Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions introduces a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed flow v1 and elliptic flow v2 in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction.
Kai: This technique is validated with PHSD model simulations of Au+Au collisions at √sNN = 9.2 GeV at freeze-out (impact parameter b = 4 − 8 fm).
Mira: The method demonstrates that the two asymmetries for each harmonic contribute equally, i.e., ⟨A2ud⟩ ≈ ⟨A2lr⟩ and ⟨A21⟩ ≈ ⟨A22⟩, so that a single asymmetry measurement suffices for a good flow estimate.
Kai: Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0.956 for v2 and 0.834 for v1, confirming that the no-RP method captures flow fluctuations well enough.
Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at the paper "Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions" from Dlin and Teryaev. They’ve introduced a method to figure out directed flow v1 and elliptic flow v2 without needing that reaction plane reconstruction we usually have to do.
Mira: Right, so it’s about finding those flows directly from particle measurements instead of reconstructing the event plane first. It seems like they tackle a real headache in heavy-ion collisions where you need those flows to understand what's happening in the early stages of the quark-gluon plasma.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, eliminating that reconstruction step is a big win because it simplifies things for real hardware. We don't want to spend precious time or computational power figuring out the plane when we could be focused on building better detectors or running more events.
Kai: Exactly. The core idea they propose is using a no-reaction-plane method, and they validate this with PHSD model simulations of Au plus Au collisions at five point nine two GeV at freeze out, for impact parameters between four and eight femtometers <ref:2604.10620#pg1>.
Mira: And the key finding there is that the two asymmetries for each harmonic contribute equally, meaning they have this symmetry where the directed flow asymmetry Aud is about as good as Alr, and similarly for the elliptic flow components <ref:2604.10620#pg1>.
Lev: If that’s true, it means they only need to measure one asymmetry to get a reliable estimate of the flow coefficient, which sounds way more practical than needing four separate measurements per event.
Kai: That’s what they show by comparing their no-RP estimators with direct calculations using the true reaction plane angles from the particles themselves <ref:2604.10620#pg1>. The Pearson correlation coefficients they report are zero point nine five six for v two and zero point eight three four for v one, which is pretty strong validation.
Mira: That correlation of zero point nine five six for the elliptic flow measurement sounds very promising because it suggests the method captures those event-by-event fluctuations quite well, even when estimating v2 <ref:2604.10620#pg6>.
Lev: And for v one, zero point eight three four is decent, but we need to keep in mind that this is still a model comparison against direct calculation using the true plane, so the real overhead on hardware would be seeing how much computational time it takes to perform that full scan over the test angle psi <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Kai: The paper then moves into how they actually do this event-by-event estimation using a test angle psi, scanning it from zero up to pi <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. They define the no-RP estimators as v one and v two depending on averages over that psi <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Mira: So, the method essentially uses a test angle ψ to sample all possible reaction plane orientations within a single event, which is supposed to mimic averaging over the true reaction plane <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. It’s an alternative way to get event-by-event flow values without doing any reconstruction <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Lev: The mathematical expressions they use for v one and v two involve sums over the asymmetries Aud and Alr, averaged over that test angle psi <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. For real hardware, the challenge will be implementing that full scan efficiently across millions of events <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Kai: The results show that when you average over psi, the distributions for those asymmetries cluster tightly around zero point five for both ratios <ref:2604.10620#pg5>. That means each asymmetry really does contribute equally to the total sum you are trying to estimate <ref:2604.10620#pg8>.
Mira: That equality is what simplifies things, because it leads them to conclude that a single asymmetry measurement is sufficient for a good flow estimate <ref:2604.10620#pg8>. This is the big simplification for experimentalists trying to measure these flows <ref:2604.10620#pg8>.
Lev: If we accept that the distributions cluster around zero point five, then the scaling they show suggests you can get v one by taking two to the k times the average of those asymmetries, which is a direct calculation using only one measured asymmetry <ref:2604.10620#pg1>.
Kai: That scaling idea is interesting because it means you don't need separate measurements for v one and v two if you use that single asymmetry to calculate both <ref:2604.10620#pg4>. It makes the measurement simpler, which is always good for data collection.
Mira: But we have to remember they are still using the same underlying physics, so we can't just treat it as a magic trick; it’s because of those equal contributions that the method works <ref:2604.10620#pg8>. This approach is fundamentally about exploiting symmetries in the flow harmonics themselves.
Lev: And for real hardware, if you are trying to run this on a detector, you need to ensure your readout noise doesn't wash out those subtle fluctuations they are measuring <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. That is a practical constraint that the simulation doesn't fully capture.
Kai: So, to wrap up the core idea of "Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions," they’re giving us a way to extract directed and elliptic flow without needing the complex event-plane reconstruction, relying on scanning a test angle psi <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Mira: And the validation shows that this no-RP method produces results that are very close to direct calculations, with those high Pearson correlations of zero point nine five six for v two and zero point eight three four for v one <ref:2604.10620#pg6>.
Lev: For us, the implication is that if we can implement this test angle scanning efficiently on our real systems, we gain a powerful tool to extract these flow coefficients with reduced overhead <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Kai: So it boils down to this: one asymmetry measurement can suffice for a good estimate of the flow coefficient because the contributions from different harmonic components balance out <ref:2604.10620#pg8>. It’s a significant simplification for experimental design.
Mira: And while it’s not magic, the way they use that test angle scanning to sample the distribution seems like a clever way to bypass the need for explicit event-plane reconstruction <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. We should keep an eye on how this scales with higher harmonics, like v four and v five <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Lev: Higher harmonics are where the physics gets messy, and if the scaling they show holds up when we move to real data, it means we can use these methods to probe those smaller components more reliably <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
Kai: So, moving forward with this paper, the focus is on using this no-RP technique as a powerful and simpler alternative for flow measurements in heavy-ion collisions <ref:2604.10620#pg1>. It’s a method that bypasses one of the most labor-intensive parts of the analysis.
Mira: And overall, what this paper suggests is that exploiting inherent symmetries in how these asymmetries contribute to the flow harmonics lets us extract the physics with less experimental overhead <ref:2604.10620#pg8>. It's a solid approach for making flow measurements more accessible experimentally.
Lev: So, for our work on error correction, this suggests that if we can measure these asymmetries reliably using this method, the required error budget for extracting the flow coefficients might be manageable <ref:2604.10620#pg3>. It gives us a target to aim for in terms of measurement precision.
Kai: Yeah, it’s a powerful alternative approach, and we should definitely keep an eye on how this no-RP method performs when we move beyond the simulation validation at five point nine two GeV <ref:2604.10620#pg1>.
Mira: It’s certainly a paper that provides a clear experimental path forward for extracting v one and v two without the need for full event plane reconstruction <ref:2604.10620#pg8>.
Lev: We'll be watching how these scaling laws hold up when we get onto actual data, because that’s where the real engineering challenge is <ref:2604.10620#pg3>.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we're looking at the summary of this paper on anisotropic flows in heavy-ion collisions and what they actually claim is possible.
Mira: Basically, they’ve developed a method called no reaction plane flow estimation that lets you find directed flow v one and elliptic flow v two without having to reconstruct the event plane first.
Lev: So, instead of tracking the detector's orientation, you just use particle information to estimate those flows directly from the hits.
Kai: Right, and they validate this by running simulations with a model called PHSD for Au plus Au collisions at five point nine two GeV at freeze out.
Mira: And their main finding there is that the two different asymmetries they calculate for each flow component actually contribute equally to the final result.
Lev: That means instead of needing four different measurements per event, you only need one asymmetry measurement to get a good estimate of both v one and v two.
Kai: It’s about this symmetry, where the directed flow asymmetry Aud is roughly equal to the Alr, and similarly for the elliptic components.
Mira: And that equality simplifies things a lot because it means you can use just one measurement to get a reliable estimate of the flow coefficient.
Lev: But they also show how they can extend this to event by event measurements using something called a test angle psi, which they scan all the way from zero up to pi.
Kai: So, that test angle scanning lets them create estimates for v one and v two on an event by event basis without needing that whole reaction plane reconstruction thing.
Mira: And when they do those calculations, the results cluster tightly around a value of zero point five for both ratios they are comparing.
Lev: That clustering around zero point five is what tells them each asymmetry contributes equally to the total sum they are trying to estimate.
Kai: So, the implication is that a single measurement can give you a good flow estimate because these components balance out in terms of their contribution.
Mira: They also show some correlation numbers when comparing their no reaction plane method against direct calculations that use the true event planes from the particles themselves.
Lev: For v two, they get zero point nine five six, and for v one, they get zero point eight three four.
Kai: Those correlation coefficients are pretty strong evidence that their no reaction plane method is capturing the event by event flow fluctuations well enough to be useful.
Mira: But we have to remember that those numbers come from comparing it against direct calculations using the true planes, so it's a comparison of methods, not just a proof of concept on its own.
Lev: The real overhead for this method is that you still have to perform that full scan over the test angle psi for every single event you want to measure.
Kai: So what they're showing us is an alternative way to measure flow in heavy-ion collisions that avoids the major reconstruction step, and it does it with a decent level of accuracy when compared against direct calculations.
Mira: This approach offers a potentially much simpler experimental path forward for measuring v one and v two without the need for full event plane reconstruction.
Lev: But we still have to figure out how to implement that test angle scanning efficiently on real hardware, because that’s where the practical challenge lies.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we’re looking at how they suggest improving this no reaction plane method for measuring flows in heavy-ion collisions.
Mira: They point out that one big improvement is using the knowledge that those two different asymmetries for each harmonic actually contribute equally to the final sum.
Lev: That’s what they found when they looked at the test angle psi, where both ratios clustered tightly around zero point five.
Kai: So, because of that equal contribution, it means you can simplify your measurements by only needing a single asymmetry measurement to get a good estimate of the flow coefficient.
Mira: That’s really practical for experimentalists because it cuts down on the number of measurements they have to take per event.
Lev: They also suggest using scaling laws that they found, where you can estimate v one by taking two to some factor times the average of those asymmetries, which means you don't need separate measurements for v one and v two.
Kai: That scaling idea is interesting because it suggests you can get directed flow just by measuring one asymmetry, which simplifies the whole setup a lot.
Mira: But we gotta be careful here because that scaling only works if the underlying physics, that equal contribution assumption, actually holds true across different collision systems and energies.
Lev: And they also mention how to make it more robust by implementing an estimator like v one equals half times q times the average of Aud and Alr over the test angle psi.
Kai: That sounds like a solid way to define that event by event flow value without needing any complex reconstruction of the reaction plane.
Mira: It’s about using that test angle scanning to mimic averaging over the true reaction plane, which is what they need for their theory to work.
Lev: For real hardware, implementing that full scan over psi for every event is going to be a huge computational lift that needs careful engineering.
Kai: So they’re trying to find this sweet spot where the theoretical simplification of one measurement works well enough, but the practical implementation doesn't take too much time.
Mira: And they also hint at something about higher harmonics, like v four and v five.
Lev: They say that the better accuracy for estimating v two comes from higher harmonics, like v four being expected to be very small.
Kai: So if you can isolate those smaller components using this method, it might help in probing the physics at even finer scales in the collision.
Mira: Ultimately, they’re proposing this no reaction plane technique as a simpler alternative for getting reliable flow measurements in heavy-ion collisions.
Lev: If we can get that fidelity on real data, it means less overhead for error correction analyses because we aren't spending all our time trying to figure out the event plane first.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at the paper "Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions."
Mira: Basically, they showed that you can get directed flow v one and elliptic flow v two without needing to reconstruct the event plane first.
Lev: They achieved this by using a test angle psi and exploiting a symmetry where different asymmetries for each harmonic contribute equally.
Kai: So the main point is that you only need one asymmetry measurement for a good estimate of both flows, which simplifies things immensely for data taking.
Mira: And they proved this works by comparing their no reaction plane method to direct calculations using the true event planes from the particles themselves.
Lev: The correlation numbers they got were zero point nine five six for v two and zero point eight three four for v one, which shows it tracks the fluctuations pretty well.
Kai: So, even though it’s an approximation, it seems like a very good tool for getting flow estimates in heavy-ion collisions.
Mira: It changes things by offering a way to measure these flows that bypasses the complex reconstruction step we usually have to do.
Lev: For real hardware running error correction algorithms, this means less overhead because you don't need to spend so much time figuring out the event plane geometry first.
Kai: Yeah, and they showed how the scaling laws help you get v one just from one asymmetry measurement instead of needing two separate measurements.
Mira: It’s a solid method for extracting flow coefficients by exploiting those underlying symmetries in the harmonics.
Lev: But we still have to worry about that test angle psi scanning taking too long on a real detector, that’s the main engineering hurdle.
Kai: It's definitely an improvement over doing full event plane reconstruction every single time you take data.
Mira: Overall, this paper gives us a much simpler experimental path forward for measuring v one and v two in heavy-ion collisions.
Lev: We should keep watching how they handle those higher harmonics, like v four and v five, because that’s where the physics gets really interesting.
Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology · Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
nucl-th, hep-ph, nucl-ex
Submitted: 2026-04-12
Updated: 2026-11-13
Comments: 6 pages, 8 figures. Extended analysis, covered some problems and questions
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions introduces a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed flow v1 and elliptic flow v2 in heavy-ion collisions…
Key concepts
- No-Reaction Plane (no-RP) Method
- A technique used to measure flow without reconstructing the event plane. Instead of needing a precise reaction plane angle, it uses specific particle emission asymmetries relative to fixed planes. This simplifies experimental analysis by eliminating the need for complex and often difficult event-plane reconstruction steps.
- Fixed-Plane Asymmetries ($A_{ud}, A_{lr}$)
- These are simple count asymmetries based on particle emission direction relative to a detector plane. They are related to directed flow ($v_1$) through approximations, allowing the method to estimate $v_1$ using only these two measurements.
- Flow Contribution Equality
- The study demonstrates that the different harmonics (like $A_{ud}$ and $A_{lr}$) contribute equally to the total flow signal. This means that instead of needing separate measurements for different components, a single asymmetry measurement can provide a reliable estimate for both directed and elliptic flow.
- Event-by-Event Estimation via Test Angle Scanning
- To get event-by-event results, the method scans a test angle ($\psi$) across its full range. The resulting estimators, $v_1( ext{noRP})$ and $v_2( ext{noRP})$, provide reliable flow values without reconstructing the true reaction plane for every single event.
Terminology
Summary
Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions introduces a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed flow v1 and elliptic flow v2 in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction. p. 0 Dlin1 and O. Teryaev1, 2
1Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Dolgoprudny, Russia
2
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia
(Dated: June 10, 2026)
We introduce a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed (v1) and elliptic (v2)
flows in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction. Teryaev1, 2
1Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Dolgoprudny, Russia
2
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia
(Dated: June 10, 2026)
We introduce a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed (v1) and elliptic (v2)
flows in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction. The method
is validated with PHSD model simulations of Au+Au collisions at √
sNN = 9. The method
is validated with PHSD model simulations of Au+Au collisions at √
sNN = 9. 2 GeV at freeze-out
(impact parameter b = 4 − 8 fm). The method
is validated with PHSD model simulations of Au+Au collisions at √
sNN = 9. 2 GeV at freeze-out
(impact parameter b = 4 − 8 fm). First, the two asymmetries for each
harmonic contribute equally to the flow signal, meaning that a single asymmetry measurement suffices for a
good estimate of the flow coefficient. Second, the noRP method correlates exceptionally well with the direct
method on an event-by-event basis, with correlation coefficients of 0. We demonstrate that the two asymmetries for each harmonic
contribute equally, i. , ⟨A
2
ud⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
lr⟩ and ⟨A
2
1⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
2⟩, so that a single asymmetry measurement
suffices for a good flow estimate. We demonstrate that the two asymmetries for each harmonic
contribute equally, i. , ⟨A
2
ud⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
lr⟩ and ⟨A
2
1⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
2⟩, so that a single asymmetry measurement
suffices for a good flow estimate. , ⟨A
2
ud⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
lr⟩ and ⟨A
2
1⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
2⟩, so that a single asymmetry measurement
suffices for a good flow estimate. Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true
reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0. , ⟨A
2
ud⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
lr⟩ and ⟨A
2
1⟩ ≈ ⟨A
2
2⟩, so that a single asymmetry measurement
suffices for a good flow estimate. Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true
reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0. Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true
reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0. 956 for v2 and 0. Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true
reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0. 956 for v2 and 0. Event-by-event comparisons with direct calculations using the true
reaction plane yield Pearson correlation coefficients of 0. 956 for v2 and 0. 956 for v2 and 0. 834 for v1, confirming that
the no-RP method captures flow fluctuations well enough. 956 for v2 and 0. 834 for v1, confirming that
the no-RP method captures flow fluctuations well enough.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Fixed-Plane Asymmetry Definitions
The method begins by defining fixed-plane asymmetries based on particle emission relative to a detector plane aligned with the xz plane. Two simple count asymmetries are defined as Aud = N↑ − N↓ / (N↑ + N↓), where ↑ is cos ϕ > 0 and ↓ is cos ϕ 0 and → is sin ϕ < 0. p. 0 For each event, we count particles that
are emitted in specific azimuthal directions relative to
this plane. Define two simple count asymmetries:
Aud =
N↑ − N↓
N↑ + N↓
,
↑: cos ϕ > 0,
↓: cos ϕ < 0;
Alr =
N← − N→
N← + N→
,
←: sin ϕ > 0,
→: sin ϕ < 0. Therefore:
⟨A
2
ud⟩ΨRP = ⟨A
2
lr⟩ΨRP =
2
π
2
v
2
1 +
1
9
v
2
3 +
1
25
v
2
5 + · · ·
. (11)
Similarly, for the elliptic flow asymmetries:
A1 =
2
π
v2 cos 2ΨRP +
2
2π
v4 cos 4ΨRP + · · · ,
A2 =
2
π
v2 sin 2ΨRP +
2
2π
v4 sin 4ΨRP + · · · ,
(13)
and after averaging:
⟨A
2
1
⟩ΨRP = ⟨A
2
2
⟩ΨRP =
2
π
2
v
2
2 +
1
4
v
2
4 +
1
9
v
2
6 + · · ·
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Elliptic Flow Extraction
Elliptic flow is accessed by defining asymmetries with respect to the fixed plane and a plane rotated by 45◦. The asymmetries A1 and A2 are defined based on particle emission regions relative to this rotated plane. p. 3 The technique
eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction by using simple count asymmetries—up–down, left–right, and
their rotated counterparts—and scanning over a set of
fixed test angles. The method is straightforward to implement experimentally, as it relies only on counting particles in predefined azimuthal regions relative to a laboratory orientation, without requiring complex detector
calibration or event-by-event reaction-plane determination. Both circles include x and y axes; dashed lines are shown only where
needed. Proceeding analogously to the directed flow case, one
finds
A1 ≈
2
π
v2 cos 2ΨRP, A2 ≈
2
π
v2 sin 2ΨRP, (7)
so that the elliptic flow coefficient can be extracted as
v
(est)
2 =
π
2
q
A2
1 + A2
2
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Event-by-Event Estimation via Test Angle Scanning
To extend the method to event-by-event measurements, a test angle ψ is scanned over its full range from 0 to π. The no-RP estimators are defined as v1(noRP) = π/2 q ⟨A2ud(ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A2lr(ψ)⟩ψ and v2(noRP) = π/2 q ⟨A21 (ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A22(ψ)⟩ψ. p. 2 For a given event, scanning ψ from 0 to π makes α =
ψ − ΨRP uniformly sample all values. This suggests an
alternative event–by–event estimator:
v
(noRP)
1 =
π
2
q
⟨A2
ud(ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr(ψ)⟩ψ,
v
(noRP)
2 =
π
2
q
⟨A2
1
(ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
(ψ)⟩ψ. Using the orthogonality arguments above, the same expressions (11) and (14) hold when the average is taken over
ψ. Hence the method yields reliable event–by–event flow
values without any event–plane reconstruction.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Validation and Performance Metrics
The no-RP method is validated by comparing its estimates with direct calculations that use the true event plane angles computed from particles. The results show that the two asymmetries for each harmonic contribute equally, meaning ⟨A2ud⟩ψ ≈ ⟨A2lr⟩ψ and ⟨A21⟩ψ ≈ ⟨A22⟩ψ. p. 3 4–6 establishes
two key findings. First, the two asymmetries for each
harmonic contribute equally to the flow signal, meaning that a single asymmetry measurement suffices for a
good estimate of the flow coefficient. 5
single asymmetry measurement already provides a reliable estimate of the flow coefficient. This greatly simplifies experimental data taking. This greatly simplifies experimental data taking. Most importantly, event-by-event correlations with the
direct method are exceptionally high: Pearson coefficients of 0. 956 for v2 and 0. 834 for v1, confirming that
the no-RP method captures flow fluctuations well enough.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Experimental Utility
The key findings establish that a single asymmetry measurement suffices for a good estimate of the flow coefficient. The no-RP technique captures the underlying flow fluctuations with remarkable fidelity, making it an excellent approximation for flow measurements, particularly for elliptic flow. p. 4 834 for v1. These values
confirm that the noRP technique faithfully captures the
underlying flow fluctuations, making it an excellent approximation for flow measurements, particularly for elliptic flow. These values
confirm that the noRP technique faithfully captures the
underlying flow fluctuations, making it an excellent approximation for flow measurements, particularly for elliptic flow. The noRP method thus offers a powerful experimental alternative (and/or complement) that avoids
reaction-plane reconstruction entirely, with potential applications in a wide range of collision systems and energies.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgments and References
The authors thank A. Borissov, E. p. 4 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank A. Borissov, E. Borissov, E. Bratkovskaya, V. Bratkovskaya, V. Serenkova, A. Serenkova, A. Taranenko and V. Taranenko and V. Voronyuk for useful
discussions and correspondence. Voronyuk for useful
discussions and correspondence. Work is supported by
RSF grant 25-72-30005
[1] A. Fixed-plane asymmetries for elliptic flow: left: A1
(in/out relative to the x-axis) – light purple (in) and light
yellow (out); right: A2 (in/out relative to the plane rotated
by 45◦
) – light green (in) and light orange (out). Both circles include x and y axes; dashed lines are shown only where
needed. Work is supported by
RSF grant 25-72-30005
[1] A. Poskanzer and S. Poskanzer and S. Voloshin, Phys. Voloshin, Phys. C 58,
1671-1678 (1998) [arXiv:nucl-ex/9805001 [nucl-ex]]. C 58,
1671-1678 (1998) [arXiv:nucl-ex/9805001 [nucl-ex]]. Gounaris, J. Gounaris, J. Layssac, G. Layssac, G. Moultaka, and F. Moultaka, and F. Renard,
Int. Renard,
Int. A 8, 3285 (1993). A 8, 3285 (1993). Dvergsnes, P. Dvergsnes, P. Pankov and N. Paver,
Phys. D 69, 115001 (2004) [arXiv:hep-ph/0401199
[hep-ph]]. D 69, 115001 (2004) [arXiv:hep-ph/0401199
[hep-ph]]. Cassing and E. D 69, 115001 (2004) [arXiv:hep-ph/0401199
[hep-ph]]. Cassing and E. Bratkovskaya, Phys. C 78,
034919 (2008). Bratkovskaya, Nucl. A 831
215-242 (2009)
[6] V. A 831
215-242 (2009)
[6] V. Konchakovski, E. Borissov, E. Bratkovskaya, V. D 69, 115001 (2004) [arXiv:hep-ph/0401199
[hep-ph]]. Cassing and E. Cassing, V. Toneev, and V. Voronyuk, Phys. C 85, 044922
(2012). Kolb, Phys. C 68, 031902 (2003)Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 1 ---
Complementary Approach to Anisotropic Flows in Heavy-Ion Collisions E. Dlin and O. Teryaev, 2 Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Dolgoprudny, Russia 2 Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia (Dated: June 10, 2026) We introduce a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed (v1) and elliptic (v2) flows in heavy-ion collisions. p. 0 Dlin1 and O. Teryaev1, 2
1Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Dolgoprudny, Russia
2
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia
(Dated: June 10, 2026)
We introduce a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed (v1) and elliptic (v2)
flows in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction. Teryaev1, 2
1Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Dolgoprudny, Russia
2
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia
(Dated: June 10, 2026)
We introduce a no-reaction-plane (no-RP) method for extracting directed (v1) and elliptic (v2)
flows in heavy-ion collisions, which eliminates the need for event-plane reconstruction. The method
is validated with PHSD model simulations of Au+Au collisions at √
sNN = 9. 2 GeV at freeze-out
(impact parameter b = 4 − 8 fm). We demonstrate that the two asymmetries for each harmonic
contribute equally, i.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 2 ---
dN dϕ ∝ 1 + 2v1 cos(ϕ − ΨRP) + 2v2 cos 2(ϕ − ΨRP) + · · ·, (arXiv:nucl-th) [nucl-th] 10 Jun 2026 We obtain for the asymmetries defined in Eq. (1): Aud = 2π/π v1 cos ΨRP + 3π/q v3 cos 3ΨRP + · · ·, Alr = 2π/π v1 sin ΨRP + 3π/q v3 sin 3ΨRP + · · ·. p. 1 Using this
expansion, one obtains for the asymmetries defined in
Eq. (1):
Aud =
2
π
v1 cos ΨRP +
2
3π
v3 cos 3ΨRP + · · · ,
Alr =
2
π
v1 sin ΨRP +
2
3π
v3 sin 3ΨRP + · · · . Using this
expansion, one obtains for the asymmetries defined in
Eq. (1):
Aud =
2
π
v1 cos ΨRP +
2
3π
v3 cos 3ΨRP + · · · ,
Alr =
2
π
v1 sin ΨRP +
2
3π
v3 sin 3ΨRP + · · · .Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 3 ---
A1 ≈ 2π/π v2 cos 2ΨRP, A2 ≈ 2π/π v4 cos 4ΨRP + · · ·, (arXiv:nucl-th) [nucl-th] We find A1 ≈ 2π/π v2 cos 3ΨRP, A2 ≈ 3π/q v5 cos 5ΨRP + · · · so that the elliptic flow coefficient can be extracted as v2(est)2 = π/2 q (A21 + A22) (8)
--- Page 4 ---
v(noRP)1 = π/2 q ⟨A2ud(ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A2lr(ψ)⟩ψ, v2(noRP) 2 = π/2 q ⟨A21 (ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A22(ψ)⟩psi. The distributions cluster tightly around 0. p. 2 The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The distributions cluster tightly around 0. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The distributions cluster tightly around 0. For each event,
we compute the average over test angles of the squared
asymmetries, ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ, ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ, ⟨A2
1
⟩ψ, and ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. For each event,
we compute the average over test angles of the squared
asymmetries, ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ, ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ, ⟨A2
1
⟩ψ, and ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. 5 for both
ratios. This demonstrates that, on average, each asymmetry contributes equally to the sum in Eq. 5 for both
ratios. This demonstrates that, on average, each asymmetry contributes equally to the sum in Eq.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 5 ---
FIG. 4. Ratios of squared asymmetry contributions for the first 300 events. p. 3 Ratios of squared asymmetry contributions for the
first 300 events. Top: ⟨A
2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A
2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A
2
lr⟩ψ). Definition of the four asymmetries used in the no-RP
method, illustrated for a fixed test angle ψ (blue arrow). Top
left: Alr (left/right) – vertical split relative to ψ – light blue
(+) and light red (−). Top right: Aud (up/down) – horizontal
split relative to ψ – light green (+) and light orange (−). Bottom left: A1 – light purple (in) and light yellow (out)
relative to ψ. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The distributions cluster tightly around 0. Both distributions cluster around
0. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. Both distributions cluster around
0. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. Both distributions cluster around
0. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. This implies that a single asymmetry suffices for a
good flow estimate. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. This implies that a single asymmetry suffices for a
good flow estimate. 5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to
the sum. This implies that a single asymmetry suffices for a
good flow estimate.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 6 ---
FIG. 5. Event-by–event correlation of v1 between the noRP method and direct calculation. p. 3 This near-unity correlation confirms that the
no-RP method provides an excellent estimate of v2 on an
event-by-event basis, despite the small systematic offset
in the mean value due to higher harmonic contributions. Event-by-event correlation of v2 between the noRP method and direct calculation. (15) and v
direct
1
from Eq. The Pearson correlation coefficient is r = 0. (15) and v
direct
1
from Eq. The Pearson correlation coefficient is r = 0. The Pearson correlation coefficient is r = 0. 834, indicating that the no-RP method faithfully reproduces the event-by-event fluctuations of directed
flow. This near-unity correlation confirms that the
no-RP method provides an excellent estimate of v2 on an
event-by-event basis, despite the small systematic offset
in the mean value due to higher harmonic contributions. Event-by-event correlation of v2 between the noRP method and direct calculation. The Pearson correlation
coefficient is r = 0. 956, demonstrating near-perfect tracking
of event-by-event variations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 7 ---
We now validate the no-RP method by comparing its results with direct calculations that use the true event plane reconstructed from the particles themselves. For each event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2 (elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. p. 2 DIRECT FLOW CALCULATION WITH
EVENT PLANE
To validate the no-RP method, we compare its results
with direct calculations that use the true event plane
reconstructed from the particles themselves. For each
event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2
(elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. DIRECT FLOW CALCULATION WITH
EVENT PLANE
To validate the no-RP method, we compare its results
with direct calculations that use the true event plane
reconstructed from the particles themselves. For each
event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2
(elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. For each
event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2
(elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. The Qvector for harmonic n is defined as
Qn,x =
X
i
pT ,i cos(nϕi), Qn,y =
X
i
pT ,i sin(nϕi),
(16)
where the sum runs over all particles in the event with
pT > 0. For each
event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2
(elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. The Qvector for harmonic n is defined as
Qn,x =
X
i
pT ,i cos(nϕi), Qn,y =
X
i
pT ,i sin(nϕi),
(16)
where the sum runs over all particles in the event with
pT > 0. The Qvector for harmonic n is defined as
Qn,x =
X
i
pT ,i cos(nϕi), Qn,y =
X
i
pT ,i sin(nϕi),
(16)
where the sum runs over all particles in the event with
pT > 0. The event plane angle is then
Ψn =
1
n
atan2(Qn,y, Qn,x). The Qvector for harmonic n is defined as
Qn,x =
X
i
pT ,i cos(nϕi), Qn,y =
X
i
pT ,i sin(nϕi),
(16)
where the sum runs over all particles in the event with
pT > 0. The event plane angle is then
Ψn =
1
n
atan2(Qn,y, Qn,x). The event plane angle is then
Ψn =
1
n
atan2(Qn,y, Qn,x). (17)
For a given particle species, the direct flow coefficients
are obtained by averaging over all particles of that species
in the event using these event plane angles:
v
direct
1 = ⟨cos(ϕ − Ψ1)⟩, vdirect
2 = ⟨cos(2(ϕ − Ψ2))⟩. The event plane angle is then
Ψn =
1
n
atan2(Qn,y, Qn,x). (17)
For a given particle species, the direct flow coefficients
are obtained by averaging over all particles of that species
in the event using these event plane angles:
v
direct
1 = ⟨cos(ϕ − Ψ1)⟩, vdirect
2 = ⟨cos(2(ϕ − Ψ2))⟩.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 8 ---
We now present the results of the no-RP method and compare them with the direct calculations. Figure 4 examines the relationship between the squared asymmetries that constitute the no-RP estimates. p. 2 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
We now present the results of the no-RP method and
compare them with the direct calculations. Figure 4 examines the relationship between the squared asymmetries
that constitute the no-RP estimates. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
We now present the results of the no-RP method and
compare them with the direct calculations. Figure 4 examines the relationship between the squared asymmetries
that constitute the no-RP estimates. For each event,
we compute the average over test angles of the squared
asymmetries, ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ, ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ, ⟨A2
1
⟩ψ, and ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. For each event,
we compute the average over test angles of the squared
asymmetries, ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ, ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ, ⟨A2
1
⟩ψ, and ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The distributions cluster tightly around 0. The
figure displays the ratios ⟨A2
ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2
ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2
lr⟩ψ) and
⟨A2
1
⟩ψ/(⟨A2
1
⟩ψ + ⟨A2
2
⟩ψ) for the first 300 events. The distributions cluster tightly around 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 9 ---
We now validate the no-RP method by comparing its results with direct calculations that use the true event plane reconstructed from the particles themselves. For each event, the event plane angles Ψ1 (directed flow) and Ψ2 (elliptic flow) are computed from the particles. The Qvector for harmonic n is defined as Qn,x = Xi pT,i cos(nϕi), Qn,y = Xi pT,i sin(nϕi), (16) where the sum runs over all particles in the event with pT > 0.2 GeV/c. The event plane angle is then Ψn = 1/n atan2(Qn,y, Qn,x) (17). For a given particle species, the direct flow coefficients are obtained by averaging over all particles of that species in the event using these event plane angles: vdirect 1 = ⟨cos(ϕ − Ψ1⟩, vdirect 2 = ⟨cos(2(ϕ − Ψ2))⟩.
--- Page 10 ---
We now present the results of the no-RP method and compare them with the direct calculations. Figure 4 examines the relationship between the squared asymmetries that constitute the no-RP estimates. The figure displays the ratios ⟨A2ud⟩ψ/(⟨A2ud⟩ψ + ⟨A2lr⟩ψ) and ⟨A21⟩ψ/(⟨A21⟩ψ + ⟨A22). Both distributions cluster tightly around 0.5, indicating that each asymmetry contributes equally to the sum. This implies that a single asymmetry suffices for a good flow estimate.
--- Page 2 ---
dN dϕ ∝ 1 + 2v1 cos(ϕ − ΨRP) + 2v2 cos 2(ϕ − ΨRP) + · · ·, (arXiv:nucl-th) [nucl-th] We obtain for the asymmetries defined in Eq. (1): Aud = 2π/π v1 cos ΨRP + 3π/q v3 cos 3ΨRP + · · ·, Alr = 2π/π v1 sin ΨRP + 3π/q v3 sin 3ΨRP + · · ·. We have Aud ≈ 2pi/π v1 cos ΨRP, Alr ≈ 2pi/π v1 sin ΨRP Hence the directed flow coefficient can be extracted per event via v(est)1 = π/2 q A2ud + A2lr (5)
--- Page 3 ---
A1 ≈ 2π/π v2 cos 2ΨRP, A2 ≈ 3π/q v5 cos 5ΨRP + · · · so that the elliptic flow coefficient can be extracted as v2(est)2 = π/2 q (A21 + A22) (8)
--- Page 4 ---
v(noRP) 1 = π/2 q ⟨A2ud(ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A2lr(ψ)⟩ψ, v2(noRP) 2 = π/2 q ⟨A21 (ψ)⟩ψ + ⟨A22(ψ)psi. The distributions cluster tightly around 0.5 for both ratios. This demonstrates that, on average, each asymmetry contributes equally to the sum in Eq. (15): ⟨A2ud⟩ψ ≈ ⟨A2lr⟩ψ ≈ 1/2 v1, ⟨A21⟩ψ ≈ ⟨A22⟩ = 1/2 v 2.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Event-by-event flow estimation can be performed without event plane reconstruction by using a single asymmetry measurement, as
a single asymmetry measurement suffices for a good flow estimate.
This simplifies experimental data taking by reducing the required measurements from four to one while maintaining reliability. -
The no-RP method can provide excellent estimates of elliptic flow on an event-by-event basis, as it achieves a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.956 with direct calculations, confirming that
the noRP method provides an excellent estimate of v2 on an event-by-event basis.
-
The system can be improved by incorporating the knowledge that
the two asymmetries for each harmonic contribute equally
and using this fact to simplify flow extraction, as shown in the result where⟨A2udψ ≈ ⟨A2lrψ ≈ 1/2 v21,
implying a single asymmetry is sufficient. -
The AI system can be enhanced to utilize the scaling observed in results, where
v1 ≈ q 2⟨A2udψ⟩ ≈ q 2⟨A2lrψ],
allowing for a direct calculation of directed flow using only one measured asymmetry instead of requiring separate measurements for v1 and v2. -
The system can be made more robust by implementing the event-by-event estimator
v(noRP)1 = 1/2q⟨A2ud(ψ)⟩ψ + 1/2q⟨A2lr(ψ)⟩ψ,
which relies on scanning a test angle ψ over its full range to achieve the same results as averaging over the reaction plane. -
The system can be trained to recognize and prioritize flow signals based on their correlation strength, as
the better accuracy of v2 estimation is due to higher harmonic v4 which is expected to be very small,
guiding the selection of the most reliable asymmetry for specific flow components.
Abstract
We present a complementary count of directed flow v 1 and elliptic flow v 2. It does not replace known methods. A fixed laboratory plane defines up--down and left--right asymmetries. A scan of the test angle is written down as a theoretical proposal. Each event is given one angle α drawn uniformly on [0,2π), the fixed plane is rotated by α, and the asymmetries are averaged over events. With θ=α known, the linear fit recovers v n true. The quadratic mean, Eq. (5), agrees with the pair form, Eq. (21), in which the 1/N self term cancels, and both sit above v n true because the event noise in A is squared. The time for one count grows linearly with the number of particles. The pair sum, and the usual two-particle correlation, grow as the square of that number. The sample is PHSD Au+Au at sqrt s NN =9.2, GeV, b=4.0 -- 5.2, fm.
Sources
- Methods for analyzing anisotropic flow in relativistic nuclear collisions
- Center-Edge Asymmetry at Hadron Colliders
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations