Mapping the limits of equilibrium in sheared granular liquid crystals

arXiv:2603.25252 · cond-mat.soft, physics.class-ph · Submitted 2026-03-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Mapping the limits of equilibrium in sheared granular liquid crystals".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Athermal elongated particles can surprisingly arrange into ordered, equilibrium-like configurations when driven.

Kai: The orientational statistics of frictionless elongated granular particles under steady shear are quantitatively described by a mean-field Onsager-like theory when corrected via the Parsons–Lee scaling.

Mira: However, as inter-particle friction is introduced, the system moves from a quasi-equilibrium steric “screening” state to a far-from-equilibrium frictional “gearing” state.

Kai: Theoretical Framework and Breakdown The study tests whether the continuum framework originally developed for thermal nematic suspensions can be adapted for driven athermal grains.

Paper summary: Mira: To wrap up this paper "Mapping the limits of equilibrium in sheared granular liquid crystals", they've established a quantitative map of the transition from a quasi-equilibrium state to a far-from-equilibrium steady state in dense, driven systems.

Kai: What that means simply is that for these elongated particles under shear, there's a clear point where the simple mathematical description of equilibrium breaks down and you need to use concepts like the Pi parameter to tell if you are in the screening regime or the gearing regime.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this gives us a tool to incorporate into kinetic theories and rheological models for dense granular suspensions, which is a big step because it moves us beyond just observing what happens in simple flows.

Mira: The authors successfully demonstrated that simple noisy Jeffery orbits are insufficient when steric interactions become significant in these flows. They also found that the transition friction increases with aspect ratio, suggesting a universal cooperative mechanism for tumbling that doesn't depend on specific geometric details as much as we thought before.

Kai: So, the main thing to take away is that if you want to model dense granular flows accurately, you can no longer treat them as simple thermal systems under shear; you have to account for the non-equilibrium driving and how friction changes the dynamics.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we've seen how these particles behave under shear—initially, they look like they’re settling into some kind of neat, ordered pattern when things are frictionless and quiet.

Mira: Exactly. But this paper is about what happens when you introduce friction and start driving the system hard. It maps out exactly where that neat picture breaks down into something totally different.

Kai: The authors, they're looking at how these elongated particles, which we often treat like simple liquid crystals, actually behave when they have real friction between them under steady shear flow.

Mira: They test a few things to see if the old theories about thermal systems still apply to these driven granular materials. They find that there is a clear switch—a point where the system flips from behaving like it's trying to reach an equilibrium state to being dominated by the driving force itself.

Kai: It’s all about this parameter, this Pi number, which tells you if you are in the screening regime or the gearing regime. If Pi is small, it’s like they are fighting to stay ordered by their neighbors; if it's big, the driving force wins completely.

Mira: What this means for dense granular flows is that we can no longer just rely on simple math for how these things align under stress. We need a new way to model them when friction gets involved because the dynamics become fundamentally non-equilibrium in a predictable way.

Kai: It shows that those simple noisy orbits we used before aren't enough anymore when you have significant particle interaction and driving force competing against each other.

Mira: And it suggests we need to develop these new kinetic theories to actually predict the orientation of these materials accurately in real-world scenarios, whether that’s for granular machines or maybe something more complex.

Kai: We’re going to look at how this transition friction changes depending on the particle shape, and how that affects the whole picture.

Institute of Civil Engineering, Institute of Materials Science and Engineering, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL) · Computational Chemistry, Lund University

cond-mat.soft, physics.class-ph

Submitted: 2026-03-26

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 16 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review RESEARCH 8, 043151 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/cjdt-6d9p

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Athermal elongated particles can surprisingly arrange into ordered, equilibrium-like configurations when driven.

Key concepts

Onsager-like theory
This is the theoretical framework originally used for thermal nematic suspensions. It describes how particles align due to steric exclusion forces when the system is near equilibrium, suggesting a predictable ordering based on particle shape and density.
Ericksen number (Π)
This diagnostic parameter compares the non-equilibrium rotational driving force against the restoring force from steric ordering. A value much greater than one indicates that external driving dominates, pushing the system far away from its natural equilibrium state.
Screening regime
This is a quasi-equilibrium state found at low friction where frequent, frictionless collisions act like a thermal bath. In this regime, the particles behave as if they are in equilibrium because steric forces effectively mimic thermal noise.

Terminology

Summary

Athermal elongated particles can surprisingly arrange into ordered, equilibrium-like configurations when driven. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Granular materials, though athermal and dissipative, can surprisingly arrange into ordered, equilibrium-like configurations when driven1 . Elongated grains, for instance, exhibit isotropic–nematic transitions driven purely by geometric steric exclusion2–4 and align in shear flows 5–11, even at modest shape anisotropies 12 .

The orientational statistics of frictionless elongated granular particles under steady shear are quantitatively described by a mean-field Onsager-like theory when corrected via the Parsons–Lee scaling. p. 6
Where the paper says it

This confirms that Π is the correct metric to gauge distance from equilibrium for those grains elongated enough so that their distribution would be nematic in a thermal system. In summary, we have shown that the orientational statistics of frictionless elongated granular particles under steady shear are quantitatively described by a mean-field Onsager-like theory, 7

However, as inter-particle friction is introduced, the system moves from a quasi-equilibrium steric “screening” state to a far-from-equilibrium frictional “gearing” state. p. 0
Where the paper says it

At the same time, we demonstrate a systematic breakdown of this equilibrium analogy at two distinct limits: at low aspect ratios, where the equilibrium theory incorrectly predicts an isotropic state, and as inter-particle friction is introduced, where the system moves from steric screening to frictional gearing. We link this frictional breakdown directly to the system being driven far from equilibrium, as quantified by an effective Ericksen number that compares non-equilibrium rotational driving to steric ordering.

Theoretical Framework and Breakdown

The study tests whether the continuum framework originally developed for thermal nematic suspensions can be adapted for driven athermal grains. The evolution of the orientation distribution is governed by a Smoluchowski-type equation that balances rotation driven by macroscopic flow against effective diffusion caused by interparticle collisions. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Particles are defined by their polar deviation from the director, θ = arccos(u·n), and their in-plane flow angle ϑ. Following DEK theory 17,23 , the evolution of this distribution is governed by a Smoluchowski-type equation, which balances the rotation driven by the macroscopic flow against the effective diffusion caused by interparticle collisions.

In the weak shearing limit, if the driving flux balances the restoring diffusion, the steady state recovers the extended Maier–Saupe equilibrium distribution. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Eliminating time in favor of accumulated strain γ 21, the evolution equation is: ∂f ∂γ + ∇u · h J˜f i = D˜ r(f)∇u · [∇uf + f∇uUex] , (1) where ∇u is the gradient operator on the unit sphere, J˜ = J /γ˙ is the normalized driving and Uex is the mean-field steric potential 13,14. If the driving flux balances the restoring diffusion (in the weak shearing limit 27), the steady state (∂γf = 0) recovers the extended Maier–Saupe equilibrium distribution28: feq(θ) = 1 Z exp (U2S2P2(cos θ) + U4S4P4(cos θ)), (2) where Z is a normalization constant, θ is the angle with the director of the distribution, S2,4 = ⟨P2,4(cos θ)⟩ are the second and fourth nematic order parameters respectively, and P2,4 are the second and fourth order Legendre polynomials.

This distribution describes a steady state where steric exclusion forces particles to preferentially align along a common axis. p. 1
Where the paper says it

U2,4 are the shape-dependent steric strengths (see SI C). Physically, this distribution describes a steady state where steric exclusion forces the particles to preferentially align along a common axis, with S2 and S4 quantifying the sharpness of this alignment.

Transition from Quasi-Equilibrium to Far-From-Equilibrium

The transition between states is quantified by an effective Ericksen number, which compares non-equilibrium rotational driving to steric ordering. The diagnostic parameter is defined as Π, comparing the nonequilibrium driving flux to the quasi-equilibrium restoring flux. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The nonequilibrium driving flux, which forces tumbling, is set by the phenomenologically-determined rotational driving, J ∼ ⟨ω⟩. The quasi-equilibrium restoring flux arises from the system’s attempt to return to the nematic state feq, and scales as the rotational diffusion Dr multiplied by the characteristic theoretical gradient of the steric potential, |∇uUex| ∼ U2S eq 2 , where S eq 2 is the nematic order parameter from equilibrium theory and we neglected the smaller contribution of the P4 term.

The quasi-equilibrium “screening” regime corresponds to Π ≪ 1, where restoring steric flux dominates, while the far-from-equilibrium “gearing” regime corresponds to Π ≫ 1, where driving dominates. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The ratio of these two competing rates, which is the ratio of the two governing dimensionless numbers, defines Π: Π = ⟨ω⟩ DrU2S eq 2 . (3) This parameter maps the system’s state: the quasi-equilibrium “screening” regime corresponds to Π ≪ 1, where restoring steric flux dominates, while the far-from-equilibrium “gearing” regime corresponds to Π ≫ 1, where driving dominates.

Evidence of Breakdown Mechanisms

The breakdown of the equilibrium analogy is visualized in the orientational distributions. First, at low aspect ratios (α < 2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We show that when sheared for long enough, sufficiently elongated frictionless granular rods exist in a quasi-equilibrium state, whose orientational statistics are quantitatively described by classical liquid crystal theory, where the noise is provided by collisions due to shear. At the same time, we demonstrate a systematic breakdown of this equilibrium analogy at two distinct limits: at low aspect ratios, where the equilibrium theory incorrectly predicts an isotropic state, and as inter-particle friction is introduced, where the system moves from steric screening to frictional gearing.

5), the equilibrium theory predicts an isotropic state (Seq2 ≈ 0) due to negligible steric interactions, whereas simulation data reveals shear-induced nematic ordering driven by non-equilibrium alignment term J˜. p. 4
Where the paper says it

First, at low α (α < 2. 5), the equilibrium theory predicts an isotropic state (S eq 2 ≈ 0) due to negligible steric interactions, whereas the simulation data (dots) reveals shear-induced nematic ordering driven by the non-equilibrium alignment term J˜.

Second, at high friction (µp = 10. p. 4
Where the paper says it

5), the equilibrium theory predicts an isotropic state (S eq 2 ≈ 0) due to negligible steric interactions, whereas the simulation data (dots) reveals shear-induced nematic ordering driven by the non-equilibrium alignment term J˜. Second, at high friction (µp = 10.

0) and high α, the non-equilibrium “frictional gearing” actively disorders the system, broadening the distribution beyond thermal prediction. p. 4
Where the paper says it

0) and high α, the theory predicts a much sharper peak than observed. Here, the non-equilibrium “frictional gearing” (Π ≫ 1) actively disorders the system, broadening the distribution beyond the thermal prediction.

Robustness and Validation

The convergence to a Non-Equilibrium Steady State (NESS) is confirmed across all simulated systems. The orientational autocorrelation function in the low-friction “screening" regime collapses onto the single-exponential decay characteristic of nematic caged Brownian dynamics, confirming that frequent, frictionless collisions effectively mimic a thermal bath. Furthermore, Jensen-Shannon divergence analysis clearly identifies the quasiequilibrium region where error is negligible for α > 2.5 and µp ≤ 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

coefficient µp, and a restitution coefficient of 0. All systems consist of N = 2000 spheroids with a 20% degree of polydispersity3 , and are sheared at constant imposed normal stress P, maintaining an inertial number I = ˙γdp ρ/P ≈ 0.

1. The diagnostic parameter Π successfully quantifies the system’s distance from equilibrium across different particle shapes and friction levels. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The collapse confirms that Π acts as a control parameter: for Π ≪ 1 (steric screening), the system remains in a quasi-equilibrium state with minimal deviation, while for Π ≳ 1 (frictional gearing), the system is driven far from equilibrium, leading to a systematic power-law divergence from the theoretical prediction. To confirm the universality of these findings across different particle shapes and beyond ideal simulations, we carried out additional simulations of rod-like particles (see SI G) and compared our framework directly against experimental measurements of granular rods from Ref.

Quantifying Non-Equilibrium Signatures

The biaxiality parameter r serves as a key signature of nonequilibrium dynamics, showing a strong link between it and the diagnostic parameter Π. For elongated particles (α > 4. p. 0

Where the paper says it

bilotto@epfl. ch March 27, 2026 Abstract Athermal elongated particles are well-known to follow Jeffery orbits when sheared in viscous fluids.

0), the biaxiality r collapses onto an increasing function of Π, confirming that driving dominates when Π grows. p. 4
Where the paper says it

As expected, higher aspect ratios produce progressively sharper peaks. However, increasing friction (Π > 1) broadens the distributions, and the equilibrium Onsager–Parsons–Lee theory systematically fails, confirming the breakdown of the equilibrium analogy.

The transition friction µt increases monotonically with α, indicating that stronger nematics are mechanically harder to break. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The system is in the quasi-equilibrium limit (Π ≪ 1) for low friction. As µp increases, Π grows by orders of magnitude, crossing the Π = 1 threshold (dashed black line) and signaling a transition to a far-from-equilibrium, drive-dominated state.

This suggests a universal cooperative mechanism for the onset of tumbling independent of specific geometric details.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The results provide a quantitative map of the transition from a quasi-equilibrium to a far-from-equilibrium steady state in dense, driven systems. The diagnostic Ericksen number Π offers a new tool that can be incorporated into advanced kinetic theories and rheological models of dense granular and fiber suspensions. p. 7

Where the paper says it

This “screening-to-gearing” map, governed by friction and elongation, extends previous models for weakly anisotropic grains 32,33 and opens a path toward a predictive continuum theory. Our diagnostic Ericksen number Π provides a new tool that can be incorporated into advanced kinetic theories34,35 and rheological models of dense granular and fiber suspensions 36,37.

Closed form expressions for the driving term are currently being developed to lead to a fully predictive theory for the orientation of elongated athermal materials under shear. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Our diagnostic Ericksen number Π provides a new tool that can be incorporated into advanced kinetic theories34,35 and rheological models of dense granular and fiber suspensions 36,37. Closed form expressions for the driving term are currently being developed26 and could lead to a fully predictive theory for the orientation of elongated athermal materials under shear.

The paper successfully demonstrates that simple noisy Jeffery orbits are insufficient to model dense granular flows once steric interactions become significant. p. 7
Where the paper says it

originally developed for thermal systems, when corrected via the Parsons–Lee scaling. This confirms the existence of a “quasi-equilibrium" nematic state in a driven dissipative system, proving that simple noisy Jeffery orbits are insufficient to model the dynamics once steric interactions become significant.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. System can quantitatively map transitions from a quasi-equilibrium to a far-from-equilibrium steady state in dense, driven systems by using an effective Ericksen number that compares non-equilibrium rotational driving to steric ordering.

  2. The improved system can predict the orientation distribution of elongated grains by using a mean-field Onsager like theory corrected via Parsons Lee scaling, providing a quantitative description of nematic ordering in sheared flows.

  3. The system can identify and distinguish between two distinct breakdown mechanisms of the equilibrium analogy: shear dominance at low aspect ratio and frictional gearing at high inter-particle friction.

  4. The system can quantify the distance from equilibrium using the diagnostic metric Pi, which compares the driving flux to the restoring diffusion, mapping regions where Pi less than one as quasi-equilibrium and Pi greater than one as far-from-equilibrium.

  5. The improved AI can predict how rotational diffusivity scales with shear rate by validating that in athermal systems, collisions act as an effective thermal noise, with the effective rotational diffusion coefficient Dr being extracted from the orientational autocorrelation function decay.

Abstract

While elongated particles in viscous fluids follow Jeffery orbits, their dynamics in dense granular flows remain unresolved. We demonstrate that sheared, low friction granular rods do not follow these orbits, but instead reach a quasi-equilibrium state quantitatively described by classical liquid crystal theory, with collisions providing effective thermal noise. This quasi-equilibrium analogy breaks down at two limits: low aspect ratios, where the theory incorrectly predicts isotropy, and high inter-particle friction, which drives a transition from steric screening to frictional gearing. We map this far-from-equilibrium breakdown using a phenomenological effective Ericksen number, establishing the limits of thermal thermodynamic analogies in driven athermal matter.

Sources

Related papers