A model for cholera with infectiousness of deceased individuals and vaccination

arXiv:2504.07432 · q-bio.PE · Submitted 2025-04-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Genomics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest computational biology and genomics papers.

Ines: We're looking at the paper: "A model for cholera with infectiousness of deceased individuals and vaccination".

Marcus: Here's the gist of the paper. A cholera transmission model is formulated that incorporates water-borne and horizontal transmissions as well as infectivity of deceased individuals because this comprehensive approach allows us to evaluate the extent to which such a contamination route is hazardous in the presence of targeted control measures.

Ines: Model Formulation The model starts from a classic SIRW model for water-borne transmission of cholera and introduces an additional compartment, D, to account for individuals having died from cholera but whose body are still infectious.

Marcus: Furthermore, an explicit compartment is considered for vaccinated individuals, assuming that the vaccine is both imperfect and waning.

Ines: The state variables include S Number of susceptible individuals, I Number of infected and infectious individuals, R Number of recovered immune individuals, V Number of vaccinated individuals, D Number of infectious dead individuals, and W Concentration of V.

Title and authors: Ines: Let's talk about this paper, "A model for cholera with infectiousness of deceased individuals and vaccination." The title tells you immediately that it’s looking at a specific set of complexities: water-borne spread, horizontal transmission, the fact that the dead can be infectious, and vaccination.

Marcus: The authors are Annour Saad Abdramanea Julien Arinob Patrick Mimphis Tchepmo Djomegnic Mahamat Saleh Daoussa Haggara from the Laboratory L2MIAS in Chad and University of Manitoba, Winnipeg. It’s a collaborative effort between different mathematical modeling backgrounds, which is always interesting to see.

Yuki: As a population geneticist, I'm interested in how they structure their model because it shows an attempt to capture the real-world dynamics of cholera transmission beyond the simplest assumptions about infection rates.

Ines: They are trying to create a framework that isn't just a textbook SIR model but something that reflects how cholera actually behaves in contaminated environments, like what we see with waterborne diseases.

Marcus: What they are doing is setting up state variables for susceptible individuals, infected individuals, recovered immune individuals, vaccinated people, infectious dead people, and the concentration of the cholera bacteria in the water. That’s a lot of moving parts to keep track of.

Yuki: And that's where I wonder how much real-world data they can plug into these compartments to make their predictions accurate for any specific region or population.

Ines: They are trying to see if this structure helps us understand the underlying biology, like how the bacteria behave in different water concentrations and how transmission changes when you introduce vaccination.

Marcus: And the key thing they are investigating mathematically is whether these different routes of transmission can lead to some kind of stable outcome or if the system gets stuck in a certain state.

The paper's summary: Ines: So, the core summary of "A model for cholera with infectiousness of deceased individuals and vaccination" is that they formulate a model that includes water-borne and horizontal transmissions, along with the infectivity of deceased individuals. They also include an Allee effect for the bacteria in the environment and imperfect and waning vaccination.

Marcus: The mathematical analysis focuses on deriving a reproduction number equation for this system, R v, which is how we measure the disease's spread in the presence of vaccination. It looks complicated because it involves terms related to environmental concentration, infection rates, and vaccine effectiveness.

Yuki: I'm paying attention to that reproduction number because it’s usually our primary tool for predicting whether an epidemic will grow or die down once we implement control measures like vaccination.

Ines: And the paper shows that in the presence of this reproduction number, there's a result about its relationship with the basic reproduction number, R zero which is R v less than or equal to R zero. But it gets interesting when you consider the vaccine effectiveness.

Marcus: The analysis also shows that if the vaccine has any effectiveness at all, say sigma is greater than zero, then this inequality becomes strict, meaning the disease spread is less controlled by vaccination alone.

Yuki: That makes sense in theory; if you have imperfect vaccines and waning immunity, you always have some residual risk that a large enough population can still sustain the spread.

Ines: Then they go on to discuss endemic equilibria, which are basically the steady states where the infection level doesn't drop to zero. They find one specific point, Em, that is locally stable when the water concentration W is greater than some threshold K C.

Marcus: And they also find a subthreshold endemic equilibrium, Eu that exists when the reproduction number with vaccination, R v, is less than one and the water concentration W falls within a certain range, between zero and some value called A C.

The paper's improvements: Ines: The authors suggest several things they think could be improved in the model structure. One big thing is adding an environmental Allee effect for the bacteria, which they say is important because it shows that once a macroscopic endemic state is reached, you can't just rely on vaccination to eliminate the disease.

Marcus: They highlight that WASH interventions—water, sanitation, and hygiene—have a stronger impact on reducing total incidence than vaccination when the environment is already severely contaminated at the start of an outbreak. That really shifts the focus of control strategy.

Yuki: That suggests a trade-off; intense environmental cleaning might make aggressive vaccination less critical in certain scenarios because you have to tackle the source first.

Ines: They also point out that there's a trade-off between sanitary infrastructure and vaccination campaigns; a deficiency in sanitation can be balanced by an aggressive, rapid vaccination effort, and vice versa. It’s not an either/or situation.

Marcus: Another key area they explore is the effect of transmission during funeral rites, which they model by varying parameters like the interment rate e and the transmission parameter beta D. They also assess control scenarios like WASH or Safe and dignified burials.

Yuki: That’s interesting because it brings in human behavior into the equation; how people handle death plays a role in how fast the disease spreads, which is something we often overlook in purely biological models.

Conclusion: Ines: To wrap up, the authors of "A model for cholera with infectiousness of deceased individuals and vaccination" show that once an endemic state is established, vaccination alone isn't enough to clear the disease; you need active water and sanitation interventions.

Marcus: They also found that the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy, and waning is complex, showing how those factors interact to influence whether we see a stable endemic state or not.

Yuki: I think what stands out is how they combine these elements—the environmental Allee effect with the vaccination dynamics—to show that no single intervention works perfectly for cholera control.

Ines: They confirm that there's no simple solution, just a lot of interacting factors to consider when trying to manage a waterborne disease like cholera.

Marcus: So, the key is recognizing that the environment itself has a role in sustaining the problem, and we need multi-faceted approaches rather than relying on just one tool.

Yuki: That's right; understanding those interactions helps us design interventions that are actually effective against this kind of disease.

Laboratory L2MIAS, University of N’Djamena, Chad · Department of Mathematics, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, Canada · School of Mathematical and Statistical Sciences, North-West University

q-bio.PE

Submitted: 2025-04-10

Updated: 2026-11-02

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 74/100

The gist: A cholera transmission model is formulated that incorporates water-borne and horizontal transmissions as well as infectivity of deceased individuals because this comprehensive approach allows us to…

Key concepts

D compartment
This compartment tracks individuals who have died from cholera but whose bodies remain infectious. This accounts for a specific route of transmission where the deceased can spread the disease to others, adding complexity beyond standard SIR models.
Reproduction Number (Rv)
Rv measures the average number of secondary infections caused by one infected person in a population with existing vaccination and environmental factors. The analysis shows Rv must be less than R0 for disease control, and its calculation is complex due to multiple transmission routes.
Environmental Allee Effect
This concept describes how the presence of the cholera bacteria in the water environment can create a threshold below which population growth (or transmission) becomes impossible. If contamination drops too low, even with some immunity, the disease cannot be maintained.
WASH Interventions
WASH refers to Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene interventions. The study found that when environmental contamination is high at the start of an outbreak, intense WASH measures are more effective at reducing total cases than vaccination efforts alone.

Terminology

Summary

A cholera transmission model is formulated that incorporates water-borne and horizontal transmissions as well as infectivity of deceased individuals because this comprehensive approach allows us to evaluate the extent to which such a contamination route is hazardous in the presence of targeted control measures. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The objective of our study is therefore to extend a classic cholera model by incorporating an Allee effect, modelling vaccination dynamics and considering deceased individuals as a potential source of contamination. This comprehensive approach allows us to evaluate the extent to which such a contamination route is hazardous in the presence of targeted control measures.

Model Formulation

The model starts from a classic SIRW model for water-borne transmission of cholera and introduces an additional compartment, D, to account for individuals having died from cholera but whose body are still infectious. Furthermore, an explicit compartment is considered for vaccinated individuals, assuming that the vaccine is both imperfect and waning. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2 Model formulation We start from a classic SIRW model for water-borne transmission of cholera including human to human transmission and introduce an additional compartment, D, to account for individuals having died from cholera but whose body are still infectious. Furthermore, we consider an explicit compartment for vaccinated individuals, assuming that the vaccine is both imperfect and waning, as was studied for a classic SIRS model in [7].

The state variables include S Number of susceptible individuals, I Number of infected and infectious individuals, R Number of recovered immune individuals, V Number of vaccinated individuals, D Number of infectious dead individuals, and W Concentration of V. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Variable Description S Number of susceptible individuals I Number of infected and infectious individuals R Number of recovered immune individuals V Number of vaccinated individuals NH Total number of (live) humans D Number of infectious dead individuals W Concentration of V. cholerae in water Table 1: State variables of the SIRVDW model.

cholerae in water. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Variable Description S Number of susceptible individuals I Number of infected and infectious individuals R Number of recovered immune individuals V Number of vaccinated individuals NH Total number of (live) humans D Number of infectious dead individuals W Concentration of V. cholerae in water Table 1: State variables of the SIRVDW model.

Mathematical Analysis

The reproduction number in the presence of vaccination is given by Rv = erCβI + δrCβD + ζ(e + ηδ)βW / (θ + (1 − σ)v + dH)erC(γ + δ + dH). The analysis shows that Rv ≤ R0, with the inequality being strict whenever the vaccine has any effectiveness (σ > 0). p. 7

Where the paper says it

5) that Rv = R0 θ + (1 − σ)v + dH θ + v + dH . 7) Since σ ∈ [0, 1], it follows that Rv ≤ R0, with the inequality being strict whenever the vaccine has any effectiveness (σ > 0).

Proposition 3. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We defer discussion of this issue to Appendix E; suffices to say here that even if it is a possibility, it does not occur under usual parameter regimes. The following proposition summarises what is known about equilibria of (2.

2 summarizes what is known about equilibria of (2. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We defer discussion of this issue to Appendix E; suffices to say here that even if it is a possibility, it does not occur under usual parameter regimes. The following proposition summarises what is known about equilibria of (2.

1) under the assumption that the vaccine does not induce a backward bifurcation. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The following proposition summarises what is known about equilibria of (2. 1) under the assumption that the vaccine does not induce a backward bifurcation.

Endemic Equilibria

The endemic equilibria of (2.1) lie at the intersections ΓC(W⋆, I⋆) = ΓH(W⋆, I⋆) = 0 in the positive quadrant. p. 5

Where the paper says it

By Lemma B. 1, the positive orthant is positively invariant under the flow of (2.

There is a unique locally asymptotically stable equilibrium point Em where W⋆ > KC. p. 7
Where the paper says it

1) possesses the following equilibria. There always exists a unique disease-free equilibrium E0, which is locally asymptotically stable if Rv < 1 and unstable if Rv > 1.

If Rv < 1, there exists one subthreshold endemic equilibrium Eu with Wu ∈ (0, AC) which is unstable. p. 7
Where the paper says it

There always exists a unique locally asymptotically stable endemic equilibrium Em with W⋆ > KC. If Rv < 1, there exists one subthreshold endemic equilibrium Eu with W⋆ ∈ (0, AC), which is unstable.

Control Scenarios and Trade-offs

The analysis shows that WASH interventions have a more pronounced effect than vaccination in reducing total incidence when the environment is severely contaminated at the onset of the outbreak. This highlights that intense WASH interventions reduce the importance of vaccination. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The prevention of cholera relies mainly on hygiene measures, including access to safe drinking water, adequate sanitation and strict personal hygiene practices, the so-called water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) interventions [56]. However, vaccination also plays a critical role, even though the cholera vaccine is not part of the standard immunisation schedule.

The trade-off analysis indicates that a deficiency in sanitary infrastructure can be compensated by an aggressive, rapid vaccination campaign and vice-versa. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keywords : Cholera, infectious bodies, Allee effect, vaccination, policy assessment. 1 Introduction Cholera is an acute diarrhoeal infection that is a global public health threat causing devastating epidemics, particularly in regions where access to clean water and sanitation infrastructure is limited [60].

Conclusion on Control

The inclusion of an environmental Allee effect affects cholera control by showing that once a macroscopic endemic state is established, vaccination alone cannot eliminate the disease and active water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) interventions must be deployed to sanitize the water. The study confirms that no silver bullet exists for cholera. p. 9

Where the paper says it

We return to this in Section 4. 5, but let us point out here that this highlights the fact that cholera is a disease that embodies the “no silver bullet” observation in infectious disease control [9]: contrary to, e.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The model incorporates an Allee effect for the bacteria in the environment and imperfect and waning vaccination. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Mathematical properties of the model are investigated, with an environmental bistability shown to combine with a vaccine-driven one, although a computational search for the latter fails to detect its presence in realistic parameter ranges. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Mathematical properties of the model are investigated, with an environmental bistability shown to combine with a vaccine-driven one, although a computational search for the latter fails to detect its presence in realistic parameter ranges. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Mathematical properties of the model are investigated, with an environmental bistability shown to combine with a vaccine-driven one, although a computational search for the latter fails to detect its presence in realistic parameter ranges. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites.

The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials is assessed. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials are assessed.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials are assessed.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials are assessed.

How the training signal is built

The model incorporates an Allee effect for the bacteria in the environment and imperfect and waning vaccination. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials is assessed.

Where the gains come from

The model incorporates an Allee effect for the bacteria in the environment and imperfect and waning vaccination. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as WASH or Safe and dignified burials is assessed.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Environmental contamination risk assessment: The model can quantify how environmental bistability shown to combine with a vaccine-driven one exists, allowing AI systems to predict when a single intervention like vaccination is insufficient and when WASH interventions are required to force the system back below the Allee threshold AC.

  2. Vaccination strategy optimization: AI systems can use the trade-off analysis from Figure 8 to determine that intense WASH interventions reduce the importance of vaccination, suggesting adaptive policy where resources are allocated based on which intervention offers a greater reduction in total incidence.

  3. Corpse transmission risk modeling: The model allows for a computational search for the latter [vaccine-driven one] fails to detect its presence in realistic parameter ranges, but it can still assess the effect of control scenarios such as Safe and dignified burials by varying the interment rate e and transmission parameter beta D.

  4. Endemic equilibrium prediction: AI can use the nullcline analysis to predict whether an endemic state will be stable (like E(C1)m with Wstar > KC) or unstable (like Eu with Wstar in 0, AC), depending on the calculated reproduction number Rv.

  5. Vaccine effectiveness and waning modeling: The system incorporates imperfect and waning vaccination, allowing AI to model how vaccine protection is lost after some time because of so-called waning by varying the parameter theta, providing more realistic predictions for long-term immunity strategies.

Abstract

A cholera transmission model is formulated that incorporates waterborne and horizontal transmissions as well as infectivity of deceased individuals. The model includes an Allee effect for the bacteria in the environment and imperfect and waning vaccination. Mathematical properties of the model are investigated, with an environmental bistability shown to combine with a vaccine-driven one, although a computational search for the latter fails to detect its presence in realistic parameter ranges. The computational analysis also considers the interplay between vaccination strategy, vaccine efficacy and waning, as well as the effect of transmission of the disease during funeral rites. The effect of control scenarios such as water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) or Safe and dignified burials are assessed.

Related papers