Exploring the growth-index (gamma) tension with lambda s CDM

arXiv:2503.12945 · astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2025-03-17 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Exploring the growth-index (gamma) tension with lambda s CDM".

Paper summary: Vera: So, to summarize this paper, they are looking at whether the lambda s cdm framework can resolve that gamma tension by treating gamma as a free parameter while adding this rapid sign-switching cosmological constant at redshift z dagger around two.

Jocelyn: The thesis is that this specific framework could explain the observed suppression of cosmic structure growth while still matching the theoretically expected value of zero point five five for gamma assuming general relativity.

Subrahmanyan: What's important is that they show this framework can address not just gamma, but also the h0 and s8 tensions at once. They explore how this late-time change affects the expansion history and structure formation in a way that lowers the present-day matter density parameter.

Vera: They set up a test by treating gamma as free and using Planck and fsigma8 data, then adding supernova data and baryonic acoustic oscillation data to see if lambda s cdm performs better on all fronts.

Jocelyn: The paper suggests that for a transition redshift z dagger around one point seven, this model can actually eliminate both the h0 tension and the gamma tension simultaneously across those different datasets.

Subrahmanyan: That result hinges on the idea that the AdS like cosmological constant causes a suppression of expansion when z is greater than z dagger, which must then be balanced by an enhancement when z is less than z dagger to keep things consistent with Planck values.

Vera: The paper also notes that a later transition, meaning a smaller redshift for z dagger, deepens the suppression of expansion at later times, which amplifies both the effect on structure growth and the effect on h0.

Jocelyn: But there's a caveat they mention: this model’s success depends heavily on what data you use; for instance, some three dimensional baao measurements from sdss iv eboss push that transition redshift up to around two point three or two point four.

Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up, the authors of "Exploring the growth-index (gamma) tension with lambda s cdm" are suggesting that a rapid sign switch in the cosmological constant around redshift two is a viable way to fix multiple problems at once.

Jocelyn: They argue that this mechanism lowers the matter density parameter, which naturally raises h0 to about seventy or seventy point one kilometers per second per megaparsec, while also keeping gamma close to zero point five five.

Subrahmanyan: It’s an elegant way because it doesn't just tweak one parameter; it links the expansion rate directly to the growth of structure in a unified way. The implication is that if we can find observational evidence for this kind of transition, it could provide a single explanation for several cosmological discrepancies.

Vera: But we have to remember that their success is really dataset dependent; the paper itself flags that using different measurements, like three dimensional baao data from sdss iv eboss or the first year of desi observations, tends to push that transition redshift up and weaken the simultaneous alleviation.

Jocelyn: So, while the theory seems promising for linking h0, s8, and gamma tensions through this specific mechanism, we need to see consistent results across different observational probes before we can really say this is the answer.

School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, University of Sheffield · Department of Physics, Istanbul Technical University · Instituto de Ciencias FĿicas, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de México

astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2025-03-17

Updated: 2026-11-17

Comments: 18 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables; matches the version published in Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, 103502 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/gs8j-1s7r

Code: https://github.com/MinhMPA/CAMB_GammaPrime_

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: The ΛsCDM framework offers a promising unified resolution to multiple major cosmological tensions—namely the H0, S8, and recently identified γ tensions—through a single underlying physical mechanism.

Key concepts

Growth Index ($\gamma$)
This index describes how fast cosmic structures, like galaxies and clusters, grow over time. In standard cosmology (General Relativity), it is expected to be around 0.55. Observations from Planck and $f\sigma_8$ data suggest a higher value of $\gamma \approx 0.64$, indicating that structure growth is faster than predicted by the simplest model.
$\Lambda_s$CDM Model
This is an extension of the standard Lambda-CDM model that includes a rapid sign-switching cosmological constant ($\Lambda_s$) at a specific redshift, $z_\dagger \sim 2$. This abrupt transition mimics a mirror AdS-to-dS shift. This mechanism is proposed to alter the expansion history and structure growth in the late universe to resolve tensions.
$H_0$ Tension
This tension refers to the significant disagreement between different measurements of the Hubble constant ($H_0$), which represents the current rate of cosmic expansion. Standard Lambda-CDM models often struggle to reconcile these different measurements, suggesting a potential issue with the model or missing physics.
$S_8$ Tension
The $S_8$ parameter is a measure related to the amplitude of matter fluctuations in the Universe. Tensions in this parameter arise when combining data from different cosmological probes, indicating discrepancies in how structure formation is evolving across different observational methods.

Terminology

Summary

The ΛsCDM framework offers a promising unified resolution to multiple major cosmological tensions—namely the H0, S8, and recently identified γ tensions—through a single underlying physical mechanism. p. 9

The Core Problem and Proposed Solution

Recent observational analyses have revealed a significant tension in the growth index γ, which characterizes the growth rate of cosmic structures. Specifically, when treating γ as a free parameter within ΛCDM framework, a combination of Planck and fσ8 data yields γ ≈ 0. p. 064, in ∼ 4σ tension with the theoretically expected value γ ≈ 0. p. 055 (assuming general relativity). p. 0 This discrepancy poses a new challenge to the standard cosmological model by suggesting that it predicts an excessive growth of structure. p. 0 The ΛsCDM framework—featuring a rapid sign-switching cosmological constant (mirror AdS-to-dS transition) in the late universe at redshift z† ∼ 2—can simultaneously alleviate the γ, H0, and S8 tensions. p. 0

Mechanism of Tension Alleviation

The ΛsCDM framework posits that around redshift z† ∼ 2, the Universe underwent a period of rapid mirror AdS-to-dS (anti-de Sitter-to de Sitter) transition in vacuum energy—namely, a rapid sign-switching cosmological constant (CC), Λs, from negative to positive while preserving its overall magnitude (“mirror” reflects this invariance)—or a similar phenomenon. This abrupt transition at z = z† introduces a discontinuity, resulting in a type II (sudden) singularity [54]. p. 1 Phenomenologically, for z < z†, ΛsCDM closely replicates the expansion history H(z) of ΛCDM, albeit with systematically higher values; it introduces a noticeable deformation of H(z) around the transition redshift z ∼ z† and becomes virtually indistinguishable from ΛCDM at higher redshifts (z ≳ 3). p. 1

Parameter Inference and Model Comparison

The study compares γΛCDM and γΛsCDM models by treating γ as a free parameter, constrained using Planck CMB and fσ8 data, and incorporating additional datasets such as Type Ia Supernovae (SN Ia) and BAO data. The analysis reveals that the H0 tension persists in the standard ΛCDM extension, while the γ tension often exceeds 3σ. p. 3 In contrast, γΛsCDM addresses late-time growth suppression by lowering omegam0 (and consequently increasing H0), rather than elevating the growth-index γ to values around 0. p. 464.

Key Findings on Tension Resolution

  1. The γΛCDM extension continues to suffer from the ∼ 5σ H0 tension of standard ΛCDM, as seen in Tables II and III and Fig. p. 3 1.

  2. The γΛsCDM model addresses the late-time growth suppression by lowering omegam0 (and consequently increasing H0), rather than elevating the growth-index γ to values around 0. p. 464.

  3. For z† ≈ 1.7, ΛsCDM can effectively eliminate both the γ and H0 tensions in each of these two data combinations. p. 7

  4. The model's success is linked to predicting a lower late-time matter density parameter than ΛCDM; specifically, Planck-ΛsCDM yields omegam0 ≃ 0.28, which, when combined with the theoretically expected growth index γ ≈ 0. p. 855 [147] under GR, leads to f0 ≃ 0. p. 849.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The results confirm that the ΛsCDM framework offers a unified mechanism that simultaneously addresses the γ, H0, and S8 tensions. The key distinction is that γΛsCDM accomplishes this by lowering omegam0, which in turn raises H0 to approximately 70–71 km s−1 Mpc−1, thereby mitigating both the Hubble and growth tensions simultaneously. p. 8 The mirror AdS-to-dS transition at z† ∼ 2 emerges as an elegant mechanism capable of addressing the Hubble, S8, and γ tensions within a single, minimal extension to the standard cosmological model. p. 8

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The authors rigorously examined this potential by adopting the abrupt ΛsCDM scenario as a proxy for rapid transitions, under the assumption that gravity is governed by GR. The key observation is that, despite their fundamental differences, γΛsCDM and γΛCDM yield nearly identical present-day growth rates, f0 = omegaγm0, across all dataset combinations. p. 8 However, they achieve this through distinct mechanisms: γΛCDM suppresses structure growth by increasing γ to ∼ 0. p. 863 while maintaining a high omegam0 > 0. p. 23, exacerbating the γ tension. p. 9 In contrast, γΛsCDM is better at preserving the theoretically expected γ ≈ 0. p. 955 by lowering omegam0 by ∼ 0. p. 202–0.05, which also naturally raises H0, without deviating from the standard ΛCDM framework as significantly as γΛCDM does from ΛCDM. p. 9 Additionally, the lower omegam0 keeps S8 below ∼ 0. p. 980, bringing it into better agreement with cosmic shear constraints. p. 9

How the training signal is built

The analysis utilized Cobaya [148], a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampler designed for cosmological models, in conjunction with CAMB [149], a Boltzmann solver. The study employed several datasets, including Planck 2018 CMB data (PL18), fσ8 measurements from redshift-space distortions (RSD), Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) and RSD measurements from SDSS-IV eBOSS, DESI BAO, Type Ia Supernovae (SN Ia) data (PP), and a Gaussian prior on the Hubble constant H0 = 73. p. 304 ± 1.04 km s−1 Mpc−1. p. 2

Where the gains come from

The ultimate success of ΛsCDM lies in its ability to preserve a theoretically motivated γ ≈ 0.55 while simultaneously raising H0 to match local measurements, without deviating from the standard ΛCDM framework as significantly as γΛCDM does from ΛCDM. p. 8 This implies that, treating γ as a free parameter, the cosmological data sets used in this work all prefer a suppressed growth of structure compared to the theoretical predictions for both models. p. 8 The rapid mirror AdS-to-dS transition at z† ∼ 2 emerges as an elegant mechanism capable of addressing the Hubble, S8, and γ tensions within a single, minimal extension to the standard cosmological model. p. 8

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved parameter inference capabilities: The system can perform rigorous Markov Chain Monte Carlo MCMC sampling using Cobaya in conjunction with CAMB GammaPrime Growth to compare gammaLambdaCDM and gammaLambdaSCDM models across multiple datasets (Planck, fsigma8, SDSS, DESI) to assess the significance of tensions.

  2. Unified tension resolution analysis: The system can determine that the ΛsCDM framework offers a unified mechanism that simultaneously addresses the γ, H0, and S8 tensions, by analyzing how gammaLambdaSCDM achieves growth suppression by lowering omegam0 (and consequently increasing H0), rather than elevating the growth-index γ to values around 0.64.

  3. Transition redshift sensitivity mapping: The system can map the effectiveness of the mirror AdS-to-dS transition by observing that lower values of omegam0 in γLambdaSCDM correlate with reduced γ and H0 tensions, providing a clear mechanism for alleviating the S8 tension through this shift.

  4. Model comparison under fixed constraints: The system can evaluate the special case of fixing z† to its best-fit value for this dataset (z† = 2.16) and quantify the resulting tension reduction, noting that this case yields ∆χ2min = -4.3, which shows a superior fit compared to γLambdaCDM.

  5. Dataset dependence assessment: The system can identify that incorporating BAO data instead of SN Ia measurements leads to a worsening of the H0 and γ tensions in both models, specifically noting that the DESI likelihood still shows a slight preference for γLambdaSCDM.

Sources

Related papers