The Terrell-Penrose effect revisited and extended for black hole spacetime
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The Terrell-Penrose effect revisited and extended for black hole spacetime".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ray tracing for the Terrell-Penrose effect in black hole spacetime examines how aberration and gravity affect images of moving sources around black holes The study demonstrates that while both cases remain apparent shape of the sphere, the apparent distortions of the images are different, and case ii) violates conformality on the observer’s celestial sphere Methodology for Ray Tracing in Curved Spacetime The paper develops a ray-tracing simulation scheme for black hole spacetime, utilizing the Schwarzschild metric to describe gravity The 4-momentum of light is given by a specific formula derived from the metric For each image order, recent study analytically demonstrated that only one light ray connects the source and the observer The celestial coordinates can be defined with cos Φ0 sin Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(ϕ)⟩stc, sin Φ0 sin Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(θ)⟩stc and cos Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(r)⟩stc These coordinates are established for static observers in the black hole spacetime.
Kai: Analysis of Terrell-Penrose Effects The study examines two contrasting cases for the Terrell-Penrose effect: i) static emission sources in the view of a moving observer, and ii) moving emission sources in the view of a static observer In flat spacetime, it was believed that the images of the emission sources in these two cases are equivalent due to the relativity of motion However, case ii) violates conformality on the observer’s celestial sphere For case i), it is found that the conformal transformation induced by the aberration effect also holds in black hole spacetime, and is not restricted to observers in geodesic motion For case ii), gravity introduces additional influence on the snapshots of a moving source through the slow-light effect.
Mira: Distortions of Extended Sources The simulation numerically examines the optical appearance of the sphere, disk and jet in the view of moving observers For a moving observer, the apparent sizes of the sphere shrink, and apparent center is shifted, exhibiting an apparent rotation that has an upper limit as speed ς → 1 In contrast to results illustrated in Ref.
71: , the ‘rotation’ angle seems to have an upper limit as the speed ς → 1 For a face-on observer, the circle within the disk remains unchanged because of the conformal transformation in Eq.
Paper summary: Kai: So we've looked at what this paper "The Terrell-Penrose effect revisited and extended for black hole spacetime" is actually saying. It’s about taking the original Terrell-Penrose effect and extending it to black hole spacetime, examining how aberration and gravity affect images of sources around those objects.
Mira: The main thesis is that while both scenarios—static sources viewed by a moving observer, and moving sources viewed by a static observer—still maintain the general shape of the sphere, the apparent distortions they experience are actually different. Specifically, case two violates conformality on the observer's celestial sphere.
Lev: So it’s not just that they look different; it’s that one of those cases breaks a fundamental geometric rule about how light should transform when you move from one frame to another.
Kai: Right. And the paper explores this by developing a ray-tracing simulation scheme using the Schwarzschild metric to model gravity. The authors establish celestial coordinates for static observers in this spacetime, like cos Phi zero sin Psi zero equals k, k of phi, t c sin Phi zero sin Psi zero equals k, k of theta, t c and cos Psi zero equals k, k of r.
Mira: They then analyze the effects by comparing case one—static emission sources viewed by a moving observer—and case two—moving emission sources viewed by a static observer. The paper notes that in flat spacetime, we used to think these two cases were equivalent because of the relativity of motion.
Lev: But they show that this equivalence doesn't hold when you introduce black hole gravity, and case two specifically violates conformality on the observer's celestial sphere >
Kai: And for case one, they find that the conformal transformation caused by the aberration effect still holds in black hole spacetime, even though it’s not restricted to observers moving on a geodesic path.
Mira: But then for case two, gravity brings in an additional influence on snapshots of a moving source through the slow-light effect. That's where the gravity really changes things compared to flat spacetime results.
Lev: The simulation part shows that when they examine extended sources like spheres, disks, and jets viewed by moving observers, the apparent sizes shrink and the center shifts with speed zeta, but they note there's an upper limit on that rotation as zeta goes to one.
Kai: They also point out a detail about a face-on observer where the circle inside the disk remains unchanged because of that conformal transformation mentioned in equation eleven which keeps circles on the observer's celestial sphere.
Mira: So, they are showing how gravity modifies those distortions compared to flat spacetime, moving beyond just what special relativity predicts for these simple setups.
Lev: This whole paper is setting up the framework by constructing the simulation scheme and deriving how gravity bends light in this specific spacetime setup >
Kai: It’s important to remember that they are focusing on two distinct distortion effects: the shape change from aberration, and a second effect called apparent lengthening due to slow-light in black hole spacetime.
Mira: They conclude by summarizing their findings regarding frame equivalence, stating that even in flat spacetime, the snapshots are inconsistent between those two cases because of the observer's celestial sphere definition.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper "The Terrell-Penrose effect revisited and extended for black hole spacetime," it’s about how these effects change when you put gravity into the picture. It takes what we knew about moving sources in flat space and tests those ideas against the reality of a black hole environment.
Mira: The main takeaway is that the snapshots are inconsistent between case one and case two, even in flat spacetime, because the observer's celestial sphere isn't just a simple concept from an inertial frame. They show this by extending Terrell-Penrose to include gravity.
Lev: Essentially, they confirm that the aberration formula derived from reference light rays is consistent with what you get from a local Lorentz transformation, which is important for how we build models that need to be robust across different physical settings >
Kai: So what this means for us is that when we are modeling phenomena near black holes, we can't just rely on flat spacetime approximations without accounting for the gravitational distortion on the image itself.
Mira: It’s about acknowledging that gravity introduces effects like slow-light that suppress apparent lengthening and shifts the dynamics compared to what you see in flat space.
Lev: For us, as engineers building error correction hardware, this means our models need to account for these frame differences when designing systems meant to handle those extreme gravitational scenarios >
Qing-Hua Zhu
School of Physics, Chongqing University
gr-qc
Submitted: 2025-11-12
Updated: 2026-10-29
Comments: v2: 28 pages, 11 figures, accepted version for CQG
Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 43 205027 (2026)
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Ray tracing for the Terrell-Penrose effect in black hole spacetime examines how aberration and gravity affect images of moving sources around black holes The study demonstrates that while both cases…
Key concepts
- Terrell-Penrose Effect
- This effect describes how the appearance of an object changes when viewed by a moving observer near a massive object like a black hole. The paper compares two scenarios: static sources viewed by a moving observer versus moving sources viewed by a static observer, showing they yield different visual results.
- Schwarzschild Metric
- This is the mathematical description used to model the curved spacetime around a non-rotating, uncharged black hole. It provides the framework for calculating how gravity affects light paths and the resulting images of distant sources.
- Conformality Violation
- Conformality relates to how geometric properties are preserved under transformation. The paper finds that in case ii) (moving sources viewed by a static observer), this property is violated on the observer's celestial sphere, indicating a fundamental difference between flat spacetime and black hole spacetime.
- Slow-Light Effect
- In strong gravitational fields, light rays experience an additional influence known as the slow-light effect. This phenomenon is crucial in case ii) where gravity modifies the snapshots of a moving source, leading to specific apparent lengthening features.
Terminology
Summary
Ray tracing for the Terrell-Penrose effect in black hole spacetime examines how aberration and gravity affect images of moving sources around black holes The study demonstrates that while both cases remain apparent shape of the sphere, the apparent distortions of the images are different, and case ii) violates conformality on the observer’s celestial sphere
Methodology for Ray Tracing in Curved Spacetime
The paper develops a ray-tracing simulation scheme for black hole spacetime, utilizing the Schwarzschild metric to describe gravity The 4-momentum of light is given by a specific formula derived from the metric For each image order, recent study analytically demonstrated that only one light ray connects the source and the observer The celestial coordinates can be defined with cos Φ0 sin Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(ϕ)⟩stc, sin Φ0 sin Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(θ)⟩stc and cos Ψ0 ≡ ⟨k, k(r)⟩stc These coordinates are established for static observers in the black hole spacetime.
Analysis of Terrell-Penrose Effects
The study examines two contrasting cases for the Terrell-Penrose effect: i) static emission sources in the view of a moving observer, and ii) moving emission sources in the view of a static observer In flat spacetime, it was believed that the images of the emission sources in these two cases are equivalent due to the relativity of motion However, case ii) violates conformality on the observer’s celestial sphere For case i), it is found that the conformal transformation induced by the aberration effect also holds in black hole spacetime, and is not restricted to observers in geodesic motion For case ii), gravity introduces additional influence on the snapshots of a moving source through the slow-light effect.
Distortions of Extended Sources
The simulation numerically examines the optical appearance of the sphere, disk and jet in the view of moving observers For a moving observer, the apparent sizes of the sphere shrink, and apparent center is shifted, exhibiting an apparent rotation that has an upper limit as speed ς → 1 In contrast to results illustrated in Ref. [71], the ‘rotation’ angle seems to have an upper limit as the speed ς → 1 For a face-on observer, the circle within the disk remains unchanged because of the conformal transformation in Eq. p. 7 (11) which preserves circles on the observer’s celestial sphere. p. 7
Influence of Gravity on Apparent Lengthening
In black hole spacetime, concepts like a rigid surface are ambiguous, leading to a focus on the apparent lengthening from the slow-light effect In flat spacetime, the apparent rotation in moving sources is not consistent with a conformal transformation In black hole spacetime, gravity suppresses the apparent lengthening as shown in the right panels of Fig. 9 Gravity affects the apparent distance between separate points, suggesting it can produce characteristic features in temporal images The covariant 3-speed ς is suggested as the physically relevant quantity for relating distortion to gravity. p. 1
Conclusion on Frame Equivalence
The snapshots of emission sources are inconsistent between the two cases, even in flat spacetime This discrepancy arises because the observer’s celestial sphere differs conceptually from conventional inertial frames The study presents a tentative extension for the Terrell-Penrose effect to black hole spacetime, showing that the aberration formula derived based on reference light rays is consistent with that obtained from local Lorentz transformation.
Acknowledgments
This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grants No. 12305073 and No. 12347101 The author thanks Prof. Hongbao Zhang and Dr. Jie Zhu for useful discussions. p. 0
References
[1] K. Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 875, L1 (2019), arXiv:1906. p. 011238
[2] K. Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 930, L12 (2022), arXiv:2311. p. 008680
[3] K. Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 910, L13 (2021), arXiv:2105. p. 001173
[4] J. P. Luminet, Astron. Astrophys. 75, 228 (1979)
[5] M. Jaroszynski and A. Kurpiewski, Astron. Astrophys. 326, 419 (1997), arXiv:astro-ph/9705044
[6] G. S. Bisnovatyi-Kogan and O. Y. Tsupko, Phys. Rev. D 105, 064040 (2022), arXiv:2201. p. 001716
[7] T. Igata, M. Omamiuda, and Y. Takamori, Phys. Rev. D 111, 084062 (2025), arXiv:2502. p. 011755
[8] P. L. B. de S´a, H. C. D. Lima, Jr., C. A. R. Herdeiro, and L. C. B Crispino, Phys Rev D 110, 104047 (2024), arXiv:2406-02695
[9] J. M. Bardeen, in Les Houches Summer School of Theoretical Physics: Black Holes (1973) pp. p. 0 215–240
[10] P. V. P Cunha, C A R Herdeiro, E Radu, and H F Runarsson, Phys Rev Lett 115, 211102 (2015), arXiv:1509-00021
[14] I I C¸imdiker, A Ovg¨un, and D Demir, Class. Quant. Grav. 40, 184001 (2023), arXiv:2308-03947
[15] G J Olmo, J L Rosa, D Rubiera-Garcia, and D Saez-Chillon Gomez, Class. Quant. Grav. 40, 174002 (2023), arXiv:2302-12064
[16] Y.-X Huang, S Guo, Y.-H Cui, Q.-Q Jiang, and K Lin, Phys. Rev. D 107, 123009 (2023), arXiv:2311-00302
[17] F Di Filippo, Phys. Rev. D 110, 084026 (24)arXiv:24-07357
[18] H Falcke, F Melia, and E Agol, Astrophys. J. Lett. 528, L13 (2000), arXiv:astro-ph/9912263
[19] Y Mizuno, Z Younsi, C M Fromm, O Porth, M De Laurentis, H Olivares, H Falcke, M Kramer, and L Rezzolla, Nature Astron. 2 (2018), arXiv:1804-05812
[20] Z Chang and Q.-H Zhu, Phys. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Rev. D 102, 044012 (26)arXiv:26-0685
[21] T Bronzwaer and H Falcke, Astrophys. J. 920, 155 (2021), arXiv:2108-03966
[27] K.-G Lim and X Y Chew, Phys. Rev. D 111, 084085 (25)arXiv:25-07029
[28] X Wang, Z Zhao, X.-X Zeng, and X.-Y Wang, Phys. Rev. D 111, 084054 (25)arXiv:25-08287
[36] Z Li and C Bambi, Phys. Rev. D 90, 024071 (14)arXiv:14-05188
[37] Z Li, L Kong, and C Bambi, Astrophys. J. 787, 152 (2014), arXiv:1401-1282
[38] J a L Rosa, P Garcia, F H Vincent, and V Cardoso, Phys. Rev. D 106, 044031 (22)arXiv:22-05115
[39] J a L Rosa, D S J Cordeiro, C F B Macedo, and F S N Lobo, Phys. Rev. D 109, 084002 (24)arXiv:24-07766
[42] Q.-H Zhu, Phys. Rev. D 111, 044010 (25)arXiv:24-1193
[43] A Lupsasca, D Kapec, Y Shi, D E A Gates, and A Strominger, Proc Roy Soc Lond A 476, 20190618 (2020), arXiv:18-09092
[44] E Himwich, M D Johnson, A Lupsasca, and A Strominger, Phys. Rev. D 101, 084020 (26)arXiv:20-08750
[45] K Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 964, L25 (24)arXiv:astro-ph/HE
[46] K Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 910, L12 (21)arXiv:2105-01169
[47] Y Hou, J Huang, M Guo, Y Mizuno, and B Chen, Astrophys. J. Lett. 988, L51 (2025), arXiv:24-0907248
[48] Y Chen, L Cheng, P Wang, and H Yang, Phys Rev D 112, 024044 (25)arXiv:24-09-05304
[49] J L Rosa, N Aimar, and H L Tamm, Phys. Rev. D 111, 124036 (25)arXiv:25-04-02472
[50] K Akiyama et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 930, L15 (24)arXiv:2311-08697
[54] Q.-H Zhu, Phys. Rev. D 109, 064031 (24)arXiv:23-01-00913
[67] R Penrose, Proc Cambridge Phil Soc. 55, 137 (1959)
[68] J Terrell, Phys. Rev. 116, 1041 (1959)
[74] K S Virbhadra and G F R Ellis, Phys. Rev. D 62, 084003 (2000), arXiv:astro-ph/9904193
[78] E Gourgoulhon, Special Relativity in General Frames. From Particles to Astrophysics, Graduate Texts in Physics (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2013)
[79] J Terrell, Am. J. Phys. 57, 9 (1989)
[80] I D Novikov and K S Thorne, in Les Houches Summer School of Theoretical Physics: Black Holes (1973) pp. 343–550
Appendix Details
The infinitesimal transformations in Eqs. (C4) reduce to the complex plane where the l-1 can generate translations, and the real part and imagery part l0 can generate dilations and rotations around z = 1 The radial and axial directions have different scaling factors in ξ in black hole spacetime f!= 1 The aberration formula derived based on reference light rays is consistent with that obtained from local Lorentz transformation The relation between ∆L/L and the covariant 3-speed ς might be the physically relevant one. p. 6 The study demonstrates that gravity suppresses the apparent lengthening as shown in the right panels of Fig. p. 8 9 The aberration formula derived based on reference light rays is consistent with that obtained from local Lorentz transformation. p. 6 The relation between Eq. (D3) and Eq. (10) can be explicitly presented by setting V = -ωro sin θo/√fo
Appendix E Example
In the example for illustrating apparent lengthening influenced by gravity, the slow-light ray tracing shows that gravity significantly influences on the moving emission source. The left panel further verifies the robustness of the results in Fig. p. 9 6 This demonstrates that gravity has only slightly influences on the appearance of static emission source at different locations. p. 0
Figures
Fig. 1 shows a schematic diagram of imaging geometric objects onto projection plane Fig. p. 4 2 presents the optical appearance of sphere for low-mass and massive black holes with selected speed ς Fig. p. 7 3 shows the optical appearance of jets for low-mass and massive black holes Fig. p. 8 4 presents the optical appearance of disks for low-mass and massive black holes with selected inclination angles Fig. p. 8 8 shows images of the moving point sources in flat spacetime (middle panel) and in black hole spacetime (right panel) Fig. p. 9 9 presents relative variance of angular distances LAC and LBC as functions of the orbital speed for selected inclination angle Fig. 10 shows the schematic diagram of the infinitesimal vectors ξ(r), ξ(ϕ) and ξ(θ) on the complex plane Fig. p. 4 11 shows optical appearance of sphere and inclined and face-on accretion disk with respect to θ-motion observers Fig. p. 6 12 shows a schematic diagram of a sphere moving along the y-axis with constant speed ς in front of a black hole Fig. p. 9
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Accurate simulation of black hole images for moving sources by implementing slow-light ray tracing to capture
apparent lengthening
in curved spacetime, as described in Section IV B. This allows AI systems to generate physically consistent visual snapshots of accretion disks and jets under relativistic motion near black holes, which is crucial for interpreting Event Horizon Telescope data. -
Modeling the apparent distortion of moving spheres and disks by incorporating the conformal transformation derived from aberration effects in black hole spacetime, as shown in Section III A. This enables AI models to distinguish between cases i) static sources viewed by a moving observer and case ii) moving sources viewed by a static observer, providing a framework to analyze inconsistencies between flat spacetime predictions and gravitational reality.
-
Development of a tool for comparing inertial frames versus celestial sphere definitions by utilizing the covariant 3-speed as the
consistent choice of aberration formula in black hole spacetime,
as mentioned in Section V and Appendix D. This capability allows AI systems to evaluate whether an observed rotation is due to a local Lorentz transformation or a fundamental change in how time and space are defined by light reception. -
Analysis of non-uniform emission distributions by using the covariant 3-speed, s, to quantify the
apparent lengthening
effects on point sources in circular orbits, as detailed in Section IV B and Figure 9. This enables AI to predict the non-uniform concentration of corotating emissions seen by an observer in both flat and curved spacetimes.
Sources
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole
- First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole in the Center of the Milky Way
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. VIII. Magnetic Field Structure near The Event Horizon
- Optics near Kerr black holes: spectra of advection dominated accretion flows
- Analytical study of higher-order ring images of accretion disk around black hole
- Gravitational lensing and accretion disk imaging of a Buchdahl dense core
- Static boson stars in the Einstein-Friedberg-Lee-Sirlin theory and their astrophysical images
- Shadows of Kerr black holes with scalar hair
- Photon rings of spherically symmetric black holes and robust tests of non-Kerr metrics
- First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
- Rings and images of Horndeski hairy black hole illuminated by various thin accretions
- Thin accretion disk images of the black hole in symmergent gravity
- Shadows and photon rings of regular black holes and geonic horizonless compact objects
- Influence of accretion disk on the optical appearance of the Kazakov-Solodukhin black hole
- On the nature of inner light-rings
- Viewing the Shadow of the Black Hole at the Galactic Center
- The Current Ability to Test Theories of Gravity with Black Hole Shadows
- Does the shape of the shadow of a black hole depend on motional status of an observer?
- The Nature of Black Hole Shadows
- Can supermassive black hole shadows test the Kerr metric?
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals