Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments

arXiv:2501.05971 · cond-mat.soft, physics.bio-ph · Submitted 2025-01-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments develops a continuum theory to describe the collective dynamics of deformable epithelial cells using two tensor order parameters to distinguish force-generating active filaments from their shape <ref:2501.05971#pg2>.

Kai: This theory demonstrates how active flows create nematic domains of anisotropic cells, drive active turbulence, and create topological defects <ref:2501.05971#pg4>.

Mira: The paper is significant because it establishes a framework to explain complex collective cell motion by distinguishing between the microstructure of active filaments and the shape of the cells <ref:2501.05971#pg5>.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The model employs a continuum approach describing a two-dimensional layer of confluent cells using a vector velocity field u and two tensor order parameter fields for the microstructure Q and W <ref:2501.05971#pg3>.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap, this paper, "Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments," lays out a continuum approach describing two-dimensional confluent cells using a vector velocity field u and two tensor order parameter fields called Q and W >

Mira: The rank two tensor Q is the filament order parameter; it represents the nematic orientational order of the filaments that make up the cytoskeletal network >

Lev: And W is another structural variable they introduced to describe cell shape, quantifying how anisotropic, or stretched out, those cells are >

Kai: The equations for these parameters are coupled, and they predict that you can have locally extensional flows even in a system where the active material itself is contractile >

Mira: The active stress tensor has both active and passive contributions; the active part comes from internal stress generated by molecular motors on those filaments >

Lev: And they link this to strain flows of active turbulence, showing that these flows deform isotropic cells with a magnitude related to the magnitude of W >

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at this paper, "Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments," what it really does is reconcile the idea that contractile cells can actually exhibit extensile behavior by making a clear distinction between the active filaments and how the cell shape itself behaves >

Mira: The authors suggest that simultaneous measurement of both filament orientation and cell shape orientations could be a way to test this idea >

Lev: And they also raise questions about the specific details of how stress fibers generate dipolar forces in this context >

Kai: It really points to the fact that we need to look at both scales—the molecular level filaments and the macroscopic cell shape—to fully understand these collective motions >

Mehrana R. Nejad, Julia M. Yeomans, Sumesh P Thampi

Department of Physics, Harvard University · School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University · The Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, Department of Physics, University of Oxford · Department of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology

cond-mat.soft, physics.bio-ph

Submitted: 2025-01-10

Updated: 2025-01-10

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 112, 045411 (2025)

DOI: 10.1103/mmyk-f9x3

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments develops a continuum theory to describe the collective dynamics of deformable epithelial cells using two tensor order…

Key concepts

Filament Order Parameter (Q)
This tensor parameter measures the nematic orientational order of the cytoskeletal filaments. It quantifies how aligned these filaments are within the cellular network, distinguishing between force-generating active filaments and their physical shape.
Cell Shape Order Parameter (W)
This variable describes the anisotropy in cell shape. It quantifies how stretched or deformed a cell is due to external forces, allowing researchers to separate the influence of active flows from the intrinsic deformation of the cells.
Filament Flow-Aligning Parameter ($\lambda Q$)
This rheological quantity determines how filaments respond to velocity gradients in active flows. It dictates whether increasing filament alignment enhances mean speed in extensile systems or changes distribution patterns in contractile systems.
Topological Defects
The model distinguishes between defects arising from the filament director field and those arising from the cell shape director field. This distinction helps explain how these two types of structural imperfections move differently within the active turbulent flow.

Terminology

Summary

Cellular dynamics emerging from turbulent flows steered by active filaments develops a continuum theory to describe the collective dynamics of deformable epithelial cells using two tensor order parameters to distinguish force-generating active filaments from their shape <ref:2501. p. 005971#pg2>. This theory demonstrates how active flows create nematic domains of anisotropic cells, drive active turbulence, and create topological defects <ref:2501. p. 005971#pg4>. The paper is significant because it establishes a framework to explain complex collective cell motion by distinguishing between the microstructure of active filaments and the shape of the cells <ref:2501. p. 005971#pg5>.

Theoretical Framework

The model employs a continuum approach describing a two-dimensional layer of confluent cells using a vector velocity field u and two tensor order parameter fields for the microstructure Q and W <ref:2501.05971#pg3>. The rank two tensor Q, referred to as the filament order parameter, represents the nematic orientational order of the filaments that form the cytoskeletal network <ref:2501. p. 105971#pg3>. A second structural variable, W, is introduced to describe cell shape and quantifies anisotropy in the cell shape <ref:2501. p. 105971#pg3>. The equations of motion for these order parameters are coupled and predict the possibility of locally extensional flows in a contractile active material <ref:2501. p. 005971#pg4>.

Flow Dynamics and Deformation

The active stress tensor includes both active and passive contributions, where the active part, Πa = −ζQ, arises from the internal stress generated by the action of molecular motors on the cytoskeletal filaments <ref:2501.05971#pg4>. Straining flows of active turbulence deform isotropic cells with a magnitude related to W <ref:2501. p. 205971#pg5>. A linear scaling for the deformation of the cells is found to be W ∼ ζλW S/(2ηΓW CW) consistent with experimental data <ref:2501. p. 205971#pg5>.

Role of Flow Alignment Parameter

The filament flow-aligning parameter, λQ, is a rheological quantity that determines the response of the filaments to velocity gradients in the active flows <ref:2501.05971#pg3>. In extensile systems (ζ > 0), an increase in λQ increases the mean speed and enhances nematic order through a bootstrapping effect <ref:2501. p. 305971#pg5>. Conversely, in contractile systems (ζ < 0), increasing λQ decreases the mean speed and weakens the peak at θEQ = π/2, leading to bimodal distributions with a new peak at θEQ = 0 <ref:2501. p. 405971#pg5>.

Topological Defect Dynamics

The model distinguishes between defects in the filament director field and those in the shape director field <ref:2501.05971#pg4>. Topological defects formed by active filaments move towards their tails in a contractile system, while shape defects are advected by the active turbulent flow field <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg5>. This distinction explains why shape defects move towards their heads or tails in contractile cell layers <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg4>.

Alignment Between Structures

The relative orientations of the active filaments and elongated cells, quantified by θW Q, are determined by the flow field characteristics <ref:2501.05971#pg7>. In contractile systems with λQ = 0, E is typically perpendicular to Q, leading to W∥E⊥Q <ref:2501. p. 505971#pg7>. However, for λQ = 0. p. 02, extensional flows can emerge in contractile systems where E∥Q occurs, resulting in W∥E∥Q <ref:2501. p. 405971#pg7>. The presence of aligned patches is consistent with measurements showing that the area fraction of cells deformed in the direction of active filaments can be as large as 70% <ref:2501. p. 505971#pg10>.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The theory successfully reconciles the idea of contractile cells exhibiting extensile behaviour by distinguishing between active filaments and cell shape <ref:2501.05971#pg10>. The paper suggests that simultaneous measurement of filament and cell shape orientations could test these ideas <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg10>. The study also poses questions regarding the details of how stress fibers generate dipolar forces <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg10>.

Supporting Information

The temporal autocorrelation of the shape tensor is approximately correlated with the active time scale, τa ∼ η/ζ <ref:2501.05971#pg9>. The study also shows that both shape deformations and flows persist over the active time scale, τa ∼ η/ζ [53] <ref:2501. p. 305971#pg5>. The analysis of flow velocity at the center of defects shows that for contractile systems with λQ = 0, the shape and filament defects almost always move together in an antiparallel configuration <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg9>. The correlation between these defects reduces with an increase in λQ because of the decrease in the strength of active turbulent flow <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg9>. The magnitude of measured velocity increases with increasing activity for both shape and filament defects irrespective of whether the filaments are extensile or contractile <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg9>. The velocities at the center of shape and filament defects are comparable for extensile systems, and they increase with increasing filament flow-aligning parameter <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg9>. For contractile systems, since the change in filament flow-aligning parameter can change the distribution of θEQ, the difference in apparent velocity measured at the center of filament and shape defects is also dependent on λQ <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg9>. The correlation between these defects reduces with an increase in λQ because of the decrease in the strength of active turbulent flow (Fig. p. 6 2(a)) and because the shape and filament defects become less correlated in position and orientation (Fig. p. 6 2(c)) <ref:2501. p. 005971#pg9>. The similarity between shape deformations and flows persisting over the active time scale suggests that activity alone can lead to both elongation and spatial nematic order without thermodynamic driving forces <ref:2501. p. 305971#pg5>. The study highlights the importance of distinguishing the roles of active filaments and cell shape, reconciling the idea of contractile cells exhibiting extensile behaviour <ref:2501. p. 605971#pg10>.

Movies

Movie 1 illustrates dynamics with contractile active filaments and λQ = 0, showing cell shape orientation and defects in the cell shape field <ref:2501.05971#pg9>. Movie 2 shows dynamics with contractile active filaments and λQ = 0. p. 78, displaying regions where cell shape is aligned with the filament orientation <ref:2501. p. 705971#pg9>.

References

[1] G. Gompper, R. p. 8 G. Winkler, T. p. 8 Speck, A. Solon, C. Nardini, F. p. 8 Peruani, H. p. 8 L¨owen, R. p. 8 Golestanian, U. p. 8 B Kaupp, L Alvarez, et al. p. 8, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 32(2020). p. 8

[2] O Hallatschek, S S Datta, K Drescher, J Dunkel, J Elgeti, B Waclaw and N S Wingreen Nature Reviews Physics 5(407) (2023). p. 8

[3] M J Bowick, N Fakhri, M C Marchetti and S Ramaswamy Physical Review X 12(010501) (2022). p. 8

[4] J M Yeomans in Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Physics (2023). p. 8

[5] J-F Joanny and L Br´ezin Active Matter and Nonequilibrium Statistical Physics: Lecture Notes of the Les Houches Summer School 112, 307 (2022). p. 8

[6] E W Gehrels, B Chakrabortty, M-E Perrin, M Merkel, and T Lecuit Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120(e22142051) (2023). p. 8

[7] R M Herrera-Perez C Cupo C Allan A B Dagle and K E Kasza PRX Life 1(013004) (2023). p. 8

[8] R J Tetley M F Staddon D Heller A Hoppe S Banerjee and Y Mao Nat Phys 15(1195) (2019). p. 8

[9] R Alert and X Trepat Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 11(77) (2020). p. 8

[10] E L˚ang A L˚ang P Blicher T Rognes P G Dommersnes and S O Bøe Science Advances 10(eadk4825) (2024). p. 8

[11] S Grosser J Lippoldt L Oswald M Merkel D M Sussman F Renner P Gottheil E W Morawetz T Fuhs X Xie et al. p. 8 Physical Review X 11(011033) (2021). p. 8

[12] S B Lemke and C M Nelson Current Biology 31(R1098) (2021). p. 8

[13] C Villeneuve A Hashmi I Ylivinkka E LawsonKeister Y A Miroshnikova C Perez-Gonz´alez S-M Myllym¨aki F Bertillot B Yadav T Zhang et al. p. 8 Nature Cell Biology 26(207) (2024). p. 8

[14] F Ascione S Caserta S Esposito V R Villella L Maiuri M R Nejad A Doostmohammadi J M Yeomans and S Guido J Royal Soc Interface 20(2023) (14).

[15] M Saadaoui D Rocancourt J Roussel F Corson and J Gros Science 367(453) (2020). p. 8

[16] G Duclos C Blanch-Mercader V Yashunsky G Salbreux J-F Joanny J Prost and P Silberzan Nat Phys 14(728) (2018). p. 8

[17] A Saraswathibhatla S Henkes E E Galles R Sknepnek and J Notbohm Extreme Mechanics Letters 48(101438) (2021). p. 8

[18] T B Saw A Doostmohammadi V Nier L Kocgozlu S Thampi Y Toyama P Marcq C T Lim J M Yeomans and B Ladoux Nature 544(212) (2017). p. 8

[19] R Alert J-F Joanny and J Casademunt Nature Physics 16(682) (2020). p. 8

[20] B H Lee I Seijo-Barandiaran and A Grapin-Botton Current Opinion in Genetics & Development 72(30) (2022). p. 8

[21] J Devany D M Sussman T Yamamoto M L Manning and M L Gardel PNAS 118(e1917853) (2021). p. 8

[25] A Doostmohammadi J Ign´es-Mullol J M Yeomans and F Sagu´es Nat Commun. p. 8 9(3246) (2018). p. 8

[26] L Balasubramaniam A Doostmohammadi T B Saw G H N S Narayana R Mueller T Dang M Thomas S Gupta S Sonam A S Yap Y Toyama R-M Mege J M Yeomans and B Ladoux Nat Mater. p. 8 20(1156–1166) (2021). p. 8

[30] H Xu M R Nejad J M Yeomans and Y Wu Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120(e2219708) (2023). p. 8

[35] M R Nejad L J Ruske M McCord J Zhang G Zhang J Notbohm and J M Yeomans Nature Communications 15(3628) (2024). p. 8

[36] L Balasubramaniam A Doostmohammadi T B Saw G H N S Narayana R Mueller T Dang M Thomas S Gupta S Sonam A S Yap et al. p. 8 Nat Mater. 20(1156) (2021). p. 8

[37] F Vafa M J Bowick B I Shraiman and M C Marchetti Soft Matter 17(3068) (2021). p. 8

[38] A Killeen T Bertrand and C F Lee Phys. p. 8 Rev. Lett. 128(078001) (2022). p. 8

[39] P G de Gennes and J Prost The Physics of Liquid Crystals Oxford University Press (1995). p. 8

[40] A N Beris and B J Edwards Thermodynamics of Flowing Systems With Internal Microstructure Oxford University Press (1994). p. 8

[41] R A Simha and S Ramaswamy Phys. p. 8 Rev. Lett. 89(058101) (2002). p. 8

[42] T Sanchez D T Chen S J DeCamp M Heymann and Z Dogic Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118(e2016708) (2021). p. 8 p. 8

[43] J Colen M Han R Zhang S A Redford L M Lemma L Morgan P V Ruijgrok R Adkins Z Bryant Z Dogic et al. p. 8 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118(e2016708) (2021).

[44] Y Hatwalne S Ramaswamy M Rao and R A Simha Phys. p. 8 Rev. Lett. 92(118101) (2004). p. 8

[45] M Luciano M Versaevel E Vercruysse A Proc´es Y Kalukula A Remson A Deridoux and S Gabriele Biophysics Reviews 3(011305) (2022). p. 8

[46] K Schakenraad J Ernst W Pomp E H Danen R M Merks T Schmidt and L Giomi Soft Matter 16(6328) (2020). p. 8

[47] D Marenduzzo E Orlandini M E Cates and J M Yeomans Phys. p. 8 Rev. E 76(031921) (2007). p. 8

[48] S P Thampi R Golestanian and J M Yeomans Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 372(20130366) (2014). p. 9

[50] S P Thampi R Golestanian and J M Yeomans EPL Europhysics Letters 105(18001) (2014). p. 9

[51] L Giomi M J Bowick X Ma and M C Marchetti Phys. p. 9 Rev. Lett. 110(228101) (2013). p. 9

[52] L Giomi M J Bowick P Mishra R Sknepnek and M C Marchetti Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 372(20130365) (2014). p. 9

[53] I Velez-Cer´on P Guillamat F Sagu´es and J Ign´esMullol Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 121(e2312494) (2024). p. 9

[54] M Serra L Lemma L Giomi Z Dogic and L Mahadevan Nature Physics 19(1355) (2023). p. 9

[55] D-Q Zhang P-C Chen Z-Y Li R Zhang B Li Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 119(e2122494) (2022). p. 9

[56] A Ardaˇseva and A Doostmohammadi Nature Reviews Physics 4(354) (2022). p. 9

[57] K Kawaguchi R Kageyama and M Sano Nature 545(327) (2017). p. 9

[58] J Rønning M C Marchetti M J Bowick and L Angheluta Proceedings of the Royal Society A 478(20210879) (2022). p. 9

Movie 1: Dynamics of a system with contractile active filaments, with filament flow aligning parameter λQ = 0. Left panel: cell shape orientation and defects in the cell shape field. p. 7 p. 7 The background color shows the magnitude of the cell elongation W. p. 7 p. 7 Right panel: active flows are shown as streamlines, defects in cell shape <ref:2501. p. 705971#pg9>.

Movie 2: Dynamics of a system with contractile active filaments, with filament flow aligning parameter λQ = 0. p. 78. Left panel: cell shape orientation and defects in the cell shape field. The background color shows the magnitude of the cell elongation W. Right panel: active flows are shown as streamlines, defects in cell shape (filaments) <ref:2501. p. 705971#pg9>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Develop continuum theories for collective cell dynamics using two tensor order parameters Q (filament order parameter) and W (cell shape order parameter). This allows for distinguishing the force-generating active filaments in the cells from their shape which is critical for accurately modeling complex cellular behavior.

  2. Implement a model where the filament flowaligning parameter lambda Q plays a significant role in determining the pattern of extensional and compressional active flows. The improved system can predict how increasing lambda Q leads to long-range correlations in the active turbulent flow field and how this affects cell alignment, specifically by showing that with increasing λQ, long-range correlations in the active turbulent flow field lead to extended regions where this alignment is parallel.

  3. Incorporate a mechanism to distinguish topological defects in both fields: the two order parameter formalism allows us to distinguish defects in the filament director field, which contribute to the active driving, and those in the shape director field, measured in experiments. This capability enables researchers to explain why shape defects can move towards their heads or tails by linking their movement to the specific orientation of these fields.

  4. Enhance simulation capabilities using a hybrid lattice Boltzmann method to solve coupled equations for Q and W. The improved system can generate simulations initialized with randomly oriented active filaments (Q) and shapes (W) to observe the resulting active turbulence and the persistence of spatial nematic order on the active length scale.

  5. Predict flow characteristics based on activity type: The system can determine that in an extensile system, active flows enhance nematic order, leading to stronger flows emerging from active hydrodynamic instabilities, whereas in a contractile system, they oppose the build up of nematic order resulting in weaker active turbulent flows.

Related papers