Parameter adjustment of nuclear leading-order local pairing energy density functionals
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Parameter adjustment of nuclear leading-order local pairing energy density functionals".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This study reports on benchmarking a protocol for adjusting parameters of a local leading-order (LO) T = 1 (like-particle) pairing energy density functional (EDF) by adjusting the density-dependence of the 1S0 pairing gap at the chemical potential in infinite nuclear matter (INM).
Kai: When using a suitably chosen reference calculation, this protocol yields consistent results for the odd-even staggering of masses of spherical and heavy deformed nuclei and also for the rotational moments of inertia calculated in a time-reversal-breaking cranked HFB approach.
Mira: The main goals of this study are: 1.
Kai: The set-up of tools for calculating isospinasymmetric paired INM under conditions matching those used to calculate paired finite nuclei with Skyrme ph EDFs, in both standard NLO and extended N2LO forms.
Paper summary: Kai: The paper focuses on adjusting parameters for a local leading-order T = one like-particle pairing energy density functional by tweaking the density dependence of the oneS zero pairing gap at the chemical potential in infinite nuclear matter > <ref:2603.13164#pg1,T = 1 like-particle pairing>
Mira: They set up tools to calculate isospinasymmetric paired INM under conditions that match those used for finite nuclei calculations with Skyrme ph EDFs, using both standard NLO and extended N2LO forms >
Lev: And they analyze how each parameter of that density-dependent local LO T = one pairing EDF affects the pairing correlations in INM > <ref:2603.13164#pg1>
Kai: Then they look at the connection between those pairing correlations in INM and finite nuclei, figuring out how that link can be used to adjust the parameters of these LO pairing EDFs so they perform consistently regardless of the underlying ph mean fields >
Mira: They also analyze three observables: odd-even staggering of masses, charge radii, and rotational moment of inertia in yrast bands >
Lev: A key finding is that gaps at the chemical potential aren't enough to fully describe the pairing interaction in infinite matter >
Kai: They found that some parameter regions lead to a nonphysical transition to a Bose-Einstein condensate of di-nucleons even when they produce realistic pairing correlations for well-bound nuclei >
Mira: They also looked at the correlation between effective mass and parameters controlling the form factor of the density dependence when reproducing pairing gaps in INM >
Lev: And they found that including or not including spin-gradient terms in the particle-hole part of the Skyrme EDF has a significant impact on the odd-even staggering of masses >
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up the "Parameter adjustment of nuclear leading-order local pairing energy density functionals," these authors are showing that tuning those specific parameters based on infinite matter results helps align the pairing description across different mean field choices >
Mira: What this really means is that you can use the behavior in a simpler system, like INM, to guide how you adjust your model for more complex systems like finite nuclei without having to start from scratch every time >
Lev: The paper points out a limitation: adjusting the gaps based on infinite matter doesn't fully capture how an energy cutoff acts differently when you move from infinite matter to a finite nucleus >
Kai: And they specifically showed that using some parameter sets, like LOD1S, can actually overestimate the odd-even staggering of neutron pairing gaps compared to experimental data >
Mira: That’s a warning that even this protocol isn't perfect and you still have to be careful when applying it to get those precise results for isotopes >
Lev: It highlights that the gap at the chemical potential isn't the whole story for describing pairing in infinite matter, which is a crucial detail for anyone building real hardware or large-scale simulations >
Universite Claude Bernard Lyon 1 · CNRS / IN2P3 / IP2I Lyon
nucl-th
Submitted: 2026-03-13
Updated: 2026-10-29
Comments: revised version after implementation of the referees' suggestions. 48 pages, 24 figures
Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. A 62, 212 (2026)
DOI: 10.1140/epja/s10050-026-01968-4
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: This study reports on benchmarking a protocol for adjusting parameters of a local leading-order (LO) T = 1 (like-particle) pairing energy density functional (EDF) by adjusting the density-dependence…
Terminology
Summary
This study reports on benchmarking a protocol for adjusting parameters of a local leading-order (LO) T = 1 (like-particle) pairing energy density functional (EDF) by adjusting the density-dependence of the 1S0 pairing gap at the chemical potential in infinite nuclear matter (INM). p. 0 When using a suitably chosen reference calculation, this protocol yields consistent results for the odd-even staggering of masses of spherical and heavy deformed nuclei and also for the rotational moments of inertia calculated in a time-reversal-breaking cranked HFB approach. p. 0
The main goals of this study are:
-
The set-up of tools for calculating isospinasymmetric paired INM under conditions matching those used to calculate paired finite nuclei with Skyrme ph EDFs, in both standard NLO and extended N2LO forms. p. 1
-
The analysis of the effect of each parameter of the density-dependent local LO T = 1 pairing EDF on pairing correlations in INM. p. 1
-
The analysis of the connection between pairing correlations in INM and finite nuclei, and how this link can be used to adjust parameters of LO pairing EDFs that have comparable performance irrespective of the underlying ph mean fields. p. 1
-
The analysis of results for three observables sensitive to pairing correlations: the odd-even staggering of masses, the odd-even staggering of charge radii, and the rotational moment of inertia in yrast bands. p. 1
The study investigates several consequences, including:
(i) Illustration that gaps at the chemical potential are not sufficient to completely characterize the pairing interaction in infinite matter.
(ii) Finding that some regions of the parameter space for the density dependence lead to a spurious transition to a Bose-Einstein condensate of di-nucleons despite producing realistic pairing correlations for well-bound nuclei. p. 0
(iii) The correlation between effective mass and parameters controlling the form factor of the density dependence when reproducing pairing gaps in infinite matter. p. 0
(iv) The significant impact on odd-even staggering of masses made by including or not the spin-gradient terms in the particle-hole part of the Skyrme EDF. p. 0
(v) The sizeable impact of keeping or not contributing to mean fields from the density-dependent LO pairing EDF on the odd-even staggering of radii. p. 0
The study compares results obtained using different reference calculations for INM, including those based on Gogny D1S and those based on SLy4+ULB, to adjust the parameters of the LO pairing EDF (Eq. p. 1 1). It is found that adjusting these parameters to reproduce the gaps from symmetric INM with SLy4+ULB leads to results that are very well reproduced in finite nuclei when compared against data for various Skyrme ph EDF parametrisations. p. 0
The analysis also shows that reproducing the Gogny D1S pairing gaps in INM requires a more mixed
character with about 20% volume contribution and a much more peaked density dependence than what is found for SLy4+ULB, suggesting that the gap at the chemical potential is not fully representative of the pairing interaction in infinite matter.
The study analyzes three observables:
-
The odd-even staggering of nuclear masses (probed by blocking a quasiparticle). p. 7
-
The odd-even staggering of nuclear charge radii (sensitive to changes in single-particle Hamiltonian potentials when blocking a quasiparticle). p. 1
-
The moment of inertia of collective rotational bands (probes superfluidity induced by pairing correlations). p. 3
The results confirm that for the LOULB parameter sets, the contribution of the pairing EDF to the potential F1,1q(r) is included and necessary for obtaining reasonable odd-even staggering of charge radii in Sn and Yb isotopes. p. 0 In contrast, LOD1S parameter sets overestimate pairing gaps in finite nuclei because they yield a mix of surface and volume features that results in too large matrix elements for states within a given spherical j shell. p. 3
The study concludes that adjusting the parameters of an LO pairing EDF to the INM gaps from Gogny D1S is not sufficient to replicate the performance of the Gogny force for pairing gaps in finite nuclei, as it fails to account for how an energy cutoff acts differently in infinite matter versus finite nuclei. p. 0 The LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the odd-even staggering of neutron pairing gaps compared to experimental data. p. 0
Relevant excerpts:
"This study reports on the benchmarking of a protocol for the adjustment of the parameters of a local leading-order (LO) T = 1 (like-particle) pairing EDF that consists in adjusting the density-dependence of the 1S0 pairing gap at the chemical potential in infinite nuclear matter (INM)."
"The main goals of this study are: 1. p. 1 the set-up of the tools for the calculation of isospinasymmetric paired INM under conditions that match the schemes used to calculate paired finite nuclei with the Skyrme ph EDF, used in both its standard NLO and extended N2LO forms; 2. p. 1 The analysis of the effect of each of the parameters of the widely used density-dependent local LO T = 1 pairing EDF on pairing correlations in INM; 3. p. 1 The analysis of the connection between pairing correlations in INM and finite nuclei, and how this link can be used to adjust the parameters of LO pairing EDFs that have comparable performance irrespective of the underlying ph mean fields; 4. p. 1 The analysis of results for three observables that are known to be sensitive to pairing correlations for isotopic chains of spherical and deformed nuclei obtained with symmetry-breaking 3d HFB calculations, which are the odd-even staggering of masses, the odd-even staggering of charge radii, and the rotational moment of inertia in the yrast band of even-even nuclei. p. 1"
In summary, adjusting the parameters of a LO pairing EDF to the INM gaps ∆q(kλ,q) at kλ,q obtained from the Gogny force is not sufficient to replicate the performance of the Gogny force for pairing gaps in finite nuclei.
The LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"In spite of uncertainties of the data and the many differences found between data and experiment, the LOULB parameter sets yield an odd-even staggering of charge radii of reasonable size, in particular for Sn and Yb isotopes, if, and only if, the contribution of the pairing EDF to F1,1q(r) is included."
The deeper origin of the problem is that for a finite-range pairing interaction like the Gogny force the gap at the chemical potential ∆q(kλ) is not fully representative for the pairing interaction in infinite matter.
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
The results obtained with SLy4+LOD1S pairing parameters yield much larger ∆(5)n than the LOULB, which in almost all cases largely overestimate the available data.
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1"
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.15 fm−1 for which the LOD1S parameter sets still yield finite gaps in INM while pairing is already almost broken down for the LOULB."
This explains why the LOD1S parameter sets significantly overestimate the ∆(5)n displayed in Fig. 17.
"The difference is made by the small region of momenta with kλ,q & 1.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Precise pairing parameter adjustment for Skyrme EDFs: The improved system can adjust LO pairing EDF parameters by using a reference calculation of paired infinite nuclear matter (INM) gaps from Gogny D1S or HFB calculations, specifically by using the full density dependence or k lambda q dependence of the gap as pseudo-data, rather than just a single density point.
-
Robust prediction across Skyrme parameter sets: The AI can predict global trends for pairing correlations in finite nuclei with any realistic Skyrme EDF parametrization by adjusting LO pairing EDF parameters to match these INM gaps, ensuring consistency irrespective of the underlying particle-hole mean field choice.
-
Discrimination between surface and volume pairing character: The system can distinguish between surface and volume character of the pair potential by analyzing how different combinations of density dependence parameter eta affect the gap in INM, as shown in Fig 9, which is crucial for correctly modeling phenomena like pair transfer reactions.
-
Identification of nonphysical instabilities: The AI can identify spurious transitions to a Bose-Einstein condensate of di-nucleons by analyzing specific regions of the parameter space for the T=1 LO pairing EDF that lead to this instability, even when realistic pairing correlations are produced in well-bound nuclei.
-
Quantitative assessment of structural sensitivity: The system can quantify how deviations in single-particle spectra around the chemical potential affect observables like odd-even staggering of masses and charge radii by analyzing how blocking incorrect configurations impacts the matrix elements delta ij.
Sources
- Skyrme-Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov mass models on a 3D mesh: V. The N2LO extension of the Skyrme EDF
- Pairing schemes for HFB calculations of nuclei
- Charge Radii Measurements of Exotic Tin Isotopes in the Proximity of $N=50$ and $N=82$
- Puzzling Isotonic Odd-Even Staggering of Charge Radii in Deformed Rare Earth Nuclei
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations