CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws

arXiv:2512.02054 · physics.gen-ph · Submitted 2025-11-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws is investigated by studying CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics models and their implications for blackbody radiation thermal laws The paper provides a general formalism for photons at low temperature, namely, with kBT ≪ mec 2 It discusses the modifications in the Planck distribution and the Stefan-Boltzmann law induced by a non-trivial CP-violating parameter Field Equations and CP Violation The investigation begins by evaluating features related to field equations and wave propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field, showing that the CP-violating term induces a bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum The authors establish modified field equations for photon propagation in a magnetic background field using auxiliary fields D and H The presence of non-trivial coefficients c2 and d3 leads to parity violating terms in the modified field equations, which are characteristic of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics These coefficients are related to the derivatives of the non-linear Lagrangian density with respect to F and G evaluated at the magnetic background field B0 The vacuum behaves like a bi-anisotropic material when d3 is not zero, meaning both electric and magnetic fields can generate contributions to magnetization and polarization vectors in different directions according to the components of the magnetic background field Dispersion Relations and Effective Models The modified dispersion relations for photon propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field are derived by assuming plane wave solutions The non-trivial solutions of Mij e0j = 0 lead to a polynomial equation P w4c4 + Qw2c2 + R = 0, which yields the frequencies w(±) These dispersion relations describe the non-trivial photon propagating modes in the presence of magnetic background field, where both B0 and k have arbitrary directions The group velocities vg i are obtained from these frequencies and satisfy the condition vg i w(±) · kˆ = w(±) k = vp The effective low-energy CP-violating model is considered, where the Lagrangian density is expanded as Lnl(F, G) = X ij a ij F i G j The Euler-Heisenberg electrodynamics corresponds to the case with ξ1, ξ2 and ξ3 being constants with the same dimension as the inverse square of the magnetic field Blackbody Radiation Thermodynamics The study examines deviations from standard blackbody radiation laws by considering non-linear electrodynamics in vacuum at low temperature, kBT ≪ mec 2 The average energy in this situation is given by ⟨E⟩ = V (2π)3 Z d3x Z hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1) The energy density u(T) is found to be u (T) = aT4, with the definition a = 4c/(2πk4B15h3c2 Φ(±), where Φ(±) ≡ Φ(±) (ξi, B0) The equation of state between the energy density and the radiation pressure remains unchanged, P = u/3, even if CP-violating terms are considered Corrections to Spectral Laws and Astrophysical Applications The spectral density of energy per unit volume is given by u (w) dw = w2π2c3hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1)Φ(±)dw The corrections to the Planck distribution lead to an increase in the number of photons in each state, and the angular contribution results in a monopole and a quadrupole contribution to the power angular spectrum The generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law is derived as R (T) = σef fT4, where σef f = σh1 + ϵ4i The effects of CP-violation become more relevant in the presence of strong magnetic fields with a magnitude of B0 = 107 T and higher orders, which encompasses some astrophysical scenarios, such as neutron stars Experimental constraints on the parameters ξi indicate that the CP-violating contribution ξ3 is non-trivial when it assumes the same order of magnitude as the CP-preserving ones, ξ1 and ξ2 with the causality condition ξ23 ≤ 4ξ1ξ2 being respected The results are consistent with previous studies on a photon gas in thermal equilibrium at temperature T, within the formalism of non-linear electrodynamics models without CPviolating contributions Concluding Remarks and Perspectives The existence of a non-trivial CP-violating term leads to a bi-anisotropic vacuum, contrasting with the usual anisotropic vacuum behavior where the electric field is responsible for the polarization tensor and the magnetic field for the magnetization tensor The model is better suited for describing phenomena in the presence of strong magnetic fields Future steps include a detailed analysis of Chandra X-ray Observatory, XMM-Newton, and Suzaku data to constrain the parameters of the effective non-linear electrodynamics It is also possible to wonder if CP-violating Born-Infeld model could be generated from low energy limit of String Theories The authors only consider the effects of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics in vacuum Page 1 --- L.P.R.

Kai: Ospedal,∗ R.

Mira: Turcati,† and S.B.

Kai: Duarte‡ are the authors of this paper The abstract summarizes the twofold investigation in CPviolating non-linear electrodynamics models On one hand, features related to field equations and wave propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field are evaluated On the other hand, blackbody radiation thermal laws in this situation are studied The paper provides a general formalism for photons at low temperature, namely, with kBT ≪ mec 2 The deviations from standard values of the thermodynamic quantities, such as energy, pressure, entropy, and specific heat are discussed In addition, we investigate the modifications in the Planck distribution and the Stefan-Boltzmann law induced by a non-trivial CP-violating parameter Back to 1956, the pioneering work of Lee and Yang on the possible parity (P) symmetry breaking in the Electroweak interaction (EW)

1: and, subsequently, the experimental confirmation by the group led by Wu

2: pointed out the relevance of discrete symmetries for a better understanding of fundamental interactions At this stage, the parity symmetry remains preserved by the strong nuclear and electromagnetic interactions After that, the CP symmetry emerged as a candidate to be the true symmetry between matter and antimatter, but it was discovered that this symmetry would also be broken by EW in decay of neutral kaon

3: Some years later, violations of CP were observed in many experiments involving meson and baryon decays Nowadays, it is well-known that the Standard Model (SM) accommodates a CP-violating contribution in the quark sector with the Cabibbo–Kobayashi–Maskawa (CKM) matrix In addition, a small CP-violating term is allowed in the context Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), with the presence of the so-called θ−term It is also important to emphasize that the combined CPT transformations, where T denotes time reversal transformation, is a fundamental symmetry for any local Quantum Field Theory, which is Lorentz invariant and has a hermitian Hamiltonian Therefore, a violation of CP automatically implies into a violation of T, such that CPT is preserved Furthermore, as pointed out by Sakharov

15: , the violation of CP appears as one of the conditions for the emergence of matter-antimatter asymmetry in the primordial universe If the contribution of the Standard Model to CP breaking is too small to explain this asymmetry, then we will need to search for new physics Beyond the Standard Model (BSM), either by introducing new interactions, gauge groups or fields Within these notable research lines and motivations, we will be particularly concerned with CP-violating contributions to non-linear electrodynamics Non-linear Electrodynamics Background A lot of efforts has been devoted to investigate general aspects of non-linear electrodynamics, which sometimes includes CP-violating contributions The vacuum of nonlinear electrodynamics may be seen as a non-linear optical medium With this in mind, the correspondence optical phenomena such as birefringences, photon splitting, second harmonic generation, wave mixing, and other optical properties were investigated in Refs.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws." It’s by Ospedal, Turcati, and Duarte. It’s about how CP violation in the vacuum affects photon behavior and how that changes the way blackbody radiation behaves.

Mira: Yeah, it tackles a couple of big things at once here: first looking at field equations and wave propagation when there's a magnetic background field, which they say shows the CP-violating term induces some kind of bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum.

Lev: Bi-anisotropic behavior sounds complex for hardware. When you're talking about real systems, you need to know what those tensors actually do when things are small.

Kai: Exactly. The paper sets up modified field equations using auxiliary fields D and H, and they find that coefficients c2 and d3 lead to parity violating terms in these equations, which is the hallmark of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics when d3 is not zero.

Mira: And what’s interesting is that this means the vacuum acts like a bi-anisotropic material; both electric and magnetic fields can generate contributions to magnetization and polarization vectors in different directions depending on the magnetic background field components, which they call B0.

Lev: That sounds like it requires a material description where permittivity and permeability aren't simple scalars anymore. How do you model that on a chip?

Kai: Well, they then move into dispersion relations by assuming plane wave solutions around this magnetic background field, and solving the resulting polynomial equation, which is P w4c4 plus Q w2c2 plus R equals zero, to find the frequencies of these non-trivial photon modes.

Mira: And those modified dispersion relations give them group velocities that satisfy a specific condition: vg i w of plus k hat equals w of plus k equals vp. That links the propagation speed directly to the frequency and wave vector in a way that changes from standard physics.

Lev: So, if I were building an optical setup to measure this, what’s the real constraint there? Is it just about finding those frequencies, or is there something practical about those group velocities?

Kai: The paper then considers an effective low-energy CP-violating model by expanding the Lagrangian density as L nl F G equals X ij a ij F i G j. This expansion gives them parameters like c1 equals one minus xi1 B20, d1 equals two xi1, and d3 equals xi3.

Title and authors: Mira: And they link these to known physics: they say the Euler-Heisenberg electrodynamics corresponds to a specific set of parameters where xi EH3 is zero. They also mention that the so called theta term of QCD can generate this CP-violating contribution in photonic interactions, which is interesting because it’s a Standard Model connection.

Lev: So, if we want to test this using experimental constraints, what kind of experiments are they thinking about? Is it just looking at photon-photon scattering experiments?

Kai: They suggest that effective field theories involving vector and pseudo-vector couplings between fermions and the photon can generate an effective CP-violation Euler-Heisenberg like electrodynamics. They also mention axion fields coupled to the electromagnetic sector leading to a CP-violating model with parameters xi phi1, xi phi2, and xi phi3.

Mira: Moving into the thermal side of things, they look at blackbody radiation at low temperature, specifically where kBT is much smaller than the mass of the particle in question. In this limit, they find a general formalism for photons.

Lev: The energy density calculation looks specific here: it gives them u T equals a T to the fourth power, and that constant a depends on those parameters xi i and B0 in a complicated way. That dependence is what you need to model accurately.

Kai: The key result from this thermal analysis is that the equation of state between the energy density and the radiation pressure remains unchanged, P equals u over three, even when you consider these CP-violating terms. That’s a pretty stable finding for thermodynamics.

Mira: But they also found corrections to the spectral laws. They get u w dw equals w two pi two c three h omega bar e beta omega minus one phi plus minus dw, which means the corrections lead to an increase in the number of photons in each state.

Lev: So, for someone just listening, what does that mean for their energy budget if they're dealing with a thermal bath? Is it a big deviation from standard blackbody radiation?

Kai: It is quantified by the relative deviation delta u u equals phi plus minus minus one, and the angular contribution results in both a monopole and a quadrupole contribution to the power angular spectrum. This means the way energy is distributed across angles changes due to CP violation.

Title and authors: Mira: They derive a generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law, R T equals sigma ef f T to the fourth power, where sigma ef f is defined as sigma h1 plus epsilon four i. The temperature dependence itself stays at T to the fourth power, which is standard for blackbody radiation.

Lev: So they are saying that even with these CP-violating terms and corrections to the Planck distribution, the overall temperature dependence of the total energy radiated still scales with T to the fourth power. That’s a crucial piece of information for thermal systems.

Kai: They conclude that these effects become more relevant when you have strong magnetic fields, specifically when B0 is at ten to seven tesla and higher orders are considered, which covers some astrophysical scenarios like neutron stars.

Mira: Phenomenological constraints on the parameters xi i indicate that the CP-violating contribution xi3 is non-trivial even if it’s assumed to be the same order of magnitude as the CP-preserving ones, xi1 and xi2, provided you respect the causality condition where xi2 three less than or equal to four times xone times xtwo.

Lev: That causality condition sounds like a serious hurdle for any physical model you try to build; it's a strong constraint on the parameters.

Kai: And they mention that these results are consistent with previous studies on photon gas in thermal equilibrium at temperature T, using non-linear electrodynamics models without CP-violating contributions.

Mira: So, the main implication is that this paper shows how CP violation in non-linear electrodynamics modifies both the propagation of photons in magnetic fields and the resulting thermal laws of blackbody radiation.

Lev: It’s a lot to digest, especially connecting the low-energy effective models to those strong field astrophysical scenarios.

Kai: Before we wrap up this paper, Lev, what's your final thought on whether these results are testable with current technology?

Lev: I think the complexity of modeling the full bi-anisotropic material behavior is where it hits real hardware development. We need much simpler effective theories to see if we can actually build something that probes those specific coefficients c2 and d3.

Mira: I agree, but the theoretical structure they present for connecting these parameters to QCD or other BSM physics is what gives us a target for experimentalists to aim for.

Kai: Exactly, so the paper on CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws gives us the framework for looking at how fundamental symmetries might leave imprints in observable quantities like radiation spectra.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap this paper, Ospedal and his team are looking at how adding CP violation into non-linear electrodynamics affects two main things: how photons actually travel in a magnetic field, and what that means for the laws of blackbody radiation when you heat stuff up.

Mira: Right. They build a general framework for photons at low temperatures, where k times B to the squared is much smaller than the mass of whatever particle we're looking at. They show that this CP-violating term messes with the standard way energy density changes with temperature.

Lev: It’s about finding those modified dispersion relations first, which are these polynomial equations that give us different frequencies for photons propagating in a magnetic field, and then they connect those frequencies to the Lagrangian expansion parameters like xi one, xi two, and xi three.

Kai: And they show that this non-trivial CP parameter means the vacuum itself behaves differently—it’s bi-anisotropic—which is a departure from what we usually assume about vacuum polarization.

Mira: The big result for the thermodynamics is that while the equation of state between pressure and energy density stays exactly the same, P equals u over three, even with these CP-violating corrections present. That part holds up pretty well.

Lev: But they also get corrections to the spectral laws, like how you find the energy per unit volume as a function of frequency; they see an increase in the number of photons in each state due to this non-linearity.

Kai: And on a bigger scale, these corrections show up in the angular distribution; they introduce both a monopole and a quadrupole contribution to the power spectrum of radiation. It’s not just straight lines anymore for where the energy goes.

Mira: They derive a generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law, which is still proportional to temperature to the fourth power, R T to the fourth power, but that constant factor sigma ef f now includes those CP-violating terms.

Lev: So what this means for us is that these effects become really pronounced when you look at very strong magnetic fields, like around ten to seven tesla or higher orders. That’s where you start seeing real astrophysical relevance in things like neutron stars.

Kai: And they give a constraint on those parameters; the CP-violating term xi three isn't just some tiny footnote anymore if it’s on the same scale as xi one and xi two, provided you respect a causality condition.

Mira: It’s interesting because they show that these results are consistent with previous studies of photon gases in thermal equilibrium, even those without CP violation at all.

Lev: The authors also flag their limitation: they only focus on the effects of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics in a vacuum, so you have to keep that context in mind when you try to apply this to something else.

Kai: So the paper gives us a blueprint for how fundamental symmetries leave imprints on observable quantities like radiation spectra when things get magnetized and hot. Next up, we're going to look at some of those specific constraints from experiments like PVLAS and hydrogen atom shift measurements.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we're moving on to what Ospedal and his team suggest as improvements for this work. Essentially, they think the paper could be better at modeling how vacuum birefringence happens when you introduce those CP-violating terms.

Kai: They point out that by using these CP-violating terms, the model naturally induces a bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum, which is a bit more realistic than just treating it as a simple anisotropic medium.

Mira: Right. It moves beyond just saying things are weird to actually describing how they act in different directions when you have those magnetic fields present. They also suggest incorporating constraints from experiments, like those related to hydrogen atom shift measurements and PVLAS experiments, to pin down the actual values of those coefficients like xi one and xi two.

Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, I think that’s crucial because if we can constrain those parameters, it tells us how much overhead you need for a real detector. If the CP-violating contribution is small but non-zero, it dictates the required sensitivity of our measurement apparatus.

Kai: And on the thermal side, they suggest incorporating those constraints to see how much deviation you actually expect from standard blackbody radiation laws at lower energies. It helps them predict exactly how much more photons you'd find in a certain state.

Mira: They also mention that this framework could potentially lead us toward a CP-violating Born-Infeld model in the low-energy limit of string theories, which is a big theoretical leap for us to consider.

Lev: That’s deep stuff, connecting QED corrections to string theory structures. It shows how these vacuum effects might arise from more fundamental physics than just adding arbitrary terms like xi three.

Kai: So the main improvement here is turning the paper into a more predictive tool where we can actually test those specific coefficients against real experimental data, instead of just looking at theoretical possibilities.

Mira: It’s about moving from a general formalism to a set of testable predictions for how much things deviate from standard physics in measurable quantities like radiation spectra.

Lev: The next step, then is figuring out if our current error-correction techniques can actually handle the complexity introduced by those bi-anisotropic tensors they're proposing.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this look at "CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws," we’ve seen how CP violation in a vacuum modifies photon propagation in magnetic fields and changes the standard laws of blackbody radiation at low temperatures.

Mira: It shows that even when you keep the equation of state stable, the way energy is distributed angularly gets tweaked by these non-linear effects. The generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law still scales with temperature to the fourth power, R T to the fourth power, but with those new correction terms included in sigma ef f.

Lev: From my side, what this implies is that we need very precise measurement tools if we want to actually detect these small shifts in spectral laws or those angular distributions. It puts a real requirement on the fidelity of any detector you build for this kind of physics.

Kai: Exactly, Lev, because if those constraints from hydrogen atom shift experiments don't align with what this model predicts for the coefficients like xi three, then we have a serious problem with our assumptions about vacuum structure.

Mira: It’s an interesting link because they also explore how this kind of physics might connect to string theory and Born-Infeld models in a low-energy limit. That opens up some very deep theoretical avenues for future work.

Lev: I think the real next step is taking those effective field theories, the ones involving axion fields or dark sector couplings, and actually designing the hardware that could probe those specific CP-violating interactions at a usable scale.

Kai: So we’ve established this general formalism for photons at low temperature with k times B to the squared much smaller than mass of particle, showing how these non-linear corrections affect both propagation and thermal laws.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of condensed matter theory applied to QED vacuum, providing a clear path for where the next generation of experimental constraints should be aimed.

Lev: It gives us concrete targets for what kind of precision we need from our next-generation cryogenic detectors if we want to look for these subtle CP-violating fingerprints in the vacuum.

Kai: We’ll be keeping an eye on those results, and next time, we’re going to dive into some of those specific experimental constraints that test these parameters directly.

L.P.R. Ospedal, R. Turcati, S.B. Duarte

Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Físicas

physics.gen-ph

Submitted: 2025-11-27

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: In this version, there are improvements to some discussions and notations. References and a new appendix have been added

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 59/100

The gist: CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws is investigated by studying CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics models and their implications for…

Key concepts

CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics
This involves extending standard electromagnetism by adding terms that violate Charge-Parity symmetry. These terms describe how the vacuum itself behaves as a non-linear medium, where the vacuum's response depends on both electric and magnetic fields in a way that breaks parity symmetry.
Bi-anisotropic behavior
When a magnetic background field is present, the vacuum acts like a material whose properties depend differently on electric and magnetic fields. The CP-violating term causes this behavior to be bi-anisotropic, meaning both electric and magnetic fields can generate contributions to magnetization and polarization in different directions.
Modified Dispersion Relations
These equations describe how photons travel through the vacuum when a strong magnetic field is present. The non-trivial solutions derived from these relations show that photon propagation depends on the direction of the magnetic field, leading to modified frequencies and group velocities compared to standard physics.

Terminology

Summary

CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws is investigated by studying CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics models and their implications for blackbody radiation thermal laws The paper provides a general formalism for photons at low temperature, namely, with kBT ≪ mec 2 It discusses the modifications in the Planck distribution and the Stefan-Boltzmann law induced by a non-trivial CP-violating parameter

Field Equations and CP Violation

The investigation begins by evaluating features related to field equations and wave propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field, showing that the CP-violating term induces a bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum The authors establish modified field equations for photon propagation in a magnetic background field using auxiliary fields D and H The presence of non-trivial coefficients c2 and d3 leads to parity violating terms in the modified field equations, which are characteristic of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics These coefficients are related to the derivatives of the non-linear Lagrangian density with respect to F and G evaluated at the magnetic background field B0 The vacuum behaves like a bi-anisotropic material when d3 is not zero, meaning both electric and magnetic fields can generate contributions to magnetization and polarization vectors in different directions according to the components of the magnetic background field

Dispersion Relations and Effective Models

The modified dispersion relations for photon propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field are derived by assuming plane wave solutions The non-trivial solutions of Mij e0j = 0 lead to a polynomial equation P w4c4 + Qw2c2 + R = 0, which yields the frequencies w(±) These dispersion relations describe the non-trivial photon propagating modes in the presence of magnetic background field, where both B0 and k have arbitrary directions The group velocities vg i are obtained from these frequencies and satisfy the condition vg i w(±) · kˆ = w(±) k = vp The effective low-energy CP-violating model is considered, where the Lagrangian density is expanded as Lnl(F, G) = X ij a ij F i G j The Euler-Heisenberg electrodynamics corresponds to the case with ξ1, ξ2 and ξ3 being constants with the same dimension as the inverse square of the magnetic field

Blackbody Radiation Thermodynamics

The study examines deviations from standard blackbody radiation laws by considering non-linear electrodynamics in vacuum at low temperature, kBT ≪ mec 2 The average energy in this situation is given by ⟨E⟩ = V (2π)3 Z d3x Z hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1) The energy density u(T) is found to be u (T) = aT4, with the definition a = 4c/(2πk4B15h3c2 Φ(±), where Φ(±) ≡ Φ(±) (ξi, B0) The equation of state between the energy density and the radiation pressure remains unchanged, P = u/3, even if CP-violating terms are considered

Corrections to Spectral Laws and Astrophysical Applications

The spectral density of energy per unit volume is given by u (w) dw = w2π2c3hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1)Φ(±)dw The corrections to the Planck distribution lead to an increase in the number of photons in each state, and the angular contribution results in a monopole and a quadrupole contribution to the power angular spectrum The generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law is derived as R (T) = σef fT4, where σef f = σh1 + ϵ4i The effects of CP-violation become more relevant in the presence of strong magnetic fields with a magnitude of B0 = 107 T and higher orders, which encompasses some astrophysical scenarios, such as neutron stars Experimental constraints on the parameters ξi indicate that the CP-violating contribution ξ3 is non-trivial when it assumes the same order of magnitude as the CP-preserving ones, ξ1 and ξ2 with the causality condition ξ23 ≤ 4ξ1ξ2 being respected The results are consistent with previous studies on a photon gas in thermal equilibrium at temperature T, within the formalism of non-linear electrodynamics models without CPviolating contributions

Concluding Remarks and Perspectives

The existence of a non-trivial CP-violating term leads to a bi-anisotropic vacuum, contrasting with the usual anisotropic vacuum behavior where the electric field is responsible for the polarization tensor and the magnetic field for the magnetization tensor The model is better suited for describing phenomena in the presence of strong magnetic fields Future steps include a detailed analysis of Chandra X-ray Observatory, XMM-Newton, and Suzaku data to constrain the parameters of the effective non-linear electrodynamics It is also possible to wonder if CP-violating Born-Infeld model could be generated from low energy limit of String Theories The authors only consider the effects of CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics in vacuum

--- Page 1 ---

L.P.R. Ospedal,∗ R. p. 0

Where the paper says it

CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics and corrections to blackbody radiation thermal laws L. Ospedal,∗ R.

Turcati,† and S. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Ospedal,∗ R. Turcati,† and S.

B. Duarte‡ are the authors of this paper The abstract summarizes the twofold investigation in CPviolating non-linear electrodynamics models On one hand, features related to field equations and wave propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field are evaluated On the other hand, blackbody radiation thermal laws in this situation are studied The paper provides a general formalism for photons at low temperature, namely, with kBT ≪ mec 2 The deviations from standard values of the thermodynamic quantities, such as energy, pressure, entropy, and specific heat are discussed In addition, we investigate the modifications in the Planck distribution and the Stefan-Boltzmann law induced by a non-trivial CP-violating parameter

Introduction

Back to 1956, the pioneering work of Lee and Yang on the possible parity (P) symmetry breaking in the Electroweak interaction (EW) [1] and, subsequently, the experimental confirmation by the group led by Wu [2] pointed out the relevance of discrete symmetries for a better understanding of fundamental interactions At this stage, the parity symmetry remains preserved by the strong nuclear and electromagnetic interactions After that, the CP symmetry emerged as a candidate to be the true symmetry between matter and antimatter, but it was discovered that this symmetry would also be broken by EW in decay of neutral kaon [3] Some years later, violations of CP were observed in many experiments involving meson and baryon decays Nowadays, it is well-known that the Standard Model (SM) accommodates a CP-violating contribution in the quark sector with the Cabibbo–Kobayashi–Maskawa (CKM) matrix In addition, a small CP-violating term is allowed in the context Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), with the presence of the so-called θ−term It is also important to emphasize that the combined CPT transformations, where T denotes time reversal transformation, is a fundamental symmetry for any local Quantum Field Theory, which is Lorentz invariant and has a hermitian Hamiltonian Therefore, a violation of CP automatically implies into a violation of T, such that CPT is preserved Furthermore, as pointed out by Sakharov [15], the violation of CP appears as one of the conditions for the emergence of matter-antimatter asymmetry in the primordial universe If the contribution of the Standard Model to CP breaking is too small to explain this asymmetry, then we will need to search for new physics Beyond the Standard Model (BSM), either by introducing new interactions, gauge groups or fields Within these notable research lines and motivations, we will be particularly concerned with CP-violating contributions to non-linear electrodynamics

Non-linear Electrodynamics Background

A lot of efforts has been devoted to investigate general aspects of non-linear electrodynamics, which sometimes includes CP-violating contributions The vacuum of nonlinear electrodynamics may be seen as a non-linear optical medium With this in mind, the correspondence optical phenomena such as birefringences, photon splitting, second harmonic generation, wave mixing, and other optical properties were investigated in Refs. [21–28] The predictions of non-linear electrodynamics are the subject of intense research and the correspondent parameters can be tested or constrained by many experiments

CP-violating Sources

Within the scenario of a purely Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), there is no contribution to CP-violating terms even if taking into account quantum corrections in any order of perturbative expansion However, in the context of the Standard Model, it is worthwhile mentioning that a CP-violating photon self-interaction can be generated from an effective contribution of the strong nuclear interaction, namely, from the so-called θ−term of QCD Therefore, the appearance of non-trivial contributions to CP-violating terms could indicate possible effects of new physics BSM Some phenomenological investigations in the photonic sector could be useful for constraining the parameters related to proposals BSM For instance, we point out that the inclusion of both vector and pseudo-vector couplings between fermions and photon can generate an effective CP-violation Euler-Heisenberg-like electrodynamics

New Physics Scenarios

Other possible sources are the introduction of dark matter candidates coupled to the photonic sector, such that the corresponding effective theories lead to CP-violating self-photon interactions The most popular approach is the incorporation of the axion field Another viewpoint is the inclusion of a new abelian dark sector UY′(1) coupled to the Electroweak sector SUL(2)×UY (1) of the Standard Model In particular, nonlinear corrections in the hypercharge sector UY (1) can induce anomalous neutral couplings between photon and Z0 boson, as well as contributions to CP-violating photonic terms

Thermal Laws Motivation

With these ideas and motivations regarding photon propagation in mind, it would be worthwhile to consider the implications for the thermal laws governing blackbody radiation Electromagnetic radiation in thermal equilibrium has played a fundamental role in modern physics Corrections to photon propagation should induce small deviations from the standard blackbody radiation laws, which modify the Stefan-Boltzmann law and thermodynamic potentials

Paper Organization

The main purpose of this paper is to further elaborate about modified dispersion relations in the presence of a magnetic background field and the violation of CP in photon self-interactions, as well as examining the implications to the blackbody radiation thermal laws Initially, in Section II, we obtain the dispersion relations for a general CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics in the presence of a magnetic background field In addition, we also present an overview of possible scenarios in which CP-violating contributions may be generated After that, in Section III, our approach aims to investigate an effective low-energy CP-violating model and its contributions to thermodynamic properties such as energy density, pressure, entropy, and specific heat Furthermore, we derive the correspondent corrections to the Planck distribution and Rayleigh-Jeans law as well as we get the modified Wien displacement and Stefan-Boltzmann laws Some phenomenological implications are also discussed Finally, in Section IV, we exhibit our concluding comments and perspectives Throughout this work, we adopt the SI units where ε0 and µ0 denote the vacuum permittivity and permeability respectively

The Model Under Consideration

In this Section, we present the modified field equations of a photon propagation in the presence of a uniform and constant magnetic background field We assume that Lnl = Lnl(F, G), with F and G being the Lorentz and gauge invariants defined as F ≡ -1/4 F squared / (µ0 c squared − B 2) and G ≡ -1/4 Fµnu Feµnu = E · B / c The field equations related to the Lagrangian density (1) are given by ∇ · D = ρ, (5) and ∇ × H = j + ∂D/∂t, (6) where D and H are auxiliary fields For Maxwell’s electrodynamics, Lnl = F, which leads to D = ε0 E and H = B/µ0 such that Eqs. (5) and (6) recover the usual inhomogeneous Maxwell’s equations

Perturbations in Magnetic Background

We assume electromagnetic fields around a magnetic background field B0, in such a way that E = e and B = B0 +b, where e and b are small perturbations Expanding Eqs. (7) and (8) in the linear perturbations leads to expressions for D and H involving coefficients c1, c2, d1, d2 and d3 evaluated at the magnetic background field Terms with odd powers in G will break the parity symmetry, leading to CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics when c2 ≠ 0 and d3 ≠ 0 The homogeneous equations for the perturbation fields are obtained by eliminating terms with coefficient c2 This allows for a redefinition of the auxiliary fields D and H in terms of matrix components Di and Hi These components correspond to permittivity and permeability tensors, where d3 ≠ 0 results in a bi-anisotropic material behavior

Modified Dispersion Relations

By assuming plane wave solutions e(x, t) = e0 e i(k·x−w t) and b(x, t) = b0 e i(k·x−w t), one arrives at the modified Gauss equation (24) The non-trivial solutions of Mij e0j = 0 are obtained by imposing that det(M) = 0 The condition α = 0 leads to the usual photon dispersion relation w2 = c2 k2 Other solutions arise from the condition (α+u·v)(α+w·t)−(u·t)(v·w) = 0, or equivalently, from the polynomial equation P w4c4 + Qw2c2 + R = 0 This leads to the frequencies w(±) The group velocities vg i are derived from these frequencies and satisfy vg i w(±) · kˆ = w(±) k = vp

CP-Violating Lagrangian Expansion

The CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics is considered by expanding the Lagrangian density as Lnl(F, G) = X ij a ij F i G j This expansion yields the parameters c1 = 1 − ξ1B20, d1 = 2 ξ1, d2 = 2 ξ2, and d3 = ξ3 The Euler-Heisenberg electrodynamics corresponds to a specific set of parameters where xiEH3 is zero The so-called θ−term of QCD can generate a contribution to CP-violating photonic interaction Effective field theories involving vector and pseudo-vector couplings between fermions and photon can generate an effective CP-violation Euler-Heisenberg-like electrodynamics Axion fields coupled to the electromagnetic sector can also lead to a CP-violating model (46) with parameters ξϕ1, ξϕ2 and ξϕ3

Blackbody Radiation Analysis

The analysis of blackbody radiation in the context of statistical mechanics is done in the regime kBT ≪ mec 2 The average energy in this situation is given by ⟨E⟩ = V (2π)3 Z hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1) The CP-violating non-linear corrections depend on Φ(±), which have some interesting properties The energy density u (T) is found to be u (T) = aT4, with the definition a = 4c/(2πk4B15h3c2 Φ(±), where Φ(±) ≡ Φ(±) (ξi, B0) The equation of state P = u/3 remains unchanged compared to the standard results from the photon gas

Corrections to Planck Distribution

The spectral density of energy per unit volume is given by u (w) dw = w2π2c3hw¯ (e β¯hw − 1)Φ(±)dw The corrections lead to an increase in the number of photons in each state, and the angular contribution results in a monopole and a quadrupole contribution to the power angular spectrum The relative deviations from Planck’s blackbody radiation law are given by δu u = Φ± − 1 The effects of CP-violation in the context of blackbody radiation thermal laws can be examined by considering constraints on the ξi−coefficients arising from experiments at low energies The corrections arising from non-linear electrodynamics lead to an increase in the number of accessible states at each frequency

Stefan-Boltzmann Law Modifications

The total radiance is defined by R (T) = Z 2π0 dϕ Z π/20 dθsinθcosθ Z ∞0 B (w, θ, T) dw The generalized Stefan-Boltzmann law is derived as R (T) = σef fT4, where σef f = σh1 + ϵ4i The temperature dependence remains the same as the usual blackbody radiation results, i.e., depends on T4

Applications and Phenomenological Analyses

The paper concludes that the effects of non-linear electrodynamics and CP-violating terms become more relevant in the presence of strong magnetic fields with a magnitude of B0 = 107 T and higher orders, which encompasses some astrophysical s…

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to model vacuum birefringence in non-linear electrodynamics systems by utilizing CP-violating terms, as shown by we show that the CP-violating term in our framework induces a bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum.

  2. Enhanced capacity to predict modifications to blackbody radiation laws, specifically deriving the modified Wien displacement and Stefan-Boltzmann laws and analyzing deviations from the Planck distribution using the effective coefficient Phi plus minus.

  3. Capability to evaluate CP-violating non-linear corrections in astrophysical scenarios by incorporating constraints derived from experimental limits on parameters such as the combined constraints related to the small deviations from the shift levels of the hydrogen atom and PVLAS experiment.

  4. Stronger analytical tools for understanding wave propagation, enabling the derivation of modified dispersion relations (Eq. 40) and their corresponding group velocities (Eq. 43), which account for both magnetic background fields and CP violation.

  5. Advanced modeling of spectral energy density distribution by incorporating the angular dependence derived from the modified dispersion relations, allowing for a detailed analysis of the monopole (l = 0) and a quadrupole (l = 2) contribution to the power angular spectrum.

Abstract

Motivated by ideas from effective field theories, we conduct a twofold investigation in CP-violating non-linear electrodynamics models. On the one hand, features related to field equations and wave propagation in the presence of a magnetic background field are evaluated. Interestingly, we show that the CP-violating term in our framework induces a bi-anisotropic behavior of the vacuum. On the other hand, blackbody radiation thermal laws in this situation are studied. Here, we provide a general formalism for photons at low temperature, namely, with k BT much less than m ec squared. The deviations from standard values of the thermodynamic quantities, such as energy, pressure, entropy, and specific heat, are discussed. In addition, we investigate the modifications in the Planck distribution and the Stefan-Boltzmann law induced by a non-trivial CP-violating parameter.

Sources

Related papers