Assessment

The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of the lifetimes of lower-lying cascade levels, which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution Fluctuations in the laser-induced ion rate also contribute to the total uncertainty

Conclusion and Future Work

The accurate reproduction of relative level spacings demonstrates that the RCCSDT method captures the essential state-dependent correlation physics in francium The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states confirms that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements Future work will include results from ongoing measurements of the higher members of the P series as well as the 6d and higher angular momentum states while a more precise determination of isotope shifts remains an important goal The agreement between experimental and theoretical lifetimes shows good agreement within uncertainties for all states, with relative deviations of 4% or less

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper presents the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium The results provide a precision experimental test of relativistic coupled-cluster theory for the heaviest alkali, showing good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies despite a residual global offset in absolute energies

How the training signal is built

The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq. (10) The lifetime (in s) of the state Ψi⟩, then, is determined by τi = 1/P f Ai→f The branching ratios (BR) for each state are listed in Table III

Where the gains come from

The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions This agreement indicates that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements These results confirm that relativistic coupledcluster theory at the RCCSDT level provides a reliable and internally-consistent description of both the atomic energy structure and transition properties of francium The good agreement indicates that the RCCSDT method yields accurate E1 matrix elements, which can be very useful for atomic parity-violating studies using francium atoms

The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy

The experimental procedure was benchmarked against previous measurements of the 8p 2P3/2 state The experimental data were obtained at the Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy (CRIS) experiment using a beam of 221Fr+ produced at the ISOLDE radioactive ion-beam facility at CERN The laser pulses for the 365–368-nm excitation needed for 7s 2S1/2 → 9p 2P1/2,3/2 were produced by a second Ti:Sa laser by internal cavity SHG The frequency of the OPO laser was determined via an internal reference calibrated on known atomic lines in francium and rubidium

The centroid of the 7s 2S1/2 → 8p 2P3/2 transition for 212Fr and isotope shift between 212Fr and isotope shift between 8p and isotope shift between isotope shift are in agreement with this literature value within uncertainties The main contribution to the total uncertainty for wavenumber measurements is statistical, followed by the OPO wavenumber calibration for the 10p levels For lifetime measurements, the dominant contribution to the systematic uncertainty arises from the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution The RCCSDT calculations exhibit a systematic offset in absolute binding energies, but relative excitation energies are reproduced with high accuracy

The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states provides an independent and more stringent validation of the theoretical wavefunctions This agreement indicates that the RCCSDT approach yields highly-accurate E1 matrix elements These results confirm that relativistic coupledcluster theory at the RCCSDT level provides a reliable and internally-consistent description of both the atomic energy structure and transition properties of francium The good agreement indicates that the RCCSDT method yields accurate E1 matrix elements, which can be very useful for atomic parity-violating studies using francium atoms

The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq. (10) The lifetime (in s) of the state Ψi⟩, then, is determined by τi = 1/P f Ai→f The branching ratios (BR) for each state are listed in Table III

The agreement between calculated and measured lifetimes of all measured states shows good agreement within uncertainties for all states, with relative deviations of 4% or less The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution

The uncertainty analysis shows that the energy and lifetime measurements are dominated by different primary sources of uncertainty For the energy (wavenumber) measurements, the statistical uncertainty is mainly governed by the laser linewidth, which limits the resolvability of the hyperfine components The lifetime measurements are primarily limited by the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels which were propagated through the full model as a systematic contribution

The transition probability (in s−1) of an atomic state(Ψi⟩) to a lower state(Ψf⟩) due to the E1 decay channel is given by Eq.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. System calibration for relativistic coupled-cluster theory can be improved by incorporating corrections for missing higher-order correlation effects, including quadruple excitations and contributions from high-angular-momentum orbitals, which are noted as requiring more computational capacity than currently available.

  2. The AI system can perform precision tests of relativistic coupled-cluster theory by comparing calculated E1 matrix elements with experimental data on lifetimes, as the paper shows good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies, despite a residual global offset in absolute energies.

  3. The system can accurately model and predict atomic parity-violating amplitudes by utilizing the experimentally verified E1 matrix elements obtained from the RCCSDT calculations.

  4. The AI system can refine its theoretical models of francium's atomic structure by adjusting the ground state energy to match experimental values, as described in the paper: we adjusted the 7s energy so that the theoretical 7s→8p transition matches the experimental value, and all other excitation energies are then reported relative to this adjusted ground state.

  5. The system can account for systematic uncertainties in lifetime measurements by propagating the uncertainties of lower-lying cascade levels through a finite-difference approach, as detailed in equation (5) of the text.

  6. The AI system can perform uncertainty propagation for excited state lifetimes by including the systematic uncertainty from cascade feeding, defined as sigma squared taua sys equals sum j delta tau(j)a squared.

Abstract

We present the first measurement of 9p 2P1/2,3/2 and 10p 2P1/2,3/2 excited levels absolute wavenumbers and radiative lifetime in francium. We used the Collinear Resonance Ionization Spectroscopy (CRIS) technique, applied on a beam of 221Fr atoms. Prior to this work, no experimental data existed for francium p-states with n > 8. The results provide a precision experimental test of relativistic coupled-cluster theory for the heaviest alkali, showing good agreement for lifetimes and relative excitation energies, despite a residual global offset in absolute energies.

Related papers