Probing cosmic anisotropy with galaxy clusters and supernovae

arXiv:2604.04408 · astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2026-04-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Probing cosmic anisotropy with galaxy clusters and supernovae".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Using galaxy clusters and supernovae to probe directional variations in the Hubble constant using hemisphere decomposition methods reveals a consistent deviation from isotropy across various models and data sets The maximum ∆H0 aligns with the CMB dipole direction in nearly all cases The study employs the hemisphere decomposition method to investigate directional variations in the Hubble constant H0 using galaxy cluster and Type Ia Supernovae data The analysis involves converting right ascension and declination angles to galactic coordinates (l, b) and constructing unit direction vectors for sky grid points, galaxy clusters (GC), and SNe Based on the inner products of these vectors with the sky direction vector, SNe and GCs are separated into hemispheres Likelihoods for each hemisphere are constructed according to Equations 5, 6, and 7 depending on the dataset combination used The likelihoods are then extremized to find the best-fit values of parameter combinations in each hemisphere for a particular sky grid point Data Combination and Model Comparison The research combines Type Ia Supernovae (SNe) data from Pantheon Plus with galaxy cluster (GC) datasets to study directional variations in H0 The combined sample consists of 313 GCs with a redshift range of 0.004 to 0.447 and SNe data covering a redshift range from 0.023 to 2.26 Two cosmological models are considered: the standard ΛCDM model and the model-independent Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography Different parameter sets (I to IV) are defined to explore various combinations of scaling-relation parameters (k, s, σint) and cosmological parameters (H0, omegam, q0, j0) Key Findings from Cluster Analysis For the galaxy cluster dataset analysis using parameter Set I and a fiducial standard ΛCDM cosmology, the maximum ∆H0 is found at (l, b) = (336◦, 0◦) with a statistical significance of 3.56σ The anisotropy level for H0 is approximately 0.06−0.12 with uncertainties δH0AL ∼ (0.03 − 0.06) The XMM-Newton dataset shows the most variation ∆H0 ∼ (13 − 20) km/s/Mpc at a significance of (3−4)σ due to its inhomogeneous distribution across hemispheres Supernovae and Calibration Effects When using the SNe dataset calibrated with Cepheid host galaxies, the maximum ∆H0 values range between (3 − 4) km/s/Mpc for redshift cut z ≤ 2.26 and (3 − 3.5) km/s/Mpc for z ≤ 0.1 The effect of using galaxy clusters as calibrators instead of Cepheid hosts on the SNe+GC dataset combination results in a reduction of ∆H0 values to (3 − 3.5) km/s/Mpc, which is statistically insignificant (≲ 1σ) Robustness Across Models and Calibrators The results are consistent across the standard ΛCDM model and the Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography expansions, suggesting that both models yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 position for SNe+GC dataset calibrated using GCs remains broadly consistent across parameter Sets II and IV Furthermore, the overall conclusion that the maximum ∆H0 lies in the hemisphere encompassing the CMB dipole direction is supported by both datasets The anisotropy level for H0 across all four cases considered is approximately 2σ Comparison with Literature The findings are similar to previous work where the PP dataset was used in several redshift bins and found angular variations of up to 4 km/s/Mpc with a statistical significance of ∼ 2σ The results for the SNe+GC dataset match those from Ref.

63: when comparing the combined dataset The anisotropy level values of H0 are approximately 2σ across all dataset combinations considered The study demonstrates that the H0 anisotropy is not severely influenced by calibration methods and may arise from other sources Allowing the calibrator parameter to fit itself in each hemisphere reduced the ∆H0 value to ∼ (1 − 1.5) km/s/Mpc, a reduction that was statistically insignificant (≲ 1.3σ) The method employed is sensitive only to dipolar behavior, and future analyses should account for residual anisotropies in different datasets Final Summary of Anisotropy The paper concludes that for all dataset combinations considered, there is a mild departure from isotropy corresponding to ∼ 2σ This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin Final Summary of Results The maximum ∆H0 position found when calibrated using GCs for ΛCDM model and full SNe sample is (168◦, 54◦) The results are tabulated in Tables 2-13 The anisotropy level of H0 is approximately 0.07−0.08 with uncertainties δH0AL ∼ (0.1 − 2σ) This shows a mild departure from isotropy at the (1.5 − 2.5)σ level for the Chandra and the combined dataset The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin Final Summary of Model Dependency The effect of having omegam and q0 as free parameters in the GC dataset analysis has very little effect on ∆H0 values The number of cosmological parameters in the considered model has a mild effect on ∆H0 values for the SNe dataset Both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The anisotropy level values of H0 are approximately 0.04 ± 0.03 and 0.05 ± 0.03 in the ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) models for the full SNe sample The higher anisotropy level in omegam and q0 shows the difference in sensitivities of these parameters on the cosmic anisotropy as also reported in Ref.

70: Final Summary of Calibration Impact The decrease in ∆H0 values when using Cepheid hosts as calibrators compared to GC calibration is statistically insignificant (≲ 1σ) This shows the robustness of the calibration method employed to break degeneracies Allowing the calibrator parameter to fit itself in each hemisphere reduced the ∆H0 value further to ∼ (1 − 1.5) km/s/Mpc This shows that the H0 anisotropy is not severely influenced by calibration methods and may arise from other sources The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour Final Summary of Anisotropy Significance The significance of the departure from isotropy is found to be ∼ 2σ for all dataset combinations considered This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour A more detailed analysis involving higher order multipoles in SNe datasets may reveal several more important features Since different datasets themselves may carry residual anisotropies, future analyses must account for these The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin Final Summary of Model Consistency The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.5 km/s/Mpc with a significance level of ∼ 2σ and is similar to the values found in the SNe-only case The results from all three cases GCs, SNe and GC+SNe using different calibrations are similar The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin The maximum ∆H0 position for SNe+GC dataset calibrated using GCs is (168◦, 54◦) Final Summary of Anisotropy Level The anisotropy level displays a significance value of ∼ 2σ for all dataset combinations considered This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour A more detailed analysis involving higher order multipoles in SNe datasets may reveal several more important features Since different datasets themselves may carry residual anisotropies, future analyses must account for these The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin Final Summary of Model Consistency The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.5 km/s/Mpc with a significance level of ∼ 2σ and is similar to the values found in the SNe-only case The results from all three cases GCs, SNe and GC+SNe using different calibrations are similar The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin Final Summary of Model Consistency The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.

Paper summary: Vera: To get here, they use a method called hemisphere decomposition, which basically splits the sky into different parts—hemispheres—and checks if H0 looks the same in each one.

Jocelyn: They are using galaxy cluster data and Type Ia Supernovae from the Pantheon Plus compilation for this test.

Subrahmanyan: It’s worth noting they're testing two different cosmological models, the standard Lambda CDM model and a more flexible Padé-(twenty-one) cosmography <ref:2604.04408#pg1>.

Vera: They define several parameter sets to look at different combinations of scaling relations and other cosmological parameters like the matter density or deceleration parameter.

Jocelyn: The study combines three hundred thirteen galaxy clusters with a redshift range from zero point zero zero four to point four forty seven, along with SNe data covering a range from zero point zero two three to two point two six <ref:2604.04408#pg2>.

Subrahmanyan: They are specifically looking at how the measurements of distance, which depend on H0, behave under these different mathematical frameworks.

Vera: The paper notes that Cepheid host calibration is usually needed for Supernovae because there’s a confusion between H0 and the absolute magnitude of those SNe.

Jocelyn: So, they use galaxy cluster scaling relations as an alternative way to calibrate the Supernovae data instead of relying solely on Cepheids.

Subrahmanyan: The conclusion from this calibration choice is that the variation in H0 is quite robust, staying within a one sigma difference when using galaxy clusters as calibrators compared to Cepheids.

Vera: This robustness across different calibration methods suggests that this directional variation isn't just an artifact of how we calibrate things.

Jocelyn: And they find a consistent deviation from isotropy of about two sigma across all the models and datasets they tested in this paper, "Probing cosmic anisotropy with galaxy clusters and supernovae."

Subrahmanyan: That finding is interesting because it suggests that this anisotropy signal might be something real rather than just statistical noise.

Vera: So, what does this mean for us as an audience? It means we’re seeing a consistent hint of directionality in how fast the universe is expanding near us.

Conclusion: Jocelyn: Thinking about the title, "Probing cosmic anisotropy with galaxy clusters and supernovae," it really captures what they did—they used these two different probes to look for this directional effect.

Subrahmanyan: The authors found that across all their model choices and data sets, they consistently get a deviation from isotropy at a two sigma level.

Vera: That two sigma level is the key here; it’s mild, but consistent enough across multiple ways of looking at the data to suggest something deeper than random error.

Jocelyn: And remember that maximum deviation line aligns with the CMB dipole direction in nearly all cases, which reinforces the idea that this signal might be related to large-scale structure or something else we haven't fully accounted for yet.

Subrahmanyan: The authors also showed that using galaxy clusters as calibrators doesn't significantly change the H0 variation, which means this result is pretty solid regardless of the calibration method used.

Vera: So, in simple terms, this paper suggests there’s a mild but persistent hint that the expansion rate isn't perfectly uniform across our observable universe.

Jocelyn: It points toward needing more detailed analysis involving higher order multipoles in Supernovae datasets to see if we can find more structure in this anisotropy.

Subrahmanyan: That makes sense, because since different datasets themselves might have their own residual anisotropies, future analyses need to account for that before we can claim a definitive cosmic signal.

Shubham Barua, *Sujit K. Dalui, †Shantanu Desai

Department of Physics, IIT Hyderabad Kandi, Telangana

astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2026-04-06

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 15 pages, 7 figures; Accepted for publication in EPJC

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Using galaxy clusters and supernovae to probe directional variations in the Hubble constant using hemisphere decomposition methods reveals a consistent deviation from isotropy across various models…

Key concepts

Hemisphere Decomposition Method
This technique splits the sky into two halves (hemispheres) based on the direction of celestial objects like galaxy clusters or supernovae. By analyzing how $H_0$ measurements differ between these hemispheres, researchers can search for directional variations in the Hubble constant, testing whether it is constant everywhere.
Hubble Constant ($H_0$) Anisotropy
This refers to the idea that the expansion rate of the universe might not be uniform in all directions. The study looked for a 'directional variation' or anisotropy in $H_0$ by comparing measurements from different sky regions. Finding such a variation would imply some physical cause beyond random statistical fluctuations.
$\Lambda$CDM vs. Padé-(2,1) Cosmography
These are two different mathematical models used to describe the universe's expansion and its fundamental components (like dark matter and dark energy). The researchers tested their findings using both models. Finding similar results across these different cosmological frameworks strengthens the conclusion that any observed anisotropy is a robust feature of the data, not an artifact of a single model.
Calibration Effects
This refers to how accurately measurements are made, often by using known objects like Cepheid variables to calibrate supernovae distances. The study investigated whether changing which objects are used for calibration (e.g., galaxy clusters versus Cepheids) significantly changes the measured $H_0$ variation, finding that the effect is statistically insignificant.

Terminology

Summary

Using galaxy clusters and supernovae to probe directional variations in the Hubble constant using hemisphere decomposition methods reveals a consistent deviation from isotropy across various models and data sets The maximum ∆H0 aligns with the CMB dipole direction in nearly all cases

Methodology for Anisotropy Testing

The study employs the hemisphere decomposition method to investigate directional variations in the Hubble constant H0 using galaxy cluster and Type Ia Supernovae data The analysis involves converting right ascension and declination angles to galactic coordinates (l, b) and constructing unit direction vectors for sky grid points, galaxy clusters (GC), and SNe Based on the inner products of these vectors with the sky direction vector, SNe and GCs are separated into hemispheres Likelihoods for each hemisphere are constructed according to Equations 5, 6, and 7 depending on the dataset combination used The likelihoods are then extremized to find the best-fit values of parameter combinations in each hemisphere for a particular sky grid point

Data Combination and Model Comparison

The research combines Type Ia Supernovae (SNe) data from Pantheon Plus with galaxy cluster (GC) datasets to study directional variations in H0 The combined sample consists of 313 GCs with a redshift range of 0.004 to 0.447 and SNe data covering a redshift range from 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We utilize Type Ia SNe data from the PantheonPlus (PP) compilation [68, 69]. It consists of 1701 light curves from 1550 distinct Type Ia SNe and covers a redshift range of 0.

023 to 2.26 Two cosmological models are considered: the standard ΛCDM model and the model-independent Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography Different parameter sets (I to IV) are defined to explore various combinations of scaling-relation parameters (k, s, σint) and cosmological parameters (H0, omegam, q0, j0)

Key Findings from Cluster Analysis

For the galaxy cluster dataset analysis using parameter Set I and a fiducial standard ΛCDM cosmology, the maximum ∆H0 is found at (l, b) = (336◦, 0◦) with a statistical significance of 3.56σ The anisotropy level for H0 is approximately 0. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The near-uniformity of the sky-map explains why the changes are small. The anisotropy level (of H0) in all four cases considered is approximately 0.

06−0.12 with uncertainties δH0AL ∼ (0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2) Equation 1 can be written in logarithmic form as log L ′ X = log k + s log τ, (3) where L ′ X = LX 1044erg/s E(z) −1 and τ = T 4keV. (4) The corresponding χ 2 expression involving uncertainties in both x and y variable is given by [85]: χ 2 cluster = X N i=1 log(2πσ2 int) + log[L ′ X,obs] − log[L ′ X,th(τ, θ)] σ 2 log Li + s 2σ 2 log Ti + σ 2 int !

03 − 0.06) The XMM-Newton dataset shows the most variation ∆H0 ∼ (13 − 20) km/s/Mpc at a significance of (3−4)σ due to its inhomogeneous distribution across hemispheres

Supernovae and Calibration Effects

When using the SNe dataset calibrated with Cepheid host galaxies, the maximum ∆H0 values range between (3 − 4) km/s/Mpc for redshift cut z ≤ 2.26 and (3 − 3.5) km/s/Mpc for z ≤ 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION The cosmological principle [1] requires the universe to be statistically homogeneous and isotropic on sufficiently large scales. The support for the cosmological principle comes from the isotropy of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) [2–4] and the distribution of galaxies on scales larger than 100 Mpc.

1 The effect of using galaxy clusters as calibrators instead of Cepheid hosts on the SNe+GC dataset combination results in a reduction of ∆H0 values to (3 − 3. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Combination of Galaxy Clusters and Supernovae Now, we combine GCs with SNe. First, we use GCs as calibrators for this dataset combination.

5) km/s/Mpc, which is statistically insignificant (≲ 1σ)

Robustness Across Models and Calibrators

The results are consistent across the standard ΛCDM model and the Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography expansions, suggesting that both models yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 position for SNe+GC dataset calibrated using GCs remains broadly consistent across parameter Sets II and IV Furthermore, the overall conclusion that the maximum ∆H0 lies in the hemisphere encompassing the CMB dipole direction is supported by both datasets The anisotropy level for H0 across all four cases considered is approximately 2σ

Comparison with Literature

The findings are similar to previous work where the PP dataset was used in several redshift bins and found angular variations of up to 4 km/s/Mpc with a statistical significance of ∼ 2σ The results for the SNe+GC dataset match those from Ref. [63] when comparing the combined dataset The anisotropy level values of H0 are approximately 2σ across all dataset combinations considered

Conclusion on Calibration

The study demonstrates that the H0 anisotropy is not severely influenced by calibration methods and may arise from other sources Allowing the calibrator parameter to fit itself in each hemisphere reduced the ∆H0 value to ∼ (1 − 1.5) km/s/Mpc, a reduction that was statistically insignificant (≲ 1. p. 9

Where the paper says it

We notice this here, where fixing k globally makes ∆H0 values large. However, the difference in the ∆H0 values is statistically insignificant (≲ 1σ).

3σ) The method employed is sensitive only to dipolar behavior, and future analyses should account for residual anisotropies in different datasets

Final Summary of Anisotropy

The paper concludes that for all dataset combinations considered, there is a mild departure from isotropy corresponding to ∼ 2σ This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin

Final Summary of Results

The maximum ∆H0 position found when calibrated using GCs for ΛCDM model and full SNe sample is (168◦, 54◦) The results are tabulated in Tables 2-13 The anisotropy level of H0 is approximately 0.07−0.08 with uncertainties δH0AL ∼ (0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

(2) Equation 1 can be written in logarithmic form as log L ′ X = log k + s log τ, (3) where L ′ X = LX 1044erg/s E(z) −1 and τ = T 4keV. (4) The corresponding χ 2 expression involving uncertainties in both x and y variable is given by [85]: χ 2 cluster = X N i=1 log(2πσ2 int) + log[L ′ X,obs] − log[L ′ X,th(τ, θ)] σ 2 log Li + s 2σ 2 log Ti + σ 2 int !

1 − 2σ) This shows a mild departure from isotropy at the (1. p. 6
Where the paper says it

12 (for Chandra and the combined dataset) with uncertainties δ H0 AL ∼ (0. This shows a mild departure from isotropy at the (1.

5 − 2.5)σ level for the Chandra and the combined dataset The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin

Final Summary of Model Dependency

The effect of having omegam and q0 as free parameters in the GC dataset analysis has very little effect on ∆H0 values The number of cosmological parameters in the considered model has a mild effect on ∆H0 values for the SNe dataset Both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The anisotropy level values of H0 are approximately 0.04 ± 0.03 and 0.05 ± 0.03 in the ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) models for the full SNe sample The higher anisotropy level in omegam and q0 shows the difference in sensitivities of these parameters on the cosmic anisotropy as also reported in Ref. p. 7

Where the paper says it

27 in the ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) models, respectively (for the full SNe sample). The higher anisotropy level in Ωm and q0 shows the difference in sensitivities of these parameters on the cosmic anisotropy as also reported in Ref.

[70]

Final Summary of Calibration Impact

The decrease in ∆H0 values when using Cepheid hosts as calibrators compared to GC calibration is statistically insignificant (≲ 1σ) This shows the robustness of the calibration method employed to break degeneracies Allowing the calibrator parameter to fit itself in each hemisphere reduced the ∆H0 value further to ∼ (1 − 1.5) km/s/Mpc This shows that the H0 anisotropy is not severely influenced by calibration methods and may arise from other sources The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour

Final Summary of Anisotropy Significance

The significance of the departure from isotropy is found to be ∼ 2σ for all dataset combinations considered This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour A more detailed analysis involving higher order multipoles in SNe datasets may reveal several more important features Since different datasets themselves may carry residual anisotropies, future analyses must account for these The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin

Final Summary of Model Consistency

The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.5 km/s/Mpc with a significance level of ∼ 2σ and is similar to the values found in the SNe-only case The results from all three cases GCs, SNe and GC+SNe using different calibrations are similar The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin The maximum ∆H0 position for SNe+GC dataset calibrated using GCs is (168◦, 54◦)

Final Summary of Anisotropy Level

The anisotropy level displays a significance value of ∼ 2σ for all dataset combinations considered This value increases to ∼ 3σ when considering the XMM-Newton GC dataset on its own due to the inhomogeneous distribution across the two hemispheres The method employed in this work is sensitive only to dipolar behaviour A more detailed analysis involving higher order multipoles in SNe datasets may reveal several more important features Since different datasets themselves may carry residual anisotropies, future analyses must account for these The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin

The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.5 km/s/Mpc with a significance level of ∼ 2σ and is similar to the values found in the SNe-only case The results from all three cases GCs, SNe and GC+SNe using different calibrations are similar The consistency of the anisotropic signal across multiple datasets and models provides qualitative evidence against a purely statistical origin

The paper finds that both ΛCDM and Pad´e-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results The maximum ∆H0 is approximately 4−5.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform directional variation analysis of H0 using galaxy clusters and Type Ia Supernovae by decomposing sky data into two hemispheres, as described in Section III A. This allows the system to calculate directional variations in H0 following the methodology of Ref [58].

  2. The improved system can distinguish between calibration methods for SNe when studying cosmic anisotropy, noting that using GCs, the maximum ∆H0 positions remain broadly consistent across parameter Sets II and IV while using Cepheid calibration introduces changes in the positions of maximum ∆H0.

  3. The AI system can incorporate a model-independent Padé-(2,1) cosmography into its analysis to check for model dependency, as both ΛCDM and Padé-(2,1) cosmography yield similar results in most cases.

  4. The improved system can perform parameter sensitivity studies by allowing cosmological parameters like H0 or q0 to vary while keeping others fixed to see how the anisotropic signal changes, as described in Section IV B.

  5. The system can identify dataset-specific systematics by testing if the anisotropy level is not severely influenced by calibration methods and may arise from other sources, noting that a dynamic variation of k shows a reduction in ∆H0 to ∼ (1 − 1.5) km/s/Mpc.

Abstract

Using Λ CDM and Padé-(2,1) cosmography, we study directional variations in the Hubble constant, H 0, using galaxy clusters (GC) and Type Ia Supernovae (SNe), from the PantheonPlus compilation, employing the hemisphere decomposition method. Since there is a degeneracy between H 0 and absolute magnitude M B for SNe, Cepheid-host calibration is usually required to constrain H 0. To complement the Cepheid-host calibration in the SNe analysis, we use GC X-ray scaling relations as a complementary probe of anisotropy. We consider five redshift bins on the full SNe sample [z min, 0.5] where z min= 0.015, 0.03, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2. Our results show that the combined GC sample is consistent with statistical isotropy and that there is a about 2.5 σ anisotropy preference in the lowest-redshift bin in the SNe-only case. This preference weakens when low-redshift SNe are progressively removed. In the SNe + GC analysis, we find that any anisotropy preference is driven by how the H 0-M B and the H 0-k (where k is the normalization parameter in the GC scaling relation) degeneracies are treated. The low-redshift bin anisotropy preference in the SNe-only analysis persists in the SNe + GC case when Cepheid-host calibration is used while the results are consistent with statistical isotropy when k is fixed. Overall, our results do not provide compelling evidence for a statistically significant anisotropy in the local expansion rate. Our findings highlight the importance of combining complementary cosmological probes and examining the dependence of anisotropy constraints on calibrations and parameter degeneracies when assessing claims of cosmic anisotropy.

Sources

Related papers