Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields

arXiv:2603.13210 · gr-qc, astro-ph.HE, hep-ph, hep-th · Submitted 2026-03-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields probes whether cosmic censorship holds when considering matter that violates the dominant energy condition by simulating spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field and finding no evidence for naked singularities or trapped surfaces in this setup.

Kai: Probing Cosmic Censorship The work investigates Penrose’s weak cosmic censorship conjecture by considering the spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field with negative energy density, which violates the dominant energy condition.

Mira: The authors aim to assess whether fully coupled evolution can dynamically generate or expose naked singularities once this condition is abandoned.

Kai: The simulations follow the nonlinear evolution of smooth, localized wave packets through collapse or dispersion.

Title and authors: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper, "Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields," by Caridi, Corelli, and Pani. It’s about testing Penrose’s weak cosmic censorship conjecture when we use matter that violates the dominant energy condition.

Mira: That sounds like a big thing for our understanding of gravity because standard assumptions often govern how collapse should behave. The authors are basically simulating the spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field with negative energy density to see if they can generate naked singularities without an event horizon.

Lev: Negative energy density is tricky; it means the matter has repulsive properties, which shouldn't normally lead to a black hole, but this setup deliberately throws that standard assumption out the window. We need to see how the evolution handles that kind of negative energy.

Kai: Exactly. They are using this phantom field as a laboratory to see if cosmic censorship is dynamically preserved even when we abandon those energy conditions. The core question is whether fully coupled evolution can generate those naked singularities or trapped surfaces they're looking for once we introduce negative energy density.

Mira: The paper’s summary suggests that for the phantom scalar field, the wave packets tend to disperse, which implies cosmic censorship stays preserved under their testing conditions. But they also mention a numerical breakdown point where things get weird, so it’s not a simple yes or no outcome.

Lev: That numerical instability is important because if it's just a numerical artifact, it means the underlying physics might still favor regularity, but if it’s real, we have to worry about what happens near that breakdown.

Kai: And what they do to improve things is introduce specific diagnostic thresholds when a black hole forms, halting the evolution right there using variables like gtt and quasi-local quantities. It’s a way to check for singularities without letting the simulation run forever into nonsense.

Mira: That's an interesting diagnostic approach because it lets them pinpoint exactly where the geometry might be breaking down physically versus just numerically. They also mention they introduced auxiliary variables, Theta and Pi, to rewrite the equations of motion in a form suitable for numerical evolution.

Lev: Rewriting the equations that way is standard procedure for numerical relativity when you want to keep things stable during integration. It helps manage those high-frequency modes they mentioned earlier by introducing a Kreiss-Oliger dissipation term.

Kai: So, to get into the details, they benchmark this against a canonical scalar field, which is the one with positive energy density, just to recover Choptuik’s critical behavior where things transition from dispersion to black hole formation. That gives them a baseline for what standard physics does.

Mira: And for that canonical case, they found that the critical amplitude A star separating dispersion from black hole formation converges toward zero point five six six Mtilde as the resolution of their simulation gets higher. It sets a very precise benchmark for when collapse becomes inevitable in standard scenarios.

Title and authors: Lev: That convergence point is crucial because it tells us where the physics fundamentally shifts, and they’ve shown that with negative energy density, things behave differently even at those critical points. The phantom field dynamics are qualitatively different from the canonical case.

Kai: Right, so for the phantom field specifically, small amplitudes disperse nicely, but for larger values it starts breaking down numerically around an amplitude A break which depends on the Courant factor CFL in a way that suggests it’s a numerical artifact rather than a real physical thing. That’s a key finding.

Mira: I think that distinction between numerical noise and genuine physics is vital because if the breakdown is just code error, then we can be more confident that cosmic censorship holds for those large amplitudes too, even with negative energy density.

Lev: But they also monitored the Misner-Sharp mass and found it stayed consistently negative throughout the evolution, which aligns with what you’d expect from a repulsive field's energymomentum tensor. That supports the idea that the field is doing exactly what we think it should be doing physically.

Kai: So, to wrap up, despite the numerical breakdown at large amplitudes for this phantom scalar field study of "Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields," they conclude that cosmic censorship appears to remain dynamically preserved even in the presence of negative-energy matter because they found no evidence for any trapped surfaces or singularities.

Mira: That means, based on their simulations, we can maintain confidence in Penrose’s conjecture even when we allow for violations of the dominant energy condition under these specific conditions. It confirms that gravitational focusing doesn't always lead to a singularity in this setup.

Lev: From my side, it means the numerical framework they built is robust enough to handle these highly dynamical regimes associated with large characteristic velocities, which is something real hardware development needs to consider if we want to test these kinds of extreme scenarios.

Kai: So, the paper shows that the repulsive nature of the phantom field systematically counteracts gravitational focusing and drives the system toward a regular dispersive state, confirming cosmic censorship in this specific context. We'll take a quick pause before we look at some other work on black hole thermodynamics.

Mira: That leads us nicely into what happens when we consider these negative energy scenarios more deeply, moving beyond just the scalar field to see how these effects manifest in more complex systems or different theoretical frameworks.

Lev: We’ll have to think about how much overhead we need on real hardware if we were actually trying to model those kinds of phantom fields with the fidelity they're aiming for here.

Kai: That's what we’ll be looking at next, when we discuss some of the other papers on arXiv that tackle these kinds of extreme gravitational dynamics.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, basically, the whole paper is about testing Penrose’s weak cosmic censorship conjecture by using matter that violates those standard energy conditions, specifically a phantom scalar field with negative energy density.

Mira: That means they are simulating how spherical collapse behaves when you have matter that has repulsive properties—negative pressure and negative energy density.

Lev: The main goal there is to see if this setup can actually create naked singularities or trapped surfaces without an event horizon forming. It's checking if cosmic censorship holds up when the usual rules are broken.

Kai: And what they found in the simulations is that for this phantom field, even at higher amplitudes, the wave packets tend to disperse instead of collapsing into a singularity.

Mira: That dispersion is what suggests that cosmic censorship remains dynamically preserved even with that negative energy matter present. It’s a pretty strong result if you think about how gravity usually works.

Lev: But they also looked at the numerical side, and there's this point where the simulation breaks down, which they found isn't really physics but a glitch in their numerical setup.

Kai: That breakdown point depends on how much computational effort you put in and the grid resolution you use for the simulation. It tells us that if we can get our simulations precise enough, regular evolution is always possible.

Mira: So, the paper suggests that even when you introduce these exotic fields violating energy conditions, gravity still seems to favor a smooth outcome rather than a naked singularity.

Lev: That’s important because if the theory predicts something else for negative energy matter—like an inevitable singularity—then we'd have to rethink those fundamental assumptions about gravity itself.

Kai: It confirms that the repulsive character of the phantom field actually counteracts gravitational focusing, pushing things toward a regular state instead of letting them collapse catastrophically.

Mira: So, it’s like saying that even with "bad" matter, as long as the field has this specific phantom nature, it gets pushed back into order.

Lev: That leads us to thinking about what happens when you move beyond just a single scalar field and look at more complex scenarios involving other fields or different types of gravity theories.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper lays out some specific improvements they think could make this kind of study more reliable by focusing on how they measure things and what variables they monitor during collapse.

Mira: They suggest that monitoring diagnostic variables like the Kretschmann scalar and the Misner-Sharp mass is key for spotting if a singularity or a trapped surface actually develops.

Lev: That’s practical because it gives you concrete numbers to track; you don't just have to guess if things are going haywire. It helps pinpoint exactly where the geometry breaks down.

Kai: They also point out that they should be paying close attention to how the breakdown of evolution changes based on the Courant factor, which is a measure of time step size in their numerical integration.

Mira: That’s important because it helps separate what’s just a numerical artifact from something that’s actually happening in the underlying physics of this phantom field.

Lev: I think that distinction is crucial for real hardware; if we can determine if a result is an error or a genuine physical effect, we know what assumptions to trust when scaling up the problem.

Kai: They also mention how convergence tests should scale with the ratio of the coarse sampling interval to the fine one, which gives them a way to prove their numerical code is actually accurate.

Mira: So, they’re pushing for better ways to prove that their method works and that they aren't just seeing noise in the data.

Lev: If you can control those errors down to a specific level of precision, it makes building real error correction schemes much more feasible because you know what kind of noise your system is dealing with.

Kai: It’s about making sure that when we finally cool and measure these things on real hardware, the fidelity is high enough to see these kinds of subtle physical effects clearly.

Mira: And this whole discussion about controlling the numerical errors gives us a better idea for how we need to model any theory that involves fields violating standard energy conditions.

Lev: It's about translating those theoretical needs into practical constraints on the hardware you'd need to build to run these complex simulations effectively.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, we looked at "Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields," and essentially, they tested whether negative energy matter can still lead to regular spacetime instead of a naked singularity.

Mira: The main implication is that even when you allow for energy conditions to be violated by phantom fields, the repulsive nature of that field seems to drive things toward a smooth evolution rather than collapse.

Lev: From my side, it’s good evidence for how the structure of the equations dictates a certain behavior, and if you can model those instabilities correctly, you can predict what happens in these extreme regimes.

Kai: The numerical tests showed that for the phantom field specifically, this regular outcome was maintained across different initial conditions and amplitudes tested.

Mira: That’s what really needs to be taken away: the result hinges on the specific assumption about how that scalar field couples to gravity, which they've shown holds up under these specific test conditions.

Lev: It means that for real error correction research, we need to be careful not just with the dynamics, but with how those non-standard terms affect the stability of any numerical scheme you build.

Kai: So it proves that in this specific setup, cosmic censorship isn't immediately broken by negative energy density matter.

Mira: It’s a confirmation that the mathematical structure we’re using still imposes constraints on gravity, even when we push the energy conditions to their limits with phantom fields.

Lev: And for future work, it suggests that if you want to explore these things further, you need robust tools that can handle the high-frequency modes they mentioned without getting bogged down in numerical noise.

Kai: So yeah, this paper gives us a solid piece of evidence that cosmic censorship is robust in this context, even with those exotic matter sources.

Mira: It opens up the door to thinking about how these types of energy violations might affect more complex systems in cosmology or quantum gravity models later on.

Lev: We'll keep an eye on what they do next because understanding these dynamical regimes is exactly what we need to know when building simulators for real-world physics.

Giovanni Caridi, Fabrizio Corelli, Paolo Pani

Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza University of Rome · INFN Sezione di Roma · Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute)

gr-qc, astro-ph.HE, hep-ph, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-03-13

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 15 pages, 18 figures; v2: version accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D

DOI: 10.1103/3c7y-437m

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields probes whether cosmic censorship holds when considering matter that violates the dominant energy condition by simulating spherical collapse…

Key concepts

Phantom Scalar Field
This is a specific type of scalar field characterized by a negative kinetic energy term, leading to negative energy density. This violates the dominant energy condition, meaning it possesses repulsive gravitational properties that counteract normal matter's tendency to collapse into black holes.
Weak Cosmic Censorship Conjecture
This conjecture suggests that singularities formed by gravitational collapse must always be hidden behind an event horizon, preventing them from being visible to outside observers. The paper tests if this holds when the collapsing matter violates standard energy conditions.
Misner-Sharp Mass
This is a measure used in general relativity to quantify the mass enclosed within a specific spatial volume. For phantom fields, this mass remains consistently negative, reflecting the repulsive nature of the field's stress-energy tensor throughout the evolution.

Terminology

Summary

Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields probes whether cosmic censorship holds when considering matter that violates the dominant energy condition by simulating spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field and finding no evidence for naked singularities or trapped surfaces in this setup. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Challenging the Weak Cosmic Censorship with Phantom Fields Giovanni Caridi,1, 2 Fabrizio Corelli,3, 1, 2 and Paolo Pani1, 2 1Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Universit`a di Roma, Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, 00185, Roma, Italy 2 INFN, Sezione di Roma, Piazzale Aldo Moro 2, 00185, Roma, Italy 3Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany Penrose’s weak cosmic censorship conjecture asserts that spacetime singularities produced by gravitational collapse are generically hidden behind event horizons, thus preventing them from causally influencing distant observers and preserving the predictability of the exterior region. In this work, we probe this conjecture in a setup that deliberately violates one of its central assumptions – the dominant energy condition – by considering the spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field with negative energy density.

Probing Cosmic Censorship

The work investigates Penrose’s weak cosmic censorship conjecture by considering the spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field with negative energy density, which violates the dominant energy condition. The authors aim to assess whether fully coupled evolution can dynamically generate or expose naked singularities once this condition is abandoned. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In principle, such a field could produce a Schwarzschild geometry with negative mass and therefore no event horizon. Our aim is to assess whether, once the dominant energy condition is abandoned, the fully coupled evolution of matter and geometry can dynamically generate or expose naked singularities, thereby probing the robustness of cosmic censorship.

The simulations follow the nonlinear evolution of smooth, localized wave packets through collapse or dispersion. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To this end, we perform high-accuracy numerical relativity simulations based on fourth-order finite-difference schemes. Starting from smooth, asymptotically flat initial data representing regular phantom scalar wave packets, we follow their fully nonlinear evolution through collapse or dispersion.

While an ordinary scalar field exhibits standard critical behavior, the phantom field displays qualitatively different dynamics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Starting from smooth, asymptotically flat initial data representing regular phantom scalar wave packets, we follow their fully nonlinear evolution through collapse or dispersion. While an ordinary (positive-energy) scalar field exhibits the standard Choptuik critical behavior at the threshold of black-hole formation, the phantom field displays qualitatively different dynamics.

For all amplitudes considered, the phantom scalar field always disperses, suggesting that cosmic censorship remains dynamically preserved even with negative-energy matter. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For all amplitudes considered, we find no evidence for trapped surfaces, naked singularities, or alternative stationary end states. Instead, the phantom scalar field always disperses, suggesting that cosmic censorship remains dynamically preserved even in the presence of negative-energy matter.

Numerical Methodology

The numerical setup simulates the spherical collapse of wave packets in an asymptotically flat background using Schwarzchild-like coordinates. The evolution equations are derived from the Einstein-KleinGordon system, where C = +1 for a phantom field and C = −1 for a canonical scalar field. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Evolution equations and constraints We consider the spherically symmetric Einstein-KleinGordon system for a real scalar field ξ. The action is S = 1 16π Z Ω √ −g h R + C(∇µξ)(∇µ ξ) i d 4x, (1) where R is the Ricci scalar, ξ is the scalar field, gµν is the spacetime metric, and C ∈ {+1, −1} determines the sign of the kinetic term: C = +1 for a phantom field, and C = −1 for a canonical scalar field.

The numerical integration employs the method of lines, using a fourth-order accurate Runge-Kutta method for time integration and fourth-order accurate centered finite differences for spatial derivatives. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(8)–(11) is performed using the method of lines [37]: the evolution equations are integrated in time at each grid point, while the spatial derivatives on the right-hand sides are evaluated by finite differences. Specifically, we employ the fourth order accurate Runge-Kutta method for time integration, and the fourth order accurate centered finite differences formula for the spatial derivatives.

A fifth-order Kreiss-Oliger dissipation term is introduced to suppress numerical instabilities arising from high-frequency modes. p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 and starting from r∞+2 (where the values of the fields are given by our boundary conditions) allows us to reach fourth order convergence on the last grid point r∞. To ensure the stability of the evolution and suppress numerical instabilities arising from high-frequency modes, we introduce a fifth-order Kreiss-Oliger dissipation term [39, 40], defined as ∂tu → ∂tu − ηKO 64∆t (∆r) 6 (D3 +D3 −u), (21) where u denotes a generic field, ηKO is a coefficient to be fixed below, while D± are first-order finite difference operators with one-sided backward (−) and forward (+) schemes.

Canonical Field Benchmark

To validate the numerical implementation, simulations of a canonical scalar field (C = −1) are performed to recover Choptuik’s critical behavior. For sufficiently small amplitudes, the canonical field disperses, leaving behind a regular spacetime. p. 5

Where the paper says it

To this end, we set C = −1 and considered Gaussian initial data with fixed parameters σ = M˜ and r0 = 10M˜ , varying only the amplitude A of the scalar field. For sufficiently small amplitudes, the scalar field disperses, leaving behind a regular spacetime.

For larger initial amplitudes, the evolution leads to black-hole formation, where the outgoing characteristic velocity v+ decreases and eventually approaches zero within a finite radial interval. p. 5
Where the paper says it

As time progresses, the outgoing characteristic velocity v+ decreases and eventually approaches zero within a finite radial interval. In this region, the evolution effectively freezes, reflecting the fact that outgoing light rays can no longer propagate to larger radii.

The critical amplitude A∗ separating dispersion from black-hole formation is found to converge toward 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Right panels: Initial amplitude A = M˜ ; the vanishing of v+ within a finite region signals the formation of a trapped surface and an apparent horizon. Critical amplitude A ∗ separating dispersion from black-hole formation as a function of spatial resolution Np.

566M˜ as resolution increases. p. 6
Where the paper says it

As the resolution increases, A ∗ converges toward 0. 566M˜ , demonstrating numerical robustness.

Phantom Field Dynamics and Breakdown

For the phantom scalar field (C = +1), the wave packet disperses for small amplitudes, but for larger values, the numerical evolution eventually breaks down. The threshold amplitude Abreak exhibits a strong dependence on the CFL factor, indicating that the observed breakdown is primarily of numerical origin rather than a genuine physical effect. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The absence of a common asymptotic value toward which Abreak converges indicates that the observed breakdown is a numerical artifact rather than a genuine physical effect. In particular, the strong dependence of Abreak on the CFL factor shows that the choice of time step plays a dominant role in resolving the dynamics.

The Misner-Sharp mass remains consistently negative throughout the evolution, consistent with the repulsive character of the field’s energymomentum tensor. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In all simulations performed with the phantom field, the Misner-Sharp mass remains consistently negative throughout the evolution. This behavior is consistent with the repulsive character of the field’s energymomentum tensor, which violates the standard energy Figure 7.

Curvature Analysis and Conclusion

The Kretschmann scalar is monitored to assess singularity development, and no trapped surfaces or singularities are observed in any simulation. The repulsive character of the phantom field systematically counteracts gravitational focusing and drives the system toward a regular dispersive state. p. 9

Where the paper says it

While the Gaussian perturbation typically propagates inward and either disperses or collapses within a finite time, the step-like configuration evolves more gradually, producing successive wavefronts and a less regular temporal pattern. This setup therefore provides a complementary probe of the dynamics, allowing us to assess how sharper gradients and multiple time scales affect the gravitational focusing properties of the phantom field.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

While the Gaussian perturbation typically propagates inward and either disperses or collapses within a finite time, the step-like configuration evolves more gradually, producing successive wavefronts and a less regular temporal pattern. This setup therefore provides a complementary probe of the dynamics, allowing us to assess how sharper gradients and multiple time scales affect the gravitational focusing properties of the phantom field.

Overall, cosmic censorship appears to remain dynamically preserved even in the presence of negative-energy matter. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For all amplitudes considered, we find no evidence for trapped surfaces, naked singularities, or alternative stationary end states. Instead, the phantom scalar field always disperses, suggesting that cosmic censorship remains dynamically preserved even in the presence of negative-energy matter.

The numerical framework proves robust and well controlled, successfully handling the highly dynamical regime associated with large characteristic velocities. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(21) is fixed to ηKO = 0. Threshold of numerical breakdown To determine whether the numerical breakdown observed at large amplitudes A reflects a genuine change in the dynamical behavior of the system or merely a numerical artifact, we investigate the threshold amplitude Abreak at which the evolution ceases to be well resolved.

Appendix Validation

Convergence tests for the numerical code show that constraint violation scales as CV∆rcoarse = ∆rcoarse/∆rfine 4. The analysis confirms that deviations at late times are consistent with the influence of Kreiss-Oliger dissipation rather than deficiencies in the underlying scheme. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Overall, within the explored parameter range, our results show no evidence for the formation of trapped surfaces, naked singularities, or alternative exotic configurations during the collapse of the phantom field. Furthermore, to verify that the observed breakdown is primarily driven by the choice of time step rather than by the Kreiss-Oliger dissipation operator, we performed an additional analysis varying the dissipation parameter ηKO, with fixed r0 = 10M˜ and σ = M˜ .

The study demonstrates that a regular evolution can, in principle, always be achieved provided the CFL factor is sufficiently small. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In particular, the strong dependence of Abreak on the CFL factor shows that the choice of time step plays a dominant role in resolving the dynamics. In other words, our results suggest that a regular evolution can, in principle, always be achieved provided the CFL factor is sufficiently small.

The critical amplitude depends only weakly on ηKO, confirming that the dominant source of the breakdown is the temporal discretization. p. 8
Where the paper says it

019 tions of at most a few ×10−2 , whereas it is significantly more sensitive to the numerical resolution and the time step. This demonstrates that our determination of the critical threshold is robust with respect to the amount of numerical dissipation and confirms that the dominant source of the breakdown is the temporal discretization.

The results show no evidence for negative-mass Schwarzschild solutions or other stationary exotic remnants within the explored parameter space. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In the present case, however, no trapped region forms and the field ultimately disperses. Overall, within the explored parameter range, our results show no evidence for the formation of trapped surfaces, naked singularities, or alternative exotic configurations during the collapse of the phantom field.

No indication of singularity formation, horizon development, or alternative stationary solutions such as wormholelike geometries is found. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(34) We will typically take ε = 10−6 as a fiducial value. The combined use of the Kretschmann scalar and this horizon-finding criterion allows us to characterize the end state of the spherical collapse, distinguishing between dispersion, black-hole formation, and potential violations of cosmic censorship or the emergence of alternative stationary configurations.

The repulsive character of the phantom field systematically counteracts gravitational focusing and drives the system toward a regular dispersive state. The numerical framework developed in this work proves robust and well controlled, successfully handling the highly dynamical regime associated with large characteristic velocities. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(21) is fixed to ηKO = 0. Threshold of numerical breakdown To determine whether the numerical breakdown observed at large amplitudes A reflects a genuine change in the dynamical behavior of the system or merely a numerical artifact, we investigate the threshold amplitude Abreak at which the evolution ceases to be well resolved.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. System can dynamically assess whether cosmic censorship is preserved by simulating phantom scalar fields, specifically probing the robustness of cosmic censorship beyond its standard assumptions.

  2. The system can differentiate between numerical artifacts and genuine physical mechanisms by analyzing how the critical amplitude Abreak changes with spatial resolution and the Courant factor CFL, as the paper notes that the observed breakdown is a numerical artifact rather than a genuine physical effect.

  3. The improved system can predict whether gravitational collapse leads to trapped surfaces or singular end states by monitoring diagnostic variables like the Kretschmann scalar and Misner-Sharp mass.

  4. It can determine if the breakdown of evolution is driven by temporal discretization versus spatial resolution, as it notes that the dominant source of the breakdown is the temporal discretization.

  5. The system can characterize qualitative spacetime dynamics for different initial conditions, distinguishing between the Gaussian packet represents a localized and smooth excitation and the double-tanh profile describes an extended configuration featuring quasi-stationary regions separated by steep gradients at the edges.

Abstract

Penrose's weak cosmic censorship conjecture asserts that spacetime singularities produced by gravitational collapse are generically hidden behind event horizons, thus preventing them from causally influencing distant observers and preserving the predictability of the exterior region. In this work, we probe this conjecture in a setup that deliberately violates one of its central assumptions - the dominant energy condition - by considering the spherical collapse of a phantom scalar field with negative energy density. In principle, such a field could produce a Schwarzschild geometry with negative mass and therefore no event horizon. Our aim is to assess whether, once the dominant energy condition is abandoned, the fully coupled evolution of matter and geometry can dynamically generate or expose naked singularities, thereby probing the robustness of cosmic censorship. To this end, we perform high-accuracy numerical relativity simulations based on fourth-order finite-difference schemes. Starting from smooth, asymptotically flat initial data representing regular phantom scalar wave packets, we follow their fully nonlinear evolution through collapse or dispersion. While an ordinary (positive-energy) scalar field exhibits the standard Choptuik critical behavior at the threshold of black-hole formation, the phantom field displays qualitatively different dynamics. For all amplitudes considered, we find no evidence for trapped surfaces, naked singularities, or alternative stationary end states. Instead, the phantom scalar field disperses in all the configurations studied. Within the parameter space explored, we find no dynamical violation of cosmic censorship.

Sources

Related papers