Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies

arXiv:2410.07661 · cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.mes-hall, physics.optics · Submitted 2024-10-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies is an ab initio study exploring two mechanisms—inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping—to dynamically control nonlinear optical responses in two-dimensional materials The paper investigates two potential mechanisms for electrically manipulating second-order optical nonlinearity in 2D materials: first, a response induced by an external field where the material lacks inherent SHG, and second, an external field inducing doping in a material that already exhibits SHG to alter the signal intensity The authors focus on two well-studied 2D Transition Metal Dichalcogenides (TMDs), bilayer MoS2 for symmetry breaking and monolayer WSe2 for induced doping These approaches represent fundamental pathways for manipulating the nonlinear optical properties of materials Electronic Field Effects on Nonlinearity The impact of an external out-of-plane electric field on SHG is analyzed by considering both electronic and ionic contributions to the macroscopic second-order polarization The electronic contribution is described by a third-order polarizability, referred to as electric field-induced second harmonic (EFISH) generation For bilayer MoS2, the ionic contribution is found to be relatively small compared to the electronic counterpart due to depolarization effects in the perpendicular direction The dependence of the induced SHG peaks on the external field shows a linear dependence for small fields and a quadratic dependence at higher fields, consistent with experimental findings Doping Effects on Intrinsic SHG For monolayer WSe2, which naturally exhibits SHG due to lacking inversion symmetry, doping is explored as a tuning strategy Doping induces two primary effects on the nonlinear response: first, the Pauli blocking effect due to partial filling of bands, and second, an increase in screening of the electron-hole interaction which reduces excitonic resonances The study found that doping can diminish the SHG response at the A-resonance in WSe2 by up to 20% of its intensity Comparison of Strategies and Limitations The comparison between the two strategies reveals that for bilayer MoS2, the ionic contribution is negligible, while excitonic effects have the potential to more than double the SHG response when an external field is applied For monolayer WSe2, doping modifies the screened interaction W, which enters in Eq.

Kai: (10) and affects the SHG intensity While the study demonstrates feasibility for fully ab initio simulations of nonlinear optical responses in 2D materials, discrepancies with experimental measurements suggest that other effects like Pauli blocking and trion formation need to be accounted for in a complete comparison The authors conclude that these findings illustrate how 2D materials can be employed for nonlinear optical switching In conclusion, the manuscript presents an ab initio study of two strategies for tuning the SHG response in 2D systems The first case shows that an external field can induce a weak SHG response in materials lacking inversion symmetry, where excitonic effects have the potential to enhance the signal The second case demonstrates that changing the dielectric constant via doping can reduce the excitonic peak response up to 20% This work demonstrates the feasibility of fully ab initio simulations for predicting nonlinear optical responses in 2D materials The research was partially funded by the European Union—NextGenerationEU under the Italian National Center 1 on HPC—Spoke 6: “Multiscale Modelling and Engineering Applications” A Approximated Electron-Hole Interaction In real-time simulations, time-dependent electric fields are essential for computing the time evolution of the polarization response To incorporate excitonic effects into real-time dynamics, a simplified screened exchange term, defined as long-range screened exchange (LSEX), is derived The LSEX approximation retains only the long-range component of the screened interaction This approach is advantageous if one is interested only in the lowest excitonic peaks, see for instance Fig.

Mira: S5 in SI The authors tested this approximation on monolayer WSe2 and bilayer MoS2, comparing the results with available experimental measurements The LSEX approximation is similar to that used in simple models, with the key difference that we explicitly calculate the matrix elements of the Coulomb interaction between different bands at finite q Computational Details Ground-state properties of both bilayer MoS2 and monolayer WSe2 were studied using density functional theory (DFT) with the Quantum-Espresso code All computational details are provided in Sec.

Kai: 2.2 Calculations of the optical susceptibilities were performed using the Yambo code Quasiparticle corrections to the fundamental band gap were applied as a rigid shift to all bands System Parameters The system k-points and bands are summarized in Table 1 For WSe2, a double-grid approach was employed for calculating the doped dielectric constants The effective layer thickness used in the SHG calculations is half of c lattice parameter of the bulk structures Atomic structures were relaxed using a cutoff of 120 eV, a k-point sampling of 32×32×1, and the FIRE minimization algorithm The electric field in the z-direction was applied using a saw-like potential Data Presentation Results for both bilayer MoS2 and monolayer WSe2 are presented in Fig.

Title and authors: Kai: So this paper, "Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies," it looks at two main ways we can control how these materials respond to light through second harmonic generation <ref:2410.07661#pg1,Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies>.

Mira: Exactly. It's looking at inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping as the two primary mechanisms for tuning those nonlinear optical responses in two-dimensional systems, which is really interesting because it addresses that difficulty of dynamically controlling nonlinear susceptibilities that has been a big challenge in this field <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Lev: And what they do is use a real-time computational approach to calculate the second harmonic generation response while applying external factors like electric fields and doping levels, which lets them observe how these things change as they are applied <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: It seems like they focus on two specific materials, bilayer molybdenum disulfide for symmetry breaking and monolayer tungsten diselenide for induced doping, which gives us a concrete place to look at this research <ref:2410.07661#pg2>.

Mira: Right. The summary of the paper explores how an external field can induce SHG in materials that don't naturally have it, like bilayer molybdenum disulfide, and also how doping can change the signal intensity in a material that already has SHG, like monolayer tungsten diselenide <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Lev: So they are essentially comparing these two fundamentally different ways to manipulate the nonlinear optical properties of these 2D materials <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: And from what I'm seeing, the paper suggests some improvements, specifically moving towards a real-time ab-initio simulation for nonlinear optical frequency conversion so they can calculate the response dynamically under an out-of-plane external field Improvements one <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: That’s a big step because it moves beyond just looking at static properties and allows them to see how the response evolves in real time as you apply those fields Improvements one <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Lev: For me, that dynamic control is what matters for building actual hardware, so being able to simulate that real-time evolution under an external field is crucial for predicting performance Improvements one <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Kai: And they also suggest using the AI system to predict the induced SHG response in materials lacking inherent symmetry by calculating the contribution of an external static electric field to the second-order polarization, which is described by equation six Improvements two <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: That’s about tuning SHG via inversion symmetry breaking, where you use a static electric field to get a response in materials that don't have it naturally Improvements two <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Lev: It takes some careful assumptions to make that prediction, so the fidelity of the simulation will really depend on how accurately they model those underlying physics Improvements two <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Kai: And then there’s the strategy of tuning SHG via doping modification, where they model how external fields induce doping, leading to changes in screening and exciton peak response in materials that already exhibit second harmonic generation Improvements three <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: That means they are looking at how changing the dielectric constant through doping can modify the screened interaction W which affects the SHG intensity in monolayer tungsten diselenide Improvements three <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Lev: Modeling those doping effects is complex because you have to account for Pauli blocking and an increase in screening of the electron-hole interaction which reduces excitonic resonances, as they mentioned <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: So, looking at the conclusion of this paper "Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies," it wraps up by showing that an external field can induce a weak SHG response in materials without inversion symmetry where excitonic effects have the potential to enhance the signal Conclusion on Tunability <ref:2410.07661#pg1,Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies>.

Mira: And they also show that changing the dielectric constant through doping can reduce the excitonic peak response up to twenty percent in monolayer tungsten diselenide Conclusion on Tunability.

Lev: The paper concludes by showing that they’ve demonstrated feasibility for fully ab-initio simulations for predicting nonlinear optical responses in two-dimensional materials Conclusion on Tunability.

Kai: So, the implication is that we can start to see how these 2D materials can be employed for nonlinear optical switching using these two strategies Conclusion on Tunability <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: It shows that the material's intrinsic properties are not fixed and can be dynamically controlled by applying external stimuli like fields or doping Conclusion on Tunability.

Lev: For us, it means we have a computational framework to test these control mechanisms before we even start building the actual devices Conclusion on Tunability.

Kai: So, as we wrap up this discussion on "Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies," it highlights how these systems can be tuned through either symmetry breaking or doping-induced modifications to their nonlinear response <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work, showing the potential for controlling second harmonic generation in these 2D systems using these two different pathways <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Lev: We need to keep pushing that real-time simulation aspect to see if those predicted effects hold up when we move from theory to actual hardware implementation Improvements one <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Kai: Right, so next time we look at papers that are focusing on the experimental setup for these kinds of optical measurements and see what they actually built in the lab Improvements two <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what we're looking at now is just wrapping up this paper on tunable second harmonic generation in two dimensional materials by comparing two different ways to control that response, inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping.

Mira: Exactly. The authors show how you can get a signal where there wasn't one before by using an external electric field to break the symmetry, and then they look at how doping can tweak the signal if it already exists.

Lev: It really boils down to two distinct strategies for dynamic control of nonlinear optical properties in these materials.

Kai: And what they found is that for bilayer molybdenum disulfide, the ionic contribution from those external electric fields turns out to be pretty small compared to the electronic part of the response.

Mira: That's interesting because you expect some ionic effect when you apply a field, but depolarization effects in those perpendicular directions really keep that contribution low.

Lev: Right, so for Mo disulfide, it seems like the electronic contribution dominates when you push that external field <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Kai: And then they looked at monolayer tungsten diselenide, which already has second harmonic generation because it lacks inversion symmetry naturally.

Mira: That's where doping comes in as the tuning mechanism, and they found that doping actually reduces the SHG response by up to twenty percent at a specific resonance peak.

Lev: So doping modifies the screened interaction W that enters their equations, which is what changes how strong that excitonic peak is <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: It suggests you can use doping to actively reduce or enhance the SHG signal in materials that are inherently nonlinear.

Mira: And the big picture here is they've proven that fully ab initio simulations can predict these kinds of nonlinear optical responses in two dimensional materials.

Lev: But there’s a caveat, which is they point out that for those real-time simulations to be useful, you need to account for things like Pauli blocking and trion formation, which isn't fully detailed yet <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: So the paper shows the feasibility of using these 2D materials for nonlinear optical switching through either symmetry breaking or doping modifications <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: It’s a solid study showing that these intrinsic properties aren't fixed; you can manipulate them with external stimuli like fields or doping.

Lev: It gives us a computational roadmap for testing those control mechanisms before we even build the actual hardware, which is important for the real-world engineering side <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: So next up, we'll look at how this relates to those other papers on materials screening and how it might impact device design.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So we're moving on to what the authors suggest next for improving their work on tunable second harmonic generation in two dimensional materials by focusing on real-time simulations and specific tuning mechanisms.

Kai: They propose using a real-time ab initio simulation to calculate the response by solving time dependent schrodinger equations under an external electric field, which would let them see how the nonlinearities evolve dynamically over time.

Mira: That’s moving from static snapshots to watching the material actually react as you turn that field on and off, which is a big improvement for understanding control.

Lev: For me, that real-time aspect is crucial because it shows how quickly those changes happen, which directly impacts the overhead you'd have if you tried to run this on actual hardware for error correction.

Kai: They also suggest using that AI system to predict the induced second harmonic generation response in materials lacking inherent symmetry by calculating the contribution of a static electric field to the second order polarization, as described by equation six.

Mira: That’s about tuning SHG via inversion symmetry breaking, meaning you use a steady electric field to get a response in materials that don't have it naturally.

Lev: That sounds like a powerful prediction tool, but the fidelity really hinges on how well they model those underlying physics for that equation six to actually be accurate <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: And then there’s the strategy of tuning SHG via doping modification, where they model how external fields induce doping, which leads to changes in screening and exciton peak response in materials that already have second harmonic generation.

Mira: So they're looking at how changing the dielectric constant through doping can modify that screened interaction W, which directly affects the SHG intensity in monolayer tungsten diselenide.

Lev: Modeling those doping effects is complicated because you have to account for Pauli blocking and an increase in screening of the electron hole interaction, which is what limits your simulation accuracy <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: The overall implication is that they are building a more sophisticated computational framework to predict nonlinear optical responses in these 2D systems <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: It shows we can use AI to model these complex interactions, but we still need those real-time dynamics and better handling of many body effects for true predictive power.

Lev: So the next step is figuring out how to get those simulations running on actual hardware, which means simplifying the math enough so it doesn't crash the quantum computer <ref:2410.07661#pg3>.

Kai: Right, so we’ve seen how they plan to improve their simulation methods and what challenges that brings for the hardware we’re trying to build.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies" shows that we have two solid ways to control nonlinear optical responses using electric fields or doping <ref:2410.07661#pg1,Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies>.

Mira: Basically, you can either break the symmetry with a field or modify the existing SHG signal intensity through doping.

Lev: It demonstrates feasibility for fully ab initio simulations, which is a big thing because it means we can test these control mechanisms computationally before we even start building things that need to be cooled and measured at high fidelity.

Kai: It suggests that 2D materials can be actively switched using these two strategies, opening up new possibilities for optical switching devices <ref:2410.07661#pg1>.

Mira: It confirms that the material's properties aren't just fixed; you can dynamically control them by applying external stimuli like fields or doping.

Lev: I just want to stress that those simulation results need to hold up when we move from theory to actual hardware implementation, which is where the real overhead lands.

Kai: We still need to look at how these theoretical predictions match what we actually build and measure in the lab.

Mira: Exactly, and next time we'll be looking at papers that are focusing on the experimental setup for these kinds of optical measurements and see what they actually built in the lab.

Simone Grillo, Elena Cannuccia, Maurizia Palummo, Olivia Pulci, Claudio Attaccalite

University of Rome Tor Vergata · Aix Marseille University, CNRS, PIIM, Physique des Interactions Ioniques et Moléculaires · CNRS/Aix-Marseille Université Centre Interdisciplinaire de Nanoscience de Marseille · European Theoretical Spectroscopy Facilities (ETSF)

cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.mes-hall, physics.optics

Submitted: 2024-10-10

Updated: 2024-12-04

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. Core 7, 081 (2024)

DOI: 10.21468/SciPostPhysCore.7.4.081

Code: https://github.com/yambo-code/yambopy

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies is an ab initio study exploring two mechanisms—inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping—to dynamically…

Key concepts

Inversion Symmetry Breaking
This mechanism involves applying an external electric field to a material that naturally lacks inversion symmetry. The field directly influences the material's second-order polarization, leading to the induction of a weak SHG response where none exists intrinsically. This is explored in bilayer MoS2.
Induced Doping Effects
In materials that already exhibit SHG, applying an external field can induce doping by altering band filling and screening. This change modifies the electron-hole interaction and exciton resonances, which can either enhance or reduce the observed SHG intensity, as seen in monolayer WSe2.
Electric Field-Induced Second Harmonic (EFISH)
This describes the electronic contribution to SHG caused by an external electric field. It is calculated using a third-order polarizability. For bilayer MoS2, this electronic effect is found to be much more significant than the ionic contribution when an out-of-plane field is applied.
Screening Modification
Doping affects how electrons and holes interact by changing the dielectric constant. This modification alters the screening of the electron-hole interaction, which in turn changes excitonic resonances. In WSe2, this effect can lead to a reduction in the SHG response at specific resonance peaks.

Terminology

Summary

Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies is an ab initio study exploring two mechanisms—inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping—to dynamically control nonlinear optical responses in two-dimensional materials

Introduction to Tuning Mechanisms

The paper investigates two potential mechanisms for electrically manipulating second-order optical nonlinearity in 2D materials: first, a response induced by an external field where the material lacks inherent SHG, and second, an external field inducing doping in a material that already exhibits SHG to alter the signal intensity The authors focus on two well-studied 2D Transition Metal Dichalcogenides (TMDs), bilayer MoS2 for symmetry breaking and monolayer WSe2 for induced doping These approaches represent fundamental pathways for manipulating the nonlinear optical properties of materials

Electronic Field Effects on Nonlinearity

The impact of an external out-of-plane electric field on SHG is analyzed by considering both electronic and ionic contributions to the macroscopic second-order polarization The electronic contribution is described by a third-order polarizability, referred to as electric field-induced second harmonic (EFISH) generation For bilayer MoS2, the ionic contribution is found to be relatively small compared to the electronic counterpart due to depolarization effects in the perpendicular direction The dependence of the induced SHG peaks on the external field shows a linear dependence for small fields and a quadratic dependence at higher fields, consistent with experimental findings

Doping Effects on Intrinsic SHG

For monolayer WSe2, which naturally exhibits SHG due to lacking inversion symmetry, doping is explored as a tuning strategy Doping induces two primary effects on the nonlinear response: first, the Pauli blocking effect due to partial filling of bands, and second, an increase in screening of the electron-hole interaction which reduces excitonic resonances The study found that doping can diminish the SHG response at the A-resonance in WSe2 by up to 20% of its intensity

Comparison of Strategies and Limitations

The comparison between the two strategies reveals that for bilayer MoS2, the ionic contribution is negligible, while excitonic effects have the potential to more than double the SHG response when an external field is applied For monolayer WSe2, doping modifies the screened interaction W, which enters in Eq. (10) and affects the SHG intensity While the study demonstrates feasibility for fully ab initio simulations of nonlinear optical responses in 2D materials, discrepancies with experimental measurements suggest that other effects like Pauli blocking and trion formation need to be accounted for in a complete comparison The authors conclude that these findings illustrate how 2D materials can be employed for nonlinear optical switching

Conclusion on Tunability

In conclusion, the manuscript presents an ab initio study of two strategies for tuning the SHG response in 2D systems The first case shows that an external field can induce a weak SHG response in materials lacking inversion symmetry, where excitonic effects have the potential to enhance the signal The second case demonstrates that changing the dielectric constant via doping can reduce the excitonic peak response up to 20% This work demonstrates the feasibility of fully ab initio simulations for predicting nonlinear optical responses in 2D materials The research was partially funded by the European Union—NextGenerationEU under the Italian National Center 1 on HPC—Spoke 6: “Multiscale Modelling and Engineering Applications”

A Approximated Electron-Hole Interaction

In real-time simulations, time-dependent electric fields are essential for computing the time evolution of the polarization response To incorporate excitonic effects into real-time dynamics, a simplified screened exchange term, defined as long-range screened exchange (LSEX), is derived The LSEX approximation retains only the long-range component of the screened interaction This approach is advantageous if one is interested only in the lowest excitonic peaks, see for instance Fig. S5 in SI The authors tested this approximation on monolayer WSe2 and bilayer MoS2, comparing the results with available experimental measurements The LSEX approximation is similar to that used in simple models, with the key difference that we explicitly calculate the matrix elements of the Coulomb interaction between different bands at finite q

Computational Details

Ground-state properties of both bilayer MoS2 and monolayer WSe2 were studied using density functional theory (DFT) with the Quantum-Espresso code All computational details are provided in Sec. 2.2 Calculations of the optical susceptibilities were performed using the Yambo code Quasiparticle corrections to the fundamental band gap were applied as a rigid shift to all bands

System Parameters

The system k-points and bands are summarized in Table 1 For WSe2, a double-grid approach was employed for calculating the doped dielectric constants The effective layer thickness used in the SHG calculations is half of c lattice parameter of the bulk structures Atomic structures were relaxed using a cutoff of 120 eV, a k-point sampling of 32×32×1, and the FIRE minimization algorithm The electric field in the z-direction was applied using a saw-like potential

Data Presentation

Results for both bilayer MoS2 and monolayer WSe2 are presented in Fig. 1, showing the ionic and electronic contributions to the induced SHG Fig. p. 6 p. 6 2 presents the two highest peaks of the induced SHG as a function of the external field Fig. p. 7 p. 7 3 shows results for undoped, positively doped with n = 0. p. 8 p. 805e (holes), and negatively doped with n = −0. p. 8 p. 805e (electrons) cases in WSe2 The results are normalized to an effective thickness as explained in Sec. p. 6 p. 6 2 The parameters for the linear and nonlinear response are detailed in Table 1 The optical susceptibilities were calculated using the Yambo code

References

The paper cites numerous foundational works in condensed matter physics, including studies on GW method corrections, second-harmonic generation spectroscopy of excitons in ZnO, and work on electrically tunable second harmonic generation in a WSe2 monolayer transistor The authors also reference studies on remote free-carrier screening to boost the mobility of two-dimensional semiconductors These references provide the theoretical and experimental context for the study's findings The paper relies on established methods from various codes, such as Quantum-Espresso and Yambo, to perform its ab initio calculations The references cover a wide range of topics relevant to the study, including symmetry breaking and doping effects in TMDs The paper acknowledges financial support from various funding bodies, including PRIN2020 ”PHOTO” The acknowledgments section lists several key contributors to the research effort The references provide a comprehensive background for understanding the theoretical framework used in this study The paper's methodology is grounded in established many-body perturbation theory and real-time approaches to optical properties The cited literature supports the claims regarding band gap narrowing and Mott transitions in doped semiconductors The work builds upon previous research concerning excitonic response in bilayer MoS2 The paper's analysis of the ionic contribution being negligible is rationalized by depolarization effects in the perpendicular direction The study's focus on dielectric constant changes as a proxy for doping is noted The paper's findings illustrate how 2D materials can be employed for nonlinear optical switching

--- Page 1 ---

SciPost Physics Core Submission

Tunable second harmonic generation in 2D materials: comparison of different strategies is an ab initio study exploring two mechanisms—inversion symmetry breaking and induced doping—to dynamically control nonlinear optical responses in two-dimensional materials

Results for both bilayer MoS2 and monolayer WSe2 are presented in Fig. 1, showing the ionic and electronic contributions to the induced SHG Fig. 2 presents the two highest peaks of the induced SHG as a function of the external field Fig. 3 shows results for undoped, positively doped with n = 0.05e (holes), and negatively doped with n = −0.05e (electrons) cases in WSe2 The results are normalized to an effective thickness as explained in Sec.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Real-time ab-initio simulation for nonlinear optical frequency conversion: The system can accurately calculate second-harmonic generation response by solving time-dependent Schrödinger equations under an out-of-plane external field, allowing dynamic control over optical nonlinearities.

  2. Tunable SHG via inversion symmetry breaking: The AI system can predict the induced SHG response in materials lacking inherent symmetry by calculating the contribution of an external static electric field to the second-order polarization, as described by Equation (6).

  3. Tunable SHG via doping modification: The AI system can model how external fields induce doping, leading to changes in screening and exciton peak response, enabling prediction of SHG intensity modifications in materials already exhibiting second-harmonic generation.

Sources

Related papers