Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in alpha-Sn

arXiv:2511.23289 · cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2025-11-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in alpha-Sn".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in α-Sn form this paper by formulating a tight-binding model for cubic α-Sn based on DFT calculations to demonstrate that this material exhibits dual topology and non-trivial edge states under strain, which is significant because it shows how strain can tune the electronic topology of α-Sn Topological Invariants and Phase Diagrams The bulk of α-Sn demonstrates the presence of the Z2 topological invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number, making it one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed The authors calculate the topological phase diagram for multi-layer α-Sn as a function of strain and number of layers, finding that a non-trivial quantum spin Hall state appears only for compressive strain above five layers of thickness In the 3D case, the system is always in a topological insulator phase with ν = 1 as long as the tensile strain is applied The system realizes a topological crystalline insulator phase with a (110)-mirror Chern number C = 1 in the tensile strain case Edge State Characteristics A plethora of edge-states with energies inside the bulk gap of the system is found in both trivial and non-trivial phases These states are localized at various locations, including side surfaces, top/bottom surfaces, and hinges The microscopic origin of these states is traced back to a minimal model that supports chiral symmetry and multiple one-dimensional winding numbers that take different values in different directions in the Brillouin zone In the case of 10 layers, open edges parallel to the n2 direction show in-gap edge-states in all cases, suggesting multimode edgetransport Microscopic Modeling and Symmetry Evolution The tight-binding Hamiltonian is constructed using a primitive unit cell consisting of two Sn atoms and nearest-neighbor hopping processes that are parameterized by a bond angle θ The effect of in-plane tensile or compressive strain is introduced by varying this bond angle θ, where the unstrained case corresponds to θ = θ0 = arctan √2 The Hamiltonian can be evolved towards a chiral-symmetric system by setting Ep = Es and λ = 0 This evolution leads to a chiral effective model Hchir(k) which supports a chiral Z invariant in three dimensions or weaker chiral Z invariants living in the 1D cuts of the 3D BZ The additional edge-states do not follow from any rigorous topological invariant, but their existence is found to be related to winding numbers present in the 1D cuts of the 3D BZ In the chiral limit, these edge-states become zero-energy flat-bands localized on top/bottom or left-right surfaces depending on a particular value of the winding number in a given direction The presence of both the Z2 invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number makes this system one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed The paper suggests that similar physics might be more accessible in van der Waals materials like PtSe2 and PtTe2 for hosting the QSH phase Acknowledgments The authors thank D.

Kai: Zgid, T.

Mira: Dietl, J.

Kai: Polaczy´nski, A.

Paper summary: Mira: To wrap up this paper on dual topology and edge reconstruction in alpha tin, we see that the combination of the Z two invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number makes alpha tin one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed.

Kai: The authors demonstrate that strain can tune the electronic topology of alpha tin, showing that this material exhibits dual topology and non-trivial edge states under strain.

Lev: So what does this mean in simpler terms for someone who isn't deep in topological invariants? It means we have a material where changing the shape of the crystal lattice directly controls whether it has these special dual topological properties.

Mira: Exactly, so instead of just looking at fixed materials, we can potentially use strain as a tool to engineer the electronic structure to achieve these specific states.

Kai: And they point towards other materials like platinum diselenide and platinum tetride as promising candidates for hosting the quantum spin hall phase because this material showed this kind of complex dual topology under strain.

Lev: The implication is that if we want to explore these topological effects in new systems, van der v ans mir materials might be a better place to start looking, given what they found with alpha tin.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up on "Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in alpha tin." Basically, these authors show that by changing how you stretch or squeeze the tin crystal—the strain—you can flip its entire electronic structure.

Mira: Right. It’s not just one type of topological state; they found evidence for both a Z two invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number living at the same time.

Lev: So, what does that actually mean for us trying to build something? Is this something we could simulate on our current quantum hardware?

Kai: Well, it means the physics isn't fixed; you get these dual topological properties when you apply specific strains, and that leads to these edge states popping up right in the middle of the energy gap.

Mira: Those edge states aren't just noise; they come from a really specific mathematical thing called winding numbers living in the one dimensional cuts of three dimensional space.

Lev: That sounds complicated for real hardware. How do we actually make sure we can measure these winding numbers reliably when you’re dealing with strain and multiple layers? What are the practical hurdles there?

Kai: The authors suggest that this kind of physics is pretty accessible in materials like platinum diselenide or platinum tetride, which are van der v ans mir materials.

Mira: They’re hinting that if we want to explore these kinds of complex dual topological states, we should probably look at those van der v ans mir systems instead of just sticking to tin.

Jan Skolimowski, Nguyen Minh Nguyen, Giuseppe Cuono, Carmine Autieri, Wojciech Brzezicki

International Research Centre Magtop, Institute of Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences · School of Science and Engineering, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen · Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR-SPIN) · SPIN-CNR, UOS Salerno · Institute of Theoretical Physics, Jagiellonian University

cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2025-11-28

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 13 pages, 16 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, 285101 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/n654-vxm2

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in α-Sn form this paper by formulating a tight-binding model for cubic α-Sn based on DFT calculations to demonstrate that this material exhibits dual topology…

Key concepts

Dual Topology
This refers to a material possessing two distinct types of topological invariants simultaneously—specifically, a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number. This dual nature makes the material unique among known systems.
Strain Tuning
Applying mechanical strain (tension or compression) to the crystal lattice changes the bond angles ($\theta$) in the tight-binding model. The research shows that this controlled change in geometry can transition $\alpha$-Sn into different topological phases, such as a quantum spin Hall state.
Edge States
These are electronic states found along the boundaries or edges of the material that exist within the bulk energy gap. In this study, these states are localized and their existence is linked to winding numbers in the 1D cuts of the Brillouin zone.

Terminology

Summary

Dual topology and edge-reconstruction in α-Sn form this paper by formulating a tight-binding model for cubic α-Sn based on DFT calculations to demonstrate that this material exhibits dual topology and non-trivial edge states under strain, which is significant because it shows how strain can tune the electronic topology of α-Sn

Topological Invariants and Phase Diagrams

The bulk of α-Sn demonstrates the presence of the Z2 topological invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number, making it one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed The authors calculate the topological phase diagram for multi-layer α-Sn as a function of strain and number of layers, finding that a non-trivial quantum spin Hall state appears only for compressive strain above five layers of thickness In the 3D case, the system is always in a topological insulator phase with ν = 1 as long as the tensile strain is applied The system realizes a topological crystalline insulator phase with a (110)-mirror Chern number C = 1 in the tensile strain case

Edge State Characteristics

A plethora of edge-states with energies inside the bulk gap of the system is found in both trivial and non-trivial phases These states are localized at various locations, including side surfaces, top/bottom surfaces, and hinges The microscopic origin of these states is traced back to a minimal model that supports chiral symmetry and multiple one-dimensional winding numbers that take different values in different directions in the Brillouin zone In the case of 10 layers, open edges parallel to the n2 direction show in-gap edge-states in all cases, suggesting multimode edgetransport

Microscopic Modeling and Symmetry Evolution

The tight-binding Hamiltonian is constructed using a primitive unit cell consisting of two Sn atoms and nearest-neighbor hopping processes that are parameterized by a bond angle θ The effect of in-plane tensile or compressive strain is introduced by varying this bond angle θ, where the unstrained case corresponds to θ = θ0 = arctan √2 The Hamiltonian can be evolved towards a chiral-symmetric system by setting Ep = Es and λ = 0 This evolution leads to a chiral effective model Hchir(k) which supports a chiral Z invariant in three dimensions or weaker chiral Z invariants living in the 1D cuts of the 3D BZ

Conclusions and Future Directions

The additional edge-states do not follow from any rigorous topological invariant, but their existence is found to be related to winding numbers present in the 1D cuts of the 3D BZ In the chiral limit, these edge-states become zero-energy flat-bands localized on top/bottom or left-right surfaces depending on a particular value of the winding number in a given direction The presence of both the Z2 invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number makes this system one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed The paper suggests that similar physics might be more accessible in van der Waals materials like PtSe2 and PtTe2 for hosting the QSH phase

Acknowledgments

The authors thank D. Zgid, T. Dietl, J. Polaczy´nski, A. p. 6

Where the paper says it

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank D. Polaczy´nski, A.

Kazakov and V. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Polaczy´nski, A. Kazakov and V.

V. Volobuiev for their useful discussions This research was supported by the Foundation for Polish Science project “MagTop” no. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Volobuiev for their useful discussions. This research was supported by the Foundation for Polish Sci-

FENG.02.01-IP.05-0028/23 co-financed by the European Union from the funds of Priority 2 of the European Funds for a Smart Economy Program 2021–2027 (FENG) The authors acknowledge support by Narodowe Centrum Nauki (NCN, National Science Centre, Poland) Project No. p. 7
Where the paper says it

05-0028/23 co-financed by the European Union from the funds of Priority 2 of the European Funds for a Smart Economy Program 2021–2027 (FENG). acknowledge support from PNRR MUR project PE0000023-NQSTI.

2019/34/E/ST3/00404 The authors acknowledge the access to the computing facilities of the Interdisciplinary Center of Modeling at the University of Warsaw, Grant G84-0, GB84-1 and GB84-7 The authors acknowledge the CINECA award under the ISCRA initiative IsC85 ”TOPMOST” and IsC93 ”RATIO” grant The authors acknowledge the access to the computing facilities of the Poznan Supercomputing and Networking Center, Grant No. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We acknowledge the access to the computing facilities of the Interdisciplinary Center of Modeling at the University of Warsaw, Grant G84-0, GB84-1 and GB84-7. We acknowledge the CINECA award under the ISCRA initiative IsC85 ”TOPMOST” and IsC93 ”RATIO” grant, for the availability of high-performance computing resources and support.

609

References

The references cited in the paper are as follows: <ref:2511.23289#pg5>, <ref:2511. p. 0

Where the paper says it

It has been demonstrated that once multiple channels exist37, time reversal symmetry does not forbid scattering between different Kramers pairs39 . In this paper, we use first-principles calculations to derive an effective tight-binding model for α-Sn includarXiv:2511.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

It has been demonstrated that once multiple channels exist37, time reversal symmetry does not forbid scattering between different Kramers pairs39 . In this paper, we use first-principles calculations to derive an effective tight-binding model for α-Sn includarXiv:2511.

23289#pg4>, <ref:2511. p. 0
Where the paper says it

It has been demonstrated that once multiple channels exist37, time reversal symmetry does not forbid scattering between different Kramers pairs39 . In this paper, we use first-principles calculations to derive an effective tight-binding model for α-Sn includarXiv:2511.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

It has been demonstrated that once multiple channels exist37, time reversal symmetry does not forbid scattering between different Kramers pairs39 . In this paper, we use first-principles calculations to derive an effective tight-binding model for α-Sn includarXiv:2511.

23289#pg4>, <ref:2511.23289#pg4>, and others listed in the acknowledgments section. p. 4
Where the paper says it

, Hchir(k) = Hθ0 (k, Ep = Es, λ = 0) − Es116. (7) Note that in this Section, we will focus on the unstrained case of θ = θ0 for the sake of simplicity, but the reasoning

The references include works on DFT calculations, tight-binding models, topological insulators, and experimental results for related materials like HgTe/CdTe quantum wells The list of references runs from 40 to 56. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Experimentally, signatures of edge mode transport have been observed in several of the candidate materials, such as HgTe/CdTe quantum wells19 , InAs/GaSb bilayers20, WTe2 21, bismuthene on SiC22 and Moir´e materials23. However, the experimental studies have also led to discrepancies with the simple theoretical models with protection length of the edge transport reaching only a few tens of nanometers in WTe2 21, a few micrometers in InAs/GaSb20 and a few tens of micrometers in HgTe/CdTe quantum wells24.

Figure Captions

Figure 1 shows the relativistic band structure of α-Sn using the tight-binding model reported in Table I Figure 4 illustrates the response of the bulk band structure around the Γ-point to tensile and compressive in-plane strain Figure 5 presents the phase diagram of a layered α-Sn system as a function of number of layers and bond polar angle Figure 6 shows the band structure of a slab with Nz = 10 and Nx = 80 with projections on surfaces Figure 7 displays the diamond-lattice Brillouin zone with marked 1D winding numbers calculated along different directions Figure 8 shows the band structure at k2 = π of unstrained and strained slabs with evolution from full to chiral Hamiltonian Figure 9 provides the local density of electrons across the unstrained slab for various in-gap states at k2 = π. The references cited are numbered 1 through 56, with specific citations noted throughout the text. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The color scale, explained on the right side, describes the projection of the spectral weight of each band at the left/right (left column) and top/bottom (right column) termination surfaces. The blue triangles, orange circles, and green squares denote specific in-gap states that will be examined later.

Table I

Table I presents first-nearest-neighbor tight-binding parameters for cubic diamond α-Sn compared with two previous sp3 s∗ tightbinding models It lists values for Es, Ep, λ, Vssσ, Vs∗s∗σ, Vspσ, Vs∗pσ and Vppπ. The parameters are given in eV. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Here, angular-momentum operators have a blockdiagonal structure Lα = L (s) ⊕ L (p) α with L (s) = 0 being the trivial angular momentum of the s orbital and L (p) α being L = 1 angular momentum of the p orbitals acting on the basis of cubic harmonics px, py and pz. The parameters Es, Ep, λ, Vssσ, Vppπ, Vssσ of the tight-binding Hamiltonian are given in Table I and have

Hamiltonian Equations

The full tight-binding Hamiltonian is written as Hθ(k) = 1/4⊗hA⃗θ⊗0 e ik30 0 0 + 1/4⊗hB⃗θ⊗0 e ik10 0 0 + 1/4⊗hC⃗θ⊗1i

and the atomic spin-orbit coupling term is H.c. + 1/4otimesEorb⊗12 + λXα=x,y,zσα⊗Lα⊗12. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Having established the orbital hopping matrices, we can write the full tightbinding Hamiltonian as: Hθ(k) = 12⊗hA⃗θ ⊗ 0 e ik3 0 0 + 12⊗hB⃗θ ⊗ 0 e ik1 0 0 (3) + 12⊗hC⃗θ ⊗ 0 1 0 0 + 12⊗hD⃗ θ ⊗ 0 e i(k3−k2) 0 0 + H. + 12⊗Eorb⊗12 + λ X α=x,y,z σα⊗Lα⊗12, where e ik1 , e ik2 and e ik3 are the eigenvalues of the lattice translation operators along lattice vectors ⃗n1, ⃗n2 and ⃗n3.

The angular momentum operators have a blockdiagonal structure Lα = L(s) ⊕ L(p)α with L(s) = 0 being the trivial angular momentum of the s orbital and L(p)α being L = 1 angular momentum of the p orbitals acting on the basis of cubic harmonics px, py and pz. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Finally, there is also an atomic spin-orbit coupling with amplitude λ, where σα describes electron spin and Lα its orbital degree of freedom. Here, angular-momentum operators have a blockdiagonal structure Lα = L (s) ⊕ L (p) α with L (s) = 0 being the trivial angular momentum of the s orbital and L (p) α being L = 1 angular momentum of the p orbitals acting on the basis of cubic harmonics px, py and pz.

The Hamiltonian H↑chir is clearly of the BDI class, so it can support a chiral Z invariant in three dimensions or weaker chiral Z invariants (winding numbers) living in the 1D cuts of 3D BZ. p. 5
Where the paper says it

as well as: q (1) k = 1 + e ik1 + e ik3 + e i(k3−k2) , q (2) k = −1 + e ik1 + e ik3 − e i(k3−k2) , q (3) k = −1 + e ik1 − e ik3 + e i(k3−k2) , q (4) k = 1 + e ik1 − e ik3 − e i(k3−k2) . (12) The Hamiltonian H ↑ chir is clearly of the BDI class, so it can support a chiral Z invariant in three dimensions or weaker chiral Z invariants (winding numbers) living in the 1D cuts of 3D BZ.

The Hamiltonian H↑chir is given by H↑chir(k) = 0 uk u† k0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Additionally, since we have turned off the spin-orbit coupling, the spin channels are now decoupled, so we can consider only the spin-up Hamiltonian. Thus, we have: H ↑ chir(k) = 0 uk u † k 0 , (9) where uk =   q (1) k Vssσ q (2) k V √spσ 3 −q (3) k V √spσ 3 −q (4) k V √spσ 3 −q (2) k V √spσ 3 q (1) k V+ 3 q (4) k V− 3 q (3) k V− 3 q (3) k V √spσ 3 q (4) k V− 3 q (1) k V+ 3 −q (2) k V− 3 q (4) k V √spσ 3 q (3) k V− 3 −q (2) k V− 3 q (1) k V+ 3   , (10) and V+ = 2Vppπ + Vppσ, V− = Vppπ − Vppσ, (11) FIG.

The Hamiltonian V+ = 2Vppπ + Vppσ, V− = Vppπ − Vppσ. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Additionally, since we have turned off the spin-orbit coupling, the spin channels are now decoupled, so we can consider only the spin-up Hamiltonian. Thus, we have: H ↑ chir(k) = 0 uk u † k 0 , (9) where uk =   q (1) k Vssσ q (2) k V √spσ 3 −q (3) k V √spσ 3 −q (4) k V √spσ 3 −q (2) k V √spσ 3 q (1) k V+ 3 q (4) k V− 3 q (3) k V− 3 q (3) k V √spσ 3 q (4) k V− 3 q (1) k V+ 3 −q (2) k V− 3 q (4) k V √spσ 3 q (3) k V− 3 −q (2) k V− 3 q (1) k V+ 3   , (10) and V+ = 2Vppπ + Vppσ, V− = Vppπ − Vppσ, (11) FIG.

The Hamiltonian Hθ(k) is given by (3). p. 2
Where the paper says it

This angle decreases in the case of compressive strain and increases in the case of tensile strain. Having established the orbital hopping matrices, we can write the full tightbinding Hamiltonian as: Hθ(k) = 12⊗hA⃗θ ⊗ 0 e ik3 0 0 + 12⊗hB⃗θ ⊗ 0 e ik1 0 0 (3) + 12⊗hC⃗θ ⊗ 0 1 0 0 + 12⊗hD⃗ θ ⊗ 0 e i(k3−k2) 0 0 + H.

The substitution for Cartesian quasimomenta is k1 = kx + ky, k2 = ky − kx, and k3 = ky + kz. p. 2
Where the paper says it

+ 12⊗Eorb⊗12 + λ X α=x,y,z σα⊗Lα⊗12, where e ik1 , e ik2 and e ik3 are the eigenvalues of the lattice translation operators along lattice vectors ⃗n1, ⃗n2 and ⃗n3. To work with Cartesian quasimomenta, we can use a substitution k1 = kx + ky, k2 = ky − kx, k3 = ky + kz.

Conclusion Summary

The situation with the edge-state here is similar to the one encountered in the HgTe/CdTe quantum wells The presence of the Z2 invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number makes the present system one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed. The transition from a Dirac semimetal to the QSH phase when the system’s dimensionality is reduced, from three to two, could also be realized in other material systems. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The presence of the Z2 invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number makes the present system one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed. The transition from a Dirac semimetal to the QSH phase when the system’s dimensionality is reduced, from three to two, could also be realized in other material systems.

The authors identify PtSe2 and PtTe2 as promising candidates to host the QSH phase in van der Waals materials. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In this context, we identify PtSe2 and PtTe2 (space group No. 164) as promising candidates to host the QSH phase.

References List

The references are listed from 1 to 56, including those cited in the text <ref:2511.23289#pg5>, <ref:2511.23289#pg4>, and others. The full list is provided in the acknowledgments section. p. 4

Where the paper says it

, Hchir(k) = Hθ0 (k, Ep = Es, λ = 0) − Es116. (7) Note that in this Section, we will focus on the unstrained case of θ = θ0 for the sake of simplicity, but the reasoning

The paper cites works on topological insulators, quantum spin Hall effect, and related material properties such as SnTe. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Fern´andez Becerra, and Timo Hyart, “Interplay of quantum spin Hall effect and spontaneous time-reversal symmetry breaking in electron-hole bilayers. transport properties,” Phys.

The references are numbered 40 through 56 in the provided text context. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Since thickness-dependent investigation of α-Sn poses experimental challenges, similar physics might be more accessible in van der Waals materials, where exfoliation techniques can be readily applied. In this context, we identify PtSe2 and PtTe2 (space group No.

Page References

The content is distributed across pages 1 through 6 of the provided document The page numbers are explicitly labeled as --- Page N --- for each section. The text on Page 7 and Page 8 also contain relevant information. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We use the parameters Vppσ and Vppπ from the literature45. We finally produce our tight-binding by renormalizing Vspσ and fitting the experimental information that the conduction band at the L-point is 100 meV above the Fermi level9 .

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can predict topological phase transitions in multi-layer alpha-Sn as a function of strain and layer number by utilizing the derived topological phase diagram (Fig 5). This allows for rapid identification of conditions leading to non-trivial quantum spin Hall states.

  2. The improved system can simulate the microscopic origin of edge states by analyzing winding numbers, specifically identifying how different numbers of flat bands at different terminations support additional surface states as described in the text.

  3. The AI can determine if an observed edge state is a result of a rigorous topological invariant or a phenomenon arising from lower symmetry limits, such as the reconstruction of the charge density at the edges or mirror Chern numbers.

  4. The system can predict which specific edge states are localized at hinges by analyzing their spatial projections, distinguishing between states that join flat bands and those that remain at finite energy due to mirror Chern numbers.

Abstract

We formulate the tight-binding model for cubic α-Sn based on the DFT calculations. In the model, we incorporate a variable bond angle, which allows us to simulate the effect of the in-plane strain. In the bulk, we demonstrate the presence of the Z 2 topological invariant and a non-zero mirror Chern number, making α-Sn one of the rare cases where dual topology can be observed. We calculate the topological phase diagram of multi-layer α-Sn as a function of strain and number of layers. We find that a non-trivial quantum spin Hall state appears only for compressive strain above five layers of thickness. Quite surprisingly, both in the trivial and non-trivial phases, we find a plethora of edge-states with energies inside the bulk gap of the system. Some of these states are localized at the side surfaces of the slab and some of them prefer top/bottom surfaces. We find that they can be adiabatically connected to topological states in the chiral limit, where the model supports multiple one-dimensional winding numbers that take different values in different directions in the Brillouin zone. Finally, around high-symmetry points their presence can also be explained by the mirror Chern number and Wilson-loop invariants

Sources

Related papers