Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides

arXiv:2512.21163 · cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2025-12-24 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides".

Title and authors: Kai: We're talking about the title "Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides" and the authors, Afan Safeer, Oktay G¨ulery¨uz, Guangyao Miao, Wouter Jolie, Thomas Michely, and Jeison Fischer. It sets up this whole investigation into how the substrate dictates the polaron behavior.

Mira: The abstract summarizes that they found stable polarons in single layer transition metal dihalides on conducting substrates and focused on how the number densities and species change with the substrate. It really zeroes in on that dependence as a key finding.

Lev: For real hardware, this means if you're trying to engineer a system based on these polarons, you can't just pick one substrate and assume the physics is universal; you have to design for the specific substrate interaction.

Kai: The paper shows that when Mn bromide is grown on graphene on Ir(one hundred ten), mobile polarons are guided through a periodic potential created by a super-moiré pattern resulting from that interaction, which suggests an interesting mechanism for guiding the charge carriers <ref:2512.21163#pg1>.

Mira: That guidance mechanism, driven by the super-moiré pattern, is what they use to link the polaron movement to the substrate structure. It connects the electronic structure of Mn bromide directly to its physical environment.

Lev: If we were trying to implement this on a real device, we’d need precise control over that super-moiré periodicity, which is a complex engineering challenge compared to just growing on a simple flat surface.

The paper's summary: Kai: The core of the study shows that the differences in polaron phenomenology across those three substrates are substantial, even though they're all single layer systems. They found that Mn bromide on graphene on Ir(one hundred ten) has four species of polarons, while on graphene on Ir(one hundred eleven) and gold on Au(nineteen), they only see two types.

Mira: And the density numbers are quite different too; for example, the total polaron number density measured for Mn bromide on Au(nineteen) is about one order of magnitude larger than what was found on graphene on Ir(twenty) <ref:2512.21163#pg3>.

Lev: That density difference is significant. If we were scaling this up to a practical device, that difference in carrier concentration could mean a huge difference in the electrical properties you’re trying to achieve.

Kai: They also noted that the apparent lateral extension of type one polarons changes depending on the substrate; it's largest on graphene on Ir(one hundred eleven), smaller on graphene on Ir(one hundred ten), and considerably smaller again for Au(nineteen).

Mira: And they established a very important point about stability: these polarons form spontaneously without external excitation, meaning their presence is an equilibrium property that actually lowers the total energy of the system.

The paper's improvements: Lev: The authors suggest that modeling polaron behavior in single layer insulators requires explicitly taking the substrate into account, which is a clear call for better theoretical frameworks.

Kai: They also estimate the polaron formation energy for Mn bromide on graphene on Ir(one hundred ten) to be less than one point nine electron volts, which is quite large compared to other calculated energies, like those for cobalt chloride which are around zero point two to zero point three electron volts <ref:2512.21163#pg1>.

Mira: That large formation energy suggests that the equilibrium distribution of polarons within the tunneling distance to a conducting substrate implies a remarkably large magnitude of the polaron formation energy.

Lev: If that formation energy is this high, it means you need a very specific and robust setup to even observe these stable polarons, because thermal hopping would be extremely difficult.

Kai: And they point out that at least one polaron type is thermally stable and immobile up to three hundred Kelvin, which shows a remarkably high barrier to thermal hopping for that specific species.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up the "Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides," the paper shows that substrate-induced periodic potentials can measurably influence polaron energetics and spatial distributions. This provides further evidence that accurate modeling of polarons in supported single layer transition metal dihalides must explicitly account for the substrate.

Kai: They conclude that type one mobile polarons in both materials are of a similar nature, and they also find that the type two two by two polarons in Mn bromide cannot be mapped experimentally with any other polaron types seen so far.

Lev: For real hardware, this means we need better experimental determination of these properties because the paper stresses that an adequate modeling approach must include the substrate to get it right.

Mira: The overall message is that the nature of these polarons depends heavily on where they are grown, and this dependence is a very important piece of information for understanding how these materials behave.

Kai: So, to summarize, we see strong variation in polaron species and density based on the substrate—from four species on Ir(one hundred ten) down to two on Au(one hundred eleven)—and they found that substrate-induced periodic potentials significantly alter their energetics <ref:2512.21163#pg1>.

Lev: Yeah, and the authors are calling for better experimental determination because we need clearer data to build the models that account for this crucial substrate dependence.

Mira: It’s a strong call to action for materials science, pushing us toward more detailed calculations that explicitly incorporate the substrate when studying these systems.

II. Physikalisches Institut, Universität zu K཯n, Germany

cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2025-12-24

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 42 pages, 19 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Single-layer MnBr2 grown on conducting substrates hosts polarons whose number densities and species vary strongly as a function of the substrate The emergence of a polaron species not reported so…

Key concepts

Polaron
A quasiparticle formed when an electron couples strongly with lattice vibrations (phonons) in a material. In this study, they are observed in single-layer MnBr2 and their properties change significantly depending on whether the substrate is graphene or gold.
Super-moiré Pattern
This is a periodic pattern created when the MnBr2 layer interacts with its substrate (like graphene or Ir). This pattern acts as a periodic potential that guides and influences the movement of mobile polarons within the material.
Substrate Dependence
The physical properties of polarons, such as their number density and type, are not uniform across different substrates. For example, MnBr2 on Au(19) has a much higher polaron density than on graphene/Ir surfaces, showing that the substrate fundamentally changes how polarons form.
Polaron Formation Energy
This is the energy required to create a polaron. The study found this energy is very large (less than 1.9 eV for one case), suggesting that polarons are stable equilibrium states in these materials, resisting thermal hopping up to 300 K.

Terminology

Summary

Single-layer MnBr2 grown on conducting substrates hosts polarons whose number densities and species vary strongly as a function of the substrate The emergence of a polaron species not reported so far, the strong interaction of polarons with a super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with its substrate, and an impressive thermal stability of polarons are uncovered in this investigation Most importantly, a hitherto somewhat overlooked strong dependence of the polaron phenomenology on the substrate is identified. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The emergence of a polaron species not reported so far, the strong interaction of polarons with a super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with its substrate, and an impressive thermal stability of polarons. Most importantly, a hitherto somewhat overlooked strong dependence of the polaron phenomenology on the substrate is identified.

Polaron Phenomenology and Interaction with the Super-moire

The study investigates polarons in single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates: graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111) The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate For MnBr2 grown on Ir(110) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K. p. 0

Where the paper says it

For MnBr2 grown on Ir(110) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

For MnBr2 grown on Ir(110) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

For MnBr2 grown on Ir(110) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K.

Mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110) as a substrate. p. 0
Where the paper says it

They can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage. For graphene on Ir(110) as a substrate, mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110).

The fuzzy polaron features arise from the mobility of the polarons driven by the interaction with the STM tip, and this alignment indicates an interaction of the polarons with the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The fuzzy stripe-like features arise from the mobility of the polarons driven by the interaction with the STM tip. The fuzzy polaron features partly align with the stripes of the super-moir´e.

Substrate Dependence of Polarons in MnBr2

The comparison of larger scale topographs of the three samples makes it clear that the differences in polaron phenomenology on the three different substrates are substantial. While MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) displays four different types of polarons, MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(111) and Au(111) exhibit only two types. p. 5

Where the paper says it

0 V [Figure 2(a)] exhibit distinct shapes and heights. We distinguish four different types of polarons: type-I mobile polarons with the largest apparent depth of ≈ 1 ˚A (encircled dark blue), shallower type-I immobile polarons with a depth of ≈ 0.

The total polaron number density on Au(111) is about an order of magnitude larger than for Gr/Ir(19) and Gr/Ir(20), with a density of ≈ 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

01 nm−2 at 300 K. However, the polaron number density at 300 K has presumably a large uncertainty, since at all Vb where polarons were visible, their interaction with the STM tip was noticeable.

6 polarons/nm−2 compared to ≈ 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Band bending induced by polarons. (a) Constant height dI/dV point spectra taken on the polarons indicated compared to a reference spectrum without a polaron.

06 polarons/nm−2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

The apparent lateral extension of the type-I polarons in MnBr2 differs across substrates, being largest on Gr/Ir(111), slightly smaller on Gr/Ir(110), and considerably smaller on Au(19). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons. Here, we investigate polarons in insulating single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates, namely graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111).

Polaron Stability and Formation Energy

Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 form spontaneously without external excitation, indicating that their presence is an equilibrium property and reduces the total energy of the system. The polaron formation energy Epol < 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

9 eV is estimated for single-layer MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) since Ecbe ≈ 1. p. 7
Where the paper says it

However, the polaron number density at 300 K has presumably a large uncertainty, since at all Vb where polarons were visible, their interaction with the STM tip was noticeable. The presence of polarons in single-layer MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) is independent of specific growth conditions.

9 eV, implying that Eel + Ecbe < 0 even in the limit of vanishing Elat. p. 2
Where the paper says it

90 ˚A closely matches the bulk lattice parameter of 3. 873 ˚A [41], confirming structural integrity of MnBr2 in the single-layer limit.

The polaron formation energy Epol < 1.9 eV is very large compared to other calculated polaron formation energies, such as those for CoCl2 which are found to be ≈ 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Band bending induced by polarons. (a) Constant height dI/dV point spectra taken on the polarons indicated compared to a reference spectrum without a polaron.

2 eV - 0.3 eV.

Conclusions

The single-layers of MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) and Gr/Ir(111) host polarons of density ≈ 6×10−2 polarons/nm−2, while on Au(19) the density is about an order of magnitude larger. On the Gr/Ir substrates, type-I mobile polarons can be created and interconverted with both type-II polarons by the STM tip. p. 9

Where the paper says it

(b) The pulse created a type-I mobile polaron under the tip, but also caused a type-I mobile polaron to move (indicated by the arrow, original location encircled in dashed blue). (c) STM topograph of a type-II 2×2 polaron.

The interaction of polarons with the super-moir´e patterns invites speculations regarding information processing. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. We note that type-I mobile polarons also move for large negative Vb as documented by a more extended data set shown as Figure S1 in the Supplementary Information (SI), Charge State, Stability and Transformations of polarons A polaron is a localized charge dressed by lattice deformation.

The presence of an equilibrium distribution of polarons within tunneling distance to a conducting substrate implies a remarkably large magnitude of the polaron formation energy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

Experimental Section

The samples were prepared in an ultrahigh vacuum chamber for molecular beam epitaxy with a base pressure below 1 × 10−10 mbar MnBr2 was grown at 450 K by sublimation of MnBr2 molecules from MnBr2 powder in a Knudsen cell heated to 670 K. Constant-current topographies were recorded with sample bias Vb and tunneling current It, as detailed in the respective figure captions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K. They can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage.

Supplementary Information

The supplementary information provides extended datasets for bias-dependent polaron imaging and mobility, including sequence of STM images of the same area acquired at varying Vb ranging from +3 V and −3.5 V. The supplementary note 6 illustrates the creation of a type-I mobile polaron in MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(111) via bias pulsing. p. 6

Where the paper says it

We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. We note that type-I mobile polarons also move for large negative Vb as documented by a more extended data set shown as Figure S1 in the Supplementary Information (SI), Charge State, Stability and Transformations of polarons A polaron is a localized charge dressed by lattice deformation.

The supplementary note 7 shows absolute heights of the STM tip over Gr/Ir(110) and MnBr2/Gr/Ir(19) as a function of Vb. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. We note that type-I mobile polarons also move for large negative Vb as documented by a more extended data set shown as Figure S1 in the Supplementary Information (SI), Charge State, Stability and Transformations of polarons A polaron is a localized charge dressed by lattice deformation.

The supplementary information also details the interaction of type-I mobile polarons with the super-moir´e patterns, concluding that substrate-induced periodic potentials can measurably influence polaron energetics and spatial distributions. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. We note that type-I mobile polarons also move for large negative Vb as documented by a more extended data set shown as Figure S1 in the Supplementary Information (SI), Charge State, Stability and Transformations of polarons A polaron is a localized charge dressed by lattice deformation.

The paper concludes that an adequate modeling of polarons in single-layer transition metal dihaldies must explicitly account for the substrate. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For graphene on Ir(110) as a substrate, mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110). Our findings indicate that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account.

The authors suggest that DFT modeling similar to ref. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For graphene on Ir(110) as a substrate, mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110). Our findings indicate that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account.

54 is needed taking the underlying metal into account to adequately describe polarons in single-layer transition metal halides. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Here, we investigate polarons in single-layer MnBr2, a transition metal dihalide that has not yet been explored from this perspective. Mn has the lowest electronegativity among the transition metals, enhancing ionic interactions with halides and thus ionic polarizability, a key factor for polaron formation [20].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

Here, we investigate polarons in single-layer MnBr2, a transition metal dihalide that has not yet been explored from this perspective. Mn has the lowest electronegativity among the transition metals, enhancing ionic interactions with halides and thus ionic polarizability, a key factor for polaron formation [20].

The authors speculate that DFT modeling similar to ref. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For graphene on Ir(110) as a substrate, mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110). Our findings indicate that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account.

54 is needed taking the underlying metal into account to adequately describe polarons in single-layer transition metal halides. The authors take the shift of the Au(19) surface state in their dI/dV spectrum as an indication that the large polaron density on Au(19) might be related to the localization of electrons that originate from the Au(19) surface state. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The spectra recorded on the different polarons exhibit an upward shift in the onset of the valence band, as expected for a localized negative charge. The spectrum of the type-I 1 × 1 polaron displays an in-gap state at Vb ≈ 1.

The authors note that at least some of the polaron species present in a metal-insulator system are linked to their interface. The omnipresence of the type-II 1 × 1 polaron in all three systems may indicate that this polaron is not linked to the interface, while the type-II 2×2 polaron being present only in MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(10) suggests that it is related to the complex interface of Gr/Ir(10) with MnBr2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Of specific relevance for the present work is the fact that MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) forms a complex super-moir´e arising from the superposition of the MnBr2/Gr, MnBr2/Ir(110), and Gr/Ir(110) moir´es [40]. RESULTS Polaron Phenomenology and interaction with the super-moir´e (a) (b) Figure 1.

The ease of inducing mobility and the ease of creation of the type-I mobile polaron by the STM tip suggest that the charge distribution of the type-I mobile polaron is closer to the surface rather than that of the type I immobile polaron, which might be located at the MnBr2/Gr interface. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. We note that type-I mobile polarons also move for large negative Vb as documented by a more extended data set shown as Figure S1 in the Supplementary Information (SI), Charge State, Stability and Transformations of polarons A polaron is a localized charge dressed by lattice deformation.

The authors conclude that substrate-induced periodic potentials can measurably influence polaron energetics and spatial distributions, providing further evidence that adequate modeling of polarons in supported single-layer transition metal dihaldies must explicitly account for the substrate. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For graphene on Ir(110) as a substrate, mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moir´e resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110). Our findings indicate that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account.

The paper concludes with a call for better experimental determination and more precise experimental determination of polaron properties in well-defined systems and their better understanding based on adequate modeling. The authors conclude that the type-I polarons in both materials are of a similar nature. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The same feature has already been observed in Figure 1(b). We therefore conclude that under the driving influence of the STM tip at sufficiently large positive sample bias, type-I mobile polarons experience a repulsive interaction with the maxima of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e.

The paper concludes that the type-II 2 × 2 polarons in MnBr2 cannot be mapped on any of the polarons experimentally described in transition metal dihalides so far. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons. Here, we investigate polarons in insulating single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates, namely graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111).

The paper concludes that the type-I mobile polaron is energetically more favorable than the type-II polarons. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The opposite process, the conversion of a type-II 2 × 2 polaron into a type-II 1 × 1 polaron, was already observed in the sequence of Figure 2 and is symbolically indicated by the dashed arrow between Figure 5(g) and (h). We tentatively conclude that the type-I mobile polaron is energetically more favorable than the type-II polarons.

The paper concludes that at least one polaron type is thermally stable and immobile up to 300 K, indicating a remarkably high barrier to thermal hopping. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Depending on the spatial extent of electron-phonon coupling, one commonly distinguishes small or Holstein polarons, where the distortion is confined to one or a few lattice sites, and large or Fr¨ohlich polarons, where both the lattice distortion and charge carrier wave function extend over many unit cells [1]. Polarons can strongly modify charge transport properties by increasing the effective mass or promoting thermal-activated hopping, and can also affect other properties such as chemical reactivity (detail reviewed in ref.

The paper concludes that the presence of an equilibrium distribution of polarons within tunneling distance to a conducting substrate implies a remarkably large magnitude of the polaron formation energy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

References

[1] C. Franchini, M. Reticcioli, M. Setvin, and U. Diebold, Nat. Rev. Mater. 6, 560 (2021)

[3] M. Reticcioli, U. Diebold, G. Kresse, and C. Franchini, Small polarons in transition metal oxides, in Handbook of Materials Modeling: Applications: Current and Emerging Materials, edited by W. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Polarons can strongly modify charge transport properties by increasing the effective mass or promoting thermal-activated hopping, and can also affect other properties such as chemical reactivity (detail reviewed in ref. Correspondingly, polarons are central to the functional behavior and technological use of many materials, for example, transition metal oxides [2–5], where charge transport is often governed by small polarons and halide perovskites [6, 7], where large polarons are frequently invoked.

Andreoni and S. Yip (Springer International Publishing, Cham, 2019) pp. 1–39

[4] A. J. Tanner and G. Thornton, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 13, 559 (2022)

[6] K. Miyata, D. Meggiolaro, M. T. Trinh, P.-P Joshi, E.-Mosconi, S.-C Jones, F.-D Angelis, and X.-Y Zhu, Sci. p. 0

Where the paper says it

21163v1 [cond-mat. mtrl-sci] 24 Dec 2025

Adv. 3, e1701217 (2017)

[9] M. Setvin, C. Franchini, X. Hao, M. Schmid, A. Janotti, M. Kaltak, C.-G Van de Walle, G. p. 2

Where the paper says it

35 K antiferromagnetic ordering [36–39]. In a previous experimental study [40] single-layer MnBr2 grown on Gr/Ir(110) displayed the same structure as a layer in the van der Waals bulk material, that is, in a hexagonal CdI2-type lattice in which six Br− ions sandwich the Mn2+ ions and coordinate them in an edge-sharing arrangement.

Kresse, and U.-D Diebold Phys Rev Lett 113 086402 (2014)

[10] C. M. Yim, M. B Watkins, M. J Wolf, C. L Pang, K Hermansson, and G Thornton Phys Rev Lett 117 116402 (2016)

[30] G. C C de Jesus, R d C Vasconcelos, L B do Vale, R F de Menezes, K G Sprenger, and R Gargano Langmuir 41 5877 (2025)

[31] J Luo, G Xiang, Y Tang, K Ou, and X Chen J Appl Phys 128 113901 (2020)

[40] A. Safeer, O G¨ulery¨uz, N Atodiresei W Jolie T Michely and J Fischer MnBr2 on the graphene on Ir(110) substrate: growth structure and super-moir´e (2025) arXiv:2508. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

19694 cond-mat. p. 0
Where the paper says it

de 1 arXiv:2512. 21163v1 [cond-mat.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

de 1 arXiv:2512. 21163v1 [cond-mat.

mtrl-sci

[43] S Kraus, F Huttmann, J Fischer T Knispel K Bischof A Herman M Bianchi R Stan A Holt V Caciuc S Tsukamoto H Wende P Hofmann N Atodiresei and T Michely Phys Rev B 105 165405 (2022)

[46] A. Bruix, J. A Miwa, N Hauptmann D Wegner S Ulstrup S S Grønborg C E Sanders M Dendzik A Grubiˇsi´c Cabo M Bianchi J V Lauritsen A A Khajetoorians B Hammer and P Hofmann Phys Rev B 93 165422 (2016)

[49] T Andreev, I Barke, and H Hovell Phys Rev B 70 205426 (2004)

[51] S Kerschbaumer S E Hadjadj A Aguirre-Ba˜nos D Longo A Pinar Sol´e O Stetsovych A Candia P Angulo-Portugal D Caldevilla F Choueikani M Corso D Serrate J LoboCheca P Jel´ınek M Ilyn and C Rogero ACS Nano 19 20693 (2025)

[54] K P McKenna Phys Rev B 94 155147 (2016)

[56] I Horcas R Fernandez J M Gomez-Rodriguez J Colchero J Gomez-Herrero and A M Baro Rev Sci Instrum 78 013705 (2007)

[21] C van Efferen L Patzold T Y Tounsi A Schobert M Winter Y i ’t Veld M Georger A Safeer C Kr¨amer J Fischer J Berges T Michely R Mozara T Wehling and W Jolie Phys Rev X 15 031030 (2025)

[26] M Cai M.-P Miao Y Liang Z Jiang Z. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Substrate Role in Polaron Formation on Single-layer Transition Metal Dihalides Affan Safeer,1, ∗ Oktay G¨ulery¨uz,1 Guangyao Miao,1 Wouter Jolie,1 Thomas Michely,1 and Jeison Fischer1 1 II. Physikalisches Institut, Universit¨at zu K¨oln, Z¨ulpicher Straße 77, 50937 K¨oln, Germany Abstract Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons.

-Y Liu W.-H Zhang X Liao L.-F Zhu D West S Zhang and Y-S Fu Nat Commun 14 3691 (2023)

[27] L Yao A Wang Q Zheng J Zhao Phys Rev B 110 054305 (2024)

[36] E O Wollan W C Koehler and M K Wilkinson Phys Rev 110 638 (1958)

[37] Y Farge M R´egis and B Royce J Phys 37 637 (1976)

[40] A Safeer O G¨ulery¨uz N Atodiresei W Jolie T Michely and J Fischer MnBr2 on the graphene on Ir(110) substrate: growth structure and super-moir´e (2025) arXiv:2508.19694 cond-mat.mtrl-sci

[41] C Ronda H Siekman and C Haas Physica B+C 144 331 (1987)

[42] C Murray W Jolie J A Fischer J Hall C van Efferen N Ehlen A Gr¨uneis C Busse and T Michely Phys Rev B 99 115434 (2019)

[47] C E Sanders M Dendzik A S Ngankeu A Eich A Bruix M Bianchi J A Miwa B Hammer A Khajetoorians and P Hofmann Phys Rev B 94 081404 (2016)

[53] P Norton R Tapping and J Goodale Surf Sci 72 33 (1978)

[55] J Coraux A T N’Diaye M Engler C Busse D Wall N Buckanie F.-J Meyer zu Heringdorf R van Gastel B Poelsema and T Michely New J Phys 11 023006 (2009)

[57] D Ghosh E Welch A J Neukirch A Zakhidov and S Tretiak J Phys Chem Lett 14 3271 (2020)

[56] I Horcas R Fernandez J M Gomez-Rodriguez J Colchero J Gomez-Herrero and A M Baro Rev Sci Instrum 78 013705 (2007)

[2512.2163] is the paper title.

--- Page 1 ---

The single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates host stable polarons Here, we investigate polarons in insulating single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates, namely graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(19) The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate For MnBr2 grown on Ir(19) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate. For MnBr2 grown on Ir(110) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite.

Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K. They can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper investigates polarons in insulating single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates: graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(19). The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Here, we investigate polarons in insulating single-layer MnBr2 grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates, namely graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111). The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate.

For MnBr2 grown on Ir(19) the largest number of polaron species is observed, namely four, of which three show clear similarities with the species observed for CoCl2 on graphite. Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K. They can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Polarons in single-layer MnBr2 are observed up to 300 K. They can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage.

How the training signal is built

The STM topographs show that fuzzy stripe-like features follow the stripes of the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e with a wavelength of λsm ≈ 2.7 nm. This alignment indicates an interaction of the polarons with the MnBr2/Gr/Ir(110) super-moir´e. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The fuzzy polaron features partly align with the stripes of the super-moir´e. This alignment indicates an interaction of 5

The fuzzy polaron features partly align with the stripes of the super-moir´e. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The fuzzy stripe-like features arise from the mobility of the polarons driven by the interaction with the STM tip. The fuzzy polaron features partly align with the stripes of the super-moir´e.

Where the gains come from

The findings indicate that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account. The total polaron number density on Au(19) is about an order of magnitude larger than for Gr/Ir(111) and Gr/Ir(110) with ≈ 0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

However, the polaron number density at 300 K has presumably a large uncertainty, since at all Vb where polarons were visible, their interaction with the STM tip was noticeable. The presence of polarons in single-layer MnBr2 on Gr/Ir(110) is independent of specific growth conditions.

6 polarons/nm−2. The presence of an equilibrium distribution of polarons within tunneling distance to a conducting substrate implies a remarkably large magnitude of the polaron formation energy. The authors conclude that at least one polaron type is thermally stable and immobile up to 300 K, indicating a remarkably high barrier to thermal hopping. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Depending on the spatial extent of electron-phonon coupling, one commonly distinguishes small or Holstein polarons, where the distortion is confined to one or a few lattice sites, and large or Fr¨ohlich polarons, where both the lattice distortion and charge carrier wave function extend over many unit cells [1]. Polarons can strongly modify charge transport properties by increasing the effective mass or promoting thermal-activated hopping, and can also affect other properties such as chemical reactivity (detail reviewed in ref.

[1] C. Franchini, M.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate substrate-dependent modeling into density functional theory calculations for single-layer transition metal dihalides to accurately describe polaron phenomenology, as the authors state that modeling of polarons in such single-layer insulators in contact with a conducting substrate requires to take the substrate explicitly into account.

  2. Develop an AI system capable of predicting the number and species of observed polarons based on the specific metallic substrate used for growth, since The number densities and species of polarons observed vary strongly as a function of the substrate.

  3. Train a model to predict polaron stability and thermal behavior at different temperatures, as single-layer MnBr2 display[s] a remarkable thermal stability, which is crucial for understanding the equilibrium property of polarons.

  4. Implement an AI that can analyze STM imaging data across varying bias voltages to distinguish between different polaron types, such as type-I mobile polarons with the largest apparent depth of approximately 1 Å versus others.

  5. Create a system that can predict polaron mobility based on substrate interaction, specifically modeling how mobile polarons in MnBr2 are guided through the periodic potential imposed from the super-moiré resulting from the interaction of MnBr2 with graphene and Ir(110).

  6. Design an AI capable of simulating polaron creation, annihilation, and conversion processes by analyzing voltage pulse effects on existing polaron populations, such as how type-II polarons easily convert into type-I mobile polarons.

  7. Build a system that can correlate substrate electronic properties with polaron density and lateral extension, addressing the finding that the total polaron number density on Au(111) is approximately an order of magnitude larger than on other substrates.

Abstract

Single-layer transition metal dihalides grown on conducting substrates were shown to host stable polarons. Here, we investigate small polarons in a single layer of the insulator MnBr 2, which was grown by molecular beam epitaxy on three different substrates: graphene on Ir(110), graphene on Ir(111), and Au(111). Polarons on these substrates can be created, converted, and moved by the STM tip when a tunneling current flows at a proper bias voltage. Four polaron species are observed in MnBr 2 grown on graphene Ir(110), three of which resemble the species previously observed for CoCl 2 on graphite, whereas MnBr 2 grown on the other substrates exhibits only two of these four species. Changing the substrate from graphene on Ir to Au(111) increases polaron number density by an order of magnitude. These large differences demonstrate that the choice of conducting substrate plays a decisive role in determining polaron phenomenology in substrate-supported single-layer insulators. Two unique observations are reported for polarons in MnBr 2 on graphene supported by Ir(110): First, mobile polarons are guided by the periodic potential originating from the super-moiré of MnBr 2 with graphene and Ir(110); second, polarons remain stable up to 300,K.

Sources

Related papers