Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Great Britain
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Genomics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest computational biology and genomics papers.
Ines: I'm Ines.
Marcus: And I'm Marcus, here with Yuki.
Ines: We're looking at the paper: "Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Great Britain".
Marcus: Here's the gist of the paper. H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns since 2020 The fit to the final model with the most informative spatial scales shows that for the first period game bird abundance and were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples Our analyses show that HPAI cases and wild birds’ abundance are highly predictive of genetic distances when aggregated over grid-based areas The differences in predictors between the two periods bears further investigation, however may be related to differences in the virus, geographical areas of spread, and seasonal factors such as the game bird hunting season in the UK Study Objective The study combines infection and bird population data using Random Forest Decision-Tree models to quantify relationships between spatially aggregated values of possible correlates with infection risk at different geographical scales and viral phylogenetic data to define scales of interactions that may influence virus circulation The authors propose a different approach that directly exploits the relationships between genetic (patristic) distance between the virus sequences, as this is highly correlated with the transmission distance between infected individuals They ask what scales of aggregation are most informative and consider whether simple gridded aggregation against aggregation according to administrative units is more relevant as an indicator of whether human, or natural activity is an underlying driver Scale Selection Methodology The selected scales are determined by assuming that the best scale is the one that on average provides aggregated variable that is the most important for the genetic distance determination with highest importance score and results in the best model fit with highest R2 The final model was constructed using variables describing HPAI H5N1 case aggregates, farm counts and wild abundance calculated over selected scales They used three metrics to select the scales of spatially aggregated variables comparing RF runs with variables defined on different scales Key Findings on Drivers The most informative factors for genetic distance prediction were period-dependent; for the first period, game bird abundance and wild bird abundance were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples For the second period, geographical distance, but also collection date and farm count identified as most informative In period 1 (December 2021 to May 2022), game bird and raptor abundance appeared important in predicting genetic distances, suggesting a bridging role between observed samples with significant undetected transmission among them In the later period (June-October 2022), farm count played an important role, and areas of higher abundance of gulls and corvids indicated much shorter genetic connections Implications for Intervention The variability of scale across risk factors and time periods illustrates the importance of considering relevant spatial scale in understanding transmission in complex disease ecosystems The methodology developed can be used to study geographical scales of complex pathogen-host-environmental systems like avian influenza combining pathogen sequence data with many variables reported in spatial resolution In the future, these investigations may be used to provide geographical scales that are the most useful to studying dynamics of HPAI spread and the scale for targeted surveillance and intervention strategies Data Integration The analysis integrated HPAI H5N1 sequences from period 03rd December 2020 to 19th October 2022 with all positive HPAI H5N1 cases from the same period, poultry farm data as of December 2022 and wild bird abundance data from eBird platform from year 2021 Data processing involved assigning grid areas (considering all resolutions from H to XXL) and 2011 Census Output Areas to each case The genetic distance between paired sequences was calculated for each pair using the Tamura and Nei 1993 model Temporal Distance Optimization A temporal distance cutoff excluding the sequences that were sampled over 30 days from each other was implemented to exclude pairs most likely because of the time of emergence This threshold was selected based on temporal distance optimization where it aimed to select the model with temporal distance threshold that had the lowest importance without compromising the model fit The results from this genetic distance threshold optimisation are presented on Figure 3 Overall, the methodology developed can be used to study geographical scales of complex pathogen-host-environmental systems like avian influenza combining pathogen sequence data with many variables reported in spatial resolution The variability of scale across risk factors and time periods that we have identified illustrates the importance of considering relevant spatial scale in understanding transmission in complex disease ecosystems In the future the investigations of scales can be implemented to improve spatial sampling strategies, define targeted interventions and the zones they are implemented in, or create more accurate risk maps The study indicates that HPAI cases and wild birds’ abundance are highly predictive of genetic distances when aggregated over grid-based areas References Apley, D.
Ines: (2018).
Marcus: ALEPlot: Accumulated Local Effects (ALE) Plots and Partial Dependence (PD) Plots.
Ines: https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/ALEPlot/index.html Barroso, P., López-Olvera, J.
Paper summary: Ines: So, we're looking at this paper called Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Great Britain. The main idea here is they want to figure out what spatial scales are most informative when trying to link infection risk to genetic distance between virus samples.
Marcus: Right, so the core thesis is that they combine infection data with bird population data using Random Forest models and viral phylogenetic data to define these interaction scales and see how they predict spread. It’s about finding the right way to look at things geographically when studying this virus.
Yuki: From a population genetics standpoint, it’s interesting because H5N1 has been spreading in previously unseen patterns since two thousand twenty and this study tries to give us a better understanding of those drivers for the spatiotemporal patterns of circulation that underpin the global spread <ref:2411.10424#pg1,in previously unseen patterns since 2020>.
Ines: Exactly. They are using these models to quantify the relationship between spatially aggregated values of possible correlates with infection risk at different geographical scales, while also defining scales based on viral phylogenetic data that might influence virus circulation.
Marcus: The paper claims they found period-dependent predictors, meaning what drives the genetic distance prediction changes depending on when you look at the data. For instance, for the first period they studied, game bird abundance and wild bird abundance were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples.
Yuki: That suggests that in that initial phase, having information about where those birds are abundant really helped us connect different virus samples through their genetic distance. What does that imply about how the virus moves across those landscapes?
Ines: It suggests a bridging role between observed samples with significant undetected transmission among them, because game bird and raptor abundance appeared important in predicting genetic distances during that first period.
Marcus: Then they shift focus for the later period, June to October two thousand twenty-two and farm count played an important role <ref:2411.10424#pg1>. They also found that areas with higher abundance of gulls and corvids indicated much shorter genetic connections there.
Yuki: So, it seems like the relevant ecological factor shifts over time—from bird abundance early on to farm activity later—which makes sense if you're looking at how different parts of the ecosystem interact with the virus.
Ines: The paper is interested in whether simple gridded aggregation against aggregation according to administrative units is more relevant as an indicator of whether human or natural activity is the underlying driver.
Marcus: They tested that by comparing their models, and they found that while the R squared value describes the fit of the whole model rather than just one variable, generally the differences from their random forest models were quite small.
Yuki: That's a bit of a caution there. It sounds like while they found interesting predictors, it’s important to remember that changing only one abundance variable doesn't necessarily mean you have the best fit for the whole picture.
Ines: Right, because as for abundance variables they changed the scales of all abundance species group variables together and that R squared change doesn't indicate the goodness of fit when only one of the abundance variables is changed. They also used three metrics to select these scales and found that the R squared was the most variable, while importance based metrics were more consistent.
Marcus: That tells us that relying on just one perfect spatial scale might be too narrow; you need to look at how different aggregation methods perform across all those variables.
Yuki: I wonder what this means for us in terms of real-world monitoring, since the paper is looking at risk mapping for avian influenza in Great Britain. It suggests that our approach to defining geographical scales needs to be flexible based on the time period and the specific drivers we are interested in.
Ines: Precisely. This whole study is about using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Great Britain, and it shows that the interaction structure isn't static across different ecological factors or time frames.
Marcus: So, to wrap up on this paper, the authors are pointing toward a more nuanced view where the most useful spatial scale depends entirely on what you are trying to predict—whether it's infection risk based on bird density or farm activity.
Yuki: It really highlights that understanding H5N1 spread requires integrating those different ecological perspectives across different time frames, which is crucial for long-term risk assessment for both wild and domestic poultry populations.
Ines: Yeah, the implications are that we can use this methodology to study geographical scales of complex pathogen host environmental systems, combining sequence data with many variables reported in spatial resolution. It helps define the best scales for targeted surveillance and intervention strategies moving forward.
Conclusion: Ines: So, we’re wrapping up our look at this paper about Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in Great Britain by looking at sequence data and spatial scales of interaction.
Marcus: Yeah, the authors are using Random Forest models to link infection risk to genetic distance between virus samples, trying to figure out which geographical scales matter most.
Ines: The conclusion they draw is that the way you define those spatial scales really depends on what you're looking at and when you look at it.
Marcus: They found that for one time period, like the first one they studied, bird abundance—both game birds and wild birds—were the biggest drivers for predicting genetic distance between samples.
Ines: That suggests that in that initial phase, knowing where those specific animals are abundant really helped connect different virus samples through their genetic distance.
Marcus: But then things shift for a later period, like June to October twenty twenty two, and farm count becomes more important in predicting those distances.
Ines: So the key finding is that the most informative factor isn't fixed; it changes based on the time period you analyze.
Marcus: Right, and they also pointed out that these differences might be because of different virus strains or maybe seasonal factors like when people are hunting game birds in places like the UK.
Ines: The paper suggests we can use this method to study how complex systems, like an influenza outbreak, work spatially by combining sequence data with many different variables reported at various resolutions.
Marcus: It gives us a framework for figuring out which geographical scales are most useful when we want to set up targeted surveillance or intervention strategies for these outbreaks.
Ines: So the next thing we need to look at is how this study can specifically help define those actionable zones for stopping the spread of this virus.
Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh · School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh
q-bio.PE
Submitted: 2024-11-15
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: Main figures and tables are updated
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 87/100
The gist: H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns since 2020 The fit to the final model with the most informative spatial scales shows…
Key concepts
- Genetic Distance
- This measures how different two influenza virus sequences are from each other, based on nucleotide substitutions. It is used here as a proxy for the distance viruses traveled or the transmission distance between infected individuals.
- Spatial Scales of Aggregation
- This refers to different ways of grouping data geographically, such as using large grid areas versus smaller administrative zones. The study tests which grouping method best captures the underlying factors driving virus spread.
- Random Forest Models
- These are sophisticated machine learning tools used to predict outcomes based on various input variables. They were employed here to determine the most important spatial and biological factors influencing the genetic distance between virus samples.
Terminology
Summary
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns since 2020 The fit to the final model with the most informative spatial scales shows that for the first period game bird abundance and were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples Our analyses show that HPAI cases and wild birds’ abundance are highly predictive of genetic distances when aggregated over grid-based areas The differences in predictors between the two periods bears further investigation, however may be related to differences in the virus, geographical areas of spread, and seasonal factors such as the game bird hunting season in the UK
Study Objective
The study combines infection and bird population data using Random Forest Decision-Tree models to quantify relationships between spatially aggregated values of possible correlates with infection risk at different geographical scales and viral phylogenetic data to define scales of interactions that may influence virus circulation The authors propose a different approach that directly exploits the relationships between genetic (patristic) distance between the virus sequences, as this is highly correlated with the transmission distance between infected individuals They ask what scales of aggregation are most informative and consider whether simple gridded aggregation against aggregation according to administrative units is more relevant as an indicator of whether human, or natural activity is an underlying driver
Scale Selection Methodology
The selected scales are determined by assuming that the best scale is the one that on average provides aggregated variable that is the most important for the genetic distance determination with highest importance score and results in the best model fit with highest R2 The final model was constructed using variables describing HPAI H5N1 case aggregates, farm counts and wild abundance calculated over selected scales They used three metrics to select the scales of spatially aggregated variables comparing RF runs with variables defined on different scales
Key Findings on Drivers
The most informative factors for genetic distance prediction were period-dependent; for the first period, game bird abundance and wild bird abundance were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples For the second period, geographical distance, but also collection date and farm count identified as most informative In period 1 (December 2021 to May 2022), game bird and raptor abundance appeared important in predicting genetic distances, suggesting a bridging role between observed samples with significant undetected transmission among them In the later period (June-October 2022), farm count played an important role, and areas of higher abundance of gulls and corvids indicated much shorter genetic connections
Implications for Intervention
The variability of scale across risk factors and time periods illustrates the importance of considering relevant spatial scale in understanding transmission in complex disease ecosystems The methodology developed can be used to study geographical scales of complex pathogen-host-environmental systems like avian influenza combining pathogen sequence data with many variables reported in spatial resolution In the future, these investigations may be used to provide geographical scales that are the most useful to studying dynamics of HPAI spread and the scale for targeted surveillance and intervention strategies
Data Integration
The analysis integrated HPAI H5N1 sequences from period 03rd December 2020 to 19th October 2022 with all positive HPAI H5N1 cases from the same period, poultry farm data as of December 2022 and wild bird abundance data from eBird platform from year 2021 Data processing involved assigning grid areas (considering all resolutions from H to XXL) and 2011 Census Output Areas to each case The genetic distance between paired sequences was calculated for each pair using the Tamura and Nei 1993 model
Temporal Distance Optimization
A temporal distance cutoff excluding the sequences that were sampled over 30 days from each other was implemented to exclude pairs most likely because of the time of emergence This threshold was selected based on temporal distance optimization where it aimed to select the model with temporal distance threshold that had the lowest importance without compromising the model fit The results from this genetic distance threshold optimisation are presented on Figure 3
Conclusion
Overall, the methodology developed can be used to study geographical scales of complex pathogen-host-environmental systems like avian influenza combining pathogen sequence data with many variables reported in spatial resolution The variability of scale across risk factors and time periods that we have identified illustrates the importance of considering relevant spatial scale in understanding transmission in complex disease ecosystems In the future the investigations of scales can be implemented to improve spatial sampling strategies, define targeted interventions and the zones they are implemented in, or create more accurate risk maps The study indicates that HPAI cases and wild birds’ abundance are highly predictive of genetic distances when aggregated over grid-based areas
References
Apley, D. (2018). ALEPlot: Accumulated Local Effects (ALE) Plots and Partial Dependence (PD) Plots. p. 9 We selected the final version presented on Fig. 1 and 2 in the Results section for which we generated
Accumulated Local Effects (ALE) plots to gain additional insight into selected variables.Where the paper says it
Barroso, P., López-Olvera, J. R., Kiluba wa Kiluba, T., & Gortázar, C. (2024). Overcoming the limitations of wildlife disease monitoring. p. 4 While wild bird
abundance reported for citizen science project is a useful, free resource, it is inherently biased in the semi-structured
data collection procedures (Vickers et al. Nonetheless, the variability of scale across risk factors, and time periods that we have identified illustrates the
importance of considering of relevant spatial scale in understanding transmission in complex disease ecosystems, as In contrast, areas of higher abundance of gulls and corvids
indicate much shorter genetic connections, potentially indicating a direct role for these species in bridging otherwise
unconnected patterns of circulation. However, such considerations are at best only indicators of future directions of
investigation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Bonilla-Aldana, D. K., Calle-Hernández, D. M., Ulloque-Badaracco, J. R., Alarcón-Braga, E. A., HernándezBustamante, E. A., Cabrera-Guzmán, J. C., Quispe-Vasquez, S. M., Huayta-Cortez, M. A., BenitesZapata, V. A., & Rodriguez-Morales, A. J. (2024). Highly pathogenic avian influenza A(H5N1) in animals: A systematic review and meta-analysis. p. 0 Title
Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic
Avian Influenza in Great Britain
Authors:
Anna Gamża*
1
, Sam Lycett1
, Aeron Sanchez1
, Rowland Kao1,2
1) The Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
2) School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Abstract
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns
since 2020. As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers for spatiotemporal
patterns of circulation, as these patterns underpin global spread, and inform about the long-term impact of the virus
on both avian and mammal populations and facilitate development of efficient intervention strategies. While there
are microbiological clues about the increased virus fitness (Fusaro et al. , 2024), studies are still ongoing to explain how
the emergence of the new strain affects the whole host-pathogen-environment system (Sacristán et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Brock, P. M., Fornace, K. M., Grigg, M. J., Anstey, N. M., William, T., Cox, J., Drakeley, C. J., Ferguson, H. M., & Kao, R. R. (2019). Predictive analysis across spatial scales links zoonotic malaria to deforestation. p. 0 For the analysis we used
HPAI N5N1 Sequences from Great Britain divided into two separately analysed periods: from December 2020 to May
2022, and from June 2022 to October 2022. The fit to the final model with the most informative spatial scales shows that for the first period game bird abundance
and were the strongest predictors of genetic distance between samples.Where the paper says it
CDC. (2024a). Current H5N1 Bird Flu Situation in Dairy Cows. p. 1 This may be because of unobserved
circulation in the Anseriforme population but also may be due to other correlated factors. Past studies on risk factors of Avian Flu, only considered risks mapped with predetermined, fixed resolution, e. Introduction
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) virus has been increasingly spreading worldwide since 2020, infecting
wild birds and mammals with unprecedented levels of mortality, and threatening domesticated poultry production in
many countries (Koopmans et al. Concerns over the continued transmission of H5N1 have recently increased
with reports of extensive circulation in the US cattle population (CDC, 2024a; Neumann & Kawaoka, 2024) and recent
reports of human cases (CDC, 2024b). Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Introduction
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) virus has been increasingly spreading worldwide since 2020, infecting
wild birds and mammals with unprecedented levels of mortality, and threatening domesticated poultry production in
many countries (Koopmans et al. Concerns over the continued transmission of H5N1 have recently increased
with reports of extensive circulation in the US cattle population (CDC, 2024a; Neumann & Kawaoka, 2024) and recent
reports of human cases (CDC, 2024b).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
CDC. (2024b). H5 Bird Flu: Current Situation. p. 1 This may be because of unobserved
circulation in the Anseriforme population but also may be due to other correlated factors. Past studies on risk factors of Avian Flu, only considered risks mapped with predetermined, fixed resolution, e. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Cornell Lab of Ornithology. (2024). eBird. Retrieved 15/11/2024 from https://ebird. p. 8 Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Defra's Science Advisory Council. (2023). Independent report. p. 7 We included both reports classified as “poultry” and
“non-poultry including wild birds”; where the later included not only wild bird cases but also captive, domestic bird
cases from hobby farm, zoos and similar premises. The locations of the outbreaks were exported from the WAHIS map
and connected to metadata downloaded from outbreak list for each report using their Outbreak IDs. Title
Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic
Avian Influenza in Great Britain
Authors:
Anna Gamża*
1
, Sam Lycett1
, Aeron Sanchez1
, Rowland Kao1,2
1) The Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
2) School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Abstract
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns
since 2020. As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers for spatiotemporal
patterns of circulation, as these patterns underpin global spread, and inform about the long-term impact of the virus
on both avian and mammal populations and facilitate development of efficient intervention strategies.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Dellicour, S., Rose, R., Faria, N. R., Lemey, P., & Pybus, O. G. (2016). SERAPHIM: studying environmental rasters and phylogenetically informed movements. p. 0 Our study indicates that the scale of geographical aggregation and/or extrapolation to consider is variable dependent
and reflects the scale of processes it indicates. In the future our findings may be used to provide geographical scales
that are the most useful to studying dynamics of HPAI spread and the scale for targeted surveillance and intervention
strategies.Where the paper says it
Edzer Pebesma, R. B., Etienne Racine, Michael Sumner, Ian Cook, Tim Keitt, Robin Lovelace, Hadley Wickham, Jeroen Ooms, Kirill Müller, Thomas Lin Pedersen, Dan Baston, Dewey Dunnington. (2024). sf: Simple Features for R. p. 1 We consider recent data (December 2020 to May 2022, and from June 2022 to October 2022) from the epidemic of
HPAI H5N1 in Great Britain and using Random Forest models, we ask how various spatially aggregated demographic
and environmental variables impacts the genetic distance between sampled viruses. Crucially we ask what scales of
aggregation are most informative, and consider the performance of simple gridded aggregation against aggregation
according to administrative units is more relevant, as this is an indicator of whether human, or natural activity is an
underlying driver.Where the paper says it
Emmanuel Paradis, S. B., Ben Bolker, Joseph Brown, Santiago Claramunt, Julien Claude, Hoa Sien Cuong, Richard Desper, Gilles Didier,Benoit Durand, Julien Dutheil, RJ Ewing, Olivier Gascuel, Thomas Guillerme, Christoph Heibl, Anthony Ives, Bradley Jones, Franz Krah. (2024). ape: Analyses of Phylogenetics and Evolution. p. 0 For the second period, this changed, with
geographical distance, but also collection date and farm count identified as most informative. Our analyses show that
HPAI cases and wild birds’ abundance are highly predictive of genetic distances when aggregated over grid-based
areas. The genetic distance between paired sequences was calculated for
each pair using the Tamura and Nei 1993 model (Tamura & Nei, 1993) (R; function: dist. dna, package: APE (Emmanuel
Paradis, 2024)).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Fusaro, A., Zecchin, B., Giussani, E., Palumbo, E., Agüero-García, M., Bachofen, C., Bálint, Á., Banihashem, F., Banyard, A. C., Beerens, N... Monne. (2024). High pathogenic avian influenza A(H5) viruses of clade 2. p. 7 without any
further specification) was a “domestic duck/goose”, “gull” (2 cases) or “buzzard” (3 cases) was “common_gull/buzzard”
and “falcon” (1 case) was “peregrine_falcon”. Public data with reported HPAI H5N1 outbreaks (“Influenza A viruses of high pathogenicity (Inf. The proper
definition of the system involves understanding of the biology of virus itself, and the local environment in which
transmission occurs. However, understanding of the latter can be difficult, at least in part because data on infection in
wildlife can be both fragmented and heavily biased (Barroso et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust. (2024). Releasing for shooting in lowland habitats. Retrieved 15/11/2024 from https://www.gwct.org.uk/game/research/species/pheasant/releasing-forshooting-in-lowland-habitats
Gamża, A., Lycett, S., Harvey, W., Hughes, J. H., Nickbakhsh, S., Robertson, D., Smith Palmer, A., Wood, A., & Kao. (2023). Spatial Analysis of Phylogenetic, Population and Deprivation Data from Scottish SarsCov-2 Outbreak Reveals Patterns of the Community Transmission. p. 0 As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers for spatiotemporal
patterns of circulation, as these patterns underpin global spread, and inform about the long-term impact of the virus
on both avian and mammal populations and facilitate development of efficient intervention strategies. We combine infection and bird population data, using Random Forest Decision-Tree models to quantify the
relationship between (i) spatially aggregated values of possible correlates with infection risk at different geographical
scales and (ii) viral phylogenetic data from British HPAI outbreaks to define scales of interactions that may influence
virus circulation.Where the paper says it
Gargallo, G., Davies, J. G., Faverjon, C., Kampichler, C., Baillie, S. R., Cameron, A., Robinson, R. A., & Sierdsema, H. (2022). Development of a prototype early warning system for avian influenza in the EU based on risk-mapping. p. 1 Understanding of the H5N1 transmission dynamic in context of the whole epidemiological system is crucial to assess
risk and impact of the virus on both avian and mammal populations either kept on farms or in the wild, and to develop
efficient intervention strategies aimed at reducing the risks to animals and humans and stopping infection spread. In a pathogen-host-environment system as complicated as Avian Influenza (Bonilla-Aldana et al.Where the paper says it
Gilbert, M., & Pfeiffer, D. p. 1 see
(Gargallo et al. , 2022; Gilbert & Pfeiffer, 2012). Title
Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic
Avian Influenza in Great Britain
Authors:
Anna Gamża*
1
, Sam Lycett1
, Aeron Sanchez1
, Rowland Kao1,2
1) The Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
2) School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Abstract
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns
since 2020. As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers for spatiotemporal
patterns of circulation, as these patterns underpin global spread, and inform about the long-term impact of the virus
on both avian and mammal populations and facilitate development of efficient intervention strategies.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
GISAID Data Science Initiative. (2024). GISAID. Retrieved 15/11/2024 from https://gisaid. p. 8 Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Koopmans, M. P. G., Barton Behravesh, C., Cunningham, A. A., Adisasmito, W. B., Almuhairi, S., Bilivogui, P., Bukachi, S. A., Casas, N., Cediel Becerra, N., Charron, D. F., Chaudhary, A., Ciacci Zanella, J. R., Dar, O., Debnath, N., Dungu, B., Farag, E., Gao, G. F., Khaitsa M., Machalaba C.,... Hayman. (2024). The panzootic spread of highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1 sublineage 2. p. 0 Title
Using sequence data to study spatial scales of interactions driving spread of Highly Pathogenic
Avian Influenza in Great Britain
Authors:
Anna Gamża*
1
, Sam Lycett1
, Aeron Sanchez1
, Rowland Kao1,2
1) The Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
2) School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Abstract
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been circulating around the globe in previously unseen patterns
since 2020. As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers for spatiotemporal
patterns of circulation, as these patterns underpin global spread, and inform about the long-term impact of the virus
on both avian and mammal populations and facilitate development of efficient intervention strategies. Methods
Data
For the analysis we integrated HPAI H5N1 sequences from period 03rd December 2020 to 19th October 2022 with all
positive HPAI H5N1 cases from the same period, poultry farm data as of December 2022 and wild bird abundance data
from eBird platform from year 2021; all data sources are summed up in Table 2. Raw data used for analysis of dependence of genetic distance between sequences of H5N1 and other variables connected
to HPAI epidemic in years 2020-2022
Dataset Source Description Notes
HPAI Sequences GISAID (GISAID Data
Science Initiative)
Genetic sequence of HPAI cases from
United Kingdom from years 2020-2022
The coordinates attributed for each
published sequence we analysed
were provided by Animal and Plant
Health Agency. , 2024; Koopmans et
al. , 2024), defining and studying all types of important potentially infectious interactions is challenging.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Le Gall-Ladevèze, C., Guinat, C., Fievet, P., Vollot, B., Guérin, J.-L., Cappelle, J., & Le Loc’h. (2022). Quantification and characterisation of commensal wild birds and their interactions with domestic ducks on a free-range farm in southwest France. p. 2 Moreover, as for abundance variables
we changed the scales of all abundance species group variablestogether, the R2
change does not indicate the goodness
of fit when only one of the abundance variables is changed. Scale selected for variables with aggregated data based on Random Forest model fits as indicated by three matrices; in
parentheses is the number of Random Forest model fit repetitions that selected the scale (out of 100) as the most informative
one; underlined is the scale selected for the final model
Variable Scale selected for season 1 Scale selected for season 2
Metrics I1 Metrics II2 Metrics III3 Metrics I1 Metrics II2 Metrics III3
Number of domestic bird cases XXL (31/100) XXL (100/100) XXL (99/100) H (91/100) H (100/100) H (100/100)
Number of wild bird cases XL (78/100) XL (97/100) XL (100/100) XXL (43/100) XXL (100/100) XXL (93/100)
Poultry farm count LA (96/100) LA (100/100) LA (100/100) LA (96/100) DZ (54/100) LA (100/100)
Abundance of corvids NA* M (72/100) M (45/100) NA* XXL (94/100) XXL (99/100)
Abundance of ducks NA* M (59/100) XXL (99/100) NA* XXL (100/100) XXL (100/100)
Abundance of game birds NA* M (100/100) M (100/100) NA* M (92/100) M (94/100)
Abundance of gulls NA* M (98/100) M (100/100) NA* XXL (99/100) XXL (100/100)
Abundance of owls NA* M (82/100) L (56/100) NA* M (100/100) M (100/100)
Abundance of raptors NA* L (100/100) L (100/100) NA* M (92/100) M (92/100)
Abundance of swans NA* XXL (75/100) XXL (100/100) NA* XXL (75/100) XXL (84/100)
Abundance of terns NA* L (100/100) L (100/100) NA* M (100/100) M (100/100)
Abundance of waders NA* M (100/100) M (52/100) NA* XXL (58/100) XL (98/100)
Abundance of All birds NA* M (99/100) M (100/100) NA* M (53/100) XXL (100/100)
1) Difference in R2 between the model including variables in all scales and separate models each with tested variable in only
one scale (tested scale)
2) Difference in permutation importance of the scaled variables from the model including variables in all scales
3) Difference in permutation importance of the scaled variables from separate models each with tested variable in only one
scale (tested scale)
* R2
change does not indicate the fit for each abundance variable separately, as the scale was changed for all abundance
variables together
Maps illustrating areas in selected scales and shapes are presented on Supplementary Figures 7-14. Introduction
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) virus has been increasingly spreading worldwide since 2020, infecting
wild birds and mammals with unprecedented levels of mortality, and threatening domesticated poultry production in
many countries (Koopmans et al. Concerns over the continued transmission of H5N1 have recently increased
with reports of extensive circulation in the US cattle population (CDC, 2024a; Neumann & Kawaoka, 2024) and recent
reports of human cases (CDC, 2024b).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Marvin N. Wright, S. W., Philipp Probst. (2023). ranger: A Fast Implementation of Random Forests. p. 9 1 and 2 in the Results section for which we generated
Accumulated Local Effects (ALE) plots to gain additional insight into selected variables. Random Forest analysis was implemented in R using package “ranger” (Marvin N. 1 and 2 in the Results section for which we generated
Accumulated Local Effects (ALE) plots to gain additional insight into selected variables. Random Forest analysis was implemented in R using package “ranger” (Marvin N.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Matthew Strimas-Mackey, S. L., Tom Auer, Daniel Fink, Cornell Lab of Ornithology. p. 5 Poultry farm count Great Britain Poultry
Register (GBPR)
Extract from GBPR as of 1 December 2022
with poultry premises locations. Wild bird abundance
data
eBird (Cornell Lab of
Ornithology)
Weekly counts from 2021 in medium and
low resolution. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Meentemeyer, R. K., Haas, S. E., & Václavík, T. (2012). Landscape epidemiology of emerging infectious diseases in natural and human-altered ecosystems. p. 1 , 2022; Gilbert & Pfeiffer, 2012). However, identifying the scales of various interactions that are at play
in transmission system such as HPAI can be challenging given the mobility of human and animal populations, and may
also be variable, for example due to the characteristics of the epidemiology, or seasonal changes in causative factors,
such as the environmental survival of virus (Stenkamp-Strahm et al.Where the paper says it
National Records of Scotland. 2011 Census Indexes. p. 5 Wild bird abundance
data
eBird (Cornell Lab of
Ornithology)
Weekly counts from 2021 in medium and
low resolution. Census geography
shapefiles
UK Data Service (UK
Data Service)
Shapefiles for administrative areas
(Output Areas) defined for 2011 Census
Postcode lookup
with administrative
areas codes
Office for National
Statistics (Office for
National Statistics)
A best-fit lookup between postcodes, 2011
Census Output Areas, Lower Layer Super
Output Areas/Data Zones, Middle Layer
Output Areas/Intermediate Zones and
Local Authority Districts
Lower and Middle Layer Super
Output Areas are areas defined for
England and Wales (Office for
National Statistics), while Data
Zones and Intermediate zones are
areas defined for Scotland
(Scotland's Census, 2021)
We divided the sequence data into two periods that we analysed separately: first period spanning from 03rd December
2020 to 31st May 2022 and second from 01st June 2022 to 19th October 2022. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. While the relationships identified here are
correlations and may not be causative, additional evidence from experimental data shows that pheasants in particular
are both highly susceptible to HPAI and shed virus in faeces with unusually long survival times in the environment
(Seekings et al. , 2024), moreover they have been the subject of speculation on a potential role in the circulation of
H5N1 (Defra's Science Advisory Council, 2023).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Neumann, G., & Kawaoka, Y. p. 1 Introduction
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) virus has been increasingly spreading worldwide since 2020, infecting
wild birds and mammals with unprecedented levels of mortality, and threatening domesticated poultry production in
many countries (Koopmans et al. Concerns over the continued transmission of H5N1 have recently increased
with reports of extensive circulation in the US cattle population (CDC, 2024a; Neumann & Kawaoka, 2024) and recent
reports of human cases (CDC, 2024b). Introduction
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) virus has been increasingly spreading worldwide since 2020, infecting
wild birds and mammals with unprecedented levels of mortality, and threatening domesticated poultry production in
many countries (Koopmans et al. Concerns over the continued transmission of H5N1 have recently increased
with reports of extensive circulation in the US cattle population (CDC, 2024a; Neumann & Kawaoka, 2024) and recent
reports of human cases (CDC, 2024b).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Office for National Statistics. (2024a). 2011 Census geographies. p. 6 • Output areas form the building blocks for all other
census geographies. Different population densities mean
the size and shape of output areas can
vary greatly
• In England and Wales, contain between 40 and 250
households and population between 100 and 625
persons as of 2011
• In Scotland, contains at least 50 people and 20
households as of 2011
Lower layer Super Output
Areas/Data Zone
• Areas composed of groups of 2011 Census Output
Areas, usually four or five, in England and Wales called
Lower Layer Super Output Areas and in Scotland, called
Data Zones
Different population densities mean
the size and shape of output areas can
vary greatly
• Lower Layer Super Output Areas contain between 400
and 1,200 households and population between 1,000
and 3,000 persons as of 2011
• Data Zones designed to have population of 500 to
1,000 persons as of 2011
Middle layer Super Output
Areas/Intermediate zone
• Areas composed of groups of Lower Layer Super
Output Areas/Data Zones usually four or five, in
England and Wales called Middle layer Super Output
Areas and in Scotland, called Intermediate zones.Where the paper says it
Office for National Statistics. (2024b). National Statistics Postcode Lookup - 2011 Census (August 2022) for the UK. p. 5 Wild bird abundance
data
eBird (Cornell Lab of
Ornithology)
Weekly counts from 2021 in medium and
low resolution. Census geography
shapefiles
UK Data Service (UK
Data Service)
Shapefiles for administrative areas
(Output Areas) defined for 2011 Census
Postcode lookup
with administrative
areas codes
Office for National
Statistics (Office for
National Statistics)
A best-fit lookup between postcodes, 2011
Census Output Areas, Lower Layer Super
Output Areas/Data Zones, Middle Layer
Output Areas/Intermediate Zones and
Local Authority Districts
Lower and Middle Layer Super
Output Areas are areas defined for
England and Wales (Office for
National Statistics), while Data
Zones and Intermediate zones are
areas defined for Scotland
(Scotland's Census, 2021)
We divided the sequence data into two periods that we analysed separately: first period spanning from 03rd December
2020 to 31st May 2022 and second from 01st June 2022 to 19th October 2022. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al. Wild bird abundance
data
eBird (Cornell Lab of
Ornithology)
Weekly counts from 2021 in medium and
low resolution. Census geography
shapefiles
UK Data Service (UK
Data Service)
Shapefiles for administrative areas
(Output Areas) defined for 2011 Census
Postcode lookup
with administrative
areas codes
Office for National
Statistics (Office for
National Statistics)
A best-fit lookup between postcodes, 2011
Census Output Areas, Lower Layer Super
Output Areas/Data Zones, Middle Layer
Output Areas/Intermediate Zones and
Local Authority Districts
Lower and Middle Layer Super
Output Areas are areas defined for
England and Wales (Office for
National Statistics), while Data
Zones and Intermediate zones are
areas defined for Scotland
(Scotland's Census, 2021)
We divided the sequence data into two periods that we analysed separately: first period spanning from 03rd December
2020 to 31st May 2022 and second from 01st June 2022 to 19th October 2022.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Sacristán, C., Ewbank, A. C., Ibáñez Porras, P., Pérez-Ramírez, E., de la Torre, A., Briones, V., & Iglesias, I. (2024). Novel Epidemiologic Features of High Pathogenicity Avian Influenza Virus A H5N1 2. p. 7 without any
further specification) was a “domestic duck/goose”, “gull” (2 cases) or “buzzard” (3 cases) was “common_gull/buzzard”
and “falcon” (1 case) was “peregrine_falcon”. Public data with reported HPAI H5N1 outbreaks (“Influenza A viruses of high pathogenicity (Inf.Where the paper says it
Scotland's Census. (2021). 2011 census: Geographies. p. 6 • Output areas form the building blocks for all other
census geographies. Different population densities mean
the size and shape of output areas can
vary greatly
• In England and Wales, contain between 40 and 250
households and population between 100 and 625
persons as of 2011
• In Scotland, contains at least 50 people and 20
households as of 2011
Lower layer Super Output
Areas/Data Zone
• Areas composed of groups of 2011 Census Output
Areas, usually four or five, in England and Wales called
Lower Layer Super Output Areas and in Scotland, called
Data Zones
Different population densities mean
the size and shape of output areas can
vary greatly
• Lower Layer Super Output Areas contain between 400
and 1,200 households and population between 1,000
and 3,000 persons as of 2011
• Data Zones designed to have population of 500 to
1,000 persons as of 2011
Middle layer Super Output
Areas/Intermediate zone
• Areas composed of groups of Lower Layer Super
Output Areas/Data Zones usually four or five, in
England and Wales called Middle layer Super Output
Areas and in Scotland, called Intermediate zones. Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Seekings, A. H., Liang, Y., Warren, C. J., Hjulsager, C. K., Thomas, S. S., Lean, F. Z. X., Nunez, A., Skinner, P., Selden, D., Falchieri, M., Simmons, H., Brown, I. H., Larsen L E., Banyard A C., & Slomka M J. (2024). Transmission dynamics and pathogenesis differ between pheasants and partridges infected with clade 2. p. 0 The differences in predictors between the two periods bears further
investigation, however may be related to differences in the virus, geographical areas of spread, and seasonal factors,
such as the game bird hunting season in the UK. This is the first phylogenetic study that indicates a possible role for
game birds in the circulation of HPAI and it is consistent with evidence from experimental studies about the potential
for pheasants in particular to become infected and spread the infection, but must be viewed with caution as our
approach does not directly indicate causation. without any
further specification) was a “domestic duck/goose”, “gull” (2 cases) or “buzzard” (3 cases) was “common_gull/buzzard”
and “falcon” (1 case) was “peregrine_falcon”. Public data with reported HPAI H5N1 outbreaks (“Influenza A viruses of high pathogenicity (Inf.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Stenkamp-Strahm, C., Patyk, K., McCool-Eye, M. J., Fox, A., Humphreys, J., James, A., South, D., & Magzamen S. (2020). Using geospatial methods to measure the risk of environmental persistence of avian influenza virus in South Carolina. p. 5 Overall, the methodology we developed can be used to study geographical
scales of complex pathogen-host-environmental systems like avian influenza combining pathogen sequence data with
many variables reported in spatial resolution. In the future the investigations of scales can be implemented to improve
spatial sampling strategies, define targeted interventions and the zones they are implemented in, or create more
accurate risk maps. , 2022; Gilbert & Pfeiffer, 2012). However, identifying the scales of various interactions that are at play
in transmission system such as HPAI can be challenging given the mobility of human and animal populations, and may
also be variable, for example due to the characteristics of the epidemiology, or seasonal changes in causative factors,
such as the environmental survival of virus (Stenkamp-Strahm et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Tamura, K., & Nei, M. p. 9 The order of sequences
withing each pair (Sequence 1 and Sequence 2) was randomised (initial order based on entry number was either
preserved or reversed with equal probabilities, using R function: sample (with replacement) to choose from two
options (swap or not) both options equally likely. The genetic distance between paired sequences was calculated for
each pair using the Tamura and Nei 1993 model (Tamura & Nei, 1993) (R; function: dist. , 2024), studies are still ongoing to explain how
the emergence of the new strain affects the whole host-pathogen-environment system (Sacristán et al. Understanding of the H5N1 transmission dynamic in context of the whole epidemiological system is crucial to assess
risk and impact of the virus on both avian and mammal populations either kept on farms or in the wild, and to develop
efficient intervention strategies aimed at reducing the risks to animals and humans and stopping infection spread.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
UK Data Service. (2024). Census boundary data. p. 7 If the point lay at the
boundary between two areas, one of the two was randomly selected. Using the Output Zone assignment other
administrative areas were assigned (as defined in Table 3) using a dataset with postcode lookup containing codes for
2011 Census Output Areas as well as codes for Lower Layer Super Output Areas/Data Zones, Middle Layer Super
Output/Intermittent Zones and Local Authority Districts downloaded from Office for National Statistics (Office for Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Vickers, S. H., Raghwani, J., Banyard, A. C., Brown, I. H., Fournie, G., & Hill, S. C. (2024). Utilizing citizen science data to rapidly assess changing associations between wild birds and avian influenza outbreaks in poultry. p. 5 Raw data used for analysis of dependence of genetic distance between sequences of H5N1 and other variables connected
to HPAI epidemic in years 2020-2022
Dataset Source Description Notes
HPAI Sequences GISAID (GISAID Data
Science Initiative)
Genetic sequence of HPAI cases from
United Kingdom from years 2020-2022
The coordinates attributed for each
published sequence we analysed
were provided by Animal and Plant
Health Agency. HPAI positive cases
in birds
World Animal Health
Information System
(World Organisation for
Animal Health, 2024)
Locations and metadata of HPAI outbreaks
reported to World Organisation of Animal
Health in years 2020-2022
Both outbreaks on poultry farms as
well as in wild birds or other bird
premises were downloaded.Where the paper says it
World Organisation for Animal Health. (2024). WAHIS: World Animal Health Information System. p. 7 Public data with reported HPAI H5N1 outbreaks (“Influenza A viruses of high pathogenicity (Inf. with)”; subtype: H5N1)
from Great Britain (excluding reports from Isle of Man, Jersey, Alderney and Guernsey; and cases from Northern
Ireland) from 3
rd December 2020 to 5th April 2024 were downloaded from World Animal Health Information System
(WAHIS) system (World Organisation for Animal Health, 2024). Total number of wild bird and domestic bird cases reported to
WAHIS in each quarter from period 3
rd December 2020 to 5th May 2024
Start quarter
Number of wild bird
cases
Number of
domestic bird cases
2020/4 4 1
2021/1 3 1
2021/2 1 0
2021/3 2 0
2021/4 164 77
2022/1 108 33
2022/2 72 11
2022/3 81 43
2022/4 219 144
2023/1 62 21
2023/2 67 10
2023/3 86 18
2023/4 15 5
2024/1 2 1
2024/2 1 0
Public wild bird abundance data describing the abundance of each species for every week of year 2021 were
downloaded from eBird platform. Relative abundance distributions were retrieved from eBird Status and Trends using
R package ebirdst (Matthew Strimas-Mackey, 2022); the details of the relative abundance generation can be found in
(Vickers et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can identify spatially variable interaction scales driving virus circulation by quantifying how variables like game bird abundance and farm count predict genetic distance between H5N1 sequences at different geographical resolutions, as shown in Table 1.
-
The system can dynamically select the most informative spatial scale for transmission analysis based on the specific time period, as evidenced by the
Differences in predictors between the two periods bears further investigation
andclear differences not only in scales of variables accumulation but also in the relative importance of the variables
mentioned in Discussion. -
The AI system can differentiate between drivers related to human activity versus natural factors by comparing model performance when using grid-based aggregation against aggregation according to administrative units, which is
an indicator of whether human, or natural activity is an underlying driver.
-
The system can provide nuanced insights into transmission dynamics by analyzing Accumulated Local Effect plots, which allow for the extraction of
univariate relationships between identified risk factors and genetic distances once correlated effects are removed.
-
The AI system can assess seasonal or temporal influences on virus spread by identifying how the collection date affects genetic distance, noting that
The role of collection date in period 2 between June to October 2022 may reflect seasonal changes.
Abstract
H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) has been recently circulating in previously unseen patterns. As the underlying causes are uncertain, we need a better understanding of the drivers of virus circulation, as they underpin the spread, and inform about the impact of HPAI. We combine infection and bird population data, using Random Forest models to quantify the relationship between spatially aggregated values of possible infection risk factors and viral phylogenetic data from HPAI outbreaks to define scales of interactions that influence virus circulation. As genetic proximity is correlated to transmission proximity, the genetic relationships of sequences and relevant variables indicate the scale and resolution of interactions driving transmission. We used H5N1 Sequences from Great Britain divided into two periods: Dec 2020-May 2022, and Jun 2022-Oct 2024. Final model with selected spatial scales shows that for the first period various wild bird abundance variables were the strong predictors of genetic distance, and for the second period, these were geographical distance, and collection date. Variables related to infections have different spatial scales for analysed periods, while variables describing the environment have more consistent scales. The differences in predictors for the periods bears further investigation, however may be related to differences in the virus, areas of spread, or seasonal factors. This is the first phylogenetic study indicating possible role for game birds in the circulation of HPAI and supports experimental studies but must be viewed with caution as our study does not indicate direct causation. We show that the scale of spatial aggregation is variable dependent and reflects the scale of underlying processes. In the future our findings may be used to study dynamics of HPAI and design targeted surveillance and intervention strategies.
Related papers
- From life-history model to theories of ecological diversity: the impact of Madhav Gadgil's work
- A multiscale discrete-to-continuum framework for structured population models
- Diversification under Global Competition: A Cutoff-Induced Localization Mechanism
- Extending indoor airborne infection risk modelling to 3D, with local surface deposition
- Drivers of periodicity in population dynamic models of long-lived, large mammals
- Mutant Fixation for a Stochastic Evolutionary Model in Fragmented Populations