Little Red Dots from Small-Scale Primordial Black Hole Clustering

arXiv:2507.07171 · astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA, gr-qc, hep-ph · Submitted 2025-07-09 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Little Red Dots from Small-Scale Primordial Black Hole Clustering".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have identified a class of compact galaxies at high redshifts (4 ≲ z ≲ 11), dubbed “little red dots” (LRDs)

1–5: .

Vera: SMBHs in LRDs could be of primordial origin from the high-density perturbations in the early Universe While primordial black holes (PBHs) produced from direct collapse generally harbor small spin

18, 19: and are excluded for heavy seeds ≳ 104 M⊙ by cosmic microwave background (CMB) distortions given the nearly Gaussian primordial density perturbations

20, 21: , this letter proposes a mechanism wherein a highredshift spinning SMBH can originate from successive mergers of PBHs in an initial small-scale cluster.

Jocelyn: Mechanism for Heavy Seed Formation The proposed mechanism involves clusters of primordial black holes, formed through long-short mode coupling on small scales in the early Universe, undergoing sequential mergers over extended timescales.

Vera: This process can evade cosmic microwave background distortions and result in heavy-seed SMBHs via runaway mergers.

Title and authors: Vera: So we’re diving into what this paper is actually proposing about these little red dots and how they relate to primordial black holes. We need to keep that in mind as we go through the details.

Jocelyn: Basically, the authors are suggesting that instead of a single massive black hole forming directly, it could be built up from smaller pieces—primordial black holes—that clump together in a cluster and then merge repeatedly over a very long time.

Subrahmanyan: That addresses the issue of heavy seeds, which is one way to explain why some supermassive black holes are so massive early on.

The paper's summary: Vera: They lay out this mechanism where primordial black holes form in clusters through long-short mode coupling on small scales in the early Universe, and then these clusters undergo sequential mergers over extended timescales.

Jocelyn: And that process can evade those cosmic microwave background distortions that usually put limits on such models, leading to heavy seed supermassive black holes through these runaway mergers.

Subrahmanyan: The paper uses Monte Carlo simulations to solve the Smoluchowski coagulation equation to figure out the runaway merging timescale, which is a really concrete result they are presenting.

The paper's improvements: Vera: Now, what’s interesting is how they improve on previous ideas. They introduce a parametrization for how density fields modulate each other, like this equation using the coupling strength eta and the long mode field Phi l of x.

Jocelyn: And they show that by setting the variance of those long modes, sigma l, to be around zero point zero zero six four eight seven in order to avoid the mu distortion constraint from CMB spectral distortions.

Subrahmanyan: That's a clever way to evade those constraints while still maintaining a PBH abundance fpbh around one percent dark matter density.

Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up this paper on "Little Red Dots from Small-Scale Primordial Black Hole Clustering," the authors suggest that initial small-scale PBH clustering could explain the rapid formation of SMBHs within the first billion years after the Big Bang.

Jocelyn: They emphasize that because of tidal interactions from other clusters, this resulting supermassive black hole is expected to be highly spinning, and they show this spin can exceed the Kerr limit.

Subrahmanyan: And they point out that the gravitational wave signature from these merging processes has two peaks, one at low frequencies and one at relatively high frequencies, which could be a distinct way to detect this mechanism.

Vera: It seems like a solid framework for how we can link the observations of LRDs to some specific physics in the early Universe.

Jocelyn: Indeed, and it sets up some interesting questions about what kind of gravitational wave signals we might actually be able to see from these events with next-generation observatories.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly, and it keeps us thinking about how structure forms when you start with these tiny seeds in the early Universe.

Borui Zhang, Wei-Xiang Feng, *, Haipeng An

Department of Physics, Tsinghua University · Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University

astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA, gr-qc, hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-07-09

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, plus supplemental material (4 figures); figures updated; references updated with expanded discussion; more details on the gravitational wave calculations provided

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have identified a class of compact galaxies at high redshifts (4 ≲ z ≲ 11), dubbed “little red dots” (LRDs) [1–5].

Key concepts

Little Red Dots (LRDs)
These are compact galaxies observed by the James Webb Space Telescope at high redshifts (4 to 11). The paper suggests their central SMBHs might have formed early through the proposed PBH merger mechanism, which is a key target for this study.
Primordial Black Holes (PBHs)
These are hypothetical black holes formed in the very early Universe from density perturbations. The authors focus on small-scale PBHs clustering together to form dense clusters, which then evolve through mergers to create larger SMBHs.
Long-Short Mode Coupling
This is a physical process where long-wavelength density fluctuations influence smaller-scale perturbations. This coupling is crucial because it allows the model to evade strict constraints from cosmic microwave background distortions while still allowing for the necessary PBH abundance.
Tidal Field Spin Acquisition
As PBH clusters merge over millions of years, interactions with tidal fields from neighboring structures impart significant angular momentum. This process is key to explaining why the resulting SMBHs are highly spinning, potentially exceeding the standard Kerr limit.

Terminology

Summary

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have identified a class of compact galaxies at high redshifts (4 ≲ z ≲ 11), dubbed “little red dots” (LRDs) [1–5]. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Little Red Dots from Small-Scale Primordial Black Hole Clustering Borui Zhang,1 Wei-Xiang Feng,1, ∗ and Haipeng An1, 2, † 1Department of Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China 2Center for High Energy Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have identified a class of compact galaxies at high redshifts (4 ≲ z ≲ 11), dubbed “little red dots” (LRDs). The supermassive black holes (SMBHs) of 105–8 M⊙ in LRDs favor a heavy-seed origin.

SMBHs in LRDs could be of primordial origin from the high-density perturbations in the early Universe While primordial black holes (PBHs) produced from direct collapse generally harbor small spin [18, 19] and are excluded for heavy seeds ≳ 104 M⊙ by cosmic microwave background (CMB) distortions given the nearly Gaussian primordial density perturbations [20, 21], this letter proposes a mechanism wherein a highredshift spinning SMBH can originate from successive mergers of PBHs in an initial small-scale cluster. p. 0
Where the paper says it

While primordial black holes (PBHs) produced from direct collapse generally harbor small spin [18, 19] and are excluded for heavy seeds ≳ 104 M⊙ by cosmic microwave background (CMB) distortions given the nearly Gaussian primordial density perturbations [20, 21]. In this Letter, we propose a mechanism wherein a highredshift spinning SMBH can originate from successive mergers of PBHs in an initial small-scale cluster, which avoids the CMB constraints.

Mechanism for Heavy Seed Formation

The proposed mechanism involves clusters of primordial black holes, formed through long-short mode coupling on small scales in the early Universe, undergoing sequential mergers over extended timescales. This process can evade cosmic microwave background distortions and result in heavy-seed SMBHs via runaway mergers. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We propose a mechanism for their formation: Clusters of primordial black holes, formed through long-short mode coupling on small scales in the early Universe, undergo sequential mergers over extended timescales. This mechanism can evade cosmic microwave background distortions and result in heavy-seed SMBHs via runaway mergers.

The resulting stochastic gravitational wave background offers a distinct signature of this process, and the forming SMBHs can be highly spinning at their formation due to the spin residual of the cluster from tidal fields. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We employ Monte Carlo simulations to solve the Smoluchowski coagulation equation and determine the runaway merging timescale. The resulting stochastic gravitational wave background offers a distinct signature of this process, and the forming SMBHs can be highly spinning at their formation due to the spin residual of the cluster from tidal fields.

This mechanism may explain the rapidly spinning SMBHs in LRDs under the assumption of obscured active galactic nuclei. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The resulting stochastic gravitational wave background offers a distinct signature of this process, and the forming SMBHs can be highly spinning at their formation due to the spin residual of the cluster from tidal fields. This mechanism may explain the rapidly spinning SMBHs in LRDs under the assumption of obscured active galactic nuclei.

Cluster Generation and Abundance

The formation of such a dense cluster is hypothesized to arise from the modulation of the overdensity field at the PBH formation scale (ks) by long-wavelength (kl) modes on larger scales through various mechanisms. A simple parametrization of this long-mode spatial modulation is given by ν(x) = νg (1 + η Φl(x)). p. 0

Where the paper says it

Clusters of this kind may arise from the modulation of the overdensity field at the PBH formation scale (ks) by long-wavelength (kl) modes on larger scales, through various mechanisms such as local-type non-Gaussianity [24, 28–40], closed domain walls [41–43], multistream inflation [44, 45], long-range scalar forces [46–48], quantum diffusion [49–51], or correlated bubble collisions [52]. A simple parametrization of the long-mode spatial modulation is given by [24]: ν(x) = νg (1 + η Φl(x)) , (4) arXiv:2507.

The fraction of PBHs relative to the total dark matter abundance, defined as fpbh ≡ omegapbh/omegadm, also depends on the long-short mode coupling η and is given by fpbh ≃ 2. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In our setting, ξα ∼ 106 given |η| ∼ 14. The fraction of PBHs relative to the total dark matter abundance, defined as fpbh ≡ Ωpbh/Ωdm, also depends on the long-short mode coupling |η|, and is given by [20, 21]: fpbh ≃ 2.

8×10 7 g⋆ / (10 6.75 − 1/4) (30 M⊙ mpbh 1/2 β(mpbh)). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here we take ks ≃ 2. 5 pc−1 at the horizonexit for PBHs of mass mpbh ≃ 30 M⊙ [24].

The condition 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The properties of the PBH cluster depend on the combination fpbhξα, which is a function of α(η, κ) and kl/ks. In particular, the condition 0.

85fpbhξα > 1 must be satisfied for decoupling before the matterradiation equality. p. 1
Where the paper says it

85fpbhξα > 1 (as shown in Fig. 1) must be satisfied for decoupling before the matterradiation equality.

PBH Population Evolution and Timescales

The cluster parameters are summarized, including the number density ncl which is only determined by the combination fpbhξα. The total mass of the cluster is given by Mcl ≃ 3 × 10 6 M⊙ (fpbhξα) 2/5 rcl cubed. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A strong coupling η boosts the clustering via ncl ∝ (fpbhξα) 4 . • The Cluster Mass: The total mass of the cluster is given by: Mcl ≃ 3 × 106 M⊙ fpbhξα 25 rcl 10 kpc3 , (9) which scales as r 3 cl ∼ 1/k3 l , implying that the wavelength of the long mode primarily determines the total mass of the cluster and ultimately sets the mass scale of the final SMBH.

The virial radius of the cluster after decoupling is computed as rvir = (3Mcl/4πmpbhncl)(1/3) ∝ (fpbhξα)−1 C(-1/3)rcl. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Therefore, for a fixed Mcl, the number of PBHs in the cluster is inversely proportional to their individual masses mpbh. • The Virial Radius and Velocity: The virial radius of the cluster after decoupling is computed as rvir = (3Mcl/4πmpbhncl) 1/3 ∝ (fpbhξα) −1 C −1/3 rcl, which decreases with the coupling |η|.

Given the above setting and kl/ks ∼ 10-4, a cluster with rvir ∼ 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As both rvir and vvir ∝ rcl ∼ 1/kl , the smaller the ratio kl/ks, the larger the rvir and vvir. Given the above setting and kl/ks ∼ 10−4 , we will show that a cluster with rvir ∼ 0.

05 pc and vvir ∼ 500 km s−1 can explain the SMBHs in LRDs through runaway mergers. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Given the above setting and kl/ks ∼ 10−4 , we will show that a cluster with rvir ∼ 0. 05 pc and vvir ∼ 500 km s−1 can explain the SMBHs in LRDs through runaway mergers.

Gravitational Wave Signatures and Spin

The merger process may last from millions to billions of years, during which the cluster can acquire a significant amount of angular momentum from tidal fields, such that the resulting SMBH inherits a large spin. The merger of a PBH cluster can be divided into three stages. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This is consistent with the given upper bound, 1/nclK00, shown in Ref. The merger of a PBH cluster can be divided into three stages.

The third stage eventually arises when the number density of these intermediate-mass PBHs grows beyond a certain threshold, and an SMBH will emerge with the surrounding small-mass PBHs, forming an extreme mass ratio inspiral system. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In the second stage, PBHs with intermediate masses begin to form and boost the merger process due to the increased merger cross section. The third stage eventually arises when the number density of these intermediate-mass PBHs grows beyond a certain threshold, and an SMBH will emerge with the surrounding small-mass PBHs, forming an extreme mass ratio inspiral system.

The overall merger processes will provide a distinct GW signature of this mechanism. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The third stage eventually arises when the number density of these intermediate-mass PBHs grows beyond a certain threshold, and an SMBH will emerge with the surrounding small-mass PBHs, forming an extreme mass ratio inspiral system. The overall merger processes will provide a distinct GW signature of this mechanism.

Discussion and Constraints

The green region in Fig. 1 shows the experimental constraints on PBH abundance, fpbh [20, 21, 88] derived from gravitational lensing, Lyman-α measurements, X-ray observations [89], and dynamical friction [90]. p. 4

Where the paper says it

— In addition to the requirements discussed in the preceding sections, the green region in Fig. 1 shows the experimental constraints on PBH abundance, fpbh [20, 21, 88], derived from gravitational lensing, Lyman-α measurements, X-ray observations [89], and dynamical friction [90].

The most stringent constraints on long-wavelength perturbations Φl arise from CMB spectral distortions [91–95]. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The primary constraint on the PBH abundance then arises only from the SMBH mass density of ρ• ∼ 105 M⊙ Mpc−3 in the local universe, currently accounting for fpbh ∼ 10−5 dark matter density – consistent with our parameter choice. The most stringent constraints on long-wavelength perturbations Φl arise from CMB spectral distortions [91–95], see also Refs.

These constraints can be evaded through the long-short mode coupling, as the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In our model, SMBHs do not form from the direct collapse of long-wavelength perturbations but instead emerge from successive mergers of small-mass PBHs. Crucially, the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

In our model, SMBHs do not form from the direct collapse of long-wavelength perturbations but instead emerge from successive mergers of small-mass PBHs. Crucially, the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0.

0064, allowing the µdistortion constraint to be satisfied while maintaining a sufficient PBH abundance fpbh ∼ 10-5. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Crucially, the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0. 0064, allowing the µdistortion constraint to be satisfied while maintaining a sufficient PBH abundance fpbh ∼ 10−5 , which will ultimately result in the SMBH population.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Crucially, the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0. 0064, allowing the µdistortion constraint to be satisfied while maintaining a sufficient PBH abundance fpbh ∼ 10−5 , which will ultimately result in the SMBH population.

The runaway merger time trm must be sufficiently short, trm ≲ 1 Gyr (z ≳ 5). p. 3
Where the paper says it

To explain SMBHs of 105–8 M⊙ in the LRDs (light-gray in Fig. 1), the runaway timescale trm must be sufficiently short, trm ≲ 1 Gyr (z ≳ 5).

Conclusions

Initial small-scale PBH clustering could potentially explain the rapid formation of SMBHs within the first billion years after the Big Bang, particularly the LRDs observed in recent JWST data. In this framework, a central SMBH emerges through successive mergers of light PBHs within the cluster. p. 4

Where the paper says it

We have considered a simplified model in which small-scale clustering arises from long-wavelength mode modulation at the PBH formation scale. In this framework, a central SMBH emerges through successive mergers of light PBHs within the cluster.

Due to tidal interactions from other clusters, the resulting SMBH is expected to be highly spinning, and extreme mass ratio inspiral systems with the central black hole will naturally form. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In this framework, a central SMBH emerges through successive mergers of light PBHs within the cluster. Due to tidal interactions from other clusters, the resulting SMBH is expected to be highly spinning, and extreme mass ratio inspiral systems with the central black hole will naturally form [27].

The GW signature associated with this mechanism may be detected by next-generation GW observatories such as the Einstein Telescope [98–100] and are distinguishable from alternative SMBH formation models, e. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Due to tidal interactions from other clusters, the resulting SMBH is expected to be highly spinning, and extreme mass ratio inspiral systems with the central black hole will naturally form [27]. The GW signature associated with this mechanism may be detected by next-generation GW observatories such as the Einstein Telescope [98–100], and are distinguishable from alternative SMBH formation models, e.

g., heavy PBH seeds [39, 101, 102] or gravothermal core collapse [103–108]. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The GW signature associated with this mechanism may be detected by next-generation GW observatories such as the Einstein Telescope [98–100], and are distinguishable from alternative SMBH formation models, e. , heavy PBH seeds [39, 101, 102] or gravothermal core collapse [103– 108].

Supplemental Material

The two-point correlation function of PBHs is given by 1 + ξpbh(r) = P2(r) / (P squared 1/ν≫1 −→ (1 + ¯ω(r))3/2 (1 − ω¯(r))1/2 exp ν squared g ω¯(r) where α(η, κ) ≡ δcηκ and κ ≡ σl/σ¯s denoting the ratio of long- to short-mode variances. The two-point correlation function ξpbh(r) of PBHs is given by 1 + ξpbh(r) = P2(r) / (P squared 1/ν≫1 −→ (1 + ¯ω(r))3/2 (1 − ω¯(r))1/2 exp ν squared g ω¯(r). p. 9

Where the paper says it

1–3) For this simple modulation model, the N-point correlation function of PBHs can be computed analytically [24]. In particular, the two-point correlation function ξpbh(r) of PBHs is given by 1 + ξpbh(r) = P2(r) P 2 1 ν≫1 −→ (1 + ¯ω(r))3/2 (1 − ω¯(r))1/2 exp ν 2 g ω¯(r) 1 + ¯ω(r) , (S.

When η ≠ 0, a plateau emerges in the intermediate regime rpbh < r < rcl, where ξpbh(r) remains nearly constant at ξα. p. 1
Where the paper says it

— According to Eq. 4, for |η| ̸= 0, the long-mode-induced modulation can generate a significant two-point correlation that remains nearly constant within the clustering scale rcl ∼ 1/kl : ξpbh(r) ≃ ξα, r ≲ rcl; 0, r > rcl , (5) where the subscript denotes coupling strength α(η, κ) ≡ δcηκ with κ ≡ σl/σ¯s ≃ 0.

The axis ratios are then given by r2/r1 = r1 − 3¯e + ¯p / 1 + 3¯e + ¯p, and r3/r1 = r1 − 3¯e + ¯p − 2¯p. p. 0
Where the paper says it

SMBHs in LRDs could be of primordial origin from the high-density perturbations in the early Universe. While primordial black holes (PBHs) produced from direct collapse generally harbor small spin [18, 19] and are excluded for heavy seeds ≳ 104 M⊙ by cosmic microwave background (CMB) distortions given the nearly Gaussian primordial density perturbations [20, 21].

p. 0
Where the paper says it

SMBHs in LRDs could be of primordial origin from the high-density perturbations in the early Universe. While primordial black holes (PBHs) produced from direct collapse generally harbor small spin [18, 19] and are excluded for heavy seeds ≳ 104 M⊙ by cosmic microwave background (CMB) distortions given the nearly Gaussian primordial density perturbations [20, 21].

The ensemble-averaged squared tidal torque is given by(1/2) = (GM2cl/rvir) (Cξα)−1/2 adec(3/2) "1 − r squared / 2r squared 1/2 + 1 − r cubed / 4r cubed 1/4 - r 4 / 8r 4. The final spin of a cluster can be estimated by integrating the ensemble-averaged tidal torque over the time interval during which the cluster remains dynamically responsive to the tidal field of neighboring clusters. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The merger process may last from millions to billions of years, during which the cluster can acquire a significant amount of angular momentum from tidal fields, such that the resulting SMBH inherits a large spin. 1 summarizes the parameter space in terms of the modulation strength |η| and the comoving wavenumber ratio kl/ks, where PBH clusters can form and potentially explain the origin of LRDs (light-gray region) via runaway mergers.

The dimensionless spin parameter as as ≃ 5. p. 3
Where the paper says it

To estimate the magnitude, we consider the quadrupole interaction model [84] and a homogeneous ellipsoid model for clusters. The dimensionless spin parameter of the cluster is estimated as (see Supplemental Material): acl ≡ cJcl/GM2 cl ≃ 5.

6 (fpbh 10-5 −1/2 ξα 10 6 −1 C 20−1/6 rclon kpc−1) "1 − r squared / 2r squared 1/2 + 1 − r cubed / 4r cubed 1/4 - r 4 / 8r 4. The axis ratios are then given by r2/r1 = r1 − 3¯e + ¯p / 1 + 3¯e + ¯p, and r3/r1 = r1 − 3¯e + ¯p − 2¯p. The average values ebar ≈0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Nevertheless, accretion strongly depends on the abundance of surrounding matter and the specific accretion model. For example, chaotic accretion of short-lived episodes with random orientations tends to damp the black hole spin down to average values of a• ≃ 0.

09 and pbar ≈0 as our inputs.

Redshift Evolution of the Most Massive Black Hole

The most massive black hole mass Mmax(z) evolves with redshift z, showing different behaviors depending on the initial cluster density ncl. For Ncl = 10 5, mpbh = 30 M, vvir = 512 km s−1, the mass grows from a maximum of 4 × 10 4 M at z ≈ 6 to a maximum of 35 M at z ≈ 20. p. 3

Where the paper says it

[71] for details. 10 6 10 5 10 4 10 3 10 2 10 1 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 f [Hz] 10 18 10 17 10 16 10 15 10 14 10 13 10 12 10 11 10 10 10 9 10 8 10 7 10 6 10 5 10 4 10 3 ­ g w h 2 Ultimate DECIGO BBO LISA TianQin Taiji ET CEaLIGO+aVIRGO(run 3) GW spectra (fpbh = 5:66 £ 10¡5 ; ncl = 2:0 £ 10 8 pc¡3 ; vvir = 512 km=s) Ncl = 10 4 ; mpbh = 10M¯ Ncl = 10 4 ; mpbh = 30M¯ Ncl = 10 5 ; mpbh = 30M¯ FIG.

For Ncl = 10 4, mpbh = 30 M, vvir = 238 km s−1, the mass evolves from a maximum of 4 × 10 4 M at z ≈ 6 to a maximum of 25 M at z ≈ 20. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The first peak arises due to the initially large abundance of small-mass PBHs in the first stage in Fig. The third stage explains the emergence of the peak at low frequencies: The strength of the GW signal is proportional to a positive power of the chirp mass, while the maximum frequency is inversely proportional to the total mass.

Timescales Associated with PBH Clusters

The coalescence timescale due to GW emission is given by tgw ≈ (3c/5r 4) p(1 + ε)(7/2)/(1 − ε)(1/2) (85 G 3(mi + mj) squared mimj c 5 v squared vir 2/7). The disruption timescale by a third PBH is tdisrup ≈ 1/(nclσpvvir). p. 2

Where the paper says it

10 using a full-conditioning method for sampling [64]. For the simulation to be valid, it can be justified that the coalescence time of two PBHs is much shorter than the disruption timescale caused by a third PBH, so that three-body interactions can be ignored during mergers.

Without mergers and losing energy through emitting GWs, an isolated PBH cluster will gradually shrink and evaporate when some PBHs undergo multiple gravitational scatterings during multiple (two-body) relaxation timescales to exceed the escape velocity, and this defines the evaporation timescale of a cluster tevap ≈ Γ trelx ≈ 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The initial cluster decouples with number density ncl and PBHs of monochromatic mass mpbh. As PBH mergers are predominantly governed by two-body interactions, and binaries coalesce via the emission of gravitational radiation, we employ the Smoluchowski coagulation equation [54–56] to study the population evolution and the timescale leading to central massive black holes: d dt ni = 1 2 X j+k=i njnkKjk − ni N Xcl−i j=1 njKij , (10) where ni is the number density of PBH with mass mi = impbh (i = 1, 2, .

4 Myr. The relaxation time trelx ≈ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Single PBHs virialized in a cluster with number density ncl will form binaries via the emission of gravitational radiation during close encounters and eventually merge. The fraction of PBHs that will coalesce over a time period ∆t can be ∗ wxfeng@mail.

1 Ncl ln Ncl rvir vvir. p. 0
Where the paper says it

cn computed as: ∆ncl ncl = 1 2 σmerg vrel ncl ∆t , (1) where σmerg = 2π 85π 6 √ 2 2/7G2 (m1+m2) 10/7m 2/7 1 m 2/7 2 c 10/7v 18/7 rel (2) is the merging cross section [25–27]. Here, G is the Newton’s constant, c is the speed of light, m1 and m2 are the masses of the two PBHs in a close encounter, and their relative velocity is vrel ≈ vvir = p GMcl/rvir, the virial velocity of the cluster, where Mcl is the cluster mass within the virial radius rvir.

In reality, the seed effect [109–111] of a PBH cluster will accumulate extra dark matter or baryons and increase the escape velocity such that Γ ∼ 3000 (10 6) if the accumulated mass is comparable to (two times of) the cluster. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the simulation, the runaway merger time of the PBH cluster is conservative, as we have neglected the effect of mass segregation due to dynamical friction. When mass segregation is included [71], the runaway merger can be even faster, as low-velocity massive PBHs will sink toward the center, and increase the merging cross section.

The upper limit of this interval is approximated by the typical time before the cluster fully merges into SMBH: Jcl = Z tmerg / tdec a(3/2) dec a(3/2) dt = 2p/(8πGρeq/3)(0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here, G is the Newton’s constant, c is the speed of light, m1 and m2 are the masses of the two PBHs in a close encounter, and their relative velocity is vrel ≈ vvir = p GMcl/rvir, the virial velocity of the cluster, where Mcl is the cluster mass within the virial radius rvir. To form a SMBH via mergers of an initial population of Ncl PBHs of equal mass mpbh, we can estimate the timescale over which half of the PBHs in the cluster coalesce into larger ones, by tmerg ∼ 1 ncl σmerg vvir ≃ 1.

85fpbhξα)(−3/2) ln p 1 + amerg/aeq + pamerg/aeq p 1 + 1/(0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In particular, the condition 0. 85fpbhξα > 1 (as shown in Fig.

85fpbhξα) + p 1/(0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In particular, the condition 0. 85fpbhξα > 1 (as shown in Fig.

85fpbhξα). p. 1
Where the paper says it

In particular, the condition 0. 85fpbhξα > 1 (as shown in Fig.

GW Spectrum Features

The stochastic GW background associated with the PBH merging processes has two peaks: one at low frequencies and the other at relatively high frequencies. The first peak arises due to the initially large abundance of small-mass PBHs in the first stage in Fig. p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 frequencies and the other at relatively high frequencies. The first peak arises due to the initially large abundance of small-mass PBHs in the first stage in Fig.

2. The third stage explains the emergence of the peak at low frequencies. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The first peak arises due to the initially large abundance of small-mass PBHs in the first stage in Fig. The third stage explains the emergence of the peak at low frequencies: The strength of the GW signal is proportional to a positive power of the chirp mass, while the maximum frequency is inversely proportional to the total mass.

The infrared behavior of the gravitational wave spectrum follows a ∼ f cubed scaling, which is much steeper than the f 2/3 scaling of a single binary inspiral event. p. 3
Where the paper says it

After the binary formation at relatively low redshifts, mergers of PBHs with their central SMBH contribute significantly at low frequencies, thereby enhancing the GW spectrum. The infrared behavior of the gravitational wave spectrum follows a ∼ f 3 scaling, which is much steeper than the f 2/3 scaling of a single binary inspiral event.

Accretion Growth and Spin from Tidal Fields

The mass M• and spin J• of the most massive black hole are determined mainly by mergers and mass accretion. The enhancement of mass growth through Eddington accretion is given by M•/mpbh = Fmerg exp (ϵL (1 − ϵM)) / (ϵM τacc tacc). p. 3

Where the paper says it

A small difference in spin results in a substantial difference in radiative efficiency. The enhancement of mass growth through Eddington accretion is given by [80] M• mpbh = Fmerg exp ϵL (1 − ϵM) ϵM τacc tacc , (12) where Fmerg ∝ Ncl is the merger enhancement factor, ϵL the accretion luminosity efficiency, ϵM the radiative efficiency, τacc ≈ 0.

A small difference in spin results in a substantial difference in radiative efficiency. p. 3
Where the paper says it

42, while ϵM(0. A small difference in spin results in a substantial difference in radiative efficiency.

Crucially, a slower mass growth rate can also reconcile the cumulative mass density accreted onto black holes with the SMBH mass density at z ≃ 4–5, based on the Sołtan argument [22] if their bolometric luminosities are estimated via spectral energy distribution fitting employing dust-obscured AGN models [23]. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Thus, a sufficiently heavy seed is favored at the beginning of the accretion phase to explain those LRDs hosting 105–8 M⊙ SMBHs in the first billion years. Crucially, a slower mass growth rate can also reconcile the cumulative mass density accreted onto black holes with the SMBH mass density at z ≃ 4–5, based on the Sołtan argument [22], if their bolometric luminosities are estimated via spectral energy distribution fitting employing dust-obscured AGN models [23].

The PBH cluster acquires significant spin through interactions with tidal fields induced by other clusters, due to its extended merger history and non-sphericity. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Regardless of accretion, our model can generate SMBHs with large spin, even if the PBHs had zero spin at their formation [19, 83]. The PBH cluster acquires significant spin through interactions with tidal fields induced by other clusters, due to its extended merger history and non-sphericity.

To estimate the magnitude, we consider the quadrupole interaction model [84] and a homogeneous ellipsoid model for clusters. p. 3
Where the paper says it

As a result, the spin of the SMBH reflects the residual spin of the cluster after mergers. To estimate the magnitude, we consider the quadrupole interaction model [84] and a homogeneous ellipsoid model for clusters.

The dimensionless spin parameter of the cluster is estimated as acl ≡ cJcl/GM2cl ≃ 5. p. 3
Where the paper says it

To estimate the magnitude, we consider the quadrupole interaction model [84] and a homogeneous ellipsoid model for clusters. The dimensionless spin parameter of the cluster is estimated as (see Supplemental Material): acl ≡ cJcl/GM2 cl ≃ 5.

6 (fpbh 10-5 −1/2 ξα 10 6 −1 C 20−1/6 rclon kpc−1) "1 − r squared / 2r squared 1/2 + 1 − r cubed / 4r cubed 1/4 - r 4 / 8r 4. To explain SMBHs of 105–8 M⊙ in the LRDs (light-gray in Fig. p. 3
Where the paper says it

53 on average. To explain SMBHs of 105–8 M⊙ in the LRDs (light-gray in Fig.

1), the runaway timescale trm must be sufficiently short, trm ≤ftr mchiral Gyr (z ≥ 5). p. 3
Where the paper says it

To explain SMBHs of 105–8 M⊙ in the LRDs (light-gray in Fig. 1), the runaway timescale trm must be sufficiently short, trm ≲ 1 Gyr (z ≳ 5).

Remarkably, the cluster spin acquired through tidal interactions in this region exceeds the Kerr limit, implying a nearly maximal residual spin (a• ≃ 1) of the SMBH after mergers. p. 3
Where the paper says it

1), the runaway timescale trm must be sufficiently short, trm ≲ 1 Gyr (z ≳ 5). Remarkably, the cluster spin acquired through tidal interactions in this region exceeds the Kerr limit, implying a nearly maximal residual spin (a• ≃ 1) of the SMBH after mergers.

The remaining PBHs, forming extreme mass ratio inspiral systems with the central SMBH, cannot merge until the GW carries away all the spin remnant of cluster. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Remarkably, the cluster spin acquired through tidal interactions in this region exceeds the Kerr limit, implying a nearly maximal residual spin (a• ≃ 1) of the SMBH after mergers. The remaining PBHs, forming extreme mass ratio inspiral systems with the central SMBH, cannot merge until the GW carries away all the spin remnant of cluster.

The most stringent constraints on long-wavelength perturbations Φl arise from CMB spectral distortions [91–95]. These constraints can be evaded through the long-short mode coupling, as the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, σl ≲ 0.0064, allowing the µdistortion constraint to be satisfied while maintaining a sufficient PBH abundance fpbh ∼ 10-5. The y-distortion constraint is weaker than that from µ-distortions in the mass range 105–8 M⊙ for LRDs, while it primarily excludes PBH clusters that would result in ultra-massive black holes, M• ≳ 10 11 M⊙, the purple region in Fig. p. 4

Where the paper says it

0064, allowing the µdistortion constraint to be satisfied while maintaining a sufficient PBH abundance fpbh ∼ 10−5 , which will ultimately result in the SMBH population. The y-distortion constraint is weaker than that from µ-distortions in the mass range 105–8 M⊙ for LRDs, while it primarily excludes PBH clusters that would result in ultra-massive black holes, M• ≳ 1011 M⊙, the purple region in Fig.

1. When mass segregation is included [71], the runaway merger can be even faster, as low-velocity massive PBHs will sink toward the center, and increase the merging cross section. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the simulation, the runaway merger time of the PBH cluster is conservative, as we have neglected the effect of mass segregation due to dynamical friction. When mass segregation is included [71], the runaway merger can be even faster, as low-velocity massive PBHs will sink toward the center, and increase the merging cross section.

The primary constraint on the PBH abundance then arises only from the SMBH mass density of ρ• ∼ 10 5 M⊙ Mpc−3 in the local universe, currently accounting for fpbh ∼ 10-5 dark matter density – consistent with our parameter choice. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Especially, following successive mergers of PBHs in the cluster, their number density declines significantly over time, making them less subject to these observational constraints. The primary constraint on the PBH abundance then arises only from the SMBH mass density of ρ• ∼ 105 M⊙ Mpc−3 in the local universe, currently accounting for fpbh ∼ 10−5 dark matter density – consistent with our parameter choice.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Accurate prediction of Supermassive Black Hole properties in LRDs: The improved system can model how a central SMBH inherits a large spin due to tidal fields from neighboring clusters, as described by the spin of the SMBH reflects the residual spin of the cluster after mergers.

  2. Simulation of Gravitational Wave Signatures: The system can generate distinct gravitational wave backgrounds with two peaks, one at low frequencies and one at relatively high frequencies, which are characteristic signatures of this PBH merging mechanism.

  3. Parameter Space Exploration for Formation Scenarios: The AI can map out the parameter space defined by modulation strength |eta| and wavenumber ratio kl/ks to identify regions consistent with the formation of high-spin SMBHs in LRDs through runaway mergers.

  4. Constraint Evasion Modeling: The system can quantify how long-short mode coupling allows for the evasion of cosmic microwave background distortions, as it demonstrates that the variance of long modes in our scenario is sufficiently small, sigma l less than 0.0064, allowing the mu distortion constraint to be satisfied.

  5. High-Density Cluster Generation Modeling: The system can model how dense clusters are generated by the modulation of the overdensity field, specifically noting that clusters of this kind may arise from the modulation of the overdensity field at the PBH formation scale (ks) by long-wavelength (kl) modes on larger scales.

  6. Runaway Merger Timescale Estimation: The improved system can calculate timescales for SMBH growth, such as estimating the runaway merging timescale trm ≈ 0.2/nclK00 for completing the merger, allowing it to predict whether a mass M• is reached within the first billion years after the Big Bang.

  7. Spin Evolution Under Mergers: The system can track how cluster spin evolves by integrating the ensemble-averaged tidal torque over time, estimating the dimensionless spin parameter as as ≈ 5.6 fpbh 10-5-1/2 ξα 106-1 C 20-1/6 rcl 10 kpc-1.

Abstract

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations have identified a class of compact galaxies at high redshifts (4 z 8), dubbed "little red dots" (LRDs). The supermassive black holes (SMBHs) of 10 5-8,M in LRDs favor a heavy-seed origin. We propose a mechanism for their formation: Clusters of primordial black holes, formed through long-short mode coupling on small scales in the early Universe, undergo sequential mergers over extended timescales. This mechanism can evade cosmic microwave background distortions and result in heavy-seed SMBHs via runaway mergers. We employ Monte Carlo simulations to solve the Smoluchowski coagulation equation and determine the runaway merging timescale. The resulting stochastic gravitational wave background offers a distinctive signature of this process, and our model suggests highly spinning SMBHs at their formation if they inherit the spin residual of the cluster from tidal fields.

Sources

Related papers