Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings".
Title and authors: Kai: So this paper is basically showing that when you use these tessellations, you can inherit the anisotropic elastic properties of the individual granular packings directly into the larger system.
Mira: And they quantified this using two rotationally invariant, normalized quantities called AG and AC to characterize how it responds to shear and compression. Typical crystals have average values around AG equals zero point one five and AC equals zero point zero nine.
Lev: So what they found is that jammed granular materials can get elastic anisotropies that are several orders of magnitude larger than those atomic crystals, which is pretty significant for structural mechanics.
Kai: They specifically focus on tessellated granular materials to keep those strong elastic anisotropies by limiting the grain rearrangements when you apply strain.
Mira: They show that homogeneous tessellations with the same granular packing in each voxel can inherit the response of a single voxel, but deviations happen because of how that single internal vertex deforms under strain.
Lev: And they also look at heterogeneous tessellations where different voxels have different granular packings, and they found those can fluctuate significantly around the average response of the two individual granular packings.
The paper's summary: Kai: The paper points out a few ways we can tune this effect. First, homogeneous tessellations with flexible boundary vertices can increase or decrease the elastic anisotropy compared to just looking at single voxels.
Mira: They also found that heterogeneous tessellations give us more tunability than the homogeneous ones because you're mixing different granular responses in different parts of the system.
Lev: And they show that by controlling those boundary deformations, we can actually tune the elastic anisotropy, which is a key part for experimental realization.
Kai: All three tessellation types—homogeneous with fixed boundaries, heterogeneous, and homogeneous with flexible boundaries—can achieve AG and AC values significantly larger than those for crystalline solids.
Mira: Specifically they found that in periodic boundary conditions at intermediate values of pressure pN two point one have AG around one zero two and AC around one zero one.
Lev: That's about two orders of magnitude larger than the crystalline materials, which means this is a very strong result for the bulk properties they are predicting.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings" we see that making tessellations out of small granular packings yields bulk materials with large elastic anisotropy while limiting grain rearrangements.
Mira: The paper shows that in systems with periodic boundary conditions at intermediate values of pressure pN two point one, you get large AG around one zero two and AC around one zero one, which is a factor of two orders of magnitude larger than crystalline solids.
Lev: From my side, the key thing is that this result depends on whether we're using periodic boundaries or physical boundaries because the boundary conditions can change things a lot at pN two point one.
Kai: And they also mention that for experimental realization, they found challenges with creating three dee tessellations where the voxels need to be strong enough to prevent rearrangement but flexible enough so that boundary stiffness doesn't dominate <ref:2604.12098#pg1>.
Mira: They also suggested using machine learning methods to explore the large space of heterogeneous tessellations to find novel material designs by optimizing those elastic modulus tensors, which is a great direction for future work.
Lev: And experimentally, they also noted that finding coordinate invariant measures of anisotropy from measurements like Young’s modulus and shear modulus might be a way around measuring all six elements of the elastic modulus tensor.
Kai: So the paper "Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings" provides a path forward for designing materials with strong directional properties using these structured packing ideas.
Mira: It’s interesting to see how they connect the microscopic structure of grain packing to macroscopic anisotropic mechanical performance in this way.
Lev: Good stuff, and it sets a clear direction for what needs to be built next in terms of material design and testing.
Conclusion: Kai: So to recap, the paper "Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings" shows that by structuring granular materials like this, you can keep that strong directional stiffness they found in the individual grains.
Mira: Right, and they did this by using two rotationally invariant measures called AG and AC to quantify how those materials respond to shear and compression.
Lev: And the numbers are pretty striking for what's possible with granular systems, showing anisotropies up to one zero two times larger than atomic crystals.
Kai: That is a huge jump, and it really highlights how much control we can have over the material’s response if we get the structural organization right.
Mira: And they showed that this effect depends heavily on the tessellation you choose—whether you use homogeneous structures or more complex heterogeneous ones for tuning.
Lev: From my side, it would take real hardware to measure those anisotropic elastic properties accurately and see if those AG and AC values hold up in practice.
Kai: It means we can start designing metamaterials with highly specific directional stiffness, which is crucial for things like acoustic cloaking or impact absorption.
Mira: And they even suggested using machine learning, like genetic algorithms, to search through the massive space of heterogeneous tessellations to find the best designs for the elastic modulus tensor.
Lev: That optimization would be necessary because designing those complex three dee structures experimentally is still a real hurdle right now.
Kai: True, building three dee voxels that are strong enough not to rearrange but flexible enough to let boundary deformations happen is still a major experimental challenge in the lab.
Mira: But the theoretical framework they gave for how AG and AC relate to the elastic modulus tensor elements, like GDC and BDC being linear functions of Cmn, is a very useful analytical tool.
Lev: It helps us predict what would happen on real devices without having to run simulations for every single configuration.
Kai: So, "Preserving elastic anisotropy with tessellations of granular packings" gives us a strong theoretical basis for designing next-generation materials with tailored mechanical properties.
Mira: And the next thing we should be watching is how this structural control interacts with other effects, like those in neural networks and emergent magnetism.
Lev: We’ll be looking at how these structured materials behave when you introduce external fields or try to implement them in devices that need robust error correction.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yale University · Integrated Graduate Program in Physical and Engineering Biology, Yale University Department of Physics, University of Michigan Department of Applied Physics, The City College of The City University of New York
cond-mat.soft
Submitted: 2026-04-13
Updated: 2026-04-13
Comments: 10 pages, 5 figures
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E. 114, 025404 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/tst4-36lr
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 81/100
The gist: Multiscale periodic metamaterials have been designed for numerous applications, such as impact absorption, acoustic cloaking, photonic band gaps, and mechanical logic gates.
Key concepts
- AG and AC
- These are normalized quantities that quantify the anisotropic response of a material to shear and compression. Crystalline solids have low values, but granular materials can achieve much higher values when structured correctly.
- Tessellation Modalities
- The paper investigates three ways to arrange voxels: homogeneous (same packing everywhere), heterogeneous (different packings in different voxels), and homogeneous with flexible boundaries. Each modality is shown to preserve or enhance the high elastic anisotropy of the underlying granular packings.
- Elastic Modulus Tensor (Cmn)
- This 6x6 matrix mathematically describes how a material deforms under stress. The authors use this tensor to analytically derive formulas for AG and AC, showing how structural organization dictates the material's overall anisotropic behavior.
Terminology
Summary
Multiscale periodic metamaterials have been designed for numerous applications, such as impact absorption, acoustic cloaking, photonic band gaps, and mechanical logic gates. p. 0 The paper seeks to develop materials with highly anisotropic elastic properties. p. 0
Introduction to Anisotropy Quantification
The authors introduce two rotationally invariant, normalized quantities that characterize the anisotropic response to shear and compression, AG and AC. Typical crystalline solids possess average elastic anisotropy AG ≈ 0. p. 015 and AC ≈ 0.09. Jammed granular materials can attain elastic anisotropies that are several orders of magnitude larger compared to atomic crystals. p. 0 The study focuses on tessellated granular materials to preserve strong elastic anisotropy by limiting grain rearrangements. p. 0
Characterization of Granular Packings
The authors show that bulk granular packings with N grains prepared at pressure p have maximal anisotropy for pN2 ∼ 1 and become isotropic in the large pN2 limit. Homogeneously tessellated granular systems can inherit the elastic response of the constituent voxel configurations with elastic anisotropy up to 100 times that of crystalline compounds over a range of pN2. p. 0 They further show methods to tune the elastic anisotropy by designing heterogeneously patterned voxel configurations and tessellations that allow large boundary deformations. p. 0
Role of Tessellation in Elastic Response
The investigation into tessellated granular materials reveals several key findings regarding structural organization.
** Homogeneous tessellations with the same granular packing in each voxel can inherit the elastic response of the single voxel. p. 7 Deviations from single voxel values occur due to deformation of the single internal vertex in response to applied strain. p. 7 The authors demonstrate that homogeneous tessellations can harness the anisotropy of granular packings in single voxels to yield large systems with large elastic anisotropy. p. 7 **
** Heterogeneous tessellations, where the voxels include two different granular packings, possess an elastic anisotropy that can fluctuate significantly around the average response of the two individual granular packings. p. 7 These heterogeneous tessellations offer more tunability than homogeneous tesselations. p. 7 **
** For a homogeneous tessellation with flexible boundary vertices, boundary deformations can increase (or decrease) the elastic anisotropy compared to that for single voxels. p. 9 All three tessellation modalities can attain AG and AC that are significantly larger than the values for crystalline solids. p. 8 **
Conclusion and Future Directions
The work demonstrates that making tessellations of small granular packings yields bulk granular materials with large elastic anisotropy while limiting grain rearrangements. Granular packings in systems with periodic boundary conditions at intermediate values of pN2 ∼ 1 possess large values of AG ∼ 102 and AC ∼ 101 around two orders of magnitude larger than that for crystalline solids. p. 9 In the large pN2 limit, granular packings in periodic boundary conditions become isotropic and have comparable anisotropy to that of crystalline solids. p. 9 Future research directions include employing machine learning methods to explore the large space of heterogeneous tessellations to maximize anisotropic elastic properties. p. 1 Additionally, challenges remain in creating 3D tessellations experimentally, requiring boundaries that are both strong and flexible. p. 9 The paper also suggests finding coordinate invariant measures of anisotropy from experimentally tractable measurements of the Young’s modulus and shear modulus. p. 9
Analytical Framework for Anisotropy
The authors provide analytical expressions for AG and AC in terms of the elements of the elastic modulus tensor Cmn for an arbitrary triclinic material. These formulas are derived from analytical evaluation of the integrals in Eqs. p. 1 13 and 14 using the tensor manipulation package OGRe in Mathematica. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The expressions for GDC and BDC are linear functions of Cmn, while GAC and UAC are quadratic functions of Cmn. p. 9
Boundary Condition Influence
The study confirms that the physical boundary conditions do not significantly impact the elastic anisotropy of the granular packings at pN2 values considered. Granular packings with physical boundaries attain maximum AC ∼ 101 and AG ∼ 102 at pN2 ∼ 1. p. 6 The range of AC and AG is not significantly changed by either the shape of the boundary for FIX boundary conditions or the ability to deform for FLEX boundary conditions. p. 6
Elastic Modulus Calculation
The elastic modulus tensor Cmn is calculated by applying affine simple shear strain steps to both the grains and boundary vertices, followed by minimization of the total potential energy. The stress tensor Σn is then obtained using the virial expression in Eq. p. 3 7 after each strain increment to obtain the elastic modulus by evaluating the slope Cmn = dΣn/dγm. p. 3
Grain Packing Protocol
Jamming granular packings is generated by first randomly placing grains at a dilute packing fraction of ϕ < 0.01 and then growing them in small packing fraction increments using the Fast Inertial Relaxation Engine (FIRE) method until the maximum force on both the grains and boundary vertices satisfies maxi(⃗fi, ⃗f b i) ≤ 10−14. p. 3 The system is grown and shrunk until the pressure satisfies p − pt /pt < 10−3, where pt is the target pressure. p. 3
Elastic Modulus Tensor Definition
The elastic modulus tensor Cmn is a 6 × 6 symmetric matrix in Voigt notation, where n and m range from 1 to 6 corresponding to the elementary strains. The map from Cartesian indices ij to the Voigt index n is explicitly defined as (xx corresponds to 1, yy to 2, zz to 3, yz to 4, xz to 5, and xy to 6). p. 3
Strain Definitions
The six elementary strains γn correspond to the three compressive strains and three shear strains. For a simple shear deformation in the x-y plane, the strain tensor is defined by Γ6 = [0 γxy 0; 0 0 0; 0 0 0]. p. 3 The strains are applied to the grain and boundary vertex positions as⃗rγi =⃗ri (Γ + I) and ⃗bγi = ⃗bi (Γ + I). p. 3
Coordinate Invariant Measures
Another coordinate-invariant measure of anisotropy is the universal anisotropy index AU, which can be written in terms of the ratios GDC (C)/GDC (S) and UDC (C)/UDC (S). The authors show that AU behaves qualitatively similarly to AG and AC since AU contains information about both shear and compressive anisotropy. p. 4
Analytical Formulas for Anisotropy
The formulas for GAC, GDC, UAC, and BDC are provided in Appendix F. These expressions were obtained from analytical evaluation of the integrals in Eqs. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 13 and 14 using the tensor manipulation package OGRe in Mathematica. The authors note that GDC and BDC are linear functions of Cmn, while GAC and UAC are quadratic functions of Cmn. p. 7 p. 7 p. 7
Elastic Modulus Tensor Elements
The analytical expressions for AG and AC for an arbitrary triclinic material in terms of elements of the elastic modulus tensor Cmn are provided in Appendix F. The authors note that orientation averages can be evaluated on the elastic modulus tensor Cmn (Voigt average) or the compliance tensor Smn = (C−1)mn (Reuss average). p. 4
Mechanical Stability Analysis
The mechanical stability of randomly generated elastic modulus tensors is analyzed by comparing results when an extra stability condition mini ci > 0 is and is not satisfied. The authors find that it is possible to attain large elastic anisotropy independent of the sign of λi. p. 6 In contrast, for randomly generated elastic modulus tensors, only the regions with large anisotropy AG ≥ 100 and AC ≥ 10−1 are associated with C with unstable eigenvalues. p. 4 p. 4
Crystalline Spring Networks
The elastic anisotropy for crystalline spring networks is comparable to the values obtained from DFT calculations, indicating that the small values of elastic anisotropy arise from structural symmetry, independent of the interatomic potential. Crystalline spring networks exhibit constant AG and AC for all values of p. p. 6
Experimental Challenges
Challenges exist for creating 3D tessellations in experiments, requiring boundaries that are both strong and flexible. Furthermore, experimentally measuring all elements of the elastic modulus tensor is challenging. p. 9 Existing methods can be sensitive to sample geometry and require large signal to noise ratios when applied to low symmetry materials such as granular packings. p. 9 The authors suggest finding coordinate invariant measures of anisotropy from experimentally tractable measurements of the Young’s modulus and shear modulus. p. 9
Machine Learning Potential
Genetic algorithms have been implemented to efficiently explore the large space of configurations and find novel material designs in the context of granular metamaterials, solid state materials, and mechanical metamaterials. This approach will be very useful in the context of designing heterogeneous tessellations, allowing optimization of desired elastic modulus tensor Cmn. p. 9 Genetic algorithms can also explore doubly heterogeneous tessellations, i. p. 9e., tessellations that contain voxels with different shapes and sizes. p. 9
Experimental Realization Hurdles
While experimental realizations of tessellated granular materials have been realized in 2D, many challenges exist for creating 3D tessellations in experiments. A key challenge is ensuring voxels have a boundary strong enough to prevent rearrangement but flexible enough so that the boundary stiffness does not dominate the grains contribution to the total elastic response. p. 9 Experimental 3D voxels must also be shapes that can fill space, and out of plane boundary buckling modes must be suppressed or strongly coupled to neighboring voxels. p. 9
Tessellation Modalities Summary
All three tessellation modalities—homogeneous with boundary constraints, heterogeneous, and homogeneous with flexible boundaries—can attain AG and AC that are significantly larger than the values for crystalline solids. In general, tessellations of granular packings can preserve the large elastic anisotropy of the constituent granular packings. p. 9 The authors find that in many cases, they can enhance the elastic anisotropy of individual voxels by adding a heterogeneous collection of grain packings and boundary flexibility. p. 9
Final Anisotropy Values
For all three tessellation modalities, the authors obtain large elastic anisotropies up to AG ∼ 102 and AC ∼ 101, which are two orders of magnitude larger than the elastic anisotropies for crystalline materials. The paper concludes that these methods can preserve the large elastic anisotropy of the constituent granular packings. p. 9 p. 9
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge support from NSF Grant No. DMREF 2118988. This work was also supported by the High Performance Computing facilities operated by Yale’s Center for Research Computing. p. 0
Appendix Details
Appendix A details the flexible boundary potential in terms of boundary vertex positions. Appendix B specifies the six strain tensors required to calculate Cmn in Voigt notation. p. 1 Appendix C discusses other measures of elastic anisotropy and shows that another commonly used measure AU is similar to AG and AC. p. 1 Appendix D details the construction of the linear spring networks derived from crystalline compounds. p. 1 Appendix E describes the protocol to generate random elastic modulus tensors Cmn with varying symmetry strength and compare their mechanical stability to that of granular packings. p. 1 Appendix F provides analytical expressions for the elements of Cmn that define AC and AG. p. 1 The paper includes six appendices in total. p. 1
Figure Descriptions
Figure 1 illustrates types of fixed boundary conditions (FIX) and flexible boundary conditions (FLEX) for granular packings. Figure 3 shows the shear and compressive anisotropy Atess C and Atess G plotted versus the single voxel anisotropy Avox C and Avox G for homogeneous tessellations. p. 7 Figure 5 illustrates how heterogeneous tessellations compare their shear and compressive anisotropy A tess G and A tess C plotted versus the average shear and compressive anisotropy of the two granular packings in the single voxels. p. 8 Figure 6 plots AG versus AU for granular packings in periodic boundary conditions and atomic crystals from a large database of crystalline materials. p. 5
Elastic Modulus Tensor Elements (Analytical)
The analytical formulas for GDC and BDC are linear functions of Cmn, while GAC and UAC are quadratic functions of Cmn. These expressions were obtained from analytical evaluation of the integrals in Eqs. 13 and 14 using the tensor manipulation package OGRe in Mathematica. The authors note that GDC and BDC are linear functions of Cmn, while GAC and UAC are quadratic functions of Cmn.
Final Anisotropy Formulas
The formulas for AG and AC for an arbitrary triclinic material in terms of elements of the elastic modulus tensor Cmn are provided in Appendix F. These expressions were obtained from analytical evaluation of the integrals in Eqs. 13 and 14 using the tensor manipulation package OGRe in Mathematica. The authors note that GDC and BDC are linear functions of Cmn, while GAC and UAC are quadratic functions of Cmn.
Comparison with Random Tensors
The probability distribution P(AC, AG) ≥ P0 for randomly generated elastic modulus tensors in Fig. 2 (a) over a range of δ from δ = 10−5 (purple) to 105 (yellow). p. 6 Although increasing symmetry tends to lower both the compressive and shear anisotropy, it is possible to obtain large values of anisotropy in a strongly cubic systems. p. 6 In contrast, for randomly generated elastic modulus tensors, only the regions with large anisotropy AG ≥ 100 and AC ≥ 10−1 are associated with C with unstable eigenvalues. The probability boundary is smoothed with a Savitzky-Golay filter of order 2 and window size 9. p. 4
Crystalline Spring Network Stability
The crystalline spring networks exhibit constant AG and AC for all values of p. p. 6 Crystalline spring networks do not rearrange with increasing pressure, which is the primary mechanism for decreases in anisotropy in granular packings with increasing pN2. p. 4 The crystalline spring networks exhibit constant AG and AC for all values of p.
Final Summary Statement
For all three tessellation modalities, the authors obtain large elastic anisotropies up to AG ∼ 102 and AC ∼ 101, which are two orders of magnitude larger than the elastic anisotropies for crystalline materials. The paper concludes that these methods can preserve the large elastic anisotropy of the constituent granular packings. The paper raises several interesting directions for future research. p. 9
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
1
The improved AI system can design materials with directionally targeted elastic properties by leveraging tessellations of granular packings to preserve strong elastic anisotropy. The system can calculate shear anisotropy AG and compressive anisotropy AC for these materials, finding that tessellated granular materials minimize grain rearrangements, which preserves the large elastic anisotropy of granular packings with AC and AC up to 102 times larger than the values for atomic crystals.
2
The AI can tune the elastic anisotropy of tessellations by designing heterogeneously patterned voxel configurations and tessellations that allow large boundary deformations. This allows for tuning the elastic anisotropy of tessellations by designing heterogeneously patterned voxel configurations and tessellations that allow large boundary deformations.
3
The improved system can optimize desired elastic modulus tensor Cmn using genetic algorithms to find novel material designs. This approach will be useful in the context of designing heterogeneous tessellations, allowing optimization of desired elastic modulus tensor Cmn.
Related papers
- Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles
- Three-body corrections to the Brownian viscosity of hard spheres without hydrodynamic interactions
- Thin active nematohydrodynamic layers: asymptotic theories and instabilities
- Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid
- Soft material mechanical property degradation at high strain rates
- Avalanche criticality emerges by thermal fluctuation in a quiescent glass