Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule

arXiv:2512.20449 · nucl-th, hep-ph · Submitted 2025-12-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule shows that different scenarios for how a nucleon is modified in a nucleus lead to distinct predictions for the GDH sum rule, offering a test to discriminate between mean field and short-range correlation effects The Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn sum rule is a generic relation that connects the spin-dependent cross-section for photoproduction off a particle to the squared ratio of the particle’s anomalous magnetic moment and its mass, (κ/M) Thus, for a nucleon embedded in a nucleus, the sum rule relates the crosssection to κ/M averaged quadratically over the nucleons comprising the nucleus.

Kai: The finding was surprising because the four-momentum transfer characterizing the reaction studied by the EMC experiment—deep inelastic scattering (DIS) of leptons off nuclei—is much larger than the scale characterizing nuclear binding: GeV as opposed to MeV, respectively.

Mira: Distinguishing Modification Scenarios The paper demonstrates that the value of the Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn (GDH) sum rule for an embedded nucleon depends on how uniformly the average modification is spread over all the nucleons, with the MF (uniform) and SRC (highly non-uniform) scenarios as examples.

Kai: The key insight is that if MF and SRC predict the same κ∗/M∗, they must predict different ∆σ∗.

Paper summary: Kai: The main thesis here is that different scenarios for how a nucleon is modified inside a nucleus lead to distinct predictions for the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule.

Mira: They claim that if mean field and short-range correlation scenarios predict the same k star over M star, they must predict different delta sigma stars.

Lev: That's a clever way to set up a test because it requires you to measure delta sigma and kappa over M independently to see if those predictions match.

Kai: The paper suggests that this feature offers a way to test the validity of these medium modification scenarios by measuring the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule.

Mira: They show that if mean field and short-range correlation predict the same k star over M star, they must produce distinct delta sigma stars for the GDH sum rule to hold true.

Lev: It’s about testing those model dependent assessments of the GDH value, as in, say seventeen <ref:2512.20449#pg2,model dependent assessments of the GDH value, as in, say 17>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the full picture of "Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule," it really boils down to how different ways a nucleon gets modified inside a nucleus affect that sum rule.

Mira: The authors suggest that determining the origin of the EMC effect and more generally, how nucleons change in a medium, is central to nuclear and hadronic research right now.

Lev: They also point out something about global properties of embedded nucleons like their mass or magnetic moment being observables through these sum rules, provided the sum rule remains valid and measurable.

Kai: So the real implication is that the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule has this discriminatory power for other types of medium effects that we're trying to understand.

Mira: It suggests that if you can measure those properties, it could help pin down whether we are dealing with mean field effects or short-range correlations in nuclear matter.

Lev: It's about using these sum rules to probe the structure of the nucleus itself through these nucleon properties.

A. Deur, M. M. Dalton, S. Sirca

Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility · Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana · Joů Stefan Institute

nucl-th, hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-12-23

Updated: 2025-12-23

Comments: 8 pages, 1 figure

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule shows that different scenarios for how a nucleon is modified in a nucleus lead to distinct predictions for the GDH sum…

Key concepts

Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn (GDH) Sum Rule
This is a mathematical relationship connecting the spin-dependent cross-section of photoproduction off a particle to the squared ratio of its anomalous magnetic moment ($\kappa$) and mass ($M$). For an embedded nucleon, it relates this cross-section to the quadratic average of $\kappa/M$ over all nucleons in the nucleus.
Mean Field (MF) Scenario
This scenario assumes that the modification experienced by a nucleon is spread out uniformly across all nucleons within the nucleus. When this assumption is applied, it leads to a specific prediction for how the GDH sum rule should behave based on its original form.
Short-Range Correlation (SRC) Scenario
This scenario describes a more complex modification where nucleons interact strongly over very short distances, leading to highly non-uniform changes. The paper explores how this non-uniformity influences the GDH sum rule predictions compared to the uniform mean field assumption.

Summary

Studying nuclear medium modification using the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule shows that different scenarios for how a nucleon is modified in a nucleus lead to distinct predictions for the GDH sum rule, offering a test to discriminate between mean field and short-range correlation effects

Introduction to the Sum Rule

The Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn sum rule is a generic relation that connects the spin-dependent cross-section for photoproduction off a particle to the squared ratio of the particle’s anomalous magnetic moment and its mass, (κ/M) Thus, for a nucleon embedded in a nucleus, the sum rule relates the crosssection to κ/M averaged quadratically over the nucleons comprising the nucleus. The finding was surprising because the four-momentum transfer characterizing the reaction studied by the EMC experiment—deep inelastic scattering (DIS) of leptons off nuclei—is much larger than the scale characterizing nuclear binding: GeV as opposed to MeV, respectively. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This reveals that the surrounding nuclear medium affects the distribution of quarks and gluons within the nucleon. The finding was surprising because the four-momentum transfer characterizing the reaction studied by the EMC experiment—deep inelastic scattering (DIS) of leptons off nuclei—is much larger than the scale characterizing nuclear binding: GeV as opposed to MeV, respectively.

Distinguishing Modification Scenarios

The paper demonstrates that the value of the Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn (GDH) sum rule for an embedded nucleon depends on how uniformly the average modification is spread over all the nucleons, with the MF (uniform) and SRC (highly non-uniform) scenarios as examples. The key insight is that if MF and SRC predict the same κ∗/M∗, they must predict different ∆σ∗. p. 1

Where the paper says it

III, but first we show that the presence of the squared term in Istat —while there is none in Iint —leads to MF and SRC predicting distinct values of the GDH components. In other words, if MF and SRC predict the same κ ∗/M∗ , they must predict different ∆σ ∗ .

For the MF scenario, the sum rule in Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In the SRC case, the nuclear modifications on an affected nucleon are thus about five times larger compared to the MF scenario, but overall they average to the same global nuclear effect that is experimentally determined. In this article, we show that the value of the Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn (GDH) sum rule [8] for an embedded nucleon depends on how uniformly the average modification is spread over all the nucleons, with the MF (uniform) and SRC (highly non-uniform) scenarios as examples.

(3) and (4) yields I∗ MF = χ squared I. p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 Using PD = −0. 1 and PS = +1, which yields PN = 0.

Conversely, for the SRC case, Eqs. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Thus, from Eqs. (3) and (4) the sum rule in the MF scenario is I ∗ MF = χ 2 I , while for the SRC case Eqs.

(6) and (9) yield I∗ SRC = ((χ − 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(3) and (4) the sum rule in the MF scenario is I ∗ MF = χ 2 I , while for the SRC case Eqs. (6) and (9) yield I ∗ SRC = (χ − 0.

8) squared / 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Sirca ˇ 2, 3 1Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility, Newport News, Virginia 23606, USA 2Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia 3 Joˇzef Stefan Institute, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia The Gerasimov–Drell–Hearn sum rule is a generic relation that has been used to make significant contributions to research in hadronic physics. It connects the spin-dependent cross-section for photoproduction off a particle to the squared ratio of the particle’s anomalous magnetic moment and its mass, (κ/M) 2 .

2 + 0.8)I.

Refining the Short-Range Correlation Picture

A refinement of the SRC scenario involves considering the polarization of embedded nucleons, leading to the D-wave depolarization (DWD) effect. This modification results in a relation I∗ DWD = 1 / PN (0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

χ I ∗/I SRC+DWD SRC MF 0. 1: Expected value of the medium-modified GDH sum, I ∗ , normalized to the free-nucleon case, I, as a function of χ, the average nuclear modification of κ/M.

2 PDζSRC + 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(8) is modified to Z ∆σ ∗ dν ν = 1 PN 0. 2 PDζSRC Z ∆σ dν ν + 0.

8PS) Iint = 1 / PN 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2 PDζSRC + 0. 8PS) Iint = 1 PN 0.

2 PD χ 2SRC + 0.8PS Istat. Using specific polarization values, this leads to a dependence on the average nuclear polarization from Eq. p. 2
Where the paper says it

8PS Istat ,(10) where PS is the S-wave polarization and PN = 0. 8PS makes explicit the correction for the average nuclear polarization from Eq.

(7).

Experimental Determination of Nucleon Properties

To test the scenarios, one needs independent determinations of κ∗ and M∗. This can be achieved by separating κ∗ and M∗ using the GDH and Schwinger sum rules in conjunction, yielding different ratios κ∗ 2/M squared and κ∗/M squared. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The Jefferson Lab low-Q2 GDH program [13–16, 25] also demonstrated that measurements of the GDH sum on the proton, neutron, deuteron and 3He by using electroproduction at very low Q2 are competitive with direct photoproduction measurements: the two experimental approaches involve systematic uncertainties of different origin but of comparable size. Hence, both the GDH and Schwinger sum rules could be measured concomitantly in a low-Q2 electroproduction experiment; this would yield different ratios κ ∗2/M∗2 and κ ∗/M∗2 from which κ ∗ and M∗ could be separated by using the relations κ ∗ = I ∗ 2I ∗ LT , M∗ = π r α 2 √ I ∗ I ∗ LT , where I ∗ LT denotes the measured Schwinger sum for the medium-modified proton.

Alternatively, one can determine κ∗ from magnetic form-factor measurements or M∗ through relativistic Dirac mass definitions. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Sum rules, however, illuminate this notion rather differently by implying that global properties of embedded nucleons are indeed observable (Sect. Many definitions of M∗ exist depending on the physics context, but the two most frequently used are the nonrelativistic mass and the relativistic Dirac mass.

Connection to the EMC Effect and Observables

The study is directly relevant to the EMC effect because most of the modification of the GDH sum for an embedded nucleon can be attributed to what causes the EMC effect. Furthermore, global properties of embedded nucleons such as M∗ or κ∗ may be considered observables through sum rules if the sum rule remains valid and measurable. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Finally, we point out that due to the link that sum rules provide between structure functions and global properties of the target, the global properties of embedded nucleons such as their mass, magnetic moment, axial charge etc. may be considered as observables measurable through sum rules.

The discriminatory power of GDH is transparent to other known types of medium effects. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In all, one expects the GDH value to be predominantly modified by the medium effects that cause, in particular, the EMC effect. Furthermore, the discriminatory power of GDH applies to these particular medium modifications, while being transparent to other known types of medium effects.

Conclusion

The paper concludes that different medium-modification scenarios leading to the same prediction for the EMC effect will result in different expectations for the GDH sum rule for a nucleon embedded in a nucleus. The discriminatory power of GDH is important since determining the origin of the EMC effect in particular, and more generally of medium modification, is a central issue in contemporary nuclear and hadronic research. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In practice this would at least depend on how the modification and the effective polarization vary with the relative momentum of paired nucleons. The discriminatory power of GDH that we describe in this article is important since determining the origin of the EMC effect in particular, and more generally of medium modification, is a central issue in contemporary nuclear and hadronic research.

Ideally, calculations based on any given model would provide specific expectations, which can then be tested by GDH measurements. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The discriminatory power of GDH that we describe in this article is important since determining the origin of the EMC effect in particular, and more generally of medium modification, is a central issue in contemporary nuclear and hadronic research. Ideally, calculations based on any given model would provide specific expectations, which can then be tested by GDH measurements.

Finally, we point out that due to the link that sum rules provide between structure functions and global properties of the target, the global properties of embedded nucleons such as their mass, magnetic moment, axial charge etc. p. 6
Where the paper says it

One may, however, test model-independently scenarios by supplementing the GDH evaluation by other measurements that provide κ ∗ and M∗ . Finally, we point out that due to the link that sum rules provide between structure functions and global properties of the target, the global properties of embedded nucleons such as their mass, magnetic moment, axial charge etc.

may be considered observables measurable through sum rules. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Finally, we point out that due to the link that sum rules provide between structure functions and global properties of the target, the global properties of embedded nucleons such as their mass, magnetic moment, axial charge etc. may be considered as observables measurable through sum rules.

References

[1] J. J. Aubert et al. p. 6

Where the paper says it

P1–0102 (S. Aubert et al.

, Phys. Lett. B 123, 275 (1983)

[2] I. C. Clo¨et et al. p. 6

Where the paper says it

50, 1431 (1983) [2] I. Clo¨et et al.

, J. Phys. G 46, 093001 (2019)

[3] A. W. Thomas, Int. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Thomas, Int. E 27, 1840001 (2019) [4] C.

J. Mod. Phys. E 27, 1840001 (2019)

[4] C. Ciofi degli Atti, Phys. p. 7

Where the paper says it

E 27, 1840001 (2019) [4] C. Ciofi degli Atti, Phys.

Rep. 590, 1 (2015)

[5] L. L. Frankfurt and M. p. 7

Where the paper says it

590, 1 (2015) [5] L. Frankfurt and M.

I. Strikman, Phys. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Frankfurt and M. Strikman, Phys.

Rep. 160, 235 (1988); L. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Strikman, Phys. 160, 235 (1988); L.

B. Weinstein et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

160, 235 (1988); L. Weinstein et al.

, Phys Rev Lett 106, 052301 (2011); O Hen, G A Miller E Piasetzky and L B Weinstein Rev Mod Phys 89, 045002 (2017)

[6] B. Schmookler et al. p. 7

Where the paper says it

89, 045002 (2017) [6] B. Schmookler et al.

, Nature 566, 354 (2019)

[7] O Hen et al., Int J Mod Phys E 22, 1330017 (2013)

[8] S. B. Gerasimov, Sov J Nucl Phys 2, 430 (1966) [Yad. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Gerasimov, Sov. 2, 430 (1966) [Yad.

Fiz. 2, 598 (1965)]; S D Drell and A C Hearn Phys Rev Lett 16, 908 (1966); M Hosoda and K Yamamoto Prog Theor Phys 36 (2), 425 (1966)

[9] K. Helbing, Prog Part Nucl Phys 57, 405 (2006)

[10] A Deur, S J Brodsky and G F de T´eramond Rep Prog Phys 82, 7 (2019)

[11] T Regge Nuovo Cim. 14, 951 (1959); V N Gribov JETP Lett 41, 667 (1961); G F Chew and S C Frautschi Phys Rev Lett 7, 394 (1961); R Blankenbecler and M L Goldberger Phys Rev 126, 766 (1962)

[12] H Dutz et al. Phys Rev Lett 91, 192001 (2003); H Dutz et al. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Dutz et al. 91, 192001 (2003); H.

Phys Rev Lett 93, 032003 (2004); H Dutz et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Dutz et al. 93, 032003 (2004); H.

Phys Rev Lett 94, 162001 (2512.275)

[13] K P Adhikari et al. Phys Rev Lett 120, 062501 (2512. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Adhikari et al. 120, 062501 (2018) [14] V.

3)

[14] V Sulkosky et al. Phys Lett B 805, 135428 (2020)

[15] X Zheng et al. Nature Phys 17, 736 (2021)

[16] A Deur et al. Phys Rev C 111, 035202 (2025)

[17] S D Bass Acta Phys Polon B 52, 43 (2021); S D Bass P Pedroni and A Thomas Eur Phys J A 59, 239 (2023)

[18] M M Dalton A Deur C D Keith and S Sirca Jefferson Lab Letter of Intent LOI12–23–004 (2023)

[19] K Saito K Tsushima and A W Thomas Prog Part Nucl Phys 58, 1 (2007)

[20] A M Baldin Nucl Phys 18, 310 (1960)

[21] J S Schwinger Proc Nat Acad Sci 72, 1 (1975)

[22] While the product fγσLT is observable, the individual quantities depends on the convention chosen for the virtual photon equivalent energy. In the Hand convention it is fγ = ν - Q squared / (2M). p. 7

Where the paper says it

72, 1 (1975) [22] While the product fγσLT is observable, the individual quantities depends on the convention chosen for the virtual photon equivalent energy. In the Hand convention [23], it is fγ = ν − Q 2 /(2M).

Another common convention is the Gilman convention for which fγ = p / (ν 2 + Q2) [23]

[23] L N Hand Phys Rev 129, 1834 (1963)

[24] F J Gilman Phys Rev 167, 1365 (1968)

[25] V Sulkosky et al. Nature Phys 17, 687 (2021)

[26] U T Yakhshiev U G Meissner and A Wirzba Eur Phys J A 16, 569 (2003); T Kolar et al. Phys Lett B 811, 135903 (2020); G Ron et al. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Kolar et al. B 811, 135903 (2020); G.

Phys Rev C 87, 028202 (2013)

[27] T Brecelj et al. Phys Rev C 101, 064615 (2519)

[28] F G Binon et al. Nucl Phys B 17, 168 (1970); Phys Rev Lett 35, 145 (1975); D Contardo et al. p. 7

Where the paper says it

B 17, 168 (1970); Phys. 35, 145 (1975); D.

Phys Lett B 168, 331 (1986); C W Bjork et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

B 168, 331 (1986); C. Bjork et al.

Phys Lett B 63, 31 (1976); C G Cassapakis et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

B 63, 31 (1976); C. Cassapakis et al.

Phys Lett B 63, 35 (1976); G Glass et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

B 63, 35 (1976); G. Glass et al.

Phys Rev D 15, 36 (1977); B E Bonner et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

D 15, 36 (1977); B. Bonner et al.

Phys Rev C 18, 1418 (1978); A S Clough et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

C 18, 1418 (1978); A. Clough et al.

Nucl Phys B 76, 15 (1974); A S Carroll et al. p. 7
Where the paper says it

B 76, 15 (1974); A. Carroll et al.

Phys Rev C 14, 635 (2522)

[29] C Mahaux P F Bortignon R A Broglia C H Dasso Phys Rep 120, 1 (1985)

[30] P E Hodgson Contemp Phys 24, 491 (1983)

[31] B A Li B J Cai L W Chen and J Xu Prog Part Nucl Phys 99, 29 (2018)

[32] J P Jeukenne A Lejeune and C Mahaux Phys Rep 25, 83 (1976)

[33] J P Blaizot B L Friman Nucl Phys A 372, 69 (1981)

[34] G E Brown J H Gunn P Gould Nucl Phys 46, 598 (1963)

[35] C Mahaux N Ngo Phys Lett B 100, 205 (1981)

[36] Z Zhang X B Feng L W Chen Chinese Physics C 45, 064104 (2021)

[37] J Su L Zhu C Guo Phys Rev C 101, 044606 (2522)

[38] Z Zhang L W Chen Phys Rev C 93, 034335 (2516)

[39] M Jaminon and C Mahaux Phys Rev C 40, 354 (1989)

[40] E N E van Dalen C Fuchs and A Faessler Phys Rev Lett 95, 022302 (2005)

[41] A Li J N Hu X L Shang W Zuo Phys Rev C 93, 015803 (2516)

[42] Z Zhang and L W Chen Phys Rev C 93, 034335 (2516)

[43] B A Li and L W Chen Mod Phys Lett A 30, 1530010 (2516)

[44] M Anselmino B L Ioffe and E Leader Sov J Nucl Phys 49, 136 (1989)

[45] X D Ji and J Osborne J Phys G 27, 127 (2001)

[46] D Drechsel S S Kamalov and L Tiator Phys Rev D 63, 114010 (2001)

[47] I C Cloet W Bentz and A W Thomas Phys Rev Lett 95, 052302 (2005); Phys Lett B 642, 210 (2519)

[48] O Hen et al. arXiv:2009. p. 7

Where the paper says it

B 642, 210 (2006) [48] O. , arXiv:2009.

09617 [nucl-ex]

[49] P Sharp and A Schmidt Eur Phys J A 61, 40 (2525)

[50] D G Crabb W Meyer Ann Rev Nucl Part Sci 47, 67 (1997)

[51] X Zheng et al. Nature Phys 17, 736 (2021)

[52] V Sulkosky et al. Phys Lett B 805, 135428 (2020)

[53] S J Brodsky H C Pauli and S S Pinsky Phys Rep 301, 299 (1998)

[54] L Frankfurt V Guzey and M Strikman Phys Rep 512, 255 (2012)

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can distinguish between Mean Field (MF) and Short-Range Correlation (SRC) scenarios by measuring whether the sum rule value can be calculated within these scenarios. This allows the AI to test model-dependent assessments of the GDH value as in, say, [17].

  2. Improved system can calculate the expected GDH sum for different scenarios using specific formulas. For example, it can use Eq. (9) for SRC cases: I star SRC = (chi - 0.8) squared / 0.2 + 0.8 I stat, which contrasts with the uniform modification case where I star MF = chi squared I.

  3. Improved system can incorporate nuclear polarization effects to refine scenario discrimination. By using Eq. (11) for D-wave depolarization, it can calculate I star DWD = 1 / PN (0.2 PD chi squared SRC + 0.8 PS) I stat, leading to a prediction that increasing modification tends to decrease the integral as this modification comes from nucleons which contribute with opposite polarization.

  4. Improved system can determine effective nucleon properties by separating them using combined sum rules. It can use the relations derived in Section III A to find κ star and M star from measured I star and I star LT, allowing it to compare the values I star and κ/M in the sense of Fig. 1 then discriminates in a model-independent way the frameworks proposed to explain medium modifications.

  5. Improved system can link GDH studies directly to understanding the EMC effect. It can identify that any non-uniformity observed using the GDH relation would be associated with the EMC region, suggesting that non-uniform modification is linked to what causes the EMC effect.

Abstract

The Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule is a generic relation that has been used to make significant contributions to research in hadronic physics. It connects the spin-dependent cross-section for photoproduction off a particle to the squared ratio of the particle's anomalous magnetic moment and its mass, (κ/M) squared. Thus, for a nucleon embedded in a nucleus, the sum rule relates the cross-section to κ/M averaged quadratically over the nucleons comprising the nucleus. This quadratic averaging can be used to constrain the mechanism responsible for the medium modification of the nucleon. We also point out that the global properties of the embedded nucleon like its axial charge, mass or magnetic moment are observables measurable through sum rules.

Sources

Related papers