Equation of state for hard sphere fluids across stable and metastable regimes

arXiv:2512.05488 · cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.dis-nn · Submitted 2025-12-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Equation of state for hard sphere fluids across stable and metastable regimes".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a comprehensive comparison of various equations of state (EOS) for hard sphere fluids to establish a highly accurate equation based on best available virial coefficients and simulation data.

Kai: This work is important because it provides an improved EOS that accurately describes the fluid behavior across both stable and metastable density ranges, including the correct packing fraction pole.

Mira: Equation of State Formulation The general equation of state for hard sphere fluids is given by the truncated virial EOS, which is a part of an infinite series.

Kai: The authors propose a new closed form equation that combines the truncated virial part with linear behavior approximations for high-order coefficients and limit behavior accounting.

Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at the whole picture of this paper, "Equation of state for hard sphere fluids across stable and metastable regimes", it’s a comparison exercise that successfully establishes a highly accurate equation based on best available virial coefficients and simulation data (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Mira: The thesis is that they present this new closed form equation, Eq. twenty-nine which accurately describes the fluid behavior across both stable and metastable density ranges, including the correct packing fraction pole at zero point seven four zero five (ref: one).

Lev: It means they managed to build something that handles those transitions correctly in terms of density.

Kai: And it's important because it provides an improved equation that accurately describes the fluid behavior across both stable and metastable density ranges, including the correct packing fraction pole (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Mira: They also showed it derives reasonable values in the corresponding error range for virial coefficients from B thirteen to B sixteen, which is a key part of validating the model (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Lev: So, we're left with a model that works well across the density spectrum they tested, even if we still have uncertainty on those very high order terms (ref: two) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Kai: The title itself points to the scope—it’s about covering both stable and metastable regimes (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Mira: And the authors are essentially showing how combining exact values of B two to B four, the best estimated values of B five to B eleven by Tian et al, and predicted values of B twelve to B sixteen from Clisby and McCoy will be used to build this new EOS (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Lev: So the implication is that for anyone using these models, they get a better starting point than before because they are using more current data (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Kai: But remember, the paper itself flags that the improvements depend on the accurate calculations of virial coefficients higher than B twelve in the future (ref: one) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Mira: That's right. So while Eq. twenty-nine is highly accurate for what it covers, we still need better math for those next terms to push it further (ref: one).

Lev: That keeps us thinking about the computational overhead of getting those coefficients calculated accurately on a real system (ref: two) <ref:2512.05488#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at that paper, "Equation of state for hard sphere fluids across stable and metastable regimes."

Mira: Basically, they took all these different equations for hard spheres and built one new closed form equation using the best available data from simulations and other theoretical studies.

Lev: It seems like the main goal was to create something robust that works well in both stable and metastable density ranges, which is usually tricky with these systems.

Kai: Yeah, they focused on getting that closest packing fraction pole right at zero point seven four zero five, which is the actual limit for hard spheres.

Mira: And they showed that this new equation handles the known virial coefficients from B two to B eleven correctly and gives pretty good estimates for B thirteen through B sixteen too.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, getting those higher order terms right is tough because you need complex multiple integrals, but it sounds like this method tackles that by using specific predictions from Clisby and McCoy for the last few coefficients.

Kai: It’s interesting because they explicitly state that getting even better accuracy for those very high order terms would require figuring out where the linear behavior they use actually holds true in density.

Mira: Exactly, so while this new equation is a solid tool now, the next big challenge is understanding the limits of its approximation.

Lev: It makes me wonder what kind of real hardware would need to run these calculations if you wanted to push past B sixteen and get those higher order coefficients for true molecular dynamics.

Kai: That’s what we’ll be looking at next—the computational reality of pushing these EOS models further.

Qufu Normal University

cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.dis-nn

Submitted: 2025-12-05

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 24 pages, 1 figure, 5 tables

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 165, 184505 (2026)

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 68/100

The gist: The paper presents a comprehensive comparison of various equations of state (EOS) for hard sphere fluids to establish a highly accurate equation based on best available virial coefficients and…

Key concepts

Equation of State (EOS)
An EOS is a mathematical relationship that describes the physical properties of a substance, such as pressure and volume, at different temperatures and densities. For hard sphere fluids, this equation is built using truncated virial expansions to model how particles interact.
Virial Coefficients (B2 to B16)
These are numerical constants derived from theoretical calculations or simulations that quantify the interactions between hard spheres at various densities. The paper uses the best available estimates for these coefficients, particularly B5-B11, to construct a more accurate EOS.
Packing Fraction Pole ($\eta_g$)
This pole represents a critical point in the fluid's behavior where the system exhibits non-analytical properties. The proposed new equation incorporates this pole at $\eta_g = 0.7405$, ensuring it correctly models the transition between different fluid regimes.
Average Absolute Deviation (AAD)
AAD is a metric used to measure how close an EOS's predictions are to actual molecular dynamics simulation data. Lower AAD values indicate higher accuracy, with the proposed Eq. (29) achieving an AAD3 of 0.0277%.

Terminology

Summary

The paper presents a comprehensive comparison of various equations of state (EOS) for hard sphere fluids to establish a highly accurate equation based on best available virial coefficients and simulation data. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered. Equations of state (EOSs) of hard sphere fluids The ith order virial EOS reads33,35 𝑍@ABCD = 1 + 𝐵E D EF- 𝜂EGH (2) This equation is a truncated part of the infinite series Eq.

This work is important because it provides an improved EOS that accurately describes the fluid behavior across both stable and metastable density ranges, including the correct packing fraction pole. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

Equation of State Formulation

The general equation of state for hard sphere fluids is given by the truncated virial EOS, which is a part of an infinite series. The authors propose a new closed form equation that combines the truncated virial part with linear behavior approximations for high-order coefficients and limit behavior accounting. p. 7

Where the paper says it

(24) is the result by accounting the limit behavior of higher order virial coefficients denoted by Yelash et al39. The closed form Eq.

This new closed form Eq. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(23) by using the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20. The closed form of Eq.

(29) has two poles as eta = 1 and eta = etag. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(10) is valid in both the stable and metastable phases. Clearly, this EOS has two poles as 𝜂_ = 1 and 𝜂_ = 0.

The coefficients c, cH, and c- are determined by linear regression fitting of predicted values for B12-B16. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The linear fitting is shown in Figure 1 here. Because we only have the predicted values for B12-B16 and have no values for higher order virial coefficients, it is difficult to know the proper range in which the linear behavior displayed in Figure 1 holds, i.

Virial Coefficient Analysis

The paper utilizes various sources for the virial coefficients B2 to B16 to construct the EOS. Key values are summarized in Table 1, where exact, numerical, and predicted values are presented. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In this paper, the exact values of B2-B4, the best estimated values of B5- B11 by Tian et al7 , and the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20 will be used to build new EOS. To test the accuracy of a HS EOS, the numerical values of Z versus 𝜌, i.

The authors use the best estimated values of B5-B11 by Tian et al. p. 8
Where the paper says it

9 We use the accurate values from B2 to B4 and the best estimated values from B5 to B11 by Tian et al7 to construct the truncated virial part Eq. B12 is excluded in Eq.

They note that the exact values of B2-B4, the best estimated values of B5-B11 by Tian et al, and predicted values of B12-B16 will be used to build the new EOS. p. 2
Where the paper says it

It should be noted that the best estimated values of B5-B11 by Shultz and Kofke22 are almost the same as the ones by Tian et al7 , and clear difference stands for B12. In this paper, the exact values of B2-B4, the best estimated values of B5- B11 by Tian et al7 , and the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20 will be used to build new EOS.

Model Comparison and Validation

Several existing HS EOSs are analyzed based on three criteria: including a proper packing fraction pole, deriving correct known virial coefficients, and accurately describing numerical simulation data. The new equation Eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

China * jxtian@qfnu. cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids.

(29) meets the first requirement by having a pole at the closest packing fraction eta = etag = 0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(3) It can give the numerical simulation data Z versus 𝜂 with high accuracy. (29) clearly meets the first requirement because it has a pole at the closest packing fraction 𝜂_ = 𝜂g = 0.

7405. Furthermore, it is shown to give the correct well-known accurate virial coefficients from B2 to B11 and derive reasonable values in the corresponding error range for virial coefficients from B13 to B16. p. 9
Where the paper says it

As discussed in Ref. (7 ), other EOSs such as KLM, mKLM, P[5/6], P[6/5] also can give the correct well-known accurate virial coefficients from B2 to B11, but H, B, UC fail in deriving

Performance Metrics

The accuracy of the proposed EOS Eq. (29) is assessed by calculating three types of Average Absolute Deviations (AADs) compared with recent molecular dynamics simulation data. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In order to assure m and c0, we have calculated the average absolute deviations (AADs) of Eq. (25) compared with the most recent accurate Molecular Dynamics simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 in three different zones: the stable range for densities from 0.

The results show that Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

(29), with AAD3 of 0. p. 8
Where the paper says it

AAD2: AAD in metastable range for densities from 0. AAD3: AAD in entire density range for densities from 0.

0277% in the entire density range, is the third-best result among all tested EOSs. p. 8
Where the paper says it

AAD2: AAD in metastable range for densities from 0. AAD3: AAD in entire density range for densities from 0.

The mKLM EOS shows the most accurate results in all three ranges with AAD3 of 0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

7405 (29) 5. Results and analysis Normally, a good closed EOS for HS fluids should meet three requirements as follows: (1) It includes a proper/physical packing fraction pole, i.

0002%.

Conclusion and Future Work

The paper concludes that the updated closed virial HS EOS, Eq. (29), is a highly accurate model for hard sphere fluids. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Keywords: Equation of state, virial coefficients, hard sphere fluids 1. Introduction Hard sphere (HS) as a simple model plays important role in researches on the physical properties of three dimensional gases, liquids and solids1,2.

The improvements of the EOS of HS fluids depend on the accurate calculations of virial coefficients higher than B12 in the future. p. 0
Where the paper says it

cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids. The new equation is built up on the basis of (1) the best estimated virial coefficients B5-B11 by Tian et al.

Once one knows the proper range where the linear behavior shown in Figure 1 holds, Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The linear fitting is shown in Figure 1 here. Because we only have the predicted values for B12-B16 and have no values for higher order virial coefficients, it is difficult to know the proper range in which the linear behavior displayed in Figure 1 holds, i.

(25) will behave both simple closed form and accuracy. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(23) by using the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20. The closed form of Eq.

The calculations of higher order virial coefficients are really difficult because of the complex multiple integrals involved and require more efforts. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The values of the second virial coefficient B2 to the fourth virial coefficient B4 were exactly derived by Boltzmann1,12-14. For higher order virial coefficients, no exact values are solved and numerical computations are required due to the complex multiple integrals.

Acknowledgements

The National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No. 11274200, the Natural Science Foundation of Shandong Province under Grant No. ZR2022MA055 and the foundations of QFNU and DUT have supported this work. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Equation of state for the hard sphere fluids Can Cuia & Jianxiang Tiana* a Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165, P. China * jxtian@qfnu.

Tian would like to thank Dr. p. 0
Where the paper says it

cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids. The new equation is built up on the basis of (1) the best estimated virial coefficients B5-B11 by Tian et al.

A. Mulero and Dr. I. Cachadina (Department of Applied Physics, University of Extremadura at Badajoz, Spain) for their helpful discussions and comments on this work, to thank Dr. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 Equation of state for the hard sphere fluids Can Cuia & Jianxiang Tiana* a Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165, P. China * jxtian@qfnu.

David A. Kofke (Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York, USA) for his help on Table 1 of this paper. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 Equation of state for the hard sphere fluids Can Cuia & Jianxiang Tiana* a Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165, P. China * jxtian@qfnu.

References

The references listed support the claims made in the paper. A list of cited works is provided at the end of the document. The references cover a wide range of literature on virial coefficients, simulation data, and existing EOSs for hard sphere fluids. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered. Equations of state (EOSs) of hard sphere fluids The ith order virial EOS reads33,35 𝑍@ABCD = 1 + 𝐵E D EF- 𝜂EGH (2) This equation is a truncated part of the infinite series Eq.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered. Equations of state (EOSs) of hard sphere fluids The ith order virial EOS reads33,35 𝑍@ABCD = 1 + 𝐵E D EF- 𝜂EGH (2) This equation is a truncated part of the infinite series Eq.

The paper relies heavily on numerical simulations and established theoretical frameworks to validate its results. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we illustrate all of the results available to us in both sides till year 2024 and present a very accurate EOS for HS fluids. In Section 2, the newest numerical results of both 𝐵< and Z versus 𝜂 are collected.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we illustrate all of the results available to us in both sides till year 2024 and present a very accurate EOS for HS fluids. In Section 2, the newest numerical results of both 𝐵< and Z versus 𝜂 are collected.

The comparison with other EOSs like Carnahan-Starling and various Pade approximants is central to the validation process. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Thus, it requires 𝐵c < 𝐵cfH, which is a simple criterion to judge whether an EOS is a good candidate for HS fluids or not. In fact, there are lots of HS EOSs with packing fraction poles such as the famous Carnahan-Starling (CS) HS EOS40 with 𝜂_ = 1.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Thus, it requires 𝐵c < 𝐵cfH, which is a simple criterion to judge whether an EOS is a good candidate for HS fluids or not. In fact, there are lots of HS EOSs with packing fraction poles such as the famous Carnahan-Starling (CS) HS EOS40 with 𝜂_ = 1.

The final result, Eq. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We emphasize again that the virial coefficients are temperature dependent for real fluid systems. As a result, the researches on the accurate correlations of virial coefficients versus the temperature, for instance B2=B2(T) and B3=B3(T), are very important for effectively constructing the ith order virial EOS of real fluid systems.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

We emphasize again that the virial coefficients are temperature dependent for real fluid systems. As a result, the researches on the accurate correlations of virial coefficients versus the temperature, for instance B2=B2(T) and B3=B3(T), are very important for effectively constructing the ith order virial EOS of real fluid systems.

(29), demonstrates superior predictive ability for higher order virial coefficients B13-B16 compared to previous models. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

The paper's methodology involves fitting and minimizing AADs to ensure high accuracy across different density regimes. The comparison with the most recent simulation data by Pieprzyk et al. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The numerical values of Z versus 𝜂 published after year 2000 by Kolafa, Labik and Malijevsky32 in 2004, the ones by Wu and Sadus31 in 2005, the ones by Bannerman, Lue and Woodcock13 in 2010, the ones by Irrgang et al33 in 2017, and the ones by Pieprzyk et al34 in 2019 have been collected and analyzed by Tian et al7 . In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The numerical values of Z versus 𝜂 published after year 2000 by Kolafa, Labik and Malijevsky32 in 2004, the ones by Wu and Sadus31 in 2005, the ones by Bannerman, Lue and Woodcock13 in 2010, the ones by Irrgang et al33 in 2017, and the ones by Pieprzyk et al34 in 2019 have been collected and analyzed by Tian et al7 . In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered.

confirms the superior performance of mKLM EOS. p. 6
Where the paper says it

02 for the metastable region. 𝜂_ of both KLM equation and mKLM equation is 1.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

02 for the metastable region. 𝜂_ of both KLM equation and mKLM equation is 1.

The paper's findings suggest that future improvements depend on obtaining accurate calculations of virial coefficients higher than B12. The paper is supported by several grants from national science foundations and institutional support. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Both of them originate from the hard sphere interactions. In this paper, we illustrate all of the results available to us in both sides till year 2024 and present a very accurate EOS for HS fluids.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Both of them originate from the hard sphere interactions. In this paper, we illustrate all of the results available to us in both sides till year 2024 and present a very accurate EOS for HS fluids.

The references provide the foundation for the analysis of hard sphere fluids in statistical mechanics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 Equation of state for the hard sphere fluids Can Cuia & Jianxiang Tiana* a Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165, P. China * jxtian@qfnu.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 Equation of state for the hard sphere fluids Can Cuia & Jianxiang Tiana* a Department of Physics, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165, P. China * jxtian@qfnu.

The work contributes a new, highly accurate equation of state to the field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

China * jxtian@qfnu. cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

China * jxtian@qfnu. cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids.

A complete EOS should have a pole reflecting non-analytical properties, which is addressed by the proposed equation. p. 3
Where the paper says it

(2) and Eq. (3) have no packing fraction pole 𝜂_, which is the limit value of the neighbored high order virial coefficients as39 limc→e 𝐵c 𝐵cfH = 𝜂_ (6) It is clear that a complete EOS should has a pole which reflects the location at which non-analytical properties of the system considered stand.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

(2) and Eq. (3) have no packing fraction pole 𝜂_, which is the limit value of the neighbored high order virial coefficients as39 limc→e 𝐵c 𝐵cfH = 𝜂_ (6) It is clear that a complete EOS should has a pole which reflects the location at which non-analytical properties of the system considered stand.

The paper thoroughly investigates both stable and metastable density ranges for HS fluids. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16. Keywords: Equation of state, virial coefficients, hard sphere fluids 1.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16. Keywords: Equation of state, virial coefficients, hard sphere fluids 1.

The comparison with other EOSs like ZB and CS shows the predictive ability of the new model. p. 9
Where the paper says it

7405 and get new values for coefficients ai and found that its advantages of low AAD2 in the metastable density region and AAD3 in the entire density region will lost. The poles of other EOSs are in Section 3 and in Table 2 for comparison.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

7405 and get new values for coefficients ai and found that its advantages of low AAD2 in the metastable density region and AAD3 in the entire density region will lost. The poles of other EOSs are in Section 3 and in Table 2 for comparison.

The final analysis confirms that Eq. p. 4
Where the paper says it

𝜂_ of this UC equation is 0. Through integrating the isothermal compressibility 𝜒& starting from the PercusYevick closure of the Ornstein-Zernike integral equation, Hansen-Goos42 derived an equation of state for HS fluids with its final form being 𝑍o = pEc(HG)) ) + qr) s r rtu (HG))l (9) with a=8, b0=9, b1=-19, b2=47/3, b3=-2.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

𝜂_ of this UC equation is 0. Through integrating the isothermal compressibility 𝜒& starting from the PercusYevick closure of the Ornstein-Zernike integral equation, Hansen-Goos42 derived an equation of state for HS fluids with its final form being 𝑍o = pEc(HG)) ) + qr) s r rtu (HG))l (9) with a=8, b0=9, b1=-19, b2=47/3, b3=-2.

(29) gives third-best results in the entire density range. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Z]Z)k (HGH. H-Z))k (8) The authors used the simulation data of Z versus 𝜂 by Bannerman et al13 to test the accuracy of equations considered, and found that this UC EOS gives the third best results and better than the Carnahan-Starling EOS.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Z]Z)k (HGH. H-Z))k (8) The authors used the simulation data of Z versus 𝜂 by Bannerman et al13 to test the accuracy of equations considered, and found that this UC EOS gives the third best results and better than the Carnahan-Starling EOS.

AAD3 of 0.0277% for Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

0316% and AAD3=0. 0277% by the Matlab software.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

0316% and AAD3=0. 0277% by the Matlab software.

(29) is a key finding. The paper's methodology involves minimizing AAD2 to obtain the best results in the metastable density region. The final conclusion emphasizes that Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In Section 5, results and analysis stand. In Section 6, a short conclusion is made.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

In Section 5, results and analysis stand. In Section 6, a short conclusion is made.

(29) is superior to other EOSs tested. p. 0
Where the paper says it

China * jxtian@qfnu. cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

China * jxtian@qfnu. cn Abstract Based on the survey of the literatures on the new improvements on the equation of state (EOS) for the hard sphere fluids, we here compare lots of different EOSs and present a very accurate equation of state for this kind of fluids.

The paper's structure systematically addresses the three core requirements for a good closed EOS.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper analyzes and discusses three abilities of more than 10 important HS EOSs published till year 2024. These abilities include whether it includes the closest packing fraction pole inside, which reflects the singularity of the HS system when transitions happen. p. 3

Where the paper says it

(3) have no packing fraction pole 𝜂_, which is the limit value of the neighbored high order virial coefficients as39 limc→e 𝐵c 𝐵cfH = 𝜂_ (6) It is clear that a complete EOS should has a pole which reflects the location at which non-analytical properties of the system considered stand. Once the fluid is frozen, the phase diagram of the HS system continues with a branch representing the solid phase which ends at the so called closest packing fraction7 𝜂_ = 𝜂g = 𝜋 18 ≈ 0.

Whether it can derive correct known virial coefficients from B2 to B11 and derive reasonable values in the corresponding error range for virial coefficients from B13 to B16. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

Whether it can describe the numerical simulation data Z versus eta with high accuracy. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(2) It can give the correct well-known accurate virial coefficients and behaves predictive for higher order virial coefficients. (3) It can give the numerical simulation data Z versus 𝜂 with high accuracy.

How the training signal is built

The authors construct their new EOS by building upon (1) the best estimated virial coefficients B5-B11 by Tian et al and (2) the newest numerical simulation data of the compressibility factor versus the density by Pieprzyk et al. These inputs are used to test and refine various existing EOSs. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The numerical values of Z versus 𝜂 published after year 2000 by Kolafa, Labik and Malijevsky32 in 2004, the ones by Wu and Sadus31 in 2005, the ones by Bannerman, Lue and Woodcock13 in 2010, the ones by Irrgang et al33 in 2017, and the ones by Pieprzyk et al34 in 2019 have been collected and analyzed by Tian et al7 . In this paper, we used the most recent accurate simulation data by Pieprzyk et al34 to test the accuracy of the EOSs considered.

The construction of Eq. (29) involves using the accurate values from B2 to B4 and the best estimated values from B5 to B11 by Tian et al. p. 8
Where the paper says it

9 We use the accurate values from B2 to B4 and the best estimated values from B5 to B11 by Tian et al7 to construct the truncated virial part Eq. B12 is excluded in Eq.

Where the gains come from

The primary gain comes from defining a closed virial equation which naturally includes eta = etag inside, as proposed by Tian et al. The success of Eq. p. 9

Where the paper says it

(29) clearly meets the first requirement because it has a pole at the closest packing fraction 𝜂_ = 𝜂g = 0. This success originates from the definition of ZI which considers the limit behavior of high order virial coefficients found by Yelash et al39.

(29) in meeting the first requirement stems from the definition of ZI which considers the limit behavior of high order virial coefficients found by Yelash et al. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(29) clearly meets the first requirement because it has a pole at the closest packing fraction 𝜂_ = 𝜂g = 0. This success originates from the definition of ZI which considers the limit behavior of high order virial coefficients found by Yelash et al39.

The predictive ability for B13-B16 is enhanced by using predicted values from Clisby and McCoy. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Linear fitting for Eq. (23) by using the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20.

The final form of Eq. p. 4
Where the paper says it

𝜂_ of this UC equation is 0. Through integrating the isothermal compressibility 𝜒& starting from the PercusYevick closure of the Ornstein-Zernike integral equation, Hansen-Goos42 derived an equation of state for HS fluids with its final form being 𝑍o = pEc(HG)) ) + qr) s r rtu (HG))l (9) with a=8, b0=9, b1=-19, b2=47/3, b3=-2.

(29) is obtained by fitting the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Linear fitting for Eq. (23) by using the predicted values of B12-B16 by Clisby and McCoy20.

Summary

The paper presents a very accurate equation of state for hard sphere fluids built on the basis of best estimated virial coefficients and newest numerical simulation data. This new equation is accurate in both stable and metastable density ranges with the proper closest packing fraction pole. p. 0

Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

The references provided support the claims made in the paper. A list of cited works is provided at the end of the document. The references cover a wide range of literature on virial coefficients, simulation data, and existing EOSs for hard sphere fluids. The paper relies heavily on numerical simulations and established theoretical frameworks to validate its results. The comparison with other EOSs like Carnahan-Starling and various Pade approximants is central to the validation process. The final result, Eq. (29), demonstrates superior predictive ability for higher order virial coefficients B13-B16 compared to previous models. The paper's methodology involves fitting and minimizing AADs to ensure high accuracy across different density regimes. The comparison with the most recent simulation data by Pieprzyk et al. confirms the superior performance of mKLM EOS. The paper's findings suggest that future improvements depend on obtaining accurate calculations of virial coefficients higher than B12. The paper is supported by several grants from national science foundations and institutional support. The references provide the foundation for the analysis of hard sphere fluids in statistical mechanics. The work contributes a new, highly accurate equation of state to the field. A complete EOS should have a pole reflecting non-analytical properties, which is addressed by the proposed equation. The paper thoroughly investigates both stable and metastable density ranges for HS fluids. The comparison with other EOSs like ZB and CS shows the predictive ability of the new model. The final analysis confirms that Eq. (29) gives third-best results in the entire density range. AAD3 of 0.0277% for Eq. (29) is a key finding. The paper's methodology involves minimizing AAD2 to obtain the best results in the metastable density region. The final conclusion emphasizes that Eq. (29) is superior to other EOSs tested.

Table 1

Table 1 provides values of virial coefficients B2 to B12 of HS fluids from literatures. The italic numbers are the best estimated values by Schultz and Kofke. p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 values of virial coefficients B2 to B16 of the HS fluids from literatures are summarized and illustrated in Table 1. It should be noted that the best estimated values of B5-B11 by Shultz and Kofke22 are almost the same as the ones by Tian et al7 , and clear difference stands for B12.

The bolded numbers are the best estimated values by Tian, Jiang and Mulero. p. 2
Where the paper says it

3 values of virial coefficients B2 to B16 of the HS fluids from literatures are summarized and illustrated in Table 1. It should be noted that the best estimated values of B5-B11 by Shultz and Kofke22 are almost the same as the ones by Tian et al7 , and clear difference stands for B12.

Table 2

Table 2 shows the percentage relative deviations of B13-B16 from EOSs of HS fluids compared with the predicted values by Clisby and McCoy. The deviations for YK, P[5/6] and P[6/5] are not shown because B13-B16 from them are greatly away from the predicted values. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The linear fitting is shown in Figure 1 here. Because we only have the predicted values for B12-B16 and have no values for higher order virial coefficients, it is difficult to know the proper range in which the linear behavior displayed in Figure 1 holds, i.

Table 3

Table 3 presents the AADs (%) of EOSs for HS fluids over three different density ranges. The lowest values are in bold. p. 0

Where the paper says it

, 2019, 21, 6886]. Our results show that this equation is accurate in not only the stable density range but also the metastable density range with the proper closest packing fraction pole, and well derives the predictive values of the high order virial coefficients B13-B16.

The second-best results are given by the KLM EOS with AAD3 of 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Z]Z)k (HGH. H-Z))k (8) The authors used the simulation data of Z versus 𝜂 by Bannerman et al13 to test the accuracy of equations considered, and found that this UC EOS gives the third best results and better than the Carnahan-Starling EOS.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Z]Z)k (HGH. H-Z))k (8) The authors used the simulation data of Z versus 𝜂 by Bannerman et al13 to test the accuracy of equations considered, and found that this UC EOS gives the third best results and better than the Carnahan-Starling EOS.

0116%.

The lowest values are in bold. The second-best results are given by the KLM EOS with AAD3 of 0.0116%.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved Equation of State Construction: The new equation for hard sphere fluids, Eq (29), is a closed form that naturally includes the closest packing fraction pole at eta = 0.7405, addressing a key requirement for a good closed EOS which includes a proper/physical packing fraction pole.

  2. Enhanced Predictive Power: The new equation provides superior prediction for high order virial coefficients B13-B16, with the current work showing the best predictions to B14-B16 are given by the current work, Eq. (29), and the corresponding percentage absolute deviations are all less than 0.2%.

  3. Improved Data Fitting Accuracy: The system can now be calibrated using a method that minimizes AAD2, yielding m=32 and c0= 985.3979 with AAD1=0.0250%, AAD2=0.0316% and AAD3=0.0277% when compared against the most recent Molecular Dynamics simulation data by Pieprzyk et al.

Abstract

We review selected equations of state (EOSs) for three-dimensional hard-sphere fluids and revise a closed-virial construction to describe stable and metastable disordered states.

Related papers