Schwarzschild Spacetime and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity

arXiv:2509.20089 · gr-qc · Submitted 2025-09-24 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Schwarzschild Spacetime and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Schwarzschild spacetime constitutes an exact solution of the modified source-free gravitational field equations provided S is a constant The study investigates static spherically symmetric solutions within the framework of the local limit of nonlocal gravity, showing that Schwarzschild spacetime is a regular solution in the exterior region because scalar torsion invariants diverge on the horizon, thus ruling out its interpretation as a black hole Theoretical Framework The investigation begins by considering static and spherically symmetric solutions of the Schwarzschild spacetime and demonstrating that it is a regular solution in the exterior region of the modified theory because scalar torsion invariants diverge on the horizon, which excludes it as a black hole The local limit of nonlocal gravity is derived from tetrad formulation of General Relativity, introducing a Weitzenb¨ock connection and associated torsion tensor Cµνρ This framework allows for the expression of the Einstein tensor in terms of torsion fields, leading to the teleparallel equivalent of GR (TEGR) Local Limit and Nonlocality The connection between TEGR and nonlocal gravity (NLG) is established by analogy with nonlocal electrodynamics of media, where constitutive relations are generally nonlocal To render TEGR nonlocal, the field equation is modified by replacing Hµνρ with a term involving a nonlocality tensor Nµνρ, which incorporates a causal kernel K(x, x′) This nonlocality is expected to eliminate the 6-fold degeneracy inherent in TEGR and lead to a unique solution adapted to fundamental observers Modified Field Equations The modified gravitational field equation for metric (5) is derived by substituting the nonlocal terms into Einstein's field equations, resulting in 0Gµν + Λgµν = κTµν + Mµν In the static situation with a perfect fluid source, this equation reduces to a set of conditions that must be satisfied everywhere in space These conditions include (1 + S)T + 2 BB′S′ = κ ϱ + Λ, (71), and (1 + S) (R + S) + A′A+B′B'S' = 0, (72), and the equation involving pressure Schwarzschild Solution in the Local Limit By setting the energy density and pressure to zero, ϱ = p = Λ = 0, the field equations yield a simple result involving Eq.

Kai: (71), leading to a modified form of the Schwarzschild solution where A(r) and B(r) depend on a constant µS The resulting metric is given by ds2 = −1 − µS 2r−1 + µS 2r2 dt2 + 1 + µS 4 (dx2 + dy2 + dz2) This solution matches the standard GR result when S = 0, where µ = µ0 = GM/c2.

Mira: The three Weitzenb¨ock torsion invariants diverge on the event horizon for the Schwarzschild spacetime, which renders it a closed null hypersurface that is a naked singularity This suggests that black hole solutions in this framework are excluded due to the divergence of these invariants The QNMs of the corresponding Schwarzschild configuration will depend on the constant gravitational susceptibility S through the mass parameter M/(1 + S) The paper concludes by noting that in the local limit, black hole solutions are excluded due to these divergence issues.

Kai: Appendix Results The analysis of the interior Schwarzschild solution shows that it can be matched continuously with a modified exterior solution by replacing µ0 with µS and ρ with ρS The interior metric is found to be conformally flat, and the modified interior solution matches the modified exterior solution when S is a constant For constant S, the Oppenheimer-Snyder model goes over to NLG by modifying masses by dividing them by 1 + S The resulting solution is valid only to the extent that r > 2M, or G = a(T)R > 2 M The exterior and interior masses are found to be the same when matching the boundary conditions The closed FLRW model is a solution of NLG provided S is a constant, where density and pressure are modified by a factor of 1 + S The Oppenheimer-Snyder model goes over to the local limit of NLG when we simply modify masses by dividing them by 1 + S.

Title and authors: Kai: We're moving on to the title and authors for this paper, "Schwarzschild Spacetime and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity." I want to clarify who is doing the heavy lifting here.

Mira: The authors are Yahya Mohammadi, Javad Tabatabaei, Shant Baghram, and Bahram Mashhoon > They're all from different research centers in Iran and the US >

Lev: As an error correction researcher building hardware for real systems, I wonder how much of this work is purely theoretical versus something they could actually test on a chip >

Kai: That’s a fair question, Lev. The paper focuses heavily on deriving the field equations and showing the mathematical exclusion of black holes based on torsion invariants diverging at the horizon >

Mira: And that's where I want to press them. They introduce this nonlocal gravity concept by modifying the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity by replacing some terms with a nonlocality tensor N mu nu, which involves a causal kernel K of x and x prime >

Lev: A causal kernel sounds complicated for implementation. When we try to run something on real hardware, we need things that are well-behaved and don't have these kinds of complex memory dependencies across space >

Kai: Exactly. The authors suggest this nonlocality is supposed to eliminate a six-fold degeneracy inherent in the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity, leading to a solution adapted to fundamental observers >

Mira: That sounds promising if it actually simplifies things for the underlying physics, but we need to see if that simplification holds up when you introduce real physical sources >

Lev: It's interesting because they are trying to get away from some kind of ambiguity in how gravity works without having a full quantum theory attached yet >

Kai: So, the paper is setting up a framework where they can handle nonlocality without immediately diving into the full complexity of quantum field theory for now >

The paper's summary: Kai: Now, let’s talk about what they actually found in this paper. They summarize that they looked at static and spherically symmetric Schwarzschild spacetime and proved it’s a regular solution outside because some scalar torsion invariants diverge on the horizon >

Mira: That divergence is key; it means that even though it looks like a black hole, this theory suggests it shouldn't be one because those invariants blow up at the horizon >

Lev: So, they are essentially saying that the structure of spacetime itself prevents a singularity from forming where we expect one >

Kai: Right. They show how the Einstein tensor components in this modified framework are calculated using terms involving torsion fields like T, R, and S >

Mira: And specifically Eq. (ten) shows that S is defined by A double prime A plus B double prime B minus two A prime alpha squared minus B prime alpha squared plus one r alpha alpha plus B prime >

Lev: That equation looks really dense for someone trying to translate it into a simulation. What's the practical implication of solving that kind of relation for something like a black hole metric >

Kai: The practical implication is that when you plug in the Schwarzschild components, they don't vanish unless S is zero, which forces the solution back to standard general relativity >

Mira: And if S is non-zero, it means the geometry fundamentally changes near the horizon compared to what we see in GR >

Lev: So, for someone running simulations on real hardware or trying to model a gravitational collapse event, this suggests you have to account for this susceptibility S being present everywhere >

Kai: Which brings us back to the fact that they are using Cartesian coordinates in nonlocal gravity because the Schwarzschild metric is naturally expressed in those coordinates >

The paper's improvements: Mira: Let’s shift to the improvements they suggest for this framework. They point out that by introducing nonlocality, which they call a causal kernel K of x and x prime, you get away from the six-fold degeneracy in the teleparallel equivalent of GR >

Lev: That sounds like a big theoretical win if it actually simplifies things because those degeneracies are usually just mathematical noise when you're trying to find a physical solution >

Kai: If that nonlocality is what fixes those degeneracies, then it means the resulting solution should be much closer to what we expect from fundamental observers >

Mira: That's the goal; they want a unique solution adapted to fundamental observers, which implies a more physically grounded description of spacetime than just the basic teleparallel equivalent of GR >

Lev: For me, I need to see if this simplification actually translates into something that is computationally tractable for error correction codes >

Kai: That’s where the challenge lies. If they can simplify the mathematics, we get a better starting point for any numerical work, even if it's just theoretical modeling >

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on this paper about "Schwarzschild Spacetime and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity," the main implication is that in this local limit of nonlocal gravity, black hole solutions are excluded because of those divergence issues on the event horizon >

Kai: Yeah, and in terms of what this means for us, it suggests that black hole solutions as we know them might not be possible in this specific nonlocal gravity limit >

Lev: So, to summarize the paper "Schwarzschild Spacetime and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity," it excludes black holes because of those divergence issues on the event horizon >

Kai: We're done with this paper for now. It’s a lot to take in about how these nonlocal effects modify spacetime near extreme gravitational sources >

Department of Physics, Sharif University of Technology · Research Center for High Energy Physics, Department of Physics, Sharif University of Technology · School of Astronomy, Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM) · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Missouri

gr-qc

Submitted: 2025-09-24

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 26 pages; v2: presentation improved

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 1271 (2026)

DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-026-16523-0

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Schwarzschild spacetime constitutes an exact solution of the modified source-free gravitational field equations provided S is a constant The study investigates static spherically symmetric solutions…

Key concepts

Schwarzschild Spacetime
This is the standard mathematical description of the gravitational field around a non-rotating, spherically symmetric mass in General Relativity. The paper tests this known solution within a modified gravity framework to see how nonlocal effects change its properties.
Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity
This framework connects teleparallel gravity (a form of GR) to nonlocal electrodynamics. It introduces a nonlocality tensor Nmu nu, which modifies the standard field equations by incorporating causal kernels, aiming to eliminate degeneracies found in simpler theories and provide a unique solution.
Weitzenböck Torsion Invariants
These are mathematical measures derived from the torsion tensor in the tetrad formulation of gravity. The paper uses these invariants to analyze the Schwarzschild horizon; their divergence on the horizon suggests that black hole solutions cannot be interpreted in this specific nonlocal gravity model.

Terminology

Summary

Schwarzschild spacetime constitutes an exact solution of the modified source-free gravitational field equations provided S is a constant The study investigates static spherically symmetric solutions within the framework of the local limit of nonlocal gravity, showing that Schwarzschild spacetime is a regular solution in the exterior region because scalar torsion invariants diverge on the horizon, thus ruling out its interpretation as a black hole

Theoretical Framework

The investigation begins by considering static and spherically symmetric solutions of the Schwarzschild spacetime and demonstrating that it is a regular solution in the exterior region of the modified theory because scalar torsion invariants diverge on the horizon, which excludes it as a black hole The local limit of nonlocal gravity is derived from tetrad formulation of General Relativity, introducing a Weitzenb¨ock connection and associated torsion tensor Cµνρ This framework allows for the expression of the Einstein tensor in terms of torsion fields, leading to the teleparallel equivalent of GR (TEGR)

Local Limit and Nonlocality

The connection between TEGR and nonlocal gravity (NLG) is established by analogy with nonlocal electrodynamics of media, where constitutive relations are generally nonlocal To render TEGR nonlocal, the field equation is modified by replacing Hµνρ with a term involving a nonlocality tensor Nµνρ, which incorporates a causal kernel K(x, x′) This nonlocality is expected to eliminate the 6-fold degeneracy inherent in TEGR and lead to a unique solution adapted to fundamental observers

Modified Field Equations

The modified gravitational field equation for metric (5) is derived by substituting the nonlocal terms into Einstein's field equations, resulting in 0Gµν + Λgµν = κTµν + Mµν In the static situation with a perfect fluid source, this equation reduces to a set of conditions that must be satisfied everywhere in space These conditions include (1 + S)T + 2 BB′S′ = κ ϱ + Λ, (71), and (1 + S) (R + S) + A′A+B′B'S' = 0, (72), and the equation involving pressure

Schwarzschild Solution in the Local Limit

By setting the energy density and pressure to zero, ϱ = p = Λ = 0, the field equations yield a simple result involving Eq. (71), leading to a modified form of the Schwarzschild solution where A(r) and B(r) depend on a constant µS The resulting metric is given by ds2 = −1 − µS 2r−1 + µS 2r2 dt2 + 1 + µS 4 (dx2 + dy2 + dz2) This solution matches the standard GR result when S = 0, where µ = µ0 = GM/c2. p. 2

Where the paper says it

(4), Λ is the cosmological constant and Tµν is the energymomentum tensor of the gravitational source. Henceforth, we consider a general static and spherically symmetric metric of the form ds2 = − 1 A2 (r) dt2 + 1 B2 (r) (dx2 + dy2 + dz2 ).

Conclusion on Black Hole Interpretation

The three Weitzenb¨ock torsion invariants diverge on the event horizon for the Schwarzschild spacetime, which renders it a closed null hypersurface that is a naked singularity This suggests that black hole solutions in this framework are excluded due to the divergence of these invariants The QNMs of the corresponding Schwarzschild configuration will depend on the constant gravitational susceptibility S through the mass parameter M/(1 + S) The paper concludes by noting that in the local limit, black hole solutions are excluded due to these divergence issues.

Appendix Results

The analysis of the interior Schwarzschild solution shows that it can be matched continuously with a modified exterior solution by replacing µ0 with µS and ρ with ρS The interior metric is found to be conformally flat, and the modified interior solution matches the modified exterior solution when S is a constant For constant S, the Oppenheimer-Snyder model goes over to NLG by modifying masses by dividing them by 1 + S The resulting solution is valid only to the extent that r > 2M, or G = a(T)R > 2 M The exterior and interior masses are found to be the same when matching the boundary conditions The closed FLRW model is a solution of NLG provided S is a constant, where density and pressure are modified by a factor of 1 + S The Oppenheimer-Snyder model goes over to the local limit of NLG when we simply modify masses by dividing them by 1 + S. These results are valid only to the extent that r > 2M, or G = a(T)R > 2 M. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The resulting solution is eliminated as a black hole in Section VI. We conclude with a discussion of our results in Section VII.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve ability to analyze modified gravity solutions by incorporating nonlocal effects into standard black hole analyses, allowing for a prediction of quasinormal modes that depend on the constant gravitational susceptibility S through the mass parameter M/(1 + S).

  2. Enhance understanding of teleparallel gravity applications by explicitly mapping the connection between Einstein's field equations and Maxwell's equations for media, enabling predictions about how nonlocal constitutive relations modify gravitational field behavior.

  3. Increase capability in solving nonlinear partial integro-differential relations by applying the local limit approximation, specifically setting the causal kernel K(x, x') proportional to a Dirac delta function to derive simpler forms of the nonlocal tensor Nmu nu.

  4. Improve the derivation of modified gravitational field equations by systematically substituting metric components and torsion invariants derived from metric (5) into Eq. (63) to obtain explicit conditions for physical validity, such as equation (72).

  5. Develop a system capable of distinguishing between General Relativity and the local limit of nonlocal gravity by analyzing the divergence patterns of Weitzenb¨ock torsion invariants on the event horizon, which is noted to render it a naked singularity.

Abstract

We investigate static spherically symmetric solutions within the framework of the local limit of nonlocal gravity. This theory departs from Einstein's general relativity (GR) through the introduction of a scalar gravitational susceptibility function S(x), 1+S > 0, which is a new feature of the spacetime that vanishes in the GR limit. It is shown that the Schwarzschild spacetime constitutes an exact solution of the modified source-free gravitational field equations provided S is a constant. The mass of the corresponding Schwarzschild solution is given by M/(1+S), where M denotes the mass of the solution in the GR limit. The interpretation of the solution in terms of a black hole is ruled out due to the divergence of the algebraic invariants of the Weitzenböck torsion at the Schwarzschild horizon.

Sources

Related papers