Proper-time flow equation and non-local truncations in quantum gravity

arXiv:2410.23696 · gr-qc, hep-th · Submitted 2024-10-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Proper-time flow equation and non-local truncations in quantum gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Proper-time flow equations can reproduce the Polyakov action at k = 0 by explicitly integrating all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recovering an effective action without integrating the conformal anomaly 1.

Kai: The study focuses on the flow of the non-local truncation in quantum gravity, specifically concentrating on the Polyakov effective action for a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two-dimensional curved space 1.

Mira: The authors demonstrate that it is possible to explicitly integrate the flow of all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recover effective action without the integration of the conformal anomaly 5.

Kai: Functional Renormalization Group in a Nutshell The functional renormalization group starts with Wilson’s idea where a bare action is expressed as an expansion of operators O

φ: , and integrating out fluctuations at scale k yields the Wilsonian action 2.

Paper summary: Kai: So wrapping up this paper, we have this work by Glaviano and Bonanno titled "Proper-time flow equation and non-local truncations in quantum gravity." They show that the proper time flow equation can be used to explicitly integrate out all local and non-local operator terms up to a scale of k equals zero.

Mira: The main point is that this integration recovers an effective action, but they found it only works cleanly when the theory is massless and xi equals zero.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means you have to be really careful about which physical limits you take, because the local versus non-local description of the gravity effects changes depending on whether the mass is large or small relative to that scale y.

Kai: It suggests that understanding quantum gravity in two dimensions might involve using these flow equations as a way to build up the full effective action step by step from known operator truncations.

Mira: And it's important because it offers a way to handle the conformal anomaly differently, avoiding its separate integration entirely, which is a significant simplification for theorists working on these models.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how these proper time flow equations work to build up the Polyakov action by integrating out all those local and non-local operator terms up to zero scale, and now we're at the conclusion of this paper on "Proper-time flow equation and non-local truncations in quantum gravity."

Mira: It really boils down to how you can systematically take a complicated theory, like quantum gravity in two dimensions, and show you the effective action piece by piece without having to tackle that conformal anomaly separately.

Lev: From where I'm sitting on building hardware for error correction, if this flow actually works out clean enough for real physics, it means we could have a much clearer roadmap for how to implement these quantum gravity corrections in a physical system.

Kai: It suggests the structure of the theory itself might dictate which terms you need to integrate first. It’s less about guessing the right expansion and more about following this specific flow equation down to zero scale.

Mira: Exactly, it implies that the way we approach integrating out fluctuations is fundamental, rather than just picking a convenient approximation at some intermediate scale.

Lev: But there's still that hurdle, isn't there? The paper itself notes the conditions under which the Polyakov action actually pops out cleanly—specifically when the mass goes to zero and another parameter, xi, goes to zero together.

Kai: Right. So we’re looking at this very specific limit where all those pieces fit together perfectly into that non-local form we expect from string theory type theories.

Mira: And that's what makes it compelling; it connects the functional method directly to a known, important result in two dimensional gravity without needing to mess with the anomaly integration explicitly.

Lev: It’s a powerful tool for deriving structure, but we still have to worry about how that structure translates into something you can actually measure or build on superconducting circuits.

Kai: Yeah, it gives us a better language for describing the quantum geometry in these low-dimensional systems without getting bogged down in the full complexity of every single term right away.

Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia Ettore Majorana, University of Catania · INAF Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania

gr-qc, hep-th

Submitted: 2024-10-31

Updated: 2024-10-31

Comments: 12 pages, 2 figures. Contribution to the proceedings of the 17th Marcel Grossman Meeting, Pescara 7-12 July 2024

Journal ref: The Seventeenth Marcel Grossmann Meeting, (2026), 2248-2259

DOI: 10.1142/9789819839926_0182

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: Proper-time flow equations can reproduce the Polyakov action at k = 0 by explicitly integrating all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recovering an effective action without…

Key concepts

Functional Renormalization Group (FRG)
This framework starts with an expansion of the bare action and integrates out quantum fluctuations step-by-step at different energy scales (k). It yields equations that describe how coupling constants change as you coarse-grain the theory, leading to a full effective action.
Proper Time Flow Equation (PTFE)
Derived from one-loop approximations using a proper time representation of the Hessian logarithm, this equation describes how the scale derivative of the effective action evolves. It incorporates a cutoff 'k' to implement Wilsonian coarse-graining and allows for scale derivatives independent of the cutoff.
Polyakov Action
This is an exact non-local effective action in two dimensions describing quantum gravity on a curved manifold. It arises from functionally integrating the trace anomaly, which is a violation of classical conformal invariance at the quantum level, resulting in terms involving the inverse of the covariant Laplacian.

Terminology

Summary

Proper-time flow equations can reproduce the Polyakov action at k = 0 by explicitly integrating all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recovering an effective action without integrating the conformal anomaly 1. p. 0

Where the paper says it

it We study the flow of the non-local truncation in quantum gravity and we focus in particular on the Polyakov effective action for a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two dimensional curved space. We show that it is possible to explicitly integrate the flow of all the local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recover effective action without the integration of the conformal anomaly.

Introduction

The study focuses on the flow of the non-local truncation in quantum gravity, specifically concentrating on the Polyakov effective action for a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two-dimensional curved space 1. The authors demonstrate that it is possible to explicitly integrate the flow of all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recover effective action without the integration of the conformal anomaly 5. p. 0

Where the paper says it

it We study the flow of the non-local truncation in quantum gravity and we focus in particular on the Polyakov effective action for a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two dimensional curved space. We show that it is possible to explicitly integrate the flow of all the local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 and recover effective action without the integration of the conformal anomaly.

Functional Renormalization Group in a Nutshell

The functional renormalization group starts with Wilson’s idea where a bare action is expressed as an expansion of operators O[φ], and integrating out fluctuations at scale k yields the Wilsonian action 2. This process results in running coupling constants described by the functional renormalization group equations k∂kgn (k) = βn (g1, g2,. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Performing the integral shows that the effect of integrating out the microscopic degrees of freedom is that the coupling constants in the bare action acquire a scale dependence Sk [ψ] = X∞ n=1 gn (k) On [ψ] (3) In this way a non-perturbative flow arises. In particular, these runnings stem from a set of differential equations called the functional renormalization group equations k∂kgn (k) = βn (g1, g2, .

..,; k) 4. To obtain the full effective action, the effective average action interpolates between the quantum effective action and the bare action 5. p. 4
Where the paper says it

This inverse operator has to be meant as the two point correlation function evaluated at two different point in the manifold M. The Polyakov action from the PTFE The general effective average action Γk[φ] interpolates smoothly between the full quantum effective action and the bare action3 .

The Functional Renormalization Group and Proper Time

The proper time renormalization group equation is derived from the one-loop approximation of the effective action using a proper time representation for the logarithm of the Hessian, which introduces a cutoff k to implement Wilsonian coarse graining 7. The improved proper time flow equation (PTFE) is given by k∂kΓk[φ] = −1/2 Z ∞ 0 ds s k ∂f s, k2,Λ ∂k Tr h e −sΓ(2)k i 14. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In this way the running of Γk[φ] includes an infinite resummation of diagrams and therefore improves on the one-loop approximation. The improved proper time flow equation (PTFE) is k∂kΓk[φ] = − 1 2 Z ∞ 0 ds s k ∂f s, k2 ,Λ ∂k Tr h e −sΓ (2) k i (14) for suitable cutoff functions the scale derivative is independent of Λ, consequently the limit Λ → ∞ can be taken.

This improved flow equation allows the scale derivative to be independent of Λ for suitable cutoff functions 15. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In this way the running of Γk[φ] includes an infinite resummation of diagrams and therefore improves on the one-loop approximation. The improved proper time flow equation (PTFE) is k∂kΓk[φ] = − 1 2 Z ∞ 0 ds s k ∂f s, k2 ,Λ ∂k Tr h e −sΓ (2) k i (14) for suitable cutoff functions the scale derivative is independent of Λ, consequently the limit Λ → ∞ can be taken.

The Polyakov Action and the Conformal Anomaly

In two dimensions, the classical energy-momentum tensor is traceless due to conformal invariance, but in the quantum domain, the effective action transforms such that Tµµ = 0 is violated, leading to an anomaly 22. The one-loop approximation proves that Tµµ = −1/24πR is the well-known trace anomaly 23. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Therefore there is an anomaly related to the conformal transformation. Using the one-loop approximation for the effective action we can prove that T µ µ = − 1 24π R (23) the well-known the trace anomaly.

Polyakov functionally integrated this anomaly to find the exact effective action on a curved manifold in two dimensions, which is a non-local action containing the inverse of the covariant Laplacian 24. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Starting from this result Polyakov17 in 1981 functionally integrating the conformal anomaly was able to find the exact effective action on a curved manifold in two dimensions Γ [g] = 1 96π Z d 2x √ gR 1 − R (24) where R is the Ricci scalar. The effective action is a non-local action containing the inverse of the covariant Laplacian .

The Polyakov Action from the PTFE

By considering a specific theory of a massive scalar field non-minimally coupled to a graviton in d = 2, the proper time flow equations yield expressions for the running of coupling constants and the form factor 31. The flow of the form factor is given by k∂kc(k,y) = 1 − 8ξ/64πy 1 + m2/k squared n+1 − 3k 2/32πny squared 1 + m2/k squared n + (4ξ − 1)k 2(n+1)/32πy (k squared + m2+(α−1)αy)n+1 > k∂kc(k,y=0) = 1/96πy + ξ/8πy + m2/16πy squared + tan−1 q 1/4m2 y − 1! p. 6

Where the paper says it

(16) and comparing to the scale derivative of eq. (25) we find k∂kak = k 2 4πn 1 + m2 k2 n , k∂kbk = 1 − 6ξ 24π 1 + m2 k2 1+n (31) for the flow of coupling constants and k∂kck (y) = 1 − 8ξ 64πy 1 + m2 k2 n+1 − 3k 2 32πny2 1 + m2 k2 n + + Z 1 0 (n + 1)(1 − 4ξ) 2 k 2(n+1) 128π (k 2 + m2 + (α − 1)αy) n+2 + (4ξ − 1)k 2(n+1) 32πy (k 2 + m2 + (α − 1)αy) n+1 + + 3k 2(n+1) 32πny2 (k 2 + m2 + (α − 1) αy) n dα (32) for the flow of the form factor, where y = .

q4m2 y − 1 - ξ/24πy − m2ξ/2πy squared − m4/4πy3 36. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The result for the form factor at k = 0 is: c (k = 0, y) = 1 96πy + ξ 8πy + m2 16πy2 + tan−1 q 1 4m2 y −1 ! q4m2 y − 1 − ξ 2 4πy − m2 ξ 2πy2 − m4 4πy3 (36) In eq.

Discussion

The results show that the Polyakov action is recovered only if ξ = 0 in the massless limit, as the limits m → 0 and ξ → 0 do not commute 41. The IR and UV limits exhibit opposite behaviors: if mass dominates, the theory becomes local in the /m2 expansion, while if m2 >> y, it is non-local 5. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In the simple case of a minimally coupled scalar field theory on a curved twodimensional manifold, the effective action is exactly known as the Polyakov action. In this contribution we consider a theory of a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two-dimensional curved space and use the non-local heat kernel trace expansion to demonstrate how PT flow equations can reproduce the Polyakov action at k = 0.

The paper notes a limitation where only the trace of heat kernel operators or a function of a Laplace-type operator can be computed, meaning Γk should be quadratic in the derivatives 11. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In the simple case of a minimally coupled scalar field theory on a curved twodimensional manifold, the effective action is exactly known as the Polyakov action. In this contribution we consider a theory of a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two-dimensional curved space and use the non-local heat kernel trace expansion to demonstrate how PT flow equations can reproduce the Polyakov action at k = 0.

References

A. Bonanno, S. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Glaviano∗ and A. Bonanno ∗∗ Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia “Ettore Majorana”, Universit`a di Catania, Via S.

Lippoldt, R. Percacci and G. P. Vacca, On Exact Proper Time Wilsonian RG Flows, Eur Phys J C 80, p 249 (2020) 1

A. Bonanno and M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Glaviano∗ and A. Bonanno ∗∗ Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia “Ettore Majorana”, Universit`a di Catania, Via S.

Reuter, Proper time flow equation for gravity, JHEP 02, p 035 (2005) 8

S.-B. Liao, Operator cutoff regularization and renormalization group in Yang-Mills theory, Phys Rev D 56, 5008 (1997) 4

S.-B. Liao, On connection between momentum cutoff and the proper time regularizations, Phys Rev D 53, 2020 (1996) 5

B. J. Schaefer, O. Bohr and J. Wambach, Finite temperature gluon condensate with renormalization group flow equations, Phys Rev D 65, p 105008 (2002) 6

B.-J. Schaefer and H.-J. Pirner, Renormalization group flow and equation of state of quarks and mesons, Nucl Phys A 660, 439 (1999) 7

B.-J. Schaefer and H.-J. Pirner, Application of the heat kernel method to the constituent quark model at finite temperature, Nucl Phys A 627, 481 (1997) 8

J. Meyer, G. Papp, H. J. Pirner and T. Kunihiro, Renormalization group flow equation at finite density, Phys Rev C 61, p 035202 (2000) 9

G. Papp, B. J. Schaefer, H. J. Pirner and J. Wambach, On the convergence of the expansion of renormalization group flow equation, Phys Rev D 61, p 096002 (2000) 10

D. F. Litim and D. Zappala, Ising exponents from the functional renormalisation group, Phys Rev D 83, p 085009 (2011) 11

A. Bonanno and F. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Glaviano∗ and A. Bonanno ∗∗ Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia “Ettore Majorana”, Universit`a di Catania, Via S.

Guarnieri, Universality and Symmetry Breaking in Conformally Reduced Quantum Gravity, Phys Rev D 86, p 105027 (2012) 12

A. M. Bonanno, M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Glaviano∗ and A. Bonanno ∗∗ Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia “Ettore Majorana”, Universit`a di Catania, Via S.

Conti and S. L. Cacciatori, Ultraviolet behavior of conformally reduced quadratic gravity, Phys Rev D 108, p 026008 (2023) 14

A. Bonanno and D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Glaviano∗ and A. Bonanno ∗∗ Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia “Ettore Majorana”, Universit`a di Catania, Via S.

Zappala, The conformal sector of Quantum Einstein Gravity beyond the local potential approximation, Phys Lett B 847, p 138311 (2023) 15

A. Polyakov, Quantum geometry of bosonic strings, Physics Letters B 103, 207 (1981) 17

A. O. Barvinsky and G. p. 5

Where the paper says it

This action sets the boundary conditions for ak, bk and ck to solve the flow equations. The trace can be evaluated using an expansion in powers of curvature invariants developed by Barvinsky and Vilkovisky18–21: Tr h e −s(−1+U) i = 1 4πs Z d 2x √ gtr 1 − sU + s R 6 1+ + s 2 RfR2d (−s) R + RfRU (−s) U + UfU (−s) U + ΩµνfΩ (−s) Ωµν + O R 3 (28) here 1 denotes the unit matrix of the space of fields on which acts and fR2d (x) = 1 32 f (x) + 1 16x [2f (x) − 1] + 3 8x 2 [f (x) − 1] fRU (x) = − 1 4 f (x) − 1 2x [f (x) − 1] , fU (x) = 1 2x , fΩ (x) = − 1 2x [f (x) − 1]

p. 5
Where the paper says it

This action sets the boundary conditions for ak, bk and ck to solve the flow equations. The trace can be evaluated using an expansion in powers of curvature invariants developed by Barvinsky and Vilkovisky18–21: Tr h e −s(−1+U) i = 1 4πs Z d 2x √ gtr 1 − sU + s R 6 1+ + s 2 RfR2d (−s) R + RfRU (−s) U + UfU (−s) U + ΩµνfΩ (−s) Ωµν + O R 3 (28) here 1 denotes the unit matrix of the space of fields on which acts and fR2d (x) = 1 32 f (x) + 1 16x [2f (x) − 1] + 3 8x 2 [f (x) − 1] fRU (x) = − 1 4 f (x) − 1 2x [f (x) − 1] , fU (x) = 1 2x , fΩ (x) = − 1 2x [f (x) − 1]

p. 5
Where the paper says it

This action sets the boundary conditions for ak, bk and ck to solve the flow equations. The trace can be evaluated using an expansion in powers of curvature invariants developed by Barvinsky and Vilkovisky18–21: Tr h e −s(−1+U) i = 1 4πs Z d 2x √ gtr 1 − sU + s R 6 1+ + s 2 RfR2d (−s) R + RfRU (−s) U + UfU (−s) U + ΩµνfΩ (−s) Ωµν + O R 3 (28) here 1 denotes the unit matrix of the space of fields on which acts and fR2d (x) = 1 32 f (x) + 1 16x [2f (x) − 1] + 3 8x 2 [f (x) − 1] fRU (x) = − 1 4 f (x) − 1 2x [f (x) − 1] , fU (x) = 1 2x , fΩ (x) = − 1 2x [f (x) − 1]

A. Vilkovisky, Beyond the schwinger-dewitt technique: Converting loops into trees and in-in currents, Nuclear Physics 282, 163 (1987) 18

A. O. Barvinsky and G. A. Vilkovisky, Covariant perturbation theory, 2: Second order in the curvature. p. 6

Where the paper says it

(30) and Ωµν is defined from [Dµ, Dν]ψ = Ωµνψ. (28) sums all contributions of the trace of the heat kernel in terms of a curvature expansion, we truncated this expansion at the second order in the curvature.

General algorithms, Nucl Phys B 333, 471 (1990) 19

A. O. Barvinsky and G. A. Vilkovisky, Covariant perturbation theory, 3: Spectral representations of the third order form-factors, Nucl Phys B 333, 512 (1990) 20

A. O. Barvinsky, Y. p. 5

Where the paper says it

This action sets the boundary conditions for ak, bk and ck to solve the flow equations. The trace can be evaluated using an expansion in powers of curvature invariants developed by Barvinsky and Vilkovisky18–21: Tr h e −s(−1+U) i = 1 4πs Z d 2x √ gtr 1 − sU + s R 6 1+ + s 2 RfR2d (−s) R + RfRU (−s) U + UfU (−s) U + ΩµνfΩ (−s) Ωµν + O R 3 (28) here 1 denotes the unit matrix of the space of fields on which acts and fR2d (x) = 1 32 f (x) + 1 16x [2f (x) − 1] + 3 8x 2 [f (x) − 1] fRU (x) = − 1 4 f (x) − 1 2x [f (x) − 1] , fU (x) = 1 2x , fΩ (x) = − 1 2x [f (x) − 1]

V. Gusev, V. V. Zhytnikov and G. A.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced non-perturbative gravity simulations by implementing proper time flow equations to explicitly integrate all local and non-local operator terms up to k = 0 without needing to integrate the conformal anomaly. This allows for a more complete recovery of effective actions, especially in theories involving non-minimal coupling.

  2. Improved ability to study quantum gravity fixed points by rigorously testing whether flow equations based on proper time regulators can accurately describe the evolution of non-local terms, specifically reproducing well-known non-local effective actions at k = 0.

  3. Development of a more accurate treatment for the trace anomaly in two dimensions by using the Polyakov action derived from the proper time renormalization group equation, which avoids integrating this anomaly directly in earlier approximations.

  4. Capability to compute the running of coupling constants and form factors through integration of beta functions derived from the improved proper time flow equation (PTFE), providing explicit expressions for these quantities dependent on a cutoff function f(s, k2, Λ).

  5. Refinement of physical predictions for coupling constants by establishing renormalization conditions, such as setting a (Λ) = Lambda 2/8pi n + m2 log mu squared Lambda squared and b (Λ) = - log mu squared Lambda squared to remove quadratic and logarithmic divergences.

Abstract

We study the flow of the non-local truncation in quantum gravity and we focus in particular on the Polyakov effective action for a non-minimally coupled scalar field on a two dimensional curved space. We show that it is possible to explicitly integrate the flow of all the local and non-local operator terms up to k=0 and recover effective action without the integration of the conformal anomaly.

Related papers