Colloquium: A critique on van der Waals and two-dimensional magnets

arXiv:2512.19417 · cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2025-12-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Colloquium: A critique on van der Waals and two-dimensional magnets".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This colloquium offers a critical overview of magnetic two-dimensional (2D) crystals, related quasi-2D van der Waals (vdW) magnets, and their heterostructures.

Kai: It provides a foundation in 2D magnetism, covering microscopic quantum spin interactions (direct exchange, superexchange), statistical physics (Onsager's solutions), micro/nano-magnetism (domain walls), early signatures of 2D spin excitations (magnons), strong electronic correlation effects leading to quantum spin liquids, and the topology of electronic band structures.

Mira: Key areas discussed include the availability of 2D/vdW magnets, predictions for these systems, dimensionality crossover, and various tuning methods such as composition, electric-field effects (linear magnetoelectric coupling, electrostatic doping), proximity effects, stress/pressure effects, stacking/moiré effects—where the magnetic interlayer interaction depends on stacking configuration (ferromagnetic in rhombohedral vs.

Kai: antiferromagnetic in monoclinic)—and exploiting van der Waals junctions for spin transport and spin-orbit torque.

Paper summary: Kai: So we've just talked about what this paper is critiquing—it’s looking at a decade of research into 2D crystals, and the main thesis is about what's actually new <ref:2512.19417#pg1>.

Mira: The authors are saying that these systems, especially the quasi-2D van der Waals magnets, they seem to be purer implementations of 2D spin models than the traditional ultra-thin film systems we usually study <ref:2512.19417#pg1,they seem to be purer implementations of 2D spin models than>.

Lev: So they see a fundamental difference in how these materials behave compared to what we've been modeling for a long time. What’s the main point they are pushing?

Kai: They are highlighting that the role of relative atomic stacking, which is changed by things like planar strains or lateral sliding, directly alters how interatomic bonds form and consequently changes the superexchange interaction between spins >

Mira: And they also say that this structural detail is important because it dictates the magnetic orientation and bond length, which in turn affects those magnetic exchange interactions >

Lev: That means if you want to control the magnetism, you can't just look at the material composition; you have to worry about how it’s stacked on itself.

Kai: They connect this structural tuning to things like proximity effects and how stacking configurations—like ferromagnetic in rhombohedral versus antiferromagnetic in monoclinic—determine the interlayer magnetic interaction >

Mira: They are also looking at how we can exploit these van der Waals junctions for spin transport or spin-orbit torque, which is where the practical applications start to get interesting >

Lev: I'm thinking that connecting the stacking geometry to functional properties like spin transport is a big hurdle for experimentalists right now. It requires very precise control over layer interfaces.

Kai: Beyond structure, they are also looking at external tuning methods, specifically using electric fields for linear magnetoelectric coupling or electrostatic doping to adjust the magnetism >

Mira: And they bring in stress and pressure effects because how you physically manipulate the material directly impacts those magnetic properties >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, all these external tuning methods—composition, electric fields, stress—are a way to explore dimensionality crossover and see how those 2D magnets behave as they move toward three dimensions > <ref:2512.19417#pg1>

Kai: They also discuss moiré effects arising from twisting nonmagnetic multilayers because those systems develop flat bands and correlated phases which are relevant to the 2D picture > <ref:2512.19417#pg1>

Mira: And they address some big, unanswered questions that have remained limited, like frustration physics, orbital magnetism, and topology in these systems >

Lev: I see that exploring things like quantum spin liquids or topological phases in these materials requires a level of material purity that is currently very hard to achieve.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at the whole "Colloquium: A critique on van der Waals and two-dimensional magnets," they aren't trying to give a complete picture, which is what they say >

Mira: They are referring the reader to more extended reviews, like Park et al. or Wang et al., because their goal isn't comprehensiveness, but offering different perspectives >

Lev: So what does this critique ultimately mean for the field? Is it a call to abandon one way of thinking and start another?

Kai: It seems the main implication is that we need to look at new physical effects that have become accessible in 2D/vdW magnets today, which weren't entirely expected before > <ref:2512.19417#pg1>

Mira: They emphasize that these new effects rarely emerge purely by accident; they were often anticipated or partially explored in other materials, so it’s a more structured exploration >

Lev: And for me, what this means is that the focus should shift to how these materials can be used as platforms for magnonics by exploiting unique couplings between quasiparticles and spin waves >

Kai: They point out that the uniqueness of these 2D/vdW materials lies in their atomically flat interfaces and their extreme susceptibility to mechanical deformation, proximity, electric-field effects, stacking moiré effects > <ref:2512.19417#pg1>

Mira: And specific opportunities open up when they host hybrid quasiparticles sensitive to magnetic fields or allow spin logic through artificial van der Waals interfaces >

Lev: I think the authors are saying that while spintronics detection schemes are inspiring, realizing truly exotic phases still requires extreme conditions on the materials >

Johann Coraux, *, Nicolas Rougemaille, *, Cedric Robert, Clément Faugeras, Andrés Saul, Benořt Gr຃maud, Luis Hueso, 7 F༞nix Casanova, 6, 7 and Aur࠻lien Manchon4, ‡

Université Grenoble Alpes · CNRS Institut NEEL · Grenoble INP · Université de Toulouse · INSA-CNRS-UPS LPCNO · Laboratoire National des Champs Magn຃tiques Intenses LNCMI-EMFL CNRS UPR3228 Univ. Grenoble Alpes Univ. Toulouse Univ. Toulouse 3 INSA-T Grenoble and Toulouse France Aix Marseille Université Aix Marseille Université de Toulon CNRS CPT Marseille · CIC nanoGUNE BRTA Donostia San Sebastian IKERBASQUE Basque Foundation for Science

cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2025-12-22

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 25 pages, 10 figures; published in Review of Modern Physics

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: This colloquium offers a critical overview of magnetic two-dimensional (2D) crystals, related quasi-2D van der Waals (vdW) magnets, and their heterostructures.

Key concepts

Direct Exchange
This is a microscopic quantum spin interaction where the magnetic moments of neighboring atoms directly influence each other's spin alignment. It is a key mechanism in determining the magnetic ordering within these 2D materials, dictating how spins interact at the atomic level.
Magnon Topology
This refers to the geometric structure or shape of spin excitations (magnons) in a material. Understanding this topology is crucial for predicting their behavior, such as whether they can exhibit topological properties like edge states when coupled with other electronic structures.
Moiré Effects
These effects arise when two nonmagnetic layers are twisted slightly relative to each other, creating a superlattice pattern. This twisting can induce new electronic features, such as flat bands and correlated phases, which are important for developing novel magnetic states in these systems.

Terminology

Summary

This colloquium offers a critical overview of magnetic two-dimensional (2D) crystals, related quasi-2D van der Waals (vdW) magnets, and their heterostructures. p. 0

Where the paper says it

They represent interesting platforms for exploring, challenging, or simply revisiting a wide range of phenomena in condensed matter magnetism. This colloquium intends to offer a critical, yet not necessarily skeptical, overview of the field, clarifying what we believe could be unique with 2D magnets, related quasi-2D van der Waals magnets, and their heterostructures.

It provides a foundation in 2D magnetism, covering microscopic quantum spin interactions (direct exchange, superexchange), statistical physics (Onsager's solutions), micro/nano-magnetism (domain walls), early signatures of 2D spin excitations (magnons), strong electronic correlation effects leading to quantum spin liquids, and the topology of electronic band structures.

Key areas discussed include the availability of 2D/vdW magnets, predictions for these systems, dimensionality crossover, and various tuning methods such as composition, electric-field effects (linear magnetoelectric coupling, electrostatic doping), proximity effects, stress/pressure effects, stacking/moiré effects—where the magnetic interlayer interaction depends on stacking configuration (ferromagnetic in rhombohedral vs. antiferromagnetic in monoclinic)—and exploiting van der Waals junctions for spin transport and spin-orbit torque. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Orbital magnetism 22 H. Van der Waals junctions for spin transport 23 I.

The discussion also covers spin excitations, including magnon detection techniques (inelastic neutron scattering, STM) and magnon transport in vdW antiferromagnets. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Detection of spin excitations in single-layers 17 2. Magnon transport 18 3.

Magnon topology has been explored concerning topological insulators and magnon edge states, as well as coupling spin excitations with others (e. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Topological magnons 18 4. Coupling spin excitations with others 19 F.

g., magneto-elastic effects leading to magnon-polarons). p. 3
Where the paper says it

Once electronic structures are computed, exchange interactions can be extracted and are often interpreted using simplified ligand-field or tight-binding–based models (Khomskii, 2014), which incorporate orbital energies, crystal-field effects, hopping integrals, and Hubbard-like Coulomb and exchange terms. Such models gave invaluable insights into the leading magnetic interactions in a wide range of oxides, sulfides, fluorides, and related materials.

Noncollinear spin textures (topological or not), frustrated systems, orbital magnetism, and flatband magnetism arising from electron correlations in materials like graphene are also addressed. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Noncollinear spin textures, topological or not 20 2. Frustrated systems 21 G.

The realization of intrinsically 2D magnetic topological phases remains challenging due to material purity requirements. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Again, the number of theoretical studies is incommensurate with the handful of experiments reporting signatures of magnon topology. Alongside tremendous progress in the realm of topological physics, the realization of intrinsically 2D magnetic topological phases is an ongoing challenge.

The paper highlights recent advances illustrating the potential of 2D magnets for spin-orbit torque through self-torque behavior in Fe 3 GeTe 2 layers and integrating 2D magnets with materials hosting strong spin-orbit coupling and broken inversion symmetry for field-free magnetization switching. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Overall, these mechanisms typically favor antiparallel spin alignment, consistent with the prevalence of antiferromagnetism in nature. In the presence of inversion symmetry breaking and spin-orbit coupling, in bulk or at interfaces, an antisymmetric exchange arises, named Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction, that stabilizes noncollinear spin alignment (Dzyaloshinskii, 1957; Moriya, 1960), leading to a rich magnetic landscape including, e.

Furthermore, the coupling between electronic band structure and magnetic order has been revealed in directbandgap semiconductor vdW antiferromagnets like CrSBr. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Hybrid functionals, such as HSE06, partly remedy these limitations by mixing LSDA/GGA with Hartree–Fock exchange, yielding more accurate band structures for 2D/vdW magnets, albeit at a higher computational cost (Wang et al. Once electronic structures are computed, exchange interactions can be extracted and are often interpreted using simplified ligand-field or tight-binding–based models (Khomskii, 2014), which incorporate orbital energies, crystal-field effects, hopping integrals, and Hubbard-like Coulomb and exchange terms.

The potential of 2D/vdW magnets for magnonics is emphasized through unique couplings between quasi-particles and spin waves, and the possibility of interfacing them with materials hosting other ferroic or charge orders. p. 7
Where the paper says it

How thermal/quantum fluctuations impact the complexity of a phase diagram finds a striking illustration in cuprates, which feature many competing phases (d-wave superconductivity, spin and charge density waves, Fermi liquids, etc), resulting in fluctuations or precursor orders with marked signatures even at temperatures above the transitions (Seibold et al. More recently, experiments involving vdW transition metal dichalcogenides have unveiled the interplay between charge and superconducting orders (Hwang et al.

While spintronics detection schemes (nonlocal spin valves, tunnel junctions, spin-torque devices) are inspiring, realizing exotic phases still requires extreme conditions. The paper notes that magnetic moiré systems obtained by twisting nonmagnetic multilayers also develop flat bands and correlated phases. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The emblematic example in 2D magnetic systems is the integer quantum Hall effect, wherein the Hall conductance is quantized in integer multiples of e 2/h, corresponding to the Chern number of the filled Landau levels (Haldane, 1988; Thouless et al. This quantum anomalous Hall effect (QAHE) preludes later discoveries of magnetic topological insulators made of either intrinsic or magnetically-doped vdW multilayers [see, e.

Although these are covered in reviews, the techniques developed for 2D magnetism are becoming useful here. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This small interaction, although always present, obviously does not account for the diversity of magnetic orlocalized delocalized metal non-metal (direct exchange) conduction electrons magnetic cation non- magnetic anion superexchange eg t 2g double-exchange antisymmetric exchange EF E = + itinerant (band) FIG. 2 Spin-spin interactions, in the picture of localized spins and in the paradigm of itinerant magnetism.

The overall conclusion is cautious: concluding the critique is delicate, and the simplest approach is to return to the introduction, emphasizing that contemporary questions often echo past motivations, and toy models still drive fundamental investigations into new materials like 2D/vdW systems. The uniqueness of these materials lies in their atomically flat interfaces and extreme susceptibility to mechanical deformation, proximity, electric-field, stacking/moiré effects—some of which are already exploited elsewhere. Specific opportunities arise when they host hybrid quasiparticles sensitive to magnetic fields or allow spin logic via artificial vdW interfaces.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved material discovery can be achieved by using machine learning algorithms to search for new materials with designer properties, as these algorithms reduce the computational cost by learning from a 'small' dataset. This allows for searching beyond traditional ab initio methodologies that rely on DFT+U, assumed collinear magnetism.

  2. Enhanced prediction accuracy can be gained by moving beyond simple Ising approximations in Monte Carlo simulations to include higher-order terms like biquadratic and directionally-dependent exchange, which can be large in 2D/vdW materials such as RuCl3. This leads to more reliable TCurie predictions.

  3. AI systems can be used to guide experimental efforts by identifying chemical trends that guide experiments, such as those found in high-throughput calculations, allowing researchers to test the robustness of DFT+U results through targeted hybrid functional calculations on selected compounds.

  4. The system can be equipped to analyze complex magnetic structures like skyrmions and domain walls using topological invariants derived from homotopy groups, which are associated with a topological invariant (or charge), which counts the winding number of the 3D spin field projected onto a plane.

  5. Improved characterization capabilities can be developed for probing magnon topology by applying scanning tunneling microscopy to single-layer materials to detect magnon-assisted tunneling conductance, providing a method for observing edge states that are currently challenging to observe with other techniques.

Abstract

Magnetic two-dimensional (2D) crystals were isolated about a decade ago, triggering a tremendous research activity worldwide. This colloquium raises a stiff question: what is really new about them? At first sight, they seem to be purer implementations of 2D spin models than traditional systems such as ultra-thin films. Yet, they partly realized their promises so far, and whether they give fresh perspectives on long-standing predictions in statistical physics is still an open question. Undoubtedly, they are uniquely amenable to electric-field effect, susceptible to mechanical deformation, and sensitive to moirés, for example. They represent interesting platforms for exploring, challenging, or simply revisiting a wide range of phenomena in condensed matter magnetism. This colloquium intends to offer a critical, yet not necessarily skeptical, overview of the field, clarifying what we believe could be unique with 2D magnets, related quasi-2D van der Waals magnets, and their heterostructures.

Sources

Related papers