First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the ψ(2S) resonance reports precise energy scan measurement of the cross section lineshape of ψ(2S) → K+K−, extracting a fundamental relative phase between strong and electromagnetic amplitudes and two distinct branching fraction solutions Measurement Methodology The analysis is based on e+e- collision data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 495 pb−1 collected with the BESIII detector at BEPCII By analyzing the cross section line-shape, the relative phase Φ between the strong and electromagnetic amplitudes of the ψ(2S) resonance is extracted, based on an assumption that the relative phase between the electromagnetic amplitude of the ψ(2S) resonance and the continuum is zero Two distinct solutions for the branching fraction B of ψ(2S) → K+K− are observed: a constructive interference solution with B = (7.49 ± 0.41) × 10−5 and Φ = (110.1 ± 6.7)◦, and a destructive interference solution with B = (10.94 ± 0.48) × 10−5 and Φ = (−106.8 ± 5.7)◦ Phase Extraction and Interference The relative phase Φ between the strong and electromagnetic (EM) amplitudes of the JPC = 1−− states is a fundamental parameter in particle physics, serving as a crucial input for studying quarkonium decays, particularly in charmonium systems The Feynman amplitude for vector charmonium states below the DD¯ threshold decaying into hadrons consists of two components: a three-gluon mediated strong amplitude Ag and a virtualphoton mediated EM amplitude Aγ Studies
1–6: reveal a striking relative phase Φ of ±90◦ between them in J/ψ decays, strongly indicating that the Φ could have a universal meaning
1, 7: in different decay modes The analyses based on SU(3) flavor symmetry
8: of the measured branching fractions reported very different values in different charmonium decays Form Factor Extraction The measured cross sections for e+e- → K+K- around the ψ(2S) also allow to extract the EM energy-dependent charged kaon form factor and the constant strong one The most general parameterization of the transition matrix Mµ EM
22: of the process γ∗ → K+K− contains only one EM form factor, FK(s), i.e., Mµ EM = eFK(s) p+ - p− Analogously, the transition matrix of the process ψ(2S) → 3g → K+K− is Mµ g = efK p+ - p−, where fK is the strong form factor, and it is defined only at the ψ(2S) mass Form Factor Comparison The modulus of the ψ(2S) strong form factor is proportional to the EM form factor through the parameter C/M2, i.e., fK = gγψ(2S) C/M2 FK(M2) = CFK(M2) r 3Γee αM The EM form factors of charged kaons are computed at all nine energy points based on the perturbative-QCD power-law behavior defined in Eq.
Kai: (3) As shown in Fig.
Title and authors: Kai: The title itself points to the core work here: an energy scan measurement of e plus e to kaons around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg1,energy scan measurement of $e>. It’s about mapping out the cross section lineshape for this decay.
Mira: And who did this, let's see. We have M. Ablikim, M. N. Achasov, P. Adlarson, X. C Ai, R Aliberti, and a whole group of collaborators listed on the first page of the paper > Page one --- First energy scan measurement of e +e − → K+K− around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg1>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, when you see this kind of scan, it means they're probing a specific region in the center-of-mass energy spectrum where we expect this psi(2S) state to be prominent > Page one --- First energy scan measurement of e +e − → K+K− around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg1>.
Kai: Exactly, and what does this measurement actually tell us? It’s about extracting a fundamental relative phase between the strong and electromagnetic amplitudes for this decay.
The paper's summary: Mira: The summary says they extracted a fundamental relative phase between the strong and electromagnetic amplitudes for the psi(2S) resonance, based on an assumption that the relative phase between these two amplitudes and the continuum is zero <ref:2603.29854#pg1>.
Kai: So it’s trying to nail down that phase parameter, which is super important for understanding quarkonium decays > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e +e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2> <ref:2603.29854#pg1,First energy scan measurement of e +e>.
Lev: If they can pin down this phase, it helps us understand the underlying dynamics of how these heavy quark states transition into hadrons, which is where we often run into problems on real hardware when trying to model these transitions accurately > Page three --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg3>.
Mira: They found two distinct solutions for the branching fraction B of psi(2S) into kaons <ref:2603.29854#pg1>. One is a constructive interference solution with B being seven point four nine times ten-five and a phase of one hundred ten point one degrees > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e +e − → K+K− around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2>.
Kai: And then there’s the destructive interference solution, where B is ten point nine four times ten-five and the phase is-one hundred six point eight degrees > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e +e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2>.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Now, this paper suggests some improvements to how we think about these measurements. They propose using the analysis of the cross section line-shape instead of just relying on SU(three) flavor symmetry analysis to extract those branching fractions B and phases <ref:2603.29854#pg3>.
Mira: That makes sense, because SU(three) symmetry has given us very different results in different charmonium decays, which suggests we need a more direct measurement like this one > Page one --- First energy scan measurement of e +e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg1>.
Lev: For real hardware, that means if we were building a detector to measure this, you wouldn't want to rely on some symmetry argument; you need the raw data from the collision event itself to get those distinct solutions > Page three --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg3>.
Kai: They also talk about extracting the electromagnetic energy-dependent charged kaon form factor and the constant strong one from these cross sections, which is a big deal for our understanding of how these particles interact electromagnetically > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2> <ref:2603.29854#pg1,First energy scan measurement of e+e>.
Mira: And they compare the modulus of the strong form factor to the electromagnetic one using a parameter C over M squared, showing how they relate through fK = g gamma psi(2S) C/M squared FK(M two) > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2> <ref:2603.29854#pg1,First energy scan measurement of e+e>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper, they show that by analyzing the cross section line shape, we can extract two distinct solutions for the branching fraction B and a fundamental relative phase between the strong and electromagnetic amplitudes.
Mira: This finding is important because it directly addresses how interference effects influence the measured branching fractions of psi(2S) decays > Page one --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg1>.
Lev: For running this on real hardware, it means that any error correction scheme needs to account for how these interference patterns might affect the measured signal, which is a subtle effect > Page three --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg3>.
Kai: They also do a combined fit to BESIII data using an ansatz for the form factor FK proportional to alpha s over sqrt s times n, and they find that n is about zero point nine six five, which is close to theoretical predictions but different from what BaBar measured, which suggests we still need more high-energy measurements.
Mira: It's a concrete result, showing how the measurement of this specific decay helps us constrain the parameters of the underlying theory regarding these quarkonium transitions > Page two --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg2> <ref:2603.29854#pg1,First energy scan measurement of e+e>.
Lev: The limitation they mention is that they are only measuring at a few energy points, so we don't have the full picture across the entire spectrum yet > Page three --- First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance <ref:2603.29854#pg3>.
Kai: So, this paper on "First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the psi(2S) resonance" gives us a clearer picture of the interference effects in charmonium decays and how to extract those crucial form factors from experimental data <ref:2603.29854#pg1,First energy scan measurement of e+e>.
Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing · Beihang University · Bochum Ruhr-University · Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics SB RAS (BINP) · Carnegie Mellon University · Central China Normal University · Central South University · Chengdu University of Technology
hep-ex
Submitted: 2026-03-31
Updated: 2026-07-27
Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures
Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 137 (2026) 11, 111904
DOI: 10.1103/q72k-vdtp
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the ψ(2S) resonance reports precise energy scan measurement of the cross section lineshape of ψ(2S) → K+K−…
Key concepts
- Relative Phase ($\Phi$)
- This is a key parameter representing the difference in phase between the strong force amplitude and the electromagnetic amplitude when decaying from a $\psi(2S)$ state. It is fundamental because it helps physicists understand how these two types of interactions interfere with each other during particle decay processes.
- Branching Fraction ($B$)
- This represents the probability that the $\psi(2S)$ resonance will decay specifically into a pair of charged kaons ($K^+K^-$). The study found two possible values for this probability based on whether the interference between strong and electromagnetic amplitudes is constructive or destructive.
- Form Factor ($F_K(s)$)
- A form factor describes how the interaction strength changes as a function of energy. In this context, it quantifies the electromagnetic coupling to charged kaons, allowing researchers to compare theoretical predictions with actual experimental measurements across different energy points.
Terminology
Summary
First energy scan measurement of e+e-to K+K- around the ψ(2S) resonance reports precise energy scan measurement of the cross section lineshape of ψ(2S) → K+K−, extracting a fundamental relative phase between strong and electromagnetic amplitudes and two distinct branching fraction solutions
Measurement Methodology
The analysis is based on e+e- collision data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 495 pb−1 collected with the BESIII detector at BEPCII By analyzing the cross section line-shape, the relative phase Φ between the strong and electromagnetic amplitudes of the ψ(2S) resonance is extracted, based on an assumption that the relative phase between the electromagnetic amplitude of the ψ(2S) resonance and the continuum is zero Two distinct solutions for the branching fraction B of ψ(2S) → K+K− are observed: a constructive interference solution with B = (7.49 ± 0.41) × 10−5 and Φ = (110. p. 31 ± 6.7)◦, and a destructive interference solution with B = (10. p. 394 ± 0.48) × 10−5 and Φ = (−106. p. 38 ± 5.7)◦
Phase Extraction and Interference
The relative phase Φ between the strong and electromagnetic (EM) amplitudes of the JPC = 1−− states is a fundamental parameter in particle physics, serving as a crucial input for studying quarkonium decays, particularly in charmonium systems The Feynman amplitude for vector charmonium states below the DD¯ threshold decaying into hadrons consists of two components: a three-gluon mediated strong amplitude Ag and a virtualphoton mediated EM amplitude Aγ Studies [1–6] reveal a striking relative phase Φ of ±90◦ between them in J/ψ decays, strongly indicating that the Φ could have a universal meaning [1, 7] in different decay modes The analyses based on SU(3) flavor symmetry [8] of the measured branching fractions reported very different values in different charmonium decays
Form Factor Extraction
The measured cross sections for e+e- → K+K- around the ψ(2S) also allow to extract the EM energy-dependent charged kaon form factor and the constant strong one The most general parameterization of the transition matrix Mµ EM [22] of the process γ∗ → K+K− contains only one EM form factor, FK(s), i.e., Mµ EM = eFK(s) p+ - p− Analogously, the transition matrix of the process ψ(2S) → 3g → K+K− is Mµ g = efK p+ - p−, where fK is the strong form factor, and it is defined only at the ψ(2S) mass
Form Factor Comparison
The modulus of the ψ(2S) strong form factor is proportional to the EM form factor through the parameter C/M2, i.e., fK = gγψ(2S) C/M2 FK(M2) = CFK(M2) r 3Γee αM The EM form factors of charged kaons are computed at all nine energy points based on the perturbative-QCD power-law behavior defined in Eq. p. 7 (3) As shown in Fig. p. 5
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved phase extraction capability: The improved AI system can extract two distinct solutions for branching fraction B, specifically a constructive interference solution with B = (7.49 ± 0.41) × 10−5 and Φ = (110.1 ± 6.7)◦, and a destructive interference solution with B = (10.94 ± 0.48) × 10−5 and Φ = (−106.8 ± 5.7)◦, by analyzing the cross section line-shape rather than relying solely on SU(3) flavor symmetry analysis.
-
Improved form factor determination: The system can extract the energy-dependent electromagnetic charged kaon form factor and the constant strong one by analyzing the measured cross sections for e+e− → K+K− around the psi(2S) resonance.
-
Improved correlation analysis: The AI system can establish a significant correlation between Φ and B, demonstrating that
interference effects must be taken into account in the ψ(2S) branching fraction measurements.
-
Improved comparison with experimental data: The system can perform a combined fit to BESIII data using the ansatz FK proportional to alpha s (√s)/sn with n free, achieving a fitted parameter n = 0.965 ± 0.024 for BESIII, which agrees with theoretical predictions but differs significantly from BaBar's n = 1.356 ± 0.047, highlighting the need for additional high-energy measurements.
-
Improved uncertainty quantification: The system can determine the total systematic uncertainty by adding all sources in quadrature and specifically account for parameter correlations using multivariate Gaussian sampling, deriving a central value for B from its distribution (Table II).
Sources
- Long-distance final-state interactions and J/psi decay
- A large final-state interaction in the 0-0- decays of J/psi
- A possible hadronic excess in psi(2S) decay and rho-pi puzzle
- On Large Final-State Phases in Heavy Meson Decays
- Phases and Amplitudes in Inclusive $\Psi$ and $\Psi'$ Decays
- Phase Difference Between the Electromagnetic and Strong Amplitudes for psi(2S) and J/psi Decays into Pairs of Pseudoscalar Mesons
- What do we learn from the $\rho-\pi$ puzzle
- Relativistic corrections to $\psi(nS)\to\rho\pi$ exclusive decays and their role in the understanding of the $\rho\pi$-puzzle
- The interference between virtual photon and 1-- charmonium in e+e-experiment
- Tests of flavor symmetry in J/psi decays
- Relative phase between strong and electromagnetic amplitudes in psi(2S) to 0- 0- decays
- First observation of psi(2S)-->K_S K_L
- Measurement of Interference between Electromagnetic and Strong Amplitudes in psi(2S) Decays to Two Pseudoscalar Mesons
- Study of the $e^+e^-\to K^+K^-$ reaction in the energy range from 2.6 to 8.0 GeV
- Measurement of \Gamma_{ee}(J/\psi)*Br(J/\psi->e^+e^-) and \Gamma_{ee}(J/\psi)*Br(J/\psi->\mu^+\mu^-)
- Measurement of the phase between strong and electromagnetic amplitudes of $J/\psi$ decays
- Isospin strikes back
- Luminosity measurements for the R scan experiment at BESIII
- Design and Construction of the BESIII Detector
- Exclusive event generator for $e^+e^-$ scan experiments
Related papers
- DrSai: an agentic AI system toward autonomous physics analysis workflows at BESIII
- CANTON- mu Proposal: A Next-Generation Muon g-2 Measurement at Sub-0.1 ppm Precision
- Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer
- ANUBIS detector and its sensitivity to neutral long-lived particles
- How to scale your HEP ML models: A recipe for robust architecture comparisons at scale
- Search for the 16 O(ppp) to 13 C pi+ pi+ e+ Decay Mode in Super-Kamiokande Using Machine Learning Techniques