Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes

arXiv:2508.08238 · astro-ph.CO, gr-qc, hep-ph · Submitted 2025-08-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Primordial black holes in the stupendously large mass range produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component The Core Finding We show that primordial black holes (PBHs) in the Stupendously Large Black Hole mass range (M ≳ 1011 M⊙) produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component This result rules out SLABs as a significant DM component.

Vera: Modeling Primordial Perturbations The model considers the total cold DM as a mixture of PBHs and particle dark matter (PDM), defined by the relation ρDM = ρPBH + ρPDM, fPBH ≡ ρPBH / ρDM.

Jocelyn: The total DM density contrast is given by δDM = fPBH δPBH + (1 − fPBH) δPDM.

Vera: The primordial PBH perturbations include an isocurvature component due to their discreteness, where δf PBH = δf ad + δf iso.

Paper summary: Vera: So, we're looking at this paper called "Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes". Basically, they're showing that primordial black holes in a really big mass range produce isocurvature perturbations that go way beyond what the current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits allow.

Jocelyn: So, what does that mean for dark matter? They are saying this result excludes these stupendously large black holes from being a significant part of the dark matter we see in our universe.

Subrahmanyan: That's a pretty strong claim because it cuts off an entire possibility for how primordial black holes could contribute to the dark matter density contrast.

Vera: The paper models the total cold dark matter as a mix of primordial black holes and particle dark matter, defined by ρDM = ρPBH plus ρPDM, and they look at how this affects the total DM density contrast.

Jocelyn: They break down the primordial black hole perturbations into an isocurvature component because of their discreteness, which leads to a relationship where the primordial DM contrast is expressed as δf DM = δf ad plus fPBH delta f iso.

Subrahmanyan: That's interesting because it sets up this specific way the total dark matter contrast relates to the adiabatic and isocurvature components.

Vera: Then they derive the isocurvature power spectrum, which they call D(delta f iso) squared E, and they find it depends on k PBH three j1(k over kf) k over kf <ref:2508.08238#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And that spherical Bessel factor j1(x) implements a cutoff for k greater than the comoving scale of PBHs, which is defined as R inverse S a assuming a equals one today due to PBH exclusion effects.

Subrahmanyan: That time-dependent comoving inverse scale kS is what makes this different from usual physical scales that redshift with the universe, which is a key part of the physics here.

Vera: They then model the constraints on this primordial isocurvature power spectrum PII(k) using CMB plus BAO data, treating it as a Dirac function where P iso II (k) equals Aiso delta(ln k minus ln k0).

Jocelyn: And they show that any scenarios whose primordial isocurvature spectrum exceeds the curve in Figure one are excluded, which sets pink constraints in Figure two for the two UV cutoffs mentioned in their equations <ref:2508.08238#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That sharp cutoff near MPBH equal to one thousand nineteen M⊙ is important because it reflects the requirement that these PBHs must form before recombination at zrec equals one thousand ninety <ref:2508.08238#pg1>.

Vera: They also mention other constraints on black hole populations, like those from light PBH evaporation via Hawking radiation constrained by the gamma-ray background, and microlensing surveys limiting abundance in intermediate ranges.

Jocelyn: And then there are constraints around stellar masses from LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA gravitational wave detections which constrain PBHs by comparing the observed merger rate with what their predictions say.

Subrahmanyan: So, to wrap up this part, the paper concludes that because of these large DM isocurvature perturbations, they set stringent limits in the mass range MPBH equals one hundred eight to one thousand nineteen M⊙ excluding them as a significant dark matter component.

Vera: The title itself "Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes" really captures what they're doing here, trying to define where these black holes stop being viable dark matter candidates.

Jocelyn: It seems like the main implication is that these specific, very large primordial black holes simply don't fit into the current picture of dark matter because their predicted perturbations are too strong for what we observe in the CMB.

Subrahmanyan: For someone just listening to this show, it means that if you're looking at models where dark matter comes from primordial black holes in that high mass range, you can probably rule them out as a major component of our universe's dark matter.

Vera: The authors also mention extensions possible, like correlations between isocurvature and adiabatic modes, and they assume a monochromatic PBH mass function which could be generalized to extended distributions.

Jocelyn: That generalization would open up more possibilities for how these perturbations behave in more complex scenarios than what this specific model covers.

Subrahmanyan: The work relies on assuming a monochromatic PBH mass function, but they also note that the study could be generalized to extended mass distributions, which is important for seeing if the exclusion holds up under different assumptions about how many black holes form.

Vera: Overall, this paper provides a specific window for these black holes and shows that within that range of masses MPBH between one hundred eight and one thousand nineteen M⊙, they don't work as a major dark matter component given the CMB constraints.

Jocelyn: So it’s less about ruling out black holes entirely, and more about ruling out them in this specific, stupendously large mass range for now.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a step toward refining our understanding of primordial structure formation by using these precise cosmological observations to narrow down the parameter space for different dark matter candidates.

Conclusion: Vera: So, we're wrapping up this look at "Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes." It basically means they've found a specific mass range where these black holes just aren't doing much for dark matter because their predicted ripples in the universe are too big.

Jocelyn: Right, so it's not that black holes don't exist, but this paper is drawing a line on which ones could actually be the main ingredient in our dark matter.

Subrahmanyan: I think the core finding here is pretty definitive; they show that primordial black holes bigger than about one thousand nineteen solar masses create isocurvature perturbations that just exceed what our current Cosmic Microwave Background data allows.

Vera: Exactly, it's a constraint based on how big those ripples in the early universe can actually be, and these large ones are being cut off by that limit.

Jocelyn: It’s interesting because this isn't just about ruling out one type of black hole; it’s about setting limits on a whole population based on the size of their mass range MPBH between one hundred eight and one thousand nineteen solar masses.

Subrahmanyan: And that mass window is really tight, so it suggests that for dark matter to come from these stupendously large black holes, you'd need to be in a very specific spot in the parameter space of how they form.

Vera: It means if we find evidence pointing toward dark matter coming from black holes larger than that range, this paper tells us that their isocurvature perturbations would have already been seen and ruled out by the CMB data.

Jocelyn: So, it’s a strong exclusion based on how these black holes affect the very early structure of our universe.

Subrahmanyan: And it opens up the next question for theorists—what if we change those assumptions about how those black holes form, or what kind of dark matter we are actually dealing with?

PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics · New York University · Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center

astro-ph.CO, gr-qc, hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-08-11

Updated: 2026-10-28

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 137 (2026) 18, 181401

DOI: 10.1103/qlf9-thf4

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: Primordial black holes in the stupendously large mass range produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits…

Key concepts

Primordial Black Holes (PBHs)
These are black holes formed in the early universe from large density fluctuations. The model specifically focuses on those with very large masses, exceeding $10^{11}$ solar masses, to test their viability as dark matter.
Isocurvature Perturbations
These are fluctuations in the relative abundance of different types of dark matter components. In this context, PBH discreteness introduces an isocurvature component ($\delta f_{iso}$) into the total dark matter density contrast, which is then constrained by CMB data.
CMB+BAO Constraints
These are observational constraints derived from Cosmic Microwave Background and Baryon Acoustic Oscillation measurements. The paper uses these to set limits on the primordial isocurvature power spectrum, which directly restricts the allowed abundance of stupendously large PBHs.
Stupendously Large Black Holes (SLABs)
This refers to a specific mass range for PBHs, defined as those with masses $M \gtrsim 10^{11} M_{\odot}$. The research focuses on this high-mass regime to determine if these objects can account for the observed dark matter density.

Terminology

Summary

Primordial black holes in the stupendously large mass range produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component

The Core Finding

We show that primordial black holes (PBHs) in the Stupendously Large Black Hole mass range (M ≳ 1011 M⊙) produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component This result rules out SLABs as a significant DM component.

Modeling Primordial Perturbations

The model considers the total cold DM as a mixture of PBHs and particle dark matter (PDM), defined by the relation ρDM = ρPBH + ρPDM, fPBH ≡ ρPBH / ρDM. The total DM density contrast is given by δDM = fPBH δPBH + (1 − fPBH) δPDM. p. 0

Where the paper says it

PBH Isocurvature Perturbations. We model the total cold DM as a mixture of PBHs and particle dark matter (PDM, such as WIMPs or ALPs), ρDM = ρPBH + ρPDM, fPBH ≡ ρPBH ρDM , (1) such that the total DM density contrast is δDM = fPBH δPBH + (1 − fPBH) δPDM.

The primordial PBH perturbations include an isocurvature component due to their discreteness, where δf PBH = δf ad + δf iso. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(2) Following the linear perturbation theory for a PBH–PDM mixture presented in [14], we assume that the primordial PDM perturbations are purely adiabatic, δ f PDM = δ f ad, where the superscript f denotes the epoch of PBH formation. The discreteness of PBHs induces an additional isocurvature component in their primordial perturbations [15] δ f PBH = δ f ad + δ f iso, (3) so that Eq.

This leads to the primordial DM contrast being expressed as δf DM = δf ad + fPBH δf iso. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The discreteness of PBHs induces an additional isocurvature component in their primordial perturbations [15] δ f PBH = δ f ad + δ f iso, (3) so that Eq. (2) provides the primordial DM contrast with an isocurvature component as well δ f DM = δ f ad + fPBH δ f iso.

Isocurvature Power Spectrum Derivation

The DM isocurvature perturbation is defined by IDM ≡ δ(nDM/nγ) nDM/nγ = δDM − 3/4 δR. Substituting the evolution equations yields IDM(a) = Tiso(a) fPBH δf iso. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(5) into Eq. (6), using that the adiabatic contribution cancels, yields IDM(a) = Tiso(a) fPBH δ f iso.

The dimensionless cross–power spectrum of two observables X and Y is defined as PXY (k) ≡ k 3/2π squared ∫ d 3r e(ik·r)⟨X(0) Y (r)⟩. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(6), using that the adiabatic contribution cancels, yields IDM(a) = Tiso(a) fPBH δ f iso. (7) We define the dimensionless cross–power spectrum of two observables X and Y as PXY (k) ≡ k 3 2π 2 Z d 3 r e ik·r ⟨X(0) Y (r)⟩, (8) where the prefactor k 3/2π 2 ensures that PXY (k) d ln k gives the contribution to the variance from modes in the logarithmic interval [k, k + dk].

The isocurvature power spectrum D(δf iso) squared E is found to be D(δf iso) squared E = 2/3π k PBH 3 j1(k/kf) k/kf. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(14) into Eq. (8) yields the isocurvature power spectrum D (δ f iso) 2 E = 2 3π k kPBH 3 3j1(k/kf ) k/kf , (15) where k is defined as comoving and kPBH is the inverse comoving PBH interspacing [18], kPBH = 4π 3 nPBH1/3 = 4πfPBH ρDM,0 3MPBH 1/3 , (16) with ρDM,0 ≃ 3 × 1010 M⊙ Mpc−3 denoting the presentday mean dark matter density [19].

Constraints and Exclusion Limits

The CMB+BAO constraints on the primordial isocurvature power spectrum PII(k) are modeled as a Dirac function, P iso II (k) = Aiso δ(ln k − ln k0). Scenarios whose primordial isocurvature spectrum [Eq. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Isocurvature is modeled as a Dirac function, P iso II (k) = Aiso δ(ln k − ln k0), and 95% CL constraints on (Aiso, k0) are shown in Fig. Since any spectrum can be decomposed as the linear combination P iso II (k) = R d ln k0 P iso II (k0) δ(ln k − ln k0), and the CMB/BAO physics is linear, PBH scenarios whose primordial isocurvature spectrum [Eq.

(18) without the transfer function] exceeds the curve in Fig. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Since any spectrum can be decomposed as the linear combination P iso II (k) = R d ln k0 P iso II (k0) δ(ln k − ln k0), and the CMB/BAO physics is linear, PBH scenarios whose primordial isocurvature spectrum [Eq. (18) without the transfer function] exceeds the curve in Fig.

1 are excluded. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(18) without the transfer function] exceeds the curve in Fig. 1 are excluded.

This yields pink (CMB+BAO) bounds in Fig. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1 are excluded. In the (MPBH, fPBH) plane, this yields the pink (CMB+BAO) bounds in Fig.

2 for the two UV cutoffs in Eq. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In the (MPBH, fPBH) plane, this yields the pink (CMB+BAO) bounds in Fig. 2 for the two UV cutoffs in Eq.

(19). The sharp cutoff near MPBH ≃ 1019 M⊙ reflects the requirement that PBHs form before recombination (zrec ≃ 1090). p. 2
Where the paper says it

2 for the two UV cutoffs in Eq. The sharp cutoff near MPBH ≃ 1019 M⊙ reflects the requirement that PBHs form before recombination (zrec ≃ 1090).

Other Astrophysical Constraints

The constraints on other PBH populations are diverse, including those from light PBH evaporation via Hawking radiation constrained by the gamma-ray background, and constraints from microlensing surveys limiting the PBH abundance in the intermediate range. Furthermore, around stellar masses, LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA GW detections constrain PBHs by comparing the observed merger rate with PBH merger predictions. p. 2

Where the paper says it

[44–47]). Around stellar masses, LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA GW detections constrain PBHs by comparing the observed merger rate with PBH merger predictions [48] (orange) (see also Refs.

Conclusion and Future Work

In conclusion, we have shown that the production of stupendously large PBHs would generate large DM isocurvature perturbations, tightly constrained by CMB and BAO data. Using the upper bounds on the isocurvature power spectrum in Fig. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In this work, we have shown that the production of stupendously large PBHs would generate large DM isocurvature perturbations, tightly constrained by CMB and BAO data. Using the upper bounds on the isocurvature power spectrum in Fig.

1, we set the stringent limits shown in Fig. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Using the upper bounds on the isocurvature power spectrum in Fig. 1, we set the stringent limits shown in Fig.

2 in the mass range MPBH ∈ [108, 1019] M⊙, excluding such objects as a significant DM component. p. 2
Where the paper says it

1, we set the stringent limits shown in Fig. 2 in the mass range MPBH ∈ [108 , 1019] M⊙, excluding such objects as a significant DM component.

Next-generation CMB experiments will improve these constraints. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In the case of full anticorrelation, limits on βiso would drop to O(10−3 ) [16], further tightening the abundance limits in the mass range considered. Next-generation CMB experiments, such as LiteBIRD [67] and the Simons Observatory [68], will improve the constraints presented here.

Note added shortly before submission of this work Ref. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Note added. Shortly before submission of this work, Ref.

[61] closed the SLAB range MPBH ∈ [1014, 1016] M⊙ using MIKE/HIRES Lyman-α data and EFT methods from Ref. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Shortly before submission of this work, Ref. [61] closed the SLAB range MPBH ∈ [1014 , 1016] M⊙ using MIKE/HIRES Lyman-α data and EFT methods from Ref.

[71].

Acknowledgments We thank Bernard Carr, Peizhi Du, Gabriele Perna, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto, Pedro Schwaller and Sokratis Trifinopoulos for useful discussions and comments on the draft. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Acknowledgments. We thank Bernard Carr, Peizhi Du, Gabriele Perna, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto, Pedro Schwaller and Sokratis Trifinopoulos for useful discussions and comments on the draft.

The authors acknowledge support by the Cluster of Excellence “PRISMA+” funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the German Excellence Strategy (Project No. p. 3
Where the paper says it

We thank Bernard Carr, Peizhi Du, Gabriele Perna, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto, Pedro Schwaller and Sokratis Trifinopoulos for useful discussions and comments on the draft. acknowledge support by the Cluster of Excellence “PRISMA+” funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the German Excellence Strategy (Project No.

390831469). p. 3
Where the paper says it

acknowledge support by the Cluster of Excellence “PRISMA+” funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the German Excellence Strategy (Project No. 390831469).

The paper also mentions extensions possible, such as correlations between isocurvature and adiabatic modes. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Our study assumes a monochromatic PBH mass function and could be generalized to extended mass distributions as in Ref. Correlations between isocurvature and adiabatic modes, either of primordial origins or induced by cosmological evolution [66], could also be explored.

The study assumes a monochromatic PBH mass function and could be generalized to extended mass distributions. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Several extensions are possible. Our study assumes a monochromatic PBH mass function and could be generalized to extended mass distributions as in Ref.

--- Page 1 ---

MITP-25-053 Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes Christopher Gerlach 1, Yann Gouttenoire 1, Antonio J. Iovino 2, 3, Nicholas Leister 1 § PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany New York University Abu Dhabi PO Box 129188 Saadiyat Island Abu Dhabi UAE Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center, 24 quai E. p. 0

Where the paper says it

MITP-25-053 Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes Christopher Gerlach , 1, ∗ Yann Gouttenoire , 1, † Antonio J. Iovino , 2, 3, ‡ and Nicholas Leister 1, § 1PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics, Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany 2New York University, Abu Dhabi, PO Box 129188 Saadiyat Island, Abu Dhabi, UAE 3Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center, 24 quai E.

Ansermet, CH-1211 Geneva 4 Switzerland

--- Page 2 ---

New York University Abu Dhabi PO Box 129188 Saadiyat Island Abu Dhabi UAE Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center, 24 quai E. Ansermet, CH-1211 Geneva 4 Switzerland

--- Page 3 ---

Department of Theoretical Physics and Gravitational Wave Science Center, 24 quai E. Ansermet, CH-1211 Geneva 4 Switzerland

--- Page 4 ---

Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany

--- Page 5 ---

Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany

--- Page 6 ---

PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany

--- Page 7 ---

PRISMA+ Cluster of Excellence & Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany

--- Page 8 ---

Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, 55099 Mainz, Germany

--- Page 11 ---

arXiv:2508.08238v1 [astro-ph. p. 0

Where the paper says it

(11) arXiv:2508. 08238v1 [astro-ph.

CO] 11 Aug 2025

--- Page 4 ---

MPBH = 10 4.1 × 10 18 M⊙

--- Page 6 ---

kPBH = (4π/3 nPBH) (MPBH / M⊙)(1/3)

--- Page 6 ---

kS(a) = R-1 S a— assuming a = 1 today — due to PBH exclusion effects.

--- Page 7 ---

kf = kS(af) ≃ 0.16 Mpc−1 γ 1/2 H cubed. p. 0

Where the paper says it

For brevity, we denote ⟨XY ⟩ ≡ PXY (k) when no ambiguity arises. For poissondistributed objects, the PBH density contrast at formation can be expressed as δ f iso(x) = ΘPBH(x)δS − 1, (9) where δS ≡ ρS/ρPBH = (nPBHVS) −1 is the ratio of the average energy density inside a PBH to the average energy density of the PBH gas with nPBH the PBH number density, ρS ≡ MPBH/VS, VS ≡ 4πR3 S /3, and RS ≡ 2GMPBH ≃ 10−19(MPBH/M⊙) Mpc the density, volume and radius of a single PBH.

38 g⋆(Tf)(1/2) MPBH(1/2)

--- Page 7 ---

kPBH = (4π fPBH ρDM,0 / 3 MPBH)(1/3)

--- Page 7 ---

kS(a) = R-1 S a— assuming a = 1 today — due to PBH exclusion effects.

--- Page 8 ---

RS = 2GMPBH ≃ 10−19(MPBH/M⊙) Mpc the density, volume and radius of a single PBH.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform stringent dark matter abundance exclusion for stupendously large black holes by calculating isocurvature perturbations exceeding Planck CMB limits, specifically ruling out MPBH in [108, 1019] Msun as a significant dark matter component.

  2. Improved AI system can predict the required non-linear scale for DM fluctuations based on the cut-off prescriptions (Case A or Case B) to determine whether structure formation is driven by Poisson fluctuations or individual seed effects, distinguishing between linear and nonlinear regimes.

  3. Improved AI system can generate 95 percent confidence level constraints in the mass range MPBH in [108, 1019] Msun for non-spinning PBHs by combining CMB/BAO data with other astrophysical constraints such as Hawking radiation bounds, microlensing limits, and gravitational wave merger rates.

  4. Improved AI system can quantify the isocurvature fraction beta iso k by comparing the theoretical spectrum derived from Eq. (18) with observed Planck constraints, allowing for a more precise determination of PBH abundance limits in different UV cut-off scenarios (Case A or Case B).

Abstract

We show that primordial black holes (PBHs) in the Stupendously Large Black Hole mass range (M 10 11,M) produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component.

Sources

Related papers