The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary Black Hole Event GW231123
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary Black Hole Event GW231123".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper searches for lensing signatures in GW231123 using model-independent residual tests and finds no strong evidence for lensing at this stage, but reveals a potential residual feature consistent with microlensing with a modulation amplitude of up to 0.8 at 95% confidence Event Context and Motivation The recently discovered gravitational wave event, GW231123, is the most massive binary black hole merger detected to date.
Kai: The inferred source masses of the event fall within the pair-instability supernova mass gap, where black holes formed directly from stellar progenitors are expected to be rare, making alternative formation scenarios for such massive black holes especially relevant.
Mira: Gravitational lensing can provide an alternative explanation for the inferred source masses of GW231123, lying within the PISN gap.
Kai: When gravitational waves propagate near massive objects, their trajectories deviate from the straight path due to the curvature of spacetime created by the massive object (A.
Title and authors: Kai: So let's talk about the title and authors of this paper, "The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary Black Hole Event GW231123". This title tells you right away what they are trying to do.
Mira: It sets a very specific scope: they are looking for a model-independent upper bound on the signature of microlensing, specifically tied to that highest mass binary black hole event, GW231123.
Lev: The "model-independent" part is key here because it means they aren't assuming a specific distribution for the lens mass; they are testing if *any* common structure across all detectors could indicate lensing.
Kai: Right, so the focus isn't on proving a specific lens model, but rather setting an upper limit on what lensing could look like based only on the data.
Mira: And it connects this to GW231123 because that event is in a mass regime—the pair-instability supernova mass gap—where black holes are expected to form in a way that makes lensing an alternative explanation for their inferred masses.
Lev: It frames the problem perfectly for us, because if we can constrain these effects, it helps us understand those rare stellar black hole formation scenarios.
Kai: It suggests that even with the uncertainties in waveform modeling, we still have a rigorous way to test for these wave-optics effects without needing a perfect lens model first.
The paper's summary: Mira: So the summary of this paper boils down to them using µGLANCE, which is this model-independent way to test for wave-optics lensing effects in the GW signal.
Kai: They use the best-fit waveform model to calculate residuals across different detectors and then cross-correlate those residuals to find any unmodeled structures that are common to all detectors.
Lev: The method requires that the feature found must be common across all detectors; if it's only in one detector, it's just noise or a waveform modeling issue, which is a big caveat.
Mira: They then perform a Bayesian inference in the lensing parameter space using an amplification template based on frequency-dependent oscillatory features to see if amplitude and phase modulation occur.
Kai: The result they report is that while they found no strong evidence for lensing at this stage, they did reveal a potential residual feature consistent with microlensing, with that modulation amplitude being up to zero point eight at ninety-five percent confidence <ref:2512.19077#pg3>.
Lev: So even without claiming a definitive detection of lensing, the paper points to a specific residual signal that needs further investigation on real hardware.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's look at the improvements they suggest for this work, because it’s clear they know where their method falls short. They are focusing on how to handle the big systematic errors.
Mira: One improvement is incorporating waveform systematics directly into Bayesian frameworks to better distinguish true astrophysical properties from artifacts, which addresses the point that these systems have very large systematics.
Lev: That's crucial for real hardware; if you can model how much the noise and modeling uncertainty shifts your estimates, you get a better picture of what's real versus just modeling error.
Kai: They also developed µGLANCE as this model-independent residual cross-correlation technique that specifically suppresses uncorrelated detector noise to find common features across all detectors.
Mira: That means they are trying to isolate the true signal from the noise component that isn't correlated between detectors, which is a necessary step for detecting any beyond modeled signature.
Lev: I like that focus on suppressing uncorrelated noise; in real hardware, we have to be very careful about what we count as a signal versus just random detector chatter.
Kai: Another improvement involves creating a systematic error quantification method using the mismatch function M of h1 and h2 to measure the deviation between different waveform models.
Mira: This is how they revealed that waveform systematics can actually play a significant role in collecting the residual of a GW event and in attributing that residual to a lensing modulation effect, which is something we didn't expect to see so strongly.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up, the paper on "The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary Black Hole Event GW231123" suggests that while they didn't find definitive proof of lensing, they found a potential feature consistent with it.
Mira: The main implication is that for high-mass events, we need better waveform models first; the current set of models shows high systematic uncertainties between them, up to about twenty-five percent at maximum <ref:2512.19077#pg2>.
Lev: That uncertainty means that before we can really constrain the source properties or definitively claim lensing, we need those accurate waveforms you mentioned earlier.
Kai: They predict that if GW231123 is lensed, similar events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity over a three-year runtime at approximately four point zero eight to two point zero two for the O4a-like detector sensitivities we have coming up.
Mira: They also point out that a lower-band detector, something like TianGo or LISA, would allow for better constraints on these intermediate mass binary black hole sources like GW231123 properties.
Lev: I think the paper does a good job of setting the stage for future observations while being very honest about the current limitations imposed by waveform modeling errors.
Aniruddha Chakraborty, Suvodip Mukherjee
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research
gr-qc, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.HE
Submitted: 2025-12-22
Updated: 2026-04-18
Comments: 25 pages, 10 figues (Included appendices). Accepted for publication in ApJ
Journal ref: 2026 ApJ 1003 20
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: The paper searches for lensing signatures in GW231123 using model-independent residual tests and finds no strong evidence for lensing at this stage…
Key concepts
- μ-GLANCE
- A model-independent technique used to test for wave-optics lensing effects in gravitational wave signals. It works by comparing residuals across different detectors, looking for structures that are common to all detectors, rather than relying on a specific lens model.
- Waveform Systematics
- Large uncertainties arising from modeling heavy binary black hole mergers. These uncertainties can create correlated residuals that mimic lensing signatures, making it hard to distinguish true lensing from modeling errors.
- μ-GLANCE Residual Cross-Correlation
- The specific method used to find common features in the data. It calculates a cross-correlation between detectors using the residual GW and detector noise, helping isolate signals that are not explained by the best-fit waveform model alone.
- Microlensing Modulation
- A potential effect where the amplitude of a gravitational wave signal is periodically modulated due to its passage near compact objects, like stars or black holes. This paper looked for evidence of such a modulation in GW231123.
Terminology
Summary
The paper searches for lensing signatures in GW231123 using model-independent residual tests and finds no strong evidence for lensing at this stage, but reveals a potential residual feature consistent with microlensing with a modulation amplitude of up to 0. p. 0 The method tests residual strain for
correlated features across the detector network via cross-correlation and infers lensing-induced modulations within a Bayesian framework. Our analysis finds no strong evidence for lensing in GW231123,
but reveals a potential residual feature that could be consistent with microlensing, with a modulation
amplitude of up to 0.Where the paper says it
Event Context and Motivation
The recently discovered gravitational wave event, GW231123, is the most massive binary black hole merger detected to date. The inferred source masses of the event fall within the pair-instability supernova mass gap, where black holes formed directly from stellar progenitors are expected to be rare, making alternative formation scenarios for such massive black holes especially relevant. p. 0 1
The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary
Black Hole Event GW231123
Aniruddha Chakraborty 1 and Suvodip Mukherjee 1
1Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Road, Navy Nagar, Colaba, Mumbai 400005, India
ABSTRACT
The recently discovered gravitational wave event, GW231123, is the most massive binary black hole
merger detected to date. The inferred source masses of the event fall within the pair-instability supernova mass gap, where black holes formed directly from stellar progenitors are expected to be rare,
making alternative formation scenarios for such massive black holes especially relevant. Examples of such channels include black holes of primordial origin, or black holes
produced to successive mergers of less massive black holes. Gravitational lensing can provide an alternative explanation for the inferred source masses of GW231123, lying
within the PISN gap. 2021e, 2024b) - to mention a few. When gravitational waves propagate near massive objects, their trajectories deviate from the straight path due to
the curvature of spacetime created by the massive object (A. When gravitational waves propagate near massive objects, their trajectories deviate from the straight path due to
the curvature of spacetime created by the massive object (A. Einstein 1936).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model-Independent Search Methodology
The authors employ µ-GLANCE, a model-independent way to test the presence of wave-optics lensing effects in a GW signal. This technique uses the best-fit GW waveform model to calculate residuals in different detectors, which then are correlated to find any unmodelled yet common structures. p. 3 It uses
the best-fit GW waveform model to calculate residuals in different detectors, which then are correlated to find any
unmodelled yet common structures. The mathematical structure of this technique is described in the appendix A. Lensing model independence: To claim a wave-optics feature detection, in a way irrespective of the astrophysics of the lens. It does not assume any mass-distribution model of the lensing object to detect wave-optics
lensing; it searches for common structures present in the residuals on the GW detectors.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Lensing Parameter Characterization
To confirm lensing, a Bayesian inference is performed in the lensing parameter space with an amplification template based on frequency-dependent oscillatory features. A wave-optics effect is observed if strong modulation of amplitude and phase occurs, indicated by non-zero estimations of the parameters b and b'. The estimation of the frequency scale f0 shows no support for any particular frequency, suggesting that oscillations are fitting noise artifacts without representing any physical process involved. p. 6 Some support for the rapid oscillations is obtained for a few waveforms. However, since the oscillation
amplitudes are small, these oscillations are fitting noise artifacts, without representing any physical process involved.Where the paper says it
Systematic Error Analysis
Waveform systematics for such heavy binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. The mismatch between the best-fit waveforms from different models varies in the range of 4. p. 7 We present the mismatch between the best-fit waveform models in the table 1. Compared to the NRSur7dq4 model
producing the lowest residual cross-correlation, we show that the mismatches of other waveforms vary in the range
4. Compared to other waveforms, mismatches reach 24. 7% (between IMRPhenomXO4a and IMRPhenomXPHM) at
maximum, implying a high degree of uncertainty between waveform models.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Future Prospects and Conclusions
If GW231123 is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity, opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform models. The authors predict detectable lensed events with future LVK observations at approximately 4. p. 1 We also show the result from the microlensing search on all O4a events in section 7. We predict detectable lensed events with future LVK observations and
how that would confirm the lensing status of GW231123 in section 8. However, we find that waveform systematics for such heavy
binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like
GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. We conclude that, if this event
is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity,
opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform
models. However, we find that waveform systematics for such heavy
binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like
GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. We conclude that, if this event
is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity,
opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform
models. Thus we check the systematic error associated with waveform modeling that can arise false
lensing signatures in section 5. In section 6, we show how residuals that show up in cross-correlation, can arise for a
high-mass unlensed event similar to GW231123. For high-mass GW events, in band durations are themselves
short ∼ (O(0. 1s)) and thus the characterization to the source is subjective to huge uncertainties since the waveform
models can possess large systematic errors. However, we find that waveform systematics for such heavy
binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like
GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. We conclude that, if this event
is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity,
opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform
models.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Residual Tests on Other Events
The search for wave-optics lensing signatures using the residual cross-correlation technique was applied to events in the GWTC-4 catalog. The residual SNRs obtained for these events show little-to-no support for wave-optics lensing from any of the events with a statistical significance of or above 3σ. p. 9 We find no evidence of a wave-optics
lensing modulation from any of the events with a statistical significance of or above 3σ. The maximum significance is
obtained for the event GW231114 043211 with a 2. We present the mismatch between the best-fit waveform models in the table 1. Compared to the NRSur7dq4 model
producing the lowest residual cross-correlation, we show that the mismatches of other waveforms vary in the range
4. 0σ as we remove the post-inspiral phases from this analysis. We find no evidence of a wave-optics
lensing modulation from any of the events with a statistical significance of or above 3σ.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implications for Detection
The observation of one lensed event from events up to all four observational runs suggests that similarly amplified lensed events are expected to be observed at approximately 4.08 ± 2.02 with O4-like detector sensitivities for a total runtime of 3 years. A detector to observe a lower-band in the detectable frequencies like deciHz like TianGo or mHz like LISA would allow for better constraints of the properties of intermediate-mass BBH GW sources like GW231123. p. 9 10
event like GW231123 can significantly move the estimation of inferred source properties away from the true properties,
we simulated unlensed GW events with very high source masses similar to that of GW231123, and estimated their
source parameters to observe whether such events can pose as false alarms in lensing (J. Read 2023; A. Thus we check the systematic error associated with waveform modeling that can arise false
lensing signatures in section 5. In section 6, we show how residuals that show up in cross-correlation, can arise for a
high-mass unlensed event similar to GW231123.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Waveform Systematics and False Alarms
The high level of waveform systematics associated with GWs from heavy BBH merger events can introduce effects similar to wave-optics lensing features. The mismatch between the best-fit waveforms from different models is observed to be up to ∼ 25% at maximum, implying a high degree of uncertainty between waveform models. p. 7 Compared to other waveforms, mismatches reach 24. 7% (between IMRPhenomXO4a and IMRPhenomXPHM) at
maximum, implying a high degree of uncertainty between waveform models. These results describe that even without lensing, the high level of waveform systematics associated
with GWs from heavy BBH merger events. Such waveform systematic error can, in turn, produce correlated residuals
that can show up in cross-correlation and mimic features that resemble lensing. In order to understand the GW waveform-modeling uncertainties for the high-mass black hole mergers, the inference
of the GW source properties with 5 different waveform models is shown in figure 1. The estimated posterior distributions
of the component masses, luminosity distance, inclination angle, effective spin, and coalescence phase are shown in the
figure.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved inference of source masses by incorporating waveform systematics into Bayesian frameworks to distinguish between true astrophysical properties and artifacts, as shown by
waveform systematics for such heavy binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like GW231123.
-
Development of a model-independent residual cross-correlation technique called µGLANCE that suppresses uncorrelated detector noise to find common features present in residuals across all detectors, allowing detection of
any beyond modeled signature
without assuming a lens mass distribution model. -
Enhanced ability to characterize lensing effects by performing Bayesian parameter estimation on the amplification template, which includes frequency-dependent oscillatory features for amplitude and phase modulation, ensuring that non-zero estimations of parameters like b and b' point towards a feature
caused by lensing.
-
Creation of a systematic error quantification method using the mismatch function M(h1, h2) to measure deviations between different waveform models, revealing that
waveform systematics can play a significant role in collecting the residual of a GW event and in attributing the residual to a lensing modulation effect.
-
Refined capability for detecting false alarms by simulating unlensed high-mass events with high matched-filter SNR and observing how
the estimates of inferred source properties start to deviate more from the true value, even when the same matched-filter SNR is kept the same with the same noise,
thus flagging potential systematic errors. -
Improved constraint on source parameter estimation by analyzing spin angular momentum effects, showing that
the chirp-mass estimates are not significantly affected much for any of the low-spin or high-spin cases
but thatthe mass-ratio, which decides higher order correction to the GW phase estimates can be impacted significantly.
Abstract
The recently discovered gravitational wave event, GW231123, is the most massive binary black hole merger detected to date. The inferred source masses of the event fall within the pair-instability supernova mass gap, where black holes formed directly from stellar progenitors are expected to be rare, making alternative formation scenarios for such massive black holes especially relevant. One proposed explanation is gravitational lensing, which can make the source masses to be inferred as higher than their true values. In this work, we search for lensing signatures in GW231123, together with other O4a events, using a model-independent approach with mu-GLANCE. The method tests residual strain for correlated features across the detector network via cross-correlation and infers lensing-induced modulations within a Bayesian framework. Our analysis finds no strong evidence for lensing in GW231123, but reveals a potential residual feature that could be consistent with microlensing, with a modulation amplitude of up to 0.8 at 95% confidence. However, we find that waveform systematics for such heavy binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. We conclude that, if this event is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity, opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform models.
Sources
- GW231123: a Binary Black Hole Merger with Total Mass 190-265 $M_{\odot}$
- GWTC-4.0: Updating the Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog with Observations from the First Part of the Fourth LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Observing Run
- GWTC-4.0: Population Properties of Merging Compact Binaries
- Tests of General Relativity with GWTC-3
- LISA Sensitivity and SNR Calculations
- On the effective spin-mass ratio relation of binary black hole mergers that evolved in isolation
- Gravitational waves from neutron stars
- GWTC-4.0: Searches for Gravitational-Wave Lensing Signatures
- Can GW231123 have a stellar origin?
- GW231123: Binary Black Hole Merger or Cosmic String?
- GW231123: A Possible Primordial Black Hole Origin
- False positives for gravitational lensing: the gravitational-wave perspective
- GW231123: Likely a product of successive mergers from $\sim 10 $ stellar-mass black holes
- Gravitational waves from coalescing compact binaries
- Cosmic Explorer: The U.S. Contribution to Gravitational-Wave Astronomy beyond LIGO
- GW231123 Formation from Population III Stars: Isolated Binary Evolution
- Gravitational Waves from Inspiralling Compact Binaries: A Post-Newtonian Approach
- GW231123 Mass Gap Event and the Primordial Black Hole Scenario
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals