Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law

arXiv:2601.17162 · gr-qc, hep-th · Submitted 2026-01-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law is explored by examining how time-dependent variations in fundamental constants affect compact systems and their evaporation dynamics.

Kai: Theoretical Framework of Varying Constants The paper investigates the Einstein equations with a time-dependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ, and non-conserved energy-momentum tensor Tµν.

Mira: The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

Kai: The covariant divergence ∇µTµν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

Title and authors: Kai: To recap, we're diving into the paper "Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law," which looks at how time-varying G and Lambda affect compact objects.

Mira: The authors are Julia Haba and Zbigniew Haba from the Institute of Theoretical Physics at the University of Wroclaw. They set up this framework by looking at non-conserved energy-momentum tensors alongside time-dependent G and Lambda.

Lev: When we look at the context, this work stems from a phenomenological description of fields and matter, which they call fluids, allowing them to derive the equations of motion for these fluids from the covariant conservation law of the energy-momentum twothree <ref:2601.17162#pg2,from the covariant conservation law of the energy-momentum>.

Kai: The paper notes that while standard Einstein equations with constant G and Lambda describe our solar system well—the Lambda CDM model—there are difficulties like dark matter or the coincidence problem.

Mira: This paper suggests that modified Einstein equations could come from an induced action resulting from quantum "matter" fields on a curved background, which can lead to a space-time dependent G nineteneleven <ref:2601.17162#pg2,from an induced action resulting from quantum "matter" fields on a curved>.

Lev: If we think about what this means for us, it opens the door to testing alternative gravity models beyond just standard Lambda CDM.

Kai: The paper also discusses how the cosmological term Lambda could be derived from the energy of the quantum vacuum, which is another route to a time-varying G twelve <ref:2601.17162#pg2,could be derived from the energy of the quantum vacuum>.

Mira: But they are careful; they acknowledge that in these modified models, things get complicated very quickly regarding how the entropy relates to the area of an event horizon.

Lev: It's a lot of assumptions underpinning this structure, so we have to keep an eye on those fundamental choices when we translate this into something testable.

Kai: So, looking ahead from here, we’ll see how these variations manifest directly in the black hole evaporation law itself.

The paper's summary: Mira: In terms of the summary, this paper focuses on how the Bianchi identity connects non-conservation of energy and momentum to those time variations in G and Lambda.

Lev: They show that for compact systems with mass M, this constraint leads directly to a power law relationship between G and M, which is G equals M minus gamma.

Kai: The crucial part they explore is how that gamma value gets determined by the assumptions about pressure or entropy.

Mira: If you define entropy as dS equals T minus one dM, then gamma equals one, which means a constant evaporation temperature if there's no pressure involved.

Lev: But if you assume the Bekenstein-Hawking formula for entropy applies even when G is changing with time, then gamma becomes two point three.

Kai: The paper then takes this and plugs it into the Stefan-Boltzmann law for mass loss, which gives them an explicit time dependence for G and M.

Mira: They compare the result from that method against what you get if you stick to the first law of thermodynamics when entropy is defined that way.

Lev: They find that these two approaches yield different results depending on whether you use the Bekenstein-Hawking formula for entropy or not when G is time-dependent three <ref:2601.17162#pg2>.

Kai: The summary basically boils down to this: the relationship between G and M depends entirely on whether you use a specific thermodynamic definition for entropy.

The paper's improvements: Lev: Now, looking at the improvements suggested by the paper, they focus on how we can handle these time-varying constants in effective field theories.

Kai: They suggest that if G is time-dependent, it might appear in effective field theories coming from things like Higgs gauge theories or Brans-Dicke theories.

Mira: They also mention that a renormalization of the Newton constant, like you see in some references thirteenfourteenfifteensixteen, can lead to a modified formula for entropy.

Lev: This connects back to microscopic counting, because they point out that the microscopic counting of states in loop quantum gravity doesn't fix the coefficient for entropy in front of the area as well.

Kai: So, it seems like they are suggesting that we need better ways to define how entropy scales when gravity itself is dynamic.

Mira: And specifically for models involving primordial black holes as dark matter, they suggest that a decreasing black hole temperature would be welcome in those specific models five <ref:2601.17162#pg2>.

Lev: That’s a practical suggestion because if you're modeling cold dark matter spikes around black holes, having the temperature decrease as you go is what makes that model more appealing.

Kai: It suggests that if we are looking for primordial black holes, we should look for evaporation laws where the temperature drops, not stay constant or explode.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up the paper "Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law," it shows that depending on gamma, the black hole temperature and luminosity can either shoot up in finite time, stay steady for its whole life, or drop off in finite or infinite time.

Mira: That dependence on gamma is what allows them to predict these different behaviors based on whether you use zero pressure or the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula.

Lev: For the final word from my side, if we’re talking about primordial black holes as dark matter, that option where the temperature tends to zero in finite or infinite time is definitely something worth investigating for observational hints.

Kai: Exactly. The study of these possible black hole evaporation laws gives us concrete hints for what we might actually look for when we observe astrophysical phenomena.

Mira: It’s a reminder that even seemingly simple things like the relationship between mass and G can have deep implications when you allow those constants to evolve.

Lev: We'll keep digging into these scenarios, because understanding how gravity itself evolves is key to probing physics beyond our current standard model.

Institute of Theoretical Physics, University of Wroclaw

gr-qc, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-01-23

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: to appear in Eur.Phys.J.Plus

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 74/100

The gist: Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law is explored by examining how time-dependent variations in fundamental constants affect compact systems and their evaporation…

Key concepts

Bianchi Identity
This mathematical identity links how energy and momentum are conserved (or not) with changes in fundamental constants like G and Lambda. It provides a crucial constraint when dealing with systems where G and Lambda are time-dependent, relating fluid conservation to the variation of these constants.
Power-law Relation (G ≃ M−γ)
The Bianchi identity leads to a power-law relationship between the Newton constant G and the mass M of a compact system. The exponent γ depends on factors like pressure or entropy. This relation is central to determining how G changes relative to the object's mass.
Black Hole Evaporation Law
This describes how the mass of a black hole decreases over time due to radiation, often modeled by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. The paper shows that substituting a time-dependent G into this law yields an evaporation rate whose behavior (e.g., temperature tending to infinity or zero) is determined by the derived exponent γ.

Terminology

Summary

Varying Newton constant, entropy and the black hole evaporation law is explored by examining how time-dependent variations in fundamental constants affect compact systems and their evaporation dynamics. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In particular, γ > 1 leads to a decreasing black hole temperature and a decreasing luminosity (that the varying G could change the evaporation law has been discussed in [10][11]). The compact systems with an event horizon could lead to useful tests (besides the ones discussed in [17][18]) of a varying Newton constant G because the area and the temperature of the horizon depend on G.

Theoretical Framework of Varying Constants

The paper investigates the Einstein equations with a time-dependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ, and non-conserved energy-momentum tensor Tµν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

The covariant divergence ∇µTµν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy.

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS=T−1dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). p. 2
Where the paper says it

In a system with zero pressure as a consequence of a constant GM we obtain constant temperature and constant luminosity during the whole evaporation process (no black hole explosion). We derive the same conclusion from the first law of thermodynamics if the entropy is determined by the equation dS = T −1dM.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In a system with zero pressure as a consequence of a constant GM we obtain constant temperature and constant luminosity during the whole evaporation process (no black hole explosion). We derive the same conclusion from the first law of thermodynamics if the entropy is determined by the equation dS = T −1dM.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In a system with zero pressure as a consequence of a constant GM we obtain constant temperature and constant luminosity during the whole evaporation process (no black hole explosion). We derive the same conclusion from the first law of thermodynamics if the entropy is determined by the equation dS = T −1dM.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In a system with zero pressure as a consequence of a constant GM we obtain constant temperature and constant luminosity during the whole evaporation process (no black hole explosion). We derive the same conclusion from the first law of thermodynamics if the entropy is determined by the equation dS = T −1dM.

If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ=23. p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 .

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 .

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 .

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 .

Dynamics of Fluid Conservation and Thermodynamics

The conservation of Tµν allows a variation in time of both G and Λ but ∂tG ≃ ∂tΛ. The Bianchi identity (3) with T˜µν of eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ.

(2) gives an equation for the “fluids” 8π∂µGTµν + 8πG∇µTµν − ∂νΛ = 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity (3) with T˜µν of eq. (2) gives an equation for the “fluids” 8π∂µGT µ ν + 8πG∇µT µ ν − ∂νΛ = 0.

The first law of thermodynamics when applied to the energy-momentum T˜µν(1) means that the supply of heat Q to the system in a volume V yields a work pdV done upon the system plus a change of its internal energy E dE + pdV = dQ = T dS. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The first law of thermodynamics when applied to the energy-momentum T˜µν (1) means that the supply of heat Q to the system in a volume V yields a work pdV done upon the system plus a change of its internal energy E dE + pdV = dQ = T dS. (21) On the rhs of eq.

This leads to the relation M ∂tG + GT ∂tS = −8πRdx/sqrt(g)∂tΛ. p. 1
Where the paper says it

If the pressure in the system is zero then this equation implies that GM is constant. In some systems the Bianchi identity leads to a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ .

Black Hole Evaporation Laws

The mass decrease of a compact object resulting from radiation described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law is given by dM/dt = −λT4A. Substituting the power-law Ansatz G = G0Mγ0 M−γ in eq. p. 8

Where the paper says it

(25) the entropy as functions of G and M in order to determine a relation between these variables. We consider a power-law Ansatz as a possible solution of eqs.

(43) into eq.(53) yields a solution for M (when γ! p. 5
Where the paper says it

The first law of thermodynamics when applied to the energy-momentum T˜µν (1) means that the supply of heat Q to the system in a volume V yields a work pdV done upon the system plus a change of its internal energy E dE + pdV = dQ = T dS. (21) On the rhs of eq.

= 3/2). The resulting evaporation law depends on the value of γ, where constant G corresponds to γ = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

Consequences for Physical Observables

The dependence of the temperature, luminosity, entropy and the mean density may substantially depend on γ. For the temperature and luminosity we have γ T,L time 0 < γ < 1 increasing to infinity finite. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We obtain a different result if we assume that Bekenstein-Hawking formula for the entropy applies without any change to models with a time-dependent G. In such a case the BekensteinHawking temperature as well as the black hole luminosity tend to infinity at the end of the evaporation process but the mean black hole density remains constant.

Forγ ≥ 3/2 the mass, the temperature and the luminosity tend to zero asymptotically in time. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We obtain a different result if we assume that Bekenstein-Hawking formula for the entropy applies without any change to models with a time-dependent G. In such a case the BekensteinHawking temperature as well as the black hole luminosity tend to infinity at the end of the evaporation process but the mean black hole density remains constant.

The mean density (63)is tending to infinity if γ 2/3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We obtain a different result if we assume that Bekenstein-Hawking formula for the entropy applies without any change to models with a time-dependent G. In such a case the BekensteinHawking temperature as well as the black hole luminosity tend to infinity at the end of the evaporation process but the mean black hole density remains constant.

The life time of the black hole for γ < 3/2 according to eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Note that if p = 0 then eq. (20) could be interpreted as the formula (22) for enthalpy with p replaced by − 1 8πΛ in the formulation of the black hole pressure according to to ref.

(58) is tf = 1/(3 − 2γ)G0M0-30¯h−1α−1.

Summary of Findings

The Bianchi identity of classical Einstein equations admits a violation of the fluid energy-momentum conservation if the Newton “constant” G and the cosmological term depend on time. The covariant energy-momentum divergence of the fluid appearing in the Bianchi identity has the form of the heat flow. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇ µ T µν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics.

If the pressure of the system is zero then the Bianchi identity relates ∂t(GM) to the time derivative of the cosmological term. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We obtain an equation which relates the time derivatives of G and the mass M of a compact system. If the pressure in the system is zero then this equation implies that GM is constant.

For a non-zero pressure an analogous formula involves the temperature and entropy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M. If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure).

A radiation of the fluid (involving an energy loss) can be included in Einstein equations if the Newton “constant” or the cosmological term depend on time. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law Julia Haba ∗ Zbigniew Haba † Institute of Theoretical Physics , University of Wroclaw 50-204 Wroclaw, Plac Maxa Borna 9, Poland Abstract In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one ( T µν ) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν.

The radiation is described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law.

When the collapse of the star is described by pasting of Schwarzschild solution with the FLRW solution for a fluid with a certain density, then the resulting black hole should have the mass M related to this density. p. 8
Where the paper says it

An investigation of the dynamics of a star collapse to the black hole has been initiated by Oppenheimer and Snyder [49]. Then, Einstein and Straus [50] [51] studied a star (Schwarzschild metric) in an expanding universe by pasting the FLWR metric with the Schwarzschild solution.

The black hole mechanics derived in classical Einstein gravity gives a relation between G, M, the entropy S and temperature T. p. 9
Where the paper says it

As conjectured by Bekenstein [56] the entropy of the black hole is proportional to its area. The calculation of the temperature of the black hole in a system of quantum scalar particles on a Schwarzschild background [57] gave the result (the formula has been established for various quantum systems defined on the Schwarzschild background [58][59]) TBH = ¯h 8πGM (48) Then, from the relations (44)-(47) we obtain the entropy SBH = 4π ¯h M2G (49) If instead of (47) we use (48) and dS = T −1 BHdM (50) appearing in the black hole mechanics in [44] then the formula for the entropy is S = 8π ¯h Z GM dM.

In some effective theories of gravity when G is time-dependent this relation may be more involved. p. 9
Where the paper says it

We discuss all options (49), (51)and (44)-(45) leading to the relation (43) with different γ. The reason is that a time-dependent G may appear in an effective field theory of various origin [60]: Higgs gauge theories with symmetry breaking [61][62],Branse-Dicke [10][11][63], f(R) and higher derivatives gravities [64][63].

From the Bianchi identity we obtain an equation relating the time derivatives of G, Λ and M to the temperature T and entropy S. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2)) and the first law of thermodynamics it follows that a change of entropy is impossible if G and Λ are constant. We obtain an equation which relates the time derivatives of G and the mass M of a compact system.

We discussed various formulas for T and S some of them directly generalizing the Bekenstein-Hawking expression and some (for γ!= 1 and γ!= 2/3) quite hypothetical. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(25) or the entropy (51), γ = 2 3 for the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy (49). The remaining values of γ ≥ 0 are rather hypothetical.

These assumptions give a relation G ≃ M−γ. p. 5
Where the paper says it

When we define the mass as M = Z dx √ γρ (23) then eqs. (20)-(21) give M ∂tG + G(∂tM + R dxp∂t √γ) = − 1 8π R dx √γ∂tΛ (24) or in terms of the entropy M ∂tG + GT ∂tS = − 1 8π R dx √γ∂tΛ.

When the expression G(M) is substituted in the Stefan-Boltzmann formula for the mass decrease then it gives an evaporation law without free parameters. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T.

Depending on the value of γ the black hole temperature and luminosity may either tend to infinity at finite time (black hole explosion), be constant during the whole black hole life time or even tend to zero in finite or infinite time. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We obtain a different result if we assume that Bekenstein-Hawking formula for the entropy applies without any change to models with a time-dependent G. In such a case the BekensteinHawking temperature as well as the black hole luminosity tend to infinity at the end of the evaporation process but the mean black hole density remains constant.

The latter option is interesting for the proposals of the dark matter as consisting of primordial black holes. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The knowledge of an exact evaporation law may be important for recent searches of the primordial black hole explosions [23][24] raised by an observation of a giant emission of neutrino radiation in KM3NeT [25] (for a search of radiation from primordial black holes see [26] and references cited there). A decreasing black hole temperature would be welcome in models of primordial black holes as a cold dark matter.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The knowledge of an exact evaporation law may be important for recent searches of the primordial black hole explosions [23][24] raised by an observation of a giant emission of neutrino radiation in KM3NeT [25] (for a search of radiation from primordial black holes see [26] and references cited there). A decreasing black hole temperature would be welcome in models of primordial black holes as a cold dark matter.

The study of the possible black holes evaporation laws should give useful hints for their search in astronomical observations. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The compact systems with an event horizon could lead to useful tests (besides the ones discussed in [17][18]) of a varying Newton constant G because the area and the temperature of the horizon depend on G. The knowledge of an exact evaporation law may be important for recent searches of the primordial black hole explosions [23][24] raised by an observation of a giant emission of neutrino radiation in KM3NeT [25] (for a search of radiation from primordial black holes see [26] and references cited there).

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The compact systems with an event horizon could lead to useful tests (besides the ones discussed in [17][18]) of a varying Newton constant G because the area and the temperature of the horizon depend on G. The knowledge of an exact evaporation law may be important for recent searches of the primordial black hole explosions [23][24] raised by an observation of a giant emission of neutrino radiation in KM3NeT [25] (for a search of radiation from primordial black holes see [26] and references cited there).

How the training signal is built

The paper derives specific relations between G and M based on different assumptions about entropy and temperature. For zero pressure in eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M. If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS = T − 1 dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure).

(25) or the entropy (51), γ = 1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law Julia Haba ∗ Zbigniew Haba † Institute of Theoretical Physics , University of Wroclaw 50-204 Wroclaw, Plac Maxa Borna 9, Poland Abstract In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one ( T µν ) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν.

If eqs.(48)-(49) are applied in eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We apply this formula to non-equilibrium systems with time-dependent variables. From the Bianchi identities (applied to eq.

(25) then γ = 2/3. The general option (43) with γ! p. 9
Where the paper says it

A microscopic counting of states in loop quantum gravity [68] does not fix the coefficient for entropy in front of the area as well. We consider also the option Sκ = κ 4G¯h A, (52) where κ = G −1 ef fG with an effective coupling Gef f which can come from a calculation of the entropy from the partition function.

= 0 leads to the solution for M (when γ! p. 2
Where the paper says it

(1) leads to the equation ∇µT˜µ ν = 0. (3) It is understood that the solution of gravity in the presence of “fluids” means a solution of both eqs.

= 3/2).

Where the gains come from

The analysis explores how a time-dependent G may appear in an effective field theory of various origin such as Higgs gauge theories with symmetry breaking or Brans-Dicke theories. A renormalization of the Newton constant as in refs. p. 9

Where the paper says it

(51)) can appear if the black hole surface is time dependent ( a trapping horizon) in an expanding universe [67]. A renormalization of the Newton constant as in refs.

[13][14][15][16] can lead to a modified formula for the entropy. p. 9
Where the paper says it

A renormalization of the Newton constant as in refs. [13][14][15][16] can lead to a modified formula for the entropy.

The microscopic counting of states in loop quantum gravity does not fix the coefficient for entropy in front of the area as well. p. 9
Where the paper says it

[13][14][15][16] can lead to a modified formula for the entropy. A microscopic counting of states in loop quantum gravity [68] does not fix the coefficient for entropy in front of the area as well.

The paper suggests that a decreasing black hole temperature would be welcome in models of primordial black holes as a cold dark matter. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The knowledge of an exact evaporation law may be important for recent searches of the primordial black hole explosions [23][24] raised by an observation of a giant emission of neutrino radiation in KM3NeT [25] (for a search of radiation from primordial black holes see [26] and references cited there). A decreasing black hole temperature would be welcome in models of primordial black holes as a cold dark matter.

The results could be compared with observations of the gamma-ray bursts. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Such models have been discussed in [19][20][21][22]. These authors show that a variation of G leads to a variation of Λ in an agreement with observations of the universe expansion.

Data availability statement No data were created or analysed in this study. The paper is 2601. p. 0
Where the paper says it

com †email:zbigniew. pl 1 arXiv:2601.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

com †email:zbigniew. pl 1 arXiv:2601.

17162 [gr-qc] 26 Feb 2026. p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl 1 arXiv:2601. 17162v2 [gr-qc] 26 Feb 2026

p. 0
Where the paper says it

pl 1 arXiv:2601. 17162v2 [gr-qc] 26 Feb 2026

Conclusion on Evaporation Laws

The final conclusion is that depending on the value of γ the black hole temperature and luminosity may either tend to infinity at finite time (black hole explosion), be constant during the whole black hole life time or even tend to zero in finite or infinite time. The latter option is interesting for the proposals of the dark matter as consisting of primordial black holes. The study of the possible black holes evaporation laws should give useful hints for their search in astronomical observations. The paper is 2601.17162 [gr-qc] 26 Feb 2026.

--- Page 5 ---

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law

In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one (Tµν) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved Tµν. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law Julia Haba ∗ Zbigniew Haba † Institute of Theoretical Physics , University of Wroclaw 50-204 Wroclaw, Plac Maxa Borna 9, Poland Abstract In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one ( T µν ) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law Julia Haba ∗ Zbigniew Haba † Institute of Theoretical Physics , University of Wroclaw 50-204 Wroclaw, Plac Maxa Borna 9, Poland Abstract In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one ( T µν ) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law Julia Haba ∗ Zbigniew Haba † Institute of Theoretical Physics , University of Wroclaw 50-204 Wroclaw, Plac Maxa Borna 9, Poland Abstract In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one ( T µν ) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved T µν.

The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇µTµν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law.

In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T.

The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M.

If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS=T−1dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ=23. We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 . We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 . We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ = 23 . We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields.

In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

--- Page 8 ---

5 Mass loss in evaporation

In this section we discuss dynamics of a change of mass of a compact object. We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time. p. 8

Where the paper says it

5 Mass loss in evaporation In this section we discuss dynamics of a change of mass of a compact object. We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

5 Mass loss in evaporation In this section we discuss dynamics of a change of mass of a compact object. We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time.

We have two equations (24) and (25) for a relation between time derivatives of G and M. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time. We have two equations (24) and (25) for a relation between time derivatives of G and M.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time. We have two equations (24) and (25) for a relation between time derivatives of G and M.

In eq.(43) we consider a power-law Ansatz G = G0Mγ0 M−γ. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(25) the entropy as functions of G and M in order to determine a relation between these variables. We consider a power-law Ansatz as a possible solution of eqs.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(25) the entropy as functions of G and M in order to determine a relation between these variables. We consider a power-law Ansatz as a possible solution of eqs.

It can be seen that if ∂tΛ = 0 and p = 0 then from eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(24)-(25) G = G0Mγ 0 M−γ . (43) It can be seen that if ∂tΛ = 0 and p = 0 then from eq.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(24)-(25) G = G0Mγ 0 M−γ . (43) It can be seen that if ∂tΛ = 0 and p = 0 then from eq.

(24) γ = 1. In order to determine a relation between G and M from eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(24) we would need to know the pressure whereas in eq. (25) the entropy as functions of G and M in order to determine a relation between these variables.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(24) we would need to know the pressure whereas in eq. (25) the entropy as functions of G and M in order to determine a relation between these variables.

(25) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In order to determine a relation between G and M from eq. (25) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S.

We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(25) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S. We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2 , (44) S = κGν1Mν2 .

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(25) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S. We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2 , (44) S = κGν1Mν2 .

We substitute it in eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2 , (44) S = κGν1Mν2 . (45) We substitute it in eq.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2 , (44) S = κGν1Mν2 . (45) We substitute it in eq.

(25) then we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1)−1. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) We substitute it in eq. Then, we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1) −1 (46) with α1 = −ν1,α2 = 1 − ν2.

If in addition we demand the definition of temperature as 1/T=∂S/∂M then we get the relation κθν2 = 1 and γ = ν2(ν1 + ν2)−1. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Then, we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1) −1 (46) with α1 = −ν1,α2 = 1 − ν2. If in addition we demand the definition of temperature as 1 T = ∂S ∂M (47) 9

p. 8
Where the paper says it

Then, we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1) −1 (46) with α1 = −ν1,α2 = 1 − ν2. If in addition we demand the definition of temperature as 1 T = ∂S ∂M (47) 9

--- Page 9 ---

5 Mass loss in evaporation

In this section we discuss dynamics of a change of mass of a compact object. We assume that such dynamics can be described in the framework of classical Einstein gravity if G and Λ are allowed to change in time. We have two equations (24) and (25) for a relation between time derivatives of G and M. In eq.(43) we consider a power-law Ansatz G = G0Mγ0 M−γ. It can be seen that if ∂tΛ = 0 and p = 0 then from eq.(24) γ = 1. In order to determine a relation between G and M from eq.(5) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In order to determine a relation between G and M from eq. (25) we need to know the temperature T and entropy S.

We consider a simple power-law Ansatz T = θGα1Mα2. We substitute it in eq.(5) then we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1)−1. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) We substitute it in eq. Then, we obtain γ = θκν2(1 + θκν1) −1 (46) with α1 = −ν1,α2 = 1 − ν2.

If in addition we demand the definition of temperature as 1/T=∂S/∂M then we get the relation κθν2 = 1 and γ = ν2(ν1 + ν2)−1.

--- Page 4 ---

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law

In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one (Tµν) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved Tµν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇µTµν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M. If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS=T−1dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ=23. We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

--- Page 3 ---

Varying Newton constant,entropy and the black hole evaporation law

In Einstein equations we represent the energy-momentum tensor as the one (Tµν) of a fluid plus the cosmological term. We consider timedependent Newton “constant” G, the cosmological term Λ and non-conserved Tµν. The Bianchi identity imposes a relation between the energy-momentum (non)conservation and the variation of G and Λ. The covariant divergence ∇µTµν can be related to the first law of thermodynamics. For compact systems of mass M from the Bianchi identity we obtain a power-law relation G ≃ M−γ with γ depending on pressure or entropy. We discuss radiation and a mass loss described by the Stefan-Boltzmann law. In this formula we insert an expression for the black hole area and its temperature T. The Bianchi identity together with a formula for temperature and entropy S determines the index γ in the relation between the Newton constant G and the mass M. If the entropy S is defined by the equation dS=T−1dM then γ = 1 (the same as for zero pressure). If the formula of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G then γ=23. We discuss consequences for the evaporation law of some modified expressions for the entropy appearing in effective models of gravity resulting from an interaction with matter fields. In particular, γ = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas γ > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can model cosmological models where Newton constant G and cosmological term Lambda vary over time by solving equations derived from Bianchi identities relating energy-momentum conservation to variations of these constants. This allows for testing alternative gravity models beyond the standard Lambda CDM framework, as suggested by Modified Einstein equations could follow from an induced action resulting from quantum 'matter' fields on a curved background.

  2. Improved AI system can predict the evaporation law of black holes based on different assumptions about entropy, specifically distinguishing between scenarios where the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy holds true for time-dependent G and cases where it does not. This enables the prediction of whether a black hole will have a "constant evaporation temperature whereas gamma = 1 leads to a constant evaporation temperature whereas gamma > 1 to a decreasing temperature and luminosity".

  3. Improved AI system can analyze the consequences of different power-law relations between Newton constant and mass, G equal to M minus gamma, which depend on the value of gamma. This system can predict the behavior of black hole temperature, luminosity, entropy, and mean density for various ranges of gamma (e.g., "gamma T,L time 0 < gamma < 1 increasing to infinity finite").

Abstract

We assume that the Newton potential of a spherically symmetric body of mass M is V=-G(M)Mr-1, where the Newton constant G may depend on M. We insert this assumption in the Schwarzschild solution. We discuss varying G in the black hole thermodynamics and black hole evaporation law. We extend the Bekenstein-Hawking formula GS= 1 over 4A, where S is the entropy and A the area, to a varying G. It is shown that if G(M) is of the form of a power-law G M-Γ then G(M)S A is still preserved but the evaporation law substantially depends on the function G(M).

Sources

Related papers