Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) could constitute all of Dark Matter if they are strongly clustered, leading to a detectable stochastic gravitational wave background by the Einstein Telescope Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) may constitute the entirety of Dark Matter in the asteroid-mass range defined as 10−16M⊙ ≲ MPBH ≲ 10−11M⊙ They generate gravitational-wave (GW) signals potentially detectable by current and future experiments.
Vera: The characteristic scale of curvature perturbations determines the typical PBH mass and sets the frequency of the associated scalar-induced gravitational-wave (SIGW) background according to f ≃ 2.7 nHz MPBH M⊙ −1/2 The Einstein Telescope (ET) will be sensitive to GW signals in the O(10) Hz band, corresponding to the formation of much lighter PBHs, MPBH ∼ 10−19M⊙.
Jocelyn: PBH Clustering Mechanisms If PBHs are strongly clustered beyond Poisson expectation at their time of formation, they can collapse into a heavier PBH even during the radiation-dominated era, evading bounds associated with evaporated PBHs.
Vera: This mechanism is commonly referred to as clusterogenesis.
Title and authors: Vera: So to recap, this paper "Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope" by A.J. Iovino and M. Maggiore looks at asteroid-mass primordial black holes as a dark matter candidate and focuses on how their clustering leads to a gravitational wave background detectable by future observatories like the Einstein Telescope.
Jocelyn: They are really focusing on the connection between these primordial black holes, specifically those in the asteroid mass range of one point one minus sixteen solar masses to one point eleven solar masses, and the resulting gravitational wave signal they can predict.
Subrahmanyan: From my side, I see this as a test case for structure formation scenarios; if we find evidence for this specific clustering mechanism causing clusterogenesis, it would give us a direct probe into how these initial density fluctuations evolve into heavy black holes.
Vera: Right. The paper sets the stage by showing that instead of just forming light, potentially evaporating black holes, if they are strongly clustered at their formation time, they can collapse into heavier ones during the radiation-dominated era to form all of dark matter.
Jocelyn: And that leads them into discussing a specific mathematical structure for how those PBH centers correlate spatially, which is what they call the compaction function and how it relates to the curvature perturbation.
Subrahmanyan: That spatial correlation description, where the discrete PBH centers have a correlation function defined by delta P H of x delta P H of zero equals one over nPBH delta D of x plus xi of x, that's where I need to see how those statistical measures actually constrain the physics.
Vera: It’s about using that compaction function directly because it better describes when a region collapses than just looking at the curvature perturbation alone, and this leads into their analysis of the non-Gaussian correlation function.
Jocelyn: So they use a threshold shift to derive this non-Gaussian correlation function, which is given by one plus xi of r equals P2g over P1g, or one plus xi of r equals one plus xi sub g greater than nu cg of r.
Subrahmanyan: That means for the black hole masses around zero point nine minus nineteen solar masses, the first peak of that function should be around ten to get a value where the PBH number density at those masses is about one, corresponding to a peak order of zero nine minus nine.
Vera: It’s about setting up the right scale for those black holes so they can actually account for all dark matter, which requires an extended power spectrum with k max over k min around ten to six point five.
The paper's summary: Jocelyn: So the summary of "Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope" boils down to this: asteroid-mass primordial black holes can constitute all of dark matter if they are strongly clustered, because that clustering causes clusterogenesis and forms heavier black holes.
Vera: And because of this process, they generate a flat stochastic background of gravitational waves during their formation that should be detectable by the Einstein Telescope, which is a major implication for us.
Subrahmanyan: What I hear is that the paper argues that the standard scenario involving large-amplitude curvature perturbations sets up a characteristic scale for PBH mass and frequency, but this clustering mechanism provides an alternative path to dark matter formation with a specific detectable signature.
Jocelyn: Exactly. It’s not just about standard black hole evaporation constraints anymore; it’s about how clustering bypasses those bounds, and the resulting gravitational wave spectrum is what makes this scenario compelling for detection.
Vera: The paper frames the entire hunt around calculating the spectral density of induced gravitational waves, which involves an integral over time and space involving terms like I c of t s plus I s P zeta g k root three over two (s plus t) i c of t s plus I s P zeta g k root three over two (s minus t).
Subrahmanyan: That expression is complex, but it shows how the gravitational wave signal depends on the dynamics of the formation process and how that interacts with the non-Gaussian features we discussed earlier.
Jocelyn: And they show that for certain final masses, specifically around one point one minus eleven solar masses and another around one point one minus fourteen solar masses, those are within the band range of current experiments like the Einstein Telescope.
Vera: So if you only listen to this part, it means we have two specific mass ranges for these PBHs that could be tested simultaneously by the Einstein Telescope or even future observatories like LISA or AION-km.
The paper's improvements: Vera: Now let's look at what the authors suggest are improvements they make to this idea, moving beyond just stating the possibility, which is what this paper does.
Jocelyn: They focus on using the clustering length determination as a key metric; they define a characteristic comoving clustering length r cl at which the correlation function xi of r equals one.
Subrahmanyan: That clustering length determines the mass of a cluster, M cl, and satisfying the Hoop conjecture requires this to have an extended power spectrum with k max over k min around ten to six point five.
Vera: And that’s significant because it means for those asteroid-like PBHs, around one point one minus nineteen solar masses, if we look at the required power spectrum width, for any value C from one to one hundred, the condition tau cl less than tau eva is satisfied.
Jocelyn: That condition relates the clustering time scale to the evaporation time scale of those lighter black holes that might otherwise be constrained by CMB distortions.
Subrahmanyan: So they’re arguing that this specific power spectrum width allows for these lighter final masses to exist without violating constraints from evaporation, which is a nice piece of physics.
Vera: It's about showing that the required clustering scale works within the constraints imposed by the evaporation limits, which is a direct improvement on previous theoretical models.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap up, this paper "Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope" suggests that asteroid-mass PBHs could indeed be all of dark matter if they cluster correctly and generate a detectable gravitational wave background.
Vera: And the key implication is that this scenario predicts a flat stochastic background of gravitational waves that should be detectable by both LISA and ET, meaning it's an inevitable signal we might find.
Subrahmanyan: From my perspective, it's telling us that if we find evidence for this specific clustering mechanism in cosmic structure formation, we’d have a direct way to probe the nature of dark matter rather than just indirect constraints.
Jocelyn: And what this means for the future is that the Einstein Telescope isn't just looking at one type of signal; it could potentially be testing multiple mass ranges simultaneously if we look at different aspects of these PBH production.
Vera: It’s a solid piece of work because it connects the initial inflationary perturbations to a specific, observable gravitational wave signature that future experiments can hunt for.
Subrahmanyan: I think the study of this paper on "Hunting Dark Matter with the Einstein Telescope" gives us a clearer path forward for connecting early universe physics to late-time gravitational wave astronomy.
A.J. Iovino, M. Maggiore, N. Muttoni, A. Riotto
New York University · Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center
astro-ph.CO, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-04-07
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: PRD published version
Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D 114 (2026) 8, 083547
DOI: 10.1103/vpk9-d7rz
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) could constitute all of Dark Matter if they are strongly clustered, leading to a detectable stochastic gravitational wave background by the Einstein Telescope…
Key concepts
- Primordial Black Holes (PBHs)
- These are black holes formed in the very early universe from fluctuations in the density of matter, rather than collapsing from normal stars. The paper focuses on asteroid-mass PBHs as a potential component of Dark Matter.
- Clusterogenesis
- This mechanism describes how PBHs can form heavier ones even during the radiation era if they are strongly clustered beyond what is expected by random chance. This process helps evade constraints placed on lighter, evaporated black holes.
- Stochastic Gravitational Wave Background (SIGW)
- This is a persistent, random hum of gravitational waves generated by the collective motion and evolution of PBHs. The Einstein Telescope is sensitive to this background signal, which could be a key way to detect these dark matter candidates.
Terminology
Summary
Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) could constitute all of Dark Matter if they are strongly clustered, leading to a detectable stochastic gravitational wave background by the Einstein Telescope
Introduction and Motivation
Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) may constitute the entirety of Dark Matter in the asteroid-mass range defined as 10−16M⊙ ≲ MPBH ≲ 10−11M⊙ They generate gravitational-wave (GW) signals potentially detectable by current and future experiments. The characteristic scale of curvature perturbations determines the typical PBH mass and sets the frequency of the associated scalar-induced gravitational-wave (SIGW) background according to f ≃ 2. p. 1 Among the various formation mechanisms, the standard scenario involves the collapse
of large-amplitude curvature perturbations generated during inflation. The characteristic
scale of these perturbations determines the typical PBH mass and, at the same time, sets the
frequency of the associated scalar-induced gravitational-wave (SIGW) background, according
to (for a recent review see Ref. [6–10] for works on the topic). On the other hand, the Einstein Telescope (ET) [11–13]
will be sensitive to GW signals in the O(10) Hz band, corresponding to the formation of much
lighter PBHs, MPBH ∼ 10−19M⊙, which would have already evaporated by today, leading
to strong constraints on their abundance because of, e.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
PBH Clustering Mechanisms
If PBHs are strongly clustered beyond Poisson expectation at their time of formation, they can collapse into a heavier PBH even during the radiation-dominated era, evading bounds associated with evaporated PBHs. This mechanism is commonly referred to as clusterogenesis. p. 2 PBHs are formed in close proximity, and their subsequent gravitational interactions can lead
to the collapse of the entire cluster into a heavier PBH, even during the radiation-dominated
era, thereby evading the bounds associated with evaporated PBHs. This mechanism is commonly referred to as clusterogenesis [30]. The MisnerSharp mass gives the mass within a sphere of areal radius R(x, t) = a(t)reζ(x) with spherical
coordinate radius r, centred around position x and evaluated at time t. The compaction
directly measures the overabundance of mass in a region and is therefore better suited than
the curvature perturbation for determining when a region collapses. 6)
where δD(x) is the three-dimensional Dirac distribution, nPBH is the average comoving number density of PBHs, and i runs over the initial positions of PBHs. The corresponding
two-point correlation function must take the general form
δPBH(x)δPBH(0)
=
1
nPBH
δD(x) − 1 +
1
n
2
PBH
DX
i̸=j
δD(x − xi)δD(xj )
E
=
1
nPBH
δD(x) + ξ(x),
(2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Non-Gaussian Correlation Analysis
The correlation function of the fully non-Gaussian curvature perturbation can be derived from the Gaussian counterpart by appropriately shifting the threshold. The resulting correlation function is given by 1 + ξ(r) = P2g/P1g = 1 + ξ g>νcg(r). p. 6 For PBH
masses of the order of 10−19M⊙, potentially testable by ET, P1 = P1g should be of the order
10−19 to get fPBH(10−19M⊙) ≃ 1, corresponding to νcg ≃ 9. Provided that the threshold is appropriately shifted, we have demonstrated that the
correlation function of the full non-Gaussian curvature perturbation is identical to that of
the Gaussian counterpart
1 + ξ>νc
(r) = P2g
P
2
1g
= 1 + ξ
g
>νcg
(r), (2. By using again the conservation of the probability we can replace P1 with P1g. For PBH
masses of the order of 10−19M⊙, potentially testable by ET, P1 = P1g should be of the order
10−19 to get fPBH(10−19M⊙) ≃ 1, corresponding to νcg ≃ 9.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Cluster Formation and Mass Constraints
The average number of PBHs in the comoving volume is given by ⟨N⟩ = nPBH Z V d3r [1 + ξ(r)]. The characteristic (comoving) clustering length rcl at which ξ(rcl) ≃ 1 determines the mass of the cluster Mcl ≡ ⟨N⟩MPBH. p. 8 the former, we will compute the characteristic (comoving) clustering length rcl at which
ξ(rcl) ≃ 1. However, the existence of a clustering length does not imply automatically that
correlation is relevant. 11)
As shown in Fig. 2, satisfying the Hoop conjecture requires a rather extended power spectrum,
with kmax/kmin ∼ 106. 5
, which implies ⟨N⟩ ≳ 105
, one can easily
verify that, for any value C ∈ [1, 100], the condition τcl ≪ τeva is satisfied3
. In order for
PBHs to account for the totality of DM, the final mass must lie in the range [3]
10−16M⊙ ≲ Mfinal
PBH ≲ 10−11M⊙ .Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implication for Einstein Telescope Detection
The spectral density of induced GWs associated to PBHs production can be computed as h2omegaGW(f) = cgh2omegar36 Z √1/3 0 dt Z ∞ √1/3 ds 7)
where C = O(1 − 102
) parametrizes the amplitude of the final overdensity upon virialization
[49, 51]. PBH clusters may collapse into BHs of mass Mfinal
PBH ≃ Mcl ≡ ⟨N⟩MPBH if the final
halo is sufficiently more compact than a BH, thereby giving rise to a population of heavier
PBHs. 2)
This relation establishes a direct link between PBH mass and GW frequency, enabling the
exploration of PBH formation across a wide mass range through different GW observatories. On the one hand, the space-based interferometer LISA [5] will probe the mHz frequency
band, corresponding to asteroid-mass PBHs, which can account for the totality of DM (see
Refs.t squared − 1/3 s squared − 1/3 t squared - s squared / 4 I c(t, s) + I s(t, s) Pζg
k√3/2 (s + t) I c(t, s) + I s(t, s) Pζg"k√3/2 (s − t). The results show that the lightest final masses of Mfinal PBH ∼ 10−11 (∆ = 8)) and Mfinal PBH ∼ 10−14 (∆ = 6. p. 8Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions
The paper concludes that asteroid-like PBHs might constitute all of Dark Matter, generating an inevitable SIGW stochastic background detectable by both LISA and ET. The indirect signal of such scenarios is the production of a flat stochastic background of gravitational waves which is detectable by the Einstein Telescope. p. 0 However, if they are
formed strongly clustered, the corresponding haloes may collapse in heavier black holes which
may form the entirety of the dark matter of the universe. The indirect signal of such scenario
is the production of a flat stochastic background of gravitational waves which is detectable
by the Einstein Telescope.Where the paper says it
Acknowledgements
We thank G. Franciolini for partecipating at the early discussions of this work. A.J.I research is funded by Tamkeen under the research grant to NYUAD ADHPG-AD457. A.R. and M.M. acknowledge support from the Swiss National Science Foundation (project number – 12 – N. p. 0 Muttoni ,
b A. Riotto b
aNew York University, Abu Dhabi, PO Box 129188 Saadiyat Island, Abu Dhabi, UAE
bDepartment of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center,
24 quai E.Where the paper says it
References
[1] B J Carr and S W Hawking, Black holes in the early Universe, Mon Not Roy Astron Soc 168 (1974) 399
[2] B J Carr, The Primordial black hole mass spectrum, Astrophys J. 201 (1975) 1
[3] B Carr, A J Iovino, G Perna, V Vaskonen and H Veerm¨ae, Primordial black holes: constraints, potential evidence and prospects 2601.06024
[4] G Dom´enech, Scalar Induced Gravitational Waves Review Universe 7 (2021) 398
[5] LISA Cosmology Working Group collaboration Cosmology with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna Living Rev Rel. 26 (2023) 5
[6] N Bartolo, V De Luca, G Franciolini, A Lewis, M Peloso and A Riotto Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter LISA Serendipity Phys Rev Lett. 122 (2019) 211301
[7] N Bartolo, V De Luca, G Franciolini, M Peloso, D Racco and A Riotto Testing primordial black holes as dark matter with LISA Phys Rev D 99 (2019) 103521
[8] LISA Cosmology Working Group collaboration Gravitational waves from inflation in LISA reconstruction pipeline and physics interpretation JCAP 11 (2024) 032
[9] LISA Cosmology Working Group collaboration Reconstructing primordial curvature perturbations via scalar-induced gravitational waves with LISA JCAP 05 (2025) 062
[11] M Punturo et al, The Einstein Telescope: A third-generation gravitational wave observatory Class. Quant. Grav. 27 (2010) 194002
[13] ET collaboration, The Science of the Einstein Telescope 2503.12263
[14] J R Chisholm, Clustering of primordial black holes: basic results Phys Rev D 73 (2006) 083504
[15] Y Tada and S Yokoyama Primordial black holes as biased tracers Phys Rev D 91 (2015) 123534
[17] K M Belotsky, V I Dokuchaev, Y N Eroshenko, E A Esipova, M Y Khlopov L A Khromykh et al Clusters of primordial black holes Eur Phys J C 79 (2019) 246
[18] V Desjacques and A Riotto Spatial clustering of primordial black holes Phys Rev D 98 (2018) 123533
[19] Y Ali-Ha¨ımoud, Correlation Function of High-Threshold Regions and Application to the Initial Small-Scale Clustering of Primordial Black Holes Phys Rev Lett. 121 (2018) 081304
[25] V Atal, A Sanglas and N Triantafyllou LIGO/Virgo black holes and dark matter The effect of spatial clustering JCAP 11 (2020) 036
[34] M Shibata and M Sasaki Black hole formation in the Friedmann universe Formulation and computation in numerical relativity Phys Rev D 60 (1999) 084002
[35] T Harada, C.-M Yoo, T Nakama and Y Koga Cosmological long-wavelength solutions and primordial black hole formation Phys Rev D 91 (2015) 084057
[36] J M Bardeen, J R Bond, N Kaiser and A S Szalay The Statistics of Peaks of Gaussian Random Fields Astrophys J. 304 (1986) 15
[37] J M Bardeen, J R Bond, N Kaiser and A S Szalay The Statistics of Peaks of Gaussian Random Fields apj 304 (1986) 15
[38] V Atal, J Garriga and A Marcos-Caballero Primordial black hole formation with non-Gaussian curvature perturbations JCAP 09 (2019) 073
[39] M Sasaki, J Valiviita and D Wands Non-Gaussianity of the primordial perturbation in the curvaton model Phys Rev D 74 (2006) 103003
[41] V Atal and C Germani The role of non-gaussianities in Primordial Black Hole formation Phys Dark Univ. 24 (2019) 100275
[43] L Frosina and A Urbano Inflationary interpretation of the nHz gravitational-wave background Phys Rev D 108 (23) 103544
[53] M Sasaki, T Suyama, T Tanaka and S Yokoyama Primordial black holes—perspectives in gravitational wave astronomy Class Quant Grav. 35 (2018) 063001
[54] J Binney and S Tremaine Galactic dynamics Princeton University Press (1987)
[55] A Arbey, J Auffinger and J Silk Evolution of primordial black hole spin due to Hawking radiation Mon Not Roy Astron Soc 494 (2020) 1257
[57] G Franciolini and A Urbano Primordial black hole dark matter from inflation The reverse engineering approach Phys Rev D 106 (2022) 123519
[58] K Tomita, Evolution of Irregularities in a Chaotic Early Universe Prog Theor Phys 54 (1975) 730
[59] S Matarrese, O Pantano and D Saez General relativistic dynamics of irrotational dust Cosmological implications Phys Rev Lett. 72 (1994) 320
[63] D Baumann, P J Steinhardt K Takahashi and K Ichiki Gravitational Wave Spectrum Induced by Primordial Scalar Perturbations Phys Rev D 76 (2007) 84019
[65] J R Espinosa, D Racco and A Riotto A Cosmological Signature of the SM Higgs Instability Gravitational Waves JCAP 9 (2018) 012
[71] V Atal and G Dom´enech Probing non-Gaussianities with the high frequency tail of induced gravitational waves JCAP 6 (2021) 001
[75] L Liu, Z C Chen and Q G Huang Implications for the non-Gaussianity of curvature perturbation from pulsar timing arrays Phys Rev D 109 (24) L061301
[79] G Perna, C Testini, A Ricciardone and S Matarrese Fully non-Gaussian Scalar-Induced Gravitational Waves JCAP 5 (2024) 086
[83] J W Foster, D Blas, A Bourgoin, A Hees M Herrero-Valea A C Jenkins et al Discovering µHz gravitational waves and ultra-light dark matter with binary resonances 2504.15334
[89] M Branchesi et al Science with the Einstein Telescope a comparison of different designs JCAP 7 (2023) 068
[91] F Iacovelli, M Mancarella, S Foffa and M Maggiore GWFAST A Fisher Information Matrix Python Code for Third-generation Gravitational-wave Detectors Astrophys J. Supp.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Advanced Dark Matter candidate identification: The improved AI can distinguish between standard PBH scenarios and clusterogenesis by calculating whether
the mean count ⟨N⟩ significantly deviates from Poisson if the second contribution from the clustering is larger than the discreteness noise nPBHV.
-
Gravitational Wave signal prediction: The system can predict the detectable signature of dark matter by computing
h2OmegaGW(f)
using Equation 4.1, specifically modeling how abroad power spectrum
results in signals detectable by current and future experiments like the Einstein Telescope. -
Clustering length determination: The AI can calculate the characteristic comoving clustering length rcl at which correlation is relevant, defined as
the characteristic (comoving) clustering length rcl at which ξ(rcl) ≃ 1,
to quantify when clustered PBH abundance matters. -
Mass range constraint application: The system can determine the required power spectrum width for asteroid-like PBHs by relating it to the Hoop conjecture, finding that
for MPBH ∼ 10−19M⊙ and kmax/kmin ∼ 106.5, one can easily verify that, for any value C ∈ [1, 100], the condition τcl≪τeva is satisfied.
Abstract
Too light primordial black holes evaporate and are therefore strongly constrained by various bounds, e.g. Cosmic Microwave Background distortion. However, if they are formed strongly clustered, the corresponding haloes may collapse into heavier black holes which may form the entirety of the dark matter of the universe. The indirect signal of such a scenario is the production of a flat stochastic background of gravitational waves which is detectable by the Einstein Telescope.
Sources
- Scalar induced gravitational waves review
- Cosmology with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
- The Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter - LISA Serendipity
- Testing Primordial Black Holes as Dark Matter through LISA
- Gravitational waves from inflation in LISA: reconstruction pipeline and physics interpretation
- Reconstructing Primordial Curvature Perturbations via Scalar-Induced Gravitational Waves with LISA
- Science Case for the Einstein Telescope
- Primordial black holes as biased tracers
- On the merger rate of primordial black holes: effects of nearest neighbours distribution and clustering
- Clusters of primordial black holes
- The Spatial Clustering of Primordial Black Holes
- Correlation function of high-threshold regions and application to the initial small-scale clustering of primordial black holes
- Primordial black holes: constraints, potential evidence and prospects
- The impact of non-Gaussianity when searching for Primordial Black Holes with LISA
- The Science of the Einstein Telescope
- Early Structure Formation in $\Lambda$PBH Cosmologies
- Clustering of primordial black holes with non-Gaussian initial fluctuations
- Clustering of primordial black holes formed in a matter-dominated epoch
- Primordial Black Holes from Broad Spectra: Abundance and Clustering
- Initial clustering and the primordial black hole merger rate
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference