Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes proposes a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes: 4πJ2/(3MV) < 1<ref:2512.07825/pg6.
Kai: This inequality is derived by analyzing the roots of the identity relating the thermodynamic variables, ensuring the avoidance of naked singularities, and consequently preventing violations of the cosmic censorship conjecture<ref:2512.07825#pg7>.
Mira: Derivation from Identity Roots The inequality is established by examining identities relating thermodynamic parameters to ensure physical constraints are met<ref:2512.07825#pg4>.
Kai: For the Kerr-AdS black hole, an identity holds among the thermodynamic parameters in extended phase space<ref:2512.07825#pg4>.
Paper summary: Kai: So what are we actually looking at with this paper, "Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes" by Hamid R Bakhtiarizadeh et al.? It establishes this new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes.
Mira: Essentially, the authors derive it from analyzing identities among the variables, which sets a condition that must be met just to have a physical horizon exist without becoming naked or violating cosmic censorship.
Lev: The implications are that this inequality acts as a necessary condition for satisfying the reverse isoperimetric inequality in rotating spacetimes, suggesting this bound holds even when rotation is involved.
Kai: It also imposes a tighter bound on the charge of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black strings, which is another concrete result they found when they looked at those specific solutions.
Mira: The paper provides strong evidence for this inequality across a broad class of solutions, from Kerr-AdS to rotating AdS black strings, and it suggests this bound applies universally regardless of the horizon topology.
Lev: The authors also show how this relates to the identity thirty-six pi M f squared V squared minus M f squared A cubed minus sixty-four pi J four equals zero for some of these solutions, which is a specific constraint they found for the uncharged Kerr-Sen-AdS black hole.
Kai: It’s a new standalone principle here, derived from the condition for a physical horizon existence, and it links directly to the cosmic censorship conjecture.
Mira: This work gives us this new inequality as a necessary condition for satisfying that reverse isoperimetric inequality in rotating spacetimes.
Lev: It also sets up some conjectures for higher dimensions, suggesting how this might generalize if the reverse isoperimetric inequality continues to hold there.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at this paper, "Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes." It’s about proving this new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes.
Mira: Yeah, basically, they’re showing that there's a mathematical rule—an inequality—that must be followed if you want to have a physical horizon without it becoming something unphysical or violating cosmic censorship.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it’s neat because they derive this from analyzing the roots of some identities relating the thermodynamic variables. It sounds like a necessary condition for the math to make sense physically.
Kai: Right, so it's not just a neat math trick; it's tied to ensuring we don't have naked singularities when we're dealing with these rotating black holes in Anti-de Sitter space.
Mira: Exactly. They look at the Kerr-AdS and even other complex geometries, like those rotating black strings, and they find this constraint shows up consistently across different setups.
Lev: It’s interesting that it seems to apply regardless of the horizon's shape or topology; that universality is what makes these kinds of constraints really powerful for testing our theories.
Kai: What’s the real impact here? It gives us a new, direct way to test if our models for rotating black holes are physically viable in gravity.
Mira: Well, it sets a benchmark. If a specific black hole solution doesn't satisfy this inequality, then we know immediately that the solution is not physically allowed under these assumptions.
Lev: For those of us building error-correction codes or even just simulating these things on real hardware, having such a fundamental constraint helps narrow down exactly what parameters we need to keep in check.
Kai: It’s a new standalone principle here, derived directly from the condition for a physical horizon existence, and it links back to the cosmic censorship conjecture.
Mira: And they even suggest how this inequality relates to that reverse isoperimetric inequality—that lower bound on entropy they mentioned earlier.
Lev: That connection suggests that if you want your black hole thermodynamics to behave nicely in a rotating spacetime, you have to satisfy this specific relationship between its mass, angular momentum, and volume.
Kai: So the authors are essentially giving us a new litmus test for any rotating AdS black hole we look at and figuring out what’s physically possible.
Mira: And they even throw out some conjectures about how this inequality might generalize when you move to higher dimensions.
Hamid R. Bakhtiarizadeh
Graduate University of Advanced Technology
gr-qc, hep-th
Submitted: 2025-12-08
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 34 pages, no figure, LaTeX file. v2: New verification for Kerr-Sen-AdS. v3: Text refined; Conclusions added. v4: Revised and substantially expanded; The relation to the refined reverse isoperimetric inequality and the ultraspinning/super-entropic case are further analyzed; The higher-dimensional conjecture is tested for thin AdS black rings with nonspherical horizon topology
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 73/100
The gist: Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes proposes a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes…
Key concepts
- Thermodynamic Inequality
- A mathematical constraint that must be satisfied by the variables describing a black hole's thermodynamics. In this context, it is a new rule derived from identities that ensures physical consistency and prevents mathematically problematic scenarios like naked singularities in rotating black holes.
- Kerr-AdS Black Hole
- This is a specific type of rotating black hole solution existing within an Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime. The paper uses this as a primary example to test the new inequality, showing that the constraint holds for this common black hole geometry.
- Reverse Isoperimetric Inequality (RII)
- This conjecture suggests a relationship between the black hole's thermodynamic volume and its entropy. The proposed inequality is shown to be a necessary condition for satisfying this RII in rotating spacetimes, linking the inequality to fundamental bounds on black hole entropy.
Terminology
Summary
Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS black holes proposes a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes: 4πJ2/(3MV) < 1<ref:2512. p. 0 Novel thermodynamic inequality for rotating AdS
black holes
Hamid R. Bakhtiarizadeh1
Department of Nanotechnology, Graduate University of Advanced Technology, Kerman,
Iran
Abstract
We propose a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Antide Sitter rotating black holes, 4πJ2/(3MV ) < 1. Bakhtiarizadeh1
Department of Nanotechnology, Graduate University of Advanced Technology, Kerman,
Iran
Abstract
We propose a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary and asymptotically Antide Sitter rotating black holes, 4πJ2/(3MV ) < 1. This inequality is derived by analyzing
the roots of the identity relating the thermodynamic variables, ensuring the avoidance of
naked singularities, and consequently preventing violations of the cosmic censorship conjecture.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Derivation from Identity Roots
The inequality is established by examining identities relating thermodynamic parameters to ensure physical constraints are met<ref:2512.07825#pg4>. For the Kerr-AdS black hole, an identity holds among the thermodynamic parameters in extended phase space<ref:2512. p. 1 Consider first the Kerr-AdS black hole [28, 31, 32],
for which the thermodynamics in extended phase space was first studied in [5]. In the
extended phase space, the following identity holds among the thermodynamic parameters
[33] (see Eq. Although the proposed inequality originates from the condition for the existence of a
physical horizon for black holes (cosmic censorship conjecture), but rewriting it in terms
of geometrical parameters yields, at least for asymptotically AdS charged and rotating
black strings, a more restrictive bound on the black string’s charge. So, it seems the
inequality is a new standalone principle and, at least for some solutions, leads to novel
results which have not been previously reported. (2)
A physical horizon requires A3 > 0, which is equivalent to
4πJ2
3MV
< 1. (3)
A similar algebraic structure appears in the extended thermodynamics of asymptotically AdS rotating black string solutions obtained by Lemos [34, 35], whose thermodynamic variables obey [37] (see Eq. Here again a physical horizon exists only if the inequality (3) is satisfied, demonstrating
that the same type of bound governs the existence of the horizon. The similarity of the
algebraic constraints highlights a universal feature independently of horizon topology.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Verification Across Black Hole Classes
The inequality has been strongly supported by examining a broad class of black hole solutions<ref:2512.07825#pg7>. This includes the Kerr-AdS black hole, uncharged rotating AdS black strings, and other complex geometries<ref:2512. p. 0 This inequality is derived by analyzing
the roots of the identity relating the thermodynamic variables, ensuring the avoidance of
naked singularities, and consequently preventing violations of the cosmic censorship conjecture. We examine the Kerr-AdS black hole as well as uncharged rotating AdS black
strings, and find strong supporting evidence for the inequality across different horizon
topologies.Where the paper says it
-
The charged case (KN-AdS black hole) is valid using the cubic function f(A), which shows a unique positive root only if condition (3) is met<ref:2512. p. 3
07825#pg5>.Where the paper says it
The treatment of the charged case (KN-AdS black hole) using the cubic f(A) ≡ M2A 3 + 16π 2Q 2 J 2A − 36πM2V 2 + 64π 3 J 4 , (12) is valid. Since f ′ (A) = 3M2A 2 + 16π 2Q 2 J 2 > 0, (13) for physically meaningful parameters (M ̸= 0, and Q, J real), f(A) is strictly increasing and therefore possesses exactly one real root.
-
For charged and rotating black strings, satisfying inequality (3) requires that q < qextr a squared + l squared 3a squared + l 4, which defines a tighter bound on the charge<ref:2512. p. 4
07825#pg5>.Where the paper says it
which yields q < qextr a 2 + ℓ 2 3a 2 + ℓ 2 < qext, (22) meaning the black string has a horizon. So, the inequality defines a tighter bound on the charge of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black strings.
-
For the charged and rotating AdS C-metric, the necessary and sufficient condition for positive area is 4πJ2/(3MV) ≤ 1<ref:2512. p. 4
07825#pg7>.Where the paper says it
(24) For the inequality to admit a positive solution for A, the right-hand side must be nonnegative, because the left-hand side A3 is non-negative for all real A ≥ 0. Thus, the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a positive area becomes simply 4πJ2/(3MV ) ≤ 1.
Connection to Reverse Isoperimetric Inequality
The proposed inequality is shown to be a necessary condition for satisfying the reverse isoperimetric inequality (RII) in the presence of rotation<ref:2512.07825#pg4>. The RII conjecture states that for a given thermodynamic volume, there exists a lower bound on the black hole entropy<ref:2512. p. 1 A central concept arising from this framework is the reverse isoperimetric inequality
(RII), which conjectures that for a given thermodynamic volume, there exists a lower
bound on the black hole entropy [14, 16]. While this inequality holds for many conventional black hole solutions, a number of important exceptions have been identified,
particularly in the context of ultraspinning and super-entropic black holes [17,20]. This allows for the
following alternate interpretation of the RII: The entropy of a black hole of thermodynamic volume V is no more than the entropy of the Schwarzschild-AdS black hole with
the same volume [33], or
A(V ) ≤ ASchw(V ). (7)
In four dimensions, the strong refined reverse isoperimetric inequality (RRII) [33] states:
For a stationary asymptotically AdS black hole of mass M, angular momenta Ji
, and
thermodynamic volume V , the following inequality holds
A(M, Ji
, V ) ≤ AKerr(M, Ji
, V ), (8)
where AKerr denotes the area of the Kerr-AdS black hole with the same parameters. The inequality is saturated for the Kerr-AdS black hole. If the
inequality (3) is satisfied, it can be seen that the right-hand side of the above inequality
reads
RKerr−AdS =
"
1 −
4πJ2
3MV 2
#−1/6
≥ 1, (11)
which verifies the validity of RII in its conventional form, in the presence of rotation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Higher Dimensional Generalization
The authors conjecture a corresponding higher-dimensional generalization of inequality (3) assuming the reverse isoperimetric inequality continues to hold in higher dimensions<ref:2512.07825#pg7>. The proposed generalizations for D dimensions are:
(Even D):
(2π(D−2)J 2min(D−1)MV.
(Odd D):
4πJ 2(D−1)(D−2)MV.
Conclusion and Significance
The work provides strong evidence supporting the new thermodynamic inequality across several classes of solutions, including Kerr-AdS, KN-AdS, rotating AdS black strings, AdS C-metrics, rotating AdS black holes of gauged supergravity, and Kerr-Sen-AdS black holes<ref:2512.07825#pg7>. The notable result is the direct derivation of the inequality for uncharged rotating black strings with non-spherical horizon topologies, underscoring the universal nature of the inequality regardless of horizon topology<ref:2512. p. 5 We have provided strong evidence supporting a new thermodynamic
inequality for stationary and asymptotically AdS rotating black holes and verify it across
several classes of solutions, including Kerr-AdS, KN-AdS, rotating AdS black strings,
AdS C-metrics, rotating AdS black holes of gauged supergravity, and Kerr-Sen-AdS black
holes. The notable result is the direct derivation of the inequality for uncharged rotating
black strings with non-spherical horizon topologies, underscoring the universal nature of
the inequality regardless of horizon topology. In the absence of this inequality, the RII conjecture fails to hold in its standard form
(R ≥ 1), in the presence of rotation. Consequently, this inequality constitutes a necessary
condition for the validity of the RII conjecture, in rotating spacetimes. Although the proposed inequality originates from the condition for the existence of a
physical horizon for black holes (cosmic censorship conjecture), but rewriting it in terms
of geometrical parameters yields, at least for asymptotically AdS charged and rotating
black strings, a more restrictive bound on the black string’s charge. So, it seems the
inequality is a new standalone principle and, at least for some solutions, leads to novel
results which have not been previously reported. Although the proposed inequality originates from the condition for the existence of a
physical horizon for black holes (cosmic censorship conjecture), but rewriting it in terms
of geometrical parameters yields, at least for asymptotically AdS charged and rotating
black strings, a more restrictive bound on the black string’s charge. So, it seems the
inequality is a new standalone principle and, at least for some solutions, leads to novel
results which have not been previously reported. The notable result is the direct derivation of the inequality for uncharged rotating
black strings with non-spherical horizon topologies, underscoring the universal nature of
the inequality regardless of horizon topology. Although the proposed inequality originates from the condition for the existence of a
physical horizon for black holes (cosmic censorship conjecture), but rewriting it in terms
of geometrical parameters yields, at least for asymptotically AdS charged and rotating
black strings, a more restrictive bound on the black string’s charge. We have provided strong evidence supporting a new thermodynamic
inequality for stationary and asymptotically AdS rotating black holes and verify it across
several classes of solutions, including Kerr-AdS, KN-AdS, rotating AdS black strings,
AdS C-metrics, rotating AdS black holes of gauged supergravity, and Kerr-Sen-AdS black
holes. The notable result is the direct derivation of the inequality for uncharged rotating
black strings with non-spherical horizon topologies, underscoring the universal nature of
the inequality regardless of horizon topology. That is the condition for the non-singularity of
the Pairwise-equal four-charge AdS black hole in gauged supergravity (see Supplement)
which verifies that the isoperimetric ratio R satisfies the RII (R ≥ 1) in its conventional
form for charged and rotating black holes with spherical horizons. Finally, we consider the Kerr-Sen-AdS black hole.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Supplemental Material
Kerr-Newman-AdS black hole. The metric of the KN-AdS black hole expressed in the Boyer–Lindquist-like coordinates take the form ds2=−∆rρ 2dt − a sin 2θΞdϕ 2+ρ 2∆rdr 2+ρ 2∆θdθ 2+sin 2θ∆θρ 2adt−r. p. 8 1140/epjp/s13360-021-01270-w
Supplemental Material
Kerr-Newman-AdS black hole. The metric of the KN-AdS black hole expressed
in the Boyer–Lindquist-like coordinates take the form [28]
ds2=−
∆r
ρ
2
dt −
a sin2
θ
Ξ
dϕ2
+
ρ
2
∆r
dr2 +
ρ
2
∆θ
dθ2 +
sin2
θ∆θ
ρ
2
adt −
r
2 + a
2
Ξ
dϕ2
(30) ,
where
ρ
2 = r
2 + a
2
cos2
θ, Ξ = 1 −
a
2
ℓ
2
, ∆r = (r
2 + a
2
)
1 +
r
2
ℓ
2
− 2mr + q
2
,
∆θ = 1 −
a
2
ℓ
2
cos2
θ, A = −
qr
ρ
2
dt −
a sin2
θ
Ξ
dϕ
, (31)
and m, q, and a character the mass M, charge Q, and angular momentum J of the
KN–AdS black hole respectively,
M =
m
Ξ2
, Q =
q
Ξ
, J = aM =
am
Ξ2
. 1140/epjp/s13360-021-01270-w
Supplemental Material
Kerr-Newman-AdS black hole. The metric of the KN-AdS black hole expressed
in the Boyer–Lindquist-like coordinates take the form [28]
ds2=−
∆r
ρ
2
dt −
a sin2
θ
Ξ
dϕ2
+
ρ
2
∆r
dr2 +
ρ
2
∆θ
dθ2 +
sin2
θ∆θ
ρ
2
adt −
r
2 + a
2
Ξ
dϕ2
(30) ,
where
ρ
2 = r
2 + a
2
cos2
θ, Ξ = 1 −
a
2
ℓ
2
, ∆r = (r
2 + a
2
)
1 +
r
2
ℓ
2
− 2mr + q
2
,
∆θ = 1 −
a
2
ℓ
2
cos2
θ, A = −
qr
ρ
2
dt −
a sin2
θ
Ξ
dϕ
, (31)
and m, q, and a character the mass M, charge Q, and angular momentum J of the
KN–AdS black hole respectively,
M =
m
Ξ2
, Q =
q
Ξ
, J = aM =
am
Ξ2
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The extended thermodynamics of KN-AdS black holes was studied in [29,30]. p. 9 The extended thermodynamics of KN-AdS black holes was studied in [29,30]. Solving r+
from S, substituting it into Eq. The extended thermodynamics of KN-AdS black holes was studied in [29,30]. Solving r+
from S, substituting it into Eq. We examine the Kerr-AdS black hole as well as uncharged rotating AdS black
strings, and find strong supporting evidence for the inequality across different horizon
topologies. Using this inequality, we further demonstrate that the reverse isoperimetric
inequality (R ≥ 1), remains unchanged, in the presence of rotation. (33), and using Eq. (32) and
P = −
Λ
8π
=
3
8πℓ2
, (35)
we can reexpress the mass of the KN–AdS black hole in terms of the thermodynamic
variables, S, P, J, and Q, as
M =
1
2
vuut
S
π
"
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
2
+
4π
2J
2
S2
1 +
8P S
3
#
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
From the first law of thermodynamics for the KN-AdS black hole in the extended phase space, dM = TdS + VdP + ΩdJ + ΦdQ, we clearly observe that the mass M of the KNAdS black hole should be essentially identified as enthalpy rather than internal energy. p. 9 (32) and
P = −
Λ
8π
=
3
8πℓ2
, (35)
we can reexpress the mass of the KN–AdS black hole in terms of the thermodynamic
variables, S, P, J, and Q, as
M =
1
2
vuut
S
π
"
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
2
+
4π
2J
2
S2
1 +
8P S
3
#
. (36)
From the first law of thermodynamics for the KN-AdS black hole in the extended phase
space,
dM = T dS + V dP + ΩdJ + ΦdQ, (37)
where T, V , Ω, and Φ are the Hawking temperature, thermodynamic volume, angular
velocity, and electric potential respectively, we clearly observe that the mass M of the KNAdS black hole should be essentially identified as enthalpy rather than internal energy.Where the paper says it
V = ∂M/∂P S,J,Q = 2S 2/3πM 1 + πQ 2S + 8PS 3+2πJ 2S squared. p. 9 (36)
From the first law of thermodynamics for the KN-AdS black hole in the extended phase
space,
dM = T dS + V dP + ΩdJ + ΦdQ, (37)
where T, V , Ω, and Φ are the Hawking temperature, thermodynamic volume, angular
velocity, and electric potential respectively, we clearly observe that the mass M of the KNAdS black hole should be essentially identified as enthalpy rather than internal energy. Then, it is straightforward to have
V =
∂M
∂P
S,J,Q
=
2S
2
3πM
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
+
2π
2J
2
S2
.Where the paper says it
Solving the equation (38) for pressure and substituting it into the mass formula (36) and using the Bekenstein–Hawking formula S = A/4, we can eliminate the pressure and reexpress the mass M in terms of (A, V, J, Q), which leads to 36πM 2V squared − M 2A cubed − 64πJ 4 = 16πQ 2J 2A. p. 9 Then, it is straightforward to have
V =
∂M
∂P
S,J,Q
=
2S
2
3πM
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
+
2π
2J
2
S2
. (38)
Solving the equation (38) for pressure and substituting it into the mass formula (36)
and using the Bekenstein–Hawking formula S = A/4, we can eliminate the pressure and
reexpress the mass M in terms of (A, V, J, Q), which leads to the following identity [33]
36πM2V
2 − M2A
3 − 64π
3
J
4 = 16π
2Q
2
J
2A.Where the paper says it
Asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black string. p. 4 which yields
q < qextr
a
2 + ℓ
2
3a
2 + ℓ
2
< qext, (22)
meaning the black string has a horizon. So, the inequality defines a tighter bound on the
charge of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black strings. (40)
Asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black string. The metric of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black string corresponding to cylindrical or toroidal
horizons is given by [34, 35]
ds2 = −f(r) (Ξdt − adϕ)
2 +
1
f(r)
dr2 +
r
2
ℓ
4
adt − Ξℓ
2
dϕ2
+
r
2
ℓ
2
dz2
, (41)
where
Ξ = r
1 +
a
2
ℓ
2
, f(r) = r
2
ℓ
2
−
m
r
+
q
2
r
2
, A = −
qΞ
r
dt −
a
Ξ
dϕ
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The relevant thermodynamic potentials per unit length of a stationary black string horizon with cylindrical topology are given by M = 1/(3Ξ2r+) 4 + q 2l 2/16πr+l cubed. p. 9 The constants a and ℓ, both having dimensions of length, can
be interpreted as the rotation parameter and AdS radius, respectively. The relevant thermodynamic potentials per unit length of a stationary black string horizon with cylindrical
topology are given by [36]
M =
1
16πℓ
3Ξ2 − 1
m, Q =
qΞ
4πℓ, J =
3
16πℓΞam, (43)Where the paper says it
The extended thermodynamics of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black strings are generalized to the the extended phase space in [37]. p. 4 Sen discovered a charged, rotating
black hole solution in the low-energy limit of heterotic string theory, now commonly
referred to as the Kerr-Sen black hole [41]. The thermodynamics is introduced in the
extended phase space in [45, 46]. (27)
Extension to higher dimensions. In dimensions larger than four, obtaining an
identity for thermodynamic variables would generically require solving a polynomial of
degree greater than four.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Kerr-Sen-AdS solution can be transformed into the rest frame at infinity by performing the simple coordinate transformation ϕ = ϕ − at/l2. p. 4 Finally, we consider the Kerr-Sen-AdS black hole. Sen discovered a charged, rotating
black hole solution in the low-energy limit of heterotic string theory, now commonly
referred to as the Kerr-Sen black hole [41]. (36)
From the first law of thermodynamics for the KN-AdS black hole in the extended phase
space,
dM = T dS + V dP + ΩdJ + ΦdQ, (37)
where T, V , Ω, and Φ are the Hawking temperature, thermodynamic volume, angular
velocity, and electric potential respectively, we clearly observe that the mass M of the KNAdS black hole should be essentially identified as enthalpy rather than internal energy. Then, it is straightforward to have
V =
∂M
∂P
S,J,Q
=
2S
2
3πM
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
+
2π
2J
2
S2
. A central concept arising from this framework is the reverse isoperimetric inequality
(RII), which conjectures that for a given thermodynamic volume, there exists a lower
bound on the black hole entropy [14, 16]. While this inequality holds for many conventional black hole solutions, a number of important exceptions have been identified,
particularly in the context of ultraspinning and super-entropic black holes [17,20].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
In this frame, the thermodynamic quantities consistently satisfy both the standard form of the first law of black hole thermodynamics and the Bekenstein–Smarr mass formula simultaneously. p. 5 by Mf and Ve, respectively. This is because both the standard form of the first law of
black hole thermodynamics and the Bekenstein-Smarr mass formula should be satisfied
simultaneously. Then, it is straightforward to have
V =
∂M
∂P
S,J,Q
=
2S
2
3πM
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
+
2π
2J
2
S2
. (38)
Solving the equation (38) for pressure and substituting it into the mass formula (36)
and using the Bekenstein–Hawking formula S = A/4, we can eliminate the pressure and
reexpress the mass M in terms of (A, V, J, Q), which leads to the following identity [33]
36πM2V
2 − M2A
3 − 64π
3
J
4 = 16π
2Q
2
J
2A. Then, it is straightforward to have
V =
∂M
∂P
S,J,Q
=
2S
2
3πM
1 +
πQ2
S
+
8P S
3
+
2π
2J
2
S2
. (38)
Solving the equation (38) for pressure and substituting it into the mass formula (36)
and using the Bekenstein–Hawking formula S = A/4, we can eliminate the pressure and
reexpress the mass M in terms of (A, V, J, Q), which leads to the following identity [33]
36πM2V
2 − M2A
3 − 64π
3
J
4 = 16π
2Q
2
J
2A.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The final identity for the uncharged Kerr-Sen-AdS black hole is 36πMf 2Ve squared − Mf 2A cubed − 64πJ 4 = 0. p. 0 This inequality is derived by analyzing
the roots of the identity relating the thermodynamic variables, ensuring the avoidance of
naked singularities, and consequently preventing violations of the cosmic censorship conjecture. We examine the Kerr-AdS black hole as well as uncharged rotating AdS black
strings, and find strong supporting evidence for the inequality across different horizon
topologies.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved thermodynamic inequality application for black hole stability This inequality provides a necessary condition for satisfying the reverse isoperimetric inequality R >= 1 in rotating spacetimes, which is crucial for understanding black hole thermodynamics in the presence of rotation.
-
Verification across diverse black hole classes This work verifies the proposed inequality across several classes of solutions, including Kerr-AdS, KN-AdS, rotating AdS black strings, AdS C-metrics, and Kerr-Sen-AdS black holes.
-
Bound on charge for rotating strings This inequality yields a more restrictive bound on the charge of asymptotically AdS charged and rotating black strings compared to existing extremal limits.
-
Necessary condition for RII validity This inequality constitutes a necessary condition for the validity of the reverse isoperimetric inequality R >= 1 in rotating spacetimes, suggesting it is a new standalone principle.
-
Higher dimensional conjecture formulation This paper conjectures a higher dimensional generalization of the inequality (3) based on intermediate RRII results, providing guidance for research in higher dimensions.
Abstract
We propose a new thermodynamic inequality for stationary, asymptotically Anti-de Sitter rotating black holes, expressed in terms of their angular momentum, mass and thermodynamic volume as 4πJ 2/(3MV)<1. For the solutions considered, this inequality follows from the requirement that the thermodynamic identities admit a physical horizon with positive area. We examine Kerr(-Newman)-AdS, Kerr-Sen-AdS, pairwise-equal four-charge AdS black holes, charged rotating AdS black strings, and charged rotating AdS C-metrics, finding strong supporting evidence for the inequality across different horizon topologies. We then reformulate the inequality in terms of the underlying metric parameters and compare the resulting constraints with the corresponding regularity and horizon-existence conditions. This analysis shows that the proposed inequality has different physical content for different geometries. We further examine charged super-entropic black holes, for which the ultraspinning limit leads instead to a lower bound on the thermodynamic ratio. This result is consistent with the violation of the reverse isoperimetric inequality characteristic of super-entropic solutions. Moreover, when combined with the refined reverse isoperimetric inequality, the proposed bound ensures the physicality of the Kerr-AdS reference solution entering the refined bound and thereby yields the conventional reverse isoperimetric inequality. We also extend the proposed relation to higher dimensions and test it for singly spinning thin AdS black ring with nonspherical horizon topology, finding that the corresponding inequalities are satisfied throughout the thin-ring regime.
Sources
- The Large N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity
- Enthalpy and the Mechanics of AdS Black Holes
- Black Hole Enthalpy and an Entropy Inequality for the Thermodynamic Volume
- P-V criticality of charged AdS black holes
- Holographic Heat Engines
- Holographic Black Hole Chemistry
- Holographic Complexity and Thermodynamic Volume
- Holographic Thermodynamics Requires a Chemical Potential for Color
- Higher-dimensional origin of extended black hole thermodynamics
- Holographic dual of extended black hole thermodynamics
- Thermodynamics of rotating black holes and black rings: phase transitions and thermodynamic volume
- Thermodynamic Volumes and Isoperimetric Inequalities for de Sitter Black Holes
- Accelerating Black Hole Chemistry
- Butterfly Velocity Bound and Reverse Isoperimetric Inequality
- Instability of Super-Entropic Black Holes in Extended Thermodynamics
- A Microscopic Description of Thermodynamic Volume in Extended Black Hole Thermodynamics
- Four-dimensional black holes with unusual horizons
- Super-Entropic Black Holes
- Ultraspinning limits and super-entropic black holes
- Rotating black holes in 4d gauged supergravity
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals