Galaxy and Halo Root Systems: Fingerprints of Mass Assembly

arXiv:2503.21015 · astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA · Submitted 2025-03-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Galaxy and Halo Root Systems: Fingerprints of Mass Assembly".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Galaxy and halo root systems discuss what we call halo or galaxy root systems, collections of particle pathlines that show the infall of matter from the initial uniform distribution into a collapsed structure The matter clumps as it falls in; projected through time, it produces filamentary density enhancements analogous to tree roots and branches, or branching river networks This relates to the larger-scale cosmic web, but is defined locally about one of its nodes: a physical, geometric version of a merger tree They find dark-matter-halo root systems on average to exhibit more roots and root branches for the largest cluster haloes than in small haloes, indicating their more complicated assembly, even in dark matter without gas physics High spin manifests as curvier roots, and that many have mass contributions that start far away from central, compact protohalo cores Root systems also show sensitivity to anisotropic infall, which we see some evidence for in a simulation with rather low box size.

Vera: Conceptual Framework of Root Systems A root system is defined as a projection of a halo through time, instead of space; it is the projected ensemble of matter trajectories, or pathlines, for all particles that end up in the halo Pathlines are common concepts in fluid mechanics.

Jocelyn: The authors view this system in comoving coordinates, so infall dominates other motions, and they subtract off any halo bulk motions that might obscure the infall pattern.

Vera: An essential concept in galaxy formation is a galaxy or halo merger tree (e.g.

Paper summary: Vera: We've just touched on those root systems—those paths showing matter infall—and this paper, "Galaxy and Halo Root Systems: Fingerprints of Mass Assembly," is all about using them as a fingerprint for how halos assemble.

Jocelyn: The thesis centers on the idea that these root systems record tracks of mass assembling into halos. They're connecting them to assembly bias, which means differences in how halos of the same final mass form based on their formation histories and spins.

Subrahmanyan: This is significant because it suggests that even if we only look at dark matter, the geometry of the infall tells us about the merger tree structure. It implies that higher-mass haloes are more connected to more filaments than smaller ones.

Vera: They show this visually using a two-dimensional example, where they project these paths through time. The key is seeing how these structures look when you trace them back to their initial uniform density space.

Jocelyn: They use the term "fingerprints of mass assembly" because they expect features in these systems to encode information about progenitor types and formation histories.

Subrahmanyan: When they look at the structure quantified by a multiscale "blob" finder, they see that filamentarity generally increases with halo mass, up to a slope of one over r for the upper limit of those curves.

Vera: That rise suggests branching because new roots appear at larger radii as you get further out from the center. The outer boundaries of these root systems are essentially their Lagrangian protohaloes, which is interesting because it links them back to the initial conditions.

Jocelyn: They also observed that larger haloes tend to be more convex and compact, while smaller haloes have streaks reaching far outside their convex cores.

Subrahmanyan: This observation supports the idea that high-mass haloes are higher peaks in the density field, encompassing larger catchment basins with more branches in their flow.

Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up this look at "Galaxy and Halo Root Systems: Fingerprints of Mass Assembly," it’s about using these projected paths to geometrically understand the growth of structures.

Jocelyn: The authors, Neyrinck, Aragón-Calvo, and Szapudi, they are showing that these root systems aren't just pretty pictures; they encode information about the entire assembly process.

Subrahmanyan: What it means for cosmology is that if we can measure these geometric fingerprints in real data—in halos—we get a direct look at the merger tree structure without needing to model all the complex gas physics.

Vera: It suggests that more massive structures are inherently more connected to the cosmic web, meaning their assembly is intrinsically more branched than smaller ones.

Jocelyn: And they're pointing toward how we can use these root systems as a way to study assembly bias across different halo populations, using the physics of dark matter alone.

Mark Neyrinck, Miguel Aragón-Calvo, István Szapudi

Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaiƙ at Manoa · Blue Marble Space · Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Instituto de Astronomía

astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA

Submitted: 2025-03-26

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: Minor changes to match version accepted to MNRAS. 2D root-system movie at https://neyrinck.github.io/haloroots2d.mp4

Code: https://github.com/neyrinck/origami2d

Project page: https://neyrinck.github.io/haloroots2d.mp4

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: Galaxy and halo root systems discuss what we call halo or galaxy root systems, collections of particle pathlines that show the infall of matter from the initial uniform distribution into a collapsed…

Key concepts

Root System
A root system is a geometric representation of a halo formed by projecting all particle paths over time instead of space. It visualizes the infall and accretion history of matter into the structure, analogous to a physical merger tree.
Filamentarity
This describes how elongated or streaky the roots are when measured at different radii. The study found that filamentarity increases with halo mass, suggesting that larger haloes exhibit more branching structures as matter flows in from various directions.
High Spin
High spin manifests as curvier or more tortuous root systems. This suggests that objects with high angular momentum have accretion histories where matter follows more complex, curved paths into the core compared to lower-spin haloes.

Terminology

Summary

Galaxy and halo root systems discuss what we call halo or galaxy root systems, collections of particle pathlines that show the infall of matter from the initial uniform distribution into a collapsed structure The matter clumps as it falls in; projected through time, it produces filamentary density enhancements analogous to tree roots and branches, or branching river networks This relates to the larger-scale cosmic web, but is defined locally about one of its nodes: a physical, geometric version of a merger tree They find dark-matter-halo root systems on average to exhibit more roots and root branches for the largest cluster haloes than in small haloes, indicating their more complicated assembly, even in dark matter without gas physics High spin manifests as curvier roots, and that many have mass contributions that start far away from central, compact protohalo cores Root systems also show sensitivity to anisotropic infall, which we see some evidence for in a simulation with rather low box size. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This relates to the larger-scale cosmic web, but is defined locally about one of its nodes: a physical, geometric version of a merger tree. We find dark-matter-halo root systems on average to exhibit more roots and root branches for the largest cluster haloes than in small haloes, indicating their more complicated assembly, even in dark matter without gas physics.

Conceptual Framework of Root Systems

A root system is defined as a projection of a halo through time, instead of space; it is the projected ensemble of matter trajectories, or pathlines, for all particles that end up in the halo Pathlines are common concepts in fluid mechanics. The authors view this system in comoving coordinates, so infall dominates other motions, and they subtract off any halo bulk motions that might obscure the infall pattern. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Pathlines are common concepts in fluid mechanics. But a couple of choices make the pattern they form particularly interesting, to our knowledge not explored before, cosmologically: (1) we view it in comoving coordinates, so infall dominates other motions; and (2) we subtract off any halo bulk motions that might obscure the infall pattern; we keep the centroid of the protohalo that eventually forms the halo in the same place at each snapshot that we use to render it.

An essential concept in galaxy formation is a galaxy or halo merger tree (e. p. 0
Where the paper says it

But a couple of choices make the pattern they form particularly interesting, to our knowledge not explored before, cosmologically: (1) we view it in comoving coordinates, so infall dominates other motions; and (2) we subtract off any halo bulk motions that might obscure the infall pattern; we keep the centroid of the protohalo that eventually forms the halo in the same place at each snapshot that we use to render it. An essential concept in galaxy formation is a galaxy or halo merger tree (e.

g. Srisawat et al. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An essential concept in galaxy formation is a galaxy or halo merger tree (e. Srisawat et al.

2013), which should usually correspond closely to the root systems we define. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Srisawat et al. 2013), which should usually correspond closely to the root systems we define.

There is also a link between root systems and ‘watershed superclusters’ or ‘basins of attraction,’ such as Laniakea (Tully et al. p. 0
Where the paper says it

But ‘tree’ in ‘merger tree’ refers to the abstract computer-science concept of nodes in a hierarchy, rather than a physical geometric branching structure. There is also a link between root systems and ‘watershed superclusters’ or ‘basins of attraction,’ such as Laniakea (Tully et al.

2014; Dupuy & Courtois 2023; Valade et al. p. 0
Where the paper says it

There is also a link between root systems and ‘watershed superclusters’ or ‘basins of attraction,’ such as Laniakea (Tully et al. 2014; Dupuy & Courtois 2023; Valade et al.

2024) defined by dominantly inward flows. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2014; Dupuy & Courtois 2023; Valade et al. 2024), defined by dominantly inward flows.

Structural Observations and Mass Dependence

The authors visually introduce the concept with a two-dimensional example. A first finding is the surprising (to us) prevalence of streaks reaching far outside of a convex shape. p. 2

Where the paper says it

For these, we rendered the haloes with 10 equally-spaced contours of the log-density up to the maximum, with increasing opacity. A first finding is the surprising (to us) prevalence of streaks reaching far outside of a convex shape.

A quick visual impression finds more ‘structure’ (more roots, and more branching) in a high-mass halo than a low-mass one. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Because it is ambiguous how physically relevant the streaks are that poke out of the central protohalo (the nearly convex shape filled with particles initially), we concentrate our attention on roots inside that central protohalo. A quick visual impression finds more ‘structure’ (more roots, and more branching) in a high-mass halo than a low-mass one.

Also, based just on a visual impression, they find that the roots in a high-spin root system are generally more curved, or tortuous. p. 3
Where the paper says it

2010a) and observations (Euclid Collaboration et al. Also, based just on a visual impression, we find that the roots in a high-spin root system are generally more curved, or tortuous (a word used to describe a curvy river system, not to be confused with ‘torturous’).

Quantifying Complexity and Shape

The authors use a multiscale ‘blob’ finder on spherical shells to quantify root abundance. At fixed shell radius, from r ∼ 30-80 ckpc/h, the filamentarity generally increases with halo mass. p. 3

Where the paper says it

3 shows the results. At fixed shell radius, from 𝑟 ∼ 30-80 ckpc/ℎ, the filamentarity generally increases with halo mass.

The slope of the upper limit of the curves is filamentarity f ∝ r 1, which is substantial, but is less steep than the surface area of the shell (∝ r 2). p. 3
Where the paper says it

The filamentarity also generally increases with radius for a given curve (corresponding to a single 20-halo mass bin). The slope of the upper limit of the curves is filamentarity 𝑓 ∝ 𝑟 1 , which is substantial, but is less steep than the surface area of the shell (∝ 𝑟 2 ); this is the expected rise if the blob-finding were due to noise.

This rise suggests branching, since new roots arise at larger radius. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The slope of the upper limit of the curves is filamentarity 𝑓 ∝ 𝑟 1 , which is substantial, but is less steep than the surface area of the shell (∝ 𝑟 2 ); this is the expected rise if the blob-finding were due to noise. The rise suggests branching, since new roots arise at larger radius.

Generally, larger haloes are more convex and compact than smaller haloes; smaller haloes are the ones that can have ‘streaks’ reaching far outside their convex cores. p. 6
Where the paper says it

(6) Shrink offending vertices/rays until their convex hull is fully inside the mask. Generally, this figure shows that larger haloes are more convex and compact than smaller haloes; smaller haloes are the ones that can have ‘streaks’ reaching far outside their convex cores.

Environmental Sensitivity and Resolution

The stacked anisotropy in 10 most massive haloes appears to have substantial anisotropies along the diagonals at r ≈ 0.2 cMpc/h. The second, lower-mass stack also shows greater accretion along diagonal directions, at large distances from the halo center, r > 0. p. 5

Where the paper says it

This comes from only 10 haloes, but these most massive haloes occupy the largest Lagrangian volumes, and are where we would most imagine the effects of the low box size to show up. The second, lower-mass stack also shows greater accretion along diagonal directions, at large distances from the halo center, 𝑟 > 0.

5 cMpc/h. The appearance of each projected halo seems to have modest dependence on resolution, although there are a few exceptions visible in Fig. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Another not-entirely-expected finding from this crude resolution study is that the externally arriving streaks that occur in many of these halo root systems are generally present (with some fluctuations in their density) in both simulations, supporting the view that they are physical instead of numerical. The appearance of each projected halo seems to have modest dependence on resolution, although there are a few exceptions visible in Fig.

6. The trend of fewer roots for lower-mass haloes seen in Fig. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The appearance of each projected halo seems to have modest dependence on resolution, although there are a few exceptions visible in Fig. We conclude that the trend of fewer roots for lower-mass haloes seen in Fig.

3 survives consideration of resolution effects. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We conclude that the trend of fewer roots for lower-mass haloes seen in Fig. 3 survives consideration of resolution effects.

Implications for Galaxy Assembly

Root systems give a visual, geometric representations of the accretion, infall, or merger history in a halo (or galaxy). The protohalo density field contains this information too, but not in a way as visually accessible to humans whose eyes are sensitive to branching systems. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Thus, we assert that they are useful summaries of the influence that the assembly history and the density field within the protohalo could have had on the final spatial arrangement and properties of the halo. The protohalo density field contains this information too, but not in a way as visually accessibles to humans whose eyes are sensitive to branching systems.

They suggest that higher-mass haloes are more connected to more filaments, and increased root prevalence at high mass accords with findings that higher-mass haloes are connected to more filaments. p. 8
Where the paper says it

A high-mass halo would typically contain a galaxy cluster which may contain hundreds of galaxies; if each of these contributes a root, some of them merging, this would account for the increased root prevalence at high mass. If, alternatively, we associate roots directly with filaments, increased root prevalence at high mass accords with findings that higher-mass haloes are connected to more filaments; for example, Codis et al.

The way a halo assembles relates to the problem of optimal transport. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Looking at how root systems depend on cosmic-web environment is another avenue for further study. The way a halo assembles relates to the problem of optimal transport (see the recent data-science text, Peyré & Cuturi 2019).

Conclusion on Assembly Processes

The finding that higher-mass haloes have more abundant and branching roots is consistent with both possibilities. A high-mass halo would typically contain a galaxy cluster which may contain hundreds of galaxies; if each of these contributes a root, some of them merging, this would account for the increased root prevalence at high mass. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The finding that higher-mass haloes have more abundant and branching roots is consistent with both possibilities. A high-mass halo would typically contain a galaxy cluster which may contain hundreds of galaxies; if each of these contributes a root, some of them merging, this would account for the increased root prevalence at high mass.

Conceptually, this is because high-mass haloes are higher peaks, encompassing larger catchment basins, and therefore with more branches in the flow. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(2018) found this even analytically, using the theory of density peaks in a Gaussian random field. Conceptually, this is because high-mass haloes are higher peaks, encompassing larger catchment basins, and therefore with more branches in the flow.

The cosmic-web context of the haloes is also important to consider. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Conceptually, this is because high-mass haloes are higher peaks, encompassing larger catchment basins, and therefore with more branches in the flow. The cosmic-web context of the haloes is also important to consider; the largest, cluster-size haloes occupy the largest nodes of the cosmic web.

Acknowledgements

We thank the developers and maintainers of the IllustrisTNG database that enabled this work MN thanks the organizers of the conferences ‘Mind the Gap: Galaxies and the Large-Scale Structure’ and ‘Cosmic Flows 2025’ for providing stimulating environments that encouraged the ideas and work presented here, and thanks Antonela Taverna for providing an in-preparation python implementation of the MMF MAC acknowledges support from the Programa de Apoyo a Proyectos de Investigación e Innovación Tecnológica (PAPIIT) IN115224 (also enabling a visit by MN) and CONAHCyT project CF-2023-I-1971 IS and MN acknowledge NASA ROSES grants 80NSSC24K1489 and 24-ADAP24-0074, and contract number 80NM0018F0610 via a JPL sub-award.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved understanding of assembly bias in dark matter haloes by analyzing halo root systems. This allows AI to quantify differences in the clustering of halo populations of the same final mass, arising from different formation histories, spins, and types of progenitors, which is a key aspect of assembly bias.

  2. Enhanced ability to probe infall anisotropy using stacked root systems. The AI can analyze angular fluctuations in a symmetrized log(1 + rhoHRS, projected, stacked) to determine if infall is preferentially along the Cartesian axes, or diagonal to them at certain angles within a small box size simulation.

  3. Development of predictive models for galaxy quenching mechanisms based on root system structure. The AI can investigate the relation between root systems and cosmic-web detachment (CWD) mechanism for external star-formation quenching, specifically looking for how major root branchings correlate with these events in high-mass haloes.

  4. Refinement of halo shape characterization using non-convexity measurements. The AI can calculate the radial extent of non-convexity to determine if a protohalo is truly convex, noting that larger haloes are more convex and compact than smaller haloes.

  5. Mitigation of resolution effects in root system analysis by comparing different particle counts. The AI can assess whether observed trends, such as the reduced number and branching of roots in lower-mass halo root systems, are artifacts of simulation resolution or physical phenomena by comparing results from simulations with 8 times more particles.

Abstract

We discuss what we call halo or galaxy root systems, collections of particle pathlines that show the infall of matter from the initial uniform distribution into a collapsed structure. The matter clumps as it falls in; projected through time, it produces filamentary density enhancements analogous to tree roots and branches, or branching river networks. This relates to the larger-scale cosmic web, but is defined locally about one of its nodes: a physical, geometric version of a merger tree. We find dark-matter-halo root systems on average to exhibit more roots and root branches for the largest cluster haloes than for small haloes, indicating their more complicated assembly, even in dark matter without gas physics. Also, we find that high spin manifests as curvier roots, and that many have mass contributions that start far away from central, compact protohalo cores. Root systems also show sensitivity to anisotropic infall, which we see some evidence for in a simulation with rather low box size.

Sources

Related papers