Forces and symmetry breaking of a living meso-swimmer

arXiv:2503.21396 · cond-mat.soft, physics.bio-ph · Submitted 2025-03-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Forces and symmetry breaking of a living meso-swimmer".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Swimming is ubiquitous in nature and crucial for the survival of a wide range of organisms Between the micro- and macroscale lies an intermediate mesoscale where both viscous and inertial forces are important The study develops a micropipette force sensor to directly probe the swimming forces of the meso-organism Artemia Through deep neural network-based image analysis, the researchers show how Artemia achieves an increased propulsive force by increasing its level of time-reversal symmetry breaking They present a universal force-based scaling law for a wide range of micro- to meso-organisms with different body shapes, swimming strategies, and level of inertia at the mesoscale.

Kai: Probing Mesoscale Dynamics The researchers utilized the micropipette force sensor (MFS) technique to directly probe the fast swimming forces of Artemia sp.

Mira: They developed this technique to measure forces with a sub-nN resolution.

Kai: The swimming force of Artemia in their MFS measurements can thus be determined by considering the elastic, viscous, and inertial forces of the pipette.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper 'Forces and symmetry breaking of a living meso-swimmer'. The authors are showing how to directly probe the swimming forces of Artemia using a micropipette force sensor.

Mira: The thesis is that Artemia achieves an increased propulsive force by increasing its level of time-reversal symmetry breaking in its swimming motion. They use deep neural network based image analysis for this.

Lev: It claims they can quantify the level of non-reciprocity using a size independent measure A over A minus five B C D, which correlates directly with the propulsive force.

Kai: The paper presents a universal force based scaling law for swimming dynamics that spans the full range of micro to mesoscale organisms with different body shapes and inertia levels.

Mira: What matters here is that this universal scaling law can be used to roughly estimate the propulsive force of any swimming organism regardless of its size, shape, or specific swimming motion.

Lev: It seems like they are bridging the gap between measuring forces on a single organism and creating a general rule for how these different kinds of swimmers move in fluid.

Kai: It connects the microscopic mechanics to the macroscopic behavior across that intermediate mesoscale where viscous and inertial forces both play big roles.

Conclusion: Kai: The title 'Forces and symmetry breaking of a living meso-swimmer' points to how the specific way an organism moves, which they call time-reversal symmetry breaking, is what drives the increased force production.

Mira: It really boils down to showing that for these medium sized organisms, just having a certain type of non-reciprocal motion makes them swim better, and this relationship holds true across different types of swimmers.

Lev: So, from an engineering standpoint, this means if you're designing something that needs to swim effectively in those intermediate regimes, focusing on inducing that specific type of movement might be more impactful than just tuning the overall speed or size.

Kai: Exactly. The implication is that understanding these fundamental symmetry breaking principles could give us better predictive tools for how complex swimmers behave in environments with fluid dynamics that aren't purely viscous or purely inertial.

R. A. Lara, N. Sharadhi, A. A. L. Huttunen, L. Ansas, E. J. G. Rislakki, G. M. Bessa, M., Backholm

Department of Applied Physics, Aalto University

cond-mat.soft, physics.bio-ph

Submitted: 2025-03-27

Updated: 2026-01-28

Journal ref: Communications Physics 9, 53(2026)

DOI: 10.1038/s42005-025-02486-3

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: Swimming is ubiquitous in nature and crucial for the survival of a wide range of organisms Between the micro- and macroscale lies an intermediate mesoscale where both viscous and inertial forces are…

Key concepts

Micropipette Force Sensor (MFS)
This technique uses a long, thin glass pipette to measure the spring-like deflection caused by the swimming force of an organism. It allows researchers to measure forces with very high resolution, considering elastic, viscous, and inertial forces involved in the pipette's movement.
Time-Reversal Symmetry Breaking
This refers to a type of non-reciprocal motion where the swimming direction is not perfectly reversible. The study found a direct correlation: when an organism exhibits more of this asymmetry, its propulsive force increases.
Universal Scaling Law
The study discovered a single mathematical law that describes swimming dynamics for organisms ranging from micro to mesoscale. This law shows that propulsive force scales predictably with swimming speed across different body shapes and inertia levels.

Terminology

Summary

Swimming is ubiquitous in nature and crucial for the survival of a wide range of organisms Between the micro- and macroscale lies an intermediate mesoscale where both viscous and inertial forces are important The study develops a micropipette force sensor to directly probe the swimming forces of the meso-organism Artemia Through deep neural network-based image analysis, the researchers show how Artemia achieves an increased propulsive force by increasing its level of time-reversal symmetry breaking They present a universal force-based scaling law for a wide range of micro- to meso-organisms with different body shapes, swimming strategies, and level of inertia at the mesoscale. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Through deep neural network-based image analysis, we show how Artemia achieves an increased propulsive force by increasing its level of time-reversal symmetry breaking. We present a universal force-based scaling law for a wide range of micro- to meso-organisms with different body shapes, swimming strategies, and level of inertia at the mesoscale.

Probing Mesoscale Dynamics

The researchers utilized the micropipette force sensor (MFS) technique to directly probe the fast swimming forces of Artemia sp. They developed this technique to measure forces with a sub-nN resolution. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Results and Discussion Developing MFS for swimming force experiments on Artemia In the MFS technique, the spring-like deflection (𝑥, Fig. 2A–B, Supplementary Movie 1),) of a long, thin, and hollow glass micropipette is used to measure forces with a sub-nN resolution (46).

The swimming force of Artemia in their MFS measurements can thus be determined by considering the elastic, viscous, and inertial forces of the pipette. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(47) have developed different approaches to allow for more dynamic measurements with cantilever-based techniques, and we have followed the former in our work. The swimming force of Artemia in our MFS measurements can thus be determined by considering the elastic, viscous, and inertial forces of the pipette: 𝐹#$!

The measured swimming forces are averaged over many swimming cycles to obtain the mean propulsive force F;. p. 5
Where the paper says it

2B), the swimming forces shows a more complicated pattern. The mean propulsive force (𝐹;) and peak-to-peak force (𝐹;-/<) are calculated by averaging over many swimming cycles.

Force Measurement Methodology

The MFS technique involves measuring the spring-like deflection of a long, thin, and hollow glass micropipette The swimming force of Artemia in their MFS measurements can thus be determined by considering the elastic, viscous, and inertial forces of the pipette F; = kx + bẋ + m-·ẍ. The damping coefficient b and effective mass m-· are determined through a dynamic calibration method using a damped harmonic oscillator model. p. 3

Where the paper says it

C) MFS cantilever spring constant (obtained through the quasi-static water drop calibration method) as a function of its length. D) The MFS damping coefficient (blue data, left y-axis) and effective mass (red data, right y-axis) obtained through the dynamic calibration method as a function of spring constant.

Kinematic Analysis and Symmetry Breaking

Deep neural network-based image analysis of the Artemia kinematics is used to quantify the level of non-reciprocity of the swimmers They identify a correlation between the propulsive force and the level of time-reversal symmetry breaking of the swimming motion. The symmetry breaking area A@ is non-zero and increases with L This non-reciprocity is quantified by the ratio A@/A-5BCD, which provides a size-independent measure of the level of non-reciprocity of the motion. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The ratio 𝐴#@/𝐴#-5BCD provides a size-independent measure of the level of non-reciprocity of the motion. We find that 𝐴#@/𝐴#-5BCD increases linearly as a function of Re until a critical value of Re ≈ 4 (Fig.

Universal Scaling Laws

The researchers gather current swimming force measurement data from the literature and show a universal scaling law for swimming dynamics spanning the full range of micro- to mesoscale organisms All data collapse on the same line, confirming the results based on swimming speed at the micro- to mesoscale regime. The propulsive force thus increases when the animal performs a more non-reciprocal motion. p. 8

Where the paper says it

To do so, we again normalise the measured mean propulsive force following the Stokes regime estimation (𝐹; ∼ 𝜂𝑓𝐿)) (24) and plot it as a function of the level of non-reciprocity, finding 𝐹;/𝜂𝑓𝐿) ∼ 𝐴#@/𝐴#-5BCD (Fig. The propulsive force thus increases when the animal performs a more non-reciprocal motion.

The universal scaling laws can be conveniently used to roughly estimate the propulsive force of any swimming organism regardless of size, morphology, or swimming motion. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This experimental finding partly goes against previous theoretical hypotheses of highly complex swimming dynamics at the mesoscale and confirms the recent results from swimming speed measurements on free-swimming organisms (24). The presented universal scaling laws can be conveniently used to roughly estimate the propulsive force of any swimming organism, regardless of size, morphology, or swimming motion.

Literature Comparison

The universal scaling graph confirms that mesoswimmers adhere to the same law as the micro-swimmers even though Re > 1 and Stokes’ law starts breaking down The thrust number Th = ρF;-/a is found to follow a Th ∼ Sw scaling law in the Stokes regime, followed by a Th ∼ Sw) scaling in the laminar and inertial regime at ca Re > 10). More force-based data would be needed in the cross-over regime to probe the exact transition point. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Re > 10) − 108. More force-based data would be needed in the cross-over regime to probe the exact transition point.

The propulsive force of a living organism is not sensitive to the addition of inertia at the mesoscale (Re ∼ 1 − 108) but becomes apparent at Re > 108. p. 9
Where the paper says it

More force-based data would be needed in the cross-over regime to probe the exact transition point. The propulsive force of a living organism is, within the scatter of the inherently noisy data of these biological systems, thus not sensitive to the addition of inertia at the mesoscale (Re ∼ 1 − 108) but becomes apparent at Re > 108.

Experimental Setup Details

The MFS manufacturing involved making micropipettes from hollow borosilicate glass capillaries The dynamic calibration method was used to obtain the damping coefficient b and the effective mass m-· for the micropipettes. Experimental organisms were selected based on their positive phototaxis. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Furthermore, analytical complications arise with organisms whose shapes cannot be approximated as spheres or cylinders (26), which is the case for many living meso-organism that have developed into complex, time-varying shapes. Various experimental and analytical approaches have been made to describe the swimming speed and frequencies across different length scales (24, 27–30).

Artemia are protected by a thin, flexible chitinous exoskeleton composed of chitin, polysaccharides and proteins. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Results and Discussion Developing MFS for swimming force experiments on Artemia In the MFS technique, the spring-like deflection (𝑥, Fig. 2A–B, Supplementary Movie 1),) of a long, thin, and hollow glass micropipette is used to measure forces with a sub-nN resolution (46).

The brine medium employed in the experiments was reconstituted from pure water with added sea salts and minerals. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A) Optical microscopy image from an MFS swimming force experiment on Artemia (body length 𝐿 = 520 ± 30 𝜇m, antenna length 𝑙/) caught by the head through suction. The Artemia swims in a brine medium (viscosity 𝜂, density 𝜌).

Data Availability

The datasets used for plotting all graphs in the paper and examples of raw data files are shared on Zenodo The MATLAB analysis codes written for this paper are shared on Zenodo. The error bars for A@ is the standard error of many swimming cycles probed in each experiment. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The frequencies and antennae angle amplitudes are similar for free (blue data) and tethered (blue data) swimmers, which confirms that the MFS technique is minimally disruptive on the animal movement. The error bars in B–D are the standard errors from many swimming cycles of one individual.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

The frequencies and antennae angle amplitudes are similar for free (blue data) and tethered (blue data) swimmers, which confirms that the MFS technique is minimally disruptive on the animal movement. The error bars in B–D are the standard errors from many swimming cycles of one individual.

The data for bacteria (E. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The micro- to meso-swimmers follow the Stokes scaling of 𝐹;-/< = (12 ± 2) ⋅ 𝜂𝑓𝐿) (solid line). The data for bacteria (E.

coli) is a mean propulsive force and the copepods data were in the cruising regime and reported as mean integrated forces. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The data for bacteria (E. coli) is a mean propulsive force, and the copepods data were in the cruising regime and reported as mean integrated forces, which are both similar in magnitude as 𝐹;-/<.

The algae (C. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here, L is the length scale of the swimmer, U its swimming velocity, and 𝜌 and 𝜂 is the fluid density and viscosity. For small organisms, such as bacteria, algae, and nematodes, Re ≪ 1 and viscous forces dominate.

reinhardtii) data were reported as mean amplitudes which were multiplied by 2 to get the F;-/<. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The algae (C. reinhardtii) data were reported as mean amplitudes, which we multiplied by 2 to get the 𝐹;-/<.

The error bars in D and E are the standard errors over many swimming cycles and the standard deviation of several measurements of the body length. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The solid line is 𝐹;-/< = (16 ± 1) ⋅ 𝐹;, where the error is the 95% confidence interval of the fit. The error bars in D and E are the standard errors over many swimming cycles and the standard deviation of several measurements of the body length.

The dashed lines in E are the 95% confidence intervals of the linear fit. p. 9
Where the paper says it

002) ⋅ Sw)) regimes (24). The errors for the fits are the 95% confidence intervals.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

002) ⋅ Sw)) regimes (24). The errors for the fits are the 95% confidence intervals.

The error bars for A@ is the standard error of many swimming cycles probed in each experiment. The error for L is the standard deviation measured several times on the same organism The error bars for all axes in D and E are the propagated errors using the standard errors for F;, f, l/, antenna tip velocity, and A@ from many swimming cycles, and the standard deviation of L. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The solid line is 𝐹;-/< = (16 ± 1) ⋅ 𝐹;, where the error is the 95% confidence interval of the fit. The error bars in D and E are the standard errors over many swimming cycles and the standard deviation of several measurements of the body length.

The error for A-5BCD is propagated using the standard error for Θ/ over many cycles, and the standard deviation of l/ measured several times. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The solid line is 𝐹;-/< = (16 ± 1) ⋅ 𝐹;, where the error is the 95% confidence interval of the fit. The error bars in D and E are the standard errors over many swimming cycles and the standard deviation of several measurements of the body length.

The dashed lines in E are the 95% confidence intervals of the linear fit.

Acknowledgments

This work was funded by the European Union (ERC, SWARM 101115076; M.B.) and the Research Council of Finland Fellowship (MesoSwim, 354904; M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Bessa, and M. Backholm* Department of Applied Physics, Aalto University, Espoo, Finland *Email: matilda.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Bessa, and M. Backholm* Department of Applied Physics, Aalto University, Espoo, Finland *Email: matilda.

B.) The authors thank Prof. p. 0
Where the paper says it

backholm@aalto. fi; ‡ These authors contributed equally.

Maciej Lisicki for valuable discussions. The work was funded by the European Union (ERC, SWARM 101115076; M. p. 1
Where the paper says it

These meso-swimmers are affected by various levels of inertial, nonlinear, and time-dependent effects (4, 13), all of which are expected to create complex propulsion strategies and dynamics (15). Theoretical work has shown that mesoscale motility often is counterintuitive in nature and sensitive to the parameter space of finite inertia (16).

B.) and the Research Council of Finland Fellowship (MesoSwim, 354904; M.B.). The authors declare no competing interests. p. 0
Where the paper says it

backholm@aalto. fi; ‡ These authors contributed equally.

The authors contributed equally. p. 0
Where the paper says it

backholm@aalto. fi; ‡ These authors contributed equally.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

backholm@aalto. fi; ‡ These authors contributed equally.

R.A.L., S.N., and E.R. managed animal husbandries R. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Although useful for basic force studies, this is not expected to capture the intricate kinematics and dynamics of a real Artemia. Using the MFS technique, we have managed to perform a detailed and direct analysis of the mesoscale dynamics of this meso-swimmer at different life stages.

A.L., S.N., and GMB performed the particle image velocimetry experiments. p. 4
Where the paper says it

No difference in the kinematics is observed between the tethered and free-swimming experiments. By performing particle image velocimetry measurements, the fluid dynamics around the actively moving antennae are also found to be comparable in both scenarios, suggesting that the presence of the MFS does not influence the flow dynamics (see Supp.

MMB, RAL, and SN wrote the manuscript. The authors contributed equally.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Direct force measurement capability allows AI systems to predict propulsive force based on time-reversal symmetry breaking, as shown by the correlation between the propulsive force and the level of time-reversal symmetry breaking of the swimming motion.

  2. The universal scaling laws derived from direct measurements enable AI models to estimate the swimming dynamics of any micro- to meso-swimmer by normalizing forces against length scale and morphology.

  3. AI systems can be trained to predict transition points where inertial forces begin to influence swimming dynamics, specifically at Reynolds numbers greater than 108 for living organisms.

  4. The system can utilize deep neural network based image analysis, such as DeepLabCut, to quantify complex kinematics like the average of the “armpit” angle amplitude remains constant as a function of body length.

Abstract

Swimming is ubiquitous in nature and crucial for the survival of a wide range of organisms. The physics of swimming at the viscosity-dominated microscale and inertia-dominated macroscale is well studied. However, in between lies a complicated mesoscale with swimmers affected by non-linear and time-dependent fluid mechanics. The intricate motility strategies, combined with complex and periodically changing body shapes add extra challenges for accurate meso-swimming modelling. Here, we have further developed the micropipette force sensor to directly probe the swimming forces of the meso-organism Artemia. Through deep neural network-based image analysis, we show how Artemia achieves an increased propulsive force by increasing its level of time-reversal symmetry breaking. We present a universal force-based scaling law for a wide range of micro- to meso-organisms with different body shapes, swimming strategies, and level of inertia at the mesoscale. These results capture fundamental aspects of biological meso-swimming dynamics and provide guidance for future biomimicking meso-robot designs.

Related papers