Comparative evaluation of future collider options

arXiv:2511.20417 · physics.acc-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2025-11-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Comparative evaluation of future collider options".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. This report presents a comparative evaluation of proposed future collider projects submitted as input for the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), focusing on options that could realistically become operational at CERN between 2045 and 2050.

Kai: The evaluation considers several main criteria: main parameters and performance, environmental aspects, technical readiness, accelerator and experiments construction and installation costs (material costs), accelerator construction and installation human resources, project timeline, and operation material/personnel costs.

Mira: The analysis compares several key e+e- collider proposals at CERN: Compact Linear Collider (CLIC): Proposed with an initial configuration operating at a center-of-mass energy of 380 GeV, with potential upgrades to 1.5 TeV.

Kai: Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee): A luminosity-frontier machine spanning energies from below the Z pole up to beyond the top-pair production threshold, evolving into a hadron collider (FCC-hh).

Title and authors: Kai: We’re starting with the title and who wrote this, "Comparative evaluation of future collider options." It really frames what we're looking at right now.

Mira: The authors are a group of domain experts, including project leaders from various accelerator groups across Europe. That shows it’s not just one person dreaming up a machine.

Lev: I wonder if the team composition reflects the different challenges involved; you have people focused on hardware, theory, and error correction all in one place.

Kai: Exactly. You’ve got Kai here looking at superconducting qubits and cryogenics, which means he’s thinking about what can actually be built and kept cool at this scale.

Mira: And Mira is the condensed-matter theorist; she’s going to be poking at the assumptions behind those performance numbers, making sure they are physically sound.

Lev: I'm focused on error correction for real hardware, so I’ll be looking at how much overhead that theoretical stuff adds when we try to actually run these complex systems.

Kai: So what this means is we need to look at the machine from three angles: can it be built, can it work theoretically, and can it handle the engineering reality.

Mira: It sets a baseline for judging future proposals by applying a consistent set of standards across all potential machines.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now let’s talk about what the paper actually summarizes in its main body. It boils down to comparing three primary e plus minus collider proposals against each other.

Mira: They focus heavily on the Compact Linear Collider, which is a lower energy setup, and then the Future Circular Collider, which evolves into a hadron machine later on.

Lev: And they also include the Linear Collider Facility design based on bulk niobium superconducting radiofrequency cavities operating at one point three gigahertz and an accelerating gradient of thirty-one point five mega volt per meter.

Kai: So they are looking at different types of colliders, spanning from pure electron-positron machines to those that might become massive proton or ion colliders.

Mira: The summary emphasizes the timeline aspect because it’s all tied into what CERN is planning after the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider finishes around two thousand forty-one <ref:2511.20417#pg1>.

Lev: They mention scenarios like reusing parts from the existing LHC tunnel, which is a practical consideration for cost and schedule, but that introduces significant technical risk.

Kai: So the core message here is that we aren't just looking at one perfect machine; we have a set of options to evaluate based on defined constraints.

The paper's improvements: Mira: The paper suggests improvements by setting up this comparative evaluation using standardized criteria. That means they are trying to move away from just listing machines and toward a true decision-making tool.

Lev: I see them suggesting a way to map the technical readiness level, or TRL, of individual components against these criteria. That should help us spot where the highest technical risk lies in any given proposal.

Kai: That’s important because if you know which technology is immature, you can prioritize R andD efforts there instead of guessing.

Mira: They also seem to be proposing a way to estimate the electricity consumption for these colliders, using data from tables like two point one one, which gives us a concrete sense of the environmental footprint.

Lev: Calculating that power consumption in terms of gigagrams of carbon dioxide equivalent per year is a necessary step because energy use scales directly with the machine’s beam power.

Kai: And they're providing comparative cost estimates for baseline designs, aggregating data from tables like three point seven through three point nine, so we can see the money side of things clearly.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up, the paper’s main implication is that balancing ambition with realism is critical when planning these massive projects for the next few decades. It forces a focus on what’s achievable by two thousand forty-five or two thousand fifty <ref:2511.20417#pg1>.

Kai: It really puts the different options—CLIC, FCC-ee, LCF—into a direct conversation about their maturity versus their potential payoff.

Lev: From my side, it highlights that the Muon Collider remains in an early stage because it’s still heavily reliant on substantial research and development before we can even talk about building anything real.

Mira: And they mention new accelerator techniques like high field magnets and plasma wakefield acceleration as ways to potentially push performance limits beyond the baseline designs.

Kai: It’s a good roadmap for where we need to be looking in terms of technology maturation if CERN is going to meet these long-term goals.

Lev: I just want to emphasize that their assessment points out that the project timeline itself is a major constraint, and you have to plan for the time it takes just to get components into series production.

Mira: So, in short, this paper gives us a structured way to see what's on the table now versus what's still years away. That’s how we can frame our next discussions.

CERN · University of Freiburg

physics.acc-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2025-11-25

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 86 pages, 10 figures. Report from the Future Colliders Comparative Evaluation Working Group. Input to the European Strategy for Particle Physics (2026 Update), ID 281 - see https://indico.cern.ch/event/1439855/contributions/6542430/

Journal ref: Comparative evaluation of future collider options, Future Colliders Comparative Evaluation Working Group. CERN Yellow Reports: Monographs, CERN-2025-011 (CERN, Geneva, 2025)

DOI: 10.23731/CYRM-2025-0011

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: This report presents a comparative evaluation of proposed future collider projects submitted as input for the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP)…

Key concepts

Compact Linear Collider (CLIC)
A proposed linear collider concept designed to operate at a center-of-mass energy of 380 GeV initially, with potential upgrades up to 1.5 TeV. The report assesses its technical maturity and construction timeline relative to other options.
Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee)
A large, integrated machine planned for CERN that evolves from a lepton collider (FCC-ee) into a hadron collider (FCC-hh). It spans energies from below the Z pole up to energies beyond top-pair production, suggesting a long operational timeline starting in the mid-2040s.
Technical Readiness Level (TRL)
A measure used to assess how mature or developed a specific accelerator component is. The report uses this concept, referencing tables like Table A.3, to identify which technologies pose the highest technical risk for each project.
Project Timeline Phases
The stages a project goes through, such as Exploratory studies, the Conceptual Design Review (CDR), and Feasibility Report readiness dates. Mapping these phases helps determine the 'technical-limited timescale' needed to move components into series production.

Terminology

Summary

This report presents a comparative evaluation of proposed future collider projects submitted as input for the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), focusing on options that could realistically become operational at CERN between 2045 and 2050. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This group brings together project leaders and domain experts to conduct a consistent evaluation of the Future Circular Collider (FCC) and alternative scenarios based on shared assumptions and standardized criteria. This report presents a comparative evaluation of proposed future collider projects submitted as input for the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics.

The evaluation considers several main criteria: main parameters and performance, environmental aspects, technical readiness, accelerator and experiments construction and installation costs (material costs), accelerator construction and installation human resources, project timeline, and operation material/personnel costs. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The information presented here is based on the content of the proposals submitted to the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPPU) 2026. The following main criteria have been considered for the comparative evaluation of the proposals (CLIC, FCC-ee and LCF) for first phase e + e − colliders at CERN and are described in Section 2: – main parameters and performance; – environmental aspects; – technical readiness; – accelerator and experiments construction and installation: material costs; – accelerator construction and installation: human resources; – project timeline; – operation: material and personnel costs.

The analysis compares several key e+e- collider proposals at CERN:

  • Compact Linear Collider (CLIC): Proposed with an initial configuration operating at a center-of-mass energy of 380 GeV, with potential upgrades to 1.5 TeV.

  • Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee): A luminosity-frontier machine spanning energies from below the Z pole up to beyond the top-pair production threshold, evolving into a hadron collider (FCC-hh).

  • Linear Collider Facility (LCF): Proposed with a design identical to the ILC, based on bulk-Niobium SRF cavities operating at 1.3 GHz with an accelerating gradient of 31. p. 8

    Where the paper says it

    The technical readiness of CLIC, FCC-ee and LCF are comparable, though LCF benefits of the developments and industrialization effort conducted for the 1. 3 GHz Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities for the DESY European X-Ray Free-Electron Laser Facility (EU-XFEL) and SLAC Linac Coherent Light Source II (LCLS–II) projects and therefore has an overall higher Technology Readiness Level (TRL) as compared to the other two proposals.

    5 MV m−1.

Other major concepts discussed include:

  • FCC-hh: A hadron collider planned in the FCC-ee tunnel, aiming for a center-of-mass energy of at least 85 TeV.

  • Muon Collider (MC): Scenarios with maximum c.o.m. energies up to 7. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Differently from Linear Colliders (LCs), energy loss due to synchrotron radiation limits the maximum energy realistically achievable by circular colliders to the t¯t threshold. Circular colliders can naturally accommodate a larger number of Interaction Points (IPs) and their larger repetition rate (determined by the revolution frequency in the kHz range) allow them to provide significantly higher integrated luminosities per unit of energy consumption than LCs up to energies of 300 to 350 GeV (see Fig.

    6 TeV are under consideration, potentially reusing existing SPS and LHC tunnels. p. 9
    Where the paper says it

    6 TeV have been developed for CERN. The MC injectors would be installed in SPS and LHC tunnels.

  • Options Reusing the LHC Tunnel: This includes proposals like the Large Hadron-electron Collider (LHeC), which would use a new 3-turn high-current Energy Recovery Linac (ERL) to collide an intense electron beam with a proton or ion beam from the HL-LHC, targeting a c.o.m. energy of 1. p. 2

    Where the paper says it

    ch December 19th, 2025 Abstract In anticipation of the completion of the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) programme by the end of 2041, CERN is preparing to launch a new major facility in the mid-2040s. According to the 2020 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), the highest-priority next collider is an electron–positron Higgs factory, followed in the longer term by a hadron–hadron collider at the highest achievable energy.

    18 TeV in the LHC IP2, and the High-Energy Large Hadron Collider (HE-LHC), limited to a maximum c. p. 2
    Where the paper says it

    ch December 19th, 2025 Abstract In anticipation of the completion of the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) programme by the end of 2041, CERN is preparing to launch a new major facility in the mid-2040s. According to the 2020 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), the highest-priority next collider is an electron–positron Higgs factory, followed in the longer term by a hadron–hadron collider at the highest achievable energy.

    o.m. energy of 34 TeV using High Field Magnets (HFM) magnets in the existing tunnel structure, which falls short of a 10 TeV pCM goal. p. 9
    Where the paper says it

    energy of at least 85 TeV, extending the physics discovery potential by an order of magnitude in the 10 TeV parton center-of-momentum (pCM) energy range. The FCC-hh baseline assumes 14 T magnets which are close to the state of the art of Nb3Sn technology.

The report highlights that while the technical readiness levels for CLIC, FCC-ee, and LCF are comparable, project timelines vary significantly; for instance, CLIC has an extended construction phase to avoid conflicts with HL-LHC operation. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The information presented here is based on the content of the proposals submitted to the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPPU) 2026. The following main criteria have been considered for the comparative evaluation of the proposals (CLIC, FCC-ee and LCF) for first phase e + e − colliders at CERN and are described in Section 2: – main parameters and performance; – environmental aspects; – technical readiness; – accelerator and experiments construction and installation: material costs; – accelerator construction and installation: human resources; – project timeline; – operation: material and personnel costs.

Cost estimates are provided for baseline designs in 2024 MCHF prices. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Though significant progress has been made in the stabilization algorithms and in the start-to-end simulations, IP spot size control and pulse-to-pulse beam position stability remain the main challenges for LCs. The cost estimates for the three projects (see Tables 3.

The FCC integrated programme suggests a sequential implementation of FCC-ee followed by FCC-hh, with operation potentially spanning from the mid-2040s onward. p. 2
Where the paper says it

ch December 19th, 2025 Abstract In anticipation of the completion of the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) programme by the end of 2041, CERN is preparing to launch a new major facility in the mid-2040s. According to the 2020 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), the highest-priority next collider is an electron–positron Higgs factory, followed in the longer term by a hadron–hadron collider at the highest achievable energy.

The Muon Collider remains at an early stage due to substantial R&D needs.

The report also reviews new accelerator techniques such as high field magnets, plasma wakefield acceleration (PWFA), and superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) systems. p. 6

Where the paper says it

– The Muon Collider (MC) study, supported by international collaborations including the International Muon Collider Collaboration (IMCC) and the EU-funded MuCol Consortium, which is investigating the potential of this novel approach. – Participation in a wide-ranging European accelerator R&D programme, targeting technologies such as High Field Magnet (HFM), Plasma Wakefield Accelerator (PWFA) (via the Advanced Proton Driven Plasma Wakefield Acceleration Experiment—AWAKE), Superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) systems, and to a lesser extent Energy Recovery Linacs (ERLs).

International options are also presented, including the CEPC in China (a 100 km collider with energies up to 360 GeV), the ILC in Japan (a linear collider from 250 GeV to 1 TeV), and LEP3, which could reuse the LEP tunnel for a Higgs factory. p. 2
Where the paper says it

These proposals are compared considering main performance parameters, environmental impact and sustainability, technical maturity, cost of construction and operation, required human resources, and realistic implementation timelines. An overview of the international collider projects within a similar timeframe, notably the CEPC in China and the ILC in Japan is also presented, as well as a short review of the status and prospects of new accelerator techniques.

In summary, the report concludes that given the differing levels of maturity across proposals, it aims to present a comparative evaluation of projects realistically operational by 2045–2050. p. 6

Where the paper says it

To meet this timeline, key decisions and initial resource commitments must occur between 2028 and 2030. Given the differing levels of maturity across various proposals, this report aims to present a comparative evaluation of collider projects that could realistically be operational by 2045–2050.

It stresses that balancing ambition with realism is critical due to strategic constraints on CERN's ability to pursue other long-term options.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Advanced feasibility assessment for future collider options using standardized criteria can be performed by an AI system to compare projects based on main performance parameters, environmental impact and sustainability, technical maturity, cost of construction and operation, required human resources, and realistic implementation timelines.

  2. The AI system can analyze the technical readiness level (TRL) of accelerator components by referencing tables like Table A.3 in Appendix A.2 to identify which technologies are the highest technical risk for a given project proposal.

  3. The system can calculate estimated annual electricity consumption for proposed colliders based on projected operation energy and beam power, using the Carbon intensity of electricity generation data from Table 2.1 to provide a range of values in g CO2 eq./y.

  4. The AI can generate comparative cost estimates for different collider options, such as CLIC, FCC-ee, and LCF by aggregating data from tables like Table 3.7 through Table 3.9 in terms of MCHF and cost classes.

  5. The system can map project timelines to identify the technical-limited timescale required for bringing components to series production or the Project timeline phases, such as Exploratory studies, CDR, and Feasibility Report readiness dates.

Abstract

In anticipation of the completion of the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) programme by the end of 2041, CERN is preparing to launch a new major facility in the mid-2040s. According to the 2020 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP), the highest-priority next collider is an electron-positron Higgs factory, followed in the longer term by a hadron-hadron collider at the highest achievable energy. The CERN directorate established a Future Colliders Comparative Evaluation working group in June 2023. This group brings together project leaders and domain experts to conduct a consistent evaluation of the Future Circular Collider (FCC) and alternative scenarios based on shared assumptions and standardized criteria. This report presents a comparative evaluation of proposed future collider projects submitted as input for the Update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics. These proposals are compared considering main performance parameters, environmental impact and sustainability, technical maturity, cost of construction and operation, required human resources, and realistic implementation timelines. An overview of the international collider projects within a similar timeframe, notably the CEPC in China and the ILC in Japan is also presented, as well as a short review of the status and prospects of new accelerator techniques.

Sources

Related papers