Exploring tidal dissipation in rubble pile binary secondaries using a discrete element model

arXiv:2410.09266 · astro-ph.EP · Submitted 2024-10-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Exploring tidal dissipation in rubble pile binary secondaries using a discrete element model".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. In this work, models of rubble pile binary secondaries are simulated in different spin states in a system similar in size and scale to Didymos-Dimorphos Tidal dissipation successfully emerges in the simulations as an aggregate of the effects of inter-element contact and friction across thousands of simulated mass elements We devise computational techniques for simulating and studying such systems, establishing rigorous numerical procedures for computing tidal quantities of interest We compute Q/k2 ∼ 71.6 +99.6 −43.6 for the secondary, smaller than previously predicted ranges 102 < Q/k2 < 106, and thus a rather dissipative result From our simulations, we observe non-classical variation of the tidal lag angle with the topographic longitude, and dependence of Q/k2 on the rotation rate Modeling Methodology The simulations are performed in GRAINS, which is a Chrono-based N-body simulation architecture that simulates gravity, contact, and friction forces acting on non-spherical mass elements Each mass element in the simulation is modeled as a convex body of a maximum of 16 vertices and an average of about 10 The setup of the rubble pile secondary is similar to the GRAINS setup in Agrusa et al.

Vera: (2022) Contact is modeled using the Smooth Contact Method of Chrono, resolving contact-normal and tangential forces The parameters for contact are computed from material physical properties as below, including Young’s modulus Y, friction µ, Poisson ratio ν, and restitution e Rotational Dynamics and Energy The simulation studies the orbital and attitude dynamics of the rubble pile secondary in a binary asteroid system The total system energy is given by Equation (14) for a point-mass primary and a perfectly rigid secondary The rotational energy of the secondary is isolated as a function of orientation and rotational state and distance between the two bodies For tidally locked cases with limited deformations of the binary secondary, frictional dissipation is not aggressive, and this quantity is thus approximately conserved in our simulations to a high degree of accuracy The rotational energy calculation allows for qualitative conclusions on roll and super-synchronous rotation based on critical values ESSR and Eroll Tidal Dissipation Quantification The total tidal torque induced by the gravitational pull of the primary on the secondary is well-approximated by an expression derived from MacCullagh’s approximation The tidal torque can be split into two components: the torque due to permanent mass asymmetry ΓPMA, and the torque due to a time-varying effect on the MoI induced by the gravitational pull of the primary, ΓTidal For a measure of how dissipative the body is, we start with the unimodal MacDonald model which conveys that smaller values indicate higher dissipation We re-arrange to isolate Q/k2, itself a measure of dissipation Key Findings and Implications The study provides computed values of Q/k2 for the super-synchronous spin case, yielding Q/k2 ∼ 71.6 +99.6 −43.6 This result is on or below the low end for binary secondaries predicted by various other studies The paper introduces a numerical recipe for studying tidal dissipation in binary systems via numerical simulation in discrete element routines The possibility of binary asteroid systems being on the more dissipative side of prior estimates, as suggested by this work, would have big implications for the scientific community Numerical Recipe and Future Work We introduce a number of helpful strategies needed for conducting further numerical studies, including the definition of a novel “topography” frame We also compile helpful insights from literature related to DEM modeling of granular material, tidal theory, and important details of binary asteroid morphology and dynamics We advocate for supplementary studies relying on numerical (and also in-laboratory) experiments, focused on the goal of improving our fundamental understanding of the underlying physics of dissipation in rubble piles The work is an important step towards a true and holistic understanding of such systems Disclaimer Views and opinions expressed are however those of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union, the European Research Executive Agency, or the European Research Council Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them References Agrusa, H.

Jocelyn: F., Ferrari, F., Zhang, Y., Richardson, D.

Vera: C., & Michel, P.

Title and authors: Vera: Now let's look at what they actually found regarding the paper "Exploring tidal dissipation in rubble pile binary secondaries using a discrete element model." They reported that they compute Q over k squared for the secondary as being around seventy-one point six plus ninety-nine point six minus forty-three point six.

Jocelyn: That specific result is significant because it falls into a range that suggests these smaller secondaries are more dissipative than some earlier predictions had suggested, which we need to keep an eye on.

Vera: Right, and they also found that this dissipation factor changes depending on the rotation rate and its position along its surface.

Jocelyn: That dependence is important because it shows how complex things get when you look at things like roll or super-synchronous rotation, which we can't just guess about without this kind of detailed modeling.

Vera: They used rotational energy limits to figure out when roll is possible versus when it isn't, based on those critical values ESSR and Eroll.

Jocelyn: That means they’re using these limits to set the initial conditions for studying spin-down behavior much more intelligently, which is a big step for understanding the rotational dynamics.

Vera: They also showed that the total tidal torque induced by the gravitational pull of the primary on the secondary can be split into two parts: one due to just a fixed mass asymmetry and another part caused by how the primary's gravity changes over time because of the secondary's orientation.

Jocelyn: To measure how dissipative it is, they started with a model called the unimodal MacDonald model which conveys that smaller values indicate higher dissipation.

Vera: The paper’s real contribution here is providing this numerical recipe for studying dissipation in these binary systems using discrete element routines like GRAINS.

Jocelyn: And they also pointed out areas where they think more work is needed, suggesting supplementary studies relying on both numerical simulations and in-laboratory experiments to get a better grasp of the physics behind dissipation in rubble piles.

Vera: It seems like this work is really pushing for a more holistic understanding of these systems, moving beyond just calculating one dissipation number.

The paper's summary: Jocelyn: So, to summarize what they found in "Exploring tidal dissipation in rubble pile binary secondaries using a discrete element model," the main thing is that they found this highly dissipative result for Q over k squared, around seventy-one point six plus ninety-nine point six minus forty-three point six.

Vera: It’s clear that these smaller secondaries are more dissipative than some earlier predictions suggested, and that comes from all those little contacts and friction across thousands of mass elements.

Jocelyn: That comes from the fact that they simulate the effects of inter-element contact and friction across those simulated mass elements, which is what causes this effect.

Vera: Right, they also showed that this dissipation isn't a fixed number; it changes depending on the rotation rate and its topography.

Jocelyn: That dependence is important because it shows how complex things get when you look at things like roll or super-synchronous rotation, which we can’t just guess about without this kind of detailed modeling.

The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: So, the authors suggest ways to improve their Q over k squared estimation by using different averaging methods for those tidal torque signals they calculated.

Vera: They’re talking about comparing averaging done over rotation cycles versus averaging done over time, which they say could lead to differences as big as a factor of three, giving them a way to be more rigorous about the dissipation.

Jocelyn: That sounds like a big deal for the data side of things because it means they aren't just relying on one type of averaging.

Vera: And on the dynamical side, they’re focusing on using those rotational energy limits—the ESSR and Eroll values—to predict if roll is possible or not before even running a full simulation.

Jocelyn: That lets them set the initial conditions for studying spin-down behavior much more intelligently, which is a big step for understanding the rotational dynamics.

Vera: Plus, they introduced that new numerical recipe, which includes defining that novel "topography" frame fixed to specific rocks deep in the interior and filtering out those initial transient behaviors common in rubble pile models.

Jocelyn: That recipe is super helpful because it gives other researchers a concrete way to start their simulations without wasting time on those messy early stages.

Vera: They also compiled insights from literature on discrete element modeling of granular material and the specific details of binary asteroid morphology and dynamics, which is just good for context.

Jocelyn: And they’re pushing for more research that combines these numerical simulations with in-laboratory experiments to really improve our fundamental understanding of how dissipation works in rubble piles.

Vera: Ultimately, these improvements aim for a more holistic view of these systems, moving beyond just calculating one dissipation number.

Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping up on "Exploring tidal dissipation in rubble pile binary secondaries using a discrete element model," this work shows that these simulations reveal a highly dissipative result for Q over k squared, around seventy-one point six plus ninety-nine point six minus forty-three point six.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological standpoint, understanding how dissipation works in these small bodies helps us model the evolution of larger structures over long periods.

Vera: Right, and they showed that this dissipation isn't a fixed number; it changes depending on the rotation rate and its topography.

Subrahmanyan: If these systems are indeed more dissipative than predicted, it changes how we estimate the energy budget of planetary systems across cosmic time.

Vera: The paper provides a numerical recipe for studying this dissipation using discrete element routines, which is a concrete tool for researchers to use going forward.

Jocelyn: They also laid out strategies for future work, like better averaging methods and combining simulations with lab experiments to get a more complete picture.

Subrahmanyan: I think connecting that micro physics of contact and friction directly to the macro scale orbital evolution is exactly what we need to confirm these theoretical models.

Vera: It’s a necessary step toward a holistic understanding of these systems, moving beyond just one simple dissipation number.

Jocelyn: So, this work gives us a new numerical recipe for studying tidal dissipation in binary systems using discrete element routines, and it points toward the need for more experimental validation.

Subrahmanyan: We'll keep an eye on what observational data coming from binary systems can constrain these results further.

Politecnico di Milano

astro-ph.EP

Submitted: 2024-10-11

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 36 pages, 16 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 85/100

The gist: In this work, models of rubble pile binary secondaries are simulated in different spin states in a system similar in size and scale to Didymos-Dimorphos Tidal dissipation successfully emerges in the…

Key concepts

Rubble Pile Binary Secondaries
These are simulated asteroid systems where the secondary body is not solid but made of loose aggregate (rubble pile). The simulation models this by treating each mass element as a convex body with contact and friction forces, mimicking how real porous asteroids behave under tidal stress.
Q/k2
This is a measure used to quantify the level of tidal dissipation in the secondary body. Lower values indicate higher dissipation, meaning more energy is lost through internal friction when the primary body's gravity pulls on it.
GRAINS Simulation Architecture
GRAINS is a specific computational tool used for these simulations. It is a Chrono-based N-body simulation that models gravity, contact, and friction forces acting on non-spherical mass elements. It allows researchers to study the complex physical interactions within the granular structure of the secondary body.

Terminology

Summary

In this work, models of rubble pile binary secondaries are simulated in different spin states in a system similar in size and scale to Didymos-Dimorphos Tidal dissipation successfully emerges in the simulations as an aggregate of the effects of inter-element contact and friction across thousands of simulated mass elements We devise computational techniques for simulating and studying such systems, establishing rigorous numerical procedures for computing tidal quantities of interest We compute Q/k2 ∼ 71. p. 06 +99.6 −43.6 for the secondary, smaller than previously predicted ranges 102 < Q/k2 < 106, and thus a rather dissipative result From our simulations, we observe non-classical variation of the tidal lag angle with the topographic longitude, and dependence of Q/k2 on the rotation rate

Modeling Methodology

The simulations are performed in GRAINS, which is a Chrono-based N-body simulation architecture that simulates gravity, contact, and friction forces acting on non-spherical mass elements Each mass element in the simulation is modeled as a convex body of a maximum of 16 vertices and an average of about 10 The setup of the rubble pile secondary is similar to the GRAINS setup in Agrusa et al. (2022) Contact is modeled using the Smooth Contact Method of Chrono, resolving contact-normal and tangential forces The parameters for contact are computed from material physical properties as below, including Young’s modulus Y, friction µ, Poisson ratio ν, and restitution e

Rotational Dynamics and Energy

The simulation studies the orbital and attitude dynamics of the rubble pile secondary in a binary asteroid system The total system energy is given by Equation (14) for a point-mass primary and a perfectly rigid secondary The rotational energy of the secondary is isolated as a function of orientation and rotational state and distance between the two bodies For tidally locked cases with limited deformations of the binary secondary, frictional dissipation is not aggressive, and this quantity is thus approximately conserved in our simulations to a high degree of accuracy The rotational energy calculation allows for qualitative conclusions on roll and super-synchronous rotation based on critical values ESSR and Eroll

Tidal Dissipation Quantification

The total tidal torque induced by the gravitational pull of the primary on the secondary is well-approximated by an expression derived from MacCullagh’s approximation The tidal torque can be split into two components: the torque due to permanent mass asymmetry ΓPMA, and the torque due to a time-varying effect on the MoI induced by the gravitational pull of the primary, ΓTidal For a measure of how dissipative the body is, we start with the unimodal MacDonald model which conveys that smaller values indicate higher dissipation We re-arrange to isolate Q/k2, itself a measure of dissipation

Key Findings and Implications

The study provides computed values of Q/k2 for the super-synchronous spin case, yielding Q/k2 ∼ 71.6 +99.6 −43.6 This result is on or below the low end for binary secondaries predicted by various other studies The paper introduces a numerical recipe for studying tidal dissipation in binary systems via numerical simulation in discrete element routines The possibility of binary asteroid systems being on the more dissipative side of prior estimates, as suggested by this work, would have big implications for the scientific community

Numerical Recipe and Future Work

We introduce a number of helpful strategies needed for conducting further numerical studies, including the definition of a novel “topography” frame We also compile helpful insights from literature related to DEM modeling of granular material, tidal theory, and important details of binary asteroid morphology and dynamics We advocate for supplementary studies relying on numerical (and also in-laboratory) experiments, focused on the goal of improving our fundamental understanding of the underlying physics of dissipation in rubble piles The work is an important step towards a true and holistic understanding of such systems

Disclaimer

Views and opinions expressed are however those of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union, the European Research Executive Agency, or the European Research Council Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them

References

Agrusa, H. F., Ferrari, F. p. 0 p. 0, Zhang, Y., Richardson, D. p. 2 p. 2 C., & Michel, P. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 (2022). Dynamical Evolution of the Didymos-Dimorphos Binary Asteroid as Rubble Piles following the DART Impact Bottke, W. p. 3 F., Vokrouhlick´y, D., Rubincam, D. p. 0 P., Broˇz, M., & Gehrels, T. (2002). The Effect of Yarkovsky Thermal Forces on the Dynamical Evolution of Asteroids and Meteoroids Burnett, E. p. 0, Fodde, I. p. 0, & Ferrari, F. p. 0 (2024). Numerical inference of viscoelastic properties in tidal models of rubble pile asteroids Burnett, E. p. 1 R., & Hayne, P. O. (2023). Spin–orbit coupling of Europa’s ice shell and interior Chen, H. p. 1, Xiao, Y., Liu, Y., & Shi, Y. (2017). Effect of young’s modulus on dem results regarding transverse mixing of particles within a rotating drum Cueva, R. H., McMahon, J. W., Meyer, A. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 J., Scheeres, D. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 J., Hirabayashi, M., Raducan, S. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 D.,... Merrill, C. C. (2024). The Secular Dynamical Evolution of Binary Asteroid System (65803) Didymos Post-DART Cuk, M. p. 3, & Burns, J. p. 1 A. (2005). Effects of thermal radiation on the dynamics of binary NEAs Daly, R. p. 0 T., Ernst, C. M., Barnouin, O. S., Chabot, N. L., Rivkin, A. S., Cheng, A. F.,... Zhang, Y. (2023). Successful kinetic impact into an asteroid for planetary defence Daly, R. p. 3 T., Ernst, C. M., Barnouin, O. S., Gaskell, R. W., Nair, H., Agrusa, H. p. 2 p. 2,... LICIACube teams (2024). p. 2 An Updated Shape Model of Dimorphos from DART Data Davis, A. p. 3 B., & Scheeres, D. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 J. (2020). Doubly synchronous binary asteroid mass parameter observability DellaGiustina, D. p. 2 N., Ballouz, R. L., Walsh, K. p. 1 p. 1 J., Marusiak, A. G., Bray, V. J., & Bailey, S. H. (2024). Seismology of rubble-pile asteroids in binary systems Efroimsky, M. p. 1 (2015). Tidal Evolution Of Asteroidal Binaries. p. 1 Ruled By Viscosity Efroimsky, M., & Lainey, V. (2007). Physics of bodily tides in terrestrial planets and the appropriate scales of dynamical evolution Ferrari, F. p. 0, Lavagna, M., & Blazquez, E. (2020). A parallel-GPU code for asteroid aggregation problems with angular particles Ferrari, F. p. 7, Raducan, S. D., Soldini, S., & Jutzi, M. (2022). Ejecta Formation, Early Collisional Processes, and Dynamical Evolution after the DART Impact on Dimorphos Ferrari, F. p. 3, & Tanga, P. p. 3 (2022). Interior of top-shaped asteroids with cohesionless surface Fleischmann, J. p. 7 A. (2015). DEM-PM Contact Model with Multi-Step Tangential Contact Displacement History (Tech. p. 6 Rep.) Frouard, J. p. 2, Quillen, A. C., Efroimsky, M., & Giannella, D. (2016). Numerical simulation of tidal evolution of a viscoelastic body modelled with a mass-spring network Goldreich, P. p. 2, & Sari, R. p. 1 (2009). Tidal Evolution of Rubble Piles Hestroffer, D. p. 3, S´anchez, P. p. 9, Staron, L., Bagatin, A. C., Eggl, S., Losert, W.,... Yano, H. (2019). Small Solar System Bodies as granular media Holsapple, K. p. 0 A. (2010). On YORP-induced spin deformations of asteroids Hou, X. p. 1, Scheeres, D. J., & Xin, X. (2017). Mutual potential between two rigid bodies with arbitrary shapes and mass distributions Jacobson, S. p. 8 A., & Scheeres, D. J. (2011). Long-Term Stable Equilibria for Synchronous Binary Asteroids Jacobson, S. p. 0 A., Scheeres, D. J., & McMahon, J. (2013). Formation of the Wide Asynchronous Binary Asteroid Population Liu, Y. p. 3, Zhang, G., Qiao, J., & Tang, X. (2024). Micromechanical testing and property upscaling of planetary rocks: A critical review Marti, J. p. 8, Quinteros, S., Mikesell, D., Margerin, L., Delage, P., & Murdoch, N. (2024). An experimental study of the influence of regolith micro-structure on seismic wave velocities Melosh, H. p. 0 J. (2011). Planetary surface processes Meyer, A. p. 1 J., Scheeres, D. J., Agrusa, H. F., Noiset, G., McMahon, J., Karatekin, O.,... Nakano, ¨ R. (2023). Energy dissipation in synchronous binary asteroids Michel, P. p. 2, K¨uppers, M., Bagatin, A. C., Carry, B., Charnoz, S., de Leon, J.,... Carnelli, I. (2023). The ESA Hera Mission: Detailed Characterization of the DART Impact Outcome and of the Binary Asteroid (65803) Didymos M¨ohlmann, D. p. 2, Seidensticker, K. J., Fischer, H.-H., Faber, C., Flandes, A., Knapmeyer, M.,... Arnold, W. (2018). Compressive strength and elastic modulus at Agilkia on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko derived from the SESAME/CASSE touchdown signals Murray, C. p. 9 D., & Dermott, S. p. 1 F. (1999). Solar System Dynamics Naidu, S. p. 0 P., Chesley, S. R., Moskovitz, N., Thomas, C. p. 2, Meyer, A. J., Pravec, P. p. 1 p. 1,... Chabot, N. L. (2024). Orbital and Physical Characterization of Asteroid Dimorphos Following the DART Impact Nimmo, F. p. 4, & Matsuyama, I. p. 1 (2019). Tidal dissipation in rubble-pile asteroids Pou, L. p. 1, & Nimmo, F. p. 1 (2024). Tidal dissipation of binaries in asteroid pairs Pravec, P. p. 1, Meyer, A., Scheirich, P., Scheeres, D., Benson, C., & Agrusa, H. p. 2 (2024). Rotational lightcurves of Dimorphos and constraints on its post-DART impact spin state Pravec, P. p. 2, Scheirich, P., Kuˇsnir´ak, P., Hornoch, K., Gal´ad, A., Naidu, S. p. 2 p. 2,... LaCluyze, A. (2016). Binary asteroid population. p. 1 3. Secondary rotations and elongations Pravec, P. p. 8, Scheirich, P., Kuˇsnir´ak, P., Sarounov´a, L., Mottola, S., Hahn, G.,... Kober, G. (2006). Photometric survey of binary near-Earth asteroids Raducan, S. p. 0 D., Jutzi, M., Cheng, A. F., Zhang, Y., Barnouin, O., Collins, G. S.,... May, B. H. (2024). Physical properties of asteroid Dimorphos as derived from the DART impact Richardson, D. p. 2 C., Walsh, K. J., Murdoch, N., & Michel, P. (2011). Numerical simulations of granular dynamics: I. p. 1 Hard-sphere discrete element method and tests Rubincam, D. P. (2000). Radiative Spin-up and Spin-down of Small Asteroids S´anchez, P. p. 9, & Scheeres, D. J. (2014). The strength of regolith and rubble pile asteroids Scheeres, D. p. 9 (2007). Rotational fission of contact binary asteroids Shuster, M. p. 1 D. (2006). The generalized wahba problem Sunday, C. p. 5, Murdoch, N., Tardivel, S., Schwartz, S. R., & Michel, P. (2020). Validating N-body code chrono for granular DEM simulations in reduced-gravity environments Tancredi, G. p. 3, Maciel, A., Heredia, L., Richeri, P., & Nesmachnow, S. (2012). Granular physics in low-gravity environments using discrete element method Tanga, P. p. 1, Comito, C., Paolicchi, P., Hestroffer, D. p. 1, Cellino, A., Dell’Oro, A.,... Delbo, M. (2009). Rubble-Pile Reshaping Reproduces Overall Asteroid Shapes Tasora, A. p. 2, Serban, R., Mazhar, H., Pazouki, A., Melanz, D., Fleischmann, J. p. 7,... Negrut, D. (2016). Chrono: An Open Source Multi-physics Dynamics Engine Taylor, P. p. 7 A., & Margot, J. p. 1-L. (2011). Binary asteroid systems: Tidal end states and estimates of material properties Thomas, C. p. 3 A., Naidu, S. P., Scheirich, P., Moskovitz, N. A., Pravec, P., Chesley, S. R.,... Agrusa, H. F. (2023). Orbital period change of Dimorphos due to the DART kinetic impact Walsh, K. p. 2 J., Ballouz, R.-L., Jawin, E. R., Avdellidou, C., Barnouin, O. S., Bennett, C. A.,... Lauretta, D. S. (2022). Near-zero cohesion and loose packing of Bennu’s near subsurface revealed by spacecraft contact Walsh, K. p. 7 J., Richardson, D. C., & Michel, P. (2012). Spin-up of rubble-pile asteroids: Disruption, satellite formation, and equilibrium shapes Williams, J. p. 3 G., & Efroimsky, M. (2012). Bodily tides near the 1:1 spin-orbit resonance: correction to Goldreich’s dynamical model Wimarsson, J. p. 4, Xiang, Z., Ferrari, F., Jutzi, M., Madeira, G., Raducan, S. D., & S´anchez, P. p. 9 (2024). Rapid formation of binary asteroid systems post rotational failure: A recipe for making atypically shaped satellites

Conclusion

In this work we obtain a highly dissipative result of Q/k2 ∼ 71.6 +99.6 −43.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved Q/k2 estimation for binary secondaries by applying different averaging methods to tidal torque signals. This allows for comparison between averaging in rotation cycles versus averaging in time, which can yield differences as large as a factor of 3, providing a more rigorous estimate of dissipation than relying on simple models.

  2. Ability to predict the qualitative behavior of spin states based on rotational energy limits. The simulation results show that "roll is possible when E > Eroll, and not possible when E ESSR," which can be used to set initial conditions for studying spin-down.

  3. Direct observation of semidiurnal tides on mass elements using the topography fixed frame G. The simulation shows two local maxima and two local minima per day on the binary secondary, which allows researchers to infer the temporal lag of the semidiurnal tide as a function of longitude and spin rate.

  4. Development of a numerical recipe for studying tidal dissipation in binary systems using discrete element routines like GRAINS. This recipe includes defining a novel topography frame fixed with respect to select rocks deep in the interior and identifying and excluding initial transient behaviors inherent to numerical rubble pile models.

Related papers