Can you fall into a McVittie black hole? Will you survive?
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Can you fall into a McVittie black hole? Will you survive?".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Yes and maybe In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time More precisely: we consider expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant In each member of this class, we identify a region of the spacetime such that an observer following an initially-ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon of the spacetime in a finite amount of proper time The curvature behaves in interesting ways along these geodesics Existence of Geodesic Trajectories The paper establishes that freely-falling test particles in McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time.
Kai: This is a key finding, as it addresses whether extended test bodies can survive crossing the event horizon The authors consider expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant and identify a region where an observer following an initially-ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon in finite proper time.
Mira: Behavior of Curvature Invariants The study investigates the behavior of various curvature quantities along causal geodesics that meet the horizon, focusing on zero-, first-, and second-order invariants.
Kai: For a vanishing cosmological constant, zero- and first-order curvature scalars remain finite in the limit as the horizon is approached along ingoing radial null geodesics, but scalar curvature terms of second order diverge, and parallel propagated frame components of the curvature tensor also diverge.
Paper summary: Kai: So we just touched on this paper, "Can you fall into a McVittie black hole? Will you survive?". The main thing is that they prove freely falling test particles in McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time >
Mira: And they set up their proof by considering expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant, and they identify a specific region where an observer following an initially ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon in finite amount of proper time >
Lev: So, the focus is on this specific class of spacetimes with that cosmological constant. What's the bigger picture here for us right now?
Kai: It matters because it addresses whether extended test bodies can survive crossing the event horizon, which is a question that's been around for a while >
Mira: And the paper goes further by looking at how curvature behaves along those specific geodesics, focusing on zero-, first-, and second-order invariants >
Lev: So we're not just looking at the point of crossing; we're analyzing the geometry right as they get there, which is where the real physics happens >
Kai: Exactly. They find that for a vanishing cosmological constant, while zero and first-order curvature scalars are finite near the horizon along ingoing radial null geodesics, the second order curvature terms diverge and parallel propagated frame components of the curvature also diverge >
Mira: That divergence in second order terms is significant because it casts doubt on the usual interpretation that Jacobi fields are finite at the horizon meaning extended test bodies remain intact >
Lev: If those tidal forces blow up as suggested by Proposition four point one, even if some specific curvature components are finite, it means we have to re-evaluate what 'intact' means for a physical body > <ref:2509.18903#pg2>
Kai: So the paper argues that in the case of a vanishing cosmological constant, extended test bodies might survive the impact with the singularity because those tidal forces diverge but they are integrable >
Mira: It’s about finding this specific region in these expanding spacetimes where an observer crosses into that horizon in finite proper time and seeing what happens to the geometry along that path >
Lev: That means we're looking at a situation where the geometry is highly dynamic right near the boundary, which is what makes it interesting for error correction studies >
Kai: So, moving on from this summary, we need to talk about the title and authors of "Can you fall into a McVittie black hole? Will you survive?".
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this discussion on "Can you fall into a McVittie black hole? Will you survive?". The authors are Brien C Nolan from the Centre for Astrophysics and Relativity at Dublin City University >
Mira: And the implication here is that for McVittie black holes, specifically when the cosmological constant is zero, we can indeed fall into them in finite proper time >
Lev: So if you're listening and you only care about how this changes things for your world—say, if it's relevant to real hardware—what does that mean?
Kai: It means that even though the geometry gets complicated near the horizon, there might be a mechanism where an extended test body can survive crossing into the black hole >
Mira: That survival isn't guaranteed by just saying Jacobi fields are finite; it depends on those diverging tidal forces being integrable, which is a specific mathematical condition >
Lev: So what this means for engineering is that we can't assume complete destruction right at the horizon, but we still have to deal with these large, diverging stresses in our calculations for survival >
Kai: Right. The paper sets the stage by showing that you can fall into a McVittie black hole and then it immediately asks if you survive >
Mira: It's a study in how different mathematical measures of gravity—like zero-order versus second-order curvature invariants—behave in extreme spacetime environments >
Lev: And for the future, we need to keep digging into those diverging tidal forces to see exactly what kind of physical limits we’re dealing with >
Brien C. Nolan
Centre for Astrophysics and Relativity, School of Mathematical Sciences, Dublin City University
gr-qc
Submitted: 2025-09-23
Updated: 2025-11-24
Comments: 26 pages, one figure. To appear in CQG
Journal ref: Classical and Quantum Gravity, Volume 42, Number 23, (2025)
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 67/100
The gist: Yes and maybe In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity…
Key concepts
- McVittie Spacetime
- This is a specific type of spacetime model used in general relativity that describes a black hole solution, often involving an expanding universe with a non-negative cosmological constant. It serves as the background for testing how matter behaves near the black hole's event horizon.
- Proper Time
- Proper time is the time measured by an observer who is moving along a specific path through spacetime. In this context, it measures how much time elapses for an object that is freely falling toward the black hole, allowing researchers to determine if they reach the horizon in a finite amount of their own experienced time.
- Curvature Invariants
- These are mathematical quantities derived from the curvature of spacetime. The paper looks at zero-, first-, and second-order invariants to see how they behave as an observer approaches the black hole horizon, revealing how the spacetime geometry changes in that critical region.
Terminology
Summary
Yes and maybe In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time More precisely: we consider expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant In each member of this class, we identify a region of the spacetime such that an observer following an initially-ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon of the spacetime in a finite amount of proper time The curvature behaves in interesting ways along these geodesics
Existence of Geodesic Trajectories
The paper establishes that freely-falling test particles in McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time. This is a key finding, as it addresses whether extended test bodies can survive crossing the event horizon The authors consider expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant and identify a region where an observer following an initially-ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon in finite proper time. p. 0 More precisely: we consider expanding McVittie
spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant. In each member of this class,
we identify a region of the spacetime such that an observer following an initially-ingoing
timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon of the spacetime in a finite amount of
proper time.Where the paper says it
Behavior of Curvature Invariants
The study investigates the behavior of various curvature quantities along causal geodesics that meet the horizon, focusing on zero-, first-, and second-order invariants. For a vanishing cosmological constant, zero- and first-order curvature scalars remain finite in the limit as the horizon is approached along ingoing radial null geodesics, but scalar curvature terms of second order diverge, and parallel propagated frame components of the curvature tensor also diverge. p. 0 In the
case of a positive cosmological constant, curvature scalars (of zero, first and second
order in derivatives), Jacobi fields and parallel propagated (p. ) frame components
of the curvature remain finite along timelike geodesics running into the black hole
horizon.Where the paper says it
Tidal Forces and Survival
The analysis of Jacobi fields and tidal forces suggests that while zero- and first-order curvature terms are finite along timelike geodesics crossing the horizon, at least some tidal forces diverge as per Proposition 4.1. This divergence is integrable, which suggests that a small test body can survive the impact with the singularity in this scenario. p. 0 frame components of
the curvature tensor that also diverge in this limit. We argue that this casts a doubt
as to whether or not an extended test body can survive crossing the black hole horizon
in this case.Where the paper says it
Conclusions on McVittie Black Holes
The main result of this paper fills an important gap in the interpretation of McVittie spacetimes, confirming that one can indeed fall into a McVittie black hole In the case with a vanishing cosmological constant, zero- and first-order curvature scalars remain finite, but the second order term diverges along any causal geodesic running into the black hole horizon. Jacobi fields along a radial timelike geodesic remain finite, but at least some tidal forces diverge as per Proposition 4. p. 0 In the
case of a positive cosmological constant, curvature scalars (of zero, first and second
order in derivatives), Jacobi fields and parallel propagated (p. ) frame components
of the curvature remain finite along timelike geodesics running into the black hole
horizon.Where the paper says it
Appendix Details
The appendix provides the explicit expressions for the second-order curvature scalars, showing that the second order term diverges in the limit as the black hole horizon is approached along all causal geodesics. The coefficients of these terms are given by complex formulas involving polynomials in m/r. p. 0 ) frame components
of the curvature remain finite along timelike geodesics running into the black hole
horizon. For a vanishing cosmological constant, scalar curvature terms of zero and
first order as well as Jacobi fields remain finite in this limit.Where the paper says it
References
The paper cites numerous foundational works related to McVittie spacetimes, general relativity, and dynamical systems. Key references include the work of McVittie [1] and subsequent analyses by Kaloper et al. p. 1 An obvious question arises as to whether or not this spherically
symmetric spacetime models a black hole in an expanding universe: this is a non-trivial
question about the global structure of the spacetime. The first study of the global
structure was undertaken by Sussman [2], and subsequent work demonstrated that
McVittie spacetimes can indeed provide models of black holes embedded in an expanding
isotropic background - see [3] and [4, 5]. Will you
survive? Nolan
Centre for Astrophysics and Relativity, School of Mathematical Sciences, Dublin City
University, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, Ireland. Falling into a McVittie Black Hole 4
The metric provides a solution of Einstein’s equation with a perfect fluid source,
with energy density and pressure given by
8πµ = 3H
2
(t) − Λ, 8πP = −2H
′
(t)γ
1/2 − 3H
2
(t) + Λ, (8)
where Λ is the cosmological constant. Here and throughout, a prime (′
) represents the
derivative with respect to argument.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix B Details
Appendix B lists the coefficients of the second-order curvature term in terms of powers of gamma, showing that these coefficients are non-vanishing at r = 2m. These coefficients are given by complex formulas involving various powers of m/r and gamma. p. 2 Falling into a McVittie Black Hole 3
above, that one can indeed fall into a McVittie black hole. In the third section, we
consider the limiting behaviour of various curvature quantities along causal geodesics
that meet the horizon.Where the paper says it
The paper includes references to differential equations and dynamical systems, such as Perko [11] and Dixon's work on extended bodies [22-24]. It also references studies on singularities in spherical symmetry by Nolan [12]. p. 0 Will you
survive? Nolan
Centre for Astrophysics and Relativity, School of Mathematical Sciences, Dublin City
University, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, Ireland. (17)
Then for an expanding universe (H > 0), we see that the assumptions (11)-(15)
all hold for this model, and allow for the presence (H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ > 0) or absence
(H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ = 0) of dark energy. These assumptions also hold for FLRW spacetimes
with P0 = ωµ0 and Λ = 0 for −1 < ω ≤ 1, including those models with accelerated
expansion (−1 < ω < −1/3).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix A Details
Appendix A provides the general form for the second-order curvature invariants, showing that they are sums of products and powers of the Weyl invariant Ψ2, matter density µ, pressure P and the cosmological constant Λ. The expressions for RabcdRabcd are given by a specific formula involving m/r. p. 2 In the third section, we
consider the limiting behaviour of various curvature quantities along causal geodesics
that meet the horizon. We consider scalar curvature invariants of zero, first and
second order in derivatives (so we consider in particular RabcdRabcd
, ∇eRabcd∇eRabcd and
∇f∇eRabcd∇f∇eRabcd). In the third section, we
consider the limiting behaviour of various curvature quantities along causal geodesics
that meet the horizon. We consider scalar curvature invariants of zero, first and
second order in derivatives (so we consider in particular RabcdRabcd
, ∇eRabcd∇eRabcd and
∇f∇eRabcd∇f∇eRabcd).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix B provides the coefficients for the term ∇fRabcd∇fRabcd, showing they are written as sums of descending positive powers of gamma 1/2. These coefficients are non-vanishing at r = 2m. p. 0 Yes and maybe. In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid
spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that
freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in
finite proper time. Yes and maybe. In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid
spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that
freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in
finite proper time. Yes and maybe. In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid
spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that
freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in
finite proper time.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The bibliography includes references to the original work by McVittie [1], and subsequent papers exploring black holes in expanding universes [3, 4, 5]. It also includes works on cosmological models like the ΛCDM model. p. 4 (15)
We note that these assumptions allow for a broad range of FLRW cosmological
models (albeit restricted to the spatially flat case). This includes the standard ΛCDM
model, for which the Friedmann equation may be written
H
2 = H2
0
Ωr
a0
a
4
+ Ωm
a0
a
3
+ ΩΛ
. (15)
We note that these assumptions allow for a broad range of FLRW cosmological
models (albeit restricted to the spatially flat case). This includes the standard ΛCDM
model, for which the Friedmann equation may be written
H
2 = H2
0
Ωr
a0
a
4
+ Ωm
a0
a
3
+ ΩΛ
. (17)
Then for an expanding universe (H > 0), we see that the assumptions (11)-(15)
all hold for this model, and allow for the presence (H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ > 0) or absence
(H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ = 0) of dark energy. These assumptions also hold for FLRW spacetimes
with P0 = ωµ0 and Λ = 0 for −1 < ω ≤ 1, including those models with accelerated
expansion (−1 < ω < −1/3). (17)
Then for an expanding universe (H > 0), we see that the assumptions (11)-(15)
all hold for this model, and allow for the presence (H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ > 0) or absence
(H0 = H0Ω
1/2
Λ = 0) of dark energy. These assumptions also hold for FLRW spacetimes
with P0 = ωµ0 and Λ = 0 for −1 < ω ≤ 1, including those models with accelerated
expansion (−1 < ω < −1/3).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The appendix details the general form for the second-order curvature invariants, showing that they are sums of products and powers of the Weyl invariant Ψ2, matter density µ, pressure P and the cosmological constant Λ. The expressions for RabcdRabcd are given by a specific formula involving m/r.
Appendix B details the coefficients for the term ∇fRabcd∇fRabcd, showing they are written as sums of descending positive powers of gamma 1/2. These coefficients are non-vanishing at r = 2m.
The references section includes references to the original work by McVittie [1], and subsequent papers exploring black holes in expanding universes [3, 4, 5]. It also includes works on cosmological models like the ΛCDM model. The list of references is extensive, including papers by Ellis et al. [17], and others on local dynamics.
Appendix B details the coefficients for the term ∇fRabcd∇fRabcd, showing that they are written as sums of descending positive powers of gamma 1/2. These coefficients are non-vanishing at r = 2m.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved understanding of McVittie spacetimes by distinguishing between positive and vanishing cosmological constants regarding curvature invariants at horizons. The improved system can rigorously determine whether zero-order and first-order curvature scalars remain finite in the limit as the horizon is approached, specifically showing that for vanishing cosmological constant,
zero- and first-order in invariants remain finite
butthe second order term diverges.
-
Enhanced prediction of tidal forces on extended bodies by incorporating higher-order curvature terms into the geodesic deviation equation analysis. The improved system can determine if a small test body can survive the impact with the singularity by evaluating how
higher order curvature terms diverge,
addressing concerns about deformationally strong singularities in cases wherehigher order approximations to the equation of motion for xi involve higher order derivatives of the curvature.
-
Refined analysis of causal geodesic behavior near horizons by linking limiting behaviors of background functions to specific geometric constraints. The improved system can predict that
along any causal geodesic running into the black hole horizon, the zero- and first-order curvature invariants are finite
when cosmological constant is non-zero, but will show thatthe second order term diverges
in the vanishing cosmological constant case.
Abstract
Yes and maybe. In contrast to the fluid particles of this perfect fluid spacetime which follow non-geodesic world-lines and escape to infinity, we prove that freely-falling test particles of McVittie spacetime can reach the black hole horizon in finite proper time. We review the relevant evidence and argue that the fate of an extended test body is less clear. More precisely: we consider expanding McVittie spacetimes with a non-negative cosmological constant. In each member of this class, we identify a region of the spacetime such that an observer following an initially-ingoing timelike geodesic crosses the black hole horizon of the spacetime in a finite amount of proper time. The curvature behaves in interesting ways along these geodesics. In the case of a positive cosmological constant, curvature scalars (of zero, first and second order in derivatives), Jacobi fields and parallel propagated (p.p.) frame components of the curvature remain finite along timelike geodesics running into the black hole horizon. For a vanishing cosmological constant, scalar curvature terms of zero and first order as well as Jacobi fields remain finite in this limit. However, scalar curvature terms of second order diverge, and we show that there are p.p. frame components of the curvature tensor that also diverge in this limit. We argue that this casts a doubt as to whether or not an extended test body can survive crossing the black hole horizon in this case.
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals