High-Quality Ultra-Fast Total Scattering and Pair Distribution Function Data using an X-ray Free Electron Laser
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "High-Quality Ultra-Fast Total Scattering and Pair Distribution Function Data using an X-ray Free Electron Laser".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. High-quality total scattering data can be obtained from single 30 fs X-ray pulses using an XFEL This work shows that this potential has been realized using the HED scientific instrument at the European XFEL and presents normalised total scattering data for 0.35Å−1 <Q< 16.6Å−1 and their PDFs from a broad spectrum of materials, including crystalline, nanocrystalline and amorphous solids, liquids, and clusters in solution Experimental Setup The experiments were carried out in interaction chamber one (IC1), which operates under a < 10−4 mbar vacuum, thus eliminating background contributions from air scattering The setup utilized the High Energy Density (HED) scientific instrument at the European XFEL in Hamburg A Varex 4343CT detector and a Jungfrau detector were used, providing a Q range of 0.35 to 16.6 Å−1 with an incident X-ray energy of 24.075 keV The maximum Q results in an approximate real-space resolution of 0.19 Å A tilted detector geometry was used to maximize counting statistics in the high-Q region.
Kai: Data Processing and Calibration The data reduction pipeline involved azimuthal integration of the data from the individual detectors to yield the intensity as a function of Q This process included scaling and merging of the individual Ix(Q) to form a merged Imerged(Q) The pair distribution function was calculated by subtracting background and performing a Fourier transform.
Mira: Detector calibration was performed using pyFAI, specifically using the pyfai-calib2 tool The integration involved normalizing each dataset to the measured intensity on a diagnostic silicon diode upstream of the sample to account for pulse-to-pulse variation in intensity.
Kai: Material Versatility The methodology was applied to a diverse set of samples including highly crystalline powders (Si, CeO2, LaB6), a nanocrystalline powder (TiO2), amorphous solids (silica glass and an Fe78B13Si9 metallic glass), a pure liquid (water), and an atomic cluster in solution For crystalline standards like NIST Si 640b, Rietveld refinement yielded a high-quality fit with an atomic displacement parameter, Biso(Si), of 0.328(7) Å2.
Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, "High-Quality Ultra-Fast Total Scattering and Pair Distribution Function Data using an X-ray Free Electron Laser," the authors demonstrate they can get high quality, quantitative total scattering and PDFs from single thirty femtosecond X-ray pulses.
Mira: They achieved this by using the HED scientific instrument at the European XFEL to obtain normalized total scattering data for a Q range of zero point three five angstrom minus one up to sixteen point six angstrom minus one across a broad spectrum of materials.
Lev: This is significant because it shows that we can get these detailed local structural insights from just one very short X-ray pulse, which is key when studying those ultrafast structural changes in complex materials.
Kai: They also showed that the maximum Q they reached is nearly twice what’s routine and about a third higher than for less demanding measurements used in pump probe experiments.
Mira: This level of data quality is now enough to produce PDFs with reasonable real-space resolution for quantitative studies of disordering structural processes, which is what they aimed for.
Lev: The implication is that we can finally get the detail needed to study how things start to lose their order over time in a way that's relevant for real hardware testing and understanding those ultrafast phenomena.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at that paper about "High-Quality Ultra-Fast Total Scattering and Pair Distribution Function Data using an X-ray Free Electron Laser."
Mira: It shows they got really good, quantitative data from just one thirty femtosecond X-ray pulse.
Kai: Yeah, they used the HED instrument at the European XFEL to get total scattering data for a wide Q range, from zero point three five angstrom minus one up to sixteen point six angstrom minus one.
Mira: And they tested it on everything from perfect crystals and nanocrystalline powders all the way down to liquid water and even an atomic cluster in solution.
Kai: The real takeaway here is that this method gives us high quality, quantitative total scattering and pair distribution function data from a single thirty femtosecond X-ray pulse.
Mira: They showed that the maximum Q they reached is nearly twice what’s routine for these kinds of measurements and about a third higher than what you get from those less stringent pump probe experiments.
Kai: This level of data quality means we can finally make PDFs with reasonable real space resolution for quantitative studies of how structures start to disorder.
Mira: It’s promising because the authors suggest that this data is now sufficient to do quantitative studies on structural processes, even for complex materials.
Kai: But they also pointed out what the next step is, which is linking these measurements to pump probe techniques with delays of tens of femtoseconds or longer.
Mira: And they mentioned that the quality of PDF data for solutions means it’s relevant for studying rapid changes in molecules in liquid.
Kai: It opens up a lot about how we can study the structural dynamics of complex materials using XFELs, which is a huge step forward.
Department of Chemistry, University of Copenhagen · Diamond Light Source Ltd · Department of Chemistry, University Science Site, Durham University · Dipartimento di Scienza e Alta Tecnologia and ToSca Lab, University of Insubria · Istituto di Cristallografia and ToSca Lab CNR Como Italy · Center for Integrated Materials Research Department of Chemistry and iNANO Aarhus University · Department of Chemistry Inorganic Chemistry Laboratory University of Oxford South Parks Road Oxford UK · School of Mathematics and Physics Queen’s University Belfast University Road Belfast UK · Institute of Earth and Environmental Sciences University of Freiburg Freiburg Germany · HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics Konkoly-Thege Mikl϶s ut 29-33 Budapest Hungary · Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY Hamburg Germany · Friedrich-Alexander University Erlangen’Nürnberg Staudtstrasse 3 Erlangen Germany · Department of Physics Clarendon Laboratory University of Oxford Parks Road Oxford UK · Center for Solid State Physics and New Materials Institute of Physics Belgrade University of Belgrade Serbia · London Centre for Nanotechnology University College London London WC1E 6BT UK · European XFEL Holzkoppel 4 Schenefeld Germany
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2025-04-30
Updated: 2025-06-13
DOI: 10.1107/S205225252500538X
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: High-quality total scattering data can be obtained from single 30 fs X-ray pulses using an XFEL This work shows that this potential has been realized using the HED scientific instrument at the…
Key concepts
- Total Scattering Data
- This data describes how X-rays scatter off a material across different momentum transfers (Q). It provides a comprehensive picture of the material's structure, encompassing both long-range order and short-range atomic arrangements. It is derived by integrating the intensity measured at various Q values.
- Pair Distribution Function (PDF)
- The PDF is a mathematical tool used to characterize the local atomic structure of materials. It shows how frequently atoms are found at a certain distance from each other, revealing information about short-range order and local structural details, which can be compared against theoretical models.
- XFEL Pulse Duration
- The experiment utilized extremely short X-ray pulses lasting approximately 30 femtoseconds (fs). This ultra-fast nature allows for the collection of high-quality scattering data from a single interaction event, enabling high momentum transfer measurements that are difficult to achieve otherwise.
- Real-Space Resolution
- This refers to the spatial detail achievable in reconstructing the material's structure. The study achieved an approximate resolution of 0.19 Å, which is sufficient for quantitatively studying structural disorder and local atomic arrangements in complex materials.
Terminology
Summary
High-quality total scattering data can be obtained from single 30 fs X-ray pulses using an XFEL This work shows that this potential has been realized using the HED scientific instrument at the European XFEL and presents normalised total scattering data for 0. p. 3 Achieving this goal involves addressing three primary challenges:
arranging detectors to mitigate the lower-than-ideal X-ray energies of XFELs, improving the experimental environment to
reduce backgrounds and designing the experimental protocols to maximise the efficiency of the measurements. This work presents our efforts to achieve high-quality, ultra-fast total scattering and PDF data at the High Energy Density
(HED) scientific instrument at the European XFEL. Here, we show that this potential has been realised using the HED scientific instrument at the European XFEL
and present normalised total scattering data for 0. 35Å−1 < Q < 16.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Setup
The experiments were carried out in interaction chamber one (IC1), which operates under a < 10−4 mbar vacuum, thus eliminating background contributions from air scattering The setup utilized the High Energy Density (HED) scientific instrument at the European XFEL in Hamburg A Varex 4343CT detector and a Jungfrau detector were used, providing a Q range of 0.35 to 16.6 Å−1 with an incident X-ray energy of 24. p. 4 , 2021), placed to maximise the 2θ coverage and providing
a Q range of ~0. 6 Å−1 with an incident X-ray energy of 24. 075 keV and beam energy of ~150 µJ (Figure 1a). The
maximum Q results in an approximate real-space resolution of 0. This work presents our efforts to achieve high-quality, ultra-fast total scattering and PDF data at the High Energy Density
(HED) scientific instrument at the European XFEL. Here, we describe the experimental setup in detail, including the use of
a tilted detector geometry designed to maximise counting statistics in the high-Q region.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Processing and Calibration
The data reduction pipeline involved azimuthal integration of the data from the individual detectors to yield the intensity as a function of Q This process included scaling and merging of the individual Ix(Q) to form a merged Imerged(Q) The pair distribution function was calculated by subtracting background and performing a Fourier transform. Detector calibration was performed using pyFAI, specifically using the pyfai-calib2 tool The integration involved normalizing each dataset to the measured intensity on a diagnostic silicon diode upstream of the sample to account for pulse-to-pulse variation in intensity. p. 6 In both cases, we also normalised each pixel
to absolute solid angle before integration to simplify the combination of the signals from the two detectors. Additionally,
we normalised each dataset to the measured intensity on a diagnostic silicon diode upstream of the sample to account for
pulse-to-pulse variation in intensity.Where the paper says it
Material Versatility
The methodology was applied to a diverse set of samples including highly crystalline powders (Si, CeO2, LaB6), a nanocrystalline powder (TiO2), amorphous solids (silica glass and an Fe78B13Si9 metallic glass), a pure liquid (water), and an atomic cluster in solution For crystalline standards like NIST Si 640b, Rietveld refinement yielded a high-quality fit with an atomic displacement parameter, Biso(Si), of 0.328(7) Å2. p. 8 045% ) and
an atomic displacement parameter, Biso(Si), of 0. 328(7) Å2 using a fixed lattice parameter (certified by NIST) of 5. 9
Results and Discussion
We applied our methodology to a diverse set of samples to show that quantitative data over a wide range of Q can be
obtained across different material types (Figure 3). We investigated highly crystalline powders (Si, CeO2, LaB6 and Ag
behenate), a nanocrystalline powder (TiO2), amorphous solids (silica glass and an Fe78B13Si9 metallic glass), a pure liquid
(water) and an atomic cluster in solution (aqueous tungsten Keggin, [W12O40]
6−).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key Findings on Resolution and Quality
The key result of this work is that high-quality, quantitative total scattering and PDFs have been obtained from single 30 fs X-ray pulses The authors demonstrated that the maximum Q is nearly twice what is currently routine and a third higher than has been achieved for the less stringent ΔS(Q) measurements often used for pump–probe experiments. These data are now sufficient to produce PDFs with reasonable real-space resolution for quantitative studies of disordering structural processes
Outlook
The outlook is highly promising—strengthened by the results presented in this work and the continued advancement toward higher-energy X-rays at XFEL facilities The authors are confident that total scattering and PDF measurements at XFELs will steadily improve, offering increasingly profound insights into the structural dynamics of complex materials. The next obvious step is to link these measurements to pump–probe techniques where delays of tens of femtoseconds and longer can be used to study optical-electronic-phononic induced changes. The quality of PDF data available from solutions shows that the measurements are also highly relevant for those studying rapid conformational changes in molecules in solution. p. 8 9
Results and Discussion
We applied our methodology to a diverse set of samples to show that quantitative data over a wide range of Q can be
obtained across different material types (Figure 3). We investigated highly crystalline powders (Si, CeO2, LaB6 and Ag
behenate), a nanocrystalline powder (TiO2), amorphous solids (silica glass and an Fe78B13Si9 metallic glass), a pure liquid
(water) and an atomic cluster in solution (aqueous tungsten Keggin, [W12O40]
6−). We conclusively
show that high-quality data can be obtained from a single ~30 fs XFEL pulse for multiple different sample types. Our efforts
not only significantly increase the existing maximum reported Q-range for an S(Q) measured at an XFEL but also mean that
XFELs are now a viable X-ray source for the broad community of people using reciprocal space total scattering and PDF
methods in their research.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Automated data processing pipeline for XFEL total scattering data: The development of a robust data reduction pipeline involving azimuthal integration, scaling and merging of individual detector intensities into a merged intensity function to calculate the pair distribution function will allow AI systems to rapidly generate high-quality PDFs from single XFEL pulses.
-
High-resolution structural analysis capability: Improved AI systems can perform small-box PDF refinement and joint reciprocal real space refinement on total scattering data, enabling the extraction of atomic displacement parameters like Biso(Si) with a high degree of precision from ultra-fast measurements.
-
Material structure classification: AI systems can analyze the resulting PDFs to quantitatively compare measured structural data against reference values from synchrotron sources, which is crucial for reliably assessing the quality and accuracy of ultra-fast total scattering data across different material types (crystalline, amorphous, liquids).
-
Disordering process characterization: The system can be used to model and extract parameters related to disordering processes such as crystallisation or amorphisation by analyzing the Q-range dependence of the PDF, capturing
fleeting moments
in atomic motion. -
Solution-based structural modeling: AI systems can use cluster refinement within frameworks like DiffPy-CMI to analyze data from solution samples, allowing for the extraction of atomic structures and parameters such as Biso(W) and Biso(O) from the pair distribution function.
Abstract
High-quality total scattering data, a key tool for understanding atomic-scale structure in disordered materials, require stable instrumentation and access to high momentum transfers. This is now routine at dedicated synchrotron instrumentation using high-energy X-ray beams, but it is very challenging to measure a total scattering dataset in less than a few microseconds. This limits their effectiveness for capturing structural changes that occur at the much faster timescales of atomic motion. Current X-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs) provide femtosecond-pulsed X-ray beams with maximum energies of approximately 24 keV, giving the potential to measure total scattering and the attendant pair distribution functions (PDFs) on femtosecond timescales. Here, we show that this potential has been realised using the HED scientific instrument at the European XFEL and present normalised total scattering data for 0.35 Å-1 < Q < 16.6 Å-1 and their PDFs from a broad spectrum of materials, including crystalline, nanocrystalline and amorphous solids, liquids, and clusters in solution. We analyse the data using a variety of methods, including Rietveld refinement, small-box PDF refinement, joint reciprocal-real space refinement, cluster refinement, and Debye scattering analysis. The resolution function of the setup is also characterised. We conclusively show that high-quality data can be obtained from a single approximately 30 fs XFEL pulse. Our efforts not only significantly increase the existing maximum reported Q-range for an S(Q) measured at an XFEL but also mean that XFELs are now a viable X-ray source for the broad community of people using reciprocal space total scattering and PDF methods in their research.
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion