Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics

arXiv:2503.06249 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-03-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics presents a two-loop analysis of contributions to Higgs production via gluon-gluon fusion arising from the triple-gluon operator in SMEFT The study illustrates the full complexity of RG improved perturbation theory beyond one-loop level in SMEFT through an instructive example involving anomalous gluon dynamics Framework and Operators The framework defines the SMEFT Lagrangian as LSMEFT = X i Ci(µ)Qi.

Kai: The relevant dimension-six operators considered include QG = f abcG a,ν µ G b,ρ ν G c,µ ρ, QtG = ¯qσµνH T e a tGa µν, and QHG = H†H Ga µνG a,µν.

Mira: The initial conditions for the Wilson coefficients at the high-energy scale Λ are set such that CG(Λ) ≫ CtG(Λ) ≫ CHG(Λ) ≃ 0.

Kai: Calculation and Renormalization The calculation uses dimensional regularization in d = 4 − 2ϵ to regulate singularities The bare amplitude contains both 1/ϵ2 and 1/ϵ poles, which are of UV origin and have no IR contributions To achieve a UV-finite result, one must account for the fact that QG mixes into the chromomagnetic top-quark dipole operator QtG at one loop, which in turn mixes into the Higgs-gluon operator QHG at the same order The remaining 1/ϵ pole determines the two-loop anomalous dimensions that govern the mixing of QG into QHG RG Evolution and Scale Independence The RG evolution is dictated by beta functions, where the one-loop beta function for G is β(1)G = 15g 2s CG, and for CHG is β(1)HG = - 14g 2s + 6y 2t CHG − 4gsytCtG The single logarithm in the evolution of CG results from the one-loop self-mixing of QG The double logarithm in the running of CHG stems from a two-step mixing process, namely QG mixes into QtG at one loop, which subsequently mixes into QHG at the same perturbative order By inserting logarithmic expressions for the ratios of Wilson coefficients into (5.3), it is a matter of simple algebra to demonstrate that the two-loop SMEFT corrections to the gg → h form factor become renormalization scale independent at O(gsy 2t) Phenomenological Implications The modification of the signal strength relative to the SM is given by δµgg = 2δκg = 2Re G(1)G(2)∗ / G(1) squared Utilizing LHC measurements, a bound on the high-scale Wilson coefficient CG is derived as

−2.08, 0.39: TeV squared based on the 68% confidence level constraint This limit is more reliable than those obtained from multijet production because it probes linear corrections at virtualities well below the UV cut-off The study demonstrates that achieving a renormalization scale independent result for the gg → h production cross section at next-to-leading order in SMEFT requires accounting for three types of contributions The findings show that dominant RG effects arise from operator mixings proportional to powers of the strong coupling constant or the top-quark Yukawa coupling, along with the RG evolution of these parameters The derived bound on CG is weaker than existing constraints from multijet production but is considered more reliable for EFT validity The compact analytical and numerical expressions presented should prove useful in this context A Real radiation The calculation of the form factor FG receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute The sum of the two-loop Feynman diagrams represents the full bare IR-finite contribution to the gg → h amplitude The form factor FG in (5.4) receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute B Matching procedure The one-loop matching equation reads K(1) = A(1) − Z(1,tG,HG)ϵ.

Title and authors: Kai: The paper is titled "Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics," and it’s written by Ulrich Haischa from the Max Planck Institute for Physics in Germany.

Mira: It’s a very focused piece of work, tackling how the triple-gluon operator affects Higgs production via gluon-gluon fusion within SMEFT.

Lev: The authors are setting up a specific calculation path to see how these higher-order effects behave when you run the theory using renormalization group evolution.

Kai: Essentially, they are showing that this contribution comes from matching and running effects at different perturbative orders, which is a key subtlety in these calculations.

Mira: They use this example to illustrate the full complexity of RG improved perturbation theory in SMEFT, which is important since one-loop results are already quite common.

Lev: I wonder if they've fully accounted for all the mixing effects between operators at this two-loop level, because that’s usually where things get messy on real hardware.

The paper's summary: Kai: The summary explains that assuming the triple-gluon operator is the dominant ultraviolet deformation, you modify the gluon-gluon fusion cross section first at the two-loop level.

Mira: These corrections arise from three distinct types of contributions, involving matching and running effects at different perturbative orders.

Lev: So, instead of just looking at one correction term, they are tracking how different parts of the theory mix as you go to higher orders in perturbation theory.

Kai: The paper states that the unphysical dependence on the renormalization scale cancels order by order in perturbation theory only when these corrections are properly combined.

Mira: And they suggest that using the relevant SMEFT RG equations lets you resum those large logarithms that appear in the gluon-gluon fusion prediction, going beyond leading logarithmic accuracy.

Lev: Resumming those logarithms is a big deal because it helps keep the calculation stable when you try to get more precise predictions for things like Higgs production.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out that the main benefit of this approach is that it allows you to resum large logarithms in the gluon-gluon fusion prediction, going beyond just leading logarithmic accuracy.

Mira: They show that by using those SMEFT RG equations, you can resum those logarithms systematically.

Lev: That systematic handling of the running effects is crucial because it means we can get a more stable result when comparing theory to actual experimental measurements at the LHC.

Kai: They also emphasize that another reason for considering this triple-gluon operator contribution is that its Wilson coefficient remains relatively weakly constrained by jet observables and top-quark processes.

Mira: They point out that the strongest constraints on this operator come from multijet production, which relies on the strong enhancement of quadratic terms.

Lev: So, while this paper focuses on Higgs production, it highlights that other channels are where we usually get stronger limits on these operators.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, the study shows that achieving a renormalization scale independent result for the gluon-gluon fusion cross section at next-to-leading order in SMEFT requires accounting for three types of contributions involving matching and running effects at different orders.

Mira: The paper concludes that dominant RG effects usually come from operator mixings proportional to powers of the strong coupling constant or the top-quark Yukawa coupling, along with the RG evolution of those parameters.

Lev: What I take away is that these dominant RG effects are tied to how strongly the coupling constants and Yukawa couplings run with energy, which is what we need to track for precision.

Kai: The derived bound on the Wilson coefficient CG from this analysis is between negative two point zero eight and positive three point nine TeV squared at a sixty-eight percent confidence level based on LHC measurements.

Mira: That limit is weaker than some constraints we get from multijet production, but the authors say it’s considered more reliable for EFT validity because it probes linear corrections at virtualities well below the ultraviolet cut-off.

Lev: I agree that probing those lower virtualities gives it a certain kind of reliability, but we still need to be careful about how much we trust these bounds when scaling up to higher orders.

Kai: So, in short, this paper provides a compact analytical and numerical expression that should be useful for anyone doing two-loop SMEFT calculations involving anomalous gluon dynamics.

Max Planck Institute for Physics

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-03-08

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 21 pages, 4 figures; v3: I thank Giuseppe Ventura for pointing out a mistake in (5.4) in the published version of this article and for verifying the new result

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 97/100

The gist: Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics presents a two-loop analysis of contributions to Higgs production via gluon-gluon fusion arising from the triple-gluon operator in SMEFT The study…

Key concepts

SMEFT Lagrangian
This is the framework used to describe physics beyond the Standard Model by adding higher-dimension operators to the Standard Model Lagrangian. The specific terms studied here involve operators like QG and QHG, which represent potential new interactions between gluons and Higgs bosons.
Renormalization Group (RG) Evolution
RG evolution describes how the physical parameters of a theory change as the energy scale at which you measure them changes. In this paper, it dictates how the Wilson coefficients of different operators mix and run with energy, ensuring that predictions remain independent of the arbitrary scale chosen for calculations.
Operator Mixing
This refers to the process where one type of interaction operator (like QG) transforms into another type (like QtG or QHG) at higher orders in perturbation theory. This mixing is crucial because it drives the running of the coefficients and determines how different SMEFT effects contribute to a final physical observable.
Form Factor FG
The form factor FG represents the correction to the Higgs production cross-section due to virtual corrections from new physics. The paper shows that for this specific process, only virtual corrections contribute to the form factor, and real emissions do not affect it.

Terminology

Summary

Higgs production from anomalous gluon dynamics presents a two-loop analysis of contributions to Higgs production via gluon-gluon fusion arising from the triple-gluon operator in SMEFT The study illustrates the full complexity of RG improved perturbation theory beyond one-loop level in SMEFT through an instructive example involving anomalous gluon dynamics

Framework and Operators

The framework defines the SMEFT Lagrangian as LSMEFT = X i Ci(µ)Qi. The relevant dimension-six operators considered include QG = f abcG a,ν µ G b,ρ ν G c,µ ρ, QtG = ¯qσµνH T e a tGa µν, and QHG = H†H Ga µνG a,µν. p. 2

Where the paper says it

For the entirety of this article, we assume that all Wilson coefficients are real. In the Warsaw basis of operators [2], the full set of dimension-six operators relevant to this study includes QG = f abcG a,ν µ G b,ρ ν G c,µ ρ , QtG = ¯qσµνH T e a tGa µν , QHG = H†H Ga µνG a,µν .

The initial conditions for the Wilson coefficients at the high-energy scale Λ are set such that CG(Λ) ≫ CtG(Λ) ≫ CHG(Λ) ≃ 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Lastly, notice that for the operator QtG the sum of the hermitian conjugate is implied in (2. Below, we concentrate on a particular class of BSM scenarios in which, at the highenergy scale Λ, the initial conditions of the Wilson coefficients follow the hierarchy: CG(Λ) ≫ CtG(Λ) ≫ CHG(Λ) ≃ 0 .

Calculation and Renormalization

The calculation uses dimensional regularization in d = 4 − 2ϵ to regulate singularities The bare amplitude contains both 1/ϵ2 and 1/ϵ poles, which are of UV origin and have no IR contributions To achieve a UV-finite result, one must account for the fact that QG mixes into the chromomagnetic top-quark dipole operator QtG at one loop, which in turn mixes into the Higgs-gluon operator QHG at the same order The remaining 1/ϵ pole determines the two-loop anomalous dimensions that govern the mixing of QG into QHG

RG Evolution and Scale Independence

The RG evolution is dictated by beta functions, where the one-loop beta function for G is β(1)G = 15g 2s CG, and for CHG is β(1)HG = - 14g 2s + 6y 2t CHG − 4gsytCtG The single logarithm in the evolution of CG results from the one-loop self-mixing of QG The double logarithm in the running of CHG stems from a two-step mixing process, namely QG mixes into QtG at one loop, which subsequently mixes into QHG at the same perturbative order By inserting logarithmic expressions for the ratios of Wilson coefficients into (5.3), it is a matter of simple algebra to demonstrate that the two-loop SMEFT corrections to the gg → h form factor become renormalization scale independent at O(gsy 2t)

Phenomenological Implications

The modification of the signal strength relative to the SM is given by δµgg = 2δκg = 2Re G(1)G(2)∗ / G(1) squared Utilizing LHC measurements, a bound on the high-scale Wilson coefficient CG is derived as [−2.08, 0.39] TeV squared based on the 68% confidence level constraint This limit is more reliable than those obtained from multijet production because it probes linear corrections at virtualities well below the UV cut-off

Conclusion and Complementarity

The study demonstrates that achieving a renormalization scale independent result for the gg → h production cross section at next-to-leading order in SMEFT requires accounting for three types of contributions The findings show that dominant RG effects arise from operator mixings proportional to powers of the strong coupling constant or the top-quark Yukawa coupling, along with the RG evolution of these parameters The derived bound on CG is weaker than existing constraints from multijet production but is considered more reliable for EFT validity The compact analytical and numerical expressions presented should prove useful in this context

A Real radiation

The calculation of the form factor FG receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute The sum of the two-loop Feynman diagrams represents the full bare IR-finite contribution to the gg → h amplitude The form factor FG in (5.4) receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute

B Matching procedure

The one-loop matching equation reads K(1) = A(1) − Z(1,tG,HG)ϵ. The two-loop matching equation required to determine the term FG in the two-loop form factor G(2) from (5. p. 8

Where the paper says it

2) of Wilson coefficients into (5. 3), it is a matter of simple algebra to demonstrate that the two-loop SMEFT corrections to the gg → h form factor become renormalization scale independent at O(gsy 2 t ).

3) is given by K(2) = A(2) − Z(2,G,HG)ϵ squared + Z(2,1,G,HG)ϵ! p. 2
Where the paper says it

This raises questions about the reliability of the effective field theory (EFT) expansion when extracting bounds on the Wilson coefficient of the triple-gluon operator from multijet observables. Given these limitations, indirect precision tests of the triple-gluon operator are of particular interest.

− Z(1,1,G,tG)—Z(1),tG=−9/2g 2syt.

C HPL formulas

The HPLs up to weight 3 that feature in our calculations are given by H(0; x) = ln (x), H(0, 0; x) = 1/2 ln2(x), and H(1, 0; x) = − ln (x) ln (1 − x) − Li2 (x), etc. The HPLs with argument 1 required in this article are H(0, 1; 1) = π/26, H(0, 0, 1; 1) = ζ(3), and H(0, 0, 0, 1; 1) = π/490

D RG formulas

The solution to the RGE for the strong coupling constant is αs(µ) ≃ αs(µ0) / (1 − αs(µ0) 4πβ0 ln µ 2 0/µ 2) The solution for the top-quark Yukawa coupling is yt(µ) ≃ η y b, where η = αs(µ)/αs(µ0) and b = 8πβ0 The final expression in (6.4) allows for a direct derivation of the second line in (6. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The single logarithm instead results from the direct two-loop mixing of QG into QHG. Notice that, from the viewpoint of RG improved perturbation theory, the double logarithm in the last line of (6.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

The single logarithm instead results from the direct two-loop mixing of QG into QHG. Notice that, from the viewpoint of RG improved perturbation theory, the double logarithm in the last line of (6.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

The single logarithm instead results from the direct two-loop mixing of QG into QHG. Notice that, from the viewpoint of RG improved perturbation theory, the double logarithm in the last line of (6.

4) The final expression corresponds to the LL term, which is proportional to the product γjm(µ0)γmi(µ0) of scale-independent anomalous dimensions

The cross section associated with the real contribution from gg → hg is obtained by integrating (A.1) over the relevant phase space, yielding an IR-finite result In the limit s → m2h, the real-emission contribution σR vanishes The form factor FG in (5. p. 4

Where the paper says it

This point is explained in Appendix A, which covers the real radiation contributions from QG. To achieve a UV-finite result, one must account for the fact that QG mixes into the chromomagnetic top-quark dipole operator QtG at one loop, which in turn mixes into the Higgs-gluon operator QHG at the same order.

4) receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute

The bare one-loop amplitude A(1) arises from Feynman diagrams shown on the left-hand side of Figure 2 The symbol Z(1,tG,HG) represents the one-loop 1/ϵ pole of the Z factor, which accounts for the mixing of QtG into QHG

The HPLs up to weight 4 appear in (5.4) only in the specific combination (5. p. 7

Where the paper says it

4), H(x) represents the following specific combination of HPLs of weight 4: H(x) = 3H(1, 0, 0, 0; x) + 2H(0, 1, 0, 0; x) + H(0, 0, 1, 0; x) + 4H(1, 1, 0, 0; x) + 2H(1, 0, 1, 0; x). 5) Moreover, we have introduced the abbreviations B(x) = 1 − H 0; (1 − x) 2 x − iδ , Lt = ln µ 2 m2 t , (5.

5) The function FtG encapsulates the one-loop correction due to the insertion of the operator QtG, given by FtG = 3 [1 − x + 1/x − 1] H(0; x) − 2x(x − 1) squared H(0, 0; x) + 2Lt

The second type of RG evolution involves the mixing of an operator Qi into Qj, with both operators potentially having nonzero self-mixing The final result, on the other hand, retains only the LL term, which is proportional to the scale-independent anomalous dimension γji(µ0) that describes the mixing of Qi into Qj The third type of RG corrections involves two-step mixing processes The final expression in (D.9) corresponds to the LL term, which is proportional to the product γjm(µ0)γmi(µ0) of scale-independent anomalous dimensions

E Conclusions

The necessity of including distinct types of contributions, involving matching and running effects at different perturbative orders, to achieve renormalization scale independent results is a general feature of SMEFT calculations beyond the tree level The findings show that in typical phenomenological applications, the dominant SMEFT RG effects stem from operator mixings that scale with powers of the strong coupling constant or the top-quark Yukawa coupling, along with the RG evolution of these parameters The derived bound on CG is weaker than existing constraints from multijet production but is considered more reliable for EFT validity The compact analytical and numerical expressions presented should prove useful in this context

F A Real radiation

The cross section associated with the real contribution from gg → hg is obtained by integrating (A.1) over the relevant phase space, yielding an IR-finite result The form factor FG in (5. p. 4

Where the paper says it

To achieve a UV-finite result, one must account for the fact that QG mixes into the chromomagnetic top-quark dipole operator QtG at one loop, which in turn mixes into the Higgs-gluon operator QHG at the same order. All relevant one-loop anomalous dimensions can be found in [7, 8].

4) receives contributions exclusively from virtual corrections, while real emissions linked to the triple-gluon operator QG do not contribute The sum of the two-loop Feynman diagrams represents the full bare IR-finite contribution to the gg → h amplitude

The matching equation required to determine the term FG in the two-loop form factor G(2) from (5.3) is given by K(2) = A(2) − Z(2,G,HG)—Z(1,1,G,tG)—Z(1),tG=−9/2g 2syt. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This raises questions about the reliability of the effective field theory (EFT) expansion when extracting bounds on the Wilson coefficient of the triple-gluon operator from multijet observables. Given these limitations, indirect precision tests of the triple-gluon operator are of particular interest.

The two-loop 1/ϵ pole can be expressed as a product of one-loop 1/ϵ poles, reflecting the locality of UV divergences

The solution to the RGE for the top-quark Yukawa coupling is yt(µ) ≃ η y b The final expression in (6.4) allows for a direct derivation of the second line in (6.4) The final expression corresponds to the LL term, which is proportional to the product γjm(µ0)γmi(µ0) of scale-independent anomalous dimensions

The findings show that in typical phenomenological applications, the dominant SMEFT RG effects stem from operator mixings that scale with powers of the strong coupling constant or the top-quark Yukawa coupling, along with the RG evolution of these parameters The derived bound on CG is weaker than existing constraints from multijet production but is considered more reliable for EFT validity The compact analytical and numerical expressions presented should prove useful in this context

The HPLs up to weight 3 that feature in our calculations are given by H(0; x) = ln (x), H(0, 0; x) = 1/2 ln2(x), and H(1, 0; x) = − ln (x) ln (1 − x) − Li2 (x), etc. The HPLs with argument 1 required in this article are H(0, 1; 1) = π/26, H(0, 0, 1; 1) = ζ(3), and H(0, 0, 0, 1; x) = π/490

The HPLs up to weight 3 that feature in our calculations are given by H(0; x) = ln (x), H(0, 0; x) = 1/2 ln2(x), and H(1, 0; x) = − ln (x) ln (1 − x) − Li2 (x), etc. The HPLs with argument 1 required in this article are H(0, 1; 1) = π/26, H(0, 0, 1; 1) = ζ(3), and H(0, 0, 0, x) = π/49

The solution to the RGE for the top-quark Yukawa coupling is yt(µ) ≃ η y b The final expression in (6.4) allows for a direct derivation of the second line in (6.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved analysis of renormalization scale independence by explicitly demonstrating that the terms in (5.4) to (5.8) involving Lt terms combine with the LLambda contributions in (6.2), resulting in logarithms of the form L = Lt+LLambda = ln Lambda 2/m2t. This allows for a more rigorous check of scale independence across different perturbative orders and mixing types.

  2. Enhanced capability to resum large logarithms by providing a complete analytical solution for the coupled RG equations (4.1) through (4.3). This allows the system to derive simple analytic expressions that are compared against exact numerical results, ensuring systematic handling of NLL and LL effects in Wilson coefficient running.

  3. More precise calculation of anomalous dimensions by incorporating the two-loop beta function beta 2HG into the RGE analysis. This capability ensures that the system can capture sizeable NLL corrections for the Higgs-gluon operator, which is crucial for accurate high-order SMEFT predictions.

  4. Robust cross-validation between different constraints on anomalous operators by comparing limits derived from Higgs production cross sections with those from multijet production. This allows the system to assess the robustness and validity of the EFT expansion by contrasting linear order bounds with quadratic contributions, as noted in Section 7.

Abstract

We present a two-loop analysis of the contributions to Higgs production via gluon-gluon fusion arising from the triple-gluon operator in the Standard Model effective field theory (SMEFT). Our discussion covers all aspects of renormalization group (RG) improved perturbation theory, including matching and running within the SMEFT. This study can therefore be seen as a blueprint of the intricacies and subtleties that arise in RG improved SMEFT calculations for collider processes beyond the leading order.

Sources

Related papers