Loss-insensitive reduction of amplified quantum noise in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Loss-insensitive reduction of amplified quantum noise in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback".
Paper summary: Kai: We’ve been looking at the paper "Loss-insensitive reduction of amplified quantum noise in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback," and it really boils down to this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme having a simple structure and low noise, plus that loss insensitivity.
Mira: Yeah, so the authors show experimentally that they got a six decibel reduction of the amplifier’s output noise in an atomic Raman amplifier, and their theoretical analysis backs up those experimental results.
Lev: What this means for us is that we have a configuration where you get significant noise suppression without having to worry about external entanglement sources being lost or mismatched by the time they reach our device.
Kai: The paper points out that the intrinsic correspondence between the recycled optical field and the amplifier’s internal mode inherently eliminates those mode mismatch issues, which is a big win for integrated photonics.
Mira: Beyond just reducing noise, this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme offers potential for further advancement in on-chip squeezing within integrated photonics because it's self-contained.
Lev: It’s good to see that the experimental results align so well with the detailed theoretical analysis they did, which gives us confidence in implementing this kind of noise reduction mechanism on real hardware.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper by Wang and Zhu on loss insensitivity in Raman amplifiers using coherent feedback, and it’s all about how they manage the noise that builds up when you amplify a signal.
Mira: Right, they show how this single-path feedback setup lets you reduce that output noise level by six decibels in an atomic Raman amplifier. It's pretty neat because it doesn't seem to care much about the loss of light in the system.
Lev: I’m interested because typically when you add feedback loops, losses just eat your noise advantage, so seeing something that stays relatively stable even when the loss is high—like seven point five percent—that’s a practical thing for building real hardware.
Kai: Yeah, it really shows how this coherent feedback architecture works by recycling the amplifier's own output to create these internal correlations without needing any external entanglement sources or complicated mode matching.
Mira: The core idea is that by tapping a small piece of the Stokes field and feeding it back into the amplifier, you prepare atoms in states correlated with that input field, which squeezes out the excess quantum noise added by amplification.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if this works as described, it means we can build these low-noise devices on-chip without needing to maintain perfect vacuum conditions for external squeezing sources everywhere.
Kai: Exactly. The authors are pointing toward a configuration that has potential for dual-phase responsiveness—meaning you could control both the optical phase and the atomic state at once, which is important for sensor development.
Mira: That's what I'm thinking too. Because this single-amplifier scheme inherently links the recycled optical field to the amplifier's internal mode, which cuts out those frustrating mode mismatch issues we usually have with two-component setups.
Lev: So, it’s simple structure, low noise, and loss insensitivity. That’s a nice combination for someone trying to move this from theory into a functioning quantum sensor on a chip.
Kai: It seems like the next step is figuring out how robust this becomes when you actually try to implement the dual-phase control aspect they mention in their conclusion.
Jianmin Wang, Rong Zhu, Z. Y. Ou
City University of Hong Kong
quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-02-26
Updated: 2026-11-18
Comments: 19pages, 6 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
The gist: The single-path coherent feedback amplifier reduces quantum noise in a Raman amplifier by approximately 6 dB…
Key concepts
- Quantum Noise in Amplifiers
- Amplifiers inherently add extra noise by coupling to internal parts while boosting the signal. Quantum fluctuations play a role here, and without proper control, this can degrade the signal-to-noise ratio by 3 dB.
- Coherent Feedback Architecture
- This architecture combines correlation generation and amplification into one device. It uses the amplifier's own output to create internal quantum correlations, eliminating the need for external entanglement sources or mode matching, making it a simpler and more robust method for noise control.
- Loss Insensitivity
- The paper demonstrates that the noise reduction achieved by coherent feedback is not ruined by losses. Even when the amplifier suffers significant loss (up to 6 dB), the quantum noise suppression effect persists, unlike common assumptions where losses always worsen quantum performance.
Terminology
Summary
The single-path coherent feedback amplifier reduces quantum noise in a Raman amplifier by approximately 6 dB, demonstrating loss insensitivity and sensitivity to feedback phase
Introduction to Quantum Noise in Amplifiers
Amplifiers inevitably add extra noise through coupling to internal degrees of freedom while amplifying the signal The introduction of quantum correlations can effectively suppress this extra noise Down to the fundamental level, when all the classical noise is eliminated, quantum fluctuations play an important role in the noise performance of the amplifier and add excess noise in addition to the amplification of the input noise, leading to the infamous high-gain 3 dB degradation in the signal-to-noise ratio The added extra noise is due to the coupling to the internal degrees of freedom of the amplifier to acquire gain for the input Parametric amplifiers are a special type of amplifier achieved through nonlinear parametric interaction processes in which an idler field is involved and serves as the internal mode of the amplifier When its internal modes are placed in a squeezed vacuum state, its quantum fluctuations can be suppressed, and the extra noise added to the amplifier can be reduced The amplifier output noise can be further reduced when its internal modes are placed in a quantum-correlated state with the input field
Coherent Feedback Architecture
A coherent feedback architecture combines correlation generation and amplification in one device providing a simpler, more robust alternative to the traditional two-component setup Coherent feedback has emerged as a versatile tool in quantum optics over the past decade, enabling dynamic control of quantum systems without relying on external measurement or state preparation By recycling the amplifier’s own output to establish quantum correlations internally, this approach eliminates the need for external entanglement sources and the associated mode matching This arrangement allows the internal states of the atoms, which do not travel, to be correlated with the input and leads to the noise reduction in the amplifier’s output The paper investigates a coherent feedback amplifier that utilizes a Raman amplifier to prepare atoms in states correlated with the Stokes field by tapping a small portion of the output Stokes field and feeding it back into the amplifier
Theoretical Noise Analysis
The input-output relation for a Raman amplifier with Alkaline atoms as medium is given by Eq.(1) The output noise level is typically characterized as Δ2Xout = G squared + g squared = 2G squared − 1 ≡ Gqn When atoms are prepared in a correlated state with the input field, the fluctuation of Xˆain + XˆSin can be smaller than their respective vacuum fluctuations, leading to noise reduction The paper derives a noise reduction factor R ≡ Δ2Xb / Δ2Xt b using Eq. p. 3 However, when atoms (𝑆ˆ
𝑖𝑛) are prepared in a correlated state with the input field ( ˆ𝑎𝑖𝑛), the
fluctuation of 𝑋ˆ
𝑎𝑖𝑛 + 𝑋ˆ
𝑆𝑖𝑛 can be smaller than their respective vacuum fluctuations (20, 21), leading
to noise reduction (8). Our approach is to tap a small portion of the output Stokes and feed it back
to the amplifier for noise cancellation by quantum correlation.Where the paper says it
Experimental Verification and Results
The experimental results show a 6 dB reduction of the amplifier’s output noise in an atomic Raman amplifier The noise reduction increases with the increase of quantum gain of the bare amplifier, which is consistent with the theoretical predictions The single-path feedback is not sensitive to loss; even when the loss reaches 6 dB (L = 0.75), the noise reduction can still reach 3 dB The noise reduction factor is loss-insensitive, in contrast to the general belief that losses always degrade the quantum noise reduction effect
Conclusion and Potential
The single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme features a simple structure, low noise, and loss insensitivity This configuration holds the potential for dual-phase responsiveness to both optical phase and atomic state, a capability that could enable the realization of a low-noise amplifier-sensor hybrid device The intrinsic correspondence between the recycled optical field and the amplifier’s mode inherently eliminates mode mismatch issues Beyond noise reduction, this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme offers potential for further advancement in on-chip squeezing within integrated photonics The authors experimentally showed a 6 dB reduction of the amplifier’s output noise in an atomic Raman amplifier The experimental results were predicted by a detailed theoretical analysis and are in good agreement with them
References
-
H. Heffner, The fundamental noise limit of linear amplifiers. p. 0
Proc. IRE 50 (7), 1604–1608 (1962).Where the paper says it
In the process, noise is inevitably amplified as well. Down to the fundamental level, when all the classical noise is eliminated, quantum fluctuations play an important role in the noise performance of the amplifier (1–4) and add excess noise in addition to the amplification of the input noise, leading to the infamous high-gain 3 dB degradation in the signal-to-noise ratio (3).
-
H. A. Haus, J. A. Mullen, Quantum Noise in Linear Amplifiers Phys. p. 1
Rev. 128, 2407–2413 (1962).Where the paper says it
Their quantum fluctuations give rise to the extra noise. Parametric amplifiers are a special type of amplifier achieved through nonlinear parametric interaction processes in which an idler field is involved and serves as the internal mode of the amplifier.
-
C. Hong, S. Friberg, L Mandel, Conditions for nonclassical behavior in the light amplifier J. p. 5
Opt Soc Am B 2 (3), 494–496 (1985).Where the paper says it
Optical pumping is employed to prepare all atoms in the ground state(not shown in the figure). The Raman amplifier whose noise behavior we aim to characterize is pumped by the continuous light field W, and we measure its output quantum noise level by a homodyne detection with its local oscillator (LO) derived from another laser that is frequency tuned close to the Stokes field (about 6.
-
R. J. Glauber, AMPLIFIERS ATTENUATORS AND THE QUANTUM THEORY OF MEASUREMENT, in 6th INS Winter Seminar on Structure and Forces in Elementary Particle Physics (1986). p. 2
Where the paper says it
We find that the output is sensitive to the feedback phase, making it a promising tool for quantum sensing applications. Theoretical principles According to the general theory of quantum amplifiers (19), the output mode is amplified from the input by an amplitude gain of 𝐺, but is also coupled to its internal modes.
-
G. J. Milburn, M L Steyn-Ross, D F Walls, Linear amplifiers with phase-sensitive noise Phys. p. 0
Rev. A 35, 4443–4445 (1987).Where the paper says it
The single-path feedback amplifier is found to be sensitive to the feedback phase, a property that expands its potential for applications in quantum precision measurement, and the general concept can be extended to integrated optics and fiber optic systems. Amplifiers are widely used instruments in modern science and technology to enhance small signals to a level that can be observed.
-
Z Y Ou, S F Pereira, H J Kimble Quantum noise reduction in optical amplification Phys. p. 0
Rev. Lett. 70, 3239–3242 (1993).Where the paper says it
In this work, we utilize the established quantum correlation between the Stokes field and atomic spin waves in the Raman amplification process to feedback a portion of the Stokes field into the amplifier. This leads to a reduction in quantum noise that is independent of the feedback loss at high gain.
-
Z Y Ou Quantum amplification with correlated quantum fields Phys. p. 3
Rev. A 48, R1761–R1764 (1993).Where the paper says it
We define this as the quantum noise gain 𝐺𝑞𝑛 by the amplification of the vacuum noise for both the input and internal modes. However, when atoms (𝑆ˆ 𝑖𝑛) are prepared in a correlated state with the input field ( ˆ𝑎𝑖𝑛), the fluctuation of 𝑋ˆ 𝑎𝑖𝑛 + 𝑋ˆ 𝑆𝑖𝑛 can be smaller than their respective vacuum fluctuations (20, 21), leading to noise reduction (8).
-
J Kong, F Hudelist, Z Y Ou W Zhang Cancellation of Internal Quantum Noise of an Amplifier by Quantum Correlation Phys. p. 3
Rev. Lett. 111, 033608 (2013).Where the paper says it
However, when atoms (𝑆ˆ 𝑖𝑛) are prepared in a correlated state with the input field ( ˆ𝑎𝑖𝑛), the fluctuation of 𝑋ˆ 𝑎𝑖𝑛 + 𝑋ˆ 𝑆𝑖𝑛 can be smaller than their respective vacuum fluctuations (20, 21), leading to noise reduction (8). Our approach is to tap a small portion of the output Stokes and feed it back to the amplifier for noise cancellation by quantum correlation.
-
J Wang, R Zhu, Y Li Z Y Ou Observation of Quantum Noise Reduction in a Raman Amplifier via Quantum Correlation between Atom and Light Phys. p. 0
Rev. Lett. 135, 203602 (2025).Where the paper says it
Loss-insensitive quantum noise reduction in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback Jianmin Wang∗ , Rong Zhu∗ , Z. Ou† Department of Physics, City University of Hong Kong, 83 Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
-
S Lloyd Coherent quantum feedback Phys. p. 0
Rev. A 62, 022108 (2000).Where the paper says it
Loss-insensitive quantum noise reduction in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback Jianmin Wang∗ , Rong Zhu∗ , Z. Ou† Department of Physics, City University of Hong Kong, 83 Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
-
J E Gough, S Wildfeuer Enhancement of field squeezing using coherent feedback Phys. p. 7
Rev. A 80, 042107 (2009).Where the paper says it
This closed-loop design eliminates external entanglement sources, and the intrinsic correspondence between the recycled optical field and the amplifier’s mode inherently eliminates mode mismatch issues. Beyond noise reduction, this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme features a simple structure, low noise, and loss insensitivity, and also offers potential for further advancement in on-chip squeezing within integrated photonics.
-
C Sayrin et al., Real-time quantum feedback prepares and stabilizes photon number states Nature 477 (7362), 73–77 (2011). p. 6
Where the paper says it
The measured output Stokes noise level is shown in Fig. 3(a) as the red trace when the feedback is on and the feedback phase 𝜑 is scanned in time.
-
Y Zhong, J Jing Enhancement of tripartite quantum correlation by coherent feedback control Phys. p. 1
Rev. A 101, 023813 (2020).Where the paper says it
Given this, a coherent feedback architecture that combines correlation generation and amplification in one device provides a simpler, more robust alternative to the traditional two-component setup (10, 11). Coherent feedback has emerged as a versatile tool in quantum optics over the past decade, enabling dynamic control of quantum systems without relying on external measurement or state preparation, and has been adopted so far to assist with a diverse range of tasks (12–16).
-
A Harwood, A Serafini Ultimate squeezing through coherent quantum feedback Phys. p. 7
Rev Res 2, 043103 (2020).Where the paper says it
Beyond noise reduction, this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme features a simple structure, low noise, and loss insensitivity, and also offers potential for further advancement in on-chip squeezing within integrated photonics. When implemented with an atomic gain medium, it holds the potential for dual-phase responsiveness to both optical phase and atomic state, a capability that could enable the realization of a low-noise amplifier-sensor hybrid device and serve as a high-performance quantum sensor.
-
M Ernzer et al., Optical coherent feedback control of a mechanical oscillator Phys. p. 1
Rev X 13 (2), 021023 (2023).Where the paper says it
Given this, a coherent feedback architecture that combines correlation generation and amplification in one device provides a simpler, more robust alternative to the traditional two-component setup (10, 11). Coherent feedback has emerged as a versatile tool in quantum optics over the past decade, enabling dynamic control of quantum systems without relying on external measurement or state preparation, and has been adopted so far to assist with a diverse range of tasks (12–16).
-
K Vodenkova, H Pichler Continuous coherent quantum feedback with time delays Tensor network solution Phys. p. 6
Rev X 14 (3), 031043 (2024).Where the paper says it
The measured output Stokes noise level is shown in Fig. 3(a) as the red trace when the feedback is on and the feedback phase 𝜑 is scanned in time.
-
S Yokoyama et al., Feasibility study of a coherent feedback squeezer Phys. p. 0
Rev. A 101 (3), 033802 (2020).Where the paper says it
Loss-insensitive quantum noise reduction in a Raman amplifier with coherent feedback Jianmin Wang∗ , Rong Zhu∗ , Z. Ou† Department of Physics, City University of Hong Kong, 83 Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
-
S Iida, M Yukawa, H Yonezawa, N Yamamoto, A Furusawa Experimental demonstration of coherent feedback control on optical field squeezing IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 57 (8), 2045–2050 (2012). p. 7
Where the paper says it
This closed-loop design eliminates external entanglement sources, and the intrinsic correspondence between the recycled optical field and the amplifier’s mode inherently eliminates mode mismatch issues. Beyond noise reduction, this single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme features a simple structure, low noise, and loss insensitivity, and also offers potential for further advancement in on-chip squeezing within integrated photonics.
-
C M Caves Quantum limits on noise in linear amplifiers Phys. p. 1
Rev. D 26, 1817–1839 (1982).Where the paper says it
Their quantum fluctuations give rise to the extra noise. Parametric amplifiers are a special type of amplifier achieved through nonlinear parametric interaction processes in which an idler field is involved and serves as the internal mode of the amplifier.
-
M D Reid Demonstration of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox using nondegenerate parametric amplification Phys. Rev. A 40, 913–923 (1989).
-
Z Y Ou, S F Pereira, H J Kimble K C Peng Realization of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox for continuous variables Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 3663–3666 (1992).
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop quantum noise reduction in amplifiers by utilizing coherent feedback to recycle a portion of the Stokes field back into its input, which
leads to a reduction in quantum noise that is independent of the feedback loss at high gain.
-
Implement loss-insensitive noise cancellation schemes in amplifier systems by designing architectures where
the feedback part does not create the quantum correlation but is simply an injection into the amplifier, which is where the quantum correlation is generated for noise reduction.
-
Create phase-sensitive quantum sensors by designing single-path feedback amplifiers that are
sensitive to the feedback phase,
allowing for applications in quantum precision measurement. -
Design integrated optics and fiber optic systems that incorporate coherent feedback architectures, as the general concept
can be extended to integrated optics and fiber optic systems.
-
Develop hybrid amplifier-sensor devices by implementing a single-amplifier coherent feedback scheme that offers
dual-phase responsiveness to both optical phase and atomic state,
potentially enabling alow-noise amplifier-sensor hybrid device.
Abstract
A quantum amplifier usually adds extra noise inevitably through coupling to internal degrees of freedom while amplifying the signal. The introduction of quantum correlations can effectively suppress this extra noise. In this work, we utilize the established quantum correlation between the Stokes field and atomic spin waves in the Raman amplification process to feed back a portion of the Stokes field into the amplifier. This leads to a reduction in amplified quantum noise that is independent of the feedback loss at high gain. A maximum of 6 dB noise reduction is observed. The single-path feedback amplifier is found to be sensitive to the feedback phase due to quantum interference, and we experimentally demonstrate an improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio of 4.4 plus or minus 0.7 dB for a phase signal encoded in the feedback loop compared to the case without feedback. This general concept can be extended to integrated optics and fiber-optic systems with potential applications in quantum precision measurement.
Related papers
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements
- Barriers to dequantization of near-term molecular electronic structure methods
- BRIDGE: Lazy-Move Compilation for Dual-Species Neutral-Atom Quantum Computers
- Non-Hermiticity of an anomalous superradiant phase