Altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb single crystals

arXiv:2512.11344 · cond-mat.mes-hall · Submitted 2025-12-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb single crystals".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: We experimentally demonstrate both the altermagnetic bulk and the topological surface magnetizations for the altermagnetic candidate CrSb Altermagnetism in CrSb CrSb belongs to a new class of altermagnetic materials, characterized by a small net magnetization accompanied by alternating spin splitting in the k-space The material reveals topological features with Weyl surface states originating from bulk band topology The authors investigate the angle dependence of magnetization M(α) for single crystals of CrSb to observe these properties Magnetization Behavior and Slopes The magnetization M(α) oscillates around zero value, meaning it is positive for maxima and negative for minima The magnetization reversal curves M(H) are non-linear in low magnetic fields with low-field hysteresis but possess almost linear high-field branches The slope of the linear branches correlates with M(α) oscillations, being positive for maxima and negative for minima Origin of Magnetic Features The interplay between the positive and negative M(H) slopes originates from several magnetic phases in CrSb Current-carrying topological surface states are responsible for the diamagnetic-like M(H) negative slope, which dominates for directions of full spin compensation in the bulk spectrum Due to spin-momentum locking, these topological surface states are spin-polarized, causing the low-field hysteresis Topological Surface State Contribution The current-carrying topological surface states lead to the diamagnetic response which dominates for directions of full spin compensation in bulk altermagnetic spectrum These surface states are responsible for the negative magnetization values observed at M(α) minima, which correspond to topological Weyl surface states The effect is mostly pronounced for smaller samples with higher surface to bulk ratio Experimental Confirmation and Conclusion The interplay between positive and negative M(H) slopes cannot originate from the experimental setup because M(α) is not allowed to change sign for homogeneous, single-phase sample magnetization The low-field hysteresis is always characterized by a negative (diamagnetic-like) M(H) slope due to the topological surface states Thus, the study experimentally demonstrates both altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We wish to thank S.S Khasanov for X-ray sample characterization and V.A.

Kai: Zyuzin for valuable discussions REFERENCES 20 N.N.

Mira: Orlova, A.A.

Kai: Avakyants, A.V.

Paper summary: Mira: Thinking about the title of this paper, "Altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb single crystals," it really captures the dual nature they're investigating. They aren't just looking at one thing here; they are looking at both the bulk behavior and these surface effects simultaneously >

Kai: Exactly. The implication is that this material isn't just a simple magnetic substance; it possesses complex physics where the bulk properties and the topological surface features are intrinsically linked >

Lev: If we look at what this means for experimental realization, it suggests that to get the full picture of CrSb's behavior, you can't just study one aspect in isolation; you need to account for both the internal structure and those boundary conditions >

Mira: And they’ve shown that the interplay between positive and negative magnetization slopes in M H curves isn't coming from a single phase, but from several magnetic phases within CrSb >

Kai: That’s a lot of physics packed into this one finding. It means the complexity is internal to the material itself, not just something imposed externally >

Lev: So for researchers looking at magnetic topological semimetals, this paper provides an experimental route to see how these surface states translate into macroscopic magnetization measurements >

Mira: It gives a concrete way to link those abstract topological band structures in the bulk to measurable physical quantities like the angle dependent magnetization curves >

Kai: Ultimately, it solidifies that CrSb is a material where topology and magnetism are deeply intertwined, and we need methods that can probe both sides of that connection >

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up our look at this paper on "Altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb single crystals." The authors are looking at how this material behaves both internally and on its surfaces.

Mira: They’ve shown that they can experimentally demonstrate both the bulk altermagnetism and those specific topological surface magnetizations for chromium antimony. That's a pretty broad claim for a single material system.

Lev: It means they’re not just looking at one type of magnetic signal; they are measuring two distinct types of magnetism that happen in the same crystal structure. We have to ask what that actually implies for the real hardware we’re trying to build.

Kai: Well, fundamentally, it suggests that you can't ignore those surface effects when you model the bulk properties of these materials because they are intrinsically linked. It means a lot of things are happening right at the boundary.

Mira: Exactly. The core finding is that the interplay between positive and negative magnetization slopes in the measurement curves comes from several different magnetic phases within CrSb, not just one simple ordering. That's a complex internal mechanism driving the external measurements we see.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you’re designing something based on this material, you have to be careful because that surface state contribution dominates in certain directions of spin compensation. That tells you where the biggest experimental uncertainty or error will likely land in your actual device measurements.

Kai: So what they did experimentally was show that their setup couldn't actually produce those conflicting slopes on its own, but the negative slope from those topological surface states always shows up in the low-field hysteresis. That’s a strong experimental confirmation of the topology there.

Mira: It confirms that current-carrying topological surface states are responsible for that diamagnetic-like negative slope, especially when you look at directions where the bulk spectrum has full spin compensation. It connects the abstract band structure directly to what you measure with a magnet.

Lev: If we take this seriously, it suggests that understanding the bulk properties of these altermagnets requires knowing what’s happening on the surface, which is often ignored in simple models. That changes how we calculate stability and response for these types of quantum materials.

Kai: It really pushes us to look at the surface physics more closely when we think about how these materials behave under magnetic fields. This opens up a whole new avenue for what we can expect from these systems, especially when scaling them up beyond tiny samples.

N.N. Orlova, A.A. Avakyants, V.D. Esin, A.V. Timonina, N.N Kolesnikov, E.V Deviatov

Institute of Solid State Physics of the Russian Academy of Sciences

cond-mat.mes-hall

Submitted: 2025-12-12

Updated: 2025-12-12

Journal ref: Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 658, 174642 (2026)

DOI: 10.1016/j.jmmm.2026.174642

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: We experimentally demonstrate both the altermagnetic bulk and the topological surface magnetizations for the…

Key concepts

Altermagnetism
A new class of materials characterized by a small net magnetization alongside alternating spin splitting in the material's momentum space (k-space). This property leads to complex and oscillating magnetic behavior that differs from conventional magnets.
Topological Surface States
Electronic states residing on the surface of the material that possess unique topological properties. In CrSb, these states are current-carrying and spin-polarized due to spin-momentum locking, which directly influences the material's magnetic response at low fields.
Magnetization M(α) Dependence
The way magnetization changes as a function of the angle ($\alpha$) of measurement. In CrSb, this dependence is $\pi$-periodic and oscillates around zero. The slopes of the high-field linear branches are different for maxima versus minima, indicating distinct magnetic contributions from bulk and surface effects.

Terminology

Summary

The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: We experimentally demonstrate both the altermagnetic bulk and the topological surface magnetizations for the altermagnetic candidate CrSb

Altermagnetism in CrSb

CrSb belongs to a new class of altermagnetic materials, characterized by a small net magnetization accompanied by alternating spin splitting in the k-space The material reveals topological features with Weyl surface states originating from bulk band topology The authors investigate the angle dependence of magnetization M(α) for single crystals of CrSb to observe these properties

Magnetization Behavior and Slopes

The magnetization M(α) oscillates around zero value, meaning it is positive for maxima and negative for minima The magnetization reversal curves M(H) are non-linear in low magnetic fields with low-field hysteresis but possess almost linear high-field branches The slope of the linear branches correlates with M(α) oscillations, being positive for maxima and negative for minima

Origin of Magnetic Features

The interplay between the positive and negative M(H) slopes originates from several magnetic phases in CrSb Current-carrying topological surface states are responsible for the diamagnetic-like M(H) negative slope, which dominates for directions of full spin compensation in the bulk spectrum Due to spin-momentum locking, these topological surface states are spin-polarized, causing the low-field hysteresis

Topological Surface State Contribution

The current-carrying topological surface states lead to the diamagnetic response which dominates for directions of full spin compensation in bulk altermagnetic spectrum These surface states are responsible for the negative magnetization values observed at M(α) minima, which correspond to topological Weyl surface states The effect is mostly pronounced for smaller samples with higher surface to bulk ratio

Experimental Confirmation and Conclusion

The interplay between positive and negative M(H) slopes cannot originate from the experimental setup because M(α) is not allowed to change sign for homogeneous, single-phase sample magnetization The low-field hysteresis is always characterized by a negative (diamagnetic-like) M(H) slope due to the topological surface states Thus, the study experimentally demonstrates both altermagnetic bulk and topological surface magnetizations for CrSb

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We wish to thank S.S Khasanov for X-ray sample characterization and V. p. 5A. Zyuzin for valuable discussions

REFERENCES

20 N.N. Orlova, A.A. Avakyants, A. p. 0 p. 0V. Timonina, N. p. 0 p. 0N. Kolesnikov, and E. p. 0V. Deviatov, ”Crossover from relativistic to non-relativistic net magnetization for MnTe altermagnet candidate”, JETP Letters, 120, 360 (2024) https://doi. p. 5org/10.1134/S0021364024602926

8 CrSb Space group P6 3/mmc, No. 194 experimental X-ray powder diffraction of CrSb single crystal (CuK) Intensity (arb. p. 1units) Diffraction angle (2)

20 N.N. Orlova, A.A. Avakyants, A.V. Timonina, N.N. Kolesnikov and E. p. 0V Deviatov, ”Magnetization symmetry for the altermagnetic candidate MnTe”, Phys Rev. p. 5 B 111,

26 G Yang, Zh. Li, S Yang, J Li, H Zheng, W Zhu, Z Pan, Y Xu, S Cao, W Zhao, A Jana, J Zhang, M Ye, Yu Song, L-H Hu, L Yang, J Fujii, I Vobornik, M Shi, H Yuan, Y Zhang, Y Xu and Y Liu,, ”Three-dimensional mapping of the altermagnetic spin splitting in CrSb”, Nature Communications Vol. p. 6 16, 1442, pp. p. 6 1 (2025)

35 Wenlong Lu, Shiyu Feng, Yuzhi Wang, Dong Chen, Zihan Lin, Xin Liang, Siyuan Liu, Wanxiang Feng, Kohei Yamagami, Junwei Liu, Claudia Felser, Quansheng Wu and Junzhang Ma,, ”Signature of Topological Surface Bands in Altermagnetic Weyl Semimetal CrSb”, Nano Letters, Vol 25, 18, pp. 7343 (2025)

36 A.A Avakyants, N. p. 0N Orlova, A. p. 0V Timonina, N. p. 0N Kolesnikov and E. p. 0V Deviatov, ”Evidence for surface spin structures from first order reversal curves in Co3Sn2S2 and Fe3GeTe2 magnetic topological semimetals”, Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 573, 170668 (2023) https://doi. p. 6org/10.1016/j.jmmm.2023.170668

37 A A Avakyants, N N Orlova, A V Timonina, N N Kolesnikov and E V Deviatov, ”Surface Spin Polarization in the Magnetic Response of GeTe Rashba Ferroelectric”, JETP Letters, 119, 625 (2024) https://doi.org/10.1134/S0021364024600605

38 A S Borovik-Romanov, ”Investigation of Weak Ferromagnetism in the MnCO3 Single Crystal”, JETP, 9, 539 (1959)

39 I Dzyaloshinsky, ”A thermodynamic theory of “weak” ferromagnetism of antiferromagnetics” J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 4(4), 241-255 (1958)

30 B A Volkov and O A Pankratov, ”Two-dimensional massless electrons in an inverted contact”, JETP Letters, 42, 178 (1985)

31 M Z Hasan and C L Kane, ”Colloquium: Topological insulators”, Reviews of Modern Physics, Vol. 82, pp. 3045–3067 (2010)

32 Daniil S Antonenko, Rafael M Fernandes, Jorn W F Venderbos, ”Mirror Chern Bands and Weyl Nodal Loops in Altermagnets”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 096703 (2025)

33 Rafael M Fernandes, Vanuildo S de Carvalho, Turan Birol, Rodrigo G Pereira, ”Topological transition from nodal to nodeless Zeeman splitting in altermagnets”, Phys. Rev. B 109, 024404 (2024)

35 Wenlong Lu, Shiyu Feng, Yuzhi Wang, Dong Chen, Zihan Lin, Xin Liang, Siyuan Liu, Wanxiang Feng, Kohei Yamagami, Junwei Liu, Claudia Felser, Quansheng Wu and Junzhang Ma,, ”Signature of Topological Surface Bands in Altermagnetic Weyl Semimetal CrSb”, Nano Letters, Vol 25, 18, pp. 7343 (2025)

36 A A Avakyants, N N Orlova, A V Timonina, N N Kolesnikov and E V Deviatov, ”Evidence for surface spin structures from first order reversal curves in Co3Sn2S2 and Fe3GeTe2 magnetic topological semimetals”, Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 573, 170668 (2023) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmmm.2023.170668

40 Junren Shi, G Vignale, Di Xiao and Qian Niu, ”Quantum Theory of Orbital Magnetization and Its Generalization to Interacting Systems”, Phys. Rev. Lett, 99, 197202 (2007)

41 Di Xiao, Ming-Che Chang, Qian Niu, ”Berry Phase Effects on Electronic Properties”, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 1959 (2010)

36 A A Avakyants, N N Orlova, A V Timonina, N N Kolesnikov and E V Deviatov, ”Evidence for surface spin structures from first order reversal curves in Co3Sn2S2 and Fe3GeTe2 magnetic topological semimetals”, Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 573, 170668 (2023) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmmm.2023.170668

45 M(α) angle dependence of magnetization is π-periodic, see the inset to Fig 5 (a) so the high-field linear branches are of different slopes in Fig 5 (a) for M(α) minima and maxima, i.e. for α = 35◦ and α = 125◦, respectively

46 The low-field M(H) region with hysteresis within ±2 kOe at 100 K

5 M(α) angle dependence of magnetization is π-periodic, see the inset to Fig 5 (a) so the high-field linear branches are of different slopes in Fig 5 (a) for M(α) minima and maxima, i.e. for α = 35◦ and α = 125◦, respectively

47 The low-field M(H) hysteresis is always characterized by negative (diamagnetic-like) M(H) slope, even for the M(α) maxima (the red curves), which is quite unusual for standard magnetic ordering

6 A term of the paper is that M(α) oscillates around zero value, so magnetization changes a sign for M(α) maxima and minima

7 The authors demonstrate that the interplay between positive and negative M(H) slopes originates from several magnetic phases in CrSb

8 Current-carrying topological surface states are responsible for the diamagnetic-like M(H) negative slope, which dominates for the directions of full spin compensation in the bulk CrSb altermagnetic spectrum

9 Due to the spin-momentum locking, topological surface states are spin-polarized, which is responsible for the low-field hysteresis

50 M(α) angle dependence of magnetization is π-periodic, see the inset to Fig 5 (a) so the high-field linear branches are of different slopes in Fig 5 (a) for M(α) minima and maxima, i.e.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can predict magnetization reversal behavior based on angle dependence by correlating M(alpha) oscillations with M(H) slope signs, specifically predicting positive or negative slopes for high-field branches based on whether alpha corresponds to a maximum or minimum of M(alpha).

  2. Improved AI can distinguish between bulk altermagnetic and topological surface magnetization responses by analyzing the sign of the low-field M(H) slope, as this is stated to be always characterized by negative (diamagnetic-like) M(H) slope due to current-carrying topological surface states.

  3. Improved AI can model temperature dependence of high-field branches for different sample masses, specifically predicting that the slopes of the linear high-field branches are diminished for this m = 2.75 mg sample, in contrast to the smallest 1.39 mg one.

  4. Improved AI can infer magnetic phase transitions by recognizing the interplay between positive and negative M(H) slopes as evidence that M(alpha) oscillations around zero value definitely require several magnetic phases.

Sources

Related papers