Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors

arXiv:2502.21230 · cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.supr-con · Submitted 2025-02-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors studies peculiarities of bulk-edge correspondence and a fate of massless edge and bulk topological (instantons) excitations at such the crossover in topological superconductors The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: The correct description of the crossover involves the bulk theory, in particular, topological excitations (instantons) Topological Context and Crossover Mechanism The paper investigates the relationship between spin-to-integer quantum Hall effects and topological phase transitions in two-dimensional electronic systems It explores how continuous increase in a symmetry breaking Zeeman magnetic field can convert the spin effect to the integer quantum Hall effect The integer quantum Hall effect (iqHe) is related to class A, while the spin quantum Hall effect (sqHe) belongs to class C, and the crossover involves moving from class C to class A via breaking of SU(2) spin rotation symmetry down to U(1) The transformation 2Z→Z should occur during the C→A crossover Edge Theory Limitations and Bulk Necessity It is not possible to describe the crossover in terms of the edge theory only The understanding of crossovers between topologically non-trivial phases is complicated by topological excitations (instantons) in the bulk and massless edge excitations which are related by the bulk-boundary correspondence The goal of this Letter is to study the sqHe-to-iqHe crossover and answer physical questions regarding edge theory description, observable dependence on bare spin Hall conductance, and the structure of the emergent iqHe staircase Bulk Theory Description via Non-Linear Sigma Model The bulk theory for sqHe is described by a non-linear sigma model (NLσM) action in class C symmetry The NLσM action for the soft diffusive edge modes is given by Eq.

Kai: (4) The information about the quantization of gH is encoded in the first term of the NLσM (4), which is nothing but the edge form of Pruisken’s θ-term The renormalization group (RG) equations for class C are well-known

63–68: Role of Zeeman Splitting in Class Transformation The introduction of the Zeeman magnetic field Bz by adding the term µBBz R dτ dyψ¯(σ3⊗1r)ψ to the action (1) explicitly breaks BdG symmetry, making the resulting Hamiltonian belong to class A In the clean case, applying a generalized TKNN formula results in spin Hall conductance quantized in units of 2e2/h The edge modes have curvature due to merging with the bulk states, and for the iqHe, this leads to gH=(2k−1)e2/h Crossover Dynamics and Observables The crossover is characterized by a length-scale LB where the system transitions from class C RG equations to class A RG equations The physical observable O at L>LB depends on g¯¯ and g¯¯H, following the transformation O(C) → O(A) The dependence of gH on L is non-monotonous with an extremum at L∼LB, leading to plateaus at odd integer values in dependence of gH on ¯gH Instanton Contributions and Final Predictions The only consistent possibility to realize Eq.

Mira: (9) is the following picture of the crossover in the non-perturbative contributions to the RG equations The W=2 instanton becomes diagonal matrix in the Nambu space, which can be interpreted as two independent class A W=1 instantons At strong Zeeman splitting, LB≪ξ(C), the odd-plateau width approaches 1 as 1−∆(odd)B ∼

(LB−l)/ξ(C): ln3(ξ(C)/LB) The staircase with ∆(odd)B ≠ ∆(even)B distinguishes the iqHe obtained in a result of crossover from the sqHe in a topological superconductor, and the ordinary iqHe The paper demonstrates that it is not possible to describe the crossover in terms of the edge theory only The correct description involves bulk theory, specifically topological excitations (instantons) Although the spin Hall conductance becomes quantized in units e2/h as a result of the crossover, the periodic dependence of physical observables on the bare spin Hall conductance has a period 2e2/h as for the sqHe The authors obtained that after the crossover, the widths of the odd and even iqHe plateaus are different in contrast to conventional iqHe The paper suggests that a magnetic field parallel to bilayers is an efficient tool to control and manipulate edge spin-current carrying states in such topological superconductors The authors conclude that the crossover involves both perturbative and non-perturbative contributions, with the latter being crucial for capturing the periodicity of physical observables The study provides a coherent physical picture of the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in both bulk and edge regions Appendix Details on Instanton Behavior The W=1 instanton is not fully suppressed by Bz at the classical level, as rotational zero modes with

T,s3: ̸=0 acquire a mass proportional to Bz ln(L/λ) The W=2 instanton becomes diagonal matrix in the Nambu space when the Zeeman splitting forces synchronization of instanton scale sizes and positions The resulting action in the presence of Zeeman splitting leads to class A, Q ∈ U(N)/

U(N/2)×U(N/2): The analysis shows that for λ > LB, the logarithmic divergence in the integral over λ disappears, indicating that instantons with scales λ > LB do not contribute to the renormalization of LDoS The synchronization of instanton scale sizes is found to be the correct mechanism for instanton zero-mode transformation Plateau Width Estimation The critical shift δgH of the transverse spin conductivity microscopic value necessary to reach the gH = 0 phase in the infrared limit (L → ∞) is computed using RG equations for class C The condition defining the critical trajectory can be expressed as 1/2=2 arctan tan πg¯H/2 exp

πDCf(gC(L), g¯): i The limiting cases of this expression show that when LB > Cξ(C)l, the quantization of transverse spin conductivity by integers occurs Conversely, when LB < Cξ(C)l, the quantization changes to even integers Solving Crossover RG Equations The crossover RG equation is solved using a Heaviside step-function approximation for the sharp crossover The solution yields gH(L) = 1/π (2 arctan (tan (πg¯H/2) exp

πDC f(gC (L), g¯): ), L ≤ LB arctan (tan (πg¯¯H) exp

πDAf(2gA(L), 2g¯): , L > LB The function f is defined in Eq.

Kai: (S.58) and the terms gC(L), gA(L) are longitudinal spin conductivities with one(two)-loop corrections in symmetry class C (A) Final Physical Implications The analysis shows that for Bz̸=0 the RG flow in Fig.

Paper summary: Kai: So to recap this paper, "Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors," they are investigating that transition between spin and integer quantum Hall effects using a continuous increase in a Zeeman magnetic field.

Mira: Their main thesis is that you can't describe this crossover just by looking at the edge theory of the system because of these bulk topological excitations known as instantons.

Lev: So, they are arguing that to understand why the physics changes so fundamentally during this transition, you have to include what's happening in the bulk.

Kai: They study how a continuous increase in a symmetry breaking Zeeman magnetic field converts the spin quantum Hall effect into the integer quantum Hall effect, moving from class C to class A.

Mira: The paper claims that understanding this requires looking at both massless edge excitations and these bulk topological instanton excitations that are related by the bulk-boundary correspondence.

Lev: So, they're essentially saying that there's a connection between what you measure on the edge and what's happening deep in the material structure.

Kai: The goal is to answer physical questions about how this crossover works, how it affects observables depending on the bare spin Hall conductance, and what the structure of that integer quantum Hall effect staircase looks like.

Mira: They demonstrate that after this crossover, the widths of the odd and even integer quantum Hall effect plateaus are actually different compared to conventional integer quantum Hall effects.

Lev: That's a specific result about the resulting phase structure, meaning it’s not just a simple change in quantization rule; it introduces new features based on how you got there.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at "Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors," the authors are really highlighting that you need a bulk view to get a complete picture of this transition.

Mira: They're stressing that the bulk theory, specifically the instantons, is what captures those non-perturbative contributions that dictate how things change during this shift between spin and integer quantum Hall effects.

Lev: For us in experimental physics, this suggests that if we are trying to realize these systems with topological features, we need to design our measurements to probe both the edge and the bulk structure simultaneously.

Kai: The implication is that the way you set up your experiment matters because it dictates which topological phase you observe at any given point during the crossover.

Mira: It suggests that controlling external fields, like a magnetic field parallel to bilayers, can be a useful knob for manipulating those edge spin-current carrying states in these materials.

Lev: In short, the paper shows that this crossover isn't just a smooth transition; it has specific topological features governed by bulk physics you need to account for.

M. V. Parfenov, I. S. Burmistrov

L D Landau Institute for Theoretical Physics · Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics, HSE University

cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.supr-con

Submitted: 2025-02-28

Updated: 2025-02-28

DOI: 10.1103/smfx-fwrl

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors studies peculiarities of bulk-edge correspondence and a fate of massless edge and bulk…

Key concepts

Spin-to-Integer Quantum Hall Effect Crossover
This describes the physical process where a system transitions from exhibiting spin quantum Hall effects (Class C) to the integer quantum Hall effect (Class A) by increasing a Zeeman magnetic field. This change involves breaking SU(2) spin symmetry down to U(1), marking a fundamental topological phase transition in the electronic system.
Bulk-Edge Correspondence
This principle links phenomena occurring in the bulk of the material (the interior) to those occurring at its boundary (the edge). In this context, it means that properties observed on the edge are fundamentally related to topological excitations existing within the bulk, such as instantons.
Topological Excitations (Instantons)
These are non-perturbative structures in the bulk theory that play a critical role during phase transitions. The paper shows that these instantons dictate the non-trivial behavior of the crossover, particularly how physical observables change and how plateaus appear in the conductance measurements.
Non-Linear Sigma Model (NLσM)
This is a mathematical framework used to describe the bulk theory of spin Hall systems. The NLσM action for Class C symmetry encodes information about edge modes and is essential for understanding how the system's topological properties evolve under changes in the magnetic field.

Terminology

Summary

Bulk-edge correspondence at the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in topological superconductors studies peculiarities of bulk-edge correspondence and a fate of massless edge and bulk topological (instantons) excitations at such the crossover in topological superconductors

The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: The correct description of the crossover involves the bulk theory, in particular, topological excitations (instantons)

Topological Context and Crossover Mechanism

The paper investigates the relationship between spin-to-integer quantum Hall effects and topological phase transitions in two-dimensional electronic systems It explores how continuous increase in a symmetry breaking Zeeman magnetic field can convert the spin effect to the integer quantum Hall effect The integer quantum Hall effect (iqHe) is related to class A, while the spin quantum Hall effect (sqHe) belongs to class C, and the crossover involves moving from class C to class A via breaking of SU(2) spin rotation symmetry down to U(1) The transformation 2Z→Z should occur during the C→A crossover

Edge Theory Limitations and Bulk Necessity

It is not possible to describe the crossover in terms of the edge theory only The understanding of crossovers between topologically non-trivial phases is complicated by topological excitations (instantons) in the bulk and massless edge excitations which are related by the bulk-boundary correspondence The goal of this Letter is to study the sqHe-to-iqHe crossover and answer physical questions regarding edge theory description, observable dependence on bare spin Hall conductance, and the structure of the emergent iqHe staircase

Bulk Theory Description via Non-Linear Sigma Model

The bulk theory for sqHe is described by a non-linear sigma model (NLσM) action in class C symmetry The NLσM action for the soft diffusive edge modes is given by Eq. (4) The information about the quantization of gH is encoded in the first term of the NLσM (4), which is nothing but the edge form of Pruisken’s θ-term The renormalization group (RG) equations for class C are well-known [63–68]

Role of Zeeman Splitting in Class Transformation

The introduction of the Zeeman magnetic field Bz by adding the term µBBz R dτ dyψ¯(σ3⊗1r)ψ to the action (1) explicitly breaks BdG symmetry, making the resulting Hamiltonian belong to class A In the clean case, applying a generalized TKNN formula results in spin Hall conductance quantized in units of 2e2/h The edge modes have curvature due to merging with the bulk states, and for the iqHe, this leads to gH=(2k−1)e2/h

Crossover Dynamics and Observables

The crossover is characterized by a length-scale LB where the system transitions from class C RG equations to class A RG equations The physical observable O at L>LB depends on g¯¯ and g¯¯H, following the transformation O(C) → O(A) The dependence of gH on L is non-monotonous with an extremum at L∼LB, leading to plateaus at odd integer values in dependence of gH on ¯gH

Instanton Contributions and Final Predictions

The only consistent possibility to realize Eq. (9) is the following picture of the crossover in the non-perturbative contributions to the RG equations The W=2 instanton becomes diagonal matrix in the Nambu space, which can be interpreted as two independent class A W=1 instantons At strong Zeeman splitting, LB≪ξ(C), the odd-plateau width approaches 1 as 1−∆(odd)B ∼[(LB−l)/ξ(C)] ln3(ξ(C)/LB) The staircase with ∆(odd)B ≠ ∆(even)B distinguishes the iqHe obtained in a result of crossover from the sqHe in a topological superconductor, and the ordinary iqHe

Summary of Findings

The paper demonstrates that it is not possible to describe the crossover in terms of the edge theory only The correct description involves bulk theory, specifically topological excitations (instantons) Although the spin Hall conductance becomes quantized in units e2/h as a result of the crossover, the periodic dependence of physical observables on the bare spin Hall conductance has a period 2e2/h as for the sqHe The authors obtained that after the crossover, the widths of the odd and even iqHe plateaus are different in contrast to conventional iqHe The paper suggests that a magnetic field parallel to bilayers is an efficient tool to control and manipulate edge spin-current carrying states in such topological superconductors

Conclusion on Crossover Description

The authors conclude that the crossover involves both perturbative and non-perturbative contributions, with the latter being crucial for capturing the periodicity of physical observables The study provides a coherent physical picture of the spin-to-integer quantum Hall effect crossover in both bulk and edge regions

Appendix Details on Instanton Behavior

The W=1 instanton is not fully suppressed by Bz at the classical level, as rotational zero modes with [T,s3]̸=0 acquire a mass proportional to Bz ln(L/λ) The W=2 instanton becomes diagonal matrix in the Nambu space when the Zeeman splitting forces synchronization of instanton scale sizes and positions The resulting action in the presence of Zeeman splitting leads to class A, Q ∈ U(N)/[U(N/2)×U(N/2)] The analysis shows that for λ > LB, the logarithmic divergence in the integral over λ disappears, indicating that instantons with scales λ > LB do not contribute to the renormalization of LDoS The synchronization of instanton scale sizes is found to be the correct mechanism for instanton zero-mode transformation

Plateau Width Estimation

The critical shift δgH of the transverse spin conductivity microscopic value necessary to reach the gH = 0 phase in the infrared limit (L → ∞) is computed using RG equations for class C The condition defining the critical trajectory can be expressed as 1/2=2 arctan tan πg¯H/2 exp [πDCf(gC(L), g¯)] i The limiting cases of this expression show that when LB > Cξ(C)l, the quantization of transverse spin conductivity by integers occurs Conversely, when LB < Cξ(C)l, the quantization changes to even integers

Solving Crossover RG Equations

The crossover RG equation is solved using a Heaviside step-function approximation for the sharp crossover The solution yields gH(L) = 1/π (2 arctan (tan (πg¯H/2) exp [πDC f(gC (L), g¯)]), L ≤ LB arctan (tan (πg¯¯H) exp [πDAf(2gA(L), 2g¯)], L > LB The function f is defined in Eq. (S.58) and the terms gC(L), gA(L) are longitudinal spin conductivities with one(two)-loop corrections in symmetry class C (A)

Final Physical Implications

The analysis shows that for Bz̸=0 the RG flow in Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precise topological phase identification in disordered systems: The AI can determine if a material is in a spin quantum Hall effect (sqHe) or integer quantum Hall effect (iqHe) regime based on the length scale L relative to LB, as described by "At L>LB the system is governed by the RG equations for the class A."

  2. Prediction of plateau width variations: The AI can predict how physical observables depend on bare spin Hall conductance after crossover, specifically noting that the widths of the odd and even iqHe plateaus are different in contrast to the conventional iqHe staircase.

  3. Simulation of crossover dynamics: The AI can simulate the length scale dependence of conductivity by solving the crossover RG equations, yielding a formula for gH(L) that shows plateaus at odd integer values in dependence of gH on bar gH start to develop as L grows beyond LB.

  4. Control over edge spin-current states: The AI can model how a magnetic field parallel to bilayers acts as an efficient tool to control and manipulate the edge spin-current carrying states in such topological superconductors in a way similar to manipulation of edge current channels in the conventional iqHe.

Sources

Related papers