Measurement of Z gamma production in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13.6 TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings

arXiv:2512.08582 · hep-ex · Submitted 2025-12-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Measurement of Z gamma production in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13.6 TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A measurement of Zγ production in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13.6 TeV has been presented.

Kai: The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1.896 ± 0.033 (stat) ± 0.054 (syst) ± 0.006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1.922 ± 0.094 pb.

Mira: Constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension-8 operators in a recently proposed effective field theory framework are determined for the first time.

Kai: Production and Selection Criteria Events with an oppositely charged pair of muons or electrons, with an invariant mass corresponding to a Z boson, together with an isolated photon are selected.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to summarize what this paper is about, they’re taking their measurement of the Z gamma production cross section and using that to set limits on these new interactions involving neutral triple gauge couplings >

Mira: Right. The thesis here is that by measuring the Z gamma process in proton-proton collisions at thirteen point six TeV, they can place constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension eight operators for the first time > <ref:2512.08582#pg1,constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension>

Lev: What this means for us is that this measurement isn't just a cross section check; it’s providing new information about how the electroweak sector behaves beyond the standard model at a very high energy scale >

Kai: They found their measured cross section is one point eight nine six plus or minus zero point zero three three statistical, plus or minus zero point zero five four systematic, plus or minus zero point zero six theoretical picobarns and this compares well to the standard model prediction of one point nine two two plus or minus zero point nine four picobarns > <ref:2512.08582#pg1,the standard model prediction of 1.922>

Mira: And they use a quadratic function describing the event yield over the standard model event yield in each electron and muon bin to compute their expected and observed limits for each operator coefficient using a profile likelihood ratio test statistic >

Lev: That quadratic fitting approach is clever, but it means the resulting limits depend heavily on those assumptions they make about how these couplings affect the yield >

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the title, "Measurement of Z gamma production in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = thirteen point six TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings," it’s clear they’re tying a concrete experimental measurement to a theoretical constraint > <ref:2512.08582#pg1,s = 13.6 TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings>

Mira: It’s about using the Z gamma process, which is already a very clean way to look at the electroweak sector, to test these dimension eight operators in this specific new effective field theory framework >

Lev: The real implication is that they’ve determined limits on neutral triple gauge couplings for the first time within this new theoretical framework, and they found that the constraints for GSPM are significantly weaker than those obtained with VPM >

Kai: That means if you only listen to the numbers, it shows that these limits on these couplings are quite tight when using the measurement derived from thirteen point six TeV proton-proton collisions > <ref:2512.08582#pg1>

Mira: Exactly. The result confirms that this measurement provides a way to constrain how strongly these new physics operators affect the interactions of neutral gauge bosons, and it highlights how different theoretical assumptions change the strength of those constraints >

CERN

hep-ex

Submitted: 2025-12-09

Updated: 2026-11-15

Comments: Replaced with the published version. Added the journal reference and the DOI. All the figures and tables can be found at http://cms-results.web.cern.ch/cms-results/public-results/publications/SMP-24-002 (CMS Public Pages)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) L091101

DOI: 10.1103/k9zs-c42w

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: A measurement of Zγ production in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13.6 TeV has been presented.

Key concepts

Zgamma production
This refers to the physical process where two protons collide and produce a Z boson, which subsequently decays into an electron or muon pair, accompanied by an isolated photon. This specific event signature is used to probe physics beyond the Standard Model.
Neutral Triple Gauge Couplings (nTGCs)
These are interaction strengths involving three gauge bosons (like the Z boson and two photons). The paper uses the measured Zgamma process to place limits on these couplings, which are predicted by higher-order quantum field theories and could indicate new physics.
Dimension-8 Operators
These are terms in an effective field theory that describe potential new interactions beyond the Standard Model. They are used here to parameterize the nTGC interactions within a framework that preserves the fundamental SU(2)L x U(1)Y gauge symmetry.

Terminology

Summary

A measurement of Zγ production in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13. p. 0

Where the paper says it

EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN) CERN-EP-2025-232 2025/12/10 CMS-SMP-24-002 Measurement of Zγ production in proton-proton collisions at √ s = 13. 6 TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings The CMS Collaboration* Abstract A measurement of the Zγ production cross section in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13.

6 TeV has been presented. p. 0
Where the paper says it

6 TeV and constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings The CMS Collaboration* Abstract A measurement of the Zγ production cross section in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13. 6 TeV is presented.

The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Events with an oppositely charged pair of muons or electrons, with an invariant mass corresponding to a Z boson, together with an isolated photon are selected. The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1.

896 ± 0.033 (stat) ± 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1. 033 (stat) ± 0.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1. 033 (stat) ± 0.

054 (syst) ± 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

033 (stat) ± 0. 054 (syst) ± 0.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

033 (stat) ± 0. 054 (syst) ± 0.

006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1. p. 0
Where the paper says it

054 (syst) ± 0. 006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1.

922 ± 0.094 pb. Constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension-8 operators in a recently proposed effective field theory framework are determined for the first time. p. 0
Where the paper says it

006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1. Constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension-8 operators in a recently proposed effective field theory framework are determined for the first time.

Production and Selection Criteria

Events with an oppositely charged pair of muons or electrons, with an invariant mass corresponding to a Z boson, together with an isolated photon are selected. The signal process pp → l+l−γ is simulated at next-to-leading order (NLO) precision in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) using MADGRAPH5 aMC@NLO version 2. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Matching of muons to tracks measured in the silicon tracker results in a relative transverse momentum pT resolution of 1% (3%) in the barrel (endcaps), for muon pT up to 100 GeV [23]. The signal process pp → ℓ +ℓ −γ is simulated at next-to-leading order (NLO) precision in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) using MADGRAPH5 aMC@NLO version 2.

9.13 [33] with up to one jet in the matrix element calculation, merged with jets from the parton showering using the FxFx matching scheme [34]. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The signal process pp → ℓ +ℓ −γ is simulated at next-to-leading order (NLO) precision in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) using MADGRAPH5 aMC@NLO version 2. 13 [33] with up to one jet in the matrix element calculation, merged with jets from the parton showering using the FxFx matching scheme [34].

Signal events must contain two same-flavor, oppositely charged leptons and a photon. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Finally, the detector response is simulated using the GEANT4 [39] package, and the simulated events are reconstructed with the same reconstruction algorithms as used for the observed events. Signal events must contain two same-flavor, oppositely charged leptons and a photon.

Muons are required to pass a set of tight identification criteria, whereas electrons are required to meet the medium identification criteria. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Signal events must contain two same-flavor, oppositely charged leptons and a photon. Muons are required to pass a set of tight identification criteria, whereas electrons are required to meet the medium identification criteria [22, 23].

All leptons are required to be isolated from the photon, quantified by an angular distance between the photon and the lepton momentum directions: ∆Rlγ = √ (∆η)2 + (∆ϕ)2 > 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Muons are required to pass a set of tight identification criteria, whereas electrons are required to meet the medium identification criteria [22, 23]. All leptons are required to be isolated from the photon, quantified by an angular distance between the photon and the lepton momentum directions: ∆Rℓγ = √ (∆η) 2 + (∆ϕ) 2 > 0.

5.

Theoretical Frameworks for Constraints

The Zγ process provides a powerful tool for placing constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings (nTGCs). These couplings first appear through the gauge invariant dimension-8 operators in the SMEFT [4–7]. p. 2

Where the paper says it

These couplings do not appear among the dimension-4 terms of the SM Lagrangian, nor are they generated by dimension-6 terms in SM extensions via the SM effective field theory (SMEFT) [1–3]. Instead, nTGCs first appear through the gauge invariant dimension-8 operators in the SMEFT [4–7].

A new theoretical framework for nTGCs has recently been proposed in which the nTGC interactions are derived from dimension-8 operators evaluated in the EW broken phase. p. 2
Where the paper says it

So far, BSM physics searches using Zγ production [11–13] have relied on a vertex parameterization model (VPM), which only considers the unbroken U(1)EM gauge symmetry [6, 15], and is in contrast to the dimension-8 operators in the SMEFT that preserve the full EW gauge group SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y of the SM. A new theoretical framework for nTGCs has recently been proposed [16], in which the nTGC interactions are derived from dimension-8 operators evaluated in the EW broken phase.

This new framework preserves the SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry, unlike conventional approaches that modify TCG vertex coupling constants. p. 2
Where the paper says it

A new theoretical framework for nTGCs has recently been proposed [16], in which the nTGC interactions are derived from dimension-8 operators evaluated in the EW broken phase. The conventional approach of modifying the TCG vertex coupling constants leads to a violation of SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry, whereas the new theoretical framework preserves the SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry.

Constraint Determination and Comparison

The analysis uses a quadratic function of the coupling values for each mllγ bin to describe the nTGC event yield over the SM event yield. Expected and observed 95% CL limits are computed for each operator coefficient, based on the profile likelihood ratio test statistic [41]. p. 7

Where the paper says it

To obtain a continuous signal yield variation as a function of the coupling, the nTGC event yield over the SM event yield is described as a quadratic function of the coupling values for each mℓℓγ bin. Expected and observed 95% confidence level (CL) limits are computed for each operator coefficient, based on the profile likelihood ratio test statistic [41].

The results show that the limit on the vertex parameter h4 differs between VPM and GSPM, with GSPM constraints being significantly weaker than those obtained with VPM. p. 8
Where the paper says it

From the results of the converted limits, it can be seen that the limit on the vertex parameter h4 differs between VPM and GSPM. The limits for GSPM, which maintains the full SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge constrains, are significantly weaker than those obtained with VPM, which preserves only the unbroken U(1)EM symmetry.

Experimental Uncertainties

The total uncertainty on the fiducial cross section is 3.4%. The experimental sources of systematic uncertainties include uncertainties in the estimate of the nonprompt photon background from control samples in data, as well as those associated with lepton and photon identification efficiencies, the lepton trigger, pileup [13] (additional inelastic pp collisions in the same or adjacent bunch crossings), and integrated luminosity [48]. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Variations of the ISR and FSR contributions consist of 4 combinations made by keeping one constant and doubling or halving the other. The experimental sources of systematic uncertainties include uncertainties in the estimate of the nonprompt photon background from control samples in data, as well as those associated with lepton and photon identification efficiencies, the lepton trigger, pileup [13] (additional inelastic pp collisions in the same or adjacent bunch crossings), and integrated luminosity [48].

The most significant contribution arises from the photon identification (1. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The statistical uncertainties from the limited size of the simulated signal and background samples are also included in the final fit, using the Barlow–Beeston-lite approach [49]. Among all types of uncertainties, the most significant contribution arises from the photon identification (1.

67%), followed by the integrated luminosity uncertainty (1. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Among all types of uncertainties, the most significant contribution arises from the photon identification (1. 67%), followed by the integrated luminosity uncertainty (1.

4%).

Final Results Summary

The observed combined result 1.896 ± 0.033 (stat) ± 0.054 (syst) ± 0.006 (theo) pb is in good agreement with the predictions, within uncertainties. p. 6

Where the paper says it

054 (syst) ± 0. 006 (theo) pb is in good agreement with the predictions, within uncertainties.

The mllγ distribution is used to set 95% confidence level limits on neutral triple gauge couplings. p. 8
Where the paper says it

006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1. The mℓℓγ distribution is used to set 95% confidence level limits on neutral triple gauge couplings.

These limits are derived, for the first time, in the context of a recently proposed framework of the effective field theory based on dimension-8 operators, which maintains SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry [16]. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The mℓℓγ distribution is used to set 95% confidence level limits on neutral triple gauge couplings. These limits are derived, for the first time, in the context of a recently proposed framework of the effective field theory based on dimension-8 operators, which maintains SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry [16].

The results combine measurements in both electron and muon channels to constrain nTGCs. p. 8
Where the paper says it

7 combine the measurements in the electron and muon channels. Two theoretical interpretations are considered: VPM and GSPM.

The limits for GSPM, which maintains the full SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge constrains, are significantly weaker than those obtained with VPM. p. 8
Where the paper says it

From the results of the converted limits, it can be seen that the limit on the vertex parameter h4 differs between VPM and GSPM. The limits for GSPM, which maintains the full SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge constrains, are significantly weaker than those obtained with VPM, which preserves only the unbroken U(1)EM symmetry.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform direct discovery of physics beyond the standard model by searching for dimension-8 operators in neutral triple gauge couplings (nTGCs). This is achieved by setting constraints on nTGCs generated by dimension-8 operators in the SMEFT framework, which first appear through the gauge invariant dimension-8 operators in the SMEFT [4–7].

  2. Improved AI can distinguish between different theoretical frameworks for nTGCs. The system can compare the predictions from dimension-8 operators with those obtained from vertex formulation, noting that the conventional approach of modifying the TCG vertex coupling constants leads to a violation of SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry, whereas the new theoretical framework preserves the SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y gauge symmetry.

  3. Improved AI can set more precise constraints on specific BSM physics parameters. The system can calculate Expected and observed 95% CL limits on nTGC parameters for the combination of the measurements in the electron and muon channels, specifically showing how the limit on the vertex parameter h4 differs between VPM and GSPM.

  4. Improved AI can optimize experimental trigger systems for specific physics targets. The system can utilize information from a two-tiered trigger system to ensure high efficiency, such as using a collection of high-level trigger paths for leptons, including single and double lepton trigger paths, to ensure a trigger efficiency exceeding 99% for events that satisfy the subsequent offline selection criteria.

  5. Improved AI can accurately reconstruct complex particle signatures. The system can employ a global particle-flow (PF) algorithm to reconstruct all individual particles in an event, combining information provided by the all-silicon inner tracker and by the crystal electromagnetic (ECAL) and brass-scintillator hadron calorimeters.

Abstract

A measurement of the Z γ production cross section in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 13.6 TeV is presented. Data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 34.8 fb-1, collected by the CMS experiment at the LHC in 2022 are used. Events with an oppositely charged pair of muons or electrons, with an invariant mass corresponding to a Z boson, together with an isolated photon are selected. The measured fiducial cross section for the combined electron and muon channels is 1.896 plus or minus 0.033 (stat) plus or minus 0.054 (syst) plus or minus 0.006 (theo) pb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 1.922 plus or minus 0.094 pb. Constraints on neutral triple gauge couplings generated by dimension-8 operators in a recently proposed effective field theory framework are determined for the first time.

Sources

Related papers